The Power of the Commons: Digital Public Goods for a More Secure, Inclusive and Resilient World

The Power of the Commons: Digital Public Goods for a More Secure, Inclusive and Resilient World

Session at a Glance

Summary

This event focused on the power of digital commons and digital public goods (DPGs) in creating a more secure, inclusive, and resilient world. Speakers from governments, international organizations, academia, and civil society discussed the transformative potential of DPGs and digital public infrastructure (DPI) in fostering sustainable development and advancing human rights globally.

Key themes included the importance of multi-stakeholder collaboration, the need to close digital divides, and the critical role of community-led initiatives in developing DPGs. Speakers highlighted successful examples like Wikipedia and emphasized how DPGs can democratize access to knowledge and technology. The discussion underscored the importance of embedding human rights and democratic values in the design of digital systems.

Participants stressed the need for robust governance frameworks and universal safeguards to ensure DPGs and DPIs respect privacy, promote inclusion, and protect against misuse. The role of governments in providing legal frameworks and supporting connectivity was discussed, alongside the importance of civil society participation in shaping digital governance.

Academia was highlighted as a key contributor to digital commons through knowledge creation, incubation of projects, and research on societal impacts. Speakers called for increased investment in digital skills and emphasized trust and safety as crucial for the continued development and use of DPGs.

The event concluded with calls to action for building a global ecosystem around DPGs, integrating them into various policy fields, and fostering international cooperation to leverage their potential in addressing global challenges and achieving sustainable development goals.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for inclusive development and achieving the Sustainable Development Goals

– The need for multi-stakeholder collaboration and community-led approaches in developing and governing DPGs

– The role of governments in supporting DPGs through policy frameworks, funding, and infrastructure

– The critical importance of embedding human rights and democratic values in the design of digital systems and DPGs

– The potential of DPGs to democratize access to knowledge and empower marginalized communities

Overall purpose:

The discussion aimed to highlight the transformative potential of digital public goods and digital public infrastructure in fostering sustainable, inclusive development worldwide. It sought to encourage multi-stakeholder partnerships to promote and protect DPGs that are truly universal and reflect diverse voices.

Tone:

The overall tone was optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers expressing enthusiasm about the potential of DPGs while also acknowledging challenges. There was a sense of urgency about the need to act now to shape the digital future in line with democratic values and human rights. The tone remained consistent throughout, emphasizing collaboration and shared responsibility among different stakeholders.

Speakers

Moderators/Facilitators:

– Costanza Sciubba Caniglia (Anti-Disinformation Strategy Lead at Wikimedia Foundation)

– Nicole Manger (Lead Global AI Governance and Digital Cooperation at Federal Foreign Office of Germany)

Speakers:

– Amandeep Gill (UN Secretary-General’s Envoy on Technology)

– Krzysztof Szczerski (Ambassador of Poland)

– Alicia Buenrostro Massieu (Deputy Permanent Representative of Mexico to the UN)

– Rebecca MacKinnon (Vice President Global Advocacy at Wikimedia Foundation)

– Ivan Sigal (Executive Director of Global Voices)

– Fabro Steibel (ITS Rio)

– Eileen Donahoe (Coordinator for Digital Freedom, US Department of State)

– Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi (Director General of NITDA Nigeria)

– Marianne Díaz Hernández (YID Campaigner at Access Now)

– Jimmy Wales (Co-founder of Wikipedia)

– Urs Gasser (Professor at Technical University of Munich)

– Emran Mian (Director General for Digital and Telecoms, UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology)

– Anna Christmann (Member of German Parliament, member of UN Secretary-General’s High-Level Advisory Body on AI)

Areas of expertise among speakers include digital governance, technology policy, digital rights, civil society engagement, digital public goods, artificial intelligence, and international relations.

Full session report

Digital Public Goods: Building a More Secure, Inclusive, and Resilient World

This high-level discussion brought together experts from governments, international organizations, academia, and civil society to explore the transformative potential of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) in fostering sustainable development and advancing human rights globally.

Event Structure and Overview

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia opened the event, outlining its structure: opening remarks, success stories, and a panel discussion. The event aimed to highlight the importance of DPGs and DPI in promoting inclusive digital transformation and sustainable development.

Key Themes and Discussions

1. The Importance of Digital Public Goods and Infrastructure

Speakers unanimously agreed on the critical role of DPGs and DPI in promoting inclusive, sustainable digital transformation. Amandeep Gill, UN Secretary-General’s Envoy on Technology, set the tone by emphasising that “well-governed commons are the foundations of human civilization. Digital is no exception, and today more than ever digital commons are vital to our interconnected world.”

Fabro Steibel provided a thought-provoking perspective, noting that “DPIs emerge earlier and faster in the Global South than in the Global North. This is what research shows and most likely this is because out of necessity. In the Global South, we need better technologies to spread and equalise wealth and power.” This insight challenged common assumptions about technological innovation and highlighted the unique contributions of the Global South in developing digital public infrastructure.

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu, Deputy Permanent Representative of Mexico to the UN, stressed the importance of DPGs and DPI in closing the digital divide, while Eileen Donahoe, Coordinator for Digital Freedom at the US Department of State, emphasised the need for universal safeguards to protect human rights in the development and implementation of these technologies.

2. Multi-stakeholder Collaboration and Community-led Approaches

The discussion highlighted the crucial role of multi-stakeholder collaboration in developing and governing DPGs. Speakers agreed that involving diverse stakeholders, including civil society, academia, and community members, is essential for creating truly inclusive and effective digital public goods.

Marianne Díaz Hernández of Access Now emphasised the role of civil society in ensuring DPGs remain transparent, inclusive, and responsive to societal needs. Urs Gasser, Professor at Technical University of Munich, highlighted academia’s multifaceted contribution: “Academia can not only contribute in these different forms substantively to the formation of digital commons and digital public goods. It can also study and assess what we can learn about digital commons as we go forward, about the societal impact about the relevance, we can assess whether we pass the Wikipedia test when new policies are rolled out.”

Jimmy Wales, co-founder of Wikipedia, stressed the importance of community-driven governance, using Wikipedia as a prime example of a successful DPG. He suggested that when considering digital policies, one should ask, “If you’re about to pass some rule, think about, is this going to wreck Wikipedia? And if it is, it might not be a great rule.”

3. The Role of Governments and Policy Frameworks

While there was broad agreement on the importance of government support for DPGs, there were nuanced differences in how speakers viewed the government’s role. Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi, Director General of NITDA Nigeria, emphasised the need for governments to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs.

Emran Mian, Director General for Digital and Telecoms at the UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology, focused on the importance of digital skills and trust and safety in the context of enjoying and creating DPGs. Anna Christmann, member of the UN Secretary-General’s High-Level Advisory Body on AI, called for bringing DPG discussions to other policy areas like climate change and COP negotiations.

4. Human Rights and Democratic Values in Digital Systems

A recurring theme throughout the discussion was the critical importance of embedding human rights and democratic values in the design of digital systems and DPGs. Marianne Díaz Hernández provided a thought-provoking comment on this issue: “When we focus on development above human rights, instead of understanding development as a tool to achieve human rights, we risk creating systems that have not been designed with human rights as a principle, but as an afterthought.”

Eileen Donahoe echoed this sentiment, advocating for universal safeguards to protect human rights in DPGs and DPI. This emphasis on human rights highlighted a key challenge: balancing rapid development of DPGs with ensuring robust protections for individual rights and freedoms.

5. Success Stories and Practical Applications

Ivan Sigal from Global Voices shared insights on the importance of multilingualism in DPGs, highlighting their work in creating tools for underrepresented languages. Fabro Steibel discussed successful DPI implementations in Brazil, emphasizing the role of open-source solutions in government services.

6. Global Digital Compact and Future Initiatives

Amandeep Gill highlighted the Global Digital Compact as a new foundation for international action on DPGs and DPI. He emphasized its role in addressing key digital issues and promoting cooperation. Gill also mentioned the upcoming OSPOS for Good Conference, focusing on open-source technologies for public good.

Anna Christmann called for new hands-on initiatives to co-design frontier open data and AI solutions as DPGs. The discussion also touched on the relevance of the upcoming Summit of the Future in shaping the global digital landscape.

7. Challenges and Future Directions

The discussion identified several challenges and areas for future focus in the development of DPGs:

– Balancing development goals with protecting human rights

– Establishing sustainable funding mechanisms for DPGs and open-source projects

– Improving data and AI literacy to enable wider participation in DPG development

– Addressing potential risks and misuse of DPGs and open data

– Ensuring multilingualism and local context in global DPGs

– Developing governance models that balance community-driven approaches with government support

– Integrating DPGs into broader policy discussions on climate change, education, and healthcare

Conclusion

The discussion underscored the transformative potential of digital public goods and digital public infrastructure in fostering sustainable, inclusive development worldwide. It emphasised the need for multi-stakeholder partnerships to promote and protect DPGs that are truly universal and reflect diverse voices. The overall tone was optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers expressing enthusiasm about the potential of DPGs while also acknowledging the challenges ahead.

As the world continues to grapple with digital transformation, the insights from this discussion provide a valuable framework for leveraging DPGs to create a more secure, inclusive, and resilient global digital ecosystem. The emphasis on human rights, community-driven approaches, and multi-stakeholder collaboration offers a path forward in harnessing the power of digital commons for the benefit of all.

Session Transcript

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Hello, good morning, welcome, Excellencies, colleagues, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you so much for joining us today for our event, The Power of the Commons, Digital Public Goods for a More Secure, Inclusive, and Resilient World. My name is Costanza Sciubba Caniglia, I am the Anti-Disinformation Strategy Lead at the Wikimedia Foundation, and I am honored today to co-moderate this event with my colleague, Nicole Mangier, Lead Global AI Governance and Digital Cooperation at the Federal Foreign Office of Germany. Before we start, I wanted to thank our co-organizers, the Office of the Tech Envoy, the Permanent Mission of Poland and Mexico, the Federal Foreign Office of Germany, TUM, the Network of Centers, and multiple Wikimedia affiliates, Wikimedia EU, Wikimedia Poland, Wikimedia Czech, and Wikimedia Deutschland. I’m going to leave the floor to Nicole in a moment, but just wanted to articulate the event is going to be divided in four parts. We’re going to have opening remarks, and then we’re going to have a section on success stories that will serve to ground the panel that will come afterwards, with a couple of examples of grassroots digital public good examples. And then we’re going to have a panel of experts, and then we’ll close with a couple of closing remarks. And with this, Nicole, to you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much, Amandeep. Thank you so much, Amandeep. So thanks a lot, Costanza. And I also very warmly welcome you to our side event, The Power of the Commons, the role of digital public goods for a more secure, inclusive, and resilient world. So this event, as Costanza said, is co-hosted by the Wikimedia Foundation and its affiliates by the governments of Mexico and Poland, and then by the UN Secretary General’s Envoy on Technology. So I want to step a little back. ask the question, like, why are we meeting here on this topic today? So, I guess we are all expecting to be, to see the pact for the future and especially the global digital compact to be adopted successfully tomorrow and adopted. Yeah, and so it’s going to be the first Compass truly global approach to an open, free, secure, and human-centered digital future for all and everywhere. And so for us today, we wanted to highlight especially the transformative potential of digital public goods for the values of the GDC, such as enabling access, inclusive access to digital technologies, and also enabling civil society to have a voice in how technology is designed and governed. Also to pool scarce resources like data and infrastructure to really increase resilience and sustainability and have a digital transformation that is also sustainable. So without further ado, I would like to introduce our esteemed speakers, opening speakers, and I first pass it on to His Excellency Under-Secretary-General Amandeep Gill, Secretary General’s Envoy on Technology.

Amandeep Gill: Thank you very much, Nicole, and I’d like to begin by welcoming all of you to the pre-summit of the Future Action Day. Thank you for being here at UN Headquarters with us. It means a lot. It means a lot to the Secretary General, to all of us. I want to also thank Mexico, Poland, and Wikimedia for organizing this event, this very important event, and I want to thank Germany for their consistent support to this constellation of important ideas. Ladies and gentlemen, well-governed commons are the foundations of human civilization. Digital is no exception, and today more than ever digital commons are vital to our interconnected world. When we speak about digital commons, we mean resources that are collectively owned and managed by a community and freely accessible to all members of our society, and on the technology front, open digital resources are key to the equitable advancement of digital digital technologies, particularly emerging technologies like AI. Nicole mentioned the Global Digital Compact. So after nearly two years of consultation and negotiations, the negotiations have concluded and there’s a text on the table as part of the pact for the future for a decision tomorrow. This document, the Global Digital Compact, embeds an international commitment to global digital commons through digital public goods and digital public infrastructure. So it is a new foundation for more meaningful, more impactful action in this area. This is very significant. The GDC can play a crucial role in democratizing access to knowledge and technological resources, ensuring that everyone everywhere, regardless of their socioeconomic status, has the opportunity to participate in benefit from the digital economy. This inclusivity is crucial for reducing inequalities and promoting social equity, aligning with the goal of leaving no one behind. Further, the collaborative nature of digital commons, including digital public goods and digital public infrastructure, fosters innovation and creativity. By enabling the free exchange of ideas and resources, by bringing data sets together, by bringing talent, coding talent in particular, together, digital commons help accelerate technological advancements and the development of new solutions to global challenges. At the same time, because you have many more eyes on the code, many more eyes on the data, you prevent misuse. You build a set of safeguards, a set of checks and balances that ensure that our digital commons work for everyone. This open and responsible innovation ecosystem can support economic growth, the creation of jobs, enhancement of productivity, contributing to overall economic prosperity and social well-being. At the UN, we know that the open nature of open source software, platforms, data, AI models are a key enabler of the Sustainable Development Goals. By leveraging the potential of Digital Commons, we believe we can accelerate progress towards the 2030 Agenda. As part of the Secretary General’s commitment to Digital Commons, my office, together with many partners, some of which are in the room today, organizes the yearly OSPOS for Good Conference. In July, we hosted this together with Germany and Kenya, the second edition of this conference. Through two days at the UN, over 600 participants from around the world gathered in New York with active engagement, high-quality discussions, and a collaborative spirit characteristic of the open-source community. I’d like to finish these remarks by inviting you all to join us in collaborating on the future of this conference in follow-up to the Global Digital Compact. In this spirit, I wish you an invigorating exchange today. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much, Under-Secretary General Gill. I pass on the word to His Excellency, Ambassador of Poland Krzysztof Szczerski. I am so sorry, possibly, for mispronouncing the name, but I hope I got it over to you.

Krzysztof Szczerski: Thank you very much, Excellencies, Mr. Special Envoy, ladies and gentlemen, I’m so excited to be here, being one of the, not only the daily reader of the Wikipedia, but also having my own profile on it. It’s good to be in the system, somehow. Okay, it’s my honor to be with you today, as we heard, in the dawn of the summit of the future, which we are all very excited about. First and foremost, let me congratulate the Wikimedia Foundation for gathering us and for working tirelessly to ensure the success of today’s discussions. Poland is, of course, happy to be the co-sponsor of this event. As a gentleman, digital cooperation is going to be heavily featured during the Summit of the Future and the entire High-Level Week. We expect, as we already heard, that already tomorrow the heads of states and governments will adopt the foundation for the global digital cooperation, the document which is named, as we heard, Global Digital Compact. This will mark the new era of recognition that we need to act swiftly, decisively and collectively to utilize and govern the ever-expanding digital sphere. I am more than happy to see involvement of many stakeholders from outside the governments like the lead organizer of this event, Wikimedia, in our discussions. It’s only with their active participation on equal footing that we can fully tap the potential of digital public goods and digital public infrastructure for realization of the Sustainable Development Goals. Colleagues, one of the aims of this meeting is to highlight the potential of digital commons, the role of which is inavailable in providing individuals and communities with free and easy access to information. And I just want to underline the word information because I think we get too much of the free and easy access to disinformation. And it’s crucially important since this device becomes now the best friend of many of ours. So therefore it’s very important to really guarantee that it’s free, easy, but also reliable. Therefore I would like to share with you just a couple of cases of how public open data is used by citizens in my country, Poland, to build interest in digital tools, to participate in public life, and to monitor the activity of public authorities. Take for example the portal dane.gov.pl. This is a universal access point to open data in Poland and has been enthusiastically embraced by various stakeholders. It’s a governmental portal, but open for everybody. Presidents interested in monitoring state activities use it as a tool for holding the government accountable. Companies leverage data to build innovative products and services. Another set of examples includes the fact-checking platforms run by civil society. There are various of them. Their adaptability to most recent events, such as fact-checking related to the upcoming elections, is one of their strengths. Our goal, however, in all these efforts, is not to simply implement open data policy, but to do more to construct a comprehensive, robust, citizen-friendly system that is fueled by the valuable data. And we have been recognized for our efforts by the major European and global open data rankings. Ladies and gentlemen, in conclusion, I am looking forward to learning about the concrete examples of how digital public goods and digital public infrastructure can contribute to a safe, resilient, and open digital world, which we strive to build in order to leave no one behind. And I wish you all the very enriching and exciting discussions, and I thank you. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: And next, I would pass on the word to Her Excellency Alicia Buenrostro Massieu, Deputy Permanent Representative of the Mexican United States to the United Nations in New York. The floor is yours.

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu: Thank you very much, and it’s also a pleasure to be here with all of you. In particular, it’s very good to share the floor with such a panel. And having the creator of Wikipedia, as my colleague from Poland has just mentioned, it’s just a real honor, and with them, a big deal as well. And for Mexico, a country that really has put a lot into the global digital compact. So it’s an honor, really, to be here today representing my country, Mexico. The Pact for the Future, and more specifically… the Global Digital Compact represents certainly an opportunity to consolidate a global digital governance framework that fosters inclusion, equity, and sustainability, as well as to emphasize the political relevance of this framework in the multilateral sphere. It’s the first time that we are working on this type of issue from a real compact, and that is a step forward and as the Ambassador of Poland has just mentioned, we really look forward to being able to witness that this has been passed tomorrow morning. So for my country, for Mexico, the promise of digital transformation lies in its ability to drive inclusive growth, reduce inequalities, and accelerate progress towards the Sustainable Development Goals. Technology must be a development catalyst and not a luxury for a few, and that is the position of my country. So this should be for everybody. Mexico’s priorities are very clear. First, we must close the digital divide and ensure that no one is left behind in the digital age. Second, to empower small and medium-sized enterprises. Technology can be a great equalizer by fostering innovation and supporting local economic activity. Third, Mexico is committed to ensuring that human rights are respected in all digital policies, and that is very important as well. As a country that enshrines the right to access information and communication technologies in our Constitution, we are dedicated to promoting meaningful digital inclusion, particularly for groups in vulnerable situations that have faced historical exclusions, such as women, indigenous peoples, and Afro-descendant communities. At the heart of our efforts is the concept of digital public goods as essential for building a digital commons that is transparent, equitable, and open to all. By investing in digital public infrastructure, we create pathways for marginalized communities to be able to fully participate in the global economy. It’s not just about providing access, but about empowering our people to innovate, to grow, and contribute to the development of their communities. Digital public goods align with Mexico’s goals of inclusive economic development and socio-economic equity. In this context, the Global Digital Compact gains relevance as a roadmap for building secure, inclusive, and rights- based digital ecosystems. Early last year, Mexico co-hosted the GDC consultation for the Americas in Mexico City, and Amandeep was there. That was along with Germany and the Office of the Secretary’s General Envoy, as I mentioned. This consultation brought together key actors from across the region to discuss the most pressing issues around digital governance and the role of digital public goods. Throughout the GDC negotiations, my country has pushed for the creation of open government initiatives, which focus on integrating digital tools into public administration to promote transparency and accountability. We are advocating for the development of inclusive and accessible digital tools, particularly tailored to small and medium enterprises and entrepreneurs. These tools must be affordable and adaptable to the needs of small businesses and local innovators, helping them leverage the power of technology for economic growth. Mexico is committed to investing in inclusive digital infrastructure, focusing on marginalized and underserved communities. By expanding access to the infrastructure in rural and in economically disadvantaged regions, we can help bridge the digital divide and ensure equitable opportunities for all. And to conclude, I would like to encourage all governments and stakeholders to ensure that digital transformation benefits all people everywhere, and that is a commitment that we almost assume. By investing in digital public goods and digital public infrastructure, and by collaborating and building on the principles, objectives, commitments, and actions outlined in the Global Digital Compact, we can consolidate the construction of a global digital environment that is inclusive, equitable, and sustainable. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you, and I would like to pass it on now to our civil society voice on this stage, Rebecca MacKinnon. She is Vice President Global Advocacy at Wikimedia Foundation and also founder of Global Voices. Rebecca, the floor is yours.

Rebecca MacKinnon: Thank you so much, Nicole. I’m here today representing the Wikimedia Foundation along with my colleague Costanza here and several other colleagues in the room. Someone was asking me just before we got seated what’s the difference between the Wikimedia Foundation and Wikipedia. We are the nonprofit organization that serves as the technical, legal, and fundraising host for Wikipedia and other volunteer-run projects that operate in over 300 languages. Wikipedia, of course, being created before the foundation existed by Jimmy Wales, who you’ll hear from later. We also have staff who support the global community of volunteers who build and maintain these projects around the world. And, of course, I’d like to thank all of our co-organizers shown on the screen today, in particular the governments of Poland, Mexico, and Germany and the Office of the UN Tech Envoy, without whose support we wouldn’t be here. And also grateful to the partnership of many others in the United Nations system, national governments, and civil society and academia who’ve helped organize this event and, more generally, in their commitment to support and protect digital public goods like Wikipedia. And we’ll take the next slide, please. So this is a group of just some of the people who maintain and create Wikipedia who traveled to Katowice in Poland just last month for an annual conference called Wikimania. It was organized, one of the key organizers actually sitting right there, the young man named Maciek. And thanks to our co-hosts and the gracious Polish people for welcoming us. We are very lucky to have him here today. Wikipedia is a digital native, but a lot of the people who build and govern this global resource of free knowledge actually find it very important to gather in person, as you see here, to brainstorm, learn from each other, and build human bonds that enable us to collaborate with empathy and understanding of each other’s lived experience. Next slide, please. New language communities are joining the Wikimedia family all the time. And this is an example, Wikimedia founder Jimmy Wales, sitting there, who you’ll hear from in a few minutes, gave the 2024 Newcomer of the Year Award at Wikimania to the people who’ve created a new version of Wikipedia in the Waiyu language. Next slide, please. And here is that new Waiyu language, Wikipedia. Waiyu is spoken by about 400,000 indigenous people in northwestern Venezuela and northeastern Colombia. It’s an example of a project that benefits an indigenous community that commercial internet companies have no financial incentive to care about. Top-down government services in a lot of countries also often fail to prioritize the needs of indigenous people whose ancient communities often span across several borders, which is why it’s so vital that governments must protect and support the people and the work behind such community-led bottom-up projects. Projects like Wikipedia, but many others, and we’ll hear some more examples later, serve the public interest by creating knowledge, infrastructure, and access to information built on a robust digital commons that we’ve heard about already, which includes open-source software, a range of open content and open data projects, and open licensing for content that enables projects to build upon one another in an interdependent ecosystem. Next slide, please. So here we have a photo of the Igbo language user group in Nigeria, jumping across. the Atlantic Ocean, and a community outreach activity that they carried out not too long ago. Wikipedia exists in several Nigerian languages, run by volunteers who all care passionately about preserving and strengthening their community’s linguistic and cultural heritage, while contributing also to a global body of knowledge about the people, places, issues, and ideas in their countries and communities. So then that knowledge also gets translated into other languages and ends up in English, et cetera. And in so doing, they’re also helping to advance technical capacity, economic opportunity, and cultural flourishing in their own communities. To put it another way, they’re directly contributing to the advancement of quite a number of SDGs. And there’s simply no way that a top-down approach to digital public infrastructure and digital public goods is going to be able to reach all of the underserved, vulnerable, and marginalized communities around the world, full of talented people who will take initiative in innovative ways if given half a chance, as we’ve been discovering throughout the Wikimedia communities. So we believe that the future of the internet should be one that promotes and protects these types of projects and these people, like those who we work with around the world. Wikipedia is one of the most famous examples, but there’s many others that have emerged over the past two decades, and we’re going to be hearing about a few of them in just a few minutes. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you, Rebecca, and thanks to all our distinguished speakers here on this stage. We are now transitioning to the second segment of hearing success stories of civil society grassroots organizations. because DPGs are really at its core about grassroots involvement and so that’s why we would like to highlight these success stories and also the perspectives of two organizations, one Global Voices and the second ITS Rio on how they are using the potential of DPGs and also possibly certain challenges what you know when it comes to governance structures, robust funding mechanisms and also creating robust data AI literacy to leverage DPGs successfully. So with that said I would like to call Fabro Steibel and Ivan Sigal on the stage with me. So we will start with one example of successful DPGs which is Global Voices. So this is really a multilingual community of writers, translators, academics and digital rights activists worldwide and I would like to give the floor to Ivan Seagal, Executive Director of Global Voices.

Ivan Sigal: Good morning. I’m Ivan Sigal as is just told. I’m now the actually outgoing Executive Director of Global Voices. This is my last public appearance in this role. We’re an organization that’s been for the past 20 years has been a forum for the perspectives and priorities of global majority writers and activists and explores how information technologies affect movements, politics, culture and information integrity. Some 8,000 writers, translators and researchers have participated from 160 countries and contributed to our to our work over the years. We’re dedicated to building understanding across cultures and languages and specifically we understand that the internet does not by itself bring around positive social change. Rather we need to invest in and build an internet based on a vision that reflects those values and we’re one of many communities and initiatives and organizations that exists as a digital public good that works in a much smaller level than a group like Wikipedia but is an example of what people can accomplish when the internet flourish functions as a flourishing and healthy information ecosystem rather than as a censored or surveilled information space or based on a small number of platforms that function as walled gardens or exists as a field of data to be extracted and monetized primarily for artificial intelligence. So my key message today is good internet regulation should support proactively support flourishing information ecosystems marked by a diversity of sources and languages and retaining the means of all people to be part of a network public’s participating in the creation sharing and consumption of information and knowledge. A key element of healthy information ecosystems is information integrity. By this I mean not just controlling or removing the most harmful elements of disinformation in online spaces, but proactively supporting the trustworthiness of information sources, ensuring that users have meaningful agency over information environments and control over their data, and working for more inclusive and diverse participation in online spaces. We work on these issues in numerous ways, such as our Civic Media Observatory, which is a research project to investigate and decode how people understand information and create knowledge in complex information ecosystems. We work with local researchers who have deep knowledge of local context and subtext of information and narrative to explain how information functions in their societies, rather than looking just at factuality or just at data flows. And the example we have there is the Unfreedom Monitor, which is a two-year, 20-country study in networked authoritarianism, which explores how states use both technology and regulation to restrict expression and augment those restrictions through information operations and propaganda. Another example of what this looks like, Global Voices for the last 15 years has run a project called Rising Voices, which is dedicated to supporting marginalized communities to participate and create online with networks of mutual support and learning. We focus on the ability of minority and indigenous language communities to create their own information spaces as they see fit. We work, for example, with Mayan language communities across the Americas to use the internet for language preservation and revitalization. These images come from our annual, this is from our 2024 Mayan Language Summit, which is now an annual event held in Mayan. Very unusual that an event is actually run in Mayan as opposed to being a secondary language to build networks of support for the use of Mayan in online contexts. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much, Ivan. And now, moving from a global organization, we are now zooming in on one regional use case. So, I am very glad to welcome Fabros Deibel here on stage for ITS Rio. So, ITS Rio, it’s the Institute of Technology Rio, that is really working to represent and strengthen Brazil’s and Latin America’s voice in global discussions and conversations on technology governance and digital rights. And it is also a member of the DPI Safeguards Initiative with Fabro himself also being in the Digital Public Goods Alliance. So, Fabro, the floor is yours.

Fabro Steibel: Nicole, thank you very much and thank you Wikimedia for the invitation. I start with a fact. DPIs emerge earlier and faster in the Global South than in the Global North. This is what research shows and most likely this is because out of necessity. In the Global South, we need better technologies to spread and equalize wealth and power. So, when you look at DPIs from the Global South, you ask them why they cannot be DPGs, why you cannot open the digital public infrastructures for good. And this is what we bring as a civil society member of Brazil, also as an academic, as a member of the network of centers, and as a member of the DPGA alliance. So, openness in Brazil is no coincidence. In the 90s, people from civil society and academia, they penetrate the government, they enter the government, and they start to foster open culture from inside the government. Outside the government, the culture keeps open and now we have a strong ecosystem. And we come from this ecosystem. So, what we are doing with DPGA and what do you think we can contribute to this debate today? Number one, we need very good green DPIs. We need open green DPIs. Brazil has CAR, C-A-R, which is a brilliant digital public infrastructure that can be even more brilliant if we bring the openness idea to it. It’s open data, but it’s not really a DPG yet. So, bringing this idea can have, as Wikimedia has a community around it that makes use of this data, make new… So, we have a lot of data, and we have a lot of data, and we can use it to do new surveillance of this data, and then we can fight deforestation or land rights. Number two, information integrity. We had Pegabot, Bot Catcher, that is an open algorithm that used to identify in Twitter the use of bots for this information. We collaborated with journalists and others having that. And we have a lot of data, and we have a lot of data, and we can use it to identify bots, and also, someone got our algorithm and made Atrapabot, a version of it using Mozilla language back to identify bots in Colombia. And lastly, the last case we have is on civic participation. So, we love to use technology to make new ways for people to enjoy deliberating together. So, we have a lot of data, and we have a lot of data, and we can use it to identify bots, and we can use it to make voting for people to deliberate in a more meaningful way other than a majority always wins. And the case studies we have shows that we have young football teams that are using Cucurdamos to select the coach. And we did this in partnership with Taiwan, who has a brilliant captain as well. And we tried it for the human aspect of the environment and it has to be, you know, you can now interact with it, and makes the environment better. You can now interact with it, and then becomes part of the more harmonious ecosystem. And we see now the perspective that can not only open technology, but open technology thinking about the human aspect as well.

Nicole Manger: I talked to leveraging DPGs, you know, across different themes and topics. And I will now pass it over to our expert panel with Costanza moderating, and they will pick up on these success stories, but also look more deeply into potential challenges like funding mechanisms, governing structures, and also data AI literacy. And also really be informed by other existing successful initiatives Amandeep mentioned before, the DPI safeguards initiative, the Digital Public Goods Alliance, and also the OSPO for Good conference that was just hosted here in New York in July. So with that, I hand it over to Costanza and our esteemed panelists. Thank you.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Let’s give a moment to our speakers to get seated. There’s, yes, a very, a very exciting panel. So we’re now going to move to the panel section of our event. I am honored to introduce some of the world-leading experts on the topic of digital public goods and digital governance. This past month and the months in front of us, as we all know, are critical times for the future of digital, global digital governance. And the global digital compact process, the pact of the future, WISE’s review, the high-level advisory board on artificial intelligence are all elements that are going to shape the future of our digital and physical world. One thing before we start that I want to say is this event is in many ways a follow-up event to a conversation that we started with Access Now during the CSW this year and before. So I just wanted to mention this and it’s great to be with Marianne today and with Access Now. But going to the panel, we wanted to have a moment here in the action day to reflect in particular on the transformative potential of digital public goods such as Wikipedia and others and digital public infrastructure and fostering sustainable development worldwide. Digital public goods, especially when grounded in robust digital commons, are essential for inclusive open, sustainable, and digital world and so we want to really encourage this multi-stakeholder partnership. As you can see, this panel has a really wide multi-stakeholder perspective and so we want to encourage this to promote and protect TPGs that truly are universal and reflect on how to best enable civil society and communities globally to have a voice in how technology is developed. So without further ado, I’ll pass it on to our panelists. Dr. Donahoe, I would like to start with you. Dr. Donahoe is the coordinator for digital freedom in the US Department of State’s Bureau of Cyberspace and Digital Policy. So Dr. Donahoe, digital public goods and DPIs have been such a central topic of discussion in the negotiations around the Global Digital Compact and more in general in the discussion about how to rethink global internet governance. I know you’ve been working about a model of right-respecting DPI which is achieved through universal safeguards. Can you tell us more about this and how multilateral and multi-stakeholder effort to protect TPGs and DPI should be shaped?

Eileen Donahoe: Great. First, let me congratulate the organizers here. This is a really remarkable event and it’s a very good reflection of where the DPG-DPI conversation is in the world and it’s very notable that this subject is at the top of the agenda at the high-level week at UNGA. I’m gonna make a comment that’s just based on observing what we’ve already heard. I think what we observed is that the multi-stakeholder community is way ahead and actually building digital public goods and global commons and that’s been going on for decades and you can use the case of Wikimedia, Wikipedia as an example. I think we’re here at UNGA which is a state-centric event. It’s a multilateral led body and I think it is really fair to say that states are generally behind and just catching on to these concepts and also that states are generally much more focused on DPIs and just trying to get ahead around that subject. So, But I will note that, so I’m gonna talk a little about what I see in the multilateral space that’s good and also what the U.S. is focused on and universal safeguards. Basically, here at the U.N. and in the Global Digital Compact, everybody’s really still focusing on definitions and concepts. And I think we’ve gravitated around several core features which include open interoperable standards and specifications that include delivery of public and private services at scale that are ideally and we will be fighting for rights respecting by design and protection of fundamental freedoms embedded in the design. But all of this is intended to drive toward inclusion, development, acceleration of the SDGs. And I just have to say it is really a giant change in the global conversation. This has been central to the G20 under the leadership of Brazil and India. It’s been part of the G7. It’s been in multiple agencies at the U.N. and that is brand new. That has never happened before. So this is really a new topic for states. What I will emphasize for the United States in particular, there are two key parts and it’s a combination of concern and excitement. The concern is that yes, DPGs and DPI hold tremendous promise to accelerate development. And obviously that is the core rationale that states are latching onto it. People are yearning to be part of the digital transformation. There is not equity around the world in that regard. And that is the driving motivation, animating energy here. But what we all have to be careful of is the risks that come with this digitization of infrastructure. And I’m sure we’re gonna be hearing. that from access, but we in the United States are also really focused on risk, and we have embraced the work of the Office of the Tech Envoy and UNDP on universal safeguards because we think that in every instance when DPIs, DPGs, digital commons are built, you have to be thinking about the impact on citizens’ rights. And the core of those concerns relates to privacy, and I will also say obviously equal protection, non-discrimination, and also the risk of exclusion from basic services if you do not build in safeguards and just embrace the technology itself. This is ultimately about bringing democratic values into the digital future around the world, and if we fail to bring safeguards with the actual access to the technology, we will be failing our citizens. The second part I want to mention that we’re really excited about, though, and this is what I do believe civil society has been onto for years, is that technology itself is now a vehicle for governance innovation. It is the way that the governing world can catch up to the pace of technological change, and I think it’s very exciting, this idea that the design, development, and deployment of the technology becomes the vehicle for spreading values and for governing in a way that protects citizens. And so, for me, that is why I’m really actually very excited about the opportunity of DPI, that it’s not just about inclusion in the digital transformation. It is about bringing values. by design in the technology. And last point I want to make is I really want to applaud the Universal Safeguards Initiative that last year at UNGA, OSET, Amandeep himself, Robert Opp from UNDP, they were on the stage launching the Universal Safeguards Initiative. That has been a year-long process. We have been part of it. Foundational principle number one is do no harm and it is about protecting human rights by design and we really applaud that. But the key idea here is no developing country and citizens in developing countries should never be asked to exchange their human rights. They do not trade off their human rights for inclusion in the digital ecosystem or for to be part of the digital transformation. That’s not okay. Development and human rights are not intention.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: They must go together so. Thank you, thank you Dr. Donahoe, such an important message. I love your conclusive message especially. Now I would like to move to Mr. Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi, Director General of NITDA Nigeria. So Mr. Abdullahi, digital public goods seem to be very important of course for social and economic development, also what we were just talking about, respectful of human rights. In your current position and as an expert on digital development, how do you see the role of government support for people to operate digital public goods and also to develop digital public goods? And before passing the floor to you, I just also want to mention Wikipedia has a very active community also of Wikimedians in Nigeria who work especially on multilingualism. So that’s also something that how do you think about those communities, not Wikipedia in particular, but in general communities that develop digital public goods in Nigeria?

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi: Okay, thank you very much. First and foremost, I want to thank the organizers for inviting me and also for giving Africa opportunity to be part of this conversation. Because for me, digital technology is dramatically transforming our world, offering immense potential benefits for the well-being and advancement of humanity, our societies and our planets. And it also holds the promise of accelerating the achievement of sustainable development goals. This can only be achieved through international cooperation that close all digital gaps. Because we recognize those digital gaps are really posing challenge to countries, in particular developing countries who have so many challenges to solve but with limited resources. So I think we should focus on closing that gap because imagine a person sitting next to you never clicked a link, never sent an email and never experienced social media. So almost half of the world population are excluded from this digital transformation, especially in Africa. So we cannot be talking about digital public good without ensuring every person is included. Because if that person is excluded, the technology will not consider that person when making its decisions. So that’s why we are quite fascinated about this conversation on digital public good. And also, like it mentioned before, this DPI-DPG conversation started from the global south, where people are excluded. And we can see the passion about bringing everyone to be part of it. And in Nigeria also, the government is focused on achieving that. We are starting with the digital public infrastructure. We are laying the foundation. We are putting the legal framework in place and also ensuring that we have a robust digital identity, a robust payment system and data exchange platform. So we have two and we are lacking the data exchange platform. platform. Now the government is working on coming up with standard and ensuring that we have that data exchange platform. That will enable us to build the digital public goods when we have the strong DPI stack in place. But now we are having some in silos, like you mentioned about Wikipedia. Wikipedia is a very good example in Nigeria of DPI, where people, the communities around are creating the platform. And that ensure democratization of access to services as well as quality information, fact-checking. Because we should learn from social media, how it started, where it is controlled by few, and also it is for profit. That’s why you can see a lot of things are happening without the control of the countries. Like we came from a way whereby most of these big techs, they don’t even listen to developing countries. They do things based on developed countries’ laws and mission, vision, and so on. And also that is really affecting us in the developing countries. Because for them it is about profit, it’s about what they will make. Few people decide what you see, what you buy, and what you can even think, or who you can friend, what you can believe. But with DPG, it will be open for societies, communities, and societies to look at information, to ensure you have the right information in place, and ensure things are fact-checked before being in public. So in Nigeria we have other smaller ones apart from the Wikipedia, which they are open, but in a siloes form. We cannot call them like a big DPGs. Like for example, we have a platform called Budget, where people can go and check information about government budget, and also do a fact-check to provide information for people in communities to look at budget line item, where the project is supposed to be executed, and check to ensure if it is executed or not. So this also can help for good governance, and it will make things to be open and transparent. So I think it’s good to support this kind of initiatives as well. We also have the National Health Information System project, which is driven by government to make health record available for decision makers, for health service providers, and so on, so that they can have access to health record and citizens can easily get services. So for governments, when you talk about DPGs, government has critical role to play, because it is about democratizing access, and also it is it is about breaking all the experience we have with social media, where few people are controlling everything. So we need to break that unaccountable control over public digital infrastructure. So the DPG will provide that. So government needs to provide the legal framework, because everything you do, you need to have laws that will guide it. You need to have framework and governance in place. So government has the convening power to bring the civil society, the private organizations, and everyone on board to discuss on the governance framework, to discuss on inclusive connectivity and also to intervene to connect the unconnected. So we have so many initiatives we are doing on that. Like in Nigeria, almost about more than 40% of the citizens are excluded. So government is promoting connectivity. We launched the 9,000 kilometers fiber optics project where government want to connect the remote societies and underserved communities. In addition to that also, we have other initiatives around digital literacy. Because it is not just about connecting, but people need to be digitally literate to navigate around the digital platform as well. So we do a lot in training people in developing our digital fluency in the country. We are working with other partners like Ministry of Education. We are developing digital literacy and skills curriculum to infuse it into our formal education so that people will learn from schools. We are also having other projects that will build talent. Because also you need to build your proficiency in building these digital offerings. Because no country will rely on another for its digital offerings. We need people within the country that can build the communities and services. So these are things government is doing in addition to the legal framework like we are working on enacting a law on digital economy and e-governance in Nigeria which can help in promoting digital public infrastructure as well as digital public good. But also for me the most important is this kind of conversation so that developing countries and African countries should have voice on what we are doing globally. Thank you.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Thank you so much. Thank you so much. Marianne, I would like to move on to you now to talk about especially how civil society is a critical stakeholder in global digital governance and for the development of digital public goods. Marianne Diaz-Hernandez is the YID campaigner at Access Now. She’s also a Venezuelan lawyer and digital rights activist and fiction writer. So as I mentioned earlier, this panel really is born as a second step of a conversation that we started together with Access Now a few months back. And so it’s great to continue this conversation and have so many more partners joining it as well. So I’m particularly interested to hear, how you think things have changed in them and what the role of civil society really should be as we move towards a new digital governance. You work extensively to make sure that all stakeholders have a perspective on digital public goods, including community development, digital public goods, and civil society agency. So what can you tell us about that?

Marianne Díaz Hernández: Thank you, Costanza. And thank you, everyone, for the privilege and the honor of your time and attention. Digital public goods, as well as the public infrastructure, which has also been mentioned a lot today on the upcoming days, I’m sure, have a profound need for community-led and community developed spaces where free speech and free assembly and civic life and dissent can thrive. And that requires the existence of spaces of total or partial anonymity and pseudonymity. And it is only possible to understand, design, and regulate these type of spaces through a multi-stakeholder lens, which is the only way that can ensure that the development and the governance of these digital commons remains transparent, inclusive, and responsive to a wide array of societal needs. DPGs are not only extremely important to society on their own standing, as the stories that were previously shared very clearly highlight, but also as the foundation for DPI, as Fabro was detailing, among others. Both of these assets need to be protected and nurtured to enable equitable access and to prevent monopolization or control by a select few. And this inclusivity ensures that the governance of digital spaces aligns with public interest and is the only way to protect them as open participatory environments that will encourage democratic engagement and free expression. And to go back to what Dr. Donahue was touching upon, when we focus on development above human rights, instead of understanding development as a tool to achieve human rights, we risk creating systems that have not been designed with human rights as a principle, but as an afterthought. We are then in need of a paradigm shift that allows us to understand that privacy, anonymity, free speech are not principles that are intentioned with the notion of development, but that have to be at the core of the design of the systems that are necessary to build the trust that the systems require in order to operate. There will be no development without these principles built into the systems that we create. So if we are to build and implement systems that are either created by the private sector, or by governments, or by any sort of hybrid model, the only way that we can make these systems accomplish what we want them to do, which is to support us in achieving the sustainable development goals, and ultimately achieving universal human rights, it is to build systems that are based in solid trust. And the construction of that trust cannot be taken by granted. It requires full and meaningful participation of society in a way that ensures and protects their agency in how to build, implement, and engage with technology. I believe then that civil society needs to work together and with other multi-stakeholders in articulating and putting forward the notion that what we require at this moment in time is a paradigm shift. We are not only speaking about enabling or defending human rights, or when these technologies are created, but about creating these technologies for a world that is built. with public in mind. Where public means built to benefit everyone by shared resources and managed by the community. And this does require a paradigm shift from a world view where resources are meant to be administered by specific actors in society. That model is not sustainable. It’s not participatory and it doesn’t help us in building strong democracies. Thank you.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Thank you so much, Marianne. And now that we are talking about civil society participation, I would like to move on to you, Jimmy. Jimmy is, Jimmy Wales is the co-founder of Wikipedia, so it’s really an honor to introduce you. So you have the unique experience of having created one of the largest, most used digital public goods in the world, which is really a unique kind of experience. What have you learned about how people are able to come together and create and govern projects that serve the public interest? And what advice can you give to all stakeholders and why is it important to do it today?

Jimmy Wales: Great, thank you. And thank you to the organizers and everyone for making this happen. It’s a great event. Yeah, so I think one of the key elements in terms of advice and thinking about this has already been mentioned a couple of times today and that is values. The original vision for Wikipedia was for all of us to imagine a world in which every single person on the planet is given free access to the sum of all human knowledge. And that’s what we’re doing at Wikipedia. And so every element of that is really, really important to us. When we say every single person on the planet, that means that we’re inherently global. We’re in many, many, many languages. And when I say the sum of all human knowledge, it means we care a lot about the quality of what we put out. It isn’t just sort of a giant random message. board we actually try to impart knowledge. This was 23 years ago when I started Wikipedia and it was just a handful of us typing away on the internet with very very limited software and very limited resources. But today Wikipedia is one of the top 10 most visited websites in the world. We have hundreds of millions of visitors every month from all around the world. We’re in over 300 languages, although of course some of those languages are quite small and just getting going. And for me that aspect of our work is one that I’m probably the most passionate about. I’m always very excited to think about the impact that we can have in bringing the ability for people to share knowledge in their own world, in their own community, in their own mother tongue. Some of the values that really carry us forward, we really care a lot about reliable sources. We have policies, for example, our well we have a lot of internal jargon. BLP policy, biography of living persons, which basically says if you see something negative in a biography it better have a source and if it doesn’t you should just remove it immediately and not just discuss what to do about it. Take it out and let’s discuss it then to say of course there’s going to be negative information. It needs to be really reliable and this can be contrasted with of course social media where people just write whatever they want and who knows maybe it’s fact-checked eventually or not. We try to be really really careful about that. One of our core community rules is no personal attacks. So obviously a lot of open spaces on the internet are just rife with personal attacks and that can be fine if it’s a political debate and discussion that often can be quite personal but it’s not right for us. We’re trying to write an encyclopedia. We’re a global movement in many many many different languages but everything in Wikipedia is locally written. Even as we move into an era of AI and I’m actually very excited about the really rapid increases that we’re seeing in the quality of machine translation and yet we have no concept or idea that we should just start wholesale translating Wikipedia into small languages because we know that it’s about that local cultural context. It’s about the local people. They will of course use these tools and it will… you know, finally accelerate that work so that we’re going to see really rapid growth in a lot of the languages that previously have been much more slower to grow. Really, Wikipedia, when we think about a digital public good, I think one of the paradigm cases that everyone should have in mind is Wikipedia. It’s a global resource used by almost everyone on the planet. We’re a non-profit organization. We’re community-built, community-driven. And when I see things in the Global Digital Compact that talk about protecting and supporting digital public goods, I’m very, very happy about this. Because too often, when policymakers are thinking about how to make decisions on public policy and the Internet, they’re really thinking about top-down social media platforms that I always say they run like feudal estates. All the people using it are like the serfs, but the master makes the rules from top down. Whereas we’re a community. We’re a bunch of people. All the rules of Wikipedia are made by the community. All of the decisions are made out in the community. The Wikimedia Foundation doesn’t engage in sort of constant moderation. Boy, the number of times people have complained to me, Wikipedia says this, Jimmy Wales is a communist. I’m like, well, first, I’m not a communist, and second, I didn’t write it. And there’s the sources, and there’s actually a debate, and you can get involved, and let’s have a discourse about human knowledge. So my call to action, really, for everyone is to, and to governments in particular, is let’s think about, as we’re doing public policy, let’s really begin to adopt what I would call the Wikipedia test. If you’re about to pass some rule, think about, is this going to wreck Wikipedia? And if it is, it might not be a great rule. And that might not be, you might want to step back and say, hold on a second, we do need to, oh, yes, clap, please, yes. We need to protect these open communities. So, thank you.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Thank you so much. First one was for the Wikipedia test. Yes, thank you so much. And now I’d like to move to Professor Gasser, who is Professor of Public Policy Governance and Innovative Technology at the Technical University of Munich, TUM, who has been a great partner also in organizing this event, and also the Dean of the TUM School of Social Sciences. So, Professor Gasser, I’d like to move to you as an expert scholar representing academia and go back to the idea of digital commons as a necessary condition for the development of digital public goods. So, academia is also a big contributor to the digital commons. How do you see its role in this context and in improving shared access to knowledge and digital public goods in general?

Urs Gasser: Wonderful. Thank you so much for inviting also perspectives from academia. And, of course, it’s a great honor to be on this panel. And I would like to start right where Jimmy started as well with values. I think if you look at the values of academia, and Fabro set the stage beautifully, you see how this idea of public interest mission of academic organizations and the public interest-driven mindset of academics and academic community make academia a natural ally to the cause of digital public goods and the commons. So, I see a lot of resemblance and echoes to what you just described. I think Fabro already pointed out and alluded to the different functions that academic institutions and, more importantly, also the human beings in academia can play as we aim for more robust commons ecosystems. I just would like to maybe highlight three such roles. The first one is academia, academic networks and individuals as trusted creators of knowledge. If you look back over the past couple of decades, academics have been key contributors to building the digital commons by sharing data and knowledge about the world and doing so through open access publishing, among other things. The second role I would like to highlight is academia as an incubator and convener. Academic communities and values have been a key driver in incubating and launching digital public infrastructures. Just think back about the origins of the internet and the world wide web that were shaped by academic values and communities. But also as we’ve heard examples today, I hope I don’t reveal secrets, but global voices or creative commons and many more projects were closely linked to academic institutions and communities when they started. So you see the role of academia here again as we think about the creation of digital public infrastructures. And let me emphasize one point, what the beauty of it is, is that it’s happening in a distributed way, in a collaborative spirit, and that’s very powerful. The third role I would like to briefly highlight is that academia can not only contribute in these different forms substantively to the formation of digital commons and digital public goods. It can also study and assess what we can learn about digital commons as we go forward, about the society. societal impact about the relevance, we can assess whether we pass the Wikipedia test when new policies are rolled out. So academia can be a learning partner in our endeavors, can help to inform policymaking and good governance. So you see all together, and I just highlighted three rules, you see how academia should actually join the calls around this table and stakeholders for strong principles, policies, and practices that embrace the wealth of distributed academic networks so that together with the other stakeholders we can double down on our commitment to build strong and robust commons ecosystems for the future. Thank you very much.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Thank you so much, and thank you to all of the panelists. I now I’m gonna move to the closing section of this event because we are already running a little over time, but thank you so much for for your participation. And now I would like to call back my co-moderator, Nicole. And for the closing remarks, Mr. Emran Mian, the Director General for Digital and Telecoms in the UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology. Yes, please, Dr. Emran Mian, you have the floor.

Emran Mian: Thank you very much. Conscious of time, I’ll be very brief. Thank you very much for organizing this event. It’s been a real pleasure to listen to stakeholders across this community talk about DPGs and their contributions to them. There’s just two things I wanted to bring out as reflections. One is focusing on digital skills and the skills that people need both to create DPGs but also to enjoy DPGs. And this is a shared responsibility, I think, across the stakeholder community, businesses, civil society, and government. And the UK government, for our part, we’re very pleased of the way in which we’re able to work with partners in countries such as Indonesia, Kenya, and Nigeria to help people to acquire these digital skills. And there’s a lot more to do on that front. And then the second thing I just wanted to draw out was trust and safety. To continue to enjoy DPGs and for DPGs to continue to be created, people need to trust the digital technologies that they are using, and they need to be safe when they’re doing so. And again, for our part as a UK government, we’ve been really pleased to be part of a conversation on AI safety and to have initiated that at Bletchley Park with a UK-hosted safety summit last year. And it’s great to see the continuance of that in all kinds of ways, including a summit in Seoul earlier this year. And earlier this morning we were hearing from the French about their plans for an AI action summit early next year. And I know this is a real source of concern. sort of attention and action for the UN as well. I’ll stop there. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much. And I will now introduce Dr. Anna Christmann. She has multiple heads in innovation technology in the German ecosystem, as member of parliament, amongst others. I guess most people here in New York know her from her role in the Secretary General’s high-level advisory body on AI. Anna, the floor is yours.

Anna Christmann: Yeah, thank you so much. I’m very happy to be part of this panel. And just mentioning first that I’m very inspired by the panels that we just had. And I think it’s an important signal that this panel takes place today in the context of the Global Digital Compact. I think that is just a very important signal of the relevance of digital common goods for the society on a global scale and all the things that we heard about leaving no one behind, strengthening the multi-stakeholder approach, access for everyone and everywhere. I think these are just very important principles and it’s good that they are here in New York in the context of the summit of the future. And then maybe two very concrete points to the questions. What is the call to action that we heard for the future now, building on what we heard today. It was all the great examples also, of course, what we have already as common global digital comments. And I would say one is to really be active now in building this international ecosystem of the multi-stakeholder approach of all the people who are involved already in the open source community and everything around, but also bringing all the other stakeholders into this field. And we heard states might not be the leaders so far, but bringing them as very active actors into this ecosystem. So I would invite us all to really start new hands on initiatives and. projects to co-design frontier open data and also AI solutions and I think there are also links to the work that we did at the high-level advisory body and artificial intelligence at the UN and we have the report which is a lot about capacity building and openness and I think that really links a lot to what we heard today. And of course they are crucial is bringing the people together have the ecosystem have also the investments and the multi-stakeholder governance I think that would be important principles for that. And then maybe mentioning also one very concrete thing that we can do from here on is bringing as a question of DPGs across policy fields and there of course in the UN context as a question of climate policy is one obvious one so bringing this idea and discussions that we had today also to the context of the COP I think would be very valuable as well and I think if everyone is active like we are also in Germany just to mention this very short with with also different initiatives around digital sovereignty data institutes as we are just building if we get this ecosystem on the global scale I think there’s lots to win for all of us. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much and so I guess in light of the timing Constanze and I will just wrap up. So it was our intention here today to convene high-level speakers from UN member states the United Nations and especially academia and civil society really to discuss best practices and a common understanding and I guess just linking to what Dr. Anna Christmann has said we really invite all of you to join our conversations to kick-start projects to really enable this global solutions architects, ecosystem on developing DPGs together.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Yes, yes, thank you. Thank you everyone, it was a fantastic conversation that I am sure will lead to many more conversations. So to be continued, thank you everyone for participating.

A

Amandeep Gill

Speech speed

116 words per minute

Speech length

579 words

Speech time

297 seconds

DPGs and DPI are essential for inclusive, sustainable digital transformation

Explanation

Amandeep Gill emphasizes that digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) are vital for an equitable and sustainable digital future. He argues that these resources are key to democratizing access to knowledge and technological resources.

Evidence

The Global Digital Compact embeds an international commitment to global digital commons through digital public goods and digital public infrastructure.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for global development

Agreed with

Fabro Steibel

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Agreed on

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

The Global Digital Compact provides a new foundation for DPG/DPI action

Explanation

Gill highlights that the Global Digital Compact, as part of the Pact for the Future, establishes a new basis for more meaningful action in the area of digital public goods and infrastructure. This document represents a significant step forward in international commitment to these resources.

Evidence

The Global Digital Compact embeds an international commitment to global digital commons through digital public goods and digital public infrastructure.

Major Discussion Point

The future of DPGs and digital governance

F

Fabro Steibel

Speech speed

194 words per minute

Speech length

552 words

Speech time

170 seconds

DPGs emerge faster in the Global South out of necessity

Explanation

Fabro Steibel points out that digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) tend to develop more quickly in the Global South due to pressing needs. He suggests that this is because these technologies are essential for spreading and equalizing wealth and power in these regions.

Evidence

Examples of DPGs from Brazil, such as CAR (rural environmental registry) and Pegabot (bot detection tool).

Major Discussion Point

The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for global development

Agreed with

Amandeep Gill

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Agreed on

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

A

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Speech speed

127 words per minute

Speech length

704 words

Speech time

330 seconds

DPGs and DPI are critical for closing the digital divide

Explanation

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu emphasizes the importance of digital public goods and infrastructure in reducing inequalities and promoting digital inclusion. She argues that these resources are essential for ensuring that technology benefits all people, particularly marginalized communities.

Evidence

Mexico’s efforts to develop inclusive digital infrastructure and tools for small and medium enterprises.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for global development

Agreed with

Amandeep Gill

Fabro Steibel

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Agreed on

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

E

Eileen Donahoe

Speech speed

130 words per minute

Speech length

829 words

Speech time

382 seconds

DPGs and DPI need universal safeguards to protect human rights

Explanation

Eileen Donahoe argues for the importance of incorporating universal safeguards into digital public goods and infrastructure to protect human rights. She emphasizes that development and human rights should not be seen as conflicting goals, but rather as complementary.

Evidence

The Universal Safeguards Initiative launched by the Office of the Tech Envoy and UNDP.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for global development

Need to balance development goals with protecting human rights

Explanation

Donahoe stresses the importance of integrating human rights protections into the design and development of digital public goods and infrastructure. She argues that development should not come at the expense of human rights, but rather should be a tool to achieve them.

Evidence

The Universal Safeguards Initiative with its foundational principle of ‘do no harm’.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and considerations in developing DPGs

K

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Speech speed

112 words per minute

Speech length

1070 words

Speech time

572 seconds

Governments need to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs

Explanation

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi emphasizes the critical role of governments in creating an enabling environment for digital public goods. He argues that governments must establish legal frameworks and ensure connectivity to support the development and use of DPGs.

Evidence

Nigeria’s initiatives to promote connectivity, including a 9,000 km fiber optics project and digital literacy programs.

Major Discussion Point

The role of different stakeholders in developing and governing DPGs

Agreed with

Amandeep Gill

Fabro Steibel

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Agreed on

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

Disagreed with

Jimmy Wales

Disagreed on

Role of government in DPG development

M

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Speech speed

143 words per minute

Speech length

573 words

Speech time

239 seconds

Civil society ensures DPGs remain transparent, inclusive and responsive to societal needs

Explanation

Marianne Díaz Hernández argues that civil society plays a crucial role in ensuring that digital public goods serve the public interest. She emphasizes the importance of community-led spaces and multi-stakeholder governance in creating transparent and inclusive digital commons.

Major Discussion Point

The role of different stakeholders in developing and governing DPGs

Agreed with

Urs Gasser

Jimmy Wales

Agreed on

Multi-stakeholder approach in DPG development and governance

Need for a paradigm shift to build technologies with the public in mind

Explanation

Díaz Hernández calls for a fundamental change in how we approach technology development. She argues for creating technologies that are built with the public interest as a core principle, rather than as an afterthought.

Major Discussion Point

The future of DPGs and digital governance

U

Urs Gasser

Speech speed

126 words per minute

Speech length

490 words

Speech time

232 seconds

Academia serves as creators, incubators and assessors of DPGs

Explanation

Urs Gasser highlights the multifaceted role of academia in the development of digital public goods. He argues that academic institutions and individuals contribute as trusted creators of knowledge, incubators of new projects, and assessors of the societal impact of DPGs.

Evidence

Examples of academic contributions to the digital commons, such as open access publishing and the incubation of projects like Global Voices and Creative Commons.

Major Discussion Point

The role of different stakeholders in developing and governing DPGs

Agreed with

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Jimmy Wales

Agreed on

Multi-stakeholder approach in DPG development and governance

J

Jimmy Wales

Speech speed

166 words per minute

Speech length

911 words

Speech time

327 seconds

Community-driven governance is key for successful DPGs like Wikipedia

Explanation

Jimmy Wales emphasizes the importance of community-driven governance in the success of digital public goods like Wikipedia. He argues that allowing the community to make rules and decisions leads to a more robust and responsive platform.

Evidence

Wikipedia’s community-driven policies and decision-making processes.

Major Discussion Point

The role of different stakeholders in developing and governing DPGs

Agreed with

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Urs Gasser

Agreed on

Multi-stakeholder approach in DPG development and governance

Disagreed with

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Disagreed on

Role of government in DPG development

E

Emran Mian

Speech speed

171 words per minute

Speech length

289 words

Speech time

101 seconds

Importance of digital skills and trust/safety for DPG adoption

Explanation

Emran Mian highlights the critical role of digital skills and trust in the adoption of digital public goods. He argues that people need both the skills to use DPGs and the confidence that these technologies are safe and trustworthy.

Evidence

UK government’s work with partners in countries like Indonesia, Kenya, and Nigeria to help people acquire digital skills.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and considerations in developing DPGs

N

Nicole Manger

Speech speed

120 words per minute

Speech length

889 words

Speech time

442 seconds

DPGs require robust funding mechanisms and data/AI literacy

Explanation

Nicole Manger points out the need for strong funding mechanisms to support the development of digital public goods. She also emphasizes the importance of data and AI literacy in leveraging DPGs effectively.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and considerations in developing DPGs

R

Rebecca MacKinnon

Speech speed

130 words per minute

Speech length

802 words

Speech time

368 seconds

Multilingualism and local context are crucial for global DPGs

Explanation

Rebecca MacKinnon emphasizes the importance of multilingualism and local context in the development of global digital public goods. She argues that DPGs should reflect the linguistic and cultural diversity of their users to be truly inclusive and effective.

Evidence

Examples of Wikipedia versions in various languages, including indigenous languages like Waiyu.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and considerations in developing DPGs

A

Anna Christmann

Speech speed

148 words per minute

Speech length

465 words

Speech time

187 seconds

Importance of bringing DPG discussions to other policy areas like climate

Explanation

Anna Christmann suggests expanding the discussion of digital public goods to other policy areas, particularly climate policy. She argues that integrating DPG concepts into broader policy discussions can enhance their impact and relevance.

Major Discussion Point

The future of DPGs and digital governance

Call for new hands-on initiatives to co-design frontier open data and AI solutions

Explanation

Christmann calls for practical initiatives to collaboratively design cutting-edge open data and AI solutions. She emphasizes the importance of multi-stakeholder involvement in these efforts to ensure their effectiveness and inclusivity.

Major Discussion Point

The future of DPGs and digital governance

Agreements

Agreement Points

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

Speakers

Amandeep Gill

Fabro Steibel

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Arguments

DPGs and DPI are essential for inclusive, sustainable digital transformation

DPGs emerge faster in the Global South out of necessity

DPGs and DPI are critical for closing the digital divide

Governments need to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs

Summary

Multiple speakers emphasized the crucial role of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) in promoting inclusive development, particularly in the Global South.

Multi-stakeholder approach in DPG development and governance

Speakers

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Urs Gasser

Jimmy Wales

Arguments

Civil society ensures DPGs remain transparent, inclusive and responsive to societal needs

Academia serves as creators, incubators and assessors of DPGs

Community-driven governance is key for successful DPGs like Wikipedia

Summary

Speakers agreed on the importance of involving multiple stakeholders, including civil society, academia, and community members, in the development and governance of DPGs.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the need to prioritize human rights and public interest in the development of digital technologies and infrastructure.

Speakers

Eileen Donahoe

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Arguments

DPGs and DPI need universal safeguards to protect human rights

Need for a paradigm shift to build technologies with the public in mind

Unexpected Consensus

Global South leadership in DPG development

Speakers

Fabro Steibel

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Arguments

DPGs emerge faster in the Global South out of necessity

DPGs and DPI are critical for closing the digital divide

Governments need to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs

Explanation

There was an unexpected consensus on the Global South’s leadership and innovation in DPG development, challenging the common perception of technological advancement being primarily driven by the Global North.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement included the importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development, the need for multi-stakeholder involvement in DPG development and governance, and the recognition of human rights and public interest in digital technologies.

Consensus level

There was a high level of consensus among speakers on the fundamental importance and potential of DPGs and DPI. This strong agreement suggests a solid foundation for future collaborative efforts in developing and implementing DPGs globally, particularly in addressing development challenges in the Global South.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Role of government in DPG development

Speakers

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Jimmy Wales

Arguments

Governments need to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs

Community-driven governance is key for successful DPGs like Wikipedia

Summary

While Abdullahi emphasizes the critical role of governments in creating an enabling environment for DPGs, Wales stresses the importance of community-driven governance. This represents a difference in perspective on the primary drivers of successful DPG development.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around the role of different stakeholders in DPG development and governance, as well as the approach to integrating human rights and public interest into DPG design.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among the speakers is relatively low. Most speakers agree on the importance of DPGs for global development and the need for inclusive, rights-respecting approaches. The differences mainly lie in the emphasis placed on various stakeholders’ roles and the specific strategies for implementation. These nuanced disagreements can actually be beneficial for developing a comprehensive approach to DPG development and governance, as they highlight different perspectives that need to be considered.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

Both speakers agree on the importance of protecting human rights in the development of DPGs, but they differ in their approach. Donahoe advocates for universal safeguards, while Díaz Hernández calls for a more fundamental paradigm shift in how technologies are developed.

Speakers

Eileen Donahoe

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Arguments

DPGs and DPI need universal safeguards to protect human rights

Need for a paradigm shift to build technologies with the public in mind

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the need to prioritize human rights and public interest in the development of digital technologies and infrastructure.

Speakers

Eileen Donahoe

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Arguments

DPGs and DPI need universal safeguards to protect human rights

Need for a paradigm shift to build technologies with the public in mind

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

Digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) are essential for inclusive, sustainable global digital transformation

DPGs and DPI require multi-stakeholder collaboration between governments, civil society, academia, and communities

Universal safeguards and human rights protections must be built into DPGs and DPI by design

Community-driven governance and local context are crucial for successful global DPGs like Wikipedia

The Global Digital Compact provides a new foundation for international action on DPGs and DPI

Resolutions and Action Items

Incorporate the ‘Wikipedia test’ when developing digital policies to ensure they don’t harm open community projects

Bring DPG discussions to other policy areas like climate change and COP negotiations

Start new hands-on initiatives to co-design frontier open data and AI solutions as DPGs

Build a global ecosystem and multi-stakeholder governance structures for DPGs

Unresolved Issues

How to balance rapid development of DPGs with ensuring robust human rights protections

Sustainable funding mechanisms for DPGs and open-source projects

How to improve data and AI literacy to enable wider participation in DPG development

Addressing potential risks and misuse of DPGs and open data

Suggested Compromises

Develop universal safeguards for DPIs that protect rights while enabling development

Use AI and machine translation to accelerate growth of smaller language Wikipedias while maintaining local community involvement

Thought Provoking Comments

Well-governed commons are the foundations of human civilization. Digital is no exception, and today more than ever digital commons are vital to our interconnected world.

Speaker

Amandeep Gill

Reason

This comment frames digital commons as a fundamental part of modern civilization, elevating their importance.

Impact

It set the tone for the discussion by emphasizing the critical nature of digital commons in our interconnected world, encouraging participants to consider their broad societal impact.

DPIs emerge earlier and faster in the Global South than in the Global North. This is what research shows and most likely this is because out of necessity. In the Global South, we need better technologies to spread and equalize wealth and power.

Speaker

Fabro Steibel

Reason

This insight challenges the common assumption that technological innovation primarily comes from the Global North.

Impact

It shifted the conversation to consider the unique needs and contributions of the Global South in developing digital public infrastructure, broadening the global perspective of the discussion.

When we focus on development above human rights, instead of understanding development as a tool to achieve human rights, we risk creating systems that have not been designed with human rights as a principle, but as an afterthought.

Speaker

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Reason

This comment highlights a crucial tension between development and human rights in the context of digital technologies.

Impact

It deepened the conversation by emphasizing the need to prioritize human rights in the design and implementation of digital systems, encouraging a more nuanced approach to development.

If you’re about to pass some rule, think about, is this going to wreck Wikipedia? And if it is, it might not be a great rule.

Speaker

Jimmy Wales

Reason

This ‘Wikipedia test’ provides a simple yet powerful heuristic for evaluating digital policies.

Impact

It introduced a practical framework for policymakers to consider the impact of regulations on open, community-driven digital public goods, potentially influencing future policy discussions.

Academia can not only contribute in these different forms substantively to the formation of digital commons and digital public goods. It can also study and assess what we can learn about digital commons as we go forward, about the societal impact about the relevance, we can assess whether we pass the Wikipedia test when new policies are rolled out.

Speaker

Urs Gasser

Reason

This comment highlights the multifaceted role of academia in both creating and studying digital commons.

Impact

It expanded the discussion to include the importance of ongoing research and assessment in the development and governance of digital public goods, emphasizing a learning-oriented approach.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by broadening its scope from a primarily Western and government-centric view to a more global, multi-stakeholder perspective. They emphasized the critical importance of digital commons in modern society, highlighted the unique contributions of the Global South, stressed the need to prioritize human rights in technological development, introduced practical frameworks for policy evaluation, and underscored the role of academia in both creating and studying digital public goods. This resulted in a rich, nuanced conversation that considered the complex interplay between technology, policy, human rights, and global development in the context of digital public goods.

Follow-up Questions

How can we ensure digital public goods and infrastructure are designed with human rights as a core principle rather than an afterthought?

Speaker

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Explanation

This is important to ensure development of digital systems aligns with human rights and builds necessary trust.

How can we better enable civil society and communities globally to have a voice in how technology is developed?

Speaker

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia

Explanation

This is crucial for ensuring digital public goods reflect diverse needs and perspectives.

How can we apply the ‘Wikipedia test’ when developing new internet regulations and policies?

Speaker

Jimmy Wales

Explanation

This approach could help protect open communities and digital public goods when crafting new rules.

How can we strengthen the multi-stakeholder ecosystem for developing digital public goods?

Speaker

Anna Christmann

Explanation

Building a robust ecosystem with diverse stakeholders is key for advancing digital public goods.

How can we integrate digital public goods into climate policy discussions, such as at COP?

Speaker

Anna Christmann

Explanation

Bringing digital public goods into other policy areas could expand their impact and application.

How can we improve digital skills both for creating and using digital public goods?

Speaker

Emran Mian

Explanation

Enhancing digital skills is crucial for the development and adoption of digital public goods.

How can we ensure trust and safety in the creation and use of digital public goods?

Speaker

Emran Mian

Explanation

Trust and safety are fundamental for the continued creation and enjoyment of digital public goods.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

A Digital Future for All (morning sessions)

A Digital Future for All (morning sessions)

Session at a Glance

Summary

This discussion focused on the importance of creating an inclusive and sustainable digital future for all. The event, hosted by ITU and UNDP, brought together leaders from government, industry, and civil society to explore how digital technologies can advance the Sustainable Development Goals.

Speakers highlighted the urgent need to bridge the digital divide, with 2.6 billion people still lacking internet access. They emphasized that connectivity alone is not enough – digital skills, affordable devices, and meaningful content are also crucial. Several initiatives were announced to expand connectivity and digital literacy, particularly in underserved communities.

The transformative potential of technologies like AI, blockchain, and satellite communications was showcased through various examples. These included using AI for flood prediction, blockchain for refugee assistance, and satellites for wildlife conservation. Speakers stressed the importance of ensuring these technologies benefit everyone, not just the privileged few.

Digital public infrastructure was presented as a key foundation for inclusive development. Examples from countries like Brazil, India and Estonia demonstrated how digital ID systems and other core platforms can improve service delivery and economic participation. However, speakers emphasized that proper safeguards for privacy and security are essential.

The discussion also explored how digital technologies can support environmental sustainability, from monitoring deforestation to enabling clean energy transitions. Youth representatives called for ensuring the digital future is equitable, secure and empowering for all.

Overall, the event highlighted both the immense opportunities and challenges of the digital revolution. Speakers agreed that realizing an inclusive digital future will require collaborative efforts across sectors and borders, with a focus on putting people and planet at the center of technological progress.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– The importance of universal and affordable digital connectivity, with a focus on connecting the 2.6 billion people who are still unconnected

– Leveraging digital technologies and AI to address global challenges like climate change, healthcare, education, and economic development

– Ensuring digital inclusion and bridging digital divides, especially for women, youth, and underserved communities

– The need for safeguards, regulations and ethical frameworks as AI and digital technologies advance

– Public-private partnerships and multi-stakeholder collaboration to drive digital transformation

Overall purpose:

The overall purpose of the discussion was to highlight the transformative potential of digital technologies and AI in achieving sustainable development goals, while emphasizing the need for inclusive and responsible approaches to ensure no one is left behind in the digital future.

Tone:

The overall tone was optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers expressing enthusiasm about technological possibilities while also acknowledging challenges. There was a sense of urgency in calls to action for bridging digital divides. The tone remained largely consistent throughout, balancing excitement about innovation with reminders of the importance of ethics and inclusion.

Speakers

Moderators/Facilitators:

– Sade Baderinwa – Eyewitness News Anchor, ABC News

Speakers:

– Achim Steiner – Administrator, UNDP

– Amandeep Singh Gill – UN Secretary General’s Envoy in Technology

– Doreen Bogdan-Martin – Secretary General , ITU

– Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub – CEO Vodacom Group and Vodafone Executive Committee Member

– Jessica Rosenworcel – Chairwoman, Federal Communications Commission, USA

– Juan Lavista Ferres – Corporate Vice President and Chief Data Scientist, Microsoft

– Emma Theophilus – Minister of Information and Communication Technology, Namibia

– Karan Bhatia – Vice President of Government Affairs and Public Policy, Google

– David Sapolsky – Senior Vice President, Global Public Policy & General Counsel, Amazon

– Ann Aerts – Head, Novartis Foundation

– Mats Granryd – Director General, GSMA

– Alexandre Reis Siqueira Freire – Commissioner, National Telecommunications Agency, Brazil

– Rabab Fatima – Under-Secretary-General and High Representative UNOHRLLS

– Bianca Faith Johnson – President, Board of Trustees, Push to Walk

– Kelly T. Clements – United Nations Deputy High Commissioner for Refugees

– Lady Mariéme Jamme – Founder and CEO, iamtheCODE

– Amr Talaat – Minister of Information and Communication Technology, Egypt

– Lisa Russell – Emmy-winning Filmmaker and Founder/CEO of Arts Envoy Lab/Create2030

– Lori Freeman – Global GM and Vice President, Salesforce for Nonprofits

– Tunde Wackman – Chief Development Officer, World Central Kitchen

– Abdullah Alswaha – Minister of Communications and Information Technology, Saudi Arabia

– Joan Joseph Moses – Educator, Roosevelt Douglas Primary School in Portsmouth, Dominica

– Tofara L. Chokera – CEO and Founder, Tofara Online

– Pamela Coke-Hamilton – Executive Director, International Trade Center

– Christopher Burns – Chief Digital Development Officer and Director, Technology Division, USAID

– Lazarus Chakwera – President of Malawi

– Esther Dweck – Minister for Management and Innovation and Public Services of Brazil

– Paul Foster – CEO, Global Esports Federation

– Brad Smith – Vice Chair and President, Microsoft

– Alan Davidson – Assistant Secretary of Commerce for Communications and Information and Administrator, National Telecommunications and Information Administration, USA

– Rumman Chowdhury – CEO and co-Founder, Humane Intelligence, United States Science Envoy, Artificial Intelligence

– Harrison Lung – Group Chief Strategy Officer, e&

– Bosun Tijani – Minister of Communications, Innovation and Digital Economy, Nigeria

– Robert Muggah – Co-Founder, Igarapé Institute

– Valentino Valentini – Deputy Minister at the Ministry of Enterprise and Made in Italy

– Jakob Granit – Director-General, Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency

– Zhiping Chen – Vice President, ZTE Corporation

– Fatou Haidara – Deputy Director General, UNIDO

– Daren Tang – Director General, WIPO

– Tawfik Jelassi – Assistant Director-General for Communication and Information, UNESCO

– Deemah AlYahya – Secretary General, Digital Cooperation Organization

– Nobu Okada – Founder and CEO, AstroScale

Youth Representatives:

– Sanjana Sanghi – UNDP India Youth Champion and Bollywood Actress

– Yuri Romashko – CEO, Institute of Analysis and Advocacy, UNDP Generation 17

– Daniella Esi Darlington – Co-Founder, Copianto AI and ITU Secretary-General’s Youth Advisory Board Member

Full session report

Expanded Summary of the Discussion on Creating an Inclusive Digital Future

Introduction

This discussion, part of the Summit of the Future Action Days, was hosted by ITU and UNDP. It brought together leaders from government, industry, civil society, and youth to explore how digital technologies can advance the Sustainable Development Goals and create an inclusive digital future for all. The event was moderated by Sade Baderinwa, a news anchor at WABC in New York, and featured a diverse array of speakers with expertise in technology, development, and policy.

Key Themes and Discussion Points

1. Universal Digital Connectivity

A central focus of the discussion was the urgent need to bridge the digital divide, with 2.6 billion people still lacking internet access. Speakers emphasised that connectivity alone is insufficient; digital skills, affordable devices, and meaningful content are also crucial for true digital inclusion.

Technological Solutions:

– Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub (Vodacom Group) stressed the importance of connecting the unconnected.

– Jessica Rosenworcel (FCC) highlighted satellite-to-cell phone communications as a potential game-changer for ending mobile dead zones.

– Juan Lavista Ferres (Microsoft) discussed using AI and satellite imagery to map population shifts for targeted connectivity efforts.

– David Sapolsky (Amazon) presented Project Kuiper for affordable global satellite broadband.

The Partner2Connect Digital Coalition was highlighted as a crucial initiative, with significant pledges announced during the event to support digital inclusion efforts globally.

2. Digital Inclusion and Skills Development

Speakers emphasised that true digital inclusion requires both infrastructure and skills development, particularly for underserved populations.

Key Points:

– Tofara L. Chokera (Tofara Online Trust) highlighted digital skills training for economic empowerment, especially for women and youth.

– Mats Granryd (GSMA) pointed out that affordable smartphones are key to bridging the digital divide.

– Lazarus Chakwera (President of Malawi) called for integrating digital literacy into national education curricula and presented the Digital Malawi Project.

– Christopher Burns (USAID) introduced the Responsible Computing Challenge to embed ethics in tech education.

3. AI for Sustainable Development

The transformative potential of AI in addressing global challenges was a recurring theme, balanced with calls for responsible and ethical development.

Applications and Initiatives:

– Karan Bhatia (Google) discussed AI for early flood warnings and disaster preparedness.

– Valentino Valentini (Ministry of Enterprise and Made in Italy) presented the AI Hub for Sustainable Development.

– Achim Steiner (UNDP) stressed the need for AI safeguards to prevent exclusion and protect rights.

– Rumman Chowdhury (Humane Intelligence) highlighted evaluating AI systems for cultural appropriateness.

– Brad Smith (Microsoft) emphasised ensuring AI benefits the Global South.

4. Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) and Digital Public Goods

DPI was presented as a key foundation for inclusive development, with speakers emphasizing its potential and the need for careful implementation.

Perspectives:

– Esther Dweck (Minister, Brazil) discussed DPI for efficient government services, financial inclusion, and environmental efforts.

– Achim Steiner highlighted that DPI requires commitment, capital, and capacity building.

– Several speakers emphasized the importance of digital public goods in fostering innovation and development.

5. Technology for Social Impact

The discussion showcased various examples of how digital technologies can create significant social impact across diverse fields.

Examples:

– Bianca Faith Johnson demonstrated exoskeleton technology that restores mobility for paralyzed individuals, highlighting the need to make such technologies widely accessible and affordable.

– Kelly T. Clements (UNHCR) discussed blockchain-based digital wallets for rapid financial aid to refugees.

– Ann Aerts (Novartis Foundation) highlighted AI and digital tools for improving healthcare outcomes and reducing inequalities.

– Zhiping Chen (ZTE Corporation) discussed digital technologies for protecting endangered species in remote areas.

6. Youth Perspectives and Initiatives

The event featured strong youth representation, highlighting their role in shaping the digital future.

Key Contributions:

– Sanjana Sanghi presented youth-led initiatives for digital inclusion and skills development.

– Yuri Romashko discussed the importance of involving young people in digital policy-making.

– Daniella Esi Darlington highlighted youth-led efforts to bridge the digital divide in Africa.

7. Space Sustainability and Innovation

Nobu Okada presented on the critical issue of space sustainability, discussing innovative technologies for space debris removal and the importance of maintaining a clean orbital environment for future space-based technologies.

8. Global Initiatives and Frameworks

Several speakers highlighted important global initiatives:

– Amandeep Singh Gill discussed the Global Digital Compact and its importance in shaping international digital cooperation.

– Deemah AlYahya presented the Digital Cooperation Organization’s Digital Economy Navigator (DEN).

– Paul Foster announced the Global Esports Federation’s pledge to support digital inclusion through gaming.

9. Creative Integration of Technology

Lisa Russell demonstrated the integration of AI in creative fields by presenting AI-generated artwork created during the event, sparking discussions on the future of human-AI collaboration in the arts.

Challenges and Unresolved Issues

1. Ensuring AI development benefits the Global South without exacerbating inequalities

2. Balancing rapid technological advancement with necessary regulatory frameworks and ethical considerations

3. Addressing potential job displacement due to AI and automation in developing countries

4. Ensuring data privacy and security in the implementation of digital public infrastructure

5. Making cutting-edge technologies widely accessible and affordable

6. Maintaining space sustainability while advancing space-based technologies

Conclusion

The discussion highlighted both the immense opportunities and challenges of the digital revolution. Speakers agreed that realising an inclusive digital future will require collaborative efforts across sectors, generations, and borders, with a focus on putting people and planet at the centre of technological progress. The overall tone was optimistic and forward-looking, balanced with a strong emphasis on ethical considerations, inclusion, and responsible development of digital technologies.

Session Transcript

Sade Baderinwa: If everyone could please take their seats, in the back, if you could please take your seats. Thank you so much. We’re going to begin. It is good to see everyone here this morning. Your Excellencies, esteemed speakers, and distinguished guests, I’m Sade Baderinwa, a news anchor at WABC in New York, and it is an absolute pleasure to be here today. Thank you. We’ve got some eyewitnesses viewers. Well, welcome to the summit of the future, Action Days, a digital future for all. We are living in an extraordinary era of technological transformation. Consider this. A cook in Thailand shares a family recipe through a short video online, and within hours, people around the globe are replicating it in their kitchens. In mere moments, that recipe transcends borders. We find ourselves at a pivotal crossroads. Technology is reshaping our lives at a speed we just couldn’t have imagined just a decade ago. It is revolutionizing industries, democratizing education, and connecting people across continents. In healthcare, artificial intelligence is diagnosing diseases with unprecedented accuracy and speed, delivering life-saving treatments to once inaccessible regions. Personalized medicine tailored to individual needs is no longer a far-off dream, but a reality on the horizon. Today, you will witness that transformation firsthand. A woman who is paralyzed will walk again through the use of technology. It truly is remarkable, and I think you all are going to be blown away. We’ll also explore how technology is being harnessed beyond the battlefield. Satellite-based networks are restoring communication in war-torn areas like Ukraine, where infrastructure is devastated. Consider the plight of refugees escaping war zones like Ukraine. They often arrive with only the clothes on their backs. No money. No legal documents and no answers for tomorrow. Technology, however, is changing that. Through blockchain technologies, refugees will be given digital wallets that offer instant access to financial aid and shelter. You’re going to hear today how this groundbreaking solution is enabling refugees to rebuild their lives in just mere minutes. Meanwhile, there are so many companies using the power of AI to predict floods, offering life-saving warnings up to a week in advance. And these forecasts are reaching dozens of countries, protecting millions of people in vulnerable areas. We’re going to talk with some of these companies today. Digital access is truly a game changer. For millions of people in isolated regions, farmers, women, and schools in rural areas, often overlooked for decades, are now part of a connected world, transforming their lives and economies simply by getting online. You’ll hear today how this is helping the previously forgotten thrive. And as we explore these advancements, we must also be vigilant with our proper safeguards, the same technologies that drive progress could deepen inequalities, threaten privacy, and marginalize the most vulnerable. Our digital future must be open, free, and secure for everyone, not just for the privileged few. So today, we will also discuss those crucial safeguards. There’s so much to cover, and it’s going to be an exciting day centered on harnessing the transformative power of technology. So, let’s get started. And first, I’d like to introduce Achim Steiner, Administrator, UNDP. Amandeep Singh Gill, UN Secretary General’s Envoy in Technology. And Doreen Bogdan-Martin, Secretary General of ITU.

Achim Steiner: Thank you. At the end, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, welcome to this amazing room this morning. My name is Achim Steiner and I’m the head of the United Nations Development Programme, UNDP. I’m delighted to extend a very warm welcome to all of you joining us for the joint opening of the A Digital Future for All event, proudly co-hosted by UNDP, the International Telecommunication Union, and the Office of the UN Secretary General’s Envoy on Technology. We are convening on the eve of the Summit of the Future, when world leaders will come together in this building to commit to the bold new solutions that better reflect the realities of the 21st century, and can respond to both today’s and tomorrow’s challenges and, perhaps even more importantly, opportunities. Our event is part of the Summit’s Action Days, which focus on building multi-stakeholder partnerships and paving the way to a more inclusive and interconnected multinaturalism. Today, representatives from every corner of the globe and all sectors of society will showcase digital solutions and announce new commitments to realize that brighter digital future for everyone, everywhere. Our vision of a digital future for all. At UNDP, we believe that digital technologies will be the fundamental driver of development this century, reshaping economies and societies, and helping to radically reshape development – from driving down poverty and inequalities, to advancing gender equality, to powering decisive climate action. Working as part of the United Nations family, we are not only closing the digital connectivity divide, we are committed to helping to shape inclusive digital ecosystems in over 100 countries today to help digital innovation flourish everywhere. First in our partner countries, we are supporting the development of digital policies and strategies that guide country-level digital transformation. Second, we enable the planning and development of digital foundations that underpin inclusive digital transformations, particularly digital public infrastructure, which represent the roads and railway tracks, so to speak, of our new digital era. Third, we provide digital capacity-building support to ensure that governments and communities and citizens have the skills they need. Our work is only possible thanks to our partnership with governments, our UN partners, international organizations, the private sector, civil society, academia and well beyond. That is also the spirit of today’s event, to create strong collaborations that reach everyone, everywhere, and that ensure that people can shape their own digital future in this era. Thank you.

Amandeep Singh Gill: Good morning. How are we today? Welcome. The future calls, and here we are, united, determined to build it together. A peaceful, prosperous, sustainable and hopeful world, where technology empowers us all and disempowers none. Our future is digital, and we have been hard at work over the past two years to ensure that it is open, safe and secure, and that it leaves no one behind. A future that upholds our hard-won victories on human rights and sustainable development. UN member states, with critical contributions of stakeholders from civil society, the tech community and academia, and the private sector, have been negotiating a global digital compact. A uniquely diverse body of experts on artificial intelligence can mean by the Secretary General has worked at warp speed to produce a blueprint for the international governance of AI. And it all comes together tomorrow at the Summit of the Future. A pact for the future with two powerful annexes, a Global Digital Compact and a Declaration on Future Generations, will be on the table for leaders to decide and adopt. The Global Digital Compact puts digitalization at the center of multilateral cooperation and a fit-for-purpose United Nations. It sets out principles and actions to advance an open, safe and secure digital future for all. The GDC provides an ambitious agenda to harness digital technologies for development and benefit of all countries and communities. It provides us with a normative foundation, a moral compass, if you will, to benchmark our progress. It includes concrete commitments and actions, almost two decades after the World Summit on Information Society, to ensure that everyone, everywhere is connected to the internet and to close digital divides. It recognizes the challenges of safety and security online and seeks to mobilize political and financial resources to protect against risks and harms. The Compact is practical. It sets out actions to close digital divides and leverage technologies to accelerate development, expand opportunities for inclusion in the digital economy so that all stakeholders have more opportunities to generate value and be more than mere consumers of digital technologies. The GDC aims to protect and promote human rights online and make the digital space safe for all, especially children, women and girls. It aims to advance responsible, equitable and interoperable data governance, and importantly, it aims to govern AI for the public benefit and inclusively. At the core of the GDC is a commitment to inclusive, equitable governance of technology, in particular emerging technologies like AI. It makes digital governance a global public policy issue, one in which all stakeholders – the private sector, the tech community, civil society and academia – have a role to play. We are at the start of a new journey. We need your engagement to ensure that the commitments in the GDC bring meaningful digital futures to all. Thank you.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: Generation that has never known a world without digital. It’s the SDG generation. Millions of young people who are stepping into their teenage years on the brink of adulthood. Their journey has been extraordinary. They have grown up in a decade that has seen part of the population using the internet nearly double, social media surrounding us, and artificial intelligence going mainstream. They’re too young to remember when the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and the Paris Agreement on Climate Change were adopted. They were just kids when a global pandemic turned their world upside down and shifted education online. Then, like all of us, they encountered generative AI. In a series of developments. have since been nothing short of extraordinary, digital runs through their veins. It’s the most connected generation of all, and the first to come of age in an era of unimaginable digital opportunities. What will they do with all this power? How will they live up to this responsibility, and what kind of future will they build? Let’s see this future through their eyes, and let’s give them a seat at the table. So we’re in 2030, a not-so-distant digital future where everyone can access the Internet anytime, anywhere. Where having the right device is a basic standard, not a privilege. Where digital skills are a fundamental part of education. Where men and women have a fair shot at opportunity and success. Where algorithms create equity, not bias. Where access to computing resources are distributed more evenly, and where human rights are the bedrock of our digital society. Where safety is the norm, and where digital and green transitions go hand-in-hand. In short, a sustainable, inclusive, and responsible digital future for all. Three fundamental truths that guide our digital track, here during the action days of the Summit of the Future. Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, the digital future is not yet written. It’s happening on our watch. We are all, all the SDG generation. So let’s forge the digital future with the audacity of youth, a future full of hope, possibility, and ambition. The best future we can dream of. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you, Doreen. Thank you so much. Where algorithms create equity and not bias. So important. Thank you for those words. Well, now I give you SDG Digital.

Official Video: Hi, it’s not what you’re thinking. We’re not experiencing technological difficulties here. This is what our digital world looked like less than 50 years ago. This is what it still looks like for 2.6 billion people. Unconnected, to cell phones, computers, global knowledge bases. That’s not the inspiring, positive, optimistic message you might be sitting there hoping for. So what would a digital future for all be like? The world is at my fingertips. Just a click away. Fingertips. Just a click away. Endless possibilities. What we do now will affect generations to come. No one has to choose between paying the bills and using the Internet. The digital world must give every woman a voice and a chance to lead. Learning with the Internet is like a super power. Starting a business has never been faster. The time starts now.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: It all began with a simple question. What’s your vision of a digital future for all? We’ve just heard some powerful voices, all part of our campaign leading up to this moment. Now it’s time for Achim and I to share our vision. For me, it really comes down to three words. Universal, meaningful connectivity. It’s a driving force of the ITU as the UN agency for digital technologies, and it’s my number one priority. I want to be able to take my future grandchildren one day to the halls of the United Nations, and I want to be able to tell them the story of how we unlocked the power of digital and emerging technologies to everyone in this decade. No matter who they are, where they live. regardless of their gender, their age, their education, or the opportunities they’ve been given.

Achim Steiner: We live in a world in which the familiar is giving way to the unknown. We cannot predict where our new digital future will take us. We can hope for it. What we can do is help create an inclusive, sustainable, and prosperous digital future. That means setting the conditions so that everyone, everywhere, can reap the benefits of our digital world. Ensuring that everyone has the necessary skills, the capacities, and access so that no one is left behind. We must also harness digital technologies to protect and restore the environment and advance the decisive climate action we need so urgently to transform lives and livelihoods and drive progress across all, yes all, 17 Sustainable Development Goals. At UNDP, this is more than a vision. We are using digital to change lives today and ensure that the generations to come have the ability to determine their own futures.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: This future that Achim and I have described is within reach. Fast forward to September 25, 2030, the SDG deadline. It’s our moment of truth. Formidable challenges that once seemed insurmountable have given way to a future filled with promises. Countries and companies have doubled down on cybersecurity. Putting security first, they’ve saved countless lives and protected the global economy from escalating threats. We’ve bridged the global digital gender gap with major breakthroughs in least-developed countries where women’s online participation has surged. Digital technologies have become a powerhouse. ally in tackling climate change and in keeping the 1.5 degree target alive. Countries have worked together to clean up millions of pieces of debris in the low-earth orbit, making space sustainability a reality. Our efforts to develop standards against deepfakes have stopped the spread of disinformation and rebuilt the public’s trust in technology. And today, developing countries are competing on equal footing in AI with the infrastructure and the talent to drive innovation that benefits us all.

Achim Steiner: The year 2030. Imagine a deadline that seemed so distant, yet our global community has achieved so much. A global community united by a clear blueprint for a better future. The Sustainable Development Goals. No one lives in extreme poverty any longer. We live in a world free from hunger. Nearly every child has a primary education. Everyone has access to clean water and sanitation. Renewable energy powers four-fifths of the world. And nearly every car sold worldwide is an electric vehicle. Where digital technologies are powering decisive climate action and the protection and restoration of our natural world. Truly monumental achievements. How did we get there? Investments in digital were pivotal. Ones that went beyond the next app or one-off digital solution. We need to invest in a digital ecosystem from which true innovation takes root and can flourish. For our global community actively shaped the AI revolution to improve lives. And now, as we stand at the threshold of a new era, we see a world where progress is not just a possibility. It is the reality we’ve built together. It is to the age of possibility we are looking at.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: When Achim and I stood here for our first SDG Digital, we dared to think digital solutions could accelerate progress on 70% of the SDG targets. Now, in 2030, that vision has exceeded our expectations. Thanks to technologies like satellites, artificial intelligence, every school in the world is connected to the Internet. When the Giga Initiative helped connect Brianna’s school in Honduras, her first thought was for the unconnected children. As she put it, all children have the same rights. That’s true for countries, and that includes two-thirds of the small island developing states that lacked early warning systems. But the Early Warnings for All initiative changed that, uniting us through emerging technologies to ensure everyone is protected. These technologies marked a turning point in our efforts to rescue the SDGs and leave no one behind. I always remember Luis, a young ALS patient who joined us for our AI for Good Global Summit from his home in Lisbon. Luis had lost his ability to speak, but an AI device connected to his brain gave him back his voice.

Achim Steiner: As Doreen has so eloquently articulated, we see a world transforming ways we couldn’t have fully imagined even a few years ago. We’ve arrived at a point where digital transformation is not just about technology. It’s about lives, our lives, our children’s lives. Consider digital public infrastructure. Every person now has a secure digital identity. We are imagining the year 2030. This has unlocked services that were previously out of reach of so many. When the digital ID initiative reached a young mother, it didn’t just give her access to education and health care. For the first time, I feel seen, she said. Closing the digital skills gap has ushered in a new era of entrepreneurship. That includes a young graduate of 23 years of age. Thanks to a new digital bank account, he has now set up his own green transport business and employs seven people. Or look to technologies being harnessed to deliver for the planet. Governments and civil society are now using AI to track deforestation in real time, showing where to take action, combating forest fires. I’ll never forget a farmer that I met who used AI to help predict changing climate patterns and double her crop yield. Today, in 2030, we have a truly global AI ecosystem. And many of the world’s most impactful AI innovations come from regions like Africa, Latin America, the Caribbean, and Asia, to just mention a few examples.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: This is the moment when we said no to digital inequalities and yes to digital opportunities. And ITU and UNDP showed true partnership. As the world unites behind the vision laid out in the pact for the future, the declaration on future generations, and the global digital compact. It’s a new beginning. It’s the start of a journey towards greater unity, peace, and innovation, a future where digital technology serves as a force for good, and for inclusion, and for sustainable development. A future worth living for.

Achim Steiner: This is a moment to redefine our digital destiny. You must turn skepticism into an appetite for the unknown, a catalyst for change, and a willingness to push new frontiers. The ITU and UNDP are working together to put this commitment into practice across the globe as part of the UN’s promise. That includes driving progress on digital public infrastructure, capacity building and financing, the means to an end. And this is not just an idle digital dream. We are bringing this vision to life, like fiber optic cables lighting up with new streams of data, understanding and growth, powering a year of transformative breakthroughs for the SDGs.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: It all began with a simple question.

Achim Steiner: What is your vision of a digital future for all?

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: Today you will see how we can make this future a reality.

Achim Steiner: To rescue the SDGs.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: To build, right now, at the summit of the future action days, an affordable, universal,

Achim Steiner: meaningful and inclusive, sustainable and peaceful, and prosperous digital future for all.

Sade Baderinwa: And thank you Doreen and thank you Achim and Amandeep. Well, excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, and now we give you, as we mentioned, SDD Digital. Thank you both for propelling us to the future and for sharing your vision. Now is the time to delve into the powerful words you mentioned. And this is act two, the hope of digital. And we’re going to showcase concrete examples of game changing solutions for a digital future for all. And some of the solutions that we will see on stage today came through a rigorous process established by the advisory group of SDD Digital. So, let’s dive right into it. Let’s take a look at this video. 2.6 billion people are unconnected. A digital future for all can only be possible if access to connectivity is universal and affordable. So, to get us started, I have the pleasure to call to the stage Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub, who is the Chief Executive Officer and Executive Director of Vodacon Group. And we also have Jessica Rosenworcel, Chairwoman, Federal Communications Commission, and Juan Lavista Ferres, Corporate Vice President and Chief Data Scientist of Microsoft. Thank you. Thank you all. So, let me go with Broadband Commissioner Shamil. I’m excited about what you guys have in store for us today, so the floor is yours.

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub: Thank you, Doreen, and thank you, Achim, for the powerful vision for 2030. It’s ambitious, it’s exciting, but let’s bring ourselves back to reality for a moment. Today, in low-income countries, just 35% of the population have access to 4G. While Vodafone and others continue to invest heavily in expanding our networks, this problem is far too big to be fixed by traditional methods. The world needs new radical approaches. We need to boldly seize the opportunities in front of us. We must accelerate action and drive real global change. The convergence of the satellite and the mobile industries can help us with this opportunity. Something amazing happens when we are forced to act with urgency. When a crisis hits, we stop debating, we stop delaying, and we smash through barriers. I want to share two stories, real recent examples, that show just how bold we can be. First, when the Ukrainian town of Irpin was devastated by Russian attacks, Vodafone Ukraine used a satellite-based network to restore mobile communications fast. Second, after Hurricane Beryl tore through the Caribbean in July, we turned to low-orbit satellites with our instant network on Union Island. Both examples show that, in the middle of a crisis, urgent application of satellite and mobile technology can ensure that, even in chaos, people’s voices can still be heard. So here’s the question. Can we harness this technology beyond war zones and natural disasters? Can we finally close the digital divide? Let’s really think about that number. 2.6 billion people are still unconnected. 2.6 billion were left out of today’s digital economy.

Official Video: In areas of conflict and natural disasters, where terrestrial networks have been destroyed, low-orbit satellites have helped us provide an essential lifeline for millions of people. But in a digital world, still missing 2.6 billion people, we need to take the same urgent actions and find bold solutions, such as satellites, to solve the world’s coverage gaps, connecting people no matter who they are or where they live.

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub: 2.6 billion people are excluded from opportunities and disconnected from basic services. But I believe we can change that. Together with our partner, AST Space Mobile, we are pushing the next technology frontier. We are working on a direct-to-mobile satellite network, one that doesn’t need dishes or special equipment. We are aiming to plug coverage gaps in low- and middle-income countries with this conversion of satellites and mobile in a safe, secure, and equitable way. Last week, five satellites were launched from Florida. They are currently 500 kilometers above us, preparing to test direct-to-mobile connectivity. This offers the real prospect of digital to millions of more people with just a regular 4G headset. With this technology, we can reach the last mile – the isolated communities, the farmers, the rural women, and the schools. Let me be clear. Connectivity is empowerment. It’s education. It’s economic inclusion. It’s health. But it’s not happening fast enough. So how can we be bolder and really make the change we need to see? I leave you with three ideas. First, investment. To achieve universal access, we need $428 billion. That’s significant, yes. But we need to think big, create a scalable investment strategy, and make it happen. Second, there is no point in creating satellite coverage if people don’t have a device to use it. We need to lower the cost of smartphones to under $20 in the least-developed countries, removing duties and surcharges on low-cost 4G devices, and promoting local production will help. Third, we need to ensure that we innovate in a way that truly benefits everyone. and without doing harm, respecting the frameworks that keep us safe online. By the way, to succeed, we must think differently. Incremental change isn’t good enough. We need something new, something bold. We can close the digital divide. But only if we are brave, innovative, and act today with true urgency. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you, Shameel. A lot of great points there. Jessica, now it’s your turn, so please tell us more about the importance of accessibility.

Jessica Rosenworcel: The big idea that I want to talk about today is going to change and save lives. I say that confidently because it already has. So let me explain with a story. It starts on Hawaii. And if you’ve ever been there, you know that Hawaii is a beautiful place with a landscape that is often green and lush. But the climate’s changing. And last year, dry, wind-fueled flames raced along the western edge of Maui, which is one of the eight major islands in Hawaii. It was the deadliest wildfire in the United States in over a century. The flames leveled the historic town of Lahaina, which is on Maui. And in the middle of this fire, when the flames were raging, we had five young people on the road on the outskirts of Lahaina. They were trapped in a white van. Skies were smoky. It was not clear where to go or what to do, so they decided to drive toward the ocean. But the roads to the water, they were blocked, and poor visibility quickly turned into no visibility. They were stuck in a sea of flames with nowhere to go. to go. Terrestrial wireless services were knocked out, so there was no way to call the emergency number 911 for help. The van was hot and it was getting hotter. The situation felt hopeless. But you see, this crew of five young people, they survived. They’re alive today thanks to a new technology. Their phone had a new feature, the ability to connect directly to emergency personnel by bypassing ground-based communications and instead using satellite signals delivered directly from space. At 6.14pm, their message asking for help reached first responders along with their location. And at 6.47pm, they sent a follow-up message to the dispatchers to say they had been rescued. Now put simply, satellite-to-cell phone communications is a game-changer. By combining space-based networks and terrestrial wireless networks, both can accomplish more together than either can do on its own. They can make our networks more resilient and more available whenever disaster strikes. And we saw that clearly in the United States in Hawaii. But you see, the combination of these services can do even more. They can end mobile dead zones. And that’s why in the United States, the Federal Communications Commission has set up a framework, the first of its kind in the world, to support supplemental coverage from space. That means we’re making it easier for wireless carriers to have all of our smartphones connected through satellites when there’s no signal on the ground. This is part of a broader effort at the Federal Communications Commission to seize the communications opportunities of the new space age. To adapt to this era when rocket launches are no longer rare. Constellations are no longer small, and satellites are no longer just big, bulky objects destined for decades in our skies. We created a new Space Bureau. And our Space Bureau has streamlined our regulatory process for licensing satellite services. It has updated our requirements to mitigate orbital debris. So new space actors are always good stewards of our skies. And it’s put forward a plan to support in-space servicing, assembly, and manufacturing. Now in the end, the goal of all of this is to build what I call the single network future. And what exactly is the single network future? It’s a future where we no longer limit ourselves to thinking about one communications technology at a time. It’s a future where fiber networks, licensed terrestrial systems, next-generation unlicensed wireless technology, and satellite broadband seamlessly interact in a way that is invisible to the user. It’s a future where we have the power to end mobile dead zones. It’s a future where it is possible to connect everyone, everywhere. So let’s make it happen. Let’s build this future together.

Sade Baderinwa: Great. Thank you, Jessica. Satellite to cell phone communication. No dead zones. Fantastic. Incredible. Well, now comes something very special. Juan, you are next.

Juan Lavista Ferres: Twenty years ago, a massive earthquake struck the Indian Ocean, causing devastating tsunamis that claimed the lives of over 230,000 people in Southeast Asia. The disaster was foreseeable hours before it struck the coastline. There were no warnings notification to people at risk. It was a turning point, one that underscored the urgent need for global early warning systems that can save lives in such critical moments. While early warning systems have their effectiveness to hinges the crucial factor, communications with people on the ground, no matter how sophisticated our technology is, if we cannot reach those in harm way, the warnings are useless. There is an illusion of accessibility and current data in today’s digital age. However, this is a misconception. The reality is that in many parts of the world, population data is outdated by decades or more. The foundational knowledge of any early warning system is understanding where people are located. That’s why Microsoft has partnered with planet labs, which image the earth daily in high resolution and the institute of health metrics and evaluation at the University of Washington to create the first high resolution maps that show population shifts over time. To understand not only where people are, but also which of those people have connectivity to receive an early warning, we are collaborating with Doreen and her team at ITU in support of the early warnings for all initiative. As you can see, here in Bonatou, we have harnessed the power of AI with planet satellite imagery and ITU data to identify communities that remain disconnected from communication channels. This information is essential for governments, companies, and international organizations to prioritize investment infrastructure that ensures that everyone is reachable in time of crisis. Everyone in this room can be part of the solution. Through cross-sector innovation, we can ensure that early warnings can reach the most vulnerable. This is about more than just warnings. It’s about giving every person, no matter where they live, the confidence of knowing that they are protected and supported in time of crisis. There are 2.6 billion people in the world that are not connected. In our smartphones today, we have more processing power than the one that was needed to put a person on the moon. There are very important problems out there that can and should be solved with data. We no longer have excuses. Thank you very much.

Sade Baderinwa: Great. Thank you, Juan, and thank you all to our speakers. And I invite you to go offstage and take your seat back in the audience. Thank you. And ladies and gentlemen, now I’d like to welcome to the stage Her Excellency Emma Theophilus, Minister of Information and Communication Technology, Namibia.

Emma Theophilus: Ladies and gentlemen, our world is now implored with the situation of climate change. And digital technologies, digital infrastructure could be the answer to our challenges. With quantum technology, an opportunity where citizens, countries, continents can overcome their challenges through quantum computing and the ability to adapt where other continents are unable to. As the world races toward the fourth industrial revolution, Africa must not be left behind. Quantum technology offers Africa a path to leapfrog traditional developmental models. And if we’re being honest, existing developmental models were not meant to develop Africa. And to ensure we accelerate the achievement of the sustainable developmental goals. Quantum technology holds tremendous potential to accelerate our developmental and directly support the achievement of these SDGs. We need to focus on creating an environment where the basics of technology are met so that quantum technologies can be used to benefit all. We need to strike the balance between laying the groundwork while ensuring we don’t miss out on opportunities to leapfrog. We need to recognize the adaptability as well as the agility of our local experiences navigating minimal resources for maximum impact in rural areas who can in fact contribute and advance quantum solutions. We need to do work to make quantum technology more inclusive and applications more compatible and that involves African countries and global south partners. We’re talking about an energy transition. In Namibia we’re talking about being the hub of the green hydrogen, ensuring energy efficiency and climate resilience directly impacting SDG 7 and SDG 13. We’re talking about enhancing healthcare outcomes, good health and well-being. Namibia continues to face healthcare challenges including disease management and limited access to advanced medical technologies, not to mention the rest of the continent. Agriculture and water management, where climate change continues to see cycles of flash floods and droughts. All the continents, all the countries, these innovations will ensure and enhance food production, supporting SDG 2 around zero hunger, and SDG 6 around clean water and sanitation. Other SDGs can easily be connected with quantum. Example, education through increasing quantum literacy, impacting SDG 4. Economic growth and technological innovation, directly impacting SDG 8 and 9. And quantum cryptography to enhance the security of communications and data around governance, security, and global partnerships around SDG 16 and SDG 17. Thank you very much.

Sade Baderinwa: And thank you very much, Your Excellency. Next we have Karan Bhatia, the Vice President of Government Affairs and Public Policy at Google. Karan, thank you. Please take the mic.

Karan Bhatia: Thank you very much. Good morning, everybody. A clear vision for 2030, 17 sustainable development goals. The clock is ticking, and we’re trailing. The time is now to get artificial intelligence into the game. Let’s journey to northern India, where my father was born. It’s a land often ravaged by floods, the most common natural disaster there for generations. Imagine floodwaters surging, engulfing homes, businesses, crippling infrastructure, endangering lives. It’s a story that has played out sadly year after year with growing intensity in recent years as the effects of climate change are increasingly evident. But what if we could foresee the floods? What if we could warn people days in advance and get them out of harm’s way, saving lives, saving livelihoods? For years, this was just a dream. Predicting when and how riverine flooding would occur was an impossibly complicated task. But it’s impossible no more. Today with Google’s Flood Hub, an AI-powered flood forecasting tool, we’re able to predict flood zones up to a week before they strike. It’s live in 80 countries, reaching more than 460 million people around the world, and we’re just getting started. We have been, we’re going to continue to work closely with governments, with the United Nations, with NGOs to implement and distribute flood forecasts to empower them to act and warn people, saving lives and livelihoods. And AI is just beginning to deliver for the SDGs in this kind of way. It’s helping farmers choose when to harvest their crops, doctors when to diagnose diseases earlier and how to, and educating people throughout the world in their native languages. It’s a tool to accelerate progress towards the SDGs. But as we’ve heard, with 2.6 billion people lacking basic Internet, we’ve got to ensure that AI doesn’t become a luxury. It needs to be universal, affordable, accessible to all. Digital inclusion requires action. We cannot allow the digital divide to now become the AI divide. Google is committed to bridging this gap. We’ve invested tens of billions of dollars annually in digital infrastructure globally, ranging from data centers to undersea cables, transforming Internet accessibility. This year alone, we’ve announced new high-capacity fiber optic links connecting Latin America to Africa, Africa to the Asia Pacific, Latin America to the Asia Pacific, and remote parts of the Pacific Ocean to America and the world. But infrastructure alone is not going to be enough. We are, and are going to continue to invest heavily in digital skilling, training across the globe, building off our track record of already having trained more than 100 million people globally with Grow with Google. And we’re now doubling down with a new focus on AI skilling to allow everyone access to this amazing technology. And we’re marrying this with world-class cloud computing and cybersecurity solutions that are critical to gain the benefit of AI. To close, at Google, we love to think big. And right now, with digital inclusion as our foundation, as our true north, AI as our superpower, and you all as our partners, we are about a future where no one is left behind, a future where the SDGs are not just aspirations, but they’re going to be achievements. Thank you very much.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you, Karan. Now, I think this is a great time to travel to space. Let’s take a look at this video, and it’s going to be followed by speaker David Sapolsky from Amazon. Let’s take a look.

Official Video: Status check, go Atlas, go Kuiper, three, two, one, and we have ignition, and liftoff. Copy that, Proto-1, we got contact with our satellites, huge milestone.

David Sapolsky: I want to thank the ITU Secretary-General, Doreen Bogdan-Martin, UNDP Administrator Achim Steiner, heads of state, and other distinguished guests, $2.6 billion. We’ve heard it before, we’re going to hear it again, but we can’t grow desensitized to this number. That’s because behind the numbers are families, frontline workers, small businesses, students, and many others who, according to the ITU, don’t have internet access at home. Progress is being made to close this gap, but we need more solutions and faster. So today I’m delighted to present Project Kuiper, Amazon’s satellite broadband initiative, as a digital solution that can deliver affordable, high-performance connectivity to unserved and underserved communities around the world and advance progress toward the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals. We started Project Kuiper to help bridge the digital divide for customers without access to reliable broadband. The goal of Project Kuiper is simple. With just one of these ultra-compact, affordable customer terminals and a view of the sky, customers will be able to access high-speed broadband from virtually anywhere in the world. Our network will have the capacity, flexibility, and performance to serve a wide range of customers, including schools, hospitals, businesses, government agencies, and others operating in places without reliable connectivity. The video you just saw included some footage from Kuiper’s launch of our satellite prototypes last year, which had a 100% success rate across key mission objectives. Kuiper will initially rely on a constellation of more than 3,200 low-Earth-orbit satellites. That means they operate at a lower orbit than traditional satellites. LEOs, as they’re called, provide sufficient speeds for many modern critical services, such as real-time video conferencing, telehealth, industrial applications, and live streaming. I’m also told you can shop online with it. Kuiper can also provide governments and communities with important tools for responding in moments of great need, such as humanitarian crises or hurricanes. or wildfires when other networks are incapacitated. While Kuiper remains acutely focused on advancing our shared mission to affordably connect the unconnected, our principles of space safety, sustainability, and mitigating space debris continue to influence every aspect of our satellite work. Over the coming years, companies will have to work hand in hand with governments and civil society groups to shape the global framework for sustainable global space operations. And you have an Amazon, a reliable, constructive partner, to do just that. As we’ve heard in today’s program, the magnitude of the divide is greater than any single entity can overcome. Through Project Kuiper, we are working to contribute to the solution by connecting people who lack reliable access to the internet affordably. But we’re not doing it alone. We’re proud to partner with governments and industry around the world, such as Vodafone and VRIO, on stage with us today. Congratulations to the ITU and the UNDP for hosting this wonderful event, and thank you for inviting Amazon to play a small part.

Sade Baderinwa: Great. Thank you, David. And thank you all. Please return to your seats. And now I’d like to talk about universal access to health and affordability of devices. Please welcome on stage Ann Aerts, head of Novartis Foundation, and Mats Granryd, director general of GSMA. And Ann.

Ann Aerts: Good morning, New York. A baby born in New York City today has a 12 years longer life expectancy than a baby born in another part of this city, maybe only a few blocks away. Why is that? Why do these children have to start with such a different prospect in life? Well, let’s wind our clocks back. If we look back at the past 30 to 50 years, we’ve seen tremendous breakthroughs in scientific innovations that have extended our life expectancy. by 15 to 20 years, and most of these gains were thanks to the progress in cardiovascular medicine. At the same time, these past 10 to 20 years, we see this convergence with technology innovations, technology that enabled us to radically re-imagine the way we deliver health and care. We can bring health services to people wherever and whenever they need it, even in their living rooms. That doesn’t sound too bad, does it? Still, cardiovascular disease is still the leading cause of death in the world, causing over 20 million people dying with heart disease every year. That is about 2,300 people per hour, equivalent to five jumbo jets falling out of the sky in an hour. And on top of that, cardiovascular disease is back on the rise, but not for everybody. In fact, it’s disproportionately rising in people that already face hardships, in disadvantaged populations. So it seems we are not having the full picture here. We’re missing a piece of the puzzle. That is because we don’t really understand what drives our health. We know that only 20% of our health is driven by the care we access. The other 80% is driven by the conditions in which we are born, we grow up, we live, and we age. Those social, economic, environmental conditions are not well understood. Yet, that is. Because today, we have an unprecedented opportunity to use the massive amounts of data we have in our hands, the computational power and data science capabilities around, to better understand that. We can bring data from the health system together with the data on all these underlying determinants. be it education, income, employment, housing, security, or access to healthy food, access to digital tools, you name it. All these data together can be brought into the machine, and advanced analytics can help us understand what truly is the leading determinants that drive our health and health inequities. Because only if we understand those can we address them, and can we address them at the root instead of patching symptoms. That is what we set out to do with AI for Healthy Cities, a Novartis Foundation partnership with the cities of New York, Singapore, Helsinki, and Basel, where we are deciphering the true drivers of health and health inequities. Only when we understand and address those can we offer two babies born on the same day, in the same city, or elsewhere, a similar chance on a long and healthy life. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Okay, thank you, Ann. Now we’re going to shift the conversation towards affordability. That’s, smartphones are a central part of our lives.

Mats Granryd: Absolutely.

Sade Baderinwa: But there’s a great barrier to entry, right?

Mats Granryd: Yeah.

Sade Baderinwa: If you don’t have the money, how can you get the smartphone?

Mats Granryd: Exactly.

Sade Baderinwa: How can you get accessibility?

Mats Granryd: That’s what I’m going to talk about.

Sade Baderinwa: Wonderful.

Mats Granryd: Super, thank you very much. Well, ladies and gentlemen, it is a great pleasure to be here, and I have a very serious message. My name is Mats Granryd, and I’m the Director General of GSMA. I think I will have another slide here. So, I’d like to introduce to you this family. It’s Fortinet and Paddy. Paddy being the father, and Fortinet the daughter. She’s a doctor, and they live in rural Uganda. She is the only doctor in Uganda. miles around, so her services were so sought after. The problem was that when light went out, when there’s no sun anymore, she could not perform her duties. Her father, though, realized that there is something called mobile internet, there is something on this handset that people are talking about. So he got a phone for her, and she can now continue to do her work and ask other doctors for help. But she can also deploy mobile-enabled solar power, which means that she has light almost as much as you want, and she can then perform her service day and night, which is a fantastic achievement. Now, she’s only one family. We know that there is more than, and we have heard this many times today, that it’s 2.6 billion people that are not as fortunate. They are not connected to internet, and predominantly to mobile internet. Now why is that? I mean, we know that people, these 2.6 billion people, the vast majority, 95 plus percent, live beneath a mobile broadband coverage. So we don’t need more stuff. We don’t need more base stations. We don’t need anything in the sky either. It is just there to use. But they can’t use it. Why? Well, it is all around affordability. And we have done a lot of research on this topic, and the biggest barrier is handset affordability. It is the cost of this device, this little device. So we need to bring down the cost of the device. We know roughly $20 is the sweet spot, and we’re not close to that. $20 might help some, but we still have issues. So the next step we need to do is to increase access to financing, to make sure that you can actually use the handset as a collateral and borrow money to buy your first hand. It’s sort of like you buy a car or a similar thing. And thirdly, is to reduce or even remove the sector-specific tax. The handset is not a luxury item. The handset is something that is a true necessity. So those are three things that we should do. And from GSMA, we have a handset affordability coalition that has been up and running now for a year. And we’re very happy to have Doreen and ITU on board, as well as the WEF Edison Alliance, and also the World Bank, helping us to reduce the handset cost and helping us to make sure that we can get good financing. So let’s get this done. Thank you very much.

Sade Baderinwa: Great. Thank you both. Please have a seat. And unfortunately, we’re running a little long, which means we have to shorten speeches. So this is going to be almost like the Oscars. You know, when the orchestra starts playing, it says your time is running up. Speakers, you’re going to hear a little ring. Where’s the person with the little bell? There you go. We’re going to hear that. And you actually have 20 seconds to wrap. So please bear with us so we can move this program along. Well, ladies and gentlemen, now comes a very exciting moment. Two years ago, ITU launched Partner to Connect, P2C, a digital coalition to advance universal and meaningful connectivity. To date, PTC’s online platform has received over 900 pledges worth an estimated value of $51 billion for connectivity projects globally. And today, five new pledges will be announced to the world. And to announce the first one, please welcome Alexandre Reis Siqueira Freire, Commissioner of National Telecommunications Agency, Anatel, Brazil. Thank you.

Alexandre Reis Siqueira Freire: Good morning, everyone. I want to share with you one of our most impactful initiatives, a project that holds the power to change the lives of an entire generation of children across Brazil. From the resources obtained by the Brazilian 5G radio frequency auction, I’m happy to announce an amount of US$549 million commitment to partner to connect digital coalition to connect public schools, particularly in underserved and remote regions like indigenous and African-Brazilian traditional communities, and urban outskirts in order to expand the access to information and communication technologies for academic purposes. Under the coordination of Commissioner of the National Telecommunication Agency, Vicente Aquino, we launched a three-year pilot project impacting 177 public schools and over 13,000 students. These schools received high-speed internet connections, Wi-Fi networks, computers for students and teachers, and solar energy systems if the premises lack electricity. The results have been transformative and strengthen our drive to continue to expand the project, which means to benefit about 40,000 schools in the year to come. The schools connectivity project led by Anatel is part of the program Accelerate Growth, launched by the federal government in 2023. It established that all 138,000 public schools will have connectivity by the end of 2020. And six, so we must secure long-term partnership to maintain the infrastructure and the connection service after 5G opt-in resources are over. We have a responsibility to make sure this progress is not temporary. If the power of the connectivity, we, countries from the global south, can face our specific challenges arise from inequalities, build more equal and promise a future for all. Thank you, everyone.

Sade Baderinwa: And thank you, Alexandre, for that generous pledge and for setting an example of the importance of investing in technology and education. So thank you so much. Ladies and gentlemen, to conclude this session, let me introduce a strong believer in P2C, Rabab Fatima, Undersecretary General and High Representative. Rabab, the floor is yours.

Rabab Fatima: Thank you very much. Again, apologies. As you can see, I’m not very digitally smart. I’m reading from paper notes because I represent a group of people. countries who are still not yet there. No? You can hear me now? Okay, okay, thank you very much. Again, very digitally challenged here for me. Yes, thank you. I’m using paper notes, not yet there, and using teleprompters. Doreen, Achim, excellencies, dear friends and colleagues, thank you very much for this opportunity to share a few words, but first of all, let me thank and congratulate ITU and UNDP for organizing another successful digital day. Another fascinating, inspiring event, and I would like to thank you for keeping the digital agenda high on our agenda. As we have heard, the internet has fundamentally transformed education, healthcare, commerce, and global connectivity, benefiting billions worldwide. Yet, a large portion of the global population remains disconnected. Yes, I’m talking about the least developed countries where only 36% of the population are online. The landlocked developing countries, the LLDCs, fare slightly better at 39%, while in small island developing states, SIDS, 67% are using the internet, and women and the rural communities in these countries are certainly the ones who are being left furthest behind. In contrast, advanced economies enjoy near universal internet access, exposing the stark inequality in opportunities, access to information, and pathways to a brighter future. Excellencies, my office supports these countries, these 92 most vulnerable countries, the 45 LDCs, the 32 LLDCs, and the 39 SIDS, home to 1.4 billion people. Nearly 60% of this population is under the age. of 25, representing a generation with immense potential for digital growth. However, the persistent digital divide continues to limit this potential. This gap is not just a technological issue, but a profound development challenge. Affordability remains a key barrier to digital connectivity. The United Nations Broadband Commission has set a target for 2025 that broadband services should cost less than 2% of monthly GNI per capita in low- and middle-income countries. Yet, as of 2023, only four LDCs have met this goal. On average, 75% of LDCs face mobile broadband costs exceeding 5% of GNI per capita. LLDCs and SIDs face similar high costs averaging above the 2% target. Even when connectivity is available, challenges persist as many are unable to utilize the Internet’s full potentials. In LDCs, LLDCs, and SIDs, a consumption gap exists, but data usage remains low despite Internet access. This gap underscores not only connectivity issues, but also lack of adequate digital skills and infrastructure. To bridge this digital divide, a comprehensive approach is required, one that integrates quality education, robust infrastructure, and affordability. And I would like to commend the Partner to Connect for making efforts to bridge this gap. Yes, I’m speaking for 92 countries, give me another minute. Looking ahead, we must focus on more of such actionable solutions. developing countries to be held in Havarone, Botswana, in December to continue this conversation. The conference will feature a dedicated connectivity track that my office will be organizing with ITU, and that will be focusing on practical digital initiatives aimed at enhancing meaningful collectivity for the LLDCs. As we look to the future, let us harness the power of digital connectivity to build a more inclusive, resilient, and sustainable future. And I look forward to continuing these important discussions with all of you at the conference in Botswana to make sure that no one is left behind in this digital leap forward, and no one is left disconnected. I thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you very much. That’s right. Take your minute. Now let’s move to session two. An inclusive and meaningful digital future is one where no one is left behind. Wondercraft, a robotics company developing a first-of-its-kind self-balancing personal exoskeleton is enabling people who cannot walk the opportunity to stand up and walk again in their everyday lives. And you actually may have already seen this during the Paris Olympics in 2024 with para-athlete Kevin Piette, who became the first person with paraplegia to work to walk the torch in the summer Olympics relay. And today, you’re going to see this very same prototype presented by Bianca Faith Johnson, JD. She is making her way there. You know what? We’re going to forget all the run-throughs because I just want to get right through you. Tell me, this is really a game-changer. Talk to me about what happened to you. I know that you became paralyzed. Tell me about that journey.

Bianca Faith Johnson: Seven years ago, I was in a near-fatal motorcycle accident, no fault of my own. And as a result of that, I sustained a T4, T6 spinal cord injury. So that’s the equivalent of me being paralyzed from about mid-chest down.

Sade Baderinwa: And that completely changed your life.

Bianca Faith Johnson: Absolutely.

Sade Baderinwa: Can you tell me just how difficult that moment was in the journey after that?

Bianca Faith Johnson: That moment was extremely difficult. Imagine waking up in the hospital and being probed by doctors asking, can you move your legs and not being able to. My entire world was literally shifted upside down. But I knew that even in that moment, I was still going to make it. And I needed to make sure that I prepared myself for what was to come, for technology such as this.

Sade Baderinwa: Wow. Well, I can see your sunshine just radiating, and I can tell that you are a fighter and you are strong. So shall we walk through this together?

Bianca Faith Johnson: Absolutely.

Sade Baderinwa: Okay. So tell me about this technology. All of a sudden you found out about it, but how did you find out about it?

Bianca Faith Johnson: So I’m actually the acting chair of an organization called Push to Walk, which is located in New Jersey. It’s a spinal cord injury gym. And we were fortunate enough to have the opportunity for Wondercraft, an amazing organization who is the creators of this exoskeleton, to come and do some demos. And I was a part of that demonstration, and from there the synergy was just perfect, and I’ve been working with them ever since.

Sade Baderinwa: Okay. So let’s show everyone, shall we? Wow. Wow. That’s incredible. Shall we walk forward a little bit? Absolutely. Okay. Wow. Wow. Incredible. Wow. Okay. That was fantastic. So this has changed everything because one thing I remember reading about you, you were saying like I was standing up talking to you and you were saying that before I had to look up, but now you’re able to look eye to eye. That means everything, right?

Bianca Faith Johnson: Everything.

Sade Baderinwa: Talk to me about that.

Bianca Faith Johnson: This is how our bodies were intended to be. So, and then, of course, I was injured, so I remember what it felt like standing upright, walking upright, and looking someone and having that type of connection eye to eye. So now, in this self-balancing prototype, this exoskeleton, I’m able to do so hands-free, and I can talk to you just like everyone else would.

Sade Baderinwa: And also, just having the freedom to go where you want to go. Did you ever imagine you would be here at the UN, walking and talking to this incredible crowd?

Bianca Faith Johnson: I did not imagine this exactly, but I knew it would be something like this.

Sade Baderinwa: Shall we walk a little bit more forward? Okay, so, as we do this, can you tell me about that first moment when you got in the exoskeleton and then being able to move like this?

Bianca Faith Johnson: It was literally everything, because imagine, for seven years, I’ve been in a seated position, unable to stand on my own or walk on my own. So the moment I was engulfed and put on this exoskeleton, it put me on, and I was able to embody the position that my body was used to doing. It is almost like a little muscle memory thing going on. It remembers where I came from, and it’s bringing me into where I need to be.

Sade Baderinwa: And it’s bringing your spirit to life again.

Bianca Faith Johnson: Yes, ma’am, yes, ma’am.

Sade Baderinwa: Was there anything else you wanted to share with everyone?

Bianca Faith Johnson: This technology is just absolutely amazing. And I just want everyone to acknowledge that what you are looking at is literally the future and the present. It has given back my, it has the potential to give me back my movement and, with it, my freedom. So I plan on just making sure that I’m maximizing on this opportunity. This should be supported. You should be spreading the word, sending it to your friends, and letting everyone know that Wondercraft, in particular, it’s an organization that is for the people. for people like me, so that we can get our lives back. And it may not change the world, but it certainly has the potential to change mine.

Sade Baderinwa: That’s what technology is all about. That’s what today is all about, giving access to people, changing their lives, right?

Bianca Faith Johnson: Yes, yes.

Sade Baderinwa: Is somebody here from Wondercraft? I wish they were.

Bianca Faith Johnson: I’m surrounded by them.

Sade Baderinwa: Okay, well, Wondercraft is here. Yes?

Bianca Faith Johnson: One right there.

Sade Baderinwa: Oh, right here. Oh, wait, wait, wait, wait. I thought you were just helping along.

Bianca Faith Johnson: Yes, yes.

Sade Baderinwa: Tell me just about what this means for you, working on this.

Physical Therapist: It is so inspiring. I’m a physical therapist by background, so being able to work with a company that puts patients first and allows people the ability to walk again is so meaningful, and that’s why Wondercraft does what it does.

Sade Baderinwa: And I’m sure you’ve seen so many patients, and you’ve seen that transformation. What is it like for you on the other side, giving people the ability to have freedom again?

Physical Therapist: It’s incredible. It’s stories like Bianca and Tony and all of the other patients in our lives that really, that we make an impact on a daily basis. So it’s just very meaningful, and we love what we do at Wondercraft.

Sade Baderinwa: And your colleague over here, I can’t leave him out.

Engineer: Yeah, so, yeah, I’m one of the engineers.

Sade Baderinwa: You’re one of the engineers.

Engineer: I don’t do-

Sade Baderinwa: So come forward, please. Everybody can see you.

Engineer: I don’t typically do a lot of PR, but- But that’s okay, that’s okay. Yeah, it’s great to be on another side of the company and be able to participate in this. And working with, not directly as a PT like Sarah, but with patients like Bianca is really a gem.

Sade Baderinwa: Well, this is the connectivity right here. The engineer, what you’re putting to paper, what you’re actually building, there you go, she could even lean in, is changing people’s lives. It’s changing her life. What does that mean to you personally?

Engineer: Oh. Oh. Yeah. That’s- I think-

Sade Baderinwa: We can feel that. We can feel that.

Engineer: It’s something that- maybe I’ll never have to experience firsthand, but we get to experience it through, like I said, great patients we get to work with, like Bianca, and be able to really talk to them face-to-face and see how their lives have changed.

Sade Baderinwa: Well, we appreciate your honesty, we appreciate your heart, because that’s what really all of this is about. We have your excellencies here, we have engineers like yourself, PT, we have somebody here who suffered from this through the hands of somebody else, but like all of these things, all of these companies, and Google, and all these other companies, Amazon, and so many others, like these things matter. And this is what we’re talking about, the digital future. What does it mean? Not leaving people behind, not leaving people behind like you. So thank you for everything that you’re doing, and we really appreciate it, and making the difference here, and for so many others. Thank you. Thank you. Wonderful. Shall we walk together? Okay, which way do you wanna go? We’re gonna turn? Okay, we’re gonna turn together. It’s truly incredible. Wow. And as an engineer, technology is only gonna get better, right?

Engineer: Yeah, of course. So, like Bianca mentioned, this is a prototype device, and we’re actively working on it every day, ensuring that we can incorporate more features to be able to give her more of her life back as she can continue to do more and more with it.

Sade Baderinwa: So things are gonna become more streamlined, it’s gonna just become easier, right?

Engineer: Certainly.

Sade Baderinwa: Okay, wonderful. Well, thank you all again. Please give them a round of applause. Woo! Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Well, as they make their way, pretty incredible, isn’t it? It really is. Now we welcome on stage United Nations Deputy High Commissioner for Refugees, Kelly T. Clements, who will talk to us about using blockchain for inclusive financial services anywhere, anytime, and on any device. Please welcome Kelly T. Clements, United Nations Deputy High Commissioner for Refugees, UNHCR. Thank you.

Kelly T. Clements: Thank you. Amazing, right? Yeah, incredible.

Sade Baderinwa: It’s wonderful. So you’re going to be able to talk about blockchain technology helping refugees. And not only is blockchain just changing how we do business, but it’s also helping victims of war-torn areas like in Ukraine or so many other places. Exactly. So you’re going to tell us more?

Kelly T. Clements: I will. I will. In fact, I’m going to tell you the story about Hannah. Hannah. Yes. I’m looking forward to it. So Hannah is a mother of two who had to flee from her hometown in Ukraine as the full-scale war broke out, caring for her elderly mother and her grandmother. When she arrived at a safe location, she had nowhere to sleep. After registering and engaging with our team on the ground, within 15 minutes, she tells us, the family received cash aid from UNHCR through a digital wallet on her phone. This support is part of a rental market program that we run in Ukraine to help families forced to flee find safe and dignified accommodation. Using cash to support displaced families settle into their new lives isn’t new. Cash, when conditions allow, provide a more dignified form of aid, giving people the choice to prioritize what they need. What was new for Hannah was the financial technology used to make and receive the transaction, a digital wallet powered by blockchain technology. Technology is reshaping every aspect of our lives, and the humanitarian sector is no exception. UNHCR alone manages a volume of over 2 million payment transactions every year. Handling transfers of $6 billion to partner organizations, vendors, and people like Hanna as part of our cash-based intervention. Until now, processing these payments had involved many banks, multiple payment technologies, complex processes, which vary among UN agencies and are costly and slow. Accessing financial services is a big challenge for many vulnerable communities that face difficulties opening a bank account, they lack identity documents, they live in remote areas with limited connectivity and services. There is a record 120 million people across the globe that do not have, many of them, the minimum ability to be able to access this cash. With minimal overhead costs, in a secure, transparent, and accountable way, we launched the UN Financial Gateway. It’s an initiative with Switzerland, the government. It standardizes and streamlines the payment infrastructure and processes the UN system uses for financial transactions. The Gateway seeks to leverage digital financial technologies to help us prepare, to deliver aid in a more agile and efficient way, while promoting financial inclusion. This is a collaboration across the UN, and with humanitarian partners, it could lead to efficiency gains of up to $60 million a year. Already in Ukraine, we’ve saved $12 million using the digital payment technology and reducing financial service fees. In Argentina, we saved 30% of our budget by mitigating local currency devaluation by using the digital wallet. This modality has assisted 2,500 households in Ukraine and Argentina alone. To scale up these solutions and reach those at risk of being excluded, we have to invest in global connectivity, digital infrastructure. digital and financial literacy. We need to bridge the gap between the financial ecosystem, available technical solutions, and the people that need them the most. We have to collaborate among many, many, many partners. So let’s go back to Hannah. We all have a role to play in this global challenge. Hannah was able to rent an apartment where she now lives with her two children, her elderly mother, and her grandmother. We support people like Hannah who have been forced to flee to restart their lives and find a new home. Thank you so much.

Sade Baderinwa: Great, thank you Kelly. I think this is so exciting. Let me, just come with me just quickly. Because people think about blockchain technology is just about exchanging money, but this is really where governments really help people in need, like you told us the story about Hannah. But it is also about reducing the costs for governments and for countries to be able to help them directly. Do you think that we’re gonna see a lot more advancements?

Kelly T. Clements: Absolutely. This is really just the tip of the iceberg in terms of both helping people like Hannah, but at a much reduced cost. You know, with with a number of people around the world that are forced to flee, we don’t have the resources to be able to assist them all. And governments were on the front lines with partners to be able to respond to people that are coming to entirely new locations with almost nothing. We need to do it much more economically, much more efficiently, and we need to use technology to show us the way.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you Kelly. Well, now I’d like to show you guys a very special story. Let’s take a look.

Official Video: My name is Adit Philip Maze. I’m a South Sudanese by nationality, schooling at our Ladies Girls Secondary School, and I’m also a member of the I Am The Code. For me, I Am The Code has helped me a lot because if I take back where I was, I was not that much confidence. I couldn’t be who I am now. But because of I Am The Court, I can now speak to the people, speak to the world, speak out what I have inside me. And thanks to that, I Am The Court also has made me a leader, not only of myself, but also to the whole school now. As the school head girl, I am capable now of helping my fellow students. I Am The Court also is helping our school with the morning breakfasts, because we usually have one, and it is after four lessons. Sometimes it is difficult to concentrate in class, but at least now we are able to be sustained due to the breakfast provided to us. And also, I Am The Court is helping us on coding, because here in school we just concentrate on books, but at least now we are exposed to the devices, and we are also exposed to the technology. We are now able to do codings, and at least now, when we go outside there, it will help us. For me, what I can tell to the world leaders is that they should include the refugee girls, and they should expose them, because where we come from, it is very difficult. We didn’t have all the things that we have now, because due to the culture and the society that we were living in. But now, as a refugee girl, I am being supported, I am exposed to the technology, I am now able to code, and also I am able to change my people back there, because they still have that mentality that we are being brought up of being neglected as a woman and as a girl. If now we are included by most people, and we are supported, the number of girls and women being neglected or discriminated, it will reduce. I would like to thank Lady Maryam, because she is my role model. Because since we started, I couldn’t make it up to where I am, because I did not know my rights. The only thing I do is just to listen to what society is telling me and do it. Thank you so much.

Sade Baderinwa: Technology really making a difference. And Lady Mariéme, please come to the stage. I’m so excited to hear your story. It’s an honor to meet you. Please come forward. I know you have things to share, but we’re talking about this technology and how it’s changing lives, even in remote areas. So for this woman, or young girl rather, and so many of the other young girls, you’re able to get them onto the future by coding. So they’re not just getting online, they’re able to meet the moment of the economy. So take it away.

Lady Mariéme Jamme: Thank you. Thank you so much for having me. I can’t start my speech without thanking Doreen. Thank you so much. And also Kelly Clements, who just spoke before me. And Ursula, the team behind ITU is just amazing. Thank you, Ursula. Thank you, everyone. Thank you. So I only have a few minutes. I timed myself, I promise you. Adit was supposed to be here, and she couldn’t make it. She was supposed to be on the stage, but she’s a refugee, and we tried very hard for her to be here with me today. So on behalf of the girls in Kakuma Refugee Camp in Kenya, thank you for giving us a few minutes to just share their stories. Thank you. So my name is Lady Mariéme Jamme. I am the founder of I Am the Code. In 2030, six years from now, Adit will be here on this stage sharing her story with you. She’ll be learning how to code. She’ll be an AI specialist. She’ll be understanding what Gen AI is. She’ll be understanding everything, because she lives in a place where it’s so hard for young women and girls. So hard. But thanks to UNHCR teams on the ground, Adit can now have an academy, the first ever academy Open, in the world, in a refugee camp and asylum seeker setting, where she’s sitting right now, she’s eating three meals a day, she’s coding, she’s developing the best coding languages in the world, from HTML to Python. When I started my work in Kakuma Refugee Camp in Kenya, I didn’t know who Adit was. She told me, today I’m a refugee, tomorrow I’m going to become a coder. And I think what is important, that as we build the future, we must include young women and girls, refugees. In Kakuma and Dadaab alone, we have over 900,000 people right now watching us. They’re refugees. And they must be part of the conversation. I stand here today before you because I didn’t go to school. I was born in Senegal. I was 50 years old yesterday, 50 years old. I know I look young. But the reason why I share this story is because young women do grow up. They grew up and they do have the sages like this and stand up and share their stories at the United Nations. So as we build the solutions for the future, we must include young women. We must include refugees. Being a refugee is just written, you know, it’s just a title. But the girls don’t feel refugees. They feel today they are coders. So as technologists, as we build the solution of tomorrow, we must do this. I’m very proud, as an African woman from Senegal, 50 years ago, I didn’t know I’d be standing here talking to you about refugees. And I have a duty, as an African woman, to make sure that I am making a contribution to my continent, but also we are making contribution to young women and girls across the world. So thank you, ITU, for including us. Thank you so much. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: And Mariéme, thank you for investing in girls and STEM, getting them involved. Thank you so much. Now let’s travel 1,800 miles up north from Kakuma. Let’s go to the cradle of civilization. Welcome on stage, Her Excellency, Amr Talaat, Minister of Information and Communication Technology of Egypt, to talk to us more about skills and the hope of digital. Thank you, His Excellency, thank you.

Amr Talaat: The hope of digital, or is it the fear of digital? Distinguished guests, this is a question that resonates with millions around the world, and perhaps more so in the global south where I come from, where technological advancements are widening the economic gaps among our nations, and the ambiguity about AI’s impact on jobs is leading many to wonder, will I find a job in the digital world? The echoes of skepticism about recent developments are looming large, but in Egypt, I also assure you that the sounds of hope are thunderous. While carrying out my public service duties, I travel all around Egypt to connect with people and gain first-hand insights into how the government can improve its digital services and empower our people with indispensable digital skills. From the shores of the Mediterranean, to the Nile Delta, to the temples of Aswan, all across the nation, I consistently witness a common theme. A mother who left her career to raise her children is now thriving as a remote digital marketing manager of an American company right here from Alexandria, thanks to the skills she gained through our free scholarships. A fresh graduate, once struggling to find employment, re-skilled in our data analytics programs and launched a startup, serving clients globally and creating jobs for more of his diligent peers. Another young engineer wanted to give back to her village. After attending our digital innovation workshops, she founded a successful e-commerce platform that not only supports local artisans, but also partners with development organizations to enhance their skills. and invest in their local capabilities. Ladies and gentlemen, the narratives of hope are imposing. They are invigorating and propel us to continue channeling public investments. To extend fiber optics in Egypt’s rural communities, benefiting over 58 million citizens, around 50% of our population. To expand our digital scaling scholarships to more than half a million beneficiaries across the nation. This year, multiplying the beneficiaries by 125 times over the past six years. And to continue digitalizing government services, while ensuring their accessibility through multiple channels, so that no one is left behind. The opportunities that our digital world is creating are glaring. Today, our world is open. Open beyond measure. Open beyond borders. Open beyond nationalities. And open beyond our differences. Today in Egypt, we embrace our commonalities. We accept the challenges of governing technology to create meaningful, inclusive impact. And we are embracing the hope of digital. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Lisa Russell on stage. She’s an Emmy Award winning filmmaker. And she’s going to talk about how AI is revolutionizing filmmaking. Lisa.

Lisa Russell: Good afternoon. Thank you. So, I just want to start off with a quick question. How many here believe that art can actually create a better world? Hands up. Hands up. Fantastic and I do as well and that is why I spent the last 20 years pushing for arts and storytelling in the UN space. My name is Lisa Russell. I’m an Emmy Award-winning filmmaker and the founder of Create 2030 and I’m a big advocate for artists to be working in the climate and sustainability sections because not only are we great entertainers, meaning we can help translate and amplify the great work being done in this space, we are also incredible creative thinkers and problem solvers and we deserve a seat at the table to help find solutions to our world’s greatest problems. Now behind me you are seeing images that have been generated using AI through my arts envoy lab and I’m on a mission to help sustainability and climate advocates learn how to become AI artists and that is because arts and storytelling is incredibly powerful, more powerful than we even realize. Did you know that there’s research that shows that a brainwave of a storyteller actually syncs up with the people who are listening to the story and people in a theater space, their heart rates synchronize with other people in the room. We have no idea the power of art and storytelling but I do believe that if we trained every climate and sustainability advocate how to use AI to amplify and translate their work we would have we would have a much wider reach. So I’m sorry Swifties, Taylor Swift should not be the voice of the world. Instead climate and sustainability advocates and creators can do so and we should be using AI to help democratize access for BIPOC and global south global majority advocates and creators to help amplify these important messages. So with that said Are you all ready to make some AI art with me? Yes Whoo. I’m gonna make you all AI artists today So behind me there’s going to be a QR code I believe it is coming soon. And this is a QR code for a survey about digital futures I want you all to take out your phones all of you and I want you to do the survey Because if you don’t do the survey you are not going to be part of this art Experience and I know you all want to be so go ahead Take the survey. I’m gonna disappear I’m gonna go do my art stuff and I’m gonna come back and I’m gonna share with you the art that we have made Together, how does that sound? Good. All right. Thank you very much. I’ll be back.

Sade Baderinwa: Hey, I Got my QR code. Okay, I gotta fill out the survey Are you guys gonna fill out the survey? Please do because she really has this extraordinary piece of art that she’s gonna put together So I’m looking forward to it So she’s gonna come back in session three to show us the product of all of our artwork. So, please Give them a survey at some point now We welcome now We welcome Lori Freeman global GM and vice president of Salesforce of nonprofits along with tunday Blackman chief development officer of world central kitchen. Lori Freeman.

Tunde Wackman: We’ve already seen so many incredible solutions here today

Official Video: There’s no place on earth that can’t be brought hope with WCK

Tunde Wackman: Like I said, we’ve already seen so many incredible solutions that help people predict disasters and provide community with critical early warning. But when that disaster strikes, World Central Kitchen is immediately on the ground, on the front lines, mobilizing volunteers and local partners to start cooking fresh, nutritious meals. Because we know that a hot meal that is locally prepared is so much more than just nutrition. It is comfort, it’s hope, and it’s dignity. Since 2010, we have provided more than 400 million meals to support climate, humanitarian, and community crises. We do it all with a commitment to inclusivity in our team and in our work, serving everyone everywhere, bringing in the local community as part of the solution. And we do it fast. As our founder, Jose Andres, likes to say, when people are hungry, send in chefs. Not tomorrow, not next week, today. Mobilizing the right resources at the right time requires the right digital solution. So I’d like to introduce Lori Freeman from Salesforce to show you how technology helps us move with the urgency of now. Lori.

Lori Freeman: As you’ve said, time is absolutely of the essence. World Central Kitchen is able to impact the work ahead within 48 hours. So let’s see how they make that happen. This work starts even before a disaster strikes. When those early alerts begin rolling in, they’re able to reach out to volunteers in the area and quickly put out the calls of support. Now the next step, preparing to feed those in need. World Central Kitchen partners with local suppliers and restaurants to serve meals that taste like home, but they’re also serving to help stimulate the local economy. And that means working with different partners all over. So they simply must rely upon activation dashboards that help them understand what’s happening in the area, tracking key information, like the number of meals served, the locations where they are, the recipients of those. Having that actionable data, it allows them to align with so many agencies like. at the UN, which helps inform the larger response. But of course, none of this would be possible without passionate humans who help support WCK through their financial gifts. So WCK manages their donor data and sends personalized journeys across each of these supporters. And they use these journeys to request critical funds to support their ongoing response efforts. As they engage their donors, they’re able to adapt in creative and meaningful ways. They even send handwritten thank you notes. I’ve received one of those. All of this engagement and donation support, it has to be rolled into fundraising dashboards to track everything. This is what helps them provide continuity, being data-driven.

Tunde Wackman: In a world where climate disasters are becoming more frequent and intense, we not only continue to innovate our disaster response through our partnership with Salesforce, but we also continue to fuel our fundraising efforts through our Climate Disaster Relief Fund. This gives the WCK relief team on the ground the ability to solely focus on what is most important, using the power of food to lift up communities across the globe. To meet the challenge of this moment, we need all hands on deck, including the collaboration of many in this room. Together, we can provide meaningful support to those in need anytime a disaster strikes. We hope you’ll join us. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you. Thank you, ladies. And now, we’re gonna talk about digital inclusion in Saudi Arabia. Please welcome His Excellency, Abdullah Alswaha, Minister of Communications and Information Technology, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, to share with us some of the advancements in digital inclusion in the kingdom. Your Excellency.

Abdullah Alswaha: Thank you. Thank you. The cost, the global cost, of gender inequality is close to $7 trillion. That’s almost 7% of the global economy and more than the joint combined output of six G20 nations. According to the UN, the world, us, we’re not on track to achieve the goal by 2030. As a matter of fact, in some of these targets, it will take us 286 years. Over the next three minutes, I’m going to share with you a story of how a nation has achieved its economic prosperity and diversification under the leadership of Prince Mohammed bin Salman by focusing on gender equality in digital. This story, and trust me when I say this, because I witnessed it firsthand, started when I was working for the Silicon Valley. That was the first time I met His Royal Highness, and he shared with us a vision, how he intends to empower people by focusing on women and youth, safeguard the planet, and shape new frontiers while diversifying our economy. Fast forward to today, we have a lot to celebrate. I was told that MISC are here. Can I hear from MISC? We started with MISC, with Saudi codes touching a million women and youth with coding with a game called Minecraft. And it’s no wonder that this story has only helped us achieve becoming the grandest and the boldest success story on planet Earth, but wait for this. it helped us achieve the highest success story in the most innovative platform known to humanity, sending the first Arab astronaut to the International Space Station, Riana Bernoulli. Riana, as a cancer researcher, she has devoted her life to fighting and predicting cancer. And as a matter of fact, in addition to Riana, the woman in the middle is actually my Chief of Staff, Noura Zaid, who has been the heartbeat and the executive force multiplier behind most of our successes in tech and digital space and STEM. And speaking of remarkable women, I have to talk about Deemah AlYahya, our General Secretary for the Digital Cooperation Organization, how we have pledged under the leadership of His Royal Highness, joining hands with 16 like-minded nations to make sure that we connect the unconnected, leave no one behind in three continents. And last but not least, I have to talk about Dr. Latifa Al-Abdulkarim, who sits on the UN Secretary General AI Advisory Board, helping humanity achieve the outcomes of the summit of the future with a human-centric AI, tackling the most pressing challenges in governance, ethics, and regulation. So it’s no wonder that as we achieved the boldest and the highest success story in women empowerment in tech, space, and STEM under the leadership of His Royal Highness, His Royal Highness Prince Mohammed bin Salman, year in, year out, we have celebrated becoming a top five nation by the UN, by ITU, by UNDP, by the World Economic Forum. And the team was kind enough to remind me today. that my time for my three minutes is over. But indeed, the time for all of us will be over when it comes to achieving the SDGs by 2030 if we do not start with empowering women in tech and digital. Thank you so much.

Sade Baderinwa: Your Excellency, can I speak with you? Can I speak with you? Please. Of course. I just wanted to take a few moments. Of course, being a woman, I am charged by seeing so many women lead these initiatives. Why was it important for Saudi Arabia to do this and have women just really be the cornerstone for all the movements going forward?

Abdullah Alswaha: It’s 50% of our productivity, prosperity, and future. So it’s only natural that as we move from 7% women empowered in tech, which was a position we did not want to be, to achieving 35%, surpassing the Silicon Valley average, the EU average, and even the G20 average, becoming the most successful story. And hear this, we have achieved our economic diversification by achieving 50% of our economy today becoming in an oil. And tell me briefly, what has this done for other women in the country, seeing women lead these initiatives? It’s got to be inspiring. I bet you’re going to hear it from Noura, Deemah, and the rest of the girls that we have here, how this has really not only transformed their lives, but have helped them contribute to a region on how we can tackle the most pressing issues. These women have led the study in collaboration with ITU on how we can connect the unconnected world, how we can deliver non-terrestrial networks to connect from satellite communication to devices. They have worked on a million empowering women and youth when it comes to the largest reskilling and upskilling activities with Saudi codes, starting up with Microsoft and Minecraft. And fast forward with AI, they are leading the work for the tech envoy today for the General Secretary on how we can tackle the most pressing issues in regulation, in standardization, and delivering a human-centric AI for the world.

Sade Baderinwa: Your Excellency, thank you very much.

Abdullah Alswaha: No, thank you. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: So, what is meaningful digital future for all? It is where everyone has the right to a safe, enriching, and productive online experience. And we heard earlier from Doreen’s TED Talk, if you’ll recall, she mentioned Giga, a UNICEF and ITU-led initiative to connect every school on the planet to the Internet by 2030. That’s only five years. I mean, it’s not far away. And exactly five years ago, Giga was born here at the heart of the United Nations. And today, we are celebrating Giga’s birthday, so let’s take a look at this video.

Official Video: At Giga, we are committed to connecting all the schools in the world to the Internet by 2030. By mapping schools using satellite imagery and AI, and by identifying cost-effective methods for delivering connectivity through infrastructure analysis, we provide governments with the tools to advance digital learning. Let’s take a look at Giga Maps. Red dots are schools that are offline. Green dots are schools connected to the Internet. In Dominica, Giga has helped turn red dots into green. Let’s meet a teacher from one of those schools.

Joan Moses: Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Joan Moses, and I’m a teacher at the Roosevelt Douglas Primary School in Potsmouth, Dominica. I stand before you in New York for the first time, filled with excitement and anticipation. This moment is a testament of how connectivity can change lives. When my school was connected to the Internet, everything changed. The internet has opened the door to a whole new world of digital resources, allowing me to bring innovative teaching methods into my classroom, creating a more stimulating and inclusive learning environment. My students are more engaged, more curious, and they’re achieving more than we have ever imagined. This May in Dominica, 835 students participated in national exams online simultaneously, thanks to the internet. Through Giga, schools in our region have also collaborated with each other and shared best practices, allowing us to learn from each other teachers and address common challenges. The internet has enriched our discussions around critical topics, such as climate change and social justice, encouraging our school community to reflect on our roles as global citizens. My students are learning about the importance of empathy, collaboration, and responsibility, qualities that are essential in today’s interconnected world. Let us work together to ensure that every child, regardless of their location, has the opportunity to connect, learn, and thrive in the digital world. Together we can bridge the gap and create a brighter future for all. But don’t just take it from me. Let’s hear from my students.

Official Video: Internet helps boost my learning, like when I have extra classes or extra activities and the teacher has like the flu or something. I still do Google stuff. It means that it is a modern day school, it’s a good school, and it also helps if your teacher needs to show you a slide show. Teachers can care for you, they can love you, and they can use the internet connection to help you learn. Diva is 5 years old now. Happy birthday, Diva!

Joan Moses: Help connect every school to the Internet, because with technology and great teachers, we can give our children access to information, opportunity and choice. Thank you.

Tofara L. Chokera: Ladies and gentlemen, I stand before you today as a living proof that embracing the digital world unlocks a future filled with endless opportunities. When I first encountered a computer at the age of 20, I had no idea how profoundly it will change my life. Today, as a founder of the Tofara Online Trust, I have witnessed firsthand how digital tools can transform not one life, but thousands. Through our flagship initiatives, the Digital Skills Development Program, we have empowered more than 12,000 women, youth and SMEs across Zimbabwe and Africa. We are empowering them with digital skills they need for international trade. We launched an initiative called the Talent for Startups in partnerships with Digital Africa, where we are equipping the youth with skills needed to secure meaningful employment in the digital economy. This year, 58% of our students were young women who are now website developers, graphics designers and digital marketing professionals. just to mention a few, giving them equal access to technology and digital skills. We stand at the crossroads of change, where the future of Africa is not just written by the hands of few, but by the collective efforts of many. It is a digital future for all, where women rise together as leaders, driving the digital era forward with their resilience, creativity and innovation. Winning the Equals in Tech Award as a leader in SME in 2022 was a milestone for us that uplifted thousands of women who looked up to us for inspiration. It shows us that our work and our voices matter. This recognition has fuelled our determination to work even harder, get opportunities to collaborate with women leaders across Africa, and also, as a board member of the Komesa Federation for Women in Business in Zimbabwe, I am advocating for a digital future where every woman is driving digital transformation for their businesses. My wish and my dream is to see every woman embrace technology, to see them learn, to see them innovate and to see them lead. The future belongs to those who dare to step in the digital space and claim it as theirs. Let’s build that future together. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you, Tofara. And please welcome to the stage Pamela Coke-Hamilton. She is the Executive Director of the International Trade Center. Pamela.

Pamela Coke-Hamilton: Thank you. I’m supposed to have a teleprompter up here, but clearly not. Thank you so much, Tofara. You represent actually for us one of the great success stories of ITC and of the International Trade Center process generally. You’ve done some powerful work and your insights are really incredible, especially what you’ve done in Zimbabwe. Your leadership and your mentorship, recognized by the Equals in Tech Awards, thank you, Doreen, has really empowered women to build digital skills and unlock economic opportunities. It’s a reminder of what is possible if we truly commit ourselves to closing the gender digital divide and of what we can achieve if we dare to do things differently. It’s why I’m so proud to be a supporter and a founding member of the Equals Initiative. Building a truly inclusive digital economy means creating access and actually enabling these same opportunities and tools that can ensure all women and all small businesses can have a digital future. I want you to imagine with me a world where every small business, no matter its size or location, can access the same data, insights as Global Jans. A world where a family-run bakery in Cambodia or a craft store in Kenya can reach international markets, identify the best opportunities, and connect with customers they never imagined possible. A world where we have finally democratized access to digital opportunities so no firm is left behind. Small businesses are the backbone of our global economy, but too often they’re unable to take full part in our digital age. Many don’t know where to start. Many don’t have the finance or the training to use the newest digital tools. Many don’t understand what the buyers in new markets want. But what if we could change that? The good news is we can, and we already know how. In Southeast Asia, over 1,000 small and medium-sized enterprises have transformed their prospects through the Digital Export Enablement Program. They have been able to access online resources. like Google Market Finder, Trademap, the Global Trade Helpdesk, and EcomConnect tools. They’ve learned what they needed to create their own strategies, thanks to online and hybrid sessions, and the support of a network of trainers. They’re using AI-powered insights and tailoring digital campaigns to connect with new audiences on a far deeper level. And they’re showing us how the future of business growth lies at the intersection of data, digital strategy, and innovation. After participating in the program, over 95% of the businesses reshaped their strategies and grew their global presence. This program was born out of a collaboration between the International Trade Center and Google, working alongside partners in the international space, like the ICC, and of course, my good friend from the World Intellectual Property Organization, Daren. Very good to see you, Daren, thanks. And this was just the beginning. Now it’s time to go global. When small businesses can access the same market insights, digital strategies, and online platforms as big corporations, the impact is clear. More growth, more jobs, and more inclusive economic development. The future belongs to those who can leverage the power of data. Together, I believe we can make that future possible. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you. Oh, wonderful. Thank you. Thank you. Pamela, thank you so much. And the importance of digital skills is essential for leveraging digital platforms and AI tools. Please welcome Christopher Burns from USAID. Christopher, please. Thank you.

Christopher Burns: Each year, more than 10 million students graduate from tech-related fields. These students are the future developers, engineers, and innovators who will shape the digital landscape, not just in their home countries, but globally because we know technology’s impacts go far beyond national borders. By integrating a responsible approach into their education, we can ensure that they enter the workforce, not just as technologists, but as architects of a digital future built on safety, inclusion, and justice. And the world needs such leaders. International development is replete with stories about the successes of digital technology, but not every instance has a happy ending. I heard a story a few years ago about a small business owner in East Africa who, in a moment of financial need, turned to a fintech lending app for a quick loan, as millions of people across the world do every year. The app’s design, its ease of access, its seamless integration with mobile money made borrowing almost too easy. But what seemed like a lifeline ended up being a trap, much like a predatory payday lender in the US. Needing to repay this initial loan very quickly to avoid a high interest rate, this business owner turned to a second lending app, and then a third, and then a fourth. As this business owner said, the apps give your money gently, and then they come for your neck. So, yes, the app did provide access to finance, but it did not solve financial inclusion, the true development challenge facing many countries. The story illustrates a theme we’ve heard many times, but seem to have not yet internalized. Technology can uplift humanity, but it can also deepen existing societal divides. Too often, the people designing these technologies are focused on innovation, without considering the full impacts of their products and services. And as AI technologies are becoming embedded in our everyday lives, we cannot afford to miss this moment. This concern is what the Responsible Computing Challenge aims to address. Designed and implemented by Mozilla Foundation, and sponsored by USAID, the challenge is an initiative that’s reshaping how we train the world’s future technologists, especially young women and girls, in an effort to close digital divides around the world. The challenge aims to embed responsibility into the core of technology and computer science curricula at universities, in the U.S., in Kenya and India, and with more to come in South Africa, Ghana, and elsewhere. Students in the Global South are aware of these issues and are eager to address them in their communities. As a student in Kenya reflecting on their experience with the challenge shared, as my classmates and I step into the workplace, we will carry this knowledge, empowered by a newfound sense of purpose, and we know the unique opportunity in our lives to ensure that when we enter the workplace, we are doing so with ethics, user-centered design, and responsibility as it means to the real world. The challenge we face is immense, and so is the opportunity. I invite you, policymakers, innovators, and leaders gathered here today to join us in this mission. The Responsible Computing Challenge is just the beginning. Your ideas, your expertise, and your commitment can help us build a future where technology truly empowers every individual. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Great, thank you so much. Okay, we are now approaching the end of the session, but we’re going to conclude with a bang. We’re going to focus on our youth, which is so important because it’s about laying out this future for them, a key pillar of this summit, future, and its action days. So, please, let me call to this day Sanjana Sanghi, Yuri Romashko, and Daniella Esi Darlington. Please, have a seat. So, Sanjana, let me start with you. You feel strongly about girls getting access to digital technology. Why? And tell me about this.

Sanjana Sanghi: Thank you for your question, and good afternoon, everyone. It’s an honor to be here. The reason why I feel so passionate about that is because I come from India, and I am youth champion for the UNDP in India, but I am also a girl who’s just grown up wanting access to education, wanting to build a life for herself. I have been fortunate to be able to get that access but in my journey of advocacy work, I have worked with girls in certain parts of our country that haven’t and I have my mother who’s actually seated in the audience here right now. Shout out to my mom who is a… Where is mom? Where is mom? Where is mom? Mom, can you raise your hand?

Sade Baderinwa: Oh, there she is.

Sanjana Sanghi: Okay. Who is a fifty-six-year-old Indian woman who wanted to make a difference and the only way she could do that is because digital technologies allowed her to connect with girls from very, very economically backward sections of society in India. Zainab and Pallavi are her name, their names and they belong to slums in India. Their parents do everyday jobs if at all. They don’t have any steady stream of income but they have somehow got themselves a smartphone. So their course modules they can see on their smartphone while my mom teaches them English which prepares them to be a part of the bigger world because they would never ever have gotten the opportunity to learn even just a basic language like English. So I have seen how women from two different generations and two different economic backgrounds with the tool of digital technology can come together and change each other’s lives. My mom feels invigorated by teaching them and Zainab and Pallavi are off to hopefully a better future.

Sade Baderinwa: Wow. Mom, you did an excellent job. Fantastic. Okay, Yuri, let’s talk about you. You attended this, this thing yesterday, right? For youth. What was your biggest takeaway?

Yurii Romashko: Well, I want to deliver two key takeaways. First, youth extremely accurately identify the main challenges of digital future based on digital today. And according to youth consultations, which was held in a Spark Blue platform, youth determined limited literacy. limited access to the internet, limited infrastructure as the key barriers which enable access to the digital technologies. So all this requires our common and global efforts. And second thing, the voice of youth is vibrant and game changer today. It ensures that policy makers and institutions should engage youth into the policy making, because of the reform agenda, because of the IA technologies, because of the digital solutions provide a lot of new opportunities. They reshape youth opportunities and therefore it’s extremely important to engage and involve youth people into the decision making process right now.

Sade Baderinwa: Well you’re a part of this decision making process right now yourself, because we have leaders here from different countries, so your voice matters. Daniella, let me get you in here. What were your takeaways from yesterday’s session?

Daniella Esi Darlington: Right, thank you so much for the question. So we realize that youth are more connected than ever before. However, there still exists a lot of digital divide in terms of internet connectivity and accessibility, especially in rural areas. And with ITU, our head of international youth day, we conducted a series of quizzes to gauge the level of awareness among youth in terms of internet usage and connectivity amongst others. And we realized that 66% of the youth were not really informed about where the biggest digital divide exists. So my key takeaway was that it’s not enough that we bridge the digital divide, we also have to bridge the awareness divide. Because you can only empower someone to do something, they can only do something if they have the knowledge about it. So we have to create more digital literacy programs for our youth, and we also have to create platforms where they apply those knowledge. especially where space technology is not so commonly known among the youth. We have to create opportunities where they can apply their knowledge in AI and space technologies to bridge and solve problems in their local communities. And my final words will be that we’ve connected our youth to the world and it’s important that we also connect them to its future. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you, thank you. So what, Sanjana, what does your vision for a digital future look like for all?

Sanjana Sanghi: Oh, it’s a daunting, you know, thought, but for me, there’s always this kind of like an invisible prefix to the digital future, which is an equitable and just a realistic digital future. By that, I mean that anything untamed can just spill in different directions, right? So what I mean by that is that when I see, say the youth being empowered with social media, when I see them getting untamed access, I see it having negative effects, negative effects on their mental health, negative effects on their attention spans, on the way they use it. So I feel like everything else in the world, even access to digital technologies needs to be guided and rooted. Like Daniela said that the ones who have it have too much and the ones who don’t have none at all. So firstly, that equitable distribution is really important because again, coming from India, I get to see it in a magnified way and who’s illiterate continues to remain digitally illiterate as well. So like many speakers here today have said that there are many developmental kind of barriers that we have to overcome for any kind of equitable digital future to be possible. So I’m waiting for that digital future where it’s more of a digital dividend and not a digital disaster.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you. And for you, Yuri, what does the digital future look like for you?

Yurii Romashko: My vision of the digital future is based on these three pillars. It is inclusivity and accessibility, digital literacy, and digital security. And my vision is very simple, to take action and transform challenges into opportunities in my community, city, country. I’m from Ukraine, where is the war. And because of the war, one of the biggest challenges is reconstruction. And there are thousands of projects simultaneously happening from all over the country. And to properly manage, control, organize, we create DREAM, Digital Restoration Ecosystem for Accountable Management. It’s an ecosystem as a single pipeline solution, where everyone sees everything that is connected with the reconstruction.

Sade Baderinwa: Great, thank you. And for you, Daniela, what does this future look like?

Daniella Esi Darlington: I’d also like to summarize that into three key words, universal, affordable, and also inclusive. For anybody to be able to leverage digital solutions, it needs to be available for them to be able to harness it. Also universality is also key to affordability. So then we have to make sure that building AI technologies and tools is, we do that with cost in mind. Because I am a tech founder, and I realized how building AI tools would not be able to, people in rural areas would not be able to leverage these tools if they don’t even have access to it in the first place. So we have to factor all these costs into digital solutions and innovations. And lastly, it has to be inclusive. We have to include people who are in the underrepresented parts of the world, those who are blind, people with disabilities. We have to bring them on board when we are developing technological tools so that it’s not just for us who are capable, but also those who lack the ability to afford these things or able to leverage these tools are also, they also have the opportunity to partake in the digital future. So that would be my future, that the digital world is inclusive, it’s universal, and also it’s affordable.

Sade Baderinwa: Good points there. Daniella, thank you. Sanjana and Yuri, this is our future. Let’s give them a round of applause. All so poised, poised and smart. Thank you all. Well now, Paul Foster is going to announce a pledge. He’s the CEO of Global Esports Federation. Please welcome him.

Paul J. Foster: Good afternoon. Your excellencies, distinguished guests, good afternoon. It’s a real pleasure to be with you today on behalf of our Global Esports Federation and our community of over 3.2 billion gamers around the world. Secretary General Doreen, Administrator Akim, thank you for the opportunity for our community to contribute to this important work. But gaming is more than a game. Our motto, World Connected, inspires us to do more. Just last month at the Paris 2024 Olympic Games as a sign of our progress, the International Olympic Committee declared that they would create next year in 2025 the very first Olympic esports games. And so today, on behalf of our global impact partners around the world, we pledge a multi-year, multi-million dollar series of global initiatives leveraging this transformation potential about our digital world and the youth of the world. Thank you very much.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you so much. And next, I’d like to welcome to the stage Brad Smith, who is the Vice Chair and President of Microsoft UNSDG. Thank you so much. Thank you.

Brad Smith: Well, I know the time is running out. Let me be brief, but let me say just a few words. First, of course, to thank Doreen and Akam and ITU and UNDP for not just today, but all the work every day. I want to say just a few words about one critical topic. When we look to the future and we think about artificial intelligence, how will we ensure that it reaches and serves the global South? That I think is one of the most important questions before the United Nations this week and this year. First, I would say we need to learn the lessons of the past. Artificial intelligence is what economists call a general-purpose technology. Think electricity. It changes every part of the economy. So first, let’s learn the lessons from the history of electricity. A hundred and forty-two years ago, the first power plant lit up lower Manhattan. And yet tonight, there are still 700 million people, 43 percent of the people who live in Africa, who do not have access to electricity. And what one sees over 15 decades is that every time electricity grew and people had access to it, economic development followed. But it has been extraordinarily uneven in many ways because of the economic structure of electricity. We all know that a power plant is very big and very expensive, as is an electric grid, even though an appliance may not cost much money at all. And the inability to overcome that economic challenge which is, in my opinion, a fundamental contributor, even cause, of one of history’s greatest technology tragedies. Because the electricity divide, I believe, is the fundamental cause in so many ways of the great north-south divide that shapes everything we are talking about here today. So now, let’s go to the future, and we have to ask ourselves, how do we ensure that this history does not repeat itself? First, we need to understand that the artificial intelligence economic structure looks a lot like electricity. At the infrastructure layer, data centers, they are big, they are expensive, they cost billions of dollars, even if it is very inexpensive to create an AI application. So what are we going to do? Well, first, we are going to have to do what was never done for electricity for the first 50 years after it was invented. Harness the power of capital and bring it to the world, and not just parts of it. And that means private companies like Microsoft, where we spent more than $50 billion last year, not just in the U.S., but in the developing world as well. But it means raising more capital, it means turning to long-term development financing, it means making this one of the great goals for the next decade to ensure that AI reaches everywhere. Second, we not only have to be thinking globally, we have to be focusing locally. And that’s what so many of you do. We need local language models so local voices can be heard. We need local data sets so that global and local problems can both be addressed. And in order to harness the power of AI at a local level, we need to recognize that just as important as the technology infrastructure. is the skilling infrastructure. It is investing to educate more data scientists, data analysts, computer scientists, and the many, many, many other fields that need to be grown so that a local economy can put AI to work. If and only if we do these things, we can ensure that AI is a leapfrog technology that helps close the gaps that divide the world in so many ways today. It will require all of us. It will require new types of partnerships. But I think it requires, among other things, a spirit of optimism that learns from the past and does our best to repeating the things that have gone wrong before. Thank you very much.

Sade Baderinwa: Brad, thank you so much. Just quickly, quickly, quickly. Okay, you’re giving us optimism. You talked about $50 billion Microsoft actually used around us, not here, but around the globe, and that we need to think locally, not just for language models, so you can hear those local voices. Because a lot of people are afraid of AI on a very granular level. Tell us just more about bridging that gap and how it can really transform the world.

Brad Smith: Well, I think bridging the gap probably requires a couple of things. One is it’s another one of the great lessons of electricity. You got to go meet people where they are, show them how they can use it, and show them how it can make their lives better. It’s an educational exercise that when you study electricity and how it moved around, it was key. And then the other thing that we also have to keep in mind and that I have to be, I think especially, it’s important for somebody like me to say, this technology and the companies that create it need to be subject to the rule of law. Local laws in countries, all the way to global governance. including at the United Nations. And that’s why the kind of multi-stakeholder activism that you see on a day like today is fundamental to ensuring that this technology truly serves the world.

Sade Baderinwa: And just really quickly, because I think this is an important point, talking about the skilled infrastructure, we also need to teach people about this new future and giving them the skills that they need.

Brad Smith: Yeah, and it’s so fascinating because I think that fundamentally you start by thinking, well, you gotta teach somebody how to do data analytics or how to use a large language model, how to write prompts. All of those things are true. I actually think the first step is to show people what they can do once they master those skills. One of my favorite things, like studying electricity, was here in the United States where it didn’t reach rural communities. There was a government initiative to just show people what it would mean to farmers, to women who were washing clothes or cooking food, to men who are harvesting crops. You have to help people see what it means for their own lives and not in just some abstract sense.

Sade Baderinwa: Wonderful. Brad Smith, thank you so much.

Brad Smith: Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you. Thank you. Okay, in this next session, we are going to see how we can harness digital technologies to protect the environment and planet. Now joining us is Nobu Okada, founder and CEO of AstroScale. Please welcome Nobu.

Nobu Okada: Hello, everybody. Take a look. This 10 millimeter metal ball could derail all the incredible digital progress we’ve been talking about today. This is a visualization of the space object reflecting millions of space debris ranging from smaller than this size to as large as a city bus size. that are traveling around the Earth at tremendous speed, 100 times faster than a bullet train. This is an urgent threat to the satellites which we rely on every day for digital technologies, from climate monitoring and traffic control to internet access and disaster response. We used to think space was big, treating rockets and satellites as disposable objects. But today, space is very congested and unsustainable. And just one collision with this metal ball could trigger a chain reaction collision that could prevent us from using space for generations. At Astroscale, our vision is to make space sustainable, and our satellites are designed to create a circular economy to remove, reuse, relocate the fuel, and in the future, repair and recycle spacecraft, leaving no waste in space. This requires advanced technology to approach and capture fast-moving, uncontrolled objects in space. And our satellites are equipped with sensors to locate objects, software for autonomous maneuvers, and robotic arms to grab an object and remove or service it. This year, our Astroscale team achieved a historic milestone, successfully locating and approaching a real piece of debris. This is the world’s first image of real space debris, an 11-meter-long rocket body weighing 3 tons, taken from just 15… meters away. And here is a time-lapse of a fly around. This debris is not sitting still. It’s moving at over seven kilometers per second. When I saw this image, I thought this is beautiful, although it’s just a garbage. And then our next mission is to remove this debris, but we should recycle this in future. Space sustainability is critical to safeguarding our future, and this matters to each and every one of you. So be an advocate for space sustainability. Together we have the responsibility and opportunity to ensure space as a resource that benefits humanity for the generation to come. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Okay, thank you so much. Now we’re actually going to turn to the Middle East, and earlier we heard from His Excellency Abdullah Alswaha about his appointment of women for his vision of the future. And joining us now is one of those appointments is Deemah AlYahya, Secretary General of Digital Cooperation Organization. Please come to the stage, Deemah.

Deemah AlYahya: Thank you so much. Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone. I would like first to thank Doreen and Achim for bringing us all together and giving us this platform to cooperate and partner together and bridge that gap, the digital divide and the digital gap. Now Ladies and gentlemen, excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, honored guests, it is 2024 and yet there are still regions in the world where a staggering 75% of the population remains disconnected from the Internet. While connecting them is a priority, we must ask ourselves, if we were to bring everyone online today, would it really solve the pressing issues of poverty, unemployment, the lack of digital skills? Is that enough? The answer is no, because it is no longer just about digital divide. It is about gender digital divide, AI divide, skill divide, and the disparity in the quality of connectivity across the borders. So how do we address this? The answer lies in three I’s, infrastructure, innovation, and inclusivity. First infrastructure, without robust infrastructure, true digital growth will remain a distant dream. Second is innovation, quantum computing, AI, blockchain, and the Internet of Things. These innovations are not just breakthroughs, they are engines for transformation that we must nourish. Third, inclusivity. Bridging the digital divide requires more than just connectivity. It depends and realize that we close the quality gap and provide equal opportunities for all to fully participate in the digital economy. So how do we ensure a bright digital future? Ladies and gentlemen, introducing the Digital Cooperation Organization’s answer, DEN, the digital economy navigator. Well, there was supposed to be a video playing, but okay, I’ll continue. So navigating tomorrow, that is our goal. And with DEN, we provide the solution with constructive insights for digital growth. DEN is not just an innovative tool. It is a game changer. It offers comprehensive, detailed view of digital economy performance across 50 countries. And it goes beyond measurement. DEN provides a clear framework with 102 indicators across 10 pillars, measuring digital economy maturity in three main dimensions, digital enablers, digital business, and digital society. This helps countries benchmark their progress and identify the steps needed to go from consumer into producers, innovators, and disruptors. Through DEN, the Digital Cooperation Organization is taking charge in providing a solution that connects fragmented efforts, offers clarity, and accelerates digital growth. I call and urge all of you to seize this opportunity, engage with us, and use DEN as a tool for all international organizations, countries, private sector. We connect the dots and connect source and connect the supply with the demand. Thank you so much. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Okay. Deemah, if you can just stay here for a moment. And sorry about the video. Unfortunately, we had technical difficulties. But you know, I spoke with His Excellency Abdullah Alswaha earlier. And he talked about the women who are being appointed these positions. And you are leading these efforts on a global scale right now. And you are giving the answers to the globe. Tell me about what this means to you personally.

Deemah AlYahya: Well, this is first, His Excellency surprised us today. And I appreciate that recognition. He and of course, Prince Mohammed bin Salman has been the force. behind enabling women and giving them the opportunity, really, to lead. What is really beautiful and what is provided now for women in Saudi Arabia is not just the opportunity, but also treated and these positions are looked at from a quality perspective and not just filling in a gap with gender equality. And this is, we’re blessed as women to be recognized and given this opportunity and now it’s our time to deliver and show that we are up to the task and we can.

Sade Baderinwa: So you’re telling me that this means something to you personally. What do you hope the other Saudi woman living at home who happens to see this streaming, what do you hope it inspires in her?

Deemah AlYahya: Well, not a Saudi woman, actually, all girls all over the world. That we can do it and opportunities are there. We have to seek for these opportunities and we have to make sure that we’re always learning and upskilling ourselves to make sure that we are up to always the task.

Sade Baderinwa: Well, you are up to the task and you are doing it. So thank you for inspiring all of the women, not just Saudi women. Thank you so much. Thank you. And I just want to remind the speakers, just for the sake of time, if we can condense the remarks because I know people are starting to get hungry in the room and we do want a break for lunch at some point. So please now allow me to welcome to the stage His Excellency Valentino Valentini, Deputy Minister at the Ministry of Enterprise and Made in Italy. Please welcome him. Thank you so much.

Valentino Valentini: Thank you so much. Thank you very much. Well, the digital revolution is reshaping our world at an unprecedented pace. The rapid advancement of technology offers immense opportunities, but it also brings with it the responsibility to ensure that these innovations support environmental sustainability. and equitable growth. To achieve a future where technology serves as a force for good, we must focus on integrating digital solutions with sustainable practices and fostering collaborations that bridge gaps and drive progress, ensuring that no one is left behind. Today, I am thrilled to share with you an initiative that embodies this vision – the AI Hub for Sustainable Development, co-designed by Italy’s G7 Presidency in partnership with the United Nations Development Programme. This initiative exemplifies our commitment to leveraging AI for sustainable development and global progress, with a focus on the African continent. It reflects our conviction that the path to the future must be inclusive and equitable, benefiting every corner of our world. Our journey in creating this AI Hub has been guided by collaboration, inclusivity, and a shared vision for the future of AI. We started by engaging with the African Union and securing the support of our G7 partners. We consulted with over 100 stakeholders, engaged with more than 300 AI startups across Africa, and initiated 80 partnerships focused on local language digitization. This collaborative effort ensures that the future of AI is shaped by diverse voices, perspectives, and innovative ideas. Our approach is centered around four critical pillars – data, computing power, talent, and enabling ecosystems. We are committed to deepening partnerships with our private sector and industry to strengthen the foundations and scale AI solutions that address the most pressing global challenges we heard today – whether it’s transforming energy, revolutionizing agriculture, improving health care, managing water resources, enhancing education and infrastructure – we’ve seen it all today, well presented here – AI holds the potential to tackle this issue. in ways we’ve only began to imagine. The AI Hub is also a cornerstone of Italy’s MATE plan, reinforcing our dedication to sustainable development and innovation in Africa. This initiative wants to go beyond technology transfer. It’s about co-creating, creating solutions together, learning from each other, and growing together. We believe that Africa must be a true partner in shaping the future of AI, and we’re committed to ensuring that this journey is one of mutual growth and shared benefits. As we stand at this pivotal moment of the Global Digital Compact, I invite you to join us in this transformative endeavor. Together, we can harness the power of AI to build a future where technology enhances our lives, protects our planet, and ensures prosperity for all. Thank you very much. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you. Who’s next? Jakob, Jakob. Thank you so much. And now I just wanted to take the moment to recognize the president, the presence of the president of Malawi, His Excellency Lazarus Chakwera. Thank you so much. We look forward to hearing from you a little bit later. And our next speaker is Jakob Granit. He’s the Director General, Swedish International Developed Corporation Agency. Please, let’s welcome Jakob. Jakob, thank you.

Jakob Granit: It’s my great privilege to address you on behalf of Sweden on a topic of hope, digital sustainability, and prosperity. The ongoing digital transformation presents mankind with plenty of hope for solutions to tackle poverty, build equitable societies, and find sustainable solutions in areas such as the green transition. At the same time, There are many risks related to digitalization, such as misinformation, and that vulnerable parts of society are left behind. To address these risks and opportunities, Sweden has worked with its co-facilitator Zambia, the Secretary General’s tech envoy, member states, and stakeholders in the intergovernmental process for a global digital compact. The compact has a key goal of an inclusive, open, sustainable, fair, safe, and secure digital future for all, and is planned to be agreed here at this summit. Now there is a strong link between the green transition and the digital transformation. Digital services often replace carbon-intensive services and transport, and the circular economy relies on digital infrastructure and services. Let me provide one example of how the Swedish International Development Co-operative Agency, SIDA, brings digital and green together. SIDA was part of establishing an investment in the GSMA Innovation Fund for Climate Resilience and Adaptation. The fund has supported start-ups across the section of green and digital. Some of the examples in the agriculture space range from a system to share tractors in Nigeria, to boosting fish farms in Kenya through iInternet of Things solutions, and to support farmers in Nepal to adapt to climate change through new techniques and access to information. These examples illustrate how the private sector can leverage the power of digital while ensuring the sustainability principles of the global digital compact. So in ending, the hope of digitalization in terms of contributing to prosperity and sustainability in support of a green transition is very large, and we hope the Global Digital Compact will provide a roadmap to unlock these opportunities. for the benefit of all of us. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you, Jakob. And our next speaker, Zhiping Chen. Thank you so much. She’s the vice president of ZTE Corporation, and she’s going to share how connectivity, entire species can be saved and preserved in one of the most remote places on earth. Zhiping.

Zhiping Chen: Thank you. Thank you for today to have a chance to be here. It’s my great honor. I’m Summer Chen, and today I want to share a wonderful story. Do you ever thinking about a place is ever in charge in time, and is rural, or in charge by the, this is Cocoshilli, one is the highest UNESCO hesitate site. In these places, park rangers, they are wirelessly protect Tibetan antelope for poachers. And we find the digital solutions to connect this remote areas. This vast isolated wilderness is a home to over 200 spices. When you step into Cocoshilli, it means leaving all behind the modern connectivities. Today I want to share a remarkable story of hope. Through these digital solutions, we protect these remote areas, caring for ecosystem in ways you never imagined. In these places, what the monthly without connection park rangers, what they are doing? Not just protect the only retirement entertainment, staring contest, to see who would blink first. Despite all these challenges, in collaboration with our partners, ZTE embarked on a mission We connected this and achieved three breakthroughs. First, successfully to build the first 5G base station. It allows for observation and in-depth animals and the live stream on the tablet, antelope migration and caring season. Nearly six, seven point millions of viewers tuned in worldwide. It’s greatly public wellness enhancement. Second, our 5G network will connect park rangers for their loved ones through a reliable railroad course. We witnessed the rangers were overwhelmed by the first call. Third, thanks for this 5G technicals, we caught on the carbon emission is another big win for environmental protection. And all our commitment is not just for Kokushile, we pushing the boundaries worldwide. For ZTE, our mission is quite clear, to making the connectivity and the trust everywhere. We believe this digital inclusion is a fundamental pillar of SDGs. It’s ensuring the digital future for all. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you. And now from the UN, let’s bring up Fatou Haidara, Daren Tang, and Tawfik Jelassi.

Fatou Haidara: Good afternoon, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen. Every solution begins with a problem. In this particular case, we are dealing with an invasive species called Acacia bushes that invades the grassland of Namibia and takes up farmland. The farmers affected were simply burning the bushes to recover land, a dangerous process but also a source of harmful emissions. The New Dose Sustainable Bush Value Chain Project uses artificial intelligence, machine learning, satellite and drone imagery to analyze and map the growth of the bush across Namibia. It is a prime example of how digital technology can be used to tackle environmental degradation and resource depletion. Artificial intelligence and geographic information systems now identify where the Acacia is growing and estimate the total biomass. This provides a foundation for the responsible harvesting of this invasive species and as next step, the harvested Acacia is turned into marketable products like charcoal and cattle feed. Together with our partners, we transform a harmful environmental issue into an economic asset. for local communities. A challenge become an opportunity. Funded by Finland, our solution has received strong support from national authorities and local communities, attracted venture capital, and led to the establishment of a factory for biomass processing. A factory like this means local value addition, job creation, and income generation. Our initiative shows how AI technologies can benefit rural populations and foster sustainable in inclusive growth. It is our collective responsibility to ensure that developing countries have access to such technologies to bridge the digital divide. At UNIDO, we will continue to explore the potential of AI for advancing local communities, job creation, and environmental sustainability. We look forward to partnering with all of you in identifying and implementing similar concrete digital solutions. I thank you.

Daren Teng: Hi, I think I’m next as the DG of WIPO. Good afternoon, everyone. I’m Daren Teng, the Director General of the World Intellectual Property Organization, the UN Agency for Innovation, Creativity, and Intellectual Property. Innovation is a process by which an idea is turned into an invention, and an invention creates impact. One of the key work, key missions of WIPO is to develop a global network of technology and innovation support centers, or TIS. But what are TIS, and how did it really harness the power of digital to unlock innovation potential? Think of every innovation journey. as a planting an idea in fertile soy. But like any seed, these seeds need the right nutrients to grow, and one key nutrient is information. One of the unique features of the IP system is that when you apply for any type of IP, you have to disclose information behind this new technology, new brand, or new design. And with over 20 million intellectual property applications filed each year, this has become a huge database of information. Policymakers use it to understand technology trends, researchers use it to identify new areas of research and decide on research priorities, and entrepreneurs apply it to find potential partners for their businesses. But making information available is only part of the story. Advice is also needed for these researchers, inventors, and entrepreneurs, especially from developing countries to take their ideas from the lab to the market. By combining cutting-edge digital tools with expert guidance, WIPO’s Technology Innovation Support Centers, or TIS, help to transform information into insights and insights into impact. WIPO’s patent scope is one example of information provided through TIS. Powered by artificial intelligence, it mines over 100 million patent documents and close to five million scientific and technical materials to allow innovators to draw insights from all fields of human research. Another example is RD, or Access to Research and Development for Innovation Program. Through this single platform, inventors in developing countries can access hundreds of thousands of scientific and technical reference materials from over 100 publishers. TIS not only provide these digital tools, they guide innovators in how to make best use of them, turning knowledge into new discoveries that drive economies and societies forward. Let me quickly share the story of two amazing innovators, Luis Miguel Segovia and Maria Almanza, both from Colombia. As students, they developed a new solution for foot pain caused by high heels. Impressed, their professor encouraged them to turn their ideas into a business. which led Luis and Maria into a local TIS. Working with an IP expert, they confirmed that their idea was new, studied the market and worked on a patent application. But support didn’t just stop there. The TIS also helped them to apply for seed funding to launch a shoe line, Calzado & Mansa. Luis and Maria are two of the many innovators that we supported throughout 1,500 centres in 93 countries. TIS handled 2.2 million enquiries last year and close to 8 million enquiries in the past four years. We are proud of these numbers, but we are proud of still people like Luis and Maria who are changing the world with their ideas. So let us work together to support them and others to bring their ideas to the world and build a better future for all of us. Thank you very much.

Tawfik Jelassi: Excellencies, esteemed delegates, distinguished guests, my name is Tawfik Jelassi, I am Assistant Director General at UNESCO. I invite you to imagine a world without public services, without schools, without security forces to protect us, without care for the environment, without social security for all. These are not just conveniences, these are the backbone of our society. They uphold equality, inclusivity, human rights, democracy. And it is not a coincidence that SDG 16, which calls for strong institutions, emphasises this. To fully realise digital transformation in the public sector could unlock over $3.5 trillion annually, according to a study by McKinsey. Yet, despite significant investments, 70% of civil servants still lack digital capabilities, according to the World Economic Forum. The cost is not just financial, it’s about lost opportunities to better serve citizens, eroding trust in institutions and undermining democratic values. Obviously, we need to tackle this. What is UNESCO doing about this? Imagine equipping the world with better education, with digital skills, and obviously with full respect of human rights, dignity, equity, and inclusivity. We need to change not only the technology, we need to change the mindsets in order to change the behavior. And we do that through capacity infrastructure, in addition to what ITU has been doing, the meaningful digital infrastructure. One of the examples is our work on AI and the rule of law, training thousands of judges, prosecutors, on the new impact of AI and Gen AI on their work. And obviously, the educational transformation, also the greening of education. So these are just some examples that we are working on, in addition to with the African Union, with ITU, with UNDP, our work on data governance, and the capacity building for civil servants. So obviously, we need to move from just policy makers and tech innovators. We have also to empower educators, citizens, everybody has a role to play. So let’s invest in a digital transformation that serves both people and the planet. Let’s restore trust in our institutions, and let’s reinforce our democratic values. Thank you for your attention. I was supposed to play 30 seconds of the famous song, Imagine, but I was told I cannot do that because of intellectual property rights, especially in the presence of the Director General of WIPO. So you can imagine the music, here are the lyrics. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you all. Thank you so much. if you can please exit the stage. Now up next for a special announcement, we have Alan Davidson from NTIA and Harrison Lung from END.

Alan Davidson: Hi, I’m Alan Davidson, and I just wanna say a very quick shout out and thank you to Doreen Bogdan-Martin for your leadership here to ITU and UNDP and all of our hosts for this second Digital Action Day. Honestly, it’s been an inspiring day. And as a starting point, as we’ve said, the internet is now the essential tool for communications in our modern world. It’s essential for access to work, to education, access to healthcare, access to opportunity. And yet it is incredible that here we are in 2024 and that billions of people around the world still lack access to a high-speed internet connection or they lack the means and the skills to use it. That has to change. In the U.S., we’re doing our part through the Biden-Harris administration’s $90 billion Internet for All initiative to connect everyone, the president keeps saying everyone, everyone in America. And we are proud today to renew and expand our support for the Partner to Connect initiative to mobilize resources to connect the unconnected around the world. In 2022, the Commerce Department delivered our Partner to Connect pledge in Kigali at the ITU’s World Telecommunications Development Conference. And we pledged at that time to provide in-kind knowledge exchange and training opportunities focused on developing the next generation of leaders who will be improving broadband connections around the world. Since then, we’ve funded several efforts to grow global connectivity, but I wanted to highlight particularly the training sessions that have been so valuable and the work that we’ve done in partnership with USTTI in Washington and in Rwanda. Both have focused on African policy leaders and entrepreneurs interested in connectivity, in Internet governance, in space-based communications. I’ll say, I had the chance to meet with this cohort of extraordinary young leaders, and they should give us all hope for the future. They were truly inspiring. As the saying goes, the kids are all right. This brings me to our news today. I’m pleased to share that NTIA is renewing and expanding our pledge. We will partner again with USTTI to bring a new cohort of current and emerging African leaders, all women, to Washington, D.C. for training. We will also bring them – yes, thank you, it’s great, it’s a great group, it’s been a great group – and we’re going to bring them to Silicon Valley as well for some experience with American-style entrepreneurship. Our grant for the African Women Digital Leaders Training Program will promote best practices, demonstrate emerging technologies, grow the leadership skills of these participants, and really invest, again, in this next generation of leaders that we need around the world if we’re going to make this connectivity a reality. We plan to continue similar trainings focused on digital skills and connectivity in the years to come. We look forward to our continued partnership with the ITU on this important effort. I’ll just say, this is a historic moment. The pandemic reminded us that connectivity is not a luxury, it’s a necessity. And the coming AI revolution is only going to deepen that divide for those who don’t have internet access. So this is our chance to connect everyone in the world with the tools that they need to thrive in the modern digital economy. It’s going to take a lot of work, but together I know we can achieve that promise of greater digital access and community around the globe. Thank you.

Harrison Lung: Your Excellencies, distinguished guests, and esteemed speakers. Thank you for the opportunity to speak here today. I would like to use this stage to reaffirm our commitment to building a sustainable and inclusive future, as well as add an additional pledge here on this stage. EN, formerly known as Etisalat, started as a UAE-based telecom operator close to 50 years ago. Since then, we have grown to become a global technology company with operations in over 30 countries across Europe, the Middle East, Africa, and Asia, and over 175 million subscribers. Thus far, we’ve made significant public commitments as part of our sustainability strategy across financial investments and population impacted in our operating footprint. Firstly, as part of the World Economic Forum’s Edison Alliance and its One Billion Lives Challenge, EN has pledged to contribute significantly to this mission by striving to improve the lives of 30 million individuals through enhanced network access, financial services, and technology education by 2025. In addition to connectivity, the digital services and applications, such as technology-supporting financial services, healthcare, and education, is critical to leveling the playing field. Secondly, as part of the UNDP, Digital for Sustainable Development Program, we will soon announce a strategic collaboration with focused initiatives across a number of areas, including AI, fintech, and education. Stay tuned for that. Thirdly, as part of our commitment to ITU’s Partner to Connect Digital Coalition, earlier this year at the Mobile World Congress in Barcelona, EN announced an investment of $6 billion between 2024 to 2026 in technological advancement, infrastructure, and innovative solutions to extend meaningful connectivity to everyone. This is particularly important as we aim to bridge the digital divide in our less developed markets, much of whom is operating in the Global South. Today, on this stage, I’m happy to announce a new pledge to Partner2Connect, a new multi-million dollar commitment to the promotion of digital economies by bridging the digital divide and building skills in underserved communities. This pledge will address many of the issues we heard of in previous segments, such as resilience in disaster-affected areas through early warning systems, capacity building and re-skilling to bring the next generation of workforce into the digital economy, and lastly, access to capital to women and small business entrepreneurs. We believe that the digital network and infrastructure is critical to uplifting the society in a digital age. Additionally, various digital services will provide access and capabilities to the general consumer and elevate enterprises to the global economy. EN is a proud partner with the ITU and the UNDP to contribute to a common vision of a sustainable, inclusive and prosperous digital future of all. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Okay, thank you all. Now, if Rumman Chowdhury can come to the stage, and His Excellency Bosun Tijani and Robert Muggah. Please, please, anywhere that’s comfortable. I’ll sit here on the edge. All right, His Excellency, let’s begin with you. I believe you have an important announcement. want to share about how Nigeria will encourage innovation in tech, but also while ensuring regulations around data privacy.

Bosun Tijani: Right. If I start with that, I think what we’re doing is a recognition that we have a unique opportunity now to rebuild trust between people and the government by ensuring that we can leverage technology to serve and provide opportunity for them during live events. So when you give birth to a child, you’re registering a business. You want to pay your tax. We think the most important thing is that we’re able to deliver this seamlessly and most comfortably to our people. So what we’ve committed to is ensuring that by 2027, that the lowest form of government is connected to quality internet. So we do have what we call the local government, which is the lowest form of interaction that our people get with our government. So the federal government is connecting all the 774 secretariat of our local government to ensure that the services that our people are seeking can be provided to them digitally.

Sade Baderinwa: Wonderful. Thank you. And let me get you in here, Rumman. What do we need to do to ensure a sustainable and inclusive development for AI?

Rumman Chowdhury: Wonderful question. With my nonprofit, Humane Intelligence, we focus on giving access to everybody in the world not to build artificial intelligence, but to evaluate artificial intelligence. We know that AI models are not fit for use around the world in different cultures, different languages. The images that they create can be stereotypical or even degrading. So what we’re trying to provide access to and what leads to a good, sustainable AI future is the ability for everyone to get their hands on AI and determine if it is good for them. Building that level of critical thinking and evaluation with AI systems is a key and often missing part of the AI development story. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: OK. Well, Robert, can you talk about, just in a condensed version, about the risk of AI in the global South?

Robert Muggah: There are multiple risks, some of which have been discussed over the last couple of hours. Some of these risks are already here. Advanced cybersecurity challenges, mass information pollution, the overabundant consumption of energy used by AI, which will be up to 3% to 4% of all energy use within the next five years. Some of them are on the horizon. AGI, artificial general intelligence outside of human control, a real concern. And some we don’t even know about. We set up a global task force last year with representatives from Africa, the Americas, Asia, including an esteemed member on the panel, to reflect a bit on what were the risks and what were the solutions for the global South. We identified four big ones, and I’ll only talk about two. The first is job displacement and inequality. Second is AI bias and discrimination. The third is surveillance and privacy violations. And the fourth is the concentration of power in a small number of AI companies. With respect to job displacement and automation, probably the most important, over 800 million jobs are at risk within the next five years from AI. In the global South, according to the ILO, 56% of all jobs in the global South are at high risk of displacement. Significant. Hugely significant. So what do we have to do? We have to do all of the stuff that’s been talked about in terms of multi-stakeholder engagement. But we also have to invest in job upgrading. We need digital literacy. We need job placement programs. We need to have employment schemes. We also need universal basic income, really socioeconomic responses to what is a digital challenge. And the good news is a lot’s happening. The AI for all in India, Connectus in Brazil, digital ambassadors in Rwanda, NGOs around the world are also investing in this area. And I think we’re also seeing UBI schemes from Namibia to India. So we see solutions, but we’ve got to scale those up.

Sade Baderinwa: I so wish I had more time to talk with you. I’ve got like 20 different questions in my mind about you already and what’s so important in terms of these guardrails and what it means for society, training workers about what is this new technology moving forward, so thank you all. Unfortunately, we’re running out of time. Really appreciate your words today. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. And now it is my great pleasure and honor to introduce his Excellency, President of Malawi, Lazarus Chakwera. Please, come to the stage. Thank you so much. Thank you.

Lazarus Chakwera: Well, I’m supposed to have my thing there, but bring me my iPad. Today, we stand at a pivotal moment in history, a moment where the digital landscape is not just a realm of technology, but a canvas upon which we can paint a brighter, more inclusive future for all. As we gather here, we must recognize that the digital revolution is not merely about advancements in technology, it is about the transformation of our societies, our economies, and ultimately our humanity. Malawi is therefore committed to bridging the digital divide because it is an economic and social issue. Our strategic plans for digital transformation include expanding digital infrastructure, enhancing digital literacy, and fostering an inclusive digital economy to ensure that no one is left behind in our digital journey. To accelerate digital adoption, Malawi has launched several initiatives with support from development partners. For instance, the Digital Malawi Project has been instrumental in expanding Internet connectivity to public institutions, institutions where the last mile rule of connectivity and inclusive digital transformation for Malawi, IDT4M projects, provide equitable access to digital technologies and foster digital literacy across all segments of society. Additionally, we have implemented a data exchange platform that leverages our national ID system as a single point of truth for identity verification. This platform is critical in assuring seamless access to services, improving efficiency across government, and reducing bureaucratic bottlenecks. Complementing this, we have also implemented an e-service platform which now serves as a single point of entry for all government digital services. These initiatives are premised on the acceptance that the digital age has brought forth unprecedented opportunities. It has connected us across continents, enabling us to share ideas, cultures, and innovations. It has empowered individuals, given them a voice and platform to advocate for change. However, while these initiatives ensure that our citizens can access essential services with greater ease, transparency, and security, with great power comes great responsibility. As we lay the foundations of a digital future, we must ensure that this future is equitable, inclusive, and peaceful. Digital literacy is essential for full participation in the digital economy. Therefore we are integrating digital literacy into our national education curricula and providing training opportunities for all age groups. Our technology hubs, which are training thousands of young people in coding, digital skills, and entrepreneurship, are playing a crucial role in fostering innovation. These hubs are not only incubating new ideas, but also creating jobs and driving the growth of Malawi’s digital economy. A truly inclusive digital future cannot be achieved in isolation. Today millions of people around the world remain disconnected, excluded from the benefits of the digital economy. Education and health care. This is not just unfortunate, it is wrong. And it is dangerous. As I said earlier, this divide is not merely a technological issue, it is a social justice issue. To build a peaceful future, we must ensure that everyone, regardless of their socioeconomic status, geographical location, or background, has access to digital tools and the internet. This requires collaboration between governments and multilevel partners, private sectors, and civil society to invest in infrastructure, education, and digital leaders. And we strive, as we strive to bridge the digital divide, we call upon the global community to not only provide financial and technical support, but also to share knowledge, innovations, and best practices. The journey toward a digital future must be a shared one, where no nation, no citizen, is left behind. In conclusion, laying the foundations of a digital future for all is a collective endeavor that requires our commitment, creativity, and compassion. As we embark on this journey, let us remember that technology is a tool, a tool that can either divide us or unite us. It is our collective responsibility to choose the path of inclusion, equity, and peace. Together, let us build a digital future that reflects our highest ideals, a future where everyone has the opportunity to thrive, where dialogue replaces discord, and where peace is not just a dream, but a reality for all. Malawi stands ready to embrace the future, a future where a digital transformation is not just an abstract concept, but a reality that improves the lives of every Malawian. The future is ours to shape, a future that benefits all humanity. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you so much, Your Excellency. Thank you so much. The President of Malawi, Lazarus Chakwera. Please give him another round of applause. Thank you. And joining us once again on the stage is Achim Steiner, he’s going to talk about the promise of digital public infrastructure, and then there will be a video and Akeem will give other remarks.

Official Video: Registry is helping to achieve the goal of the Paris Agreement by reforesting 12 million hectares and creating interoperability between stakeholders and infrastructure across natural resources. But it is not just Malawi, Finland and Brazil. The impact of DPI is growing, with more and more countries leveraging the transformative power of digital public infrastructure. To keep the promise of the Sustainable Development Goals, DPI represents a fundamental pivot that involves everyone, everywhere, and that includes you. Let’s work together to build a safe and inclusive digital future for all.

Achim Steiner: Isn’t it amazing? This is all happening already. And congratulations just to three more pioneers. In many ways, development is, as we have heard from a number of people today, an agenda of hope. This hope for a better future has historically driven development and humanities progress. If there was no hope, we wouldn’t be where we are now. This hope still matters. And hope in one’s own ability to change the course of history, influence people’s decisions and actions. This is why laying the foundations for a digital future is about hope and actions. I want to take you through the journey of building digital public infrastructure across countries today. In fact, it says with the video, but you have just seen it. So, you know, sometimes the script is a little bit behind. Can we go on to the next part? And as we stand at this juncture where our collective commitment to digital foundations can catalyze this brighter future for everyone, everywhere on our planet, I think you have already sensed that in the previous segment of this extraordinary day, we explored groundbreaking digital technologies and the profound impact they can have on sustainability and inclusivity. All the innovative solutions making connectivity universal and affordable, the digital tools enhancing inclusiveness. Their groundwork is laid both inspiring and formidable. Now as we transition to discussing the fundamental structures that support these innovations, we need to collectively shape the future by laying the foundations that are safe and inclusive and serve the public interest. We often talk about physical infrastructure, things like roads and power lines and water utilities that are fundamental to development. In fact, for many, they are already taken for granted. These are the building blocks that elevate the welfare of people and allow people to gain a livelihood. Let’s apply that same understanding for a moment to the digital world. Digital public infrastructure, or DPI, is an approach that goes beyond one-off solutions like apps or portals. It encompasses foundational systems, like digital identity systems we just saw, or payment platforms that allow people, businesses and governments to interact in a secure, inclusive and efficient way. This in turn enables everything from facilitating the access of vital health records online to enabling people more easily to start their own businesses. However, just as traditional infrastructure, like roads and railway tracks, have speed limits and guardrails, we also need to ensure that DPI has the principles, policies and institutions that keep the interests, safety and rights of people and protection of our planet at the very heart of these foundations. As we take equal access to physical infrastructure for granted, DPI must also ensure public value and provide safe, inclusive services at scale. While some governments are deploying DPI rapidly, others are just beginning their digital journeys. Both face risks like privacy concerns, data security and exclusion without proper safeguards. Conversely, embedding safety and inclusion can reduce inequalities and foster trust. This is why putting people and our planet at the centre of DPI is so critical. Digital public infrastructure plays a pivotal role in advancing all the interconnected sustainable development goals by employing digital technologies to address global challenges at scale. For example, foundational digital infrastructure, like digital identification platforms, have the potential to facilitate access to finance or access to healthcare. Again, we heard examples this morning already. Yet, to fully unlock the potential of DPI, we must put people and planet at the center. This requires building on three essential pillars, commitment, capital, capacity. First, commitment. Governments must commit to the importance of inclusive, safe, and equitable digital systems, not just the hardware, not just the fiber optic cable or the devices. Trust and equity are the cornerstones of a progressive society. Without these safeguards, we risk creating systems that exclude vulnerable populations or violate fundamental rights. Brazil, India, and Estonia are often cited as prominent examples for their digital ID systems, which have advanced development. These systems must be specifically designed with safeguards to prevent exclusion or data misuse. Second, capital. Financial investment is critical, not only for building digital public infrastructure, but more importantly for ensuring that robust safeguards are in place. No single entity can do this alone. It requires a collective effort from governments, the private sector, and global partners, civil society, scientists, academia, everyone. Together, actors have to work together and leverage their financial resources to support sustainable, secure, and inclusive DPI that serves everyone. Third and finally, capacity. Skilled teams, an empowered civil society, and expert technical support and beyond are crucial for the effective implementation and governance of DPI safeguards. Yet capacity must go beyond mere technical expertise. It’s about fostering an ecosystem – we’ve heard that word used quite frequently this morning – of collaboration and accountability, where actors share knowledge and resources to ensure that safeguards are implemented and continuously adapted to protect the rights of all users in a rapidly changing field. Our commitment to DPI extends beyond getting the technology right. It must include ensuring these systems are secure, trusted, and protect the rights of all users. Safeguards should not be optional. They are essential to the acceptance and success of digital public infrastructure globally. People need to be empowered and free to shape their own lives. That’s the fundamental basis for 21st century development. And together, we are not just updating systems, we are programming a future – a digital ecosystem that will enable every individual to thrive in this interconnected world that is already here. Thank you for giving me a couple of minutes to share these thoughts with you. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you so much. And now let’s welcome Esther Dweck, Her Excellency, Minister for Management and Innovation and Public Services of Brazil. Thank you, Esther. Thank you.

Esther Dweck: It’s an honor to participate in this session. In Brazil, we believe the future must be green and inclusive, driven by a fair digital revolution. The digital agenda is essential to development, addressing systemic inequality, including the technological ones. Brazil is committed to a triple transition – ecological, digital, and social – reducing inequalities both within and between countries. Brazil’s digital policies are aligned with the SDGs, and we are increasingly considering the environmental impact of digitalization. Under President Lula’s leadership, digital public infrastructures are key to Brazil’s digital transformation, ensuring sustainable, just, and inclusive development. We believe DPIs should be implemented with proper and universal safeguards, built through participatory processes to ensure that they are safe and inclusive and protect people’s rights. A prime example is our National Identity Card, linked to the gov.br platform, which provides access to over 4,000 public services for more than 160 million users. Other DPIs include PICS, our instant payment system that enhances financial inclusion, and the UNIFI Register for Social Policies, which improves social program management and access. The National Health Data Network ensures continuity of care through data sharing between public and private health care providers. The Rural Environmental Registry is a green DPI that supports environmental efforts such as reducing deforestation, restoring forests, implementing agriculture traceability, and fostering carbon markets. It plays a crucial role in a rural financial instrument such as credit and insurance, protecting biomes, increasing agriculture resilience, and will be a central at COP30 in Belém next year. Brazil is also advancing DPI for artificial intelligence, taking into account digital sovereignty. Achieving this requires a collaborative across government, especially those of the global south, civil society, the private sector, and multilateral organizations. Our National AI Plan includes developing an autonomous capacity in the field and launching a Portuguese-language LLM which respects intellectual property rights and cultural heritage, promoting AI in health care, education, and transportation. We emphasize open innovation, competition, and protection of human rights to prevent monopolies that stifle innovation. As we continue our presidency of G20 and prepare for COP30 and BRICS leadership, Brazil reaffirms its commitment to promote an inclusive DPI to foster a fair and equal digital future. Last year, we brought here a perspective on Brazil’s DPIs. After a year, we are here returning to collaborate with our global voices, seeking to promote digital inclusion, digital public infrastructure, digital public goods, and other strategies to foster an equitable planet. Together, we must act now for a sustainable, inclusive digital future. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Thank you so much, Your Excellency. Thank you very much. Okay. Remember that art piece we said we were going to work on? You’re supposed to do the survey? Well, now we’ve got it. We’ve got Lisa Russell back. Come on, Lisa.

Lisa Russell: All right. Thank you so much.

Sade Baderinwa: Okay. So, tell everyone what you did, how you did it, and take it away.

Lisa Russell: So, as you know, we collected information from the surveys, and we generated AI art using only a keyboard. There are no cameras, no microphones, no graphic pens. And this is the beauty of AI art in labeling people across the world to have access to creating artwork for people and for the planet. And so, I’m really excited to share with you the images that were generated using the data from the survey. Every answer, there are six answers, every answer corresponds with a different color of the SDG, and we synthesized the data, fed it some prompts, some creative prompts, and here are some of the images that we have generated using the Digital Futures Survey. So, if we can go ahead and show these images. And that is our official video. I believe there are three more images we’re going to show, I believe. So, this was all generated using, see all the colors in it? Those colors correspond to your answers in the digital survey. And this is the kind of artwork that we can create. And again, this is why we need an arts movement in the UN. We need artists to be able to help translate and amplify the incredible and important work being done in these spaces. This is just a small example. And I’m hoping, and I want to train every advocate for climate change, for sustainability, on how to translate their important work in art so that we can move audiences, move more general audiences. So I believe, are we showing the other images or? I think we are not showing the other images. So thank you so much.

Sade Baderinwa: Well, I’ll have to say, I think this is beautiful.

Lisa Russell: Yes, thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: This is beautiful. But, you know, it really is important. First of all, I love artists because it’s like you’re the soul of who we are and interpreting what that soul is. So if people are interested in learning more, certainly from all of these agencies, they can contact you?

Lisa Russell: Yes. Arts Envoy Lab is my program. I’m with Create 2030, and I am dying to teach young advocates on how to use creative AI. So definitely please get in touch with me. I’d appreciate it. ArtsEnvoyLab.com. Thank you.

Sade Baderinwa: Love it. Thank you, Lisa. And I’m going to contact you. Okay. Well, that wraps it up for our morning session. Thank you so much. And it was a pleasure being here with all of you today. So have some lunch, enjoy, network with different people here, and then the afternoon session will begin around 2.30. Thank you again, and I hope you enjoyed yourself.

M

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

Speech speed

131 words per minute

Speech length

583 words

Speech time

266 seconds

Connecting 2.6 billion unconnected people is crucial

Explanation

Joosub emphasizes the importance of connecting the 2.6 billion people who are currently unconnected to the internet. He argues that this is a critical step in bridging the digital divide and ensuring equal access to digital opportunities.

Evidence

Vodafone and partners are investing in expanding networks and exploring new technologies like satellite-based networks to reach unconnected populations.

Major Discussion Point

Universal Digital Connectivity

Agreed with

Jessica Rosenworcel

Juan Lavista Ferres

David Sapolsky

Agreed on

Universal digital connectivity is crucial for development

Disagreed with

Jessica Rosenworcel

David Sapolsky

Disagreed on

Approach to bridging the digital divide

J

Jessica Rosenworcel

Speech speed

134 words per minute

Speech length

644 words

Speech time

288 seconds

Satellite-to-cell phone communications can end mobile dead zones

Explanation

Rosenworcel argues that satellite-to-cell phone communications technology can eliminate mobile dead zones. This technology allows for connectivity in areas where traditional ground-based networks are unavailable or have been disrupted.

Evidence

She cites an example from Hawaii where satellite-to-cell phone technology helped save lives during a wildfire when terrestrial networks were knocked out.

Major Discussion Point

Universal Digital Connectivity

Agreed with

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

Juan Lavista Ferres

David Sapolsky

Agreed on

Universal digital connectivity is crucial for development

Disagreed with

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

David Sapolsky

Disagreed on

Approach to bridging the digital divide

J

Juan Lavista Ferres

Speech speed

136 words per minute

Speech length

402 words

Speech time

177 seconds

AI and satellite imagery can map population shifts to target connectivity efforts

Explanation

Ferres explains how AI and satellite imagery can be used to create high-resolution maps of population shifts over time. This technology helps identify communities that remain disconnected from communication channels, allowing for more targeted connectivity efforts.

Evidence

Microsoft is partnering with Planet Labs and the Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation to create these maps, which can inform infrastructure investment decisions.

Major Discussion Point

Universal Digital Connectivity

Agreed with

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

Jessica Rosenworcel

David Sapolsky

Agreed on

Universal digital connectivity is crucial for development

D

David Sapolsky

Speech speed

150 words per minute

Speech length

482 words

Speech time

191 seconds

Project Kuiper aims to provide affordable global satellite broadband

Explanation

Sapolsky introduces Project Kuiper, Amazon’s satellite broadband initiative. The project aims to deliver affordable, high-performance connectivity to unserved and underserved communities worldwide using a constellation of low-Earth-orbit satellites.

Evidence

Project Kuiper plans to use over 3,200 low-Earth-orbit satellites to provide internet access with sufficient speeds for modern critical services like video conferencing and telehealth.

Major Discussion Point

Universal Digital Connectivity

Agreed with

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

Jessica Rosenworcel

Juan Lavista Ferres

Agreed on

Universal digital connectivity is crucial for development

Disagreed with

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

Jessica Rosenworcel

Disagreed on

Approach to bridging the digital divide

T

Tofara L. Chokera

Speech speed

122 words per minute

Speech length

363 words

Speech time

178 seconds

Digital skills training is essential for economic empowerment, especially for women and youth

Explanation

Chokera emphasizes the importance of digital skills training for economic empowerment, particularly for women and youth. She argues that providing digital skills enables individuals to participate in the digital economy and access new opportunities.

Evidence

Through the Digital Skills Development Program, Chokera’s organization has empowered over 12,000 women, youth, and SMEs across Zimbabwe and Africa with digital skills for international trade.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Inclusion and Skills

Agreed with

Lazarus Chakwera

Christopher Burns

Agreed on

Digital skills training is essential for economic empowerment

M

Mats Granryd

Speech speed

150 words per minute

Speech length

518 words

Speech time

206 seconds

Affordable smartphones are key to bridging the digital divide

Explanation

Granryd argues that the high cost of smartphones is a major barrier to digital inclusion. He emphasizes the need to bring down the cost of devices to around $20 to make them accessible to more people in developing countries.

Evidence

GSMA has established a handset affordability coalition to work on reducing handset costs and improving financing options for smartphone purchases.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Inclusion and Skills

L

Lazarus Chakwera

Speech speed

115 words per minute

Speech length

720 words

Speech time

372 seconds

Digital literacy must be integrated into national education curricula

Explanation

President Chakwera emphasizes the importance of integrating digital literacy into national education curricula. He argues that this is essential for full participation in the digital economy and for preparing the workforce of the future.

Evidence

Malawi is integrating digital literacy into its national education curricula and providing training opportunities for all age groups. The country has also established technology hubs that are training thousands of young people in coding, digital skills, and entrepreneurship.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Inclusion and Skills

Agreed with

Tofara L. Chokera

Christopher Burns

Agreed on

Digital skills training is essential for economic empowerment

C

Christopher Burns

Speech speed

173 words per minute

Speech length

551 words

Speech time

190 seconds

The Responsible Computing Challenge aims to embed ethics in tech education

Explanation

Burns introduces the Responsible Computing Challenge, an initiative to reshape how future technologists are trained. The challenge aims to embed responsibility and ethics into the core of technology and computer science curricula, especially for young women and girls.

Evidence

The challenge is being implemented in universities in the U.S., Kenya, and India, with plans to expand to South Africa and Ghana. It focuses on teaching students to consider the full impacts of their products and services.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Inclusion and Skills

Agreed with

Tofara L. Chokera

Lazarus Chakwera

Agreed on

Digital skills training is essential for economic empowerment

K

Karan Bhatia

Speech speed

145 words per minute

Speech length

538 words

Speech time

221 seconds

AI can be used for early flood warnings and disaster preparedness

Explanation

Bhatia highlights how AI can be used to predict and mitigate natural disasters. He specifically mentions Google’s Flood Hub, an AI-powered flood forecasting tool that can predict flood zones up to a week in advance.

Evidence

Google’s Flood Hub is live in 80 countries, reaching more than 460 million people around the world.

Major Discussion Point

AI for Sustainable Development

Agreed with

Valentino Valentini

Achim Steiner

Rumman Chowdhury

Agreed on

AI can be leveraged for sustainable development

V

Valentino Valentini

Speech speed

140 words per minute

Speech length

455 words

Speech time

194 seconds

AI Hub for Sustainable Development focuses on data, computing power, talent, and ecosystems

Explanation

Valentini introduces the AI Hub for Sustainable Development, an initiative co-designed by Italy’s G7 Presidency and UNDP. The hub aims to leverage AI for sustainable development, focusing on four critical pillars: data, computing power, talent, and enabling ecosystems.

Evidence

The initiative has engaged with over 100 stakeholders, 300 AI startups across Africa, and initiated 80 partnerships focused on local language digitization.

Major Discussion Point

AI for Sustainable Development

Agreed with

Karan Bhatia

Achim Steiner

Rumman Chowdhury

Agreed on

AI can be leveraged for sustainable development

A

Achim Steiner

Speech speed

148 words per minute

Speech length

2059 words

Speech time

832 seconds

AI must be developed with safeguards to prevent exclusion and protect rights

Explanation

Steiner emphasizes the need for safeguards in AI development to prevent exclusion and protect individual rights. He argues that these safeguards should be an essential part of digital public infrastructure, not an optional add-on.

Major Discussion Point

AI for Sustainable Development

Agreed with

Karan Bhatia

Valentino Valentini

Rumman Chowdhury

Agreed on

AI can be leveraged for sustainable development

DPI requires commitment, capital, and capacity building

Explanation

Steiner argues that successful implementation of Digital Public Infrastructure requires three essential pillars: commitment from governments, capital investment, and capacity building. He emphasizes that these elements are crucial for ensuring that DPI is inclusive, safe, and equitable.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI)

R

Rumman Chowdhury

Speech speed

174 words per minute

Speech length

117 words

Speech time

40 seconds

Evaluating AI systems for cultural appropriateness is crucial

Explanation

Chowdhury argues for the importance of evaluating AI systems for cultural appropriateness and potential biases. She emphasizes that AI models are often not fit for use across different cultures and languages, and can produce stereotypical or degrading content.

Evidence

Chowdhury’s nonprofit, Humane Intelligence, focuses on giving people worldwide the ability to evaluate AI systems, not just build them.

Major Discussion Point

AI for Sustainable Development

Agreed with

Karan Bhatia

Valentino Valentini

Achim Steiner

Agreed on

AI can be leveraged for sustainable development

E

Esther Dweck

Speech speed

128 words per minute

Speech length

420 words

Speech time

196 seconds

DPI enables efficient government services and financial inclusion

Explanation

Dweck highlights how Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) can improve government service delivery and promote financial inclusion. She argues that DPI is key to Brazil’s digital transformation strategy.

Evidence

Brazil’s National Identity Card, linked to the gov.br platform, provides access to over 4,000 public services for more than 160 million users. The PICS instant payment system enhances financial inclusion.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI)

DPI must be implemented with proper safeguards and participatory processes

Explanation

Dweck emphasizes the importance of implementing DPI with proper safeguards and through participatory processes. This approach ensures that DPI is safe, inclusive, and protects people’s rights.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI)

DPI can support environmental efforts like reducing deforestation

Explanation

Dweck explains how DPI can be used to support environmental initiatives. She highlights Brazil’s Rural Environmental Registry as an example of a ‘green DPI’ that aids in efforts to reduce deforestation and restore forests.

Evidence

The Rural Environmental Registry supports environmental efforts such as reducing deforestation, restoring forests, implementing agriculture traceability, and fostering carbon markets.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI)

B

Bianca Faith Johnson

Speech speed

173 words per minute

Speech length

486 words

Speech time

167 seconds

Exoskeleton technology can restore mobility for paralyzed individuals

Explanation

Johnson demonstrates how exoskeleton technology can help paralyzed individuals regain mobility. She argues that this technology has the potential to significantly improve quality of life for people with spinal cord injuries.

Evidence

Johnson, who is paralyzed from mid-chest down, demonstrates walking using a self-balancing exoskeleton prototype developed by Wondercraft.

Major Discussion Point

Technology for Social Impact

K

Kelly T. Clements

Speech speed

148 words per minute

Speech length

665 words

Speech time

268 seconds

Blockchain-based digital wallets can provide rapid financial aid to refugees

Explanation

Clements explains how blockchain-based digital wallets can be used to provide quick financial assistance to refugees. This technology allows for faster, more efficient distribution of aid in crisis situations.

Evidence

She cites an example from Ukraine where a family received cash aid through a digital wallet within 15 minutes of registering with UNHCR.

Major Discussion Point

Technology for Social Impact

A

Ann Aerts

Speech speed

138 words per minute

Speech length

499 words

Speech time

216 seconds

AI and digital tools can improve healthcare outcomes and reduce inequalities

Explanation

Aerts argues that AI and digital tools have the potential to significantly improve healthcare outcomes and reduce health inequalities. She emphasizes the importance of understanding and addressing the social determinants of health through data analysis.

Evidence

The Novartis Foundation’s AI for Healthy Cities initiative uses data analytics to understand the true drivers of health and health inequities in cities like New York, Singapore, Helsinki, and Basel.

Major Discussion Point

Technology for Social Impact

Z

Zhiping Chen

Speech speed

89 words per minute

Speech length

323 words

Speech time

216 seconds

Digital technologies can protect endangered species in remote areas

Explanation

Chen discusses how digital technologies, particularly 5G networks, can be used to protect endangered species in remote areas. She argues that these technologies enable better monitoring and conservation efforts in previously inaccessible regions.

Evidence

ZTE built the first 5G base station in Cocoshilli, a remote UNESCO World Heritage site, allowing for real-time observation and live streaming of Tibetan antelope migration.

Major Discussion Point

Technology for Social Impact

Agreements

Agreement Points

Universal digital connectivity is crucial for development

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

Jessica Rosenworcel

Juan Lavista Ferres

David Sapolsky

Connecting 2.6 billion unconnected people is crucial

Satellite-to-cell phone communications can end mobile dead zones

AI and satellite imagery can map population shifts to target connectivity efforts

Project Kuiper aims to provide affordable global satellite broadband

These speakers agree on the importance of expanding digital connectivity to unconnected populations, emphasizing various technological solutions including satellite communications and AI-driven mapping.

Digital skills training is essential for economic empowerment

Tofara L. Chokera

Lazarus Chakwera

Christopher Burns

Digital skills training is essential for economic empowerment, especially for women and youth

Digital literacy must be integrated into national education curricula

The Responsible Computing Challenge aims to embed ethics in tech education

These speakers emphasize the importance of digital skills training and education, particularly for youth and underserved populations, to ensure participation in the digital economy and responsible use of technology.

AI can be leveraged for sustainable development

Karan Bhatia

Valentino Valentini

Achim Steiner

Rumman Chowdhury

AI can be used for early flood warnings and disaster preparedness

AI Hub for Sustainable Development focuses on data, computing power, talent, and ecosystems

AI must be developed with safeguards to prevent exclusion and protect rights

Evaluating AI systems for cultural appropriateness is crucial

These speakers agree on the potential of AI to address sustainable development challenges, while also emphasizing the need for responsible development and evaluation of AI systems.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasize the importance of Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) for development, while stressing the need for proper implementation with safeguards and capacity building.

Esther Dweck

Achim Steiner

DPI enables efficient government services and financial inclusion

DPI must be implemented with proper safeguards and participatory processes

DPI requires commitment, capital, and capacity building

Unexpected Consensus

Technology for social impact across diverse fields

Bianca Faith Johnson

Kelly T. Clements

Ann Aerts

Zhiping Chen

Exoskeleton technology can restore mobility for paralyzed individuals

Blockchain-based digital wallets can provide rapid financial aid to refugees

AI and digital tools can improve healthcare outcomes and reduce inequalities

Digital technologies can protect endangered species in remote areas

Despite coming from diverse fields (healthcare, refugee aid, conservation), these speakers unexpectedly converge on the potential of various technologies to create significant social impact in their respective areas.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement include the importance of universal digital connectivity, the need for digital skills training, the potential of AI for sustainable development, and the role of Digital Public Infrastructure in development.

Consensus level

There is a high level of consensus among the speakers on the transformative potential of digital technologies for development and social impact. This consensus implies a strong foundation for collaborative efforts in leveraging technology for global development goals. However, speakers also consistently emphasize the need for responsible implementation, including safeguards and capacity building, suggesting a nuanced approach to technological adoption.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Approach to bridging the digital divide

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

Jessica Rosenworcel

David Sapolsky

Connecting 2.6 billion unconnected people is crucial

Satellite-to-cell phone communications can end mobile dead zones

Project Kuiper aims to provide affordable global satellite broadband

While all speakers agree on the importance of connecting the unconnected, they propose different technological solutions: expanding traditional networks, satellite-to-cell phone communications, and low-Earth-orbit satellite broadband.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around the specific technological approaches to achieve universal connectivity and digital inclusion.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among speakers is relatively low. Most speakers agree on the overall goals of digital inclusion and leveraging technology for sustainable development. The differences mainly lie in the specific approaches or focus areas each speaker emphasizes. This level of disagreement is not likely to hinder progress towards the shared goals, but rather encourages a diverse range of solutions to address the complex challenges of digital transformation.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

Both speakers agree on the importance of digital inclusion, but Granryd focuses on hardware affordability while Burns emphasizes the need for ethical education in technology.

Mats Granryd

Christopher Burns

Affordable smartphones are key to bridging the digital divide

The Responsible Computing Challenge aims to embed ethics in tech education

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasize the importance of Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) for development, while stressing the need for proper implementation with safeguards and capacity building.

Esther Dweck

Achim Steiner

DPI enables efficient government services and financial inclusion

DPI must be implemented with proper safeguards and participatory processes

DPI requires commitment, capital, and capacity building

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

Universal digital connectivity is crucial, with 2.6 billion people still unconnected

Digital inclusion requires both infrastructure and skills development, especially for underserved populations

AI and digital technologies have significant potential for sustainable development and social impact

Digital public infrastructure (DPI) is essential for efficient government services and financial inclusion, but must be implemented with proper safeguards

Emerging technologies like exoskeletons, blockchain, and AI can address critical social and environmental challenges

Resolutions and Action Items

Expand satellite-based internet connectivity to reach unconnected populations

Integrate digital literacy into national education curricula

Develop AI solutions for disaster preparedness and environmental protection

Implement digital public infrastructure with safeguards to protect rights and prevent exclusion

Increase investment in digital skills training, especially for women and youth

Create partnerships between governments, private sector, and civil society to advance digital inclusion

Unresolved Issues

How to ensure AI development benefits the Global South and doesn’t exacerbate existing inequalities

Balancing rapid technological advancement with necessary regulatory frameworks and ethical considerations

Addressing potential job displacement due to AI and automation in developing countries

Ensuring data privacy and security in the implementation of digital public infrastructure

How to make cutting-edge technologies like exoskeletons widely accessible and affordable

Suggested Compromises

Collaborate across sectors and countries to develop inclusive AI solutions that respect local contexts

Balance rapid digital transformation with careful implementation of safeguards and regulations

Invest in both digital infrastructure and skills development simultaneously to ensure meaningful connectivity

Develop open-source and affordable technologies to make digital solutions more accessible to developing countries

Thought Provoking Comments

Can we harness this technology beyond war zones and natural disasters? Can we finally close the digital divide?

Speaker

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

Reason

This rhetorical question challenges participants to think bigger about applying emergency connectivity solutions to everyday life.

Impact

It shifted the conversation from reactive emergency measures to proactive, widespread connectivity initiatives.

Satellite-to-cell phone communications is a game-changer. By combining space-based networks and terrestrial wireless networks, both can accomplish more together than either can do on its own.

Speaker

Jessica Rosenworcel

Reason

This insight highlights a innovative technological approach to bridging the digital divide.

Impact

It introduced a new dimension to the connectivity discussion, prompting consideration of hybrid terrestrial-satellite solutions.

We need to focus on creating an environment where the basics of technology are met so that quantum technologies can be used to benefit all.

Speaker

Emma Theophilus

Reason

This comment emphasizes the importance of foundational digital infrastructure before pursuing advanced technologies.

Impact

It grounded the discussion in practical realities while still maintaining a vision for future technological advancements.

To fully realise digital transformation in the public sector could unlock over $3.5 trillion annually, according to a study by McKinsey. Yet, despite significant investments, 70% of civil servants still lack digital capabilities.

Speaker

Tawfik Jelassi

Reason

This comment provides concrete data on both the potential benefits and current challenges of digital transformation in government.

Impact

It shifted the focus to the importance of digital skills training and capacity building in the public sector.

As we lay the foundations of a digital future, we must ensure that this future is equitable, inclusive, and peaceful.

Speaker

Lazarus Chakwera

Reason

This statement emphasizes the ethical imperatives alongside technological progress.

Impact

It broadened the discussion beyond technical solutions to include social and ethical considerations in digital development.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by consistently emphasizing the dual challenges of expanding digital access and ensuring that access is equitable, inclusive, and beneficial to all. The speakers moved from identifying the scale of the problem to proposing innovative technological solutions, while also highlighting the need for policy frameworks, skills development, and ethical considerations. This created a comprehensive dialogue that addressed both the technical and human aspects of creating a digital future for all.

2.6 billion people are unconnected. a digital future for all can only be possible if access to connectivity is universal and affordable.

Speaker

Sade Baderinwa

Reason

This comment frames the central challenge and goal of the entire discussion, highlighting the massive scale of the digital divide.

Impact

It set the tone for the subsequent speakers to address how to overcome this divide through various technological and policy solutions.

Follow-up Questions

How can we ensure AI reaches and serves the global South?

Speaker

Brad Smith

Explanation

This is crucial to prevent the digital divide from becoming an AI divide and to ensure equitable access to AI’s benefits globally.

How can we create strong collaborations to reach everyone, everywhere with digital technologies?

Speaker

Achim Steiner

Explanation

Collaboration is essential to ensure universal access to digital technologies and their benefits.

How can we lower the cost of smartphones to under $20 in the least-developed countries?

Speaker

Mohamed Shameel Aziz Joosub

Explanation

Affordable devices are crucial for bridging the digital divide and enabling access to digital services.

How can we ensure proper safeguards are in place for digital public infrastructure?

Speaker

Achim Steiner

Explanation

Safeguards are essential to protect user rights, ensure inclusivity, and build trust in digital systems.

How can we integrate responsible computing into technology and computer science curricula globally?

Speaker

Christopher Burns

Explanation

This is important to ensure future technologists consider the full impacts of their products and services on society.

How can we address the potential job displacement and inequality caused by AI in the global South?

Speaker

Robert Muggah

Explanation

This is crucial to mitigate the negative impacts of AI on employment and economic inequality in developing countries.

How can we ensure everyone has the ability to evaluate AI systems for their specific contexts and needs?

Speaker

Rumman Chowdhury

Explanation

This is important to ensure AI systems are appropriate and beneficial for diverse global contexts and cultures.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

Saturday Opening Ceremony: Summit of the Future Action Days

Saturday Opening Ceremony: Summit of the Future Action Days

Session at a Glance

Summary

This discussion focused on the Declaration on Future Generations, a key component of the upcoming Summit of the Future at the United Nations. The opening ceremony featured speeches from UN Secretary-General António Guterres and other leaders, emphasizing the importance of inclusive multilateralism and addressing global challenges like climate change, inequality, and conflict. A panel of experts then explored the potential impact of the Declaration and ways to implement its goals.

Key themes included the need to consider long-term consequences of current decisions, incorporate diverse perspectives (especially from youth and indigenous communities), and reform global financial and governance systems to better serve future generations. Panelists highlighted specific actions governments could take, such as focusing on competitive economic sectors, bridging local and global concerns, and fostering social connections across generations.

The discussion underscored the interconnectedness of past, present, and future in addressing global issues. Participants stressed the importance of civil society pressure on governments and the need for wealthier nations to support climate adaptation in vulnerable countries. The conversation also touched on innovative approaches, such as using legal systems to advance intergenerational equity and rethinking economic models to benefit future Africans.

Overall, the discussion emphasized the transformative potential of the Declaration on Future Generations, while acknowledging the challenges in translating its principles into concrete action. Participants called for continued engagement from diverse stakeholders to ensure the Declaration leads to meaningful change in global governance and decision-making.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– The Declaration on Future Generations and its potential to transform global decision-making to consider long-term impacts

– The need for concrete actions and implementation to give life to the declaration’s principles

– The importance of including diverse voices, especially from youth, indigenous communities, and developing countries

– Economic opportunities and challenges in building a sustainable future, particularly for Africa

– The role of civil society in pressuring governments and driving change

Overall purpose:

The discussion aimed to build momentum and gather diverse perspectives on how to effectively implement the Declaration on Future Generations, which will be adopted at the upcoming Summit of the Future. Speakers explored ways to translate the declaration’s principles into meaningful action across sectors and regions.

Tone:

The tone was largely optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers expressing hope about the potential for positive change. However, there were also notes of urgency and concern about the scale of challenges facing future generations. The tone became more action-oriented as speakers discussed specific steps needed to realize the declaration’s goals.

Speakers

Speakers:

– Folly Bah Thibault – Journalist and global champion for Education Cannot Wait, served as host/moderator

– António Guterres – UN Secretary-General

– Matthew Dominick – NASA astronaut

– Jeanette Epps – NASA astronaut

– Astronauts from China Space Station (unnamed)

– Carole Osero-Ageng’o – Co-chair of UN Civil Society Conference

– Oli Henman – Co-chair of Coordination Mechanism of Major Groups and other stakeholders

– Saumya Aggarwal – Co-founder of Youth for Peace International

– Andrew Holness – Prime Minister of Jamaica

– Evelyn Wever-Croes – Prime Minister of Aruba

Panel discussion participants:

– Thomas Hale (Moderator) – Professor of global public policy at University of Oxford

– Hina Jilani – Lawyer, human rights defender, member of the Elders

– Abdullahi Alim – CEO of Africa Future Fund

– Paolo Baca – Deputy Director of De Justicia

Areas of expertise:

– Folly Bah Thibault: Journalism, education advocacy

– António Guterres: International diplomacy, UN leadership

– Astronauts: Space exploration, international cooperation

– Carole Osero-Ageng’o & Oli Henman: Civil society engagement, stakeholder coordination

– Saumya Aggarwal: Youth advocacy, peacebuilding

– Andrew Holness & Evelyn Wever-Croes: Government leadership, international relations

– Thomas Hale: Global public policy, long-term governance challenges

– Hina Jilani: Human rights law, civil society advocacy

– Abdullahi Alim: African economic development, future-oriented investment

– Paolo Baca: Indigenous rights, environmental law

Full session report

Expanded Summary of Discussion on the Declaration on Future Generations

Introduction

This discussion focused on the Declaration on Future Generations, a key component of the upcoming Summit of the Future at the United Nations. The event featured an opening ceremony with speeches from UN Secretary-General António Guterres and other leaders, followed by a panel discussion moderated by Thomas Hale, exploring the potential impact of the Declaration and ways to implement its goals.

Opening Ceremony

UN Secretary-General António Guterres emphasized the need for intergenerational solidarity and responsibility in addressing global challenges. He called for more inclusive multilateralism, greater representation of developing countries, and reforms to international financial institutions.

Andrew Holness, Prime Minister of Jamaica, stressed the importance of embedding futures thinking in decision-making processes. He outlined key components of the Declaration, including its purpose to safeguard the interests of future generations and promote long-term thinking in governance.

Evelyn Wever-Croes, Prime Minister of Aruba, further elaborated on the Declaration’s aims to ensure that present actions do not compromise the well-being of future generations.

Panel Discussion

1. Youth Perspective – Saumya Aggarwal, Youth for Peace International

Aggarwal advocated for meaningful youth participation in policymaking and investing in youth-led solutions. She presented specific recommendations from the Youth Action Day, including:

– Establishing a UN Youth Office

– Creating a UN Special Envoy for Future Generations

– Implementing a Global Citizens’ Assembly

2. Indigenous and Global South Perspective – Paolo Baca, Deputy Director of De Justicia

Baca offered insights on time from Andean indigenous cultures, challenging Western assumptions about intergenerational relationships. He discussed a Colombian court case granting rights to future generations, highlighting its outcomes and implementation challenges.

3. African Perspective – Abdullahi Alim, CEO of Africa Future Fund

Alim provided context on demographic shifts in Africa, noting that “One billion Africans will be born in the next generation alone.” He outlined the Africa Future Fund’s goals, including:

– Restructuring debt measurement and management for African countries

– Focusing on competitive economic sectors to drive growth

– Leveraging Africa’s demographic dividend for sustainable development

4. Human Rights and Civil Society – Hina Jilani, Lawyer and Human Rights Defender

Jilani emphasized the disproportionate impact of climate change on vulnerable communities and the need to compensate developing countries. She stressed the importance of:

– Civil society pressure on governments to drive change

– Developing plans for socially connected communities

– Strengthening UN human rights mechanisms

She also referenced an intergenerational call to action issued by the Elders.

5. Civil Society Engagement – Carole Osero-Ageng’o, Co-chair of UN Civil Society Conference

Osero-Ageng’o stressed the importance of intergenerational dialogue and collaboration in addressing global challenges.

6. UN System Reform – Oli Henman, Co-chair of Major Groups Coordination Mechanism

Henman emphasized the need to strengthen UN human rights mechanisms and reform global governance structures to better serve future generations.

Key Themes and Outcomes

1. Intergenerational Solidarity and Long-term Thinking

2. Inclusive Multilateralism and Diverse Perspectives

3. Global Challenges and Opportunities, particularly climate change and demographic shifts

4. Reforming Global Financial and Governance Systems

5. Role of Civil Society and Community Building

Concrete Actions Proposed

– Appointing a UN Special Envoy for Future Generations

– Establishing a UN Youth Office

– Implementing a Global Citizens’ Assembly

– Developing plans for socially connected communities

– Restructuring debt measurement for African countries

– Providing compensation and resources to developing countries facing climate impacts

Conclusion and Next Steps

The discussion concluded with a sense of optimism about the potential for positive change, tempered by an acknowledgment of the urgent challenges facing future generations. An upcoming forum was announced to check on progress in implementing the Declaration. The Summit of the Future Action Days was mentioned as a platform for continued engagement and action.

A visual scribe created a summary of the session, capturing key points and themes graphically.

As the event concluded, it was clear that while the Declaration on Future Generations offers transformative potential, translating its principles into concrete action will require ongoing effort, collaboration, and innovative thinking across sectors and regions.

Session Transcript

Folly Bah Thibault: summit of the future action days. Yes! I love the energy already. Loving the energy. My name is Folly Bah Thibault, a journalist and global champion for Education Cannot Wait, the United Nations Education Fund for Emergencies and Protected Crises. I’m thrilled to be your host this morning as we gather here in New York to reimagine how we can all work together to address the opportunities and challenges of our time. Now on day one of the action days Friday, we saw what meaningful youth engagement looks like in practice in shaping our common future. We heard from youth leaders about the importance of cross-generational collaboration to create lasting solutions on crucial issues like climate change, gender equity, and women and girls empowerment. We’ll hear more about their recommendations from the youth rapporteur who will be joining us on stage in just a few moments. In today’s sessions, we are bringing together a broad and diverse set of global leaders and actors from all across sectors. They’ll share their ideas and experiences on how to advance on critical themes including digital and technology, peace and security, and sustainable development and financing. In addition to those themes, we’ll have a dedicated focus throughout the day on future generations. Throughout this opening ceremony, ladies and gentlemen, we’ll also have a visual scribe working in the background to create a visual summary of this session so you won’t miss anything at the end of the day. But first, to open this exciting day, it’s my pleasure and honor to welcome the United Nations Secretary-General, His Excellency António Guterres.

António Guterres: Excellencies, dear friends, all protocol observed. Welcome to the summit of the Future Action Days, which kicked off yesterday with a youth-led afternoon. A day full of ideas, energy, hope and expectation, and a perfect reminder of why we are here. Today promises to be just as dynamic. Looking out, I see world leaders, I see mayors and legislators, I see civil society, the private sector, academics, artists, activists and young people. You come from every corner of the world, every generation and every walk of life. Friends, this is what effective, inclusive, networked multilateralism must look like. Four years ago, we began the process that brings us here today. And because we saw a world in trouble, torn apart by conflict and inequalities, threatened by climate chaos and unregulated technologies, with the Sustainable Development Goals in peril, with many countries now mirrored in disastrous debt and the cost of living crisis. We saw our multilateral institutions ailing, unable to respond to contemporary challenges, let alone those of tomorrow. We saw faith in multilateral solutions eroding. And we saw trust in each other dissipating just when we needed it most. So we began a journey to reform, to renew the international system, so that it meets the moment and is fit for the future. We need multilateralism that is more inclusive, more effective and more networked, with stronger links between international institutions and with the people. That means greater representation in developing countries, and it means a stronger voice for all of you and what you represent. This ambition was rooted in some clear truth. The world belongs to us all. People want a say in the decisions that affect them. And while governments have primary responsibility that we do not deny, we will not solve today’s global problems without contributions from all of society, from civil society and young people, delivering change, promoting accountability, demanding better standing up for truth and justice, and using new technologies to organize for a better world. From business and finance, critical to combating the climate crisis and shaping our digital future for the benefit of all. From scientists, innovators and academics, pushing the boundaries of our knowledge and developing solutions to the great challenges that we face, from hunger and disease to online aid. Dear friends, over the past four years, the people in this room and your colleagues around the world participated in the most consultative process ever undertaken by the United Nations. We have seen a total of 1.5 million people, from every one of our member states, involved in discussions and consultations everywhere. Hundreds of civil society groups in putting into the Pact for the Future the Global Digital Compact and the Declaration on Future Generations and thousands of written contributions. Together, you have pushed for vision ambition and I thank you for that. We have now three milestone texts that are on the table which must open the door to changes our world in a way that it desperately needs. The pact for the future must lay the ground for reform. Reform of the outdated United Nations Security Council to make it more effective but also more representative of what the world is today. Reform of our international financial institutions so that they supercharge resources for sustainable development and for climate action. Reforms of the rules governing outer space currently a chaotic free-for-all and reform how we respond to complex global shocks and work together on peace and security. On the other hand the Global Digital Compact must be a blueprint for closing digital divides and the first universal agreement on artificial intelligence laying the foundations for a global platform centered at the UN that can bring all actors together. The Declaration on Future Generations must commit leaders to take tomorrow into account as they make decisions today and gender equality and human rights must weave through every aspect of those texts reflecting the fact that they are fundamental to every area of life. Excellences, friends, the issues at the heart of these texts justice, rights, peace and equality have animated my work for decades driving me forward. I know the same is true for many of you. I will not give up. and I know that you won’t either. The adoption of these texts will not be the end of the journey. It will simply be a new beginning. Our next task is to breathe life into these texts, to put words into action, and to use them to set humanity on a better course. Your continued engagement, commitment and pressure will be vital. That work starts with these Action Days. We look forward to hearing your ideas and solutions on what these new frameworks mean for you and how, together, you can help to make them a reality. A renewed multilateralism will not be built in a day or by governments alone. It will be fuelled and carried forward by all of you and the groups that you represent. We have fought for ambition. Now, let’s fight for action together. On behalf of the United Nations, thank you for joining us in this vital task.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you. Now, our next speakers exemplify the essence of international collaboration. There are currently multiple astronauts in space, and we have the privilege to hear from some of them. The crews on board the International Space Station and the Tianyong Space Station orbiting above us are quite literally showing us that global teamwork knows no bounds. Cosmonauts of the Russian Federation on the ISS are currently changing shifts, as you’ll appreciate their safety is of paramount importance. Ladies and gentlemen, let’s now take a giant leap, well, a virtual one at least, into space with this message from astronauts on the International Space Station and the Tianyong Space Station. Take a look.

Matthew Dominick: Greetings from the International Space Station. I’m NASA astronaut Matthew Dominick with my crewmate, Jeanette Epps. International cooperation and collaboration in space are just as critical to our work aboard this international research lab as it is back on Earth.

Jeanette Epps: On the ISS, we do research in microgravity that is not possible on Earth. From our unique vantage point in space, we can better understand our changing planet. NASA’s Earth Science Mission, many implemented with our partnerships around the world, are helping decision makers improve life on Earth, safeguard our future, and help us discover and innovate for the benefit of all.

Matthew Dominick: As you gather this week for the UN General Assembly, we encourage all nations to help assure peaceful, safe, and sustainable space exploration for the benefit of humankind.

China Space Station: We greet everyone from China’s space station. The peaceful use of outer space is a common goal for humanity. In a summit of the future, countries will jointly explore important issues such as multilateralism and international cooperation in the field of space under the framework of the UN, which will have significant impact on global governance of outer space. We feel honored to participate in it. China has always adhered to the peaceful use of outer space. The China Space Station, a landmark project of China’s space industry, officially entered a new stage of application and development in 2023 after two years of on-orbit assembly and construction. The China Space Station belongs not only to China but also to the world. As early as 2019, the Chinese Government opened the utilization resources of China’s Space Station to other countries to ensure that more countries could participate in manned space technology and application research, which was a strong support to the UN 2030 Sustainable Development Goals. We are willing to continue to conduct space exchange and cooperation with other countries and actually promote building a community with a shared future for mankind in the field of outer space based on equality, mutual benefit, peaceful use, and inclusive development. We wish the UN Summit of the Future a complete success. Thank you.

Folly Bah Thibault: Isn’t that just amazing? Amazing. Thank you to the incredible astronauts on board the ISS and the Tiangong Space Station for that out-of-this-world message, as you saw. Only at the UN can you see such great things, right? Their vantage point reminds us that while we may be separated by vast distances, our shared challenges and aspirations unite us all. So thank you once again to the astronauts. Now let’s bring our focus back on Earth. us and turn our attention to two remarkable leaders who are driving positive change within our communities. They have both been instrumental in organizing and facilitating consultations with civil society in the lead-up to the summit of the Future Action Days. First, we are going to hear from Ms. Carole Osero-Ageng’o, who was one of the co-chairs of the UN Civil Society Conference that took place in May in Nairobi. Please give a warm welcome to Carole.

Carole Osero-Ageng’o: Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, as we reflect on the 69th Civil Society Conference, the first in the Global South, and which was in support of the Summit of the Future, three points stand out – connection, convening, and collaboration in an intersectional and intergenerational world, before, during, and after the conference. Excellencies, the nine-week collaboration in planning the conference was a collaborative endeavor, a collaborative endeavor showing the strength and the diversity of civil society and the broad issues of interests of civil society, which we learned we must bring together at all possible junctures, because we do not engage with these issues, one to the exclusion of another. My co-chair, Nudhara Yusuf, and I, in framing the objectives of inclusion, impact, and innovation, asked ourselves, how do we drive impact? How do we catalyze change? Excellencies, in the run-up to the conference, unprecedented rains and resultant floods in Nairobi did not spare the United Nations campus where we were to hold the conference. but it united civil society in support of the victims of the floods in Nairobi, showing the spirit of collaboration and partnership that sits at the foundation of civil society. The outcome package of the conference is now available on the conference website, detailing two days of workshops and impact coalition engagements. The impact coalitions covered broad issues ranging from development, financing for development, AI governance, future generations. The impact coalitions bring together civil society, academia, think tanks, member states and other stakeholders for action-oriented inputs into the summit. The civil society continues to lean into the diversity that defines us, even as we seek to build common ground and move ahead to advance the ambitions of the millions of people around the world who benefit from our actions. We do not always agree, and that is fine. That is diversity. The coming days will see civil society input tap into the existing stakeholder collaboration platforms that work together to put the conference, including the major groups and other stakeholders, coalition for the UN. We need GNEC and Congo to engage in the key reform issues contained in the pact. We, however, seek and will continue to seek greater opportunity for civil society in the UN processes. Excellencies, it is also time to reframe the narrative on aging from a challenge to an opportunity, and we saw this in the intergenerational activities yesterday. Prospective aging of the youth of today calls for envisioning of young people here today as older people of the future, a future consisting also of other young people. The prospect shifts the definition of who is old as life expectancy increases to recognize the many older adults today who are engaged and productive and bring valuable contributions to society. We must recognize and protect their fundamental rights, but we can also harness the knowledge, experience, and innovation of this growing population segment as a resource for future generations. And we are also interconnected and interdependent in our families, communities, and societies, and globally, so we need to seek solutions that work for all of us. I thank you very much.

Folly Bah Thibault: Carole, thank you very much for your remarks. Thank you for your contributions to this summit of the future. Thank you. Next, we’ll hear from Mr. Oli Henman, who’s one of the co-chairs of the Coordination Mechanism of Major Groups and other stakeholders. Oli, welcome to the stage.

Oli Henman: Thank you very much. Excellencies, Secretary-General, ladies and gentlemen, colleagues, and friends. It’s a great honor to speak here today as we face the future together. My name is Oli Henman, and together with Rashima Quatra, I’m one of the co-chairs of the Major Groups and other Stakeholders Coordination Mechanism. This mechanism has been working together since the Rio Earth Summit in 1992 and is recognized under mandate by the General Assembly. Its 21 constituencies are thematic and regional in nature, and these constituencies represent millions of diverse people from around the world. We have engaged over many months in dialogue with the co-facilitators of the key documents of the Summit for the Future, And we are grateful for this regular engagement, including at the Nairobi CSO Conference. Over these Action Days, we are witnessing the energy and dynamism of civil society, the collaboration with a wide range of partners, and fresh ideas from so many diverse groups. We are glad to be here together during the Action Days, but our voice must also be heard at the Summit itself. We cannot be excluded from the opportunity to shape our common future and insist on meaningful inclusion in all UN processes. In terms of the pact for the future and what comes next, we have some key insights based on our shared positions, and I am glad that many other colleagues are here to share their views over these days as well. Firstly, the pact must demonstrate the UN’s values to champion a democratic and rights-based multilateral system, ensuring meaningful participation of all stakeholders. We appreciate the mention of ECOSOC-accredited NGOs and also the specific call for meaningful inclusion of relevant stakeholders. However, we are concerned at attempts to create additional barriers for accreditation. And while we called for greater collaboration with civil society, unfortunately we do not see that in the revised text. We welcome the continued dialogue with Member States, and we commit to engage with a wide range of delegations going forward to ensure a strong exchange of ideas. Secondly, on human rights, we are very glad to see a recommitment to shared principles on the universality of rights. Everyone’s rights must be guaranteed. While in recent years we have witnessed populism and inflammatory language from some political leaders which has led to an us-and-them culture, erosion of rights, and the rollback of hard-fought equalities, massive violations in situations of conflict. In order to guarantee these rights, the UN’s own structures for protection and enhancement of rights must be strengthened. We call for accelerating support for the human rights pillar of the UN and forging clearer links at the country level with resident coordinator teams. Thirdly, we are pleased to see renewed commitment for financing to deliver real change. It is essential that adequate financing is agreed to deliver the SDGs. And in particular, we are glad to see the reference to targeting programs to support those who are being left behind. We believe the pact provides one step along the way, and note that crucial discussions for financing will be taking place next year at the Financing for Development Forum. Fourthly, it is essential that this pact sets out a renewed vision that is built on equity, fairness and trust. We must step back from the brink of catastrophic wars and conflict, and instead direct our energy and resources to a reinvestment in social protection. We therefore look forward to the World Social Summit in 2025 as a key moment to reset priorities and ensure recommitment to people-centered development, accessible and affordable public services and social protection for all. Finally, the pact’s recognition of the need to protect wildlife and ecosystems is a positive step, but we must accelerate efforts to restore biodiversity for the health of our planet and future generations. Climate change imperils us all. We are therefore glad to see the commitment to accelerating action on climate change and scaling up finance for adaptation and prevention of loss and damage. However, these commitments are not compatible with new fossil fuel exploration, and we therefore urge all governments to halt any new oil, gas or coal exploration. The future is in all of our hands. We have it in our collective power to reshape the world for our children and their children. It is essential that we do not go home empty-handed. When I go back home and see my young boys and hear the optimism in their voices, I want to be able to say that yes, the world is listening and change is coming. We cannot contemplate failure. Thank you.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you very much, Ali, for that powerful message. The future is in all of our hands. Ali also talked about the energy in civil society, and I want to hear the energy in this room now. for a better future for all of us. Is there energy? Are we energized? Yes? Are we gonna do it all together? Yes. Thank you very much, Oli, for bringing us the civil society view there. We’re grateful for your contributions. Now, as I mentioned earlier, day one of the Summit of the Future Action Day brought together young people from all over the world to discuss how we can all work together for a better future. And here now to reflect on yesterday’s Youth-Led Action Day is Ms. Saumya Aggarwal, co-founder of the Youth for Peace International, which is an organization dedicated to fostering peace and understanding among youth globally. Saumya, the floor is yours.

Saumya Aggarwal: Excellencies, distinguished guests, and fellow youth. Collectively, the world is significantly behind on the achievements set out in the Sustainable Development Goals and many other global frameworks. Today, young people make over one-third of the world’s population, and youth are creating innovative and sustainable solutions to the problem we are currently facing. However, young people around the world are losing or have lost trust in our governance systems, and we must collectively decide to change our approach and reshape the path forward. We are so excited to start the Summit of the Future with the Youth Action Days. It’s the first time in history that we have dedicated a youth day, and multi-stakeholders have shown genuine interest to learn and listen to us. Young people have been rigorously preparing for the Summit of the Future, and it was refreshing to see that the processes were co-designed and coordinated between UN agencies, youth constituencies, youth-led and youth-focused organizations. Let’s see where we are, because these spaces are only meaningful. when we commit to make a shift and learn. Yesterday was nothing less than inspiring. Youth voices were very loud and clear that they are watching the leaders and the upcoming summit should not be just another international conference. Yesterday, young people alongside policy makers and civil society discussed key recommendations to ensure the implementation of the Pact for the future and beyond. Let me share with you key takeaways that have been highlighted by the young people clustered under the three themes of today’s Action Day. First, on inclusivity for peaceful futures, we need to collaborate with the national coalitions to advance the UNHCR 2250 on youth peace and security commitments and support the efforts of young people and youth-led organizations in the implementation. Allocate flexible, accessible, and sustainable financial support for adolescent-led, youth-led, youth-focused organizations and networks, including for humanitarian action. Strengthen partnerships and dialogue between the youth-led organizations, policy makers, and humanitarian and development actors to ensure youth-driven solutions are recognized, scaled, and sustainable. Address the prevalence of climate and eco-anxiety among youth, which is contributing to a global mental health crisis. Usually we have seen that mental health support is neglected. Recommit to peace, youth protection, and human rights as youth are urging an emergent and permanent ceasefire in all conflict zones. For a digital future, explore potential strategies to mitigate growing digital risk and leverage digital opportunities to build an inclusive, safe, and meaningful digital futures for all. We also need to advocate for youth inclusion in digital and AI policymaking spaces, discuss current and future implications of emerging digital technologies with the focus on the consequences for young people, and explore mechanisms that protect the youth from digital harm. And finally, if we want to ensure sustainable futures, we have to take immediate actions to mitigate security risks and threats to building a peaceful world and sustainable societies. Establish national youth consultative bodies like youth advisory councils to ensure that young people and adolescents inform foreign and national policies. Young people must be part of policymaking and decision-making processes and governance systems at various levels. Raise recognition and legitimization of youth efforts in traditional governance structures and facilitate a culture for meaningful youth participation. Young people also brought recommendations on gender yesterday, such as the need to revitalize the Commission on the Status of Women and the Commission on Population and Development in partnership with civil society and youth. Under the intergenerational equity and solidarity, youth and partners demand to create an intergenerational dialogue platform as well as to leverage science, data, statistics, and strategic foresight to ensure long-term thinking and planning in their governance structures. These are clear examples that young people need to be included across discussions, negotiations, and policies, because all matters are youth matters. He acknowledged that his generation prioritized profit in systems that ultimately failed us. This must be corrected. Our generation needs to be included in decision-making spaces and be meaningfully engaged in shaping those processes. The change needs to happen now and youth lead for a better future. Thank you everyone. Have a great day.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you, Saumya, for so eloquently summarizing your discussions and capturing the energy that we all felt yesterday on day one of the Summit of the Future Action Days. So this now concludes our first opening segment and we’ll now zero in on one of the summit’s major targeted outcomes and that is the Declaration on Future Generations, which will be a vital step forward in ensuring that the rights and interests of future generations are at the heart of global decision-making. To discuss this, I’m delighted to welcome to the stage His Excellency Andrew Holness, Prime Minister of Jamaica, to join us. Thank you.

Andrew Holness: Secretary General of the United Nations, His Excellency António Guterres, Excellencies and distinguished delegates, representatives of the United Nations, civil society, youth, major groups and other stakeholders, it is a distinct honor to join you this morning in building momentum towards the Summit of the Future. and to formally commence the discussions on future generations. Allow me to congratulate and commend all of you for your tremendous efforts over these past few years to ensure the success of the Summit. Jamaica is proud to have co-facilitated the intergovernmental process for the Declaration on Future Generations, and I take this opportunity to express my appreciation to our co-facilitator, the Kingdom of the Netherlands, for their excellent collaboration during this challenging process. I would also like to thank the Secretary General and his team for the support provided to our respective teams during the negotiations and consultations. The inclusivity of the Summit of the future and its preceding action days, as well as the proprietary processes leading up to this very critical moment, is truly symbolic of the approach that is required to preserve a robust and effective multilateral system with the United Nations at its core. It is clear that member states and the UN system cannot chart this path alone. We must leverage the knowledge, expertise and vigor of civil society, youth, academia, the private sector and other stakeholders to deliver a better future for this planet and for all its people. The Declaration on Future Generations has certainly benefited from this. coming together of great minds, and reflects the diverse perspectives and challenges across the world that must be taken into account as we lay the foundation for the next century and beyond. Indeed, with the adoption of this Declaration at the Summit tomorrow, we will be able to celebrate a universal realization that, even as we address the challenges of today, we have an obligation to protect the interests of future generations and ensure that they will inherit a planet in which they can thrive. We must now translate that enthusiasm into action by giving life to the Declaration. We are grateful that, during the consultations, all stakeholders recognized that it was important to not only manifest lofty intent to take account of the needs of future generations, but to agree to fundamental guiding principles, make far-reaching commitments, and prescribe concrete actions to propel us to achieve this end. Having completed the negotiations, it is now our responsibility to ensure effective implementation of the Pact for the Future, the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration on Future Generations. For governments like mine, this effort will require a whole-of-society collaboration as we seek to embed futures thinking. in all our decision-making processes across national and local government. The role of civil society, academia, and the private sector in this endeavour will be critical in developing solutions, as well as building and maintaining momentum towards implementation. In Jamaica, my government has already begun to invest in anticipatory planning and future-proofing, recognising first and foremost that a solid macroeconomic foundation is the most basic requirement. We have lowered our debt-to-GDP ratio, increased our foreign exchange reserves, reduced our unemployment rate, and achieved single-digit inflation as well as financial sector stability. This has allowed us to increase investment in sustainable and smart infrastructure, building for the future while taking account of changing demographic trends. We are, however, well aware of the capacity limitations of developing states to deal with the multidimensional challenges we currently face. Climate change, debt sustainability, economic stability, access to financing for development, global shocks, among others. Technology and knowledge transfer must therefore be facilitated, including through mutually agreed arrangements. The international financial institutions must be reformed to provide the necessary access to financing as the means of implementation. The multilateral system, with the UN at its core, must be equipped to provide opportunities for developing and sharing best practices. In this regard, a follow-up mechanism will also be important, so that implementation of commitments we make over the next few days can be appropriately measured and monitored. Excellencies, with the adoption of the Pact and its annexes, we have charted a path and made the first bold steps. Let us now move forward with hope and determination to ensure that our collective legacy will be a peaceful, healthy and prosperous planet for all our peoples and a sustainable future for the generations to come. I thank you.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you.

Evelyn Wever-Croes: Mr. President, Excellencies, distinguished guests, I’m delighted to be here with you all today on this inspiring occasion to take part in the discussion and to listen to your valuable insights. The Kingdom of the Netherlands is proud to have co-facilitated the intergovernmental process for a declaration on future generations alongside Jamaica. I would like to express my deepest gratitude to the Most Honorable Andrew Holness, Prime Minister of Jamaica, for his unwavering commitment and collaboration throughout this process. The declaration represents a significant milestone, and it will be annexed to the Pact for the Future during the Summit of the Future, an event that provides a rare, once-in-a-generation opportunity to create lasting change. This summit is our chance to set things right, not only for the people of today, young and old, but for the generations yet to come. Our decisions and our actions sent ripple effects across time, shaping the future. By making thoughtful and responsible choices now, we ensure a positive intergenerational impact benefiting those who will inherit this world. The declaration has the potential to mark a pivotal moment in our multilateral efforts to address global crisis and to establish a robust framework for long-term sustainable development. By embracing strategic foresight and carefully considering the long-term effects of our decisions, we can pave the way for a more equitable and sustainable world for future generations. It is essential that we demonstrate intergenerational solidarity. Challenges such as inequality and discrimination, climate change, food insecurity, the digital divide and ongoing conflicts are human-made. They demand collective solutions. It is our collective responsibility to champion impactful and long-lasting solutions. Governments, policymakers and all stakeholders must work together to turn legal and policy decisions into a unified, intergenerational agenda that safeguards the interests of future generations. The Declaration promises to bring about a major shift in how we think, making sure that caring for future generations and sharing responsibility across generations are priorities in our decisions. This is especially important when it comes to climate change. Like many countries around the world, my country, Aruba, and indeed our entire kingdom, which spans two continents, is facing the consequences of global warming. Rising sea levels and more extreme weather events clearly show us how what we do or don’t do affects everyone, now and in the future. The devastating hurricanes and floods in our Caribbean region are a stark reminder of this reality. Yet, history teaches us that forward-thinking decisions can protect future generations. By learning from past mistakes and taking decisive action today, we will secure long-term benefits for ourselves and for those to come after us. And this is why I look to the future with what I call realistic optimism. But there is a catch. We need to act now, and we must act collectively. Civil society partners, research institutions, the private sector, and so many others gathered here today all have an essential role to play. By supporting governments, policymakers, and international organizations like the United Nations, we can steer decisions towards this common goal, a thriving legacy for future generations. Today is the International Day of Peace, which was designated by the General Assembly as a time of nonviolence and ceasefire. Unfortunately, today is not a day without conflict, as the violence in the Middle East, Sudan, and Ukraine shows. While solving these conflicts is beyond what we can expect to achieve today, that doesn’t mean we should stop working towards a better future. And that is why I’m honored to be here today with you. Your Excellencies, distinguished guests, I would like to extend my sincere thank you to the Secretary General of the United Nations for his forward-thinking vision in prioritizing future generations and entrusting us with the responsibility of advancing the Declaration. His leadership has helped make the concept of future generations more tangible. Additionally, I want to express my gratitude to all the stakeholders here today, civil society, academia, the private sector, and impact coalitions, for your active participation over the past two years. Your dedication has been critical in shaping this process. With the Declaration on Future Generations, we must thrive. good ancestors, to leave behind a world that offers a better quality of life for those who follow. I look forward to continuing this journey together, shaping a more inclusive and just future. Thank you.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you very much Madam Prime Minister and thank you as well to the Prime Minister of Jamaica for your efforts in ensuring the interests of future generations remains at the top of the global agenda. We’re getting things set up now for our panel discussion. We’ll be joined by a panel of experts working on the topic of future generations, moderated by Thomas Hale, who is a professor of global public policy in the Blavatnik School of Government at the University of Oxford. His work, Thomas’s work, has focused on precisely the issue of how we safeguard our future and address the subject of what he terms long problems. Professor Hale will be joined by three distinguished panelists. Our first panelist is Hina Jilani, a pioneering lawyer and human rights defender and a member of the Elders, an esteemed group of global leaders. Ms. Jelani will be joined by Abdullahi Alim, the CEO of the Africa Future Fund, which is a new financing mechanism to advance the rights and prosperity of future Africans. And to round out our panel, we have Paolo Baca, the Deputy Director of De Justicia. Dr. Baca’s work blends academic scholarship with public engagement and his extensive fieldwork has fostered collaborations with indigenous organizations. worldwide. So we’re honored to have these experts join us at the General Assembly today to provide their diverse perspectives on the Declaration of Future Generations. And I will turn it over now to Professor Hale and his panelists.

Thomas Hale: Thank you very much, Foley, for this kind introduction. Ladies and gentlemen, tomorrow, every member state of the United Nations will adopt a Declaration on Future Generations, thanks to the hard work of many people in this room and a few late hours last night. This is a potentially transformative document. But as we’ve just heard from these speakers, the potential of any document to transform our world depends entirely on what happens next, what action follows from the text. And we have a fantastic panel today to talk about the work they’re doing to advance the goals and the objectives that the Declaration speaks to. And I’m going to be asking them, what is the transformative potential of this document, and how do we unlock it? And those are important questions because we are facing a world, this document is arriving in a world that is fraught. We face war, we face debt, we face a climate crisis, we face the lingering effects of a global pandemic, we face many immediate challenges. And so why now? Why in September 2024 are we talking about future generations? And a document answers that critical question in two ways. First, it recognizes the fundamental connection between the immediate, urgent challenges we face and the long-term trends and drivers from which they grow. It understands that things like climate change, poverty, underdevelopment, lack of health, lack of justice are fundamental risk factors that create crises. And as we all saw in our own lives just a few years ago, when a crisis gets out of control, we can’t react our way out of it. We can’t respond only. We need to anticipate and act in advance, and that’s a fundamental shift consistent with the goals of the United Nations to advance sustainable development. Second, the document, and I think this is really striking and important, it recognizes a fundamental consensus across cultures, across religions, across philosophies, across value systems that we all have an interest and indeed a responsibility to think about the future, to think about leaving a better world for those that come after us. And in a world where consensus is sorely lacking, isn’t it helpful, isn’t it powerful to think about the powerful consensus that exists there? Now of course these kind of lofty words fall flat. They ring hollow without action to follow up. And so we’re going to hear from a panel thinking about what that action looks like. But of course we see already trends happening around the world that are driving forward action to support future generations. Just this week, the European Union appointed a commissioner with responsibility for intergenerational fairness. This month, the South Korean Constitutional Court ordered the government to enhance its climate targets to better serve future generations. This is actually happening on the ground everywhere. And so the real question for this declaration is how it can catalyze more such changes going forward. Abdullahi, I’d like to start with you. You’re the CEO of the Africa Future Fund, working to support leaders and transformative businesses. to solve the continent’s greatest challenges. You’ve also worked at the International Chamber of Commerce, so you know what the private sector thinks. And you’ve just done a survey of a number of private sector leaders across Africa, asking them, what do you think about future generations? What did they say?

Abdullahi Alim: So yes, my name is Abdullahi Alim, and I’m currently leading an outfit called the Africa Future Fund. I’m no longer with the International Chamber of Commerce, so just a quick mention to the technical team. One billion Africans will be born in the next generation alone, and I think by the close of this century, you can expect about three to four billion total more Africans to be born. When you think of the mega cities of the future, it’ll be cities like Lagos, cities like Dar es Salaam, cities like Mogadishu, where I was born. And for some context, Mogadishu alone, by the end of this century, will be more populous than the entire country of Spain. Just to give you some scope of where the world and where the trajectory of population growth is growing. So from my perspective, when I think future generations, to make it as specific as possible, from my vantage point, I’m talking about future Africans. If this rapid growth in population that we’re expecting over the next few decades isn’t also met with commensurate increases in industrialization, in living standards, of course, without clocking past ecological boundaries, then we will have yet another wasted generation. And it’s from this place that we created the Africa Future Fund. We’re trying to take big bets on our communities. We’re trying to channel big investments to seismically change the geopolitical economic might of the continent over the next few decades. What does that look like? It looks, for example, like backing a local African initiative that is studying, that is, most importantly, IP-ing active compounds that are found in plant life that are indigenous to the Congolese basin. These kind of active compounds will be critical to the modern genomic revolution and to some of the anti-cancer treatment. statements of the future. It’s about backing, for example, fellowships that bring together young Africans at the forefront of combating advanced disinformation warfare. There’s one particular form, if anybody’s interested in like the future of disinformation called adversarial AI, we wrote a piece for them, about them rather, for foreign policy. And so some of the foremost thinkers on this topic are actually from the continent. So unlike what you normally see where it’s European, US or advanced Asian economies leading the world on thought and sort of exporting it to sub-Saharan Africa, we want to get to a stage where we’re leading and setting the standard for global resilience in this case. And you know, to be also honest, it’s also about backing young progressive political voices on the continent, training them on what the future looks like so that they’re able to really rise to the occasion when they assume positions of influence, positions of power. As Thomas alluded to, we ran a massive consultation across the continent to figure out what does the future look like, what’s the significance of it to your work if you are, for example, the head of a sovereign wealth fund, if you are a former head of state, if you are a young entrepreneur, three main priorities that made it very, very practical for us. It’s about restructuring the way debt is measured on the continent. Unlike anywhere else in the world, the majority of the debt in Africa is actually owned by the private sector. And it’s four times more expensive to borrow debt on the continent than anywhere else in the world. Number one, reforming debt. The second one is around really advancing export-oriented industrial policy. It makes no sense that, for example, Cote d’Ivoire, the largest producer of cashew nuts, makes a very limited gain in the global supply chain relative to countries like Vietnam, relative to countries like India. And the third one is really about taking more potential out from our SMEs. And we have this concept known as search funds, which we’re also championing. Three key ideas that came when we spoke to CEOs, when we spoke to government leaders, young entrepreneurs, and I’ll go into a bit more detail.

Thomas Hale: Fantastic, thank you so much for highlighting the opportunity that thinking about the future can highlight. We often think about the risks and how we manage them, but actually we need to have a real laser focus on the opportunity side as well. Pablo, I’ll come to you next if I may. You work for Davis TCO, which is a fantastic group of researchers and advocates working across a range of issues. But many people here will have heard about a famous case that you won in which a group of youth and children successfully sued the government in Colombia’s highest court for action to prevent deforestation in the Amazon because of the impacts that that would have on climate change and the climate future generations will inherit. So how do you think about this question, future generations, in your own work, and is there more potential to unlock that kind of transformation going forward?

Paolo Baca: Thank you, Tom. I will start on the issue how future generations’ perspective have changed my mind, and later on I will talk about the justicious case. I have been working with indigenous peoples for over two decades, and I have learned from Andean communities from Colombia, Ecuador, and Peru that the issue on future generations have to be tackled from a temporality perspective. For Andean indigenous peoples, the time is not linear or chronological. It happens in Western cultures. For them, for example, the future is behind us, and the past is in front, and that is women carry on their kids, their children, on the back, because children are the future. And the past is in front because in front they find the wisdom of the elders. And the wisdom of the elders are the meanings that can drive the present of our daily lives. So in indigenous cosmologies, the future is not something that will come. It’s something that is linked with past and present, and it changes everything. Because for them, there is no separation between nature and culture. They think and they belong to the mountains, they belong to the lakes, and their ancestors belong to those sources of the land. And it changes the perspective about human rights and international law, for example. And using this kind of framework, the justicia sued the Colombian state because deforestation was increasing in the Amazon region. And we use the concept of future generations in order to stop deforestation. And the Supreme Court ordered an intergenerational pact to stop deforestation in the Amazon region. Nevertheless, after six years of this important ruling, the implementation, in a way, has been a failure, at least in terms of this intergenerational pact. On the one hand, because it is necessary to build a mechanism to drive inter-jurisdictional models between the Colombian states and the indigenous Amazonian peoples. And it has been difficult, so we need to work together to put forward the voice of indigenous peoples in their own terms to understand how future generation pacts should work. And on the other hand, the armed conflict, it is still an issue in Colombia. And unfortunately, the conflict is still going on in the Amazon region, and it has put some difficulties to implement the pact and to stop deforestation. So unfortunately, deforestation is increasing and we don’t have the intergenerational pact.

Thomas Hale: I think it’s a really important example for us to think about, a really innovative case of using law to take indigenous thinking into the heart of modern governance, and then the challenge, the ongoing challenge, of trying to deliver that requiring a deeper transformation of governance systems. So like for many of the things we’re thinking about around future generations, a step forward, but then many more steps to come and a long-term perspective needed to drive the fundamental transformation. Ms. Jelani, can I turn next to you? You are a pioneering lawyer. You founded the first all-woman law firm in Pakistan. You’ve represented the UN as a special representative for human rights defenders. You’re working currently with the elders. You’ve seen these issues change over time, but you’ve also been at the forefront of that change. And yesterday, you and the other elders issued an intergenerational call to action. So how does the future generations declaration, which we’re coming to tomorrow influence the work that you’re doing?

Hina Jilani: Thank you, Thomas, for that question. Let me say, first of all, that when we talk about a declaration on future generations, what springs to my mind immediately is Article 1 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which essentially says that every human being is endowed with reason and conscience. If that belief is true, then I see no reason for hesitation on the implementation of any of the agreed principles and implementation strategies that the Declaration says. If there is hesitation on the part of those that are making decisions and policies that affect the lives of their own people and the global environment, I would regretfully have to say that this belief that all human beings are endowed with reason and a conscience is going to be confounded. I also believe that the transformation that we are talking about and our aspiration to bring about that transformation is really rooted in the respect for human rights, in the recognition that only a rule-based order can propel that change and be able to achieve what are the crisis and critical areas of concern to us today. You’ve spoken about climate change and its effect. I come from a country which is one of the top 10 countries to be affected by climate change. So the effects of climate change for people like me are not in the abstract. They are not just a technical issue for us to deal with or an academic, are not of academic concern. We see things happening to people where displacement, loss of livelihood, loss of life in many cases is so real and is affecting so many of the vulnerable communities. Paulo speaks of indigenous communities. I have seen people who have traditionally been inhabitants of land for centuries having to leave that land, having to leave that way of life because of climate change. We all know what the COVID pandemic did to us and how it has changed our lives. So I do believe that if there is reason, if there is a conscience, and if there is a will to preserve the environment in which we live and to develop the consensus to bring about an environment in the world where dialogue is possible, where it’s important to understand the values of diversity rather than that becoming the reason for division, where intolerance is totally rejected, where people not only talk about tolerating others but have a belief that tolerance will be replaced by accommodation of everyone’s belief, everyone’s culture, everyone’s needs. So these are some of the things that I look forward to. And I think the civil society has a very critical role to play, because these are the people who can not take on governments, but at least create a balance in the power of the state and the voices of the people. And one of my colleagues, one of the other elders, President Santos, from your country, said yesterday that governments understand pressure. The civil society can build that pressure.

Thomas Hale: An important source of action, not just in the world at all, but also for this declaration, which is, as I think the speakers before highlighted, benefited from some of that pressure and ideas. I love how you’ve connected, Mr. Lani, the declaration coming tomorrow to the long history and the fundamental human rights that sit at the center of the multilateral system, and how this is an extension and a deepening and a recognition of how that understanding must evolve as we face problems like climate change and other things that last generation to generation. I want to come back to the panel with a burning point, which is going back to this idea of, how do we unlock the transformation? How do we make this text come to life? How do we breathe life into it, as the Secretary General said? I’m curious what the one action you would like governments to take next. They’re going to sign this thing tomorrow, agree the thing. What should they do the day after? What should they make their top priority? I think there’s many, many ones. But what’s one you would like to see them take forward? I wonder, Abdullahi, if I can come back to you first.

Abdullahi Alim: So I think for me it’s, is it just one? Just your top one. I would say, focus on. For me, it’s always an economic conversation, to be honest. Because if your population is going to double, if it’s going to triple, you’re almost planning for a new country over the next few decades. So think about which sectors are your most competitive and hone in your entire government strategy based on that. That sounds very simple, but it’s actually somewhat difficult to do. Again, I’ll go back to the example of the cashew nut trade in West Africa. I spoke to a young entrepreneur who told me, you know, I export my raw cashew nuts, let’s say, I’m just going to give a hypothetical number, let’s say $1 a kilo. He then sells it to somebody based in another part of the world who has machinery that is able to roast, that is able to salt at scale these nuts, and then sell it for $10. So this person has already lost $9 because they just happen to be based in a part of the world that lacks industrial capacity. So for me, it’s a case where I think each government needs to come to terms with the fact that focus on two or three critical sectors where you think you have growth opportunities. Make sure your roads and transportation authority, your investment authority, your education, like everybody needs to be focused on that one competitive sector because ultimately to protect future generations, you’re going to need money. You’re going to need capital because it’s going to require a lot of infrastructure.

Thomas Hale: And I think your comment is particularly trenchant given the current debt burden that so many future majority countries hold. And so it’s not even about building for the future, it’s also about getting the legacy of the past righted in that sense.

Abdullahi Alim: If you were to give… Sorry, I’m going to be very cheeky. If you were to give a loan to any business anywhere in the world, can I tell you which region in the world you’ll most likely recover your loan is from? It’s sub-Saharan Africa at number one. More so than Europe, more so than Latin America, more so than South Asia. The number one region in the world for loan recovery when it comes to lending to the private sector is sub-Saharan Africa. But still very expensive for us.

Thomas Hale: Fantastic opportunity. The opportunity is really shining through in this Future Generations narrative. Paulo, what’s the one action you would like to see taken?

Paolo Baca: Well, I think that it is very important to make a bridge between the local and the global. I think that countries such as Pakistan or Colombia are suffering the consequences of the climate crisis, but we are not the ones who produce the crisis. So I think that it is important that the wealthier countries, the ones who are producing global warming, acknowledge that, and that acknowledgement is connected with the past of, for example, colonial history, racial and structural discrimination, and of course it is also connected with the generations to come to build a better future for everyone. So I think that we need to move forward from these global forums, which are very important, of course, and go also to the local communities and try to understand these kinds of discussions from their point of view. So it is very important to engage, for example, with peasants, with Afro-descendants, with indigenous peoples, with these sectors who have the knowledge to stop the climate crisis, because they have the biocultural knowledge, for example, in the Amazon, to make sustainable development for future generations and be more open. have been with us, because they have the skills to go, for example, to the course, to the United Nations.

Thomas Hale: Indeed. And your work shows exactly the potential of that. Your work shows how to do that, which I think is so important, because I think many people will say, OK, that’s a really good idea, but how do we do it? And you’ve given us a model in this case that is a work in progress, as you said very clearly, but is a good starting point. So this is a really, I think, practical way forward that you’re articulating. Ms. Jilani, your top wish to see after government sign the Declaration on Future Innovations?

Hina Jilani: Can I just, if you allow me, add to something that Paolo has just said? Look, as a human rights defender, I have always criticized government’s failure to take care of climate consequences and extreme emergencies that happen. But there are times when I pity our governments, because even where there is willingness, the ability to respond is not there. So I do think that globally, we, countries who have almost no carbon footprint, have to be compensated. We have to have enough resources for adaptation, for mitigation, and to respond to the people’s loss of livelihood and other issues that emerge. But coming to your question now, I think my top priority, apart from many others that compete with this one, is governments must ensure that they have a plan to develop communities that demonstrate the power of social connection. One thing I can say as an elder, we may be called the elders. But we don’t think that we are a repository of all wisdom. We have a plan and a policy and a commitment to seeking out the pockets of wisdom where they exist and learning from those. And one of the important things that the elders totally believe in and have a faith in is this intergenerational connection. I think this kind of social connection is critical to ending loneliness, to ending social isolation, bringing about people’s ability to reach out to each other, learn from each other, and in that context also to inform the global environment on what the essential needs are all the time. I’m not going to enumerate all the problems that we have today. But let me say, through this whole policy of social connection, ending isolation, ending loneliness, which is not just a public health issue. It’s an issue of governance, really. By doing that, we can fix it.

Thomas Hale: Well, I think your comments remind me very much of the philosopher Edmund Burke, who said, described society as a pact between the past, the present, and the future. And that is indeed what this declaration is recognizing. And what the fantastic work you each have described is aiming to give life to, to put meaning into those ideas and principles, whether it be economic issues, whether it be the incorporation of indigenous ideas to protect the environment, whether it be fundamental human rights protections. And of course, that’s a perfect framing for our discussions for the rest of today, where we’ll have numerous sessions looking at how we take forward the ideas in the pact overall and how the declaration on future generations can best be implemented. And I think as a final point to add to those discussions, you said it very well, Ms. Jilani. Governments don’t always have the capacities to deliver on these things. And so a key question for us today is what more do we want the multilateral system to be doing to support us, to support governments to deliver on the pact? For example, in the declaration text, there’s an upcoming forum to check in on progress as a report. There’s a noting of the Secretary General’s proposal to appoint a special envoy for future generations. What more support should the multilateral system provide to take forward these ideas is another key part of our discussions today. In conclusion, please join me in thanking our extraordinary panel. Thank you.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you all very much. Thank you, Professor Hale. Thank you. That was such a great discussion, great conversation. Thank you all very much for your time here today. A fascinating discussion moderated by Professor Hill. Thank you very much. It’s so inspiring to hear unique voices across sectors and generations who remind us that we all have a role to play in building this future together. With that, Excellencies and Ladies and Gentlemen, we end our opening ceremony. Before leaving, however, we want to show you a summary of the discussions this morning that our visual scribe has been working on diligently in the background, summing up, as you can see there, the main themes addressed this morning. Look at it. Isn’t it great? Please, a round of applause for our visual scribe. Now, as Professor Hill mentioned, our discussions will continue throughout the day and throughout the building, so please make your way now to the other sessions, the main sessions. In conference room four, the sessions on a sustainable future for all will focus on key action areas of sustainable development and financing for development that will deliver on the aspirations of the 2030 Agenda. In the trusteeship chamber, the peaceful future for all session, which will focus on intergenerational dialogue for peace. And in ECOSOC chamber, join us for a digital future for all sessions, which will bring forward looking commitments from all stakeholders to harness innovation, science, and data in a more inclusive, safe, and sustainable manner. And of course, don’t forget to join us for the closing ceremony, everyone, at 5.30 p.m. in ECOSOC as well, where we’ll share our learnings from the day’s interactive and thought-provoking sessions and look towards the next steps in creating our shared future. Thank you all very much. I’ll kindly ask you to please quickly leave the room, because we have another session in place. And, you know, continue your conversations outside and in the other rooms, ECOSOC chamber and the different sessions that we’re having this morning. Thank you all very much. I wish you an excellent day, and see you at 5.30 for our closing ceremony. Thank you very much.

A

António Guterres

Speech speed

119 words per minute

Speech length

858 words

Speech time

430 seconds

Intergenerational solidarity and responsibility

Explanation

Guterres emphasizes the importance of considering future generations in current decision-making. He calls for a shift in thinking to prioritize long-term impacts and shared responsibility across generations.

Evidence

Mention of the Declaration on Future Generations as a key outcome of the Summit of the Future

Major Discussion Point

Declaration on Future Generations

Agreed with

Carole Osero-Ageng’o

Hina Jilani

Agreed on

Importance of intergenerational dialogue and collaboration

Reforming international financial institutions

Explanation

Guterres advocates for reforming international financial institutions to better support sustainable development and climate action. He argues that current systems are inadequate to address contemporary global challenges.

Evidence

Mention of the need to ‘supercharge resources for sustainable development and for climate action’

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Systems

Agreed with

Abdullahi Alim

Agreed on

Need for reforming global financial systems

Inclusive and networked multilateralism

Explanation

Guterres calls for a more inclusive and networked form of multilateralism. He emphasizes the need for greater representation of developing countries and stronger links between international institutions and people.

Evidence

Statement: ‘We need multilateralism that is more inclusive, more effective and more networked, with stronger links between international institutions and with the people.’

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Systems

A

Andrew Holness

Speech speed

95 words per minute

Speech length

739 words

Speech time

462 seconds

Embedding futures thinking in decision-making

Explanation

Holness emphasizes the importance of incorporating long-term thinking into government decision-making processes. He argues for the need to consider the impacts of current decisions on future generations.

Evidence

Mention of Jamaica’s efforts to invest in anticipatory planning and future-proofing

Major Discussion Point

Declaration on Future Generations

P

Paolo Baca

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Bridging local and global perspectives

Explanation

Baca emphasizes the importance of connecting local and global perspectives in addressing climate change and future challenges. He argues for incorporating indigenous knowledge and perspectives into global decision-making processes.

Evidence

Example of the Colombian Supreme Court case involving indigenous communities and deforestation in the Amazon

Major Discussion Point

Declaration on Future Generations

Indigenous perspectives on time and nature

Explanation

Baca highlights how indigenous communities view time and nature differently from Western perspectives. He argues that these alternative worldviews can provide valuable insights for addressing long-term challenges.

Evidence

Description of Andean indigenous peoples’ non-linear concept of time and their relationship with nature

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and Opportunities for Future Generations

H

Hina Jilani

Speech speed

113 words per minute

Speech length

814 words

Speech time

428 seconds

Developing socially connected communities

Explanation

Jilani emphasizes the importance of fostering social connections and ending isolation within communities. She argues that this is crucial for addressing various societal challenges and informing global governance.

Evidence

Statement: ‘I think my top priority, apart from many others that compete with this one, is governments must ensure that they have a plan to develop communities that demonstrate the power of social connection.’

Major Discussion Point

Declaration on Future Generations

Agreed with

António Guterres

Carole Osero-Ageng’o

Agreed on

Importance of intergenerational dialogue and collaboration

Climate change impacts on vulnerable communities

Explanation

Jilani highlights the disproportionate impact of climate change on vulnerable communities, particularly in developing countries. She argues for the need to compensate and support these countries in addressing climate-related challenges.

Evidence

Personal experience from Pakistan, which is among the top 10 countries affected by climate change

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and Opportunities for Future Generations

A

Abdullahi Alim

Speech speed

181 words per minute

Speech length

1042 words

Speech time

344 seconds

Population growth and economic development in Africa

Explanation

Alim discusses the rapid population growth expected in Africa and the need for commensurate economic development. He argues for strategic investments in key competitive sectors to drive economic growth and improve living standards.

Evidence

Projection of 1 billion Africans to be born in the next generation, and 3-4 billion by the end of the century

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and Opportunities for Future Generations

Debt burdens and financing for developing countries

Explanation

Alim highlights the challenges of debt and financing for African countries. He argues for restructuring debt measurement and improving access to affordable financing for development.

Evidence

Statement that debt in Africa is four times more expensive than elsewhere in the world

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and Opportunities for Future Generations

Agreed with

António Guterres

Agreed on

Need for reforming global financial systems

Restructuring debt measurement for African countries

Explanation

Alim advocates for reforming how debt is measured and managed for African countries. He argues that current systems disadvantage African nations and hinder their economic development.

Evidence

Mention of debt restructuring as one of three main priorities identified in consultations with African leaders

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Systems

Agreed with

António Guterres

Agreed on

Need for reforming global financial systems

Supporting progressive young political voices

Explanation

Alim emphasizes the importance of supporting and training young, progressive political voices in Africa. He argues that this is crucial for preparing future leaders to address long-term challenges.

Evidence

Mention of backing and training young progressive political voices as part of the Africa Future Fund’s activities

Major Discussion Point

Youth Engagement and Empowerment

Agreed with

Saumya Aggarwal

Agreed on

Importance of youth participation in decision-making

S

Saumya Aggarwal

Speech speed

120 words per minute

Speech length

686 words

Speech time

342 seconds

Meaningful youth participation in policymaking

Explanation

Aggarwal advocates for the inclusion of youth in decision-making processes at various levels of governance. She argues that young people must be part of policymaking to ensure their perspectives are considered in shaping the future.

Evidence

Call for establishing national youth consultative bodies and including youth in foreign and national policy-making

Major Discussion Point

Youth Engagement and Empowerment

Agreed with

Abdullahi Alim

Agreed on

Importance of youth participation in decision-making

Investing in youth-led solutions and organizations

Explanation

Aggarwal calls for increased financial support and resources for youth-led organizations and initiatives. She argues that this is crucial for enabling young people to develop and implement innovative solutions to global challenges.

Evidence

Recommendation to allocate flexible, accessible, and sustainable financial support for adolescent-led and youth-led organizations

Major Discussion Point

Youth Engagement and Empowerment

C

Carole Osero-Ageng’o

Speech speed

126 words per minute

Speech length

518 words

Speech time

245 seconds

Intergenerational dialogue and collaboration

Explanation

Osero-Ageng’o emphasizes the importance of fostering dialogue and collaboration between different generations. She argues that this approach is crucial for addressing complex global issues and creating sustainable solutions.

Evidence

Reference to intergenerational activities at the conference and the need to reframe the narrative on aging

Major Discussion Point

Youth Engagement and Empowerment

Agreed with

António Guterres

Hina Jilani

Agreed on

Importance of intergenerational dialogue and collaboration

O

Oli Henman

Speech speed

168 words per minute

Speech length

768 words

Speech time

273 seconds

Strengthening UN human rights mechanisms

Explanation

Henman calls for strengthening the human rights pillar of the UN and improving its implementation at the country level. He argues that this is essential for protecting and enhancing rights globally.

Evidence

Call for ‘accelerating support for the human rights pillar of the UN and forging clearer links at the country level with resident coordinator teams’

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Systems

Agreements

Agreement Points

Importance of intergenerational dialogue and collaboration

Speakers

António Guterres

Carole Osero-Ageng’o

Hina Jilani

Arguments

Intergenerational solidarity and responsibility

Intergenerational dialogue and collaboration

Developing socially connected communities

Summary

These speakers emphasized the need for collaboration and dialogue across generations to address global challenges and create sustainable solutions.

Need for reforming global financial systems

Speakers

António Guterres

Abdullahi Alim

Arguments

Reforming international financial institutions

Debt burdens and financing for developing countries

Restructuring debt measurement for African countries

Summary

Both speakers highlighted the importance of reforming international financial institutions and debt structures to better support developing countries, particularly in Africa.

Importance of youth participation in decision-making

Speakers

Saumya Aggarwal

Abdullahi Alim

Arguments

Meaningful youth participation in policymaking

Supporting progressive young political voices

Summary

These speakers advocated for increased youth involvement in policy-making processes and leadership roles to shape the future.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the disproportionate impact of climate change on vulnerable communities and the need to incorporate local perspectives in global decision-making.

Speakers

Paolo Baca

Hina Jilani

Arguments

Bridging local and global perspectives

Climate change impacts on vulnerable communities

Unexpected Consensus

Importance of indigenous knowledge in addressing global challenges

Speakers

Paolo Baca

António Guterres

Arguments

Indigenous perspectives on time and nature

Inclusive and networked multilateralism

Explanation

While not explicitly stated by Guterres, his call for more inclusive multilateralism aligns with Baca’s emphasis on incorporating indigenous perspectives, suggesting an unexpected consensus on the value of diverse knowledge systems in global governance.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement include the importance of intergenerational collaboration, the need for financial system reforms, increased youth participation in decision-making, and the recognition of diverse perspectives in addressing global challenges.

Consensus level

There is a moderate to high level of consensus among the speakers on these key issues. This suggests a shared understanding of the critical challenges facing future generations and the need for inclusive, collaborative approaches to address them. The implications of this consensus could lead to more coordinated efforts in implementing the Declaration on Future Generations and related initiatives.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Approach to addressing climate change impacts

Speakers

Hina Jilani

Paolo Baca

Arguments

Jilani highlights the disproportionate impact of climate change on vulnerable communities, particularly in developing countries. She argues for the need to compensate and support these countries in addressing climate-related challenges.

Baca emphasizes the importance of connecting local and global perspectives in addressing climate change and future challenges. He argues for incorporating indigenous knowledge and perspectives into global decision-making processes.

Summary

While both speakers acknowledge the importance of addressing climate change, they differ in their proposed approaches. Jilani focuses on compensation and support for vulnerable countries, while Baca emphasizes the incorporation of indigenous knowledge and local perspectives.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement among the speakers were primarily related to specific approaches and focus areas in addressing global challenges, rather than fundamental disagreements on core issues.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among the speakers was relatively low. Most speakers shared similar overarching goals related to sustainable development, addressing climate change, and improving global governance systems. The differences were mainly in the specific strategies or areas of emphasis each speaker prioritized based on their expertise and regional perspectives. This low level of disagreement suggests a general consensus on the importance of considering future generations and the need for systemic reforms, which could facilitate more unified action on these issues.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

All three speakers agree on the need for reform in global financial and decision-making systems to better address future challenges. However, they differ in their specific focus areas: Guterres emphasizes reforming international financial institutions, Holness focuses on incorporating long-term thinking in government processes, and Alim specifically addresses debt measurement for African countries.

Speakers

António Guterres

Andrew Holness

Abdullahi Alim

Arguments

Guterres advocates for reforming international financial institutions to better support sustainable development and climate action. He argues that current systems are inadequate to address contemporary global challenges.

Holness emphasizes the importance of incorporating long-term thinking into government decision-making processes. He argues for the need to consider the impacts of current decisions on future generations.

Alim advocates for reforming how debt is measured and managed for African countries. He argues that current systems disadvantage African nations and hinder their economic development.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the disproportionate impact of climate change on vulnerable communities and the need to incorporate local perspectives in global decision-making.

Speakers

Paolo Baca

Hina Jilani

Arguments

Bridging local and global perspectives

Climate change impacts on vulnerable communities

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

The Declaration on Future Generations aims to ensure the rights and interests of future generations are at the heart of global decision-making

There is a need for intergenerational solidarity and responsibility in addressing global challenges like climate change

Youth engagement and empowerment is critical for shaping a better future

Reforms are needed in global systems like the UN Security Council and international financial institutions to better serve future generations

Indigenous and local perspectives are valuable for sustainable development and addressing climate change

Economic development and industrialization in Africa presents both challenges and opportunities for future generations

Resolutions and Action Items

Governments should develop plans to foster socially connected communities

Countries should focus on developing their most competitive economic sectors to drive growth

Wealthier countries should provide compensation and resources to developing countries facing climate impacts

The UN should appoint a Special Envoy for Future Generations

An upcoming forum will be held to check on progress of implementing the Declaration

Unresolved Issues

How to effectively implement the intergenerational pact ordered by Colombia’s Supreme Court to stop deforestation

Specific mechanisms for reforming international financial institutions

How to balance rapid population growth in Africa with sustainable development

Concrete steps for meaningful youth inclusion in policymaking processes

Suggested Compromises

Balancing economic growth and industrialization with staying within ecological boundaries

Combining global frameworks with local and indigenous knowledge and practices

Integrating perspectives of both older and younger generations in decision-making

Thought Provoking Comments

We need multilateralism that is more inclusive, more effective and more networked, with stronger links between international institutions and with the people. That means greater representation in developing countries, and it means a stronger voice for all of you and what you represent.

Speaker

António Guterres

Reason

This comment highlights the need for a fundamental shift in how global governance operates, emphasizing inclusivity and stronger connections between institutions and people.

Impact

It set the tone for the subsequent discussions on reforming multilateral institutions and including diverse voices in decision-making processes.

One billion Africans will be born in the next generation alone, and I think by the close of this century, you can expect about three to four billion total more Africans to be born. When you think of the mega cities of the future, it’ll be cities like Lagos, cities like Dar es Salaam, cities like Mogadishu, where I was born.

Speaker

Abdullahi Alim

Reason

This comment provides a striking perspective on demographic shifts and urbanization in Africa, highlighting the continent’s growing importance in shaping the global future.

Impact

It shifted the conversation to focus more on the specific challenges and opportunities facing Africa, and the need for targeted strategies to support sustainable development in rapidly growing regions.

For Andean indigenous peoples, the time is not linear or chronological. It happens in Western cultures. For them, for example, the future is behind us, and the past is in front, and that is women carry on their kids, their children, on the back, because children are the future. And the past is in front because in front they find the wisdom of the elders.

Speaker

Paolo Baca

Reason

This comment introduces a fundamentally different cultural perspective on time and generations, challenging Western assumptions about the relationship between past, present, and future.

Impact

It broadened the discussion to include non-Western perspectives on intergenerational relationships and responsibility, encouraging participants to think beyond conventional frameworks.

I think my top priority, apart from many others that compete with this one, is governments must ensure that they have a plan to develop communities that demonstrate the power of social connection.

Speaker

Hina Jilani

Reason

This comment shifts the focus from abstract policy discussions to the importance of building strong, connected communities as a foundation for addressing future challenges.

Impact

It introduced a more human-centered perspective to the discussion, emphasizing the role of social cohesion in creating resilient societies capable of addressing long-term challenges.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by broadening its scope beyond traditional policy frameworks. They introduced diverse cultural perspectives, highlighted the specific challenges facing regions like Africa, and emphasized the importance of social connection and community-building. This led to a more nuanced and inclusive conversation about how to address long-term global challenges, incorporating voices and viewpoints from various sectors and cultures. The discussion evolved from abstract policy talk to considering practical, human-centered approaches to building a sustainable and equitable future for all generations.

Follow-up Questions

How can we reform international financial institutions to provide better access to financing for developing countries?

Speaker

Andrew Holness

Explanation

This is important to address capacity limitations of developing states in dealing with multidimensional challenges like climate change and debt sustainability.

What mechanisms can be developed to drive inter-jurisdictional models between national governments and indigenous peoples?

Speaker

Paolo Baca

Explanation

This is crucial for implementing intergenerational pacts and stopping deforestation in regions like the Amazon.

How can we restructure the way debt is measured and managed in Africa?

Speaker

Abdullahi Alim

Explanation

This is important because debt in Africa is primarily owned by the private sector and is significantly more expensive than in other parts of the world.

What strategies can be employed to advance export-oriented industrial policies in African countries?

Speaker

Abdullahi Alim

Explanation

This is crucial for increasing African countries’ gains in global supply chains and fostering economic development.

How can we create an intergenerational dialogue platform to ensure long-term thinking and planning in governance structures?

Speaker

Saumya Aggarwal

Explanation

This is important for incorporating youth perspectives in policymaking and decision-making processes.

What concrete actions can be taken to embed futures thinking in decision-making processes across national and local governments?

Speaker

Andrew Holness

Explanation

This is crucial for effective implementation of the Declaration on Future Generations and other global frameworks.

How can we develop communities that demonstrate the power of social connection to address issues like loneliness and social isolation?

Speaker

Hina Jilani

Explanation

This is important for fostering intergenerational connections and informing global governance on essential needs.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

Friday Closing Ceremony: Summit of the Future Action Days

Friday Closing Ceremony: Summit of the Future Action Days

Session at a Glance

Summary

This discussion focused on the outcomes of the Youth Action Day at the Summit of the Future, highlighting the importance of meaningful youth engagement in global decision-making processes. The event brought together young leaders, UN officials, and government representatives to discuss key issues affecting youth and future generations.

Deputy Secretary-General Amina Mohammed emphasized the significance of youth participation in shaping the future, particularly in areas such as peace and security, technology, and international financial architecture reform. Young rapporteurs presented recommendations from various thematic sessions, including gender equality, digital inclusion, intergenerational solidarity, climate action, and humanitarian efforts.

Key recommendations included ensuring youth representation in national delegations to UN processes, scaling support for youth-led initiatives, and integrating young people into global security dialogues. The importance of indigenous knowledge, multilingualism, and inclusive technology was also highlighted.

The discussion underscored the need for reforming democratic processes to better include youth voices and address global challenges. Participants stressed the importance of investing in education, capacity building, and creating opportunities for young people, especially in humanitarian contexts and for refugees.

Amina Mohammed concluded by emphasizing the UN’s commitment to placing youth at the helm of affairs and the importance of intergenerational collaboration in shaping a more inclusive and sustainable future. The event demonstrated the UN’s efforts to meaningfully engage youth in global governance and decision-making processes.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– The importance of meaningful youth engagement in policy and decision-making, especially for the Summit of the Future

– The need for intergenerational solidarity and equity in addressing global challenges

– Recommendations for inclusive digital futures and technology access for youth

– The role of youth in governance, peace, security and humanitarian action

– Calls for reforming international financial systems and governance structures to be more inclusive of youth voices

Overall purpose:

The discussion aimed to gather youth perspectives and recommendations on key global issues to inform the Summit of the Future and broader UN processes. It served as a platform for youth representatives to directly address UN leadership with their priorities and demands for meaningful inclusion.

Tone:

The tone was energetic, passionate and optimistic throughout. Speakers conveyed a sense of urgency about the need for youth voices to be heard, while also expressing hope about the potential for positive change if youth are genuinely engaged. The UN leadership responded encouragingly, reinforcing the importance of youth participation.

Speakers

Based on the transcript, the main speakers and moderators were:

– Felipe Paullier – Moderator/facilitator, Assistant Secretary General for Youth Affairs

– Amina Jane Mohammed – Main speaker, Deputy Secretary General of the United Nations

– Isidora – Youth rapporteur, activist from Chile focused on gender equality and inclusion

– Zongxu Xie – Youth rapporteur, PhD researcher from China

– Jana Zghabi – Youth rapporteur, university student passionate about global policies

– Leticia – Youth rapporteur, indigenous woman from Ecuador

– Aryan Sanghrajka – Youth rapporteur, young leader for refugees, migration and human rights

– Martin Manyozo – Youth rapporteur, founder of Clean Cities Project focused on climate action

– DJ Cuppy – Master of Ceremony/DJ

The transcript indicates these were the main speakers, with Felipe Paullier moderating and the youth rapporteurs presenting recommendations from different thematic sessions. Amina Jane Mohammed provided responses and closing remarks as the senior UN official present.

Full session report

Youth Action Day at the Summit of the Future: A Comprehensive Overview

The Youth Action Day at the Summit of the Future brought together young leaders, UN officials, and government representatives to discuss key issues affecting youth and future generations. The event, moderated by Felipe Paullier, Assistant Secretary General for Youth Affairs, featured Amina Jane Mohammed, Deputy Secretary General of the United Nations, as the main speaker, alongside several youth rapporteurs presenting recommendations from various thematic sessions held in different rooms.

Key Themes and Discussions

Felipe Paullier opened the event by challenging the myth of youth political apathy, stating, “Today we have demonstrated that young people are interested and capable of engaging at the highest level.” He highlighted the visual projection of recommendations and mentioned the “fishbowl” where additional suggestions were placed.

Jana Zghabi, speaking on youth inclusion, advocated for increased youth representation in national delegations to UN processes. She emphasized, “We need to advance the commitments laid out in UN Security Council Resolution 2250 on Youth, Peace and Security.”

Zongxu Xie focused on technology and digital inclusion, stressing the importance of ensuring digital skills are accessible through education. He stated, “We need to view youth as active participants and co-creators, rather than passive recipients of policies and technologies.”

Martin Manyozo called for structured laws to empower youth in decision-making processes, saying, “We need concrete, actionable recommendations for youth empowerment in governance structures.”

Leticia, an indigenous woman from Ecuador, began her speech in Kichwa before switching to Spanish. She emphasized the importance of combining traditional knowledge with technology to address climate challenges, stating, “Youth are leaders in caring for the environment.”

Aryan Sanghrajka, a young leader for refugees, migration and human rights, called for scaling up support for youth-led humanitarian action. He emphasized, “We need to ensure young refugees move beyond education into decent work and invest in displaced youth potential and leadership.”

Isidora, an activist from Chile, advocated for establishing consultative mechanisms with young people, especially those with disabilities.

Amina Mohammed’s Closing Remarks

Amina Mohammed reinforced many of the points raised by the youth speakers. She highlighted the potential of technology to connect people and provide equal opportunities, stating, “Technology can be used to leapfrog development and equalise capacities across the world.”

On climate change, Mohammed identified it as an entry point for youth engagement. She also agreed on the need to address root causes of displacement and humanitarian crises, praising Chad’s response to refugees as an example.

Mohammed emphasized the UN’s commitment to placing youth at the helm of affairs and the importance of an intergenerational approach to shaping the future. She also stressed the significance of democracy and addressing humanitarian crises, stating, “We need to ensure that democracy delivers for people.”

Event Conclusion

Felipe Paullier acknowledged the UN staff and the Youth Office team for their contributions.

The event concluded with a performance by DJ Cuppy, who expressed her excitement about participating in the Youth Action Day and her commitment to youth empowerment.

This Youth Action Day demonstrated a strong commitment to meaningful youth engagement in global governance and decision-making processes. It highlighted the potential of young people to contribute to solving global challenges across various domains, from climate action to humanitarian efforts, while emphasizing the need for structural changes to empower youth and the value of intergenerational approaches in shaping a more inclusive and sustainable future.

Session Transcript

Felipe Paullier: Hello. Good afternoon. How are you? Welcome back. That’s great. So, welcome to everyone to this ECOSOC Youth Chamber, I can say, because it’s quite different than what it’s usually done. And I’m very excited to be here. I’m Felipe Paullier, Assistant Secretary General for Youth Affairs, and we’re here for the closure of this Youth Action Day in the Summit of the Future. So let’s start with a lot of energy, and I invite you to join on this stage a very special guest we have to end this Action Day at the highest level. And I invite all of you in the room to receive her with all your energy, the Deputy Secretary General, Ms. Amina Mohammed. Please join us on stage. It’s very nice how this chamber looks from this side. And you know, this has been a crazy but incredible day, from the opening ceremony to the dialogue with the Secretary General of the United Nations, to all of the thematic sessions. I think that this day is a clear testament that youth political apathy is a complete myth. This day has shown us the interest, the capacity. of young people to engage at the highest level. So, during all of the thematic sessions in this afternoon, substantial discussions took place. A lot of energy got into this room, but also the conference forum, the trusteeship council, and everything that happened will be compiled in one outcome document that will reflect the actions that young people identified as priority areas in the implementation of the pact for the future and beyond. And after this brief introduction, I want to ask our guest, the Deputy Secretary General, we want to hear from you. I want to ask you, why do you think this is an important day? And why do you think that it’s important that we advance on more meaningful youth engagement when it’s about policy and decision making, especially in the frameworks of the summit of the future? DSG?

Amina Jane Mohammed: Okay, no pressure. Thank you very much, everyone. It’s fantastic to have you all in this room. If you were not in this room, it wouldn’t look like this, I can assure you. It would look like the ECOSOC chamber, the trusteeship chambers that we understand and know, so why is it important to have you here? Well, first, I’m not going to take the whole blame. There is a gentleman who is in the corner there, very quietly, and that is Guy Ryder, who runs the show for the summit of the future. And really important was his conviction that without youth starting off the summit of the future, what’s the point of the future if we can’t address that now? And if we can’t address that with those of the vision, those of the energy, and those really with the ideas that are going to make this work. He brought in for us the word meaningful. And we took that seriously every step of the way when we spoke with you, Philippe, that if it wasn’t meaningful, then of course everyone would say we ticked the box and what happened, what next? So really important that you’re here today. We didn’t know that today, perhaps tomorrow, but we hope today, would be when we would get to agreeing the pact. And I think, you know, you brought in a certain energy and spirit that that helps us to get over those difficult hurdles where, as yet, not enough young people in the room negotiating. And if there were, we probably would have a pact that was the ambition that we really want. But it just might happen, and it’s happening because you’re here in this room. What difference is this all going to make? A lot of difference. First, if you look at the pact, it’s about meeting commitments. And there’s still six years to go on the SDGs. So it’s important that you take whatever you got out of these rooms and you reinforce the momentum and the pressure that we need on governments, on leaders, and on everyone at country level, at the regional level, and the global level to get the SDGs done. And we’re not done until we get there. And when we get there, we’ll have another look at them. But until then, you cannot give up on the life of every single one that is being left behind today. The SDGs matter. The second is that we’ve got these three really important areas that we have to dig into. And this is what you’ve been talking about. And essentially, you will be the energy, the wind beneath the wings of this. It is peace and security. And we have to think about women peace and security and youth peace and security. And that’s gonna be at the core of finding ways to get out of the conflicts that we have today. It just doesn’t reside in these halls. We play a big role or not. But it is you in these very, very tough environments. The second of those three big important things is the new era of technology. You know it best. And are you going to… Shape the narrative and really what it is that we do with technology We can help to put guardrails around it. But in the end, it will be you that determine what happens with technology You’re using it already. It’s an extension of you In my generation, we’re still catching up SG will tell you he’s still analog. I think I’m a little better because of my six kids But I have to tell you it’s yours and it’s yours to make or break and we will give you the tools To try to help in that world. Last but not least, Philippe, I think it’s the international financial architecture Sounds incredibly technical, but essentially it is about the means of implementation It’s about resources, finance, money And where is it? And SG this morning talked about power And the power in this world is where money is and that money has to be accessed to invest in each and every one of Our futures much more equally than it has been done today And so when we look at the financial architecture that was designed and I’m going to underscore it here by a few men a few years Ago today, we’re redesigning it with a few more women and it has to be inclusive, responsive, and fit for purpose And that’s what we need in order to have the fuel for the SDGs, for the technology, for everything that you’ve agreed to this afternoon

Felipe Paullier: Thank You DSG Thank you Thank you for bringing Guy into the conversation because he’s I think the most humble UN official I have met but he’s always and he’s a real youth champion and And that’s why we are here, you know since the beginning pure support for this to happen and So now we are getting into the core of this conversation DSG. So I will invite by two, six young rapporteurs, six young experts, young people that were participating in each of the thematic sessions, and they will come here to share what are the outcomes of these conversations. And I will initially invite two incredible young leaders, Isidora and Zongxu, to join us on stage. Let’s give him a lot of energy, and her. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Welcome Isidora. Welcome Isidora. So before I give Isidora and Zongxu the floor, I want to draw everyone’s attention to one fact, that is that during this session we will have the visual projection of the recommendations of the six thematic sessions on screen by the fantastic job that the artist Malik Afegbua has done, symbolizing the path that we need to take towards a more just, inclusive and sustainable future. And I have noticed that both rapporteurs, they are bringing something with them and I think that’s something for the DSG but I will let them to explain what’s that about. So I will start with Isidora. Isidora, eres un activista de Chile. You’re an activist from Chile and you work on gender equality and inclusion and you have been following the discussions in the gender meeting and the slogan of inclusion. So what would you like to share with us? What would you like to share about the recommendations from that meeting?

Isidora: First of all I had prepared what I wanted to say in English so that everyone could understand but I’m gonna give you some context in Spanish and then I’m going to finish in Spanish too. Participating in this meeting was really an amazing experience for me and it was very exciting because for the first time me as an activist and I have been working with the UN for quite a while now as young leaders for SDGs and I’ve been part of UN Women as well, it was amazing to put things into practice and look at intersectionality and diversity for women in different contexts and realities in different countries and that really gave me some hope. Hope because we can really see that a reality is possible where every person despite their differences is able to participate and so I’ll start with the recommendation saying that first of all let’s seek to establish consultative mechanisms working with young people so allowing all of us to participate in equal conditions in particular persons with disabilities and women with disabilities. We need to be seen, we shouldn’t go unnoticed, we shouldn’t be left behind. Let’s also try and establish good practices like generation equality. the UN Trust Fund for Ending Violence Against Women and Girls and lastly we need to establish mechanisms that bolster accountability for gender because when we come to these spaces our speeches sound great but when it comes to putting things into practice we need to be the leaders of the future so why not give us the tools so that we can become those leaders? By way of conclusion I want to say that even thinking about my own reality I’m actually quite a lucky person as a Chilean young person a Latin American woman with a disability and I’m here in front of you despite the challenges that we face representing people due to systemic issues are present in societies in their countries and due to those reasons aren’t able to be here today and I think that today’s meeting is very important because when we think about diversity when we think about inclusion we wonder how will we put things into practice will that be possible and then we realize at this meeting that through multilateralism through intergenerational participation we can do it we can hear from different realities and hear about different experiences so for example care economic support for persons with disabilities that’s something that we don’t hear about that much but we did hear about it at this meeting we had a testimony from someone who lived that experience

Felipe Paullier: Gracias Isidora, thank you Isidora and I will want now to give the floor to Zongxu. Zongxu you are a PhD researcher and the co-founder of Xingua Global Youth Dialogue in China and you joined the session on inclusive digital future so please can you share with us tell us more about the recommendations questions that came from that group, you have the floor.

Zongxu Xie: Distinguished Her Excellency Amina Mohammed, His Excellency Felipe Paullier, colleagues, my young peers from all countries, greetings. My name is Zongxu Xie from Guizhou, China, a Ph.D. researcher in hydraulic engineering at Tsinghua University. It is an honor today to report on our discussion as a youth repertoire and share my thoughts on how to jointly build and promote a more inclusive digital future. Youth is the most dynamic and creative group in society. In the era of rapid digitalization, my hometown of Guizhou has provided new development opportunities for young people by vigorously developing the digital economy. Guizhou empowers rural revitalization through e-commerce and live streaming and promotes ecological civilization and green development through digital technology, making it a vivid case of digitalization transforming the development opportunities for young people in the region. In our discussion today, we should note that despite the abundant resources in many parts of the world, inadequate resource allocation and access continues to limit the development potential of young people. Realizing value in the wave of digital economy development requires equal opportunities. Today, we put forward the following three key actions to achieve the above-mentioned goal. First, ensure skills are accessible through digital education. We should ensure that every youth, especially those in less developed regions, can access the necessary digital skills. Second, more cross-border cooperation and more technology sharing. Governments, businesses, and CSOs should join hands to ensure an equitable distribution of technological resources. Cross-border cooperation will narrow the technology gap, bridge the digital divide, and eliminate digital technical barriers so that every young person can equally enjoy the dividends from digitalization and AI, and thus can better integrate into modern society. Third, strengthen youth participation towards better policy formulation. Young people’s voice must be fully respected, and they should be invited to participate in the development of technology and digital policies. By establishing an effective feedback mechanism, we can ensure that young people’s perspectives are valued and incorporated into practice, making the co-created digital ecosystem more representative and effective. Dear colleagues, an inclusive digital future is not only our philosophy but our mission. Today, many speakers have emphasized that youth are not only passive recipients of technology and education, but rather active participants and co-creators. By working together, we surely can build a digital era from which every young person can benefit. I thank you.

Felipe Paullier: Thank you, Zongxu. And thank you both for speaking your native languages. I think that’s the beauty of this organization, and multilingualism is something crucial for us. So thank you for it. DSG, we would like to hear your reflections about these recommendations.

Amina Jane Mohammed: Thank you so much. Thank you.

Felipe Paullier: I’m not sure how to translate.

Amina Jane Mohammed: I’m just joking. But I think the real point of this is that languages speak so much closer to our hearts. And they shape the way in which we interpret and that we feel things and want to communicate. And I think that that’s one of the big asks that we should have of the future and technology. But thank you both very much for your briefs of what must have been a very difficult discussion to summarize in three minutes, right? On the first, an inclusivity. Having an inclusive conversation, agenda, society, outcomes is really difficult. And each one of the steps of the way is important. And I think recognizing first and foremost that our 8 billion people are incredibly diverse. And in understanding that diversity from the lowest level of our community is the beginning for me. And not a top-down approach in trying to identify and represent and put people into cookie cutter regions and countries. Each country is incredibly different and has different expectations. So I hope that when you spoke and what spoke to me most of all was the consultative processes that we have. They have not to be an exercise in whether we have had one or not, but how we plan to have one, what the agenda is, broadening it and deepening it, and ensuring that we follow through on these agenda. Even if we choose to agree to disagree or we don’t do something about it, feedback. If I’ve heard anything in terms of what perhaps people don’t do so well is the feedback. So you don’t know what your meaningful discussion resulted in. And it may not result in something that comes within the next 24 hours or even year. But I think a continuous dialogue of feeding in and feeding out and back to make that happen. Of course, you talked about disability. And I think that that for us has been one of the major issues that we’ve had to deal with here in a real way. So we have all the policies and the tools, and we try to make accessibility. much better, but I think we’re very far from really making this something that we do in our daily work, not just here in the UN, but across the UN in different countries and offices. So on the inclusivity, nothing of our future can work or will it make impact if we don’t look at the most vulnerable and the smallest member of our families. That should be the litmus test as to whether we’ve succeeded in an agenda or not. So thank you. On the technology, that’s even, you know, as I said, it was one of the three things after the SDG commitments of what is important and listening to access is really important because not everyone will have that access. In fact, hundreds of millions of people don’t. The skill sets that go with them and perhaps in those that feel that they could be left behind with technology, this is a time for us to leapfrog. It’s a time for us not to go through the same methods that we have to include people, but to say this is a chance for us to equalize the world in its capacities. That’s going to require one of the three areas I spoke to, financing. So my reflections on this are that you’ve got it all right, technology sharing, the development that you’re co-creating and you’re not being fed it, but you’re actually shaping the future with technology as a tool to connect and to provide that prosperous world where people and the planet are taken care of. So I very much look forward to working with you on that and thank you for the recommendations.

Felipe Paullier: Thank you. So thank you, Isi. Thank you, Sendu. And what do you want to do with those letters?

Zongxu Xie: I want to put the envelope inside.

Felipe Paullier: That’s good.

Isidora: Yeah, that’s for you to read our recommendations that came from us.

Felipe Paullier: That’s great. Thank you. And let’s put it on the fishbowl. So now, thank you both. And I will invite, in a few minutes, to the next of our rapporteurs to join us on stage. So I want to invite now Jana and Leticia to join us on stage. Let’s give them a lot of energy also. They also need it. During this afternoon also, there were two different sessions in another room, the one that is next to this one, in the Trusteeship Council, running under the same principle of equity. And we have now two of the rapporteurs from those sessions that discuss one of it, intergenerational solidarity, and the other one was discussing about foresight for climate and sustainability. I will start with Jana. Jana, you are a university student passionate about global policies. Can you please share with us what are the recommendations that emerge from this session on intergenerational equity and solidarity? The floor is yours.

Jana Zghabi: Distinguished Deputy Secretary General, esteemed delegates, and honored guests, assalamu alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh. I am Jana Zghabi, and it’s an honor to stand before you today as a proud representative of the Misk Foundation and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. I had the privilege of attending the thematic session Intergenerational Solidarity and Equity for a Shared Future. This session highlighted the importance of connecting generations to address the concerns, aspirations, and issues we currently face. And I’m here to present a few recommendations that emerged from those discussions. First, youth representation must be prioritized. Member states should commit to having meaningful youth involvement in national delegations to UN processes and conferences, fulfilling Article 39 of the Declaration. Youth are not only the leaders of tomorrow, but the changemakers of today, and our voices must be heard in the halls where decisions are made. Second, long-term thinking is essential. By leveraging science, data, statistics, and strategic foresight, member states can ensure governance structures that are both adaptable and forward-looking, in line with Article 35. These tools provide a roadmap for creating policies that are resilient to the uncertainties of the future. Finally, we must urgently reform the international financial architecture. This includes establishing a sovereign debt workout mechanism and embracing metrics beyond GDP. Financial systems should prioritize the people, not just the profits, and pave the way for equitable global development. In closing, the future of global governance depends on how well we listen to and act on the needs of young people today. It’s time to build a system that empowers youth and protects future generations. We the youth are not only the leaders of the future, we are the ones holding the torches for change today, and our opinions and contributions guide decision-makers and shed light on angles that they may not be aware of.

Felipe Paullier: Thank you. Leticia, It’s great to have you up on the stage. You are a young woman from the Kichwa-Otavalo people of Ecuador, and the first person to in your community to go to university. You participated in the Foresight Meeting for Climatic and Environmental Sustainability, and it would be great if you could share the recommendations from that meeting with us. Thank you. Go ahead.

Leticia: Thank you, Felipe. My native language is Kichwa, and, okay, it’s a joke. I’m sure that, at least for one second, it felt a bit strange. You were probably thinking, what’s she saying? Is she going to just end up only speaking her native language, Kichwa? What you felt at that second is something that indigenous populations, rural populations, have felt for a long time, for decades. They don’t know how to react to the disasters that they often face. So, I’m sure that, at least for one second, it felt a bit strange. You were probably thinking, what’s she saying? Is she going to just end up only speaking her native language, Kichwa? What you felt at that second is something that indigenous populations, rural populations, have felt for a long time, for decades. So, I’m sure that, at least for one second, it felt a bit strange. So, I’m sure that, at least for one second, it felt a bit strange. So, I’m sure that, at least for one second, it felt a bit strange. drought is increasing poverty among our populations in our countries, that’s such a frustrating feeling because we don’t have the tools that we need to control these disasters, not even to prevent them. And the truth is that I came with the intention of raising awareness about the situation that my country is going through due to drought and due to the huge amount of fires that we’re having in my country, but not only in my country, but rather in all countries in South America and not even only in South America, across the world actually, we’re seeing so many fires that are burning our natural resources. So against this backdrop, I want to mention that traditional and ancestral knowledge of indigenous peoples are also being undervalued as time goes on because the climate crisis affects our way of life and our natural resources to a huge extent, to the extent that our traditional knowledge cannot beat it, we can’t fight against it. Our water is increasingly polluted because we’re seeing more and more powerful chemical treatments and then we can’t reuse water because it’s polluted and due to these crises, we as the team here at this meeting have some recommendations. So the first recommendation I want to share with you is that we young people shouldn’t only be participating because we’re young, but because we have innovative ideas and because we combine knowledge and technology and we can have more impact, more impact and clout when it comes to caring for our environment and we can also make decisions at round tables, in political fora. So that’s my first recommendation. My next recommendation is for us to have… recognition, for our role as leaders to be legitimized in the traditional governance structure. That way, we can benefit from knowledge, technical assistance, and we can better help our countries and the initiatives that we’re working on. And number three, because there are a few recommendations, there were several actually, so I’ve just focused on the three main ones, which is dealing with the benefits and risks of digitalization initiatives for youth. As a woman from the global south, I want to tell you that first of all, we need to look at what problems each of our countries face. In my country, technological transfer has been very low. However, I think we can pull our traditional knowledge with technology and change the situation. I hope that that will be the case. Thank you.

Felipe Paullier: Gracias, Leticia. Thank you, Leticia, for bringing these recommendations. And thank you both, Jana and Leticia. And now, if you want, Leticia, you can also drop the recommendations of your session in this fishbowl. And I will invite you to change with the two next rapporteurs. But before that, DSG.

Amina Jane Mohammed: Thank you very much. And both incredibly important recommendations, particularly on the intergenerational aspect of this. It is about how we include you. I think this youth summit has been the beginning of that, but you have to make so many more demands that start from the country level. We could, and you could, a couple of your countries that would be willing to put in a resolution that makes that so for all meetings that are attended in the United Nations that youth are in the delegations. This is something you can do with the youth office. But that goes through a number of processes, and 193 family members is a lot of people to agree. And I would suggest that you begin to do this in parallel at the level of your countries. And there are many countries who are putting youth in their delegation. Just make sure it’s not token to the high-level week, that it’s in every delegation that comes here for the important discussions that are discussed at, you know, the CSW or the commission that we have on the rights of persons with disabilities. These are all important opportunities, so let that happen. We had at one point agreed here in the UN that we wouldn’t have panels that were just men, that we would try to find parity, and we wouldn’t attend panels with just men on them. Not in every issue can one do that, because this is not… We haven’t gotten to the mainstream yet, so on the peace and security side of our house, really hard. But you could say that about panels, that, you know, we would not attend panels where there is not at least one member of the panel, or, you know, one out of four are women and one with disabilities, and, you know, and we go on down to make sure that when you see the panel, you feel included. You see yourself in that panel. This matters, you know, what is visible to everyone is what is the beginning of change. We begin to normalize this and not see it as just a one-off, so I hope that we can take that from you as we do. And on the, of course, international financial architecture, that is, too, about what we do with long-term thinking. The implications of not being able to meet commitments today will affect future generations. Things don’t stand still. Climate change doesn’t stand still. It’s crossing borders. It is impacting life in ways that sometimes we are irreversible. And that has a financial cost. And so when we talk about the long-term thinking, technology, in the UN, we’re trying to brace up for our UN 2.0 that looks at the quintet of change. Data is a big part of it. But so is behavioral change. So is foresight. And I think all of these matter to what we’re saying. And I picked up the issue that you talked about with the sustainable debt, GDP. We cannot continue to measure things the way we did decades ago. This is a different environment. There are different challenges and, obviously, concerns that people need to be included. So really important. And last but not least, voice. That matters. And we need to find better ways to bring that in in an intergenerational way. Thank you, Leticia, for talking about how we are going to deal with it. First of all, again, it’s an inclusion, right? And when you first started to speak your language, it took me back to my visit to the Amazon not long ago. And I don’t think a picture, or even talking about it, can express what an asset we have. And the people that we met there, the kind of solutions that they will bring to our lives, I don’t know what it is that we’re doing, squirreling away for three, four years, when they will tell you in a few hours how to solve these problems. We need to give equal respect and space to indigenous solutions in the lives that we have today. They will not be sustainable if we don’t. The world is changing fast. And we also are saying that we’re one family, one humanity, but unless we use the tools that we have at our disposal to make those connections, to make sure that we’re all able to connect in this room, as I’m sure we connected here with people who are not in this room. But if COVID showed us one thing, we really were not alone. We were, maybe physically, we’re just down to our families or our friends, but it suddenly opened up a whole new world. When we were meeting, we were meeting with people that we couldn’t see. But out there were hundreds and thousands of people that were engaging, and we couldn’t always take on everything. But there was a connection there, technology made that happen. And I think that that’s what we need to make sure happens, is that we’re not just talking about across countries, but within the depths of each country. Who is in there? Who are we leaving behind? Map and identify that, and make sure, again, that everyone is connected. And we need to put targets on that, and not just, they are in the resolutions in principle. Implement the resolutions country by country. Use the UN. The UN is present in over 131 countries. It’s incumbent upon them to respond to your needs, because that’s why we’re there. So every time you see us in any one of your countries, please reach out, and let’s make sure that happens. Climate change is a really good entry point for this, because I think we all understand that this is an existential threat to our humanity and to the home as we know it. So use the momentum of climate. The sustainable development agenda, it’s about everything. And we need to use that in an integrated way. So out of the silos, when we talk about indigenous people, let’s not just wait until they meet. Let’s actually talk about them as an everyday member of the family, and that every issue we discuss, we need to ask, where are those with disabilities? Where are those with languages that are not in the six that we have, but we have the tools to do so? Guy, I think you remember recently, we saw the SG speaking Chinese. We know the SG doesn’t speak Chinese, but I can tell you that you wouldn’t know. And that actually connected him to people, because he was speaking in their language. So tools can do things to, I think, make us much closer, much more respectful and inclusive, and more understanding of the assets that this world has to offer and that we can use for good.

Felipe Paullier: Thank you DSG. Thank you once again Jana and Leticia. So this session is starting to wrap up and as we come into the last segment I want to invite two, the last but not the least, guests we want to have in our session to tell us about what happened in their rooms. So Martin and Aryan, welcome to this stage. So Martin and Aryan are joining us bringing the outcomes of the sessions that were happening on the conference room floor. That one was on governance for human rights, peace and security and political processes and the other one was on innovative solutions in humanitarian action. And I will start with Aryan. So Aryan, you are an award-winning young leader for refugees, migration and human rights and at the age of 14 you found it, forced to flee. So can you please share with us about the outcomes of the humanitarian session? The floor is yours.

Aryan Sanghrajka: Thank you Felipe. Deputy Secretary General, excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, my name is Aryan Sanghrajka and I’m the global focal point of the Migration, Youth and Children platform. Today’s session on forced displacement and humanitarian context reminded me of two key things. The need to be bold in our ambitions and inclusive in our actions. Listening to the messages of young refugees, I couldn’t help but think of my grandmother. She was just 24 years old when she was forcibly displaced from Uganda in 1972. Forced displacement, then and now, is a tragic reality for millions of young children and youth around the world. But as my grandma is a testament, displacement doesn’t strip away resilience, it amplifies it. The tenacity, determination, and drive to overcome obstacles is alive in every young person and displaced leader today who refuses to let circumstances define their future. And the messages from youth, the UN system, and governments were clear. First, a need to scale support for youth-led action, delivering on the Compact for Young People and Humanitarian Actions objective. Multi-stakeholder support and platforms are essential for providing young people with the expertise, technical assistance, and accessible funding they need to turn their ideas into solutions. In forced displacement and protracted crises around the world, young innovators are already making an impact. With the right support, they can go further, faster. And second, we must ensure that young refugees move beyond education and into decent work. Access to quality education, training, employment, and entrepreneurship opportunities through programs like the Youth on the Move Fellowship has the potential to change lives. By supporting young refugees out of education and into work, and ensuring they have the means to access them, we can also rescue our current trajectory to achieve the SDGs by 2030. And finally, change cannot happen without investment. An investment which puts youth-led solutions on the fast track to success. An investment which unlocks the potential, talent, and leadership of young refugees and migrants. And an investment which creates a true, unshakable partnership with young displaced people by giving them an equal seat at the decision-making table. And crucially, to every young migrant, refugee, asylum seeker, and displaced person, invest in yourselves. Invest in yourselves to be an unequivocal force for peace and the development of our planet and its people. because the time to sit on the sidelines has passed. Action is truly no longer optional. The energy, attention, and revitalization youth have brought to addressing forced displacement and humanitarian crises cannot and must not fade when we leave this room today, because our common vision, led by and for young people, starts with action right here and right now. Thank you very much.

Felipe Paullier: Thank you, Aryane, and Martin, you’re the founder and the executive director of Clean Cities Project, which focuses on climate action, but we want us to share about the outcomes of the session on governance.

Martin Manyozo: Great. Honorable Deputy Secretary General, distinguished guests, and fellow young leaders, I stand before you today to share with you the recommendations from today’s governance thematic section and emphasize on the core and critical role that young people must play in order to shape the future of peace, security, and governance. Our world today is facing complex challenges, and the solutions to these issues demand youth active participation. It is no longer enough to have youth at the margins. We must empower them to take lead in decision-making processes that affect not only their future, but even our shared world. And the first recommendation is, youth must be empowered in global policy and global security decision-making. Platforms such as the Summit for the Future, Peace Building, Architecture Review, and Security Council Reform offer critical opportunities to integrate young people into global security dialogues. Meaningful engagement requires prioritizing education, capacity building, and transitional cooperation. Addressing systematic barriers that prevent youth from engaging in peace and security discussions will allow them to become true stakeholders in global governance. Structured laws for youth must be created in these spaces, giving them the power to shape decisions rather than simply observe them. And the second recommendation is, it is essential to advance the commitments laid out in the United Nations Security Council Resolution 2020-50. Toxnic engagement of youth is no longer acceptable, and I believe young people in here can agree with me. Young people should not only be heard, but their voices should be embedded within peace and security processes. This involves investing in youth-led organizations, increasing financing to support their initiatives. The youth peace and security agenda will not only be and will not never be effective if comprehensive strategies and dedicated funding are implemented, enabling youth to lead, protect, and transform their communities. Thirdly, and the third recommendation is, youth must be engaged to be essential stakeholders in governance and violence prevention. Governments and international organizations should collaborate with young people to co-design and co-implement violence prevention strategies, programs, and policies. Institutions need to become inclusive, responsive, and accountable to youth voices. At every stage of program, development from conceptualization to evaluation, youth feedback must be integral. Their insights and experiences are critical to creating a lasting peace. Finally, the global community must really commit to peace, youth protection, and human rights. Countries worldwide are calling for an immediate and permanent ceasefire in all conflict zones. They demand the protection of civilians. They demand the protection of civilians, vulnerable population and aid workers as well as facilitation of humanitarian and medical need and aid to those in need, especially in fragile and conflict related and affected legions. Immediate action is necessary and youth voices must lead to these efforts. In conclusion, empowering youth with the legal decision-making processes and power, ensuring financing in their actions and efforts and promoting their lives and safety in all areas are critical and a critical step forward to a more peaceful, secure future. Deputy Secretary General, distinguished guests, young people in here and millions of young people watching us around the world, the meaningful inclusion of young people in global policy, global governance is not a light or it’s not just an option. Rather, it is a responsibility and we must act now. Thank you.

Felipe Paullier: Yes, Jane.

Amina Jane Mohammed: I think they said it all. I’m gonna start from the last speaker because I believe that we’re talking about governance that is rooted really in a functioning democracy. I think everyone in this room believes in the values of democracy but I think we can also all agree that the model itself is breaking, fragile, not performing in many of our countries and what we are seeing is a response to that, whether it is a unconstitutional change or it is protests or we are finding more terrorism, whatever it is, it’s democracy not functioning and I think today we are reinforcing that message to everyone back at home that we need to take that seriously and with, you know, the majority, the largest cohort of youth in the world, if we don’t, I think we’re just in really big trouble. We’re in big enough trouble as it is but it will get worse so states need to listen. Cities need to listen. The transforming education summit we had, you talked for capacity building. I’m not sure that that’s the Band-Aid we need. We need to be teaching people from the time that they go into school to the time that they leave, which is lifelong learning, about what you do to keep peaceful societies, how you lift and fight and protect democracies, and that it doesn’t just become an activity or a campaign. This is a lifelong endeavor to make that environment where the rule of law, people’s rights, ought not to be what we are asking for as an add-on or an activity. And we’ve lost it somehow. So maybe this is one of the things that we take out of the summit of the future, is how to do that reset and to make sure that truly, truly our voices are embedded in the fabric of democracy, human rights, and freedom for everyone. Thank you for that. Humanitarian action, people on the move. And people on the move are finding themselves in different, fragile, precarious situations where atrocities that are being committed today and many not seen should not be happening, not in 2024. When I recently visited the border of Sudan and Chad, the famine in Sudan is conflict-related. That means it’s man-made. And I can assure you there’s no woman’s hand in that except the suffering, the rape, the death of many children, the atrocities that are committed in the name of men fighting each other. That has to stop. That cannot be continued. It’s not acceptable. And women can no longer be used as a end to war. This is happening in every environment where you see a humanitarian crisis. It will be young people who are losing their futures. I’m so grateful that you’re really talking about what that environment looks like. don’t put our life on hold because we’re in a camp or we are fleeing, but there’s an education and after an education, there needs to be a livelihood and a livelihood to connect us. And with technology today, I mean, your home is where it is and in many places, it’s not where you would wish. And so how can we make sure that you’re not missing those opportunities and that you are included? And so, you know, take your message. Let’s not put your lives on hold. Let’s make sure that you are engaged and let’s really ask those who have made commitments to ensure that we save lives, that we understand we have to save livelihoods lest we lose the lives tomorrow. And the donors that we have that have really dug deep to do the best that they can, sadly, it’s just not enough. And I’m sure if you ask the average taxpayer in many of our countries, will they dig deeper to save a life or a livelihood? They will say yes, especially when they see the majority of these people were speaking about a young people and they are women. So let’s increase that and make sure that we have it so that we can scale what you’ve just talked about. It’s possible, there’s for sure we have the tools and I’ll say something for Chad. Chad is one of the poorest countries on God’s earth and they’ve received almost 2 million refugees and people that are displaced. What does that say for their generosity? They got poorer. They opened up their schools that in the end collapsed under the weight of the number of people that came and their hospitals that have collapsed and their health systems that have collapsed because they cannot bear the burden of a million or two million more people. In some parts of this world, we’re complaining about 10,000 and when we look at what we have, there surely is no justice in that. And so for an oasis of Chad that all around it is conflict, we must find the resources to put into those humanitarian crises so that when Chad sees itself in a village of poverty but opens its doors to everyone who is fleeing for safety, they should then get a dividend in a return that turns that village into a township, a township that has recognized that people must live together. especially those that are fleeing. No one wants to leave home. And the day that you have to leave home and you have open arms, we as a human family should be supporting that in every way that we can because this is part of our human family, it’s one of us. It could be us if we were born in a different place. And I think that’s what we all have to remember, there’s no one is not at risk of this and particularly when we talk about climate now in terms of our people on the move. So let’s dig deeper. We will certainly try to do that to respond better. We are already in our agencies that are our humanitarian heroes who are out there every day, but we’re also looking to see how can we start crossing these pillars of development of human rights of the political pillars to get a better understanding of how to make this work together. Ultimately, it’s about an end to conflict. And for that, we need young people, we need women, we need the political will, most of all, we need leaders. Today, we are quoting many, many leaders and often they’ve already gone. Can we talk about leaders today, incumbent upon them when they sit in a position of power, elected to power, that they have accountability? They are in this building in the next week or so. I hope many of you will stay behind and pass those messages in the halls. Don’t wait until you get into a room like this. Just as the SG said, you want power, you take it. Step in front of someone, I have a message for you. I know that you’re the president of this country, probably breaking protocol, don’t quote me. But I was once an activist. I didn’t wait for someone to give me permission to talk to a leader if I found the opportunity when I know that things are in terrible shape. So thank you for this. Thank you very much.

Felipe Paullier: Thank you, Martin, Aryan. And thank you also for leaving these recommendations in this. Thank you, guys. It was a pleasure to have you. So, I want to start to wrap up now, and want to thank not only the six rapporteurs, but all the young people, all the ministers, all the ambassadors, all the government officials that were in these conversations, and that brought us these recommendations. I also want to acknowledge the whole process and the whole work behind these recommendations. They are not only emerging from these rooms, from what happened this afternoon. They are echoing the recommendations and the demands we have heard before. In the ECOSOC Youth Forum, in the SDG Summit last year, or in the UN Civil Society Conference in the road to the summit of the future. And these recommendations need to be the foundation that drives action in the implementation of the pact for the future and beyond. And we are able to be here today and to have this space because many, many people were working also for it to happen. So, I want also to acknowledge and to thank all the amazing staff in this house, from the security guards, from the translators, to all the people working in the funds programs, agencies, member states, governments, that allow us to be here. And let me specifically and very especially recognize my team, the United Nations Youth Office team, for all the care and heart they put into this process. Thank you. and it’s clear, youth lead for the future. So I would like to invite you to give us some closing remarks after all this whole session we had this day.

Amina Jane Mohammed: So I have a four-page speech. And that’s one of the things that you have now, I think, blown out of the water. We don’t need that speech. I just heard from Philippe my marching orders. So thank you for that. Those marching orders, I believe, are in those love letters that you’ve given to the Secretary General, Guy Ryder, and myself. Thank you, Guy, for actually making this meaningful, and that we are here with our UN teams for doing that. The Secretary General said this morning, when asked the question about which world he would choose, and he talked about not choosing one, but building one. I think that’s a big message for us to take away, because life is about the years you have ahead of you, and each one is how do you make each step count more inclusively, more meaningfully, with more action and call to action for all the things that you’ve talked about here today. For us at the United Nations, we have taken this on board. I think you will see most of what you have said in the Pact of the Future. These conversations we’ve been having to plan this day that began the UN Summit of the Future and the High-Level Week, I think is an example of where we place youth, and I’m not going to say at the center, but at the helm of affairs, and in that intergenerational march forward, where we are co-creating, we are collaborating. That’s what we would like to see. This is, again, another attempt at resetting and making that. making that work for everyone, and I hope that this will be a reality in the lives of those that are not in this room and that you will be taking messages and be the messengers to take this forward over the next six years to the Sustainable Development Goals but more importantly into the work that I think for the first time we’ve had a conversation with young people about future generations. We never had that opportunity in my time to talk about future generations, but today you have and I think we’re talking about your future now, but as you shape that future it is also about what you leave for those that are yet to come, and I hear that in everything that you said which has been underscored by inclusivity, include, include, include, voice, voice, voice, meaningful, meaningful, meaningful and get past the jargon into actions that we need to take. So thank you very much and I wish you the very best in the next few days and I hope that you will continue to make your voices loud for everyone.

Felipe Paullier: Thank you DSG. So to end, let’s start, let’s end this day with the same energy we started and let’s invite our Master of Ceremony, but now our DJ, DJ Cuppy, happy to have you here.

Amina Jane Mohammed: I have a message for DJ Cuppy. You said you wanted to be the first president in Nigeria, woman president, and what did I say? After me, eh?

Music: Baby, you don’t know that you’re the one living my soul I want you to know, I won’t ever let you go All your past is your love, your love from the dead That past is your love, your love from the dead I can’t get enough, your love from the dead Your love from the dead All your past is your love, your love from the dead That past is your love, your love from the dead I can’t get enough, your love from the dead Your love from the dead Baby, you don’t know that you’re the one living my soul I want you to know, I won’t ever let you go All your past is your love, your love from the dead That past is your love, your love from the dead I can’t get enough, your love from the dead Baby, you don’t know that you’re the one living my soul I want you to know, I won’t ever let you go All your past is your love, your love from the dead That past is your love, your love from the dead I can’t get enough, your love from the dead Copy this here, press this I’ve been, I’ve been loving you for days Never said I didn’t want you Cause now you the form of mine I love you, love you, die It’s all because of you, baby Make a brother gonna sing this song It’s a day for you, my lover Nobody else, my lover Mashi se me ka we tonta blimata Si mi si wala, ya wago de o Mashi se me ka we tonta blimata Si mi si wala, ya wago de o Habena, habena, habena, habena No lu mi wa yo, no lu mi wa yo Habena, habena, habena, habena No lu mi wa yo, no lu mi wa yo Champion lover Tell you go be my lover I don’t fit in without my lover Tu te pambie mi, my lover I can’t hear the other thing move To copy this tune, press this

F

Felipe Paullier

Speech speed

110 words per minute

Speech length

1563 words

Speech time

850 seconds

Meaningful youth participation in decision-making

Explanation

Felipe Paullier emphasizes the importance of meaningful youth participation in decision-making processes. He argues that youth political apathy is a myth and that young people have shown interest and capacity to engage at the highest levels.

Evidence

The Youth Action Day and its various sessions demonstrate youth engagement and interest in high-level discussions.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Inclusion and Representation

Agreed with

Jana Zghabi

Zongxu Xie

Martin Manyozo

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Meaningful youth participation in decision-making

J

Jana Zghabi

Speech speed

143 words per minute

Speech length

306 words

Speech time

128 seconds

Youth representation in national delegations to UN processes

Explanation

Jana Zghabi advocates for member states to commit to meaningful youth involvement in national delegations to UN processes and conferences. She argues that youth voices must be heard in the halls where decisions are made.

Evidence

Reference to Article 39 of the Declaration, which supports youth involvement in UN processes.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Inclusion and Representation

Agreed with

Felipe Paullier

Zongxu Xie

Martin Manyozo

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Meaningful youth participation in decision-making

Long-term thinking in governance structures

Explanation

Jana Zghabi emphasizes the need for long-term thinking in governance structures. She suggests leveraging science, data, statistics, and strategic foresight to ensure adaptable and forward-looking governance.

Evidence

Reference to Article 35, which supports the use of tools for creating resilient policies.

Major Discussion Point

Intergenerational Solidarity and Equity

Reforming international financial architecture

Explanation

Jana Zghabi calls for urgent reform of the international financial architecture. She argues for establishing a sovereign debt workout mechanism and embracing metrics beyond GDP to prioritize people over profits.

Major Discussion Point

Intergenerational Solidarity and Equity

Z

Zongxu Xie

Speech speed

117 words per minute

Speech length

400 words

Speech time

203 seconds

Youth as active participants and co-creators, not passive recipients

Explanation

Zongxu Xie emphasizes that youth should be seen as active participants and co-creators in shaping the digital future, rather than passive recipients of technology and education. He argues for youth involvement in the development of technology and digital policies.

Evidence

Reference to speakers emphasizing youth as active participants and co-creators in the session.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Inclusion and Representation

Agreed with

Felipe Paullier

Jana Zghabi

Martin Manyozo

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Meaningful youth participation in decision-making

Ensuring digital skills are accessible through education

Explanation

Zongxu Xie advocates for ensuring that every youth, especially those in less developed regions, can access necessary digital skills through education. This is seen as crucial for realizing value in the digital economy.

Major Discussion Point

Technology and Digital Inclusion

Agreed with

Leticia

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Technology as a tool for inclusion and development

Cross-border cooperation and technology sharing

Explanation

Zongxu Xie calls for more cross-border cooperation and technology sharing. He argues that governments, businesses, and CSOs should collaborate to ensure equitable distribution of technological resources and narrow the technology gap.

Major Discussion Point

Technology and Digital Inclusion

Agreed with

Leticia

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Technology as a tool for inclusion and development

M

Martin Manyozo

Speech speed

124 words per minute

Speech length

550 words

Speech time

264 seconds

Empowering youth in global policy and security decision-making

Explanation

Martin Manyozo argues for empowering youth in global policy and security decision-making processes. He emphasizes the need for youth to take the lead in addressing complex global challenges.

Evidence

Reference to platforms such as the Summit for the Future, Peace Building Architecture Review, and Security Council Reform as opportunities for youth integration.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Inclusion and Representation

Agreed with

Felipe Paullier

Jana Zghabi

Zongxu Xie

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Meaningful youth participation in decision-making

Advancing commitments in UN Security Council Resolution 2250 on Youth, Peace and Security

Explanation

Martin Manyozo calls for advancing the commitments laid out in UN Security Council Resolution 2250 on Youth, Peace and Security. He argues that youth voices should be embedded within peace and security processes, not just heard.

Evidence

Reference to the need for investing in youth-led organizations and increasing financing to support their initiatives.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Inclusion and Representation

L

Leticia

Speech speed

135 words per minute

Speech length

592 words

Speech time

262 seconds

Combining traditional knowledge with technology to address climate challenges

Explanation

Leticia emphasizes the importance of combining traditional and ancestral knowledge of indigenous peoples with technology to address climate challenges. She argues that this combination can lead to more effective solutions.

Evidence

Reference to the undervaluation of traditional knowledge in the face of climate crisis.

Major Discussion Point

Climate Change and Environmental Sustainability

Agreed with

Zongxu Xie

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Technology as a tool for inclusion and development

Youth as leaders in caring for the environment

Explanation

Leticia argues that young people should be recognized as leaders in caring for the environment. She emphasizes the need for youth to have their role legitimized in traditional governance structures.

Major Discussion Point

Climate Change and Environmental Sustainability

A

Aryan Sanghrajka

Speech speed

150 words per minute

Speech length

453 words

Speech time

180 seconds

Scaling support for youth-led humanitarian action

Explanation

Aryan Sanghrajka calls for scaling support for youth-led humanitarian action. He emphasizes the need for multi-stakeholder support and platforms to provide young people with expertise, technical assistance, and accessible funding.

Evidence

Reference to the Compact for Young People and Humanitarian Action objective.

Major Discussion Point

Humanitarian Action and Forced Displacement

Agreed with

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Addressing humanitarian crises and forced displacement

Ensuring young refugees move beyond education into decent work

Explanation

Aryan Sanghrajka advocates for ensuring young refugees move beyond education into decent work. He argues for access to quality education, training, employment, and entrepreneurship opportunities for young refugees.

Evidence

Reference to programs like the Youth on the Move Fellowship.

Major Discussion Point

Humanitarian Action and Forced Displacement

Agreed with

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Addressing humanitarian crises and forced displacement

Investing in displaced youth potential and leadership

Explanation

Aryan Sanghrajka calls for investment in displaced youth potential and leadership. He argues for creating true partnerships with young displaced people by giving them an equal seat at the decision-making table.

Major Discussion Point

Humanitarian Action and Forced Displacement

Agreed with

Amina Mohammed

Agreed on

Addressing humanitarian crises and forced displacement

A

Amina Mohammed

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Using technology to connect and provide equal opportunities

Explanation

Amina Mohammed emphasizes the potential of technology to connect people and provide equal opportunities. She argues that technology can be used to leapfrog development and equalize capacities across the world.

Evidence

Reference to the COVID-19 pandemic as an example of how technology connected people during isolation.

Major Discussion Point

Technology and Digital Inclusion

Agreed with

Zongxu Xie

Leticia

Agreed on

Technology as a tool for inclusion and development

Leveraging technology for intergenerational dialogue

Explanation

Amina Mohammed suggests using technology to facilitate intergenerational dialogue and understanding. She argues that technology can help bridge language barriers and connect people across different backgrounds.

Evidence

Example of the Secretary-General speaking Chinese through AI technology.

Major Discussion Point

Technology and Digital Inclusion

Agreed with

Zongxu Xie

Leticia

Agreed on

Technology as a tool for inclusion and development

Climate change as an entry point for youth engagement

Explanation

Amina Mohammed proposes using climate change as an entry point for youth engagement. She argues that the existential threat of climate change makes it a compelling issue for youth involvement in global discussions.

Major Discussion Point

Climate Change and Environmental Sustainability

Addressing root causes of displacement and humanitarian crises

Explanation

Amina Mohammed emphasizes the need to address the root causes of displacement and humanitarian crises. She argues for increased resources and support for countries hosting large numbers of refugees and displaced persons.

Evidence

Example of Chad hosting nearly 2 million refugees despite being one of the poorest countries.

Major Discussion Point

Humanitarian Action and Forced Displacement

Agreed with

Aryan Sanghrajka

Agreed on

Addressing humanitarian crises and forced displacement

Intergenerational approach to shaping the future

Explanation

Amina Mohammed advocates for an intergenerational approach to shaping the future. She emphasizes the importance of youth considering not only their own future but also that of future generations.

Major Discussion Point

Intergenerational Solidarity and Equity

Agreed with

Felipe Paullier

Jana Zghabi

Zongxu Xie

Martin Manyozo

Agreed on

Meaningful youth participation in decision-making

I

Isidora

Speech speed

147 words per minute

Speech length

452 words

Speech time

183 seconds

Establishing consultative mechanisms with young people

Explanation

Isidora calls for establishing consultative mechanisms to work with young people, allowing all to participate in equal conditions. She emphasizes the importance of including persons with disabilities and women with disabilities in these mechanisms.

Evidence

Reference to the need for implementing good practices like Generation Equality and the UN Trust Fund for Ending Violence Against Women and Girls.

Major Discussion Point

Intergenerational Solidarity and Equity

Agreements

Agreement Points

Meaningful youth participation in decision-making

Felipe Paullier

Jana Zghabi

Zongxu Xie

Martin Manyozo

Amina Mohammed

Meaningful youth participation in decision-making

Youth representation in national delegations to UN processes

Youth as active participants and co-creators, not passive recipients

Empowering youth in global policy and security decision-making

Intergenerational approach to shaping the future

Multiple speakers emphasized the importance of meaningful youth participation in decision-making processes at various levels, from national delegations to global policy and security discussions.

Technology as a tool for inclusion and development

Zongxu Xie

Leticia

Amina Mohammed

Ensuring digital skills are accessible through education

Cross-border cooperation and technology sharing

Combining traditional knowledge with technology to address climate challenges

Using technology to connect and provide equal opportunities

Leveraging technology for intergenerational dialogue

Speakers agreed on the potential of technology to foster inclusion, bridge gaps in development, and address global challenges when combined with traditional knowledge and used for cross-border cooperation.

Addressing humanitarian crises and forced displacement

Aryan Sanghrajka

Amina Mohammed

Scaling support for youth-led humanitarian action

Ensuring young refugees move beyond education into decent work

Investing in displaced youth potential and leadership

Addressing root causes of displacement and humanitarian crises

Speakers emphasized the need to support youth-led humanitarian action, provide opportunities for young refugees, and address the root causes of displacement and humanitarian crises.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers strongly advocated for increased youth representation and empowerment in high-level UN processes and decision-making, particularly in the areas of peace and security.

Jana Zghabi

Martin Manyozo

Youth representation in national delegations to UN processes

Empowering youth in global policy and security decision-making

Advancing commitments in UN Security Council Resolution 2250 on Youth, Peace and Security

Both speakers emphasized the importance of combining different forms of knowledge and fostering cooperation to address global challenges, particularly in the context of technology and climate change.

Leticia

Zongxu Xie

Combining traditional knowledge with technology to address climate challenges

Cross-border cooperation and technology sharing

Unexpected Consensus

Reforming international financial architecture

Jana Zghabi

Amina Mohammed

Reforming international financial architecture

Addressing root causes of displacement and humanitarian crises

While most speakers focused on youth participation and technology, there was an unexpected consensus on the need to reform the international financial architecture to address global challenges, including humanitarian crises.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement centered around meaningful youth participation in decision-making processes, leveraging technology for inclusion and development, and addressing humanitarian crises and forced displacement. There was also consensus on the need for intergenerational approaches and reforming global systems to better address current challenges.

Consensus level

There was a high level of consensus among the speakers on the importance of youth inclusion and empowerment across various global issues. This strong consensus implies a growing recognition of the crucial role young people play in shaping the future and addressing global challenges. It also suggests a potential shift in how international organizations and governments approach youth engagement in policy-making and implementation.

Disagreements

Overall Assessment

Summary

There were no significant disagreements among the speakers. The discussion was largely characterized by complementary viewpoints and shared goals.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement was minimal. Speakers generally supported each other’s arguments and built upon them, focusing on different aspects of youth involvement, technology, and sustainable development. This alignment suggests a strong consensus on the importance of youth participation in shaping the future across various domains.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

Both speakers agree on the importance of technology in shaping the future and involving youth. However, Zongxu Xie focuses more on youth as active participants in developing technology and policies, while Amina Mohammed emphasizes technology as a tool for equalizing opportunities and connecting people.

Zongxu Xie

Amina Mohammed

Zongxu Xie emphasizes that youth should be seen as active participants and co-creators in shaping the digital future, rather than passive recipients of technology and education. He argues for youth involvement in the development of technology and digital policies.

Amina Mohammed emphasizes the potential of technology to connect people and provide equal opportunities. She argues that technology can be used to leapfrog development and equalize capacities across the world.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers strongly advocated for increased youth representation and empowerment in high-level UN processes and decision-making, particularly in the areas of peace and security.

Jana Zghabi

Martin Manyozo

Youth representation in national delegations to UN processes

Empowering youth in global policy and security decision-making

Advancing commitments in UN Security Council Resolution 2250 on Youth, Peace and Security

Both speakers emphasized the importance of combining different forms of knowledge and fostering cooperation to address global challenges, particularly in the context of technology and climate change.

Leticia

Zongxu Xie

Combining traditional knowledge with technology to address climate challenges

Cross-border cooperation and technology sharing

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

Youth inclusion and meaningful participation in decision-making processes is crucial at all levels, from local to global

Technology and digital inclusion are key for empowering youth and creating equal opportunities

Intergenerational solidarity and long-term thinking are necessary for addressing global challenges

Climate change and environmental sustainability require combining traditional knowledge with new technologies

Humanitarian action and support for displaced youth need to be scaled up and focused on long-term solutions

Resolutions and Action Items

Member states should commit to including youth in national delegations to UN processes

Establish consultative mechanisms to work with young people, especially those with disabilities

Scale up support for youth-led humanitarian action initiatives

Advance commitments laid out in UN Security Council Resolution 2250 on Youth, Peace and Security

Reform the international financial architecture to be more inclusive and responsive to youth needs

Unresolved Issues

Specific mechanisms for implementing youth inclusion in global policy-making processes

Details on how to combine traditional knowledge with new technologies for climate action

Concrete steps for reforming the international financial architecture

Specific strategies for addressing root causes of displacement and humanitarian crises

Suggested Compromises

Balancing the use of technology with preserving traditional and indigenous knowledge

Integrating youth perspectives into existing governance structures rather than creating entirely new systems

Combining capacity building for youth with reforms in education systems to promote lifelong civic engagement

Thought Provoking Comments

Youth political apathy is a complete myth. This day has shown us the interest, the capacity of young people to engage at the highest level.

Speaker

Felipe Paullier

Reason

This comment challenges the common perception of youth disengagement and sets the tone for the entire discussion by emphasizing youth capacity and interest in high-level engagement.

Impact

It framed the subsequent discussion around youth empowerment and meaningful participation, encouraging speakers to focus on concrete ways to involve youth in decision-making processes.

We took that seriously every step of the way when we spoke with you, Philippe, that if it wasn’t meaningful, then of course everyone would say we ticked the box and what happened, what next?

Speaker

Amina Jane Mohammed

Reason

This comment highlights the importance of genuine, meaningful youth engagement beyond tokenism, showing a commitment to substantive youth involvement.

Impact

It set a standard for the discussion, encouraging subsequent speakers to focus on concrete, actionable ways to involve youth meaningfully rather than superficially.

Young people’s voice must be fully respected, and they should be invited to participate in the development of technology and digital policies.

Speaker

Zongxu Xie

Reason

This comment emphasizes the need for youth involvement specifically in technology and digital policy, areas where youth often have unique insights.

Impact

It broadened the discussion to include specific policy areas where youth participation is crucial, leading to more targeted recommendations.

What you felt at that second is something that indigenous populations, rural populations, have felt for a long time, for decades. They don’t know how to react to the disasters that they often face.

Speaker

Leticia

Reason

This comment powerfully illustrates the experience of marginalized communities, drawing a parallel between momentary confusion and long-term systemic exclusion.

Impact

It shifted the conversation to include perspectives from indigenous and rural populations, broadening the scope of the discussion on inclusion and representation.

Structured laws for youth must be created in these spaces, giving them the power to shape decisions rather than simply observe them.

Speaker

Martin Manyozo

Reason

This comment moves beyond general calls for youth inclusion to advocate for specific structural changes to empower youth in decision-making processes.

Impact

It pushed the discussion towards more concrete, actionable recommendations for youth empowerment in governance structures.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by consistently emphasizing the need for meaningful, structural youth inclusion across various domains – from technology policy to governance structures. They challenged existing perceptions of youth capacity and pushed for concrete actions to empower young people in decision-making processes. The comments also broadened the conversation to include perspectives from marginalized communities, emphasizing the intersectionality of youth issues with other forms of systemic exclusion. Overall, these insights drove the conversation towards more specific, actionable recommendations for youth empowerment and inclusion at the highest levels of policy-making and governance.

Follow-up Questions

How can we ensure meaningful youth involvement in national delegations to UN processes and conferences?

Speaker

Jana Zghabi

Explanation

This is important to fulfill Article 39 of the Declaration and ensure youth voices are heard in decision-making processes.

How can we leverage science, data, statistics, and strategic foresight to create more adaptable and forward-looking governance structures?

Speaker

Jana Zghabi

Explanation

This is crucial for developing policies that are resilient to future uncertainties, in line with Article 35.

How can we reform the international financial architecture to prioritize people over profits and pave the way for equitable global development?

Speaker

Jana Zghabi

Explanation

This includes establishing a sovereign debt workout mechanism and embracing metrics beyond GDP.

How can we better integrate traditional and ancestral knowledge of indigenous peoples with modern technology to address climate change?

Speaker

Leticia

Explanation

This is important to combine traditional wisdom with innovative solutions in tackling environmental challenges.

How can we scale support for youth-led action in humanitarian contexts?

Speaker

Aryan Sanghrajka

Explanation

This is essential for providing young people with the expertise, technical assistance, and accessible funding they need to turn their ideas into solutions.

How can we ensure young refugees move beyond education and into decent work?

Speaker

Aryan Sanghrajka

Explanation

This is crucial for changing lives and rescuing the current trajectory to achieve the SDGs by 2030.

How can we create structured roles for youth in global security dialogues and decision-making processes?

Speaker

Martin Manyozo

Explanation

This is important for empowering youth to shape decisions rather than simply observe them in global governance.

How can we advance the commitments laid out in the United Nations Security Council Resolution 2020-50?

Speaker

Martin Manyozo

Explanation

This involves investing in youth-led organizations and increasing financing to support their initiatives in peace and security processes.

How can governments and international organizations collaborate with young people to co-design and co-implement violence prevention strategies, programs, and policies?

Speaker

Martin Manyozo

Explanation

This is critical for creating inclusive, responsive, and accountable institutions that incorporate youth feedback at every stage of program development.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

AI/Gen AI for the Global Goals

Session at a Glance

Summary

This discussion focused on the potential of artificial intelligence (AI) to accelerate sustainable development and empower Africa’s youth. The panel explored how AI can be leveraged to address challenges in various sectors, including agriculture, education, and finance, while also considering the ethical implications and necessary infrastructure.

Speakers emphasized the importance of collaboration between governments, private sector companies, and youth-led startups in implementing AI-driven initiatives. They highlighted the need for policies that support AI integration into youth development programs and educational systems across Africa. The discussion also touched on the challenges of implementing digital innovation in Africa, including regulatory hurdles and the high cost of AI technology.

A key point raised was the importance of African ownership in the AI value chain, from hardware development to data ownership. Panelists stressed the need for African countries to participate beyond the service layer of AI to ensure long-term benefits and cost-effectiveness. The discussion also addressed the ethical considerations in implementing AI technology, particularly in preventing a widening digital divide.

The panel highlighted ongoing efforts to integrate AI skills into educational curricula and create platforms for young innovators to access funding and support. They emphasized the potential of AI to create job opportunities and drive economic growth in Africa, while also acknowledging the need to address potential job displacements.

Overall, the discussion underscored the transformative potential of AI for Africa’s development, while emphasizing the importance of inclusive, ethical, and collaborative approaches to its implementation. The panelists called for increased investment in AI education, infrastructure, and local innovation to ensure that Africa can fully harness the benefits of this technology.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– The potential of AI to accelerate progress on sustainable development and the UN Sustainable Development Goals

– The need for collaboration between governments, private sector, and other stakeholders to responsibly develop and implement AI

– Challenges around AI access, infrastructure, and skills gaps, particularly in developing countries and Africa

– Ethical considerations and risks associated with AI development and deployment

– The role of youth and innovation in driving AI adoption and solutions in Africa

The overall purpose of the discussion was to explore how AI, particularly generative AI, can be leveraged as a tool to accelerate sustainable development and empower youth in Africa, while addressing challenges and ethical concerns.

The tone of the discussion was generally optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers highlighting the transformative potential of AI. However, there was also a pragmatic acknowledgement of significant challenges that need to be overcome, particularly around access, skills, and ethical implementation. The tone became more action-oriented towards the end, with calls for concrete partnerships and initiatives to move the agenda forward.

Speakers

Speakers:

– Sanda Ojiambo – CEO and Executive Director of the UN Global Compact

– Shea Gopaul – Permanent Representative for the International Board Organization of Employers

– Chido Cleopatra Mpemba – African Union Youth Envoy

– Christopher P. Lu – Deputy Command Representative of the UN for Management Reform from the U.S. government

– Gerbrand Haverkamp – Executive Director of the World Benchmarking Alliance

– Henry Kipponen – Chief Innovation Officer from Unite AI Companies

– Dr. Jamila Bio Ibrahim – Nigeria’s Minister of Youth

– Priscilla Boa-Gue – Google’s head for pan-African institutions, government affairs and public policy

– Kolawole Olajide – CEO and co-founder of Sava (fintech company)

Moderators/Facilitators:

– Amelia (no last name given) – Moderated first panel discussion

– Farai Gundan – Moderator for second panel, inspirational youth leader at Harvard University

– Tonilyn Lim – Chief of Programs of the UN Global Conference, facilitated transitions between panels

Areas of expertise varied among speakers, covering topics such as:

– UN initiatives and global partnerships

– Business and employment

– Youth development in Africa

– AI and technology policy

– Sustainable development

– Government affairs

– Fintech and entrepreneurship

Full session report

Expanded Summary of AI and Sustainable Development Discussion

This comprehensive discussion explored the potential of artificial intelligence (AI) to accelerate sustainable development and empower Africa’s youth. The panel, comprising experts from various sectors, delved into how AI can address challenges in agriculture, education, finance, and other key areas, while also considering ethical implications and necessary infrastructure.

Potential of AI for Sustainable Development

Speakers unanimously agreed on AI’s significant potential to drive progress towards the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Sanda Ojiambo, CEO of the UN Global Compact, emphasized that AI, particularly generative AI, can be a “true game-changer for sustainability progress”. She highlighted its ability to democratize access to information, accelerate innovation through cross-disciplinary thinking, and increase productivity. Ojiambo also discussed the UN Global Compact’s recent report on AI for sustainable development, which outlines how AI can contribute to each of the 17 SDGs and provides guidance for businesses on responsible AI implementation.

However, the discussion also acknowledged the need for a balanced perspective. Ojiambo cautioned that while AI could help solve global goals, gaps in technology access could exacerbate global inequalities. This nuanced view set the tone for a broader exploration of both opportunities and challenges.

Challenges and Risks in AI Implementation

The panel identified several significant hurdles to AI implementation in Africa:

1. Infrastructure limitations: The lack of basic infrastructure such as internet access and electricity in many areas was highlighted as a major challenge.

2. Cost barriers: Kolawole Olajide, CEO of Sava, pointed out the high costs of AI development and implementation for African startups.

3. Ethical considerations: Priscilla Boa-Gue from Google stressed the need for responsible AI principles and ethical guidelines.

4. Informal sector challenges: Dr. Jamila Bio Ibrahim, Nigeria’s Minister of Youth, discussed the difficulties of implementing AI solutions in Africa’s large informal sector, where traditional data collection and digital integration are limited.

These challenges underscored the complexity of leveraging AI for development in Africa, prompting discussions on potential solutions and strategies.

African Initiatives and Strategies

The discussion highlighted several initiatives aimed at harnessing AI for Africa’s development:

1. African Union’s AI Strategy: Chido Cleopatra Mpemba discussed the African Union’s efforts to develop a comprehensive AI strategy and policy brief to guide the continent’s approach to AI adoption and regulation.

2. Make Africa Digital Campaign: Mpemba also mentioned this initiative, which aims to promote digital literacy and skills across the continent.

3. Google’s AI Research Centers: Priscilla Boa-Gue detailed Google’s investments in AI research centers in Ghana and Kenya, focusing on developing locally relevant AI solutions and supporting African AI researchers.

4. Nigeria’s Youth Empowerment Initiatives: Dr. Jamila Bio Ibrahim outlined Nigeria’s efforts to support youth in technology and AI, including plans to integrate AI and digital skills into educational curricula and provide funding for youth-led AI initiatives.

Empowering African Youth through AI

A key focus of the discussion was how to harness AI to benefit Africa’s youth. Strategies discussed included:

1. Investing in talent development and digital skills training for youth

2. Integrating AI and digital skills into educational curricula

3. Providing funding and investment opportunities for youth-led AI initiatives

4. Creating enabling policy environments to support AI startups

Importance of Collaboration and Partnerships

Speakers consistently emphasized the crucial role of multi-stakeholder collaboration in effectively developing and implementing AI technologies. Ojiambo called for partnerships between governments, private sector, and civil society. Boa-Gue highlighted the potential of collaborations between tech companies and African institutions to develop localized AI solutions. Olajide stressed the importance of cooperation between youth-led startups, established businesses, and governments.

African Ownership in the AI Value Chain

Kolawole Olajide raised a thought-provoking point about the need for African countries to participate beyond the service layer of AI: “If as a continent, we only participate in that service layer, we have a big problem in the long-term. We will continue to, it will be very expensive for us.” This insight highlighted the importance of building local AI capabilities and infrastructure in Africa, including manufacturing and hardware development.

Ethical Considerations and Governance

The panel addressed the importance of ethical AI development and deployment. Gerbrand Haverkamp, Executive Director of the World Benchmarking Alliance, emphasized the role of international bodies like the UN in AI governance, stating, “If we do not do it here in the UN, it will either be decided in the US, in Europe, or in China, and then we know which other countries will not be at the table.” This comment led to discussions on the need for inclusive global governance structures for AI.

Unresolved Issues and Future Considerations

Despite the productive discussion, several issues remained unresolved, including:

1. Ensuring AI benefits reach rural and marginalized communities

2. Ownership and control of African data used to develop AI systems

3. Increasing African participation in hardware development and other parts of the AI value chain

4. Balancing innovation with ethical concerns and responsible AI development

The discussion also touched on the upcoming UN Summit of the Future, which will focus on youth engagement and the role of emerging technologies in shaping global futures.

In conclusion, the discussion underscored the transformative potential of AI for Africa’s development, while emphasizing the importance of inclusive, ethical, and collaborative approaches to its implementation. The panelists called for increased investment in AI education, infrastructure, and local innovation to ensure that Africa can fully harness the benefits of this technology, while also addressing the significant challenges and ethical considerations that lie ahead.

A notable contribution came from a young Indian speaker who mentioned writing an AI book for African children, highlighting the growing global interest in promoting AI education for youth across continents.

Session Transcript

Sanda Ojiambo: Good afternoon, everybody, and thank you so much for making the time to be here. My name is Sanda Ojiambo. I’m the CEO and Executive Director of the UN Global Contact. It’s really great to welcome you to our offices. First, I just want to say sincere apologies. I know we’ve had to make some changes on venue. On the positive side, we’re now being streamed live on UN Web TV, so we do have a much larger and global following, which I think is great for the opportunity that we have. But just to say, yes, the negotiations for the pact for the future, which will be central to the summit of the future, happened to be, should I say, protracted. And so essentially, most available space, there was a request to avail space so that member states or governments could conclude this piece of negotiation and discussion. So thank you for being accommodating. I know we’re all here to rally behind the pact and what we want to achieve for the summit of the future, which includes a lot of the important work that we want to do around technology and AI. So thank you for accommodating that. I know a few of our guests are on the way. They had engagements at the United Nations, so they need to make their way over here. But we will certainly kick off. I will just make some comments to start. I know there’s a lot that we want to talk about. This has been a really exciting report that we’ve been able to compile with our partners and really marks, I think, for the Global Compact, a great launchpad into looking at the world of Gen AI for the global goals. I want to first just thank the African Union Office of the Youth Envoy. I know she’s on the way. She was a dear friend, a strong advocate for everything future looking and a great youth envoy. So I appreciate her and her effort. I know colleagues from her office are here. I’d also like to thank the International Organization of Employees. Who’s also a great friend and strong advocate for private sector and all the transformative work that it does in all of its phases. Your collaboration has allowed us to drive this conversation forward. So thank you very much. Cleo and Shiv for your support on this. The Summit and indeed the Pact of the Future, we will see by the end of the week, put a strong focus on young people. There’s a declaration by the youth that will come out and it’s really the opportunity to look at new solutions, chart a new vision of what the world can look like after these four years that have been particularly hard from an economic perspective, a social perspective and certainly in terms of governance and society functioning. So the Summit and the Pact call us to imagine a new future that is really grounded in multilateralism, that has strong global governance underpinning it, that embraces the global digital compact that I’m sure you’ll hear about over the next couple of days and certainly has young people and driving forward the sustainable development goals. And so then therefore technology and AI is so central to making sure that we can get there because as we reflected on last year at this time, as you know, we’re so far behind on where we need to be with the global goals. Business is uniquely positioned to drive this forward as we know. Business was called to the table in 2015 when the goals were being designed to look at the goals of a strong investment opportunity, an opportunity not only to bridge markets but really to bridge the gaps that exist between communities, people, societies and the world. So business still remains core to the work that we need to do for the remaining years till 2030. Gen AI gives us the opportunity to crunch large data sets, to find the insights that we need and to truly deliver the solutions to move the goals forward. We interviewed about 30 executives to put this report together and all of them recognized the capacity and the potentials for Gen AI to truly transform industry and what we need to do. A larger survey of about 1,600 CEOs revealed that 75% of those companies, admittedly large companies, are in the process of embedding AI into their work and their strategies. According to this new report, and thank you to Accenture, our partners, for working with us on this, Gen AI can be a true game-changer for sustainability progress because it will democratize access to information, it will accelerate innovation through the solutions, through cross-disciplinary thinking, and certainly by increasing productivity. Schools can help navigate complex and sustainable development problems, such as circular business, more productive supply chains, and I’m truly wishing I had Gen AI when I was in school. I’m told it solves a lot of the challenges I face trying to do my homework and my assignments. But imagine Gen AI combined with robotics and what the future would look like for many. I come from Kenya, the African continent, often referred, Kenyan specifically, no offense to the other African world, the Silicon Savannah, sometimes called the hotbed of innovation. You know, what do we need? We need scale, we need technology, we need access to crunch those data sets and make solutions that make sense, not only for those small startup entrepreneurs, but for the big issues that a lot of the developing and the emerging world needs to solve. At best, AI will help us solve the global goals, and that’s really important, but we must take a reality check because we realize that gaps in technology are really what keeps the world separate. On the one hand, we’re moving forward with large language models. On the other hand, the people who still don’t have access to connectivity can’t afford it or simply are still working using a feature phone. So, you know, there’s a lot of work that will go on around looking at what Gen AI can and should look like, how we bridge those technology gaps from a policy perspective, from an infrastructure perspective, from a device perspective, from a content perspective, from a pricing perspective. So much work to be done, even while we accelerate forward on this. Additionally, and under that, we need to look at issues such as rights, bias, ethics, complex areas because we’re really charting uncharted waters. Lots of work going on on this. Allow me to just mention the Secretary General’s high level advisory body on technology and AI that is doing some groundbreaking work on supporting efforts. and discussions on global governance, very important. Regional efforts are also key. We will hear from the African Union about how it’s building a vibrant and inclusive AI startup ecosystem. We must look at each region’s priorities and needs. Technology is not applied agnostically or across many different infrastructure and policy areas as well. This report, as you’ll see, will outline tangible actions to help companies use technology as it should and for the global goals. Companies, as we always say in the Global Compact, must work in partnership with governments, with civil society, with communities, empower young people, empower SMEs, empower innovators to really drive technology forward. Gen AI is already shaping the global landscape. Every day, I sense something new and really wonder where the future may lie. It’s really interesting that we’re here gathering the summit of the future, where we can really look at what a combined future for the world can look like. So really important. So I just want to say thank you so much to all those who helped put the report together. Many from my team here, who I know thoroughly enjoyed the exercise. I enjoyed reading the report, debating about some of the critical issues that were in there. And we’re very hopeful that this report will provide value, not just for Global Compact members, for anybody in the private sector and our broad stakeholder ecosystem, who’s really looking to see how we can get to 2030 and really deliver on the Sustainable Development Goal. So thank you so much to all of you for coming. I know we have a few people walking in also. They come over from the UN office, but welcome and we really look forward to an energizing discussion. Thank you.

Moderator: Great. Thank you, Sanda. I think we can hand it to Shea. Yeah. Great.

Shea Gopaul: So thank you, Sanda. And like Sandra, I’d like to thank the African Union, as well as Global Compact. is a co-sponsor with us today. My name is Shea Gopaul, I’m the permanent rep for the International Board Organization of Employers. For those of you that don’t know us, we are an organization representing 50 million companies with our employers federations and our members in over 150 different countries. We focus on social employment issues from policy to advocacy, to really capacity building at country level. So we too undertook a study with Deloitte and looking at G20 countries where we looked at their AI readiness and how prepared are countries as we embark on this new world of AI. And while there’s a dual nature to AI and its impact on the labor market and society, obviously there are some very positive significant points in particularly productivity and efficiency gains, but there’s also an awful lot and people are very worried about is job displacements and social disparities. The recent IMF report has said that AI will affect 40% of jobs around the world, but in advanced economies where we’re moving so quickly on this, it could be actively 60%. Now there will be job losses, but there will be job gains. And I think there’s some really interesting numbers, but they’re not all saying the same thing. If you look at MIT, some of the numbers are a bit alarming because they’re using also historical data. You have the ILO coming out, the West says 14 million jobs could be lost, that’s 2%. Whereas the OECD is saying, no, let’s look at this, it could be more positive. No matter what is happening in the AI world, there will be job loss and people need to be trained and retrained into these new positions. Women in particular are being very affected by this. And the first round, particularly in gen AI, is a lot of the administrative positions which are being taken by many women. And unfortunately, some of those are the jobs where they need to be re-skilled immediately so that they can move in and fit into other jobs. But women also have a disadvantage. And if you look at the statistics, they are not as much in STEM education. They’re at a disadvantage, and therefore men are much more educated and trained, and they will be able to move forward. But AI will not take your job away, but the person with AI skills will. So there are a lot of gains in productivity, as I said, and particularly in sectors like manufacturing, logistics, and healthcare, we see a lot of tasks being automated. And there is an increase in productivity, particularly, as I said, in these advanced economies. Routine tasks are being removed, and then people are being able to spend more time on creativity, strategic work, and overall productivity. So in general, in G20 countries, they all say that they’re well-prepared and positioning themselves for AI. And there are many opportunities, and they are all, however, at very different stages. Everyone says that they’re looking at a strategy, and they have actually set up ministries and groups that are really looking at AI governance and all the other issues around it. But as Sandra said, the current digital infrastructure is very serious. And while we’re talking about this and saying it’s so great in many advanced economies, you shouldn’t forget that 33% of the world is without access so you’re not gonna be using generative AI. There are various forms and levels of investment. AI takes investment and particularly private investment. And that’s where it’s very unevenly distributed. 81% of the private investment in AI is in two countries and that’s China and the US. That means that there are a lot of countries that don’t have the resources. And so therefore there’s a push by governments to be putting more of public funds into this. The skills gap is very serious, but most importantly there’s something called the skills mismatch. Particularly in South Africa, Brazil and Mexico, they have the largest skills mismatch. And this could cause some serious problems because young people who are educated and want to work but do not have the skills for a job that can cause very serious frustrations and eventually unrest, which is what we saw a lot in 2012 when we had a lot of the youth unemployment problems we’re dealing with. But also the IMF looked at several factors when you’re looking at readiness. And there’s things like doing business in a country, the startup environment, the human capital, again, investment. But there are common efforts across countries and everyone recognizes its importance. However, the infrastructure development is recognized as being serious. Digital infrastructure is the cornerstone. However, they are all putting prioritization on high-speed internet, cloud computing, advanced technologies in order to be able to integrate their AI. Workforce development and skills enhancement is a very serious issue and they’re trying to tackle it and R&D becomes very important in these G20 countries. However, there are some serious issues and I’m going to point to a few of them which I sort of raised. But there needs to be an equitable distribution of the AI benefits. And this is where there’s really serious concern. Because many countries are not ready with the infrastructure, and this is really going to cause even worse income inequalities. Private sector and public sector must come together on this to become a leader in AI. They’re working on workforce development, but they’re also looking at AI integration into the economy. The skills gap, I said, is huge, the mismatch, but we do see that a lot of countries are very quickly taking on targeted programs and efforts, and private sector is assisting with this in modernizing the educational curricula. And for instance, Brazil has a strategy right now where they’re putting a strong AI workforce development together with financial resources, scholarships, and AI degrees. But there needs to be the balance between innovation and ethical concerns. Strategies should really adapt to the address of emerging ethical concerns, such as algorithms and the implication of AI on privacy. So just to conclude, we have the study, it’s out there, lots is happening, but we need to share. Those that are at the advantage and those who are doing well really need to share with others to bring everyone up to the same level. To conclude, we need a human-centric approach, where we consider the workplace, education, misinformation, and ethics are absolutely critical for any strategy. We know we can’t do it alone, and we know that many could be left behind even more. The Global Compact Study is great because we know that we can achieve great outcomes in their examples, but we also know that we can’t do it alone, and we know that many could be left behind even more. of coming together, but we need to share, complement, and work in partnership. So, thank you.

Sanda Ojiambo: I just have an additional job with the MC, but allow me to welcome the delegates from the African Union. Welcome. I know you had to do a walk-off. Sincere apologies for the change of venue. Thank you for being accommodating. We kicked off the program. I provided my remarks. My dear colleague shared spoken from the international organization before us. So, if you’re ready, we’d very much welcome your remarks from the African Union and the President, Madam, the youth envoy. Thank you very much. Would you like to come up front?

Chido Cleopatra Mpemba: Thank you, everyone. First of all, my apologies for being late. This is my fifth event for the day. There’s one more to go. So, I’ve just come from the UN, where we’re closing an event on gender equality for young girls and adolescents. As you’re aware that today’s also the UN Summit of the Future Youth Action Day, but I’m happy to be here. First of all, to my sister, Sanda. Thank you for doing this in collaboration with the African Union, the Minister of Youth for Nigeria, the Minister of Youth Development for Nigeria, my dear sister, Dr. Jamila. Everyone, thank you for being with us today, and I see a lot of familiar faces that we have in the room, young professionals like Kola, like Melvin, just to name a few that have joined us here today. I’m going to speak mostly about the work in the Office of the Youth Envoy, and the reason I’m going to mention this is because knowing that UN Global Contact works with the private sector, I think it’s important that we raise the best practices of the private sector working with young people in Africa. So at the African Union with the Digital Transformation Strategy, and within this, the Office of the Youth UNWRADE launched a campaign, which is the Make Africa Digital campaign. This campaign is in partnership with Google and AfriZim Bank, and we also have the support from UN Global Compact in launching a policy brief. We’ve taken this campaign to seven countries with the partnership of the private sector because we believe it’s important that we have a digital literate, you know, future generation. So, you know, we’ve been going across the continent, partnering with local tech hubs and ensuring that young people get to learn about digital literacy and we prepare them for the future of work. But not only that, we realized when we went about this campaign, that some of the communities that we visited, for example, when we were in Ghana, we’re in a community just far up from Accra. And, you know, some of the people raised a concern when we’d gone there for the training and they said, actually, you’re here to train us, but we don’t have the digital access. So you might come and talk about digital literacy, but we don’t have the technology. And as a result, we then decided to actually start having consultations with young people in different communities to say, this is actually working. What more would you like within the context of Africa and the support from the private sector and the African Union? Because we all know that AI is a new thing, right? It’s a new buzz. Recently, the African Union actually launched an AI strategy, which was adopted by our member states at the AU Head of State Assembly in June. We know that the UN is also launching an AI strategy. I’m not sure if it’s been launched and it’s coming up very soon. And as a result, we came up with this policy brief. The policy brief is on AI and user sustainability in Africa. And we’re really excited for, you know, different stakeholders to get to appreciate this policy brief from the private sector to the member states and the governments. and ensuring that we do better really for African youth. When we talk to the youth in Africa, what comes up the most is unemployment is such an issue. A lot of young people are unemployed and we need to address that. We can address that through education, through working with the private sector as well, but we can also address this by raising entrepreneurs. How can we ensure that we capacitate our young people? How do we ensure that we raise funding for young people? Because it’s one thing if we capacitate them and if we train them, and there’s no funding, to further accelerate the initiative. So I think that’s what I would like to leave in the room. I hope my team will pardon me because I didn’t get a chance to read all their hard work and their research in this, but appreciating, and acknowledging my team really. I’m here with a delegation of a women-led delegation from across the continent that are here with me today from Cameroon. We have a delegation from Zimbabwe, Nigeria. We have a delegation from Mali. We have a delegation of young women that are with me in this room. And the reason I’m not missing it is because in as much as we talk about youth representation, it’s also important that we include those that are marginalized. And often the young women are marginalized. So let us also think about that. If we talk about AI, we talk about young people, but let us not forget the marginalized, the people in non-urban areas, that are often left behind. I was literally in the session I was in just now at the U.S. and I was just raising awareness of a statistic on young girls that are out of school compared to the ratio to boys. And it’s quite huge. The gap is quite huge in Africa. We need to do something about that. But in closing, just to appreciate everyone’s here and I’m looking forward to the discussions that will be ongoing in this room and for everyone to further contribute really in building and developing the Africa that we want and meeting the SDG goals, but also the Agenda 2063. So thank you very much.

Sanda Ojiambo: Thank you so much Chido, really for your leadership and as you said, bringing forward that generation of both, you know, marginalized young people as well as women and everything that is so important for the world that we live in. You don’t have a t-shirt. Thank you. You’re absolutely welcome. It’s good to have you here and sincere apologies, you might know more about the levels of negotiation that are going on within the United Nations. So please accept our apologies to everybody, once again, having to make a very last minute change of venue. As I mentioned before, here on The Positive, we’re now being streamed live on UN Web TV, so we are, you know, globally visible, but more importantly, I think it’s just great to be able to have this discussion as we continue to stream in. I just want to say a special welcome to the Ambassador. Thank you so much for all of your support in all that we do. I know we move on to an interactive panel and they’ve put these painfully high seats for all of you. But lovely to be able to welcome the panel and have you up here for this interactive panel. Allow me also to recognize, indeed, the Minister for Youth from Nigeria. Madam, thank you so much for joining us and all of our special guests who are making the time to come over. I’d love to be able to introduce the panel. The other Ambassador, Christopher Lu, is the Deputy Command Representative of the UN for Management Reform from the U.S. government. We have Gerbrand Haverkamp, the Executive Director of the World Benchmarking Alliance, to be here. And certainly Henry Kipponen, the Chief Innovation Officer from Unite AI Companies. Please, you are all welcome to join. And I’ll be moderated by Amelia. And we have moderation from Amelia.

Amelia: Thank you. I know there’s a little bit of shuffling, so I’ll let everyone find their seats. All right. Thank you all so much for joining us, and thank you to all the wonderful speakers for being here. And thank you all for joining me. I’m excited to have you all here. As we discussed, we are at a crossroads. As I discussed, we are at a crossroads. On the one hand, we are desperately behind where we need to be when it comes to the SDGs, with only 17% on-track spending. And on the other hand, as we discussed, we have exciting, amazing technology, such as Gen-AI, that can help accelerate the progress that we need, that can help close some of the gaps and really get us to where we need to be by 2030. Please speak up. Oh, I apologize here. I will try. As I said, we’re at a crossroads where we need to, on the one hand, accelerate our progress on the SDGs, and look at really taking advantage of the tools at our disposal, such as Gen-AI. Can you all hear me now? I’ll try and project more. So I’m really excited to have our three panels today, where we’re going to be talking about different perspectives, from government to private sector, on how Gen-AI can really be used to accelerate sustainable development and accelerate the global goals. And for those who might be interested, there are reports and postcards outside to read more. But during this panel, I really want to touch on three things. The first is innovation, the excitement around Gen-AI, really expanding on what Sanda already talked about at the beginning of the opening session. The second is some of the risks that Sherry touched on, from employment to misinformation to bias and more. And the third is the real importance of collaboration. When it comes to both enabling that acceleration, but also mitigating and managing those risks. I’d love to start off with innovation. So, we all know that, I’m sorry, I’m going to turn my back to you now, so we all know that several companies around the world have really made commitments when it comes to sustainability. Yet they’re facing headwinds, the geopolitical conflict, to the economy, and more. So, I’m curious, from your perspective, how can GEN-AI be used as a tool to really help accelerate some of this, to help overcome the challenges and accelerate some sustainability progress? I’ll open up with Henry.

Henry Kipponen: Yeah, so there are many cases, and we’ve heard here that AI is a new thing. I think I founded my first AI company in 2012 or 2013, so from that moment, it was pretty clear where things are going. So, for example, the private sector hasn’t done a very good job of implementing that, neither has the governments. And so, there are many things, for example, starting from precision farming, that’s a very obvious case. Then there are, for example, in construction, what you can do with algorithmic planning is to, for example, create structures that are as strong as done by using a lot of material like concrete and metals, but you can chip away some of the materials in those uses. You can reduce food waste, for example, by predicting the demand, and we’re not doing that currently. Like, 50% of everything that comes from farms goes to trashcans somewhere, and it doesn’t make any sense. Also, there are some other things that, for example, people usually tend to think that if algorithms make decisions based on, for example, who is hired where, then it’s always biased. But that’s just like, that’s humans who are doing the bias in that. So they are now like, understanding how to build the data sets. Because I mean, it’s about the data sets and how the algorithm works. But I would assume that if we would do that, for example, like, like, we would like make algorithms make all those decisions, for example, for jobs, then we would audit them. Everyone who’s the decision didn’t like the decision might ask from the corporation or whoever, and ask to show that how did the algorithm work. And that would actually create transparency. But those are like very obvious use cases. And we don’t need any technology. Technology was there like 10 years ago for doing that. But we just don’t have the way to do that.

Amelia: I think we all know that sometimes there’s a gap between having a tool and actually implementing it for good. But I do like the example of really taking away that bias and implementing more transparency. That brings me to the next one. From benchmarking perspective, that is a lot of essentially enabling transparency on the action that companies are taking. Will Jen and I be able to help with that transparency? How are you thinking about evaluating companies more?

Gerbrand Haverkamp: Yeah, so first, we look at the world’s 2000 most influential companies from a perspective of the Sustainable Development Goals. So what can these companies do to make sure that we achieve the SDGs? And I don’t want to be the parsley pooper here. But I’m going to be anyway a little bit. There is a lot of excitement. But if you look at what companies are actually doing, that’s what we know from benchmarking is they’re falling massively behind. And so I can be excited about precision agriculture. But I’m going to be excited when it’s in the hand of smallholder farmers, because that’s what is going to make a difference. And this is where we constantly see those challenges. So I am and I want to be and I am excited about new technologies. But it’s always a question about how do we make that available? Because right now, it’s quite what it is. something simple as internet access is a reflection of inequality, but it also widens inequality if we don’t fix it. I think for us as an organization, like we, so therefore we are constantly interested in how can we measure the impact that companies have on people and planets. And whilst these companies operate in a world of big data, when it comes to the data on their actual impact, we have mainly data gaps. So I’m really, really interested in, I think someone made a joke about data centers, right? There’s not a lot of data about data centers and their energy use, et cetera. So these are sort of the discrepancies that we need to start fixing. Like how do we actually start to deploy these solutions to get clarity and data on issues where we now don’t have sight? So I hope for us as an organization, that also means technological development in terms of how do we then utilize that? We’re an NGO, so we’re not the best at that kind of stuff, but we need to figure it out and how do we work with that? But I think that’s, for me, it’s really the critical bit, like how, with every new wave of technology, how are we going to make it accessible?

Amelia: I think absolutely we’ve touched on themes of accessibility and that is critical. I’m curious, Ambassador Lu, from the standpoint of both it being a innovative, nascent technology, but also having these issues of accessibility, et cetera, what’s the perspective of governments to be able to make it accessible to the people?

Christopher P. Lu: Yeah, I mean, look, AI is new, but it’s actually really not that new. I mean, we’ve been having this conversation for the last two years since the advent of chat GPT, but AI goes way before that. Every time you go online and you do a search and it suggests something to you, that’s AI. Every time you go on Google Maps to try to figure out how long it’s going to take you, that’s AI. I think the difference is the power and what it can do. And I think the challenge that governments have is how do we ensure that these benefits flow to everyone while mitigating the risks? And we know about some of the risks, this information. I think in some ways, the greatest risk that we face is that the benefits don’t flow to everybody and that it has the potential to both decrease inequality, but widen inequality. there’s a major capacity challenge right now. I mean, AI is like a very fancy sports car and a lot of countries don’t even have paved roads. So the question is, how do you connect people to the internet? How do you even give them reliable electricity so they can connect to the internet? So that’s kind of one challenge, but then it’s also understanding that countries don’t need to have the capability, particularly in the developing world to develop AI. They just need to be able to take advantage of it. So when you’ve got AI tools that help, you know, farmers better grow crops or that can predict floods or that can assess the credit worthiness for microloans, all of that can help the developing world. We just need to get those tools into the hands of people. And often you could do that through a smartphone connection. And so this is something we in the U.S. government have been thinking a lot about. The challenge that I think for the perspective of the U.S. is we often think about these as problems that governments can solve. And yes, governments have capacity to solve them. Truthfully, these will ultimately be solved by the private sector. The private sector and U.S. tech companies, European tech companies, will have the ability to lay the cable that will connect people to the internet and will provide the skilling. Government can provide an impetus to this, but government alone can’t solve it, nor can the U.N. solve this problem.

Amelia: Absolutely, and that actually takes us to the topic of collaboration. Because we do think, as you mentioned, Ambassador Liu, that collaboration is the key between the private sector and government to be able to really utilize the technology, the skills, the finances at our fingertips to be able to implement that change. So I’m sure it’s a big thing about collaboration from initially the private sector. What more would you both like to see from global cross-sector partnerships? How can we help close that gap in terms of access, in terms of potential employment changes, et cetera?

Henry Kipponen: Well, what I see is like, I look at it from the perspective of innovation. It’s something that’s like… This technological change is huge because now it’s democratized. So basically, anyone can create, for example, a learning algorithm using Gen AI and large language models and code that, for example. But unless you have access to the Internet, if you don’t have the devices, it doesn’t make any sense. But again, I’m a little bit skeptical about organizations or governments deciding on what to innovate, because we just don’t know. And this is where young people and this collaboration comes in, because I mean, this is the most important part. What I think is that since the future is not created, maybe we want to include all of those people who will be living this planet after, for example, I’m born. I’m young in Europe, by the way. European youth convoy looks like this. That’s how it is. But again, I think that is the part that when we’re trying to direct innovation to somewhere, it goes usually wrong, and especially with new technologies. We must create the platform, have the resources, as has been said here, have the access for that. And then, for example, funding it in a way that maybe there are some projects that the who gives the money decides what to do. But like it’s done in research that like you just give money to people who have some ideas and some of them might be groundbreaking, which are solving actual problems. But I’m very interested in about this point of like, in 2015 happened a big thing when Google democratized some of the tools, that was a huge thing that happened. And now it’s democratized for like all who have the access to the Internet and for these devices. And that, for me, is a creative revolution. And especially when people who have not been taken away from taking part of some of the things get access to that, then we’re going to see change. But it’s not going to be the change that we’re now protecting. It is going to be something totally different. And I’m just like hoping that it will be the sort of like the good people now doing it because, I mean, there are so many bad uses for AI and usually it’s the bad people who like take it first and do it to, for example, like reduce trust between people. So we have a crisis of democracy and we’ve seen that happening already. So now it’s the for the good people time to like move in.

Gerbrand Haverkamp: I think it’s, of course, absolutely right that it’s ultimately companies that deliver and I would not want to make any suggestions to change that. But I think if there’s one role for the UN, it is to spell out what the responsibility of business is when it comes to the deployment of technology. And because once we have clear norms and guidance, within parameters, we actually want to deploy this technology, we want to develop it. That’s different from saying what to develop, but it is giving the guardrails for how we do it. And the UN has done it before, right, with the UN Guiding Principles for Business and Human Rights. It sets out principles within business, which business can operate. And I think there’s now an opportunity, starting with the Global Digital Compact, to spell out for nations, and therefore for companies, what the ethical principles are that we want to apply when developing and deploying these new technologies. And I think the UN is really the only place where that can be done. Because if we do not do it here in the UN, it will either be decided in the US, in Europe, or in China, and then we know which other countries will not be at the table. So if we really want, if we’re talking about inclusivity, and we want this to be available for all, then we need to be able to set the norms and standards and parameters at a place and the UN is the only place where that can be done. Because otherwise, it will be set by the world’s biggest economies, or the world’s biggest economies will choose not to do it. And therefore, I think it’s really, really unique not to undermine that position of the UN, because the UN is the only place that has the legitimacy to do that. So if there’s one thing that I hope will come out of this Global Digital Compact, is articulation of what the responsibility of business is. That’s very different from saying what business should be doing, but it’s saying within these parameters is how we’re going to work. And we’ve done it before with human rights, and I think we have an opportunity to do it now as well for the generative AI and other new technologies.

Amelia: Absolutely. What are those ethical principles and frameworks that we need to be thinking about? Anything to add?

Christopher P. Lu: Yeah, it’s actually one of the reasons why we in the US led the effort on the first ever UN resolution on AI that passed in March. And it was to begin to set out some of these rules of the road for how AI should be operated and governed and how it should be developed. And I mean, the miraculous aspect of this is that we were able to get 193 countries to agree with this, even though, candidly, there’s only a couple dozen that have the capability of actually meaningfully developing AI. But it was essentially to start putting down some basic rules of the road that countries could adopt if they adopt their own regulatory scheme. And obviously, the US scheme is much different than the Chinese scheme, which is much different than the EU scheme. But there’s a basic set of principles that should guide it. And I do agree with the both panels. The UN has an important role in this. But what’s important to understand is that the importance of bringing every stakeholder to the table. And that’s a point of distinction within the UN. There are countries right now who do think the only people that should discuss AI are country to country conversations. And I think that’s short-sighted. I mean, other than China right now, if you look at the other major countries that are developing AI, the vast majority of the investments in AI are happening in the private sector. These are not government-funded investments. They’re private sector investments. So not to include those companies in the conversation leaves it both player, frankly, not including civil society NGOs, who can be the important check to ensure that human rights and civil liberties are all being protected. That’s an oversight as well. So those are some of the broad guiding principles of how we’ve tried to negotiate global digital compact.

Amelia: Thank you. I’m going to wrap up with one final quick question before we get applauded off the stage. I think it’s very exciting to hear about what we need coming out. Just very curiously, what, if I may ask you each, what do you find most exciting in the next five to 10 years about the potential of Gen AI to unlock sustainable development? what’s the one thing that you’re most excited about? And I’ll start, and that’s early.

Christopher P. Lu: I mean, it’s, I’m not even trying. I mean, you know, when you look at breast cancer detection, education, skilling, agriculture, I mean, sustainability, it’s all really exciting. And yet, we know what the risks are. And so I think that balance of how we get the benefits and mitigates them, the risk is both exciting and scary. I know that’s not an answer, but that’s about it.

Henry Kipponen: There are many interesting venues with that, but I’m still wondering all the time, the food waste part, because that doesn’t make any sense to anyone. Because our food system is not producing money for anyone. So it doesn’t make sense in that. And then we’re wasting resources, and people are starving, and that kind of stuff. And I think that would be at least partially solvable with AI technologies. And it’s not like DNA and AI, it’s like some of the basic machine learning algorithms that can do that too.

Amelia: Yeah, addressing that, I believe 40% of food waste, that doesn’t even help feed the population. Yeah. Absolutely.

Gerbrand Haverkamp: I hope climate change, my hope is on climate change. I mean, generally, AI will contribute hugely to the energy, but it will try to deal with its own problem. And in dealing with that, I hope it gets some breakthroughs on climate change.

Amelia: That’d be very exciting. Well, I would like to invite you all to thank your panelists.

Tonilyn Lim: Good afternoon, I’m Tonilyn Lim, Chief of Programs of the UN Global Conference. I’m not Sanda’s AI. I’m taking over. She has to go to another meeting. But anyway, I’d like to thank the panel who really gave us a very rich explanation. of the possibilities in many applications, the role of the private sector in providing infrastructure, skills development and support of the public sector’s initiatives, as well as how to get technology more accessible, especially to farmers, SMEs, small businesses and individuals as such, and the role of the UN in providing the guardrails and also partnerships on the ground as countries continue to develop their own regulations and how private sector can also support in that undertaking and all the other sectors of society. So we’ll now go on to the second panel. It will be an interactive dialogue on also empowering Africa’s future, AI as a catalyst for youth development. So I’d like to call on the moderator, Farai Gundan, from the inspirational youth leader at Harvard University. All right, thank you. And maybe also call to the stage now our other panelists from Bren Chiliabogwe, head of Pan-African institutions, government institutions and public policy of Google, Kolawole Olajide, CEO and co-founder of Sava, and Rodney Njika, UNESCO liaison head to the United Nations Economic Commission in Africa.

Farai Gundan: Sorry, the Honorable Minister of Youth from Nigeria will be joining us.

Tonilyn Lim: Okay, thank you. Honorable Minister, may we also invite you to the stage? Thank you.

Farai Gundan: Thank you so much. Good afternoon to all the parties in the room and the minister made some way to the chairs here. All protocol observed. I’m honored to be here today. I must say getting everyone in the room in one place is almost as rare as catching a New York cab during rush hour. So that was actually me going to AI to ask, okay, give me a joke that will fit this room. Africa boasts the youngest population in the world with over 60% of its population under the age of 25. So to the gentleman who said. and that’s European, this is Africa’s youth here. This is how young we look and how young we are. This dynamic youth demographic holds immense potential as a driving force for innovations, economic growth and social change. With proper investment in education, skills development and entrepreneurship, Africa’s youth could transform the continent into a global leader in technology, sustainable development, creative industries and unleashing the best energy and talent of its next generation. And no, that wasn’t AI, that came from my heart. This panel, Empowering Africa’s Youth, AI as a Catalyst for Youth Development, seeks to amplify our voices, the voice and role of youth, business, government as ethical stewards of AI development and guide the private sector as we make advances with Gen AI. Against the backdrop of the policy brief that was mentioned earlier, Artificial Intelligence for Sustainable Youth Development in Africa, a multi-stakeholder collaboration including member states and the private sector. A sheet has gone around the room with a QR code for the link to the policy brief. I’m hoping we’ve all had a chance to actually scan it. So I’ll give a moment to figure out where the sheet is. It’s important that we actually scan and have access to this policy brief. I do want to congratulate you, Chido and Sandra in her absence and your various teams as well as your partners in the role and the work that you have done in putting together this policy brief. So can we just put our hands together for the equity? I certainly look forward to digging into it and sharing with my network. And I challenge all of us in the room to do the same. Now that is out of the way, I’m honored to introduce a very representative panel that reflects the promise and the potential of Africa. Her Excellency, Dr. Jamila Ibrahim, who’s a Nigerian medical doctor, development specialist and politician, currently serving as Nigeria’s minister of youth. She was appointed to the minister, to the position by President Bula to be in September, 2023. So please help me welcome your honours. To her right is Priscilla Boa-Gue. She currently serves as Google’s head for pan-African institutions, government affairs and public policy, where she oversees policy engagement with the African Union Commission, EU Economic Commission for Africa, African Development Bank, amongst other regional organizations. And then, right next to me is a fellow entrepreneur. It turns out that Paula and I are both Spintech founders and he is co-founder and CEO of Saba, and he has co-founded Bridge Labs, driven by his passion for creating high-quality tech solutions that empower organizations to excel in the modern era, while providing employment for young professionals across the continent. I’m so delighted to have this amazing panel and we’re going to be discussing, the title of our panel is, again, Empowering Africa’s Future, AI as a Catalyst for Youth Development. And I’m going to start with the minister herself. I know you’re new to the role. A significant portion of Africa’s youth is employed in the informal sector. How can AI be leveraged to support youth working in the sector? And what steps are actually being taken to formalize and optimize their contributions towards technology? And I want to also reflect on the ambassador. You mentioned that the fundamentals have to be in place for us to take advantage of AI, particularly on the continent. So I would love to hear your views on. on what, how can we leverage our AI, given the backdrop of no power in some instances, no water, and the infrastructure needs to be expanded.

Jamila Bio Ibrahim: Thank you. Thank you very much for having me on the panel. Well, looking at the infrastructure gaps in Africa and in Nigeria in context, we’re in the process of speaking, I’ll just speak in the context of what the Nigerian government is doing. We’re very committed to investing in young people. And of course, speaking out on talents, because we reflect, you know, from the recent past, most of the tech, we have about six of the tech influence that emerged from Africa are actually Nigerians. We have the founders of, the founder of Andela, Flutterwave, which is a fintech company, I’m sure you’re familiar with. We have this talents that are yet untapped, and we’re very aware of that. And we’re working very hard to ensure that we invest in these talents, regardless of the infrastructure gaps. And we’re also, in our part, at the Ministry of Youth Development, we’re tasked with the responsibility to ensure that we create a new environment for young people to thrive. And education, intelligence, and of course, the digital technology space, even though we have a Ministry of Digital Communications and Digital Technology, this ministry drives the policy of, you know, technology and digital communications. However, as a ministry of youth, we have a very robust collaboration. to ensure that we have this, we really identify young people and because we are the first point of contrast between young people and governments, right, and leveraging on a fund that we supervise or we superintend, the Mutual Investment Fund, which is about 17 million U.S. dollars, equivalent that has been approved by the Federal Executive Council to ensure that we empower or rather invest in young people across various sectors, including sectors that were earlier mentioned, the green and green economy and agriculture space. Of course, for us as well, we have an emerging space for that, for the view economy, right, and for extractive as well. And I was very excited when the previous panelists mentioned the deployment of technology to address waste and of course, when they mentioned agriculture. So, the Mutual Investment Fund is, we hope to empower young people in various sectors, including agriculture. And looking at agriculture alone and seeing that reference was made particularly to agriculture and how we can use young people’s creativity to create solutions in that space. And I believe that with efficient intentions and digital technology improvement in digital technology, we will be able to achieve a lot if we are leveraging on agriculture alone, which is our lowest-priority food experience for income from Nigeria. So, beyond that, we really want to invest in young people who are doing remarkable, you know, things in this space. And as a ministry, we’re also in the process of design or rehabilitating our youth development centres and making them up to standard, where we have various devices and all that young people require to, you know, design. softwares and just to create, basically to be digitally creative and as a matter of fact, we’re also going down to the grassroots to ensure that we’re very inclusive and ensure that we do not leave young people in these communities behind. We want to work with the private sector and telecoms companies to ensure that these communities have access and then reach the sub-divide in Nigeria. And you also are aware that a not very recent policy direction or statement was made by Nigeria or commitment rather, the cost of the main band cables for internet infrastructure was actually crushed. It was crushed a great deal. I think it’s about one and a half per metre now to leave fibre optic cables for the tech companies in order to ensure that we give access to rural communities and to people in rural communities to technology. So I think that is a very, it’s a remarkable achievement for us as a government. And we’re also ensuring that, I mean, if this policy comes to fruition and the private sector leverages on it, I think that’s enabling the environment to ensure that we increase access. Yeah, I’m excited about the TIFO administration. I also see that they also liberalise access to power as well. So that has been some exciting development, ensuring that even the most rural communities are able to access it.

Farai Gundan: Thank you so much for your remarks, Dr. Jamila. Over to you, Priscilla. You are over at Google. How should policies evolve to support the integration of AI into youth development? programs in Africa. And then I also want to add to that, who then owns that data? Because it’s one thing to actually begin to develop these training models with the data, but who should own data? Does it reside on the continent or does it reside here in the U.S. with the various companies?

Priscilla: Thank you so much. I’m humbled to be here next to the minister who is also a doctor on the side in your spare time. I think you’re a tremendous example of our African community. Google has been on the continent for about 17 years and we invest $1 billion. And we are in four countries across the continent, Nigeria, Ghana, South Africa, and Kenya. And I bring this up because two of those countries actually host our African AI research centers. So we already employ PhD students, researchers, engineers who are African, who are from Africa, who are deploying and developing technologies for Africa. So the technology exists and we have researchers and experts who focus on how do we identify solutions to the pressing problems that we have on the continent. And they’ve been doing this since 2018. So now we have a new center in Kenya that focuses on food security, some of the agricultural precision, and some of the different food security issues that we mentioned. But it’s important to note that Africa is a regionally diverse space, right? And so is our digital ecosystem. It is very diverse. Now we have some very strong digital economies like Nigeria, Kenya, South Africa, and Ghana. So we have a lot of work to do to distribute from some of that world, right? And this is where I think that young people have a really important role to play because they are developing some of this innovation, like our both of you are deploying some of these technologies. But we need to have supportive and enabling systems in place. So, what I’ve been doing is working with the African Union, with our colleagues at the Commission to see how do we do this at scale? How do we take a really positive example to expand it to those 55 member countries? And I think one of the greatest examples that we have is African Startup Policy Framework that recently just came out. And so, this will enable all of the member states to develop policies that incentivize founders to go and take a leap from work, to then go and start their startups, to have incubators in place, to have grants, and to really be able to have a community that supports the development of startups. Because Google was once a startup, once upon a time as well. And so, we think about what was in place in order for a company like Google to thrive? And how do we create more of those that are African, that are African-based? And so, policy is really, really critical. In addition to putting in place policies to support our young people, we also have to get our policymakers at a level where they are literate and really conversant in subjects that we are discussing, right? It’s hard to have a conversation with someone who’s not speaking the same language, right? We’re speaking past each other. And this is globally, not just in Africa. My colleagues in the EU face some of the same issues. And I think the advantage that we have is that we can take some of the lessons from the other regions and then choose what will be best and what will work for the continent. So that we can determine how we leapfrog, because we don’t have some of the same legacy issues that some of the developing countries have, right? So I think in some spaces, we actually have some advantages when it comes to policy. And then we have some disadvantages that we know about, but we’re doing a lot in this space. And I would love to invite everyone here, actually, to our AI policy training, short plug, at the Global Africa Business Initiative. So it will be on Wednesday. Right here in the city. We hope you can come. It’s basically an AI policy training course for policymakers and government officials. If you’re not a government official, you can still reach out to me. We have other programs. But it’s basically intended to make sure that our policymakers are literate in this domain and that they also can see the value and how we can help them in the delivery of government services to citizens. And then can also feel empowered to regulate AI.

Farai Gundan: Amazing. I love the fact that it is centralizing, at least at a policy development level. I actually was involved in the market entry for a flood away in South Africa. And so that is part of my journey as a FinTech founder. So I’m so excited. But essentially what happens and speaks to this is we literally have to go to every central bank in Africa, 55, and ask for permission and understand the regulatory environment in each marketplace. And then begin to build our API stack for each marketplace. So you can imagine how challenging this can be, but excited about what Gen AI can do for us. So to you, Kola, founder to founder, FinTech founder to founder, from your experience as CEO of Sava, a FinTech payment system, what are the main challenges facing the implementation of digital innovation in Africa? And I’ll let you share the pain, what keeps us up at night. And hopefully they’re quite similar.

Kolawole Olajide: Thank you so much. So at Sava we built the smartest bank card in Africa. And, you know, with the partnership with MasterCard and raising $5 million from investors. The goal was, you know, how do we enable investment in Africa in the next 20 pages. We built software that allows businesses to issue cards and write rules. You can write rules across four verticals, budget, time, location, and merchant. You could write a rule to say, hey, Conrad business of Africa is traveling to the United States. This card will only work on these days. This card will only work on these merchants, and these merchants, this card will only work at this time of the day. If Conrad will submit certain receipts on time, he wouldn’t be able to use the card anymore. So now you might have so many merchants coming up every day on the continent, and we need these rules to be active in real time. There’s just so much computing power going to be keeping this system active. And, you know, building this solution has opened my eyes to, I mean, deeply into the world of AI. And I’ll start with the point on the regulations, right? With this solution now, with the MasterCard partnership, we can basically operate in any country, MasterCard operates in the United States today, but we still need regulatory approval in each country to be able to go live. Right now, we have approvals in South Africa, and we have approvals in Kenya, and we’re growing. But I think what’s really important for me, I mean, in this, for my experience, was the cost of training this machine. I think there’s a lot of conversations we’re having around at the service layer, which is what can we do with these tools? But if as a continent, we’re not, you know, intentional about being in the value chain of what creates these tools, it would always continue to be a barrier for entry, even if we have the best centers on the continent. Right. And, you know, I’ll just quickly talk you through the value chain of, you know, AI, before it gets into your hands on certificate. Yeah. There’s a specialized hardware that needs to be developed. And a lot of that is designed with resources from the continent, but made in China. Then because of high demand for computing power, these devices, and then this specialized hardware is already fully bought out by two to three companies, Google, Microsoft. Then there are some intellectual property models, proprietary models, called the foundational models that hosts the machine learning ops. And then we have custom layers for different applications, and then we have the services. If as a continent, we only participate in that service layer, we have a big problem in the long-term. We will continue to, it will be very expensive for us. And I think it’s important that for government, we need to be intentional about being participating in this chain. How do we get Google and Microsoft and some of these players to localize some of the technology and help bring down the costs, so that the top talent on the continent can deal with better solutions at an affordable price and also scale up.

Farai Gundan: Thank you so much. And it is definitely a pipeline issue, it’s definitely a value chain issue, where we have to play and own, I’m really big on ownership, ownership of the data, because it comes from us, right? So we have to own that data, even where the data resides, it has to reside on the continent. I was in Rwanda, and President Parker Ghani has said, Rwanda is a proof of concept country. And so come in and play and try all these things, but we retain that knowledge, we retain our failures, we retain our successes, because we understand our people. When talking about value chain, Minister Jamila, Dr. Jamila, what is being done to integrate AI and digital skills at the inter-educational systems across Nigeria, but also across the continent? And I have a two-part question for you. And the second part is, how can governments and the private sector work together to put young people with the necessary AI skills to thrive in the future economy? Taking what Paula has said in mind, that we’re not at the service level, so we’re not creating like fun games, service level games, but really at a hardware. Can we create the hardware that’s necessary to capture this data? Can we play at every level? So what are we doing from an educational perspective? And it’s a pipeline question.

Jamila Bio Ibrahim: Yes, very, very interesting question. Integrating AI at government level, in the schools and curriculum and all of that. I had engagements with the Minister of Education, because that’s the responsibility. Yes, policy mandates of the Ministry of Education. And I’m very excited to tell you that earlier this year, we had the EdTech conference in Abuja, in partnership with Mastercard Foundation. It was fully collaborated with the Ministry of Education, Ministry of Youth and Ministry of Education. And then there’s also an ongoing review of the curriculum at the national level to ensure that we integrate AI into our learning model. Right. And that’s, I mean, the direction, that’s the policy direction for this administration to ensure that we capacitate young people for learning, to think of AI within ethical limits. And, well, partnerships, I was just going to speak to how to engage and see how we can collaborate, yes, with Google, see how we can work together, even beyond the software, the games and the hardware. I mean, I have set some stages here, but I just went on the floor around some of the government offices in Nigeria, and realized that there were a lot of these components that were only here. So it raised a lot of concern here, and I had to talk to some of the heads of government to see how we can leverage the power of creativity and the potential of young Nigerians to actually start designing and fabricating and creating these components. So for local consumption.

Farai Gundan: So manufacturing.

Jamila Bio Ibrahim: Manufacturing.

Farai Gundan: On the continent.

Jamila Bio Ibrahim: On the continent.

Farai Gundan: So our inputs from the continent, beneficiation has to go on the continent.

Jamila Bio Ibrahim: That’s right. So there is the call to all partners to come to the table to work with us. I mean, we may not have all the resources, but we have a little change we can use to invest in new materials.

Farai Gundan: I don’t think Nigeria, you can put a little of Nigeria.

Jamila Bio Ibrahim: Well, I really, really think it’s time. I mean, who doesn’t invest in presidential initiatives to develop enterprises across the various digital technologies space, creative industry, agriculture, extractive industry as well. And there are also opportunities for investment in health sector as well. I mean, we have tech solutions in health as well. The continent has over 100 million young people who are unemployed and underemployed. Yes. And 53 million of these young people are Nigerians.

Farai Gundan: Yeah. So 100 million across the continent, 53 are Nigerian.

Jamila Bio Ibrahim: That is correct. So that leaves me with sleepless nights at the wedding to ensure that we continue to create opportunities to replace the youth capacity of these young people. and place them in meaningful employment. And that’s what, you know, inspired us to create or to design the initiative called the Co-exemption Initiative on Regions and Vice-Versa. I mean, all the sectors we’ve mentioned and we’ve been passing it on to people beyond just faculty, field and health, we’re handing it on to people through that process, the process of ideation of their, you know, conception of their ideas, all the way down to the creation of, I mean, access to markets and to the point of return on investment. We’re highly committed to that. And we’re, I mean, what’s it called? Partners, general and board and private sector, I mean, governments. Inquilus here, and Google is here.

Farai Gundan: So I do want to quickly jump in. You mentioned that you want to pull our sister to the side and maybe talk about collaboration. And I’m really excited to see that already, you know, partnerships are coming out of this. So talking about that, well, on the Google side, should a partnership or collaboration come out of this? The question would be, AI is one of Google’s priority areas in Africa. What ethical considerations should be taken into account when implementing AI technology? So here you are, the minister wants to talk to you about a collaboration. What should, what ethical consideration from your side, from your perspective, that should go into this? Just a quick answer to that.

Priscilla: I’ll just say there are many ethical considerations. We have ethical, responsible AI principles that we developed in 2018, actually, that we use to guide our company’s deployment of AI. But particularly in Africa, some of the things we think about a lot is how do we prevent a widening digital divide? Right. So, we’re deploying these amazing technologies. How do we make it more accessible and useful to more people on the continent? And how do we make sure that we’re not left behind in a lot of these conversations? A lot of that, for us, will have to do with having African data, African data sets, like you were saying, and making sure that we have local languages included as part of the development of data. And so, we’re doing a lot more partnerships with African universities and African researchers in this particular context.

Farai Gundan: Excellent. Thank you so much. In the interest of time, I’m going to move over to Kola. And I want you to wrap up our panel by answering this question. How can collaboration between youth-led startups, such as Atlas, because we are the youth, private sector, and governments be beneficial for the implementation of AI-driven initiatives?

Kolawole Olajide: Great question. So, yeah, I think technology would always move faster than innovation. We would always have both entrepreneurs trying to push the boundaries, right? But I think it’s, we need to be intentional about, you know, shortening that gap. And instead of solving for the perfect framework, because this moves so fast, let’s solve for having the right people in the room, right? And believe me, if we have the right people in the room, no matter how fast technology moves, you know, with the right people in the room, we’ll be able to catch up much faster, and hopefully at some point, we will be ahead, right? You know, and with that being said, I think, you know, sharing my experience, we would need a lot more, you know, private, you know, I would say investors in Africa to take the startup scene seriously, right? Now, a lot of the funding is international, and then you come to a lot of, you know, foreign PCs, and that also influences, you know, our goals. And yeah, of course, and also investment in education, right? We need the right talent to be able to take this forward on the continent. And yeah, I think it’s a super exciting time. You know, I remember when cloud was the hottest thing, right? And everyone, you know, we were late to that game. Now we’re paying so much to get, you know, great, I mean, good quality access to stable cloud. Let’s just make sure the same doesn’t happen with AI.

Jamila Bio Ibrahim: I really think it’s important to encourage young innovators and creators. I really think I need to just let you know that there’s a lot of hope, you know, that the Ministry of Youth is bringing to young people in that space. And in the coming months, we hope to actually create a platform where through venture capital funding, I mean, young people can have access to, you know, some form of an investment. So we have a platform where we’re working very hard to see, we bring young people across the states to teach potential investors. And of course, we leverage as well on the youth development bank that we hope to establish. And that’s in the long term. But in the interim, we can leverage temporarily in the short term, yes, on the youth investment fund and just, you know, do this venture capital thing where people can teach their ideas. And we’re calling on partners to work with us to achieve this.

Farai Gundan: Yes. Thank you so, so much. Thank you for indulging us. To the Honorable Minister, thank you. Priscilla, thank you. Kola, thank you. Thank you to the partners, to Chido, and to everyone else at the A&E.

Moderator: In lieu of a full question and answer, since we’re running out of time, but please, you have the floor. Thank you so much for all these panels and information. I want to make a reflection about who could be involved in this especially too. I’m just coming back from Africa, precisely from the people in Dava, I’m sure some of you know it. It’s an amazing organization of grassroots researchers from all over Africa. They’re doing an amazing work on AI for good. In fact, I think they are leading the AI for good research in the world and we have a lot to learn internationally from what’s happening there. And so all this to say that I think academia and research, it’s not just a discussion, it seemed to me that it was a little bit discussion of private sector startups and government trying to put some regulation of what’s happening from the private sector. Maybe we have to think deeper. What are the goals of AI? Is it just innovation? Innovation for what, right? We are working on many different uses of generative AI and other types of AI, simulations for new policies, informing new global development indicators. This is also AI. And this is happening in Africa too. So this is just what I wanted to say. Let’s include all the stakeholders, especially in Africa. They’re doing an amazing work and we all have to learn from what’s happening there, especially in Dava.

Tonilyn Lim: Thank you very much. I think that was also a message that we got from the other panelists, the partnership, the involvement of different stakeholders from the UN to the private sector and certainly also academia and the research community certainly have to come together all to make this work, scale it for better adoption while respecting freedoms and rights as such. So anyway, I would like to close this session. I actually am not happy to do that, but we have to close at some point. Oh, sorry. We have a youth representative. I can’t, I just have to give like everything. Yes. Oh, okay. Do you want to come here?

Little boy: I just want to say that I am, I’m from India. I’m the world’s youngest speaker on technology and innovation. I’ve written a book on AI and I feel that can impact many lives of African kids who cannot be educated. Thank you. Sorry, I’m his father. No, thank you. It was a pleasure to be reading this book.

Tonilyn Lim: Yes. Thank you very much. So, along with the publication of Ranveer, please also have a chance to download publications from the UN Global Conference on AI for the Global Goals and also publications from IOE and our partners from AU. Thank you very much. And thank you all for attending this session. Thank you.

S

Sanda Ojiambo

Speech speed

183 words per minute

Speech length

1832 words

Speech time

598 seconds

AI can accelerate innovation and increase productivity to drive SDG progress

Explanation

Sanda Ojiambo argues that AI has the potential to accelerate innovation and increase productivity, which can help drive progress towards the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). This suggests that AI can be a powerful tool for achieving global sustainability targets.

Evidence

A survey of about 1,600 CEOs revealed that 75% of large companies are in the process of embedding AI into their work and strategies.

Major Discussion Point

The potential of AI for sustainable development and achieving the SDGs

Agreed with

Gerbrand Haverkamp

Agreed on

AI has significant potential for sustainable development and achieving SDGs

Disagreed with

Kolawole Olajide

Disagreed on

Focus of AI development and implementation

Gen AI can help solve complex sustainability problems like circular business models and food waste reduction

Explanation

Sanda Ojiambo suggests that Generative AI can be used to address complex sustainability challenges. This includes developing circular business models and reducing food waste, which are important aspects of sustainable development.

Major Discussion Point

The potential of AI for sustainable development and achieving the SDGs

Agreed with

Gerbrand Haverkamp

Agreed on

AI has significant potential for sustainable development and achieving SDGs

AI has potential to transform industries and deliver solutions for the global goals

Explanation

Sanda Ojiambo argues that AI has the capability to revolutionize various industries and provide solutions that can help achieve global sustainability goals. This implies that AI can have a wide-ranging impact across different sectors.

Evidence

Interviews with about 30 executives revealed recognition of AI’s capacity to truly transform industry and drive progress towards global goals.

Major Discussion Point

The potential of AI for sustainable development and achieving the SDGs

Agreed with

Gerbrand Haverkamp

Agreed on

AI has significant potential for sustainable development and achieving SDGs

Need for multi-stakeholder collaboration including governments, private sector, and civil society

Explanation

Sanda Ojiambo emphasizes the importance of collaboration between various stakeholders, including governments, private sector, and civil society. This multi-stakeholder approach is seen as crucial for effectively developing and implementing AI technologies for sustainable development.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of collaboration and partnerships

Agreed with

Priscilla Boa-Gue

Kolawole Olajide

Agreed on

Importance of collaboration and partnerships in AI development and implementation

C

Christopher Lu

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Lack of basic infrastructure like internet access and electricity in many areas

Explanation

Christopher Lu points out that many areas, particularly in developing countries, lack basic infrastructure such as internet access and electricity. This poses a significant challenge to the implementation and adoption of AI technologies in these regions.

Evidence

Lu mentions that 33% of the world is without internet access, making it impossible for them to use generative AI.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and risks of AI implementation in Africa

Risk of widening inequality if AI benefits don’t reach everyone

Explanation

Christopher Lu warns that if the benefits of AI are not distributed equally, it could lead to increased inequality. This highlights the importance of ensuring that AI technologies are accessible and beneficial to all segments of society.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and risks of AI implementation in Africa

K

Kolawole Olajide

Speech speed

157 words per minute

Speech length

807 words

Speech time

306 seconds

High costs of AI development and implementation for African startups

Explanation

Kolawole Olajide highlights the significant costs associated with AI development and implementation for African startups. This financial barrier can hinder innovation and adoption of AI technologies in the African context.

Evidence

Olajide mentions the high costs of training AI models and the need for specialized hardware, which is often bought out by large tech companies.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and risks of AI implementation in Africa

Disagreed with

Sanda Ojiambo

Disagreed on

Focus of AI development and implementation

Collaboration between youth-led startups, private sector and governments

Explanation

Kolawole Olajide emphasizes the importance of collaboration between youth-led startups, the private sector, and governments. This collaborative approach is seen as crucial for the successful implementation of AI-driven initiatives in Africa.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of collaboration and partnerships

Agreed with

Sanda Ojiambo

Priscilla Boa-Gue

Agreed on

Importance of collaboration and partnerships in AI development and implementation

P

Priscilla Boa-Gue

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Need for ethical considerations and responsible AI principles

Explanation

Priscilla Boa-Gue emphasizes the importance of ethical considerations and responsible AI principles in the development and deployment of AI technologies. This ensures that AI is used in a way that respects human rights and societal values.

Evidence

Boa-Gue mentions Google’s ethical and responsible AI principles developed in 2018 that guide the company’s deployment of AI.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and risks of AI implementation in Africa

Creating enabling policy environments to support AI startups

Explanation

Priscilla Boa-Gue argues for the creation of supportive policy environments to foster AI startups. This includes developing policies that incentivize founders and provide necessary support structures for startup growth.

Evidence

Boa-Gue mentions the African Startup Policy Framework as an example of an initiative to enable member states to develop policies that support startups.

Major Discussion Point

Strategies for empowering African youth through AI

Partnerships between tech companies and African institutions to develop local AI solutions

Explanation

Priscilla Boa-Gue highlights the importance of partnerships between tech companies and African institutions. These collaborations aim to develop AI solutions that are tailored to local needs and contexts in Africa.

Evidence

Boa-Gue mentions Google’s partnerships with African universities and researchers to develop AI solutions with African data and local languages.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of collaboration and partnerships

Agreed with

Sanda Ojiambo

Kolawole Olajide

Agreed on

Importance of collaboration and partnerships in AI development and implementation

J

Jamila Bio Ibrahim

Speech speed

130 words per minute

Speech length

1415 words

Speech time

651 seconds

Investing in talent development and digital skills training for youth

Explanation

Jamila Bio Ibrahim emphasizes the importance of investing in talent development and digital skills training for youth. This strategy aims to prepare young people for the AI-driven future and enable them to contribute to technological innovation.

Evidence

Ibrahim mentions the Nigerian government’s commitment to investing in young people and tapping into untapped tech talents.

Major Discussion Point

Strategies for empowering African youth through AI

Integrating AI and digital skills into educational curricula

Explanation

Jamila Bio Ibrahim discusses the integration of AI and digital skills into educational curricula. This approach aims to ensure that young people are equipped with the necessary skills to thrive in an AI-driven economy from an early age.

Evidence

Ibrahim mentions an ongoing review of the curriculum at the national level in Nigeria to integrate AI into the learning model.

Major Discussion Point

Strategies for empowering African youth through AI

Providing funding and investment opportunities for youth-led AI initiatives

Explanation

Jamila Bio Ibrahim discusses the importance of providing funding and investment opportunities for youth-led AI initiatives. This strategy aims to support young innovators and creators in developing AI solutions.

Evidence

Ibrahim mentions plans to create a platform for venture capital funding and leverage the youth investment fund to support young people’s ideas.

Major Discussion Point

Strategies for empowering African youth through AI

G

Gerbrand Haverkamp

Speech speed

202 words per minute

Speech length

808 words

Speech time

239 seconds

AI can contribute to breakthroughs on climate change

Explanation

Gerbrand Haverkamp expresses hope that AI can lead to significant breakthroughs in addressing climate change. This suggests that AI technologies could play a crucial role in developing solutions to one of the world’s most pressing environmental challenges.

Major Discussion Point

The potential of AI for sustainable development and achieving the SDGs

Agreed with

Sanda Ojiambo

Agreed on

AI has significant potential for sustainable development and achieving SDGs

U

Unknown speaker

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Inclusion of academia and grassroots researchers in AI development

Explanation

An audience member argues for the inclusion of academia and grassroots researchers in AI development. This suggests that a broader range of perspectives and expertise should be involved in shaping AI technologies and their applications.

Evidence

The speaker mentions the work of Dava, an organization of grassroots researchers from Africa, as an example of important contributions to AI for good research.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of collaboration and partnerships

Agreements

Agreement Points

AI has significant potential for sustainable development and achieving SDGs

Speakers

Sanda Ojiambo

Gerbrand Haverkamp

Arguments

AI can accelerate innovation and increase productivity to drive SDG progress

Gen AI can help solve complex sustainability problems like circular business models and food waste reduction

AI has potential to transform industries and deliver solutions for the global goals

AI can contribute to breakthroughs on climate change

Summary

Multiple speakers emphasized AI’s potential to drive progress towards sustainable development goals through innovation, productivity increases, and addressing complex sustainability challenges.

Importance of collaboration and partnerships in AI development and implementation

Speakers

Sanda Ojiambo

Priscilla Boa-Gue

Kolawole Olajide

Arguments

Need for multi-stakeholder collaboration including governments, private sector, and civil society

Partnerships between tech companies and African institutions to develop local AI solutions

Collaboration between youth-led startups, private sector and governments

Summary

Speakers agreed on the crucial role of collaboration between various stakeholders, including governments, private sector, civil society, and academic institutions, in effectively developing and implementing AI technologies.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers highlighted significant challenges in implementing AI in Africa, particularly related to infrastructure and cost barriers.

Speakers

Christopher Lu

Kolawole Olajide

Arguments

Lack of basic infrastructure like internet access and electricity in many areas

High costs of AI development and implementation for African startups

Both speakers emphasized the importance of creating supportive environments for AI startups and youth-led initiatives through policy and funding mechanisms.

Speakers

Priscilla Boa-Gue

Jamila Bio Ibrahim

Arguments

Creating enabling policy environments to support AI startups

Providing funding and investment opportunities for youth-led AI initiatives

Unexpected Consensus

Importance of local data and context in AI development

Speakers

Priscilla Boa-Gue

Unknown speaker

Arguments

Partnerships between tech companies and African institutions to develop local AI solutions

Inclusion of academia and grassroots researchers in AI development

Explanation

Despite representing different sectors (tech industry and academia), both speakers emphasized the importance of involving local institutions and researchers in AI development, highlighting a shared recognition of the value of local context and expertise.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement centered around AI’s potential for sustainable development, the need for collaboration and partnerships, and the importance of addressing infrastructure and cost challenges in AI implementation in Africa.

Consensus level

There was a moderate level of consensus among speakers on key issues. This consensus suggests a shared understanding of AI’s potential benefits and challenges in the African context, which could facilitate more coordinated efforts in AI development and implementation. However, the diversity of perspectives also highlights the complexity of the issues and the need for continued dialogue and collaboration among various stakeholders.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Focus of AI development and implementation

Speakers

Sanda Ojiambo

Kolawole Olajide

Arguments

AI can accelerate innovation and increase productivity to drive SDG progress

High costs of AI development and implementation for African startups

Summary

While Sanda Ojiambo emphasizes the potential of AI to drive progress towards SDGs, Kolawole Olajide highlights the financial barriers that African startups face in developing and implementing AI technologies.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around the challenges of implementing AI in Africa, including infrastructure limitations, costs, and the need for ethical considerations.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among the speakers is relatively low. Most speakers acknowledge both the potential benefits and challenges of AI implementation in Africa. The differences in their arguments mainly stem from their different areas of expertise and focus, rather than fundamental disagreements. This suggests a generally aligned perspective on the topic, which could facilitate collaborative efforts in addressing the challenges and leveraging the opportunities of AI for sustainable development in Africa.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

Both speakers agree on the need to address potential negative impacts of AI, but they focus on different aspects. Christopher Lu emphasizes the risk of widening inequality, while Priscilla Boa-Gue focuses on the need for ethical considerations and responsible AI principles.

Speakers

Christopher Lu

Priscilla Boa-Gue

Arguments

Risk of widening inequality if AI benefits don’t reach everyone

Need for ethical considerations and responsible AI principles

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers highlighted significant challenges in implementing AI in Africa, particularly related to infrastructure and cost barriers.

Speakers

Christopher Lu

Kolawole Olajide

Arguments

Lack of basic infrastructure like internet access and electricity in many areas

High costs of AI development and implementation for African startups

Both speakers emphasized the importance of creating supportive environments for AI startups and youth-led initiatives through policy and funding mechanisms.

Speakers

Priscilla Boa-Gue

Jamila Bio Ibrahim

Arguments

Creating enabling policy environments to support AI startups

Providing funding and investment opportunities for youth-led AI initiatives

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

AI has significant potential to accelerate sustainable development and progress on the SDGs, particularly in areas like agriculture, healthcare, and climate change mitigation

There are major challenges to AI implementation in Africa, including lack of infrastructure, high costs, and risks of widening inequality

Empowering African youth through AI requires investment in education, skills training, supportive policies, and funding opportunities

Multi-stakeholder collaboration between governments, private sector, academia, and civil society is crucial for responsible and inclusive AI development in Africa

Resolutions and Action Items

Google to host an AI policy training for African policymakers and government officials

Nigerian Ministry of Youth to create a platform for young innovators to pitch ideas to potential investors

Nigerian government to review and update educational curricula to integrate AI

African Union to implement the African Startup Policy Framework to support AI startups

Unresolved Issues

How to ensure AI benefits reach rural and marginalized communities

Ownership and control of African data used to develop AI systems

How to increase African participation in hardware development and other parts of the AI value chain

Balancing innovation with ethical concerns and responsible AI development

Suggested Compromises

Partnering with tech companies to localize AI technology development in Africa to reduce costs

Balancing government regulation with allowing space for innovation in AI startups

Combining international investment with local African investment in AI initiatives

Thought Provoking Comments

Gen AI can be a true game-changer for sustainability progress because it will democratize access to information, it will accelerate innovation through the solutions, through cross-disciplinary thinking, and certainly by increasing productivity.

Speaker

Sanda Ojiambo

Reason

This comment highlights the transformative potential of AI for sustainable development in multiple dimensions.

Impact

It set the tone for the discussion by emphasizing AI’s positive potential, leading to further exploration of specific use cases and applications.

At best, AI will help us solve the global goals, and that’s really important, but we must take a reality check because we realize that gaps in technology are really what keeps the world separate.

Speaker

Sanda Ojiambo

Reason

This balanced perspective acknowledges both the potential and challenges of AI adoption, particularly in developing regions.

Impact

It shifted the conversation to address issues of access and equity, prompting discussion on infrastructure needs and policy considerations.

AI will not take your job away, but the person with AI skills will.

Speaker

Shea Gopaul

Reason

This succinct statement captures a key concern about AI’s impact on employment in a memorable way.

Impact

It focused attention on the critical need for AI skills development and education, which became a recurring theme in later discussions.

If we do not do it here in the UN, it will either be decided in the US, in Europe, or in China, and then we know which other countries will not be at the table.

Speaker

Gerbrand Haverkamp

Reason

This comment underscores the importance of inclusive global governance for AI.

Impact

It emphasized the role of international bodies like the UN in AI governance, leading to discussion of ethical principles and regulatory frameworks.

If as a continent, we only participate in that service layer, we have a big problem in the long-term. We will continue to, it will be very expensive for us.

Speaker

Kolawole Olajide

Reason

This insight highlights the need for African countries to participate in all layers of the AI value chain, not just as end-users.

Impact

It shifted the discussion towards strategies for building local AI capabilities and infrastructure in Africa, including manufacturing and hardware development.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by highlighting both the transformative potential of AI for sustainable development and the critical challenges that need to be addressed, particularly in developing regions. The conversation evolved from general optimism about AI’s potential to a more nuanced exploration of access issues, skills development needs, governance challenges, and the importance of building local AI capabilities across the entire value chain. This led to a rich discussion of practical strategies and policy considerations for leveraging AI to benefit youth and drive sustainable development in Africa while addressing equity concerns.

Follow-up Questions

How can AI be made more accessible and affordable for developing countries and rural communities?

Speaker

Sanda Ojiambo, Christopher P. Lu, Jamila Bio Ibrahim

Explanation

Multiple speakers emphasized the need to bridge the digital divide and ensure AI benefits reach all communities, not just advanced economies.

What ethical principles and governance frameworks should guide AI development and deployment globally?

Speaker

Gerbrand Haverkamp, Christopher P. Lu

Explanation

Speakers highlighted the need for clear ethical guidelines and governance structures for AI, potentially developed through UN-led efforts.

How can African countries participate more in the AI value chain beyond just the service layer?

Speaker

Kolawole Olajide

Explanation

Olajide stressed the importance of Africa being involved in hardware development and other upstream aspects of AI, not just applications.

What steps are needed to integrate AI and digital skills into educational curricula across Africa?

Speaker

Farai Gundan, Jamila Bio Ibrahim

Explanation

Speakers discussed the need to update education systems to prepare youth for an AI-driven future economy.

How can governments and private sector collaborate to create more local manufacturing of AI hardware in Africa?

Speaker

Jamila Bio Ibrahim

Explanation

Ibrahim expressed interest in developing local manufacturing capabilities for AI components currently imported.

What measures can be taken to ensure African data used for AI development remains owned and stored on the continent?

Speaker

Farai Gundan

Explanation

Gundan raised concerns about data ownership and storage location for AI systems trained on African data.

How can more African private investors be encouraged to fund local AI and tech startups?

Speaker

Kolawole Olajide

Explanation

Olajide noted the reliance on foreign investors and the need for more local investment in African tech startups.

What role can academia and research institutions play in shaping AI development in Africa?

Speaker

Audience member

Explanation

An audience member highlighted the importance of including academic and research perspectives in AI discussions, not just private sector and government.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

UN issues final report with key recommendations on AI governance

In a world where AI is rapidly reshaping industries, societies, and geopolitics, the UN advisory body has stepped forward with its final report – ‘Governing AI for Humanity,’ presenting seven strategic recommendations for responsible AI governance. The report highlights the urgent need for global coordination in managing AI’s opportunities and risks, especially in light of the swift expansion of AI technologies like ChatGPT and the varied international regulatory approaches, such as the EU’s comprehensive AI Act and the contrasting regulatory policies of the US and China.

One of the primary suggestions is the establishment of an International Scientific Panel on AI. The body, modelled after the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, would bring together leading experts to provide timely, unbiased assessments of AI’s capabilities, risks, and uncertainties. The International Scientific Panel on AI would ensure that policymakers and civil society have access to the latest scientific understanding, helping to cut through the hype and misinformation that can surround new technological advances.

The AI Standards Exchange implementation would form a standard exchange bringing together global stakeholders, including national and international organizations, to debate and develop AI standards. It would ensure AI systems are aligned with global values like fairness and transparency.

AI Capacity Development Network is also one of the seven key points that would address disparities. The UN here proposes building an AI capacity network that would link centres of excellence globally, provide training and resources, and foster collaboration to empower countries that lack AI infrastructure.

Another key proposal is the creation of a Global AI Data Framework, which would provide a standardised approach to the governance of AI training data. Given that data is the lifeblood of AI systems, this framework would ensure the equitable sharing of data resources, promote transparency, and help balance the power dynamics between big AI companies and smaller emerging economies. The framework could also spur innovation by making AI development more accessible across different regions of the world.

The report further recommends forming a Global Fund for AI to bridge the AI divide between nations. The fund would provide financial and technical resources to countries lacking the infrastructure or expertise to develop AI technologies. The goal is to ensure that AI’s benefits are distributed equitably and not just concentrated in a few technologically advanced nations.

In tandem with these recommendations, the report advocates for a Policy Dialogue on AI Governance, emphasising the need for international cooperation to create harmonised regulations and avoid regulatory gaps. With AI systems impacting multiple sectors across borders, coherent global policies are necessary to prevent a ‘race to the bottom’ in safety standards and human rights protections.

Lastly, the UN calls for establishing an AI Office within the Secretariat, which would serve as a central hub for coordinating AI governance efforts across the UN and with other global stakeholders. This office would ensure that the recommendations are implemented effectively and that AI governance remains agile in rapid technological change.

Through these initiatives, the UN seeks to foster a world where AI can flourish while safeguarding human rights and promoting global equity. The report implies that the stakes are high, and only through coordinated global action can we harness AI’s potential while mitigating its risks.

Building Bridges through Science Diplomacy: Accelerating progress toward sustainable development

Building Bridges through Science Diplomacy: Accelerating progress toward sustainable development

Session at a Glance

Summary

This discussion focused on the role of science diplomacy in addressing global challenges and fostering international cooperation. Speakers highlighted how scientific collaboration can build trust between nations and contribute to sustainable development. Several case studies were presented, including marine conservation efforts between Costa Rica and Ecuador, the SESAME particle accelerator in the Middle East, and gorilla conservation work in Africa. These examples demonstrated how science can transcend political boundaries to tackle shared problems.

Participants emphasized the need to embed scientific expertise more deeply in diplomatic and policymaking processes. There were calls to increase funding for international scientific partnerships and to ensure developing countries are included. The importance of indigenous knowledge systems was highlighted, with a plea for their equal recognition alongside Western scientific approaches. Challenges facing science diplomacy were discussed, including geopolitical tensions, sanctions that hinder collaboration, and the undermining of trust in science.

Young scientists face particular obstacles in engaging in science diplomacy, such as visa restrictions and limited mobility. Speakers advocated for more inclusive policies to involve researchers from countries currently excluded from global scientific discourse. The discussion emphasized the need to simplify and communicate science effectively to the public to combat misinformation. Overall, participants agreed on the critical importance of strengthening the role of science in multilateral efforts to address urgent global issues like climate change and emerging technologies.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– Science diplomacy is crucial for addressing global challenges and building trust between nations

– There is a need to better integrate scientific evidence and expertise into policymaking and diplomatic processes

– Young scientists and researchers from underrepresented regions face challenges in participating in international scientific collaboration

– Indigenous knowledge systems should be recognized and integrated with Western scientific approaches

– Building public trust in science and combating misinformation is important for effective science diplomacy

Overall purpose/goal:

The discussion aimed to highlight the vital role of science in strengthening multilateralism and diplomacy to address urgent global challenges like climate change and sustainable development. It sought to showcase examples of successful science diplomacy and explore ways to enhance collaboration between scientists, policymakers and diplomats.

Tone:

The overall tone was optimistic and action-oriented, with speakers emphasizing the potential for science to build bridges between nations and drive positive change. However, there were also notes of urgency and concern, particularly regarding challenges like declining trust in science and barriers to international scientific cooperation. The tone became more impassioned during some of the calls to action in the closing remarks.

Speakers

Moderators/Facilitators:

– Melissa Fleming (Undersecretary General for Global Communications at the UN) – Moderated first part

– María Estelí Jarquín (Coordinator of international relations at UK Centre for Ecology and Hydrology) – Moderated second part

Speakers:

– Maritza Chan (Ambassador, Permanent Representative of Costa Rica to the UN) – Expertise in diplomacy and marine conservation

– Omar Hilale (Ambassador, Permanent Representative of Morocco to the UN) – Expertise in science, technology and innovation for Africa’s development

– Peter Gluckman (President of the International Science Council) – Expert on science diplomacy

– Gihan Kamel (Principal scientist at SESAME) – Expertise in science diplomacy in the Middle East

– Tara Stoinski (President of the Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund) – Expertise in gorilla conservation and research

– Evelina Santa-Kahle (Women in Science Diplomacy Association) – Expertise in promoting women in science diplomacy

– Jose Julio Casas (Eastern Tropical Marine Corridor) – Expertise in marine conservation

– Sandrine Dixson-Declève (Co-president of the Club of Rome) – Expertise in facilitating difficult conversations on climate and sustainability

– Dalee Sambo Dorough (Arctic indigenous peoples expert) – Expertise in indigenous rights and knowledge systems

– Mohammad Hosseini (Assistant professor at Northwestern University) – Expertise in research ethics and trust in science

– Tshilidzi Marwala (Rector of the United Nations University) – Expertise in higher education and science policy

– Emran Mian (Director General at UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology) – Expertise in science policy and international collaboration

Full session report

Science Diplomacy: Bridging Nations and Addressing Global Challenges

This discussion, moderated by Melissa Fleming and María Estelí Jarquín, brought together a diverse panel of experts to explore the critical role of science diplomacy in addressing global challenges and fostering international cooperation. The conversation highlighted successful case studies, identified key challenges, and proposed strategies for enhancing collaboration between scientists, policymakers, and diplomats.

Importance of Science Diplomacy

Speakers emphasized the crucial importance of science diplomacy for tackling global issues. Ambassador Maritza Chan highlighted how scientific collaboration can bridge gaps between nations, while Ambassador Omar Hilale stressed its potential to leverage scientific expertise for developing comprehensive, long-term sustainable solutions, particularly in amplifying Africa’s voice in international discussions. Sir Peter Gluckman, President of the International Science Council, underscored the urgency of utilizing scientific knowledge wisely, warning of the risks if we fail to do so.

Challenges and Opportunities

Despite its importance, speakers identified several challenges facing science diplomacy. Sir Peter Gluckman noted that the era of globalization and commitment to global interdependence in science is in retreat, with new technologies challenging existing frameworks. Dr. Gihan Kamel of SESAME acknowledged that while science alone cannot solve political and economic problems, science diplomacy can play a crucial role.

The discussion highlighted the need to embed scientific expertise more deeply in diplomatic and policymaking processes. Professor Tshilidzi Marwala argued for bringing scientists into the core of political decision-making, while Dr. Emran Mian emphasized the importance of governments putting science at the heart of decision-making and funding international scientific collaboration. Dr. Mian also noted the UK’s significant investment in international science partnerships and suggested that governments sometimes need to “get out of the way” to allow natural scientific collaboration.

Diversity and Inclusion in Science Diplomacy

Several speakers stressed the importance of promoting diversity and inclusion in science diplomacy. Evelina Santa-Kahle introduced the Women in Science Diplomacy Association (WSDA), highlighting its mission to increase female representation in science and science diplomacy. Dr. Dalee Sambo Dorough emphasized the need to recognize and respect indigenous knowledge systems alongside scientific research, calling for the implementation of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples in relation to science diplomacy.

Dr. Mohammad Hosseini provided a personal perspective on the challenges faced by young scientists and researchers from countries currently excluded from global scientific discourse. He highlighted issues such as visa restrictions and limited mobility, underscoring the transformative potential of science diplomacy as a source of hope for researchers from politically isolated countries.

Building Trust and Implementing Science in Policymaking

A recurring theme was the need to build public trust in science and combat misinformation. Professor Tshilidzi Marwala emphasized the importance of science literacy as a human rights issue and called for simplifying scientific language to make it more accessible to the general public. Sandrine Dixson-Declève of the Club of Rome forcefully argued for the integration of scientific evidence into policymaking, calling for accountability from governments in respecting scientific evidence.

Case Studies and Successful Initiatives

The discussion featured several case studies demonstrating the power of science diplomacy:

1. Jose Julio Casas presented the Eastern Tropical Marine Corridor, a collaborative effort between Costa Rica, Panama, Colombia, and Ecuador to protect marine biodiversity and promote sustainable fishing practices.

2. Dr. Gihan Kamel provided insights into the SESAME particle accelerator project in the Middle East, illustrating how scientific collaboration can transcend political boundaries.

3. Dr. Tara Stoinski discussed gorilla conservation efforts in Africa, highlighting how scientific research has informed conservation strategies and fostered cooperation between countries sharing gorilla habitats.

Resolutions and Action Items

The discussion concluded with several calls to action and proposed resolutions, including:

1. Deeper investment in science, especially in inclusive ways

2. Building more local forums for collaboration between community leaders, businesses, scientists, and the public

3. Creating more public repositories of scientific research and data

4. A commitment from the United Nations University to support efforts to build trust in science and take science to the people

Professor Marwala also mentioned the UN’s International Decade of Sciences and Sustainable Development as an opportunity to further promote science diplomacy.

Unresolved Issues and Future Directions

Despite the productive discussion, several issues remained unresolved, including:

1. How to effectively integrate science into diplomatic processes and policymaking

2. Addressing restrictions on scientific collaboration due to geopolitical tensions and sanctions

3. Improving science communication and literacy among the general public

4. Balancing national interests with the need for global scientific collaboration

In conclusion, the discussion highlighted the vital role of science diplomacy in addressing global challenges and fostering international cooperation. While acknowledging significant obstacles, speakers remained optimistic about the potential for science to build bridges between nations and drive positive change. The conversation emphasized the need for more inclusive, diverse, and effective approaches to science diplomacy to navigate the complex global challenges of the 21st century.

Session Transcript

Melissa Fleming: I can feel the buzz in the room. But I could I get your attention, please? Hello, everyone. It’s great to see the energy in this room, especially around a topic that’s linked to science. So that’s I find very exciting because we do have excellencies in the room. That means diplomats. We have scientists, we have scholars, and we also have young people. And I’d like to give a special welcome to the young people who are with us today. So welcome to this Summit of the Future Action Day side event, Building Bridges Through Science Diplomacy, Accelerating Progress Towards Sustainable Development. And I’m really pleased to convene this group of member states, representatives of the scientific and academic communities and other stakeholders for this important discussion. And we’re here to showcase the vital role of science in strengthening multilateralism to respond to the urgent global challenges that our world is facing. For those of you who don’t know me, my name is Melissa Fleming, and I am the Undersecretary General for Global Communications here at the United Nations. And I’m really honored to be moderating the first part of this event. A quick procedural note before we begin. This event is paper smart, so you can access the program through the QR code provided. QR codes also to full biographies of the speakers will appear on the title slides displayed before each speaker speaks. I’d like to thank the co-organizing partners of today’s event, the International Science Council, the German Center for Research and Innovation of New York, the United Nations Academic Impact, the IMPACT Coalition, Science and Policy Solutions for the Planet, as well as the Permanent Missions of Costa Rica and South Africa to the UN. Special thanks also to our esteemed speakers whose insights and leadership will guide our discussions today. Your contributions are invaluable as we work together to strengthen the relationship between science and diplomacy and to build a more sustainable and just future for all. Dear friends, we meet in turbulent times. Science diplomacy has arguably never been more needed, and probably it’s a term that not many people know, and that we need to popularize because we need policymakers to be informed as they navigate complex and interlocking global crises and as they endeavor to make the world a more sustainable, peaceful, and equitable place. So the department that I lead, the Department of Global Communications, has had a long and fruitful collaboration with the scientific community to bring robust science to global audiences, and we’re trying to do that using cutting-edge strategic communications as well as insights from behavioral science as well. This has been the backbone of some of our key campaigns. This has included sharing life-saving public health guidance during the pandemic, boosting vaccine confidence, and making the scientific case for an urgent transition away from fossil fuels. This, I have to say, has become an increasing challenge in the digital age, in the age of social media, where lies seem to surface and travel much faster than facts. So we have a communications challenge, and I know, speaking to many scientists, that they feel that they need a lot of help in how to communicate and navigate in this information age. So our speakers will explore these and many other forms that science diplomacy takes today, from peace building to harnessing the potential for AI for all of humanity. And they will share insights on how science diplomacy can help drive sustainable development, not just for those of us alive today, but as the theme is very much at this summit of the future and these action days for future generations. And we hope that this side event is the start of a big galvanization of support for deeper science policy engagement. It is my pleasure now to welcome our first speaker, Her Excellency Ambassador Maritza Chan, Permanent Representative of Costa Rica to the UN. Costa Rica has been a champion in science diplomacy for decades. An example of this has been leading the creation of the Eastern Tropical Marine Corridor, a regional initiative led by the governments of Ecuador, Costa Rica, Colombia, and Panama. And this initiative seeks the conservation of biological diversity and sustainable use of marine resources. Ambassador Chan has been recognized by the United Nations Regional Center for Peace, Disarmament, and Development in Latin America and the Caribbean as one of the leading agents for change, advocating for arms control, disarmament, and nonproliferation in 2014 and again in 2021. Excellency, the floor is yours.

Maritza Chan: Thank you very much, Melissa. It’s so invigorating to see so many faces today. Thank you for being here. Costa Rica is thrilled to be part of the organizers. Today is a day of celebration. The summit of the future action days just kicked off, and this afternoon we have enjoyed the voice of youth in the multilateral system. And what better message could we send to the younger generation than the importance of building bridges through science? This is precisely the goal of this side event, to highlight science as a vital tool for fostering peace, collaboration, and diplomacy. Since I started my journey as a diplomat, I have believed that evidence, scientific evidence must inform diplomatic decisions. Please allow me to provide two examples where science has been essential to enhance multilateral action. In December 2020, Costa Rica and Ecuador submitted the first joint partial presentation to the UN Secretary General seeking to extend the limits of our continental shelves in the Pacific Ocean. According to Article 76 of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, countries that provide field data demonstrating scientific geomorphical conditions on the ocean floor can secure exclusive rights to explore, exploit, and conserve areas of the seabed and subsoil beyond their existing 200 nautical mile exclusive economic zones. Costa Rica and Ecuador met these conditions in the Martan region between Scocos Island in Costa Rica and the Galapagos Islands in Ecuador. This achievement marks the culmination of a decade-long negotiation process, which relied heavily on scientific experience that supported the diplomatic efforts of both countries. Geologists, volcanologists, and biologists came together with diplomats to advance one of the most inspiring science diplomacy examples in Latin America. And today we celebrate this success as a milestone in the establishment, as you mentioned Melissa, of the Eastern Tropical Pacific Marine Corridor, one of the world’s largest marine conservation areas. This case study will be explored in greater detail in this event. The second example is around space technology. The UN Office for Outer Space Affairs has demonstrated how space technology supports the achievement of the SDGs, which are essential for maintaining peace and international security. There’s no development without peace and no peace without human rights. Similarly, states have discussed in various UN forums how technologies like Earth observation satellites can improve the verification and monitoring of international peace and security treaties. This capacity fosters trust in an area that would need it the most and can provide crucial data to inform even security council deliberations. Although many outer space systems, such as those designed for debris removal or on orbit servicing, were initially created for benign purposes, then often have dual use capabilities like robotic arms that could be repurposed to harm other space objects. By leveraging the expertise of those who develop and operate these technologies, we can better address concrete threats and enhance space security. This, in turn, helps in crafting effective legal and policy measures to ensure the safety and security of space activities. As we have seen in these two examples, we can agree that scientists and diplomats, scientists need diplomats and diplomats need scientists. to build to accelerate progress towards sustainable development. And my last point relates to the intricate link between peacekeeping and evidence-based policymaking. Allow me to share a critical message as the President of the 4th UN Review Conference on Small Arms and Light Weapons that ended in June and as the current Chair of the 1st Committee that is related to disarmament and international security. One critical area where peacekeeping capabilities need significant strengthening via significant increase of evidence and information is weapons, technical, intelligence, and police contingents. Documenting the proliferation of arms, ammunitions, and explosions is essential for UN peacekeeping civilian protection mandates. However, these activities often suffer from insufficient resources and lack systemic operationalization, partly due to limited technical intelligence capacity in peacekeeping. Enhancing these capacities would improve the mission’s ability to provide actionable intelligence to national authorities for legal accountability in crimes involving illicit weapons, support counterterrorism and counterinsurgency operations, and monitor UN security arms embargoes. Hence, evidence-based policymaking ensures that our responses are founded in reality and driven by the best available data. In closing, I would like to extend my heartfelt appreciation to the organizers for the hard work and dedication in making this event possible. Your efforts have created a platform for minimal dialogue and collaboration. And let me finish calling you to ensure that developing economies and underrepresented regions are also included in this undertaking, so they will not or we will not be left behind. I wish you a very successful and action-oriented Action Days. The summit of the future is already here, and we just need to agree on the pact.

Melissa Fleming: Absolutely. Thank you. Thank you, Ambassador Marisa Chan. examples that demonstrate how scientific evidence can inform diplomatic decisions and also how they need each other, right? So excellent examples in marine conservation, space technology, and in security. Now it is my pleasure to introduce His Excellency Ambassador Omar Hilal, permanent representative of the Kingdom of Morocco to the United Nations. Ambassador Hilal has recently taken over as chair of the Coalition on Science, Technology, and Innovation, or STI, for Africa’s development. This coalition has a significant initiative for science diplomacy that we’re going to hear about, I think. So Excellency, you have the floor.

Omar Hilale: Thank you very much, dear Melissa. Your preliminary remarks inspired me some ideas. It’s that science is the field of evidence and concrete actions. Diplomacy is the art to make the impossible possible. And as Eliza just said, we need scientists as they need diplomacy. And when they gather all together, they are able to reach the best results, to help the world, to heal the wounds of our planet, and also to contribute to the implementation of SDGs. So together we can do a lot, and I’m very happy to be part of this meeting today. Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, esteemed colleagues, and honored guests, it is an honor for me to welcome you all to today’s discussion on the theme Building Bridges Through Science, Diplomacy, Accelerating Progress Towards Sustainable Development. As we navigate the complexities of our interconnected world, the intersection of science and diplomacy offers us a unique opportunity to address global challenges collaboratively. As we embark into this crucial topic, particularly in the context of the Summit of the Future and the Pact of the Future, the discussion around the role of science, diplomacy, and in advancing sustainable development becomes increasingly vital. Science, diplomacy allows us to bridge gaps between nations, facilitating collaboration and knowledge sharing that are essential for addressing global challenges. Working toward the achievement of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, it is crucial to recognize that effective science, diplomacy can enhance our collective ability to implement policies that are informed by research and evidence. Through collaborative efforts, we can ensure that the benefits of scientific advancements are shared equitably, and that all voices are heard in the decision-making process. In an era marked by pressing issues such as climate change, resource scarcity, and public health crisis, science, diplomacy offers framework for leveraging scientific expertise and innovation. By fostering partnerships across borders, we can develop comprehensive strategies that not only tackle immediate problems, but also lay the groundwork for long-term sustainable solutions. In my capacity as the incoming chair of the Coalition on Science, Technology, and Innovation for Africa, I would emphasize that Africa stands at a pivotal moment, rich in potential and brimming with talents, yet we also face significant challenges that require innovative solutions and collaborative approaches. Science diplomacy offers us a unique pathway to address these issues by fostering partnerships that transcend borders and disciplines. Africa’s commitment to regional and international cooperation enhances its potential in science diplomacy. By aligning with global initiatives such as the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, Africa can showcase its dedication to addressing critical issues while amplifying its voice in international discussions. In this transformative era, Africa’s involvement in science diplomacy is not just an opportunity, it is a necessity. By fostering collaboration, promoting inclusivity, and championing innovative solutions, Africa can lead the way toward a more sustainable and equitable future for all. Colleagues are not just conscious of the huge potential of the science diplomacy, Morocco’s vision adopted an innovative approach to science diplomacy, emphasizing on collaboration, sustainability, and capacity building, positioning the country as a key player in addressing regional and global challenges. As such, Morocco concluded partnerships focused on research and technology to exemplify the role of science initiatives in renewable energy and water management initiatives for sustainable agriculture. Our collaborations are extended projects with institutions focused on sustainable agriculture practices. These partnerships aim to improve food security and resilience against climate change, showcasing the benefits of science diplomacy in agriculture. Together with the International Science Council, regional initiatives are launched to facilitate knowledge sharing and training for Moroccan scientists, enhancing their capacity to address local sustainability challenges. These examples, among others, illustrate how science diplomacy not only fosters international collaboration, but also directly contributes to the national sustainable development goals by leveraging scientific knowledge. knowledge and technology. I would like to reiterate my thanks for joining us today. Let us engage in this discussion with an open mind and commitment to harnessing the power of science diplomacy as a tool for sustainable development. Together we can build a resilient and prosperous future for all. I thank you very much.

Melissa Fleming: Thank you Omar, His Excellency Omar Hilale, and also for talking about how science and diplomacy can make the impossible possible in your words and that can heal wounds of our planet and bridge gaps between nations through policies informed by evidence and through that to lay the groundwork for sustainable solutions. So that was a very inspiring words. Thank you very much and it’s now my great pleasure to welcome our esteemed keynote speaker, the President of the International Science Council, Sir Peter Gluckman. Sir Gluckman is a leading expert on science diplomacy. His rich experience includes serving as the first Chief Scientific Advisor to the Prime Ministers of New Zealand and serving as Foundation Chair of the International Network of Government Science Advice. I’m delighted to give him the floor to deliver today’s keynote address.

Peter Gluckman: Thank you very much and thank you to the two co-chairs for inspiring words to start this session off. In the decades during and after the Cold War, science diplomacy was an important component of the foreign policy toolkit of major countries, a part of international efforts to respond to both global challenges and reduce global tensions. The Antarctic Treaty, IASA, the Montreal Protocol and the IPCC are all examples of the success of science diplomacy in that era. While often encapsulated within international science cooperation, science diplomacy is something more. It’s about achieving diplomatic goals, both domestic and global, through science-assisting diplomacy. However, the rationale and the conditions under which science diplomacy blossomed 20 years ago are changing and fragmenting as the linkage between science and technology, geostrategic and economic interests grow. In this paradoxical and changing context, science diplomacy also must evolve. The era of globalization and with it the commitment to global interdependence and cooperation on global science issues is in some, sadly, in retreat. It’s offered the space in which science diplomacy can operate. The drive to open science is being replaced in political declarations from many countries with the mantra as open as possible, as closed as necessary and greater restrictions on scientific interchange between the political poles are emerging. Yet the world faces common and global challenges which science and technology must address. The paradox is obvious. We need actions that could help navigate the inherent conflict. conflict between the real politic of geostrategic tensions and the globalism that many in the global science community and most of the citizens of this world want to see happen. We’re challenged by the new technologies that do not respect national boundaries, rapidly emerging advances in AI, in synthetic biology, quantum, in the use of the ocean bed, in inner and outer space, in extraterrestrial resources, are all examples which are challenging us. Adding to the complexity is that much emergent technology is driven by companies that largely avoid both national and transnational regulation and even challenge the role of nation states. As the conditions that gave value to science diplomacy change, its practice must change. And although at times science diplomacy has seemed very academic, as our two chairs have already said, it is the key linkage between the very different worlds of diplomacy and science that are essential for all our futures. In this confused and conflicted space, we must consider the potential roles of different actors. Formal diplomatic processes must be informed by science, and the international science community has a key role to now play in advancing track two efforts, which, given the context, may take on greater importance if the multilateral situation does not improve. The International Science Council is unique in its membership, including the World Scientific Academies and international science organizations from the global north, the global south, the global east, the global west, and across both the natural and social sciences, across large countries, across small island developing states. Increasingly it’s both seen the need to, and is now being requested, to take a greater role in track two diplomacy. Today we’re in an era where domestic science, economic, and national security policies can conflict with broader objectives relating to the global commons. Diplomats will need to take a much more multi-stakeholder approach, including governments, business, academia. The global community must give greater support to the international science community, allowing it to be an integral partner in these discussions, than rather simply, as is too often, a tokenistic afterthought. Real politics demands that first and foremost, science diplomacy will serve a nation’s interest. Science diplomacy can do so in domains such as security, trade, environmental management, and technology access, but it must also be recognized by every government that it’s in every nation’s interest to advance the global commons. And here, science diplomacy has a critical domestic role to ensure that every nation understands that it is in their interests, their interests are best served by acting collaboratively. Track two, science diplomacy, can be a valued partner to a somewhat stuttering multilateral system. Too few countries have embedded science diplomacy within their diplomatic toolkit. Only with science advisors and foreign ministries connected to domestic science communities can the two-way interchange between track two and track one approaches become more effective. The world has slipped sadly on its commitment to sustainable development goals, and I hope that this summit really does achieve what it must, which is to rebuke the global commitment to these goals. The science community must and will play its role in ensuring progress is in fact made. I’m famous for talking bluntly, and last year at the high-level political forum, I ended my keynote address then with the words which I’ll use again now. Unless we use science wisely and urgently, we are all at risk. Thank you very much.

Melissa Fleming: Thank you very much, Sir Peter Gluckman, on your powerful insights and also outlining the complexities of today’s world and all of the challenges and the critical role that the science community will play to advance what you call the global commons and that it’s in every nation’s interest. I really appreciate that. I’d like to now pass the floor to Ms. Maria Esteli-Jarquin. who coordinates the international relations of the U.K. Center for Ecology and Hydrology. In parallel, Ms. Jarquin is a special advisor to the International Science Council and member of their standing committee of outreach and engagement. And I am pleased that she will now moderate the remainder of today’s program. So Ms. Jarquin, the floor is yours.

María Estelí Jarquín: Thank you so much, USG Melissa Fleming. When this event was selected to take place on Action Day number one, dedicated to youth, we felt it was a natural decision. As a young person myself, I like to think of young people full of hope for the future, driven by curiosity and imagination for the unknown, elements that are also present in science, hope and curiosity, two engines that move humanity forward. Now why it is so important to discuss about science in the United Nations? We are in one of the world’s greatest epicenters of diplomacy, and diplomacy has been many times inspired by science, always in constant evolution as a collective effort, always striving to help us work towards a concert of nations. As a Latin American young person, it is my absolute honor to now serve as your moderator for the next part. For the last five years working in science diplomacy, I have been deeply inspired by the great stories that have brought science and diplomacy together to advance sustainable development. So let’s discover four case studies where science has strengthened multilateralism. For our first case study, we will travel to the Middle East to hear about the region’s first major international center of excellence. Dr. Gihan Kamel, principal scientist, will tell us the story of Sesame. All eyes on the screen, please.

Gihan Kamel: To all of you and thank you who are building bridges rather than walls. I would like to thank the organizers for the kind invitation to present Sesame as a case of science, diplomacy and the Middle East, a region that is distant to instabilities, to blood and tears, to conflicts and wars. Sesame is the first and only facility of its kind in the Middle East and neighboring regions, a particle accelerator that produces a unique type of radiation which allows researchers over a huge range of domains to investigate matter, similar to many large-scale infrastructures known as synchrotron light sources all over the world, not only providing cutting-edge technologies but also cutting-edge relationships. Modeled on CERN and established as an intergovernmental organization under the umbrella of the UNESCO, the only factor that governs Sesame is science and this is the simple one-line story about Sesame, a facility existing in the heart of the Middle East owned by eight members, Jordan where it’s hosted, Egypt, Palestine, Israel, Iran, Turkey, Cyprus and Pakistan, clear enough why Sesame is addressed as a successful model on science diplomacy. We go beyond experiments inside labs being directed towards the sustainable development goals. Our motto is not only science for peace but also for society. Together with a close follow-up of the international Science Council Collective Projection of Science Missions for Sustainability. Collaboration is not a stranger in the business of science. Totally coherent, fair and an obvious strategy to get fruitful results. But sometimes it’s not enough. Because what if what we need is more than budget? What if what we need is peace? A lesson learned from CERN was that successful bridge building through scientific collaboration can work with two conjugated and complementary pillars, excellent science and reliable diplomacy. With this in mind, Sesame was established thanks to the huge, extensive and continuous international support. Without it, Sesame wouldn’t exist. It was integrated in 2017 and in 2019, it became the world’s first large accelerator, fully powered by renewable energy. It allows for brain drain reversal. And it opens a door to women scientists in the region and beyond. A key factor in our success is that we leave all the differences outside the fence. We only take our expertise and time. We only take our expertise and knowledge. We take patience, dedication, persistence, despite the so many challenges that we face on a daily basis, above all the geopolitical and the financial instabilities. Can science save us? Can science save Sesame? Can Sesame save the Middle East? No. The only fact that we know is that science alone cannot solve the many political security and economic problems that we are facing. But we know very well that science diplomacy can. It has an important role to play in addressing health, environment, energy and food challenges that contribute to our regional instability. Thank you so much.

María Estelí Jarquín: Africa, where we will learn about conservation efforts to protect mountain gorillas via extensive research and development. Thank you. extensive scientific research, education, and community outreach. Let’s hear this story from Dr. Tara Stoinski, president of the Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund.

Tara Stoinski: Thank you so much for the opportunity to speak with you today on our work in conservation and the key role that science plays in this work. I’m Dr. Tara Stoinski, CEO and chief scientific officer of the Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund. The Fossey Fund is the world’s longest running and largest organization dedicated to the study and conservation of gorillas, and we have been on the literal front lines of gorilla conservation for almost 60 years. Our work in both Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of the Congo focuses on four key pillars, providing daily boots on the ground protection to gorillas and their critical ecosystems, conducting the science needed to develop effective conservation strategies, training the conservation and scientific leaders of today and tomorrow, and building resiliency in the human populations who share the gorilla’s habitat to improve their lives and lessen their dependence on forest resources. These activities touch on at least nine of the 17 UN sustainable development goals, including conserving life on land, climate action, gender equity, reduced inequalities, zero hunger, quality education, and no poverty. They have also played a critical role in bringing mountain gorillas back from the brink of extinction. In fact, mountain gorillas are the only great ape on the planet besides us that are increasing in number, an all too rare conservation success story. While the scientific work that we do focuses on advancing our understanding of gorillas and their forest habitats, its impact extends much beyond that. It is the building block for training the next generation of scientific and conservation leaders and creating the communities of multinational and multidisciplinary researchers that are desperately needed to solve the environmental crises facing our planet. Biodiversity loss and climate change, the two largest of these crises, do not recognize national boundaries and the science to solve them must not either. Working together ensures different perspectives and experiences are represented in the effort to find solutions at the national, regional, and international level. And we at the FOSSE fund see this in practice every day. In the last five years, we have collaborated with 400 scientists from around the world on more than 75 publications. These collaborations have expanded the impact of our science much beyond what we would be able to do alone. At our Ellen DeGeneres campus, a state-of-the-art research and education center in Rwanda that opened in 2022, we focus on bringing together early career scientists from across Africa to receive training, conduct science, and build multinational professional networks. These collaborations have produced papers at a continent-wide scale, for example, examining how climate change is affecting great ape habitat across Africa. This type of research is crucial to demonstrating the need for collective action across nations and creating solutions at scale. We need to be doing more to facilitate these types of collaborations and to ensure that the work is led by range country scientists and centered in the range countries where the studies are done. Thank you again for the opportunity to speak today. And if you would like to learn more about our work, please visit us at guerrillafund.org.

María Estelí Jarquín: Our third case study is an initiative that started in Washington and aims to make a global impact. The Women in Science Diplomacy Association. We are honored to have Ms. Evelina Santa-Kahle here with us today. Go ahead.

Evelina Santa-Kahle: Thank you very much and thank you for the opportunity to speak here today and introduce to you the Women in Science Diplomacy Association, or in short WSDA as we call it. WSDA was founded out of a necessity, actually out of the necessity for representation, claiming our voice, claiming also our place in the area of science diplomacy was the driving force behind founding WSDA. Because we thought it’s not possible that in an area that is so important for the future, namely science and science diplomacy, that this area is so heavily underrepresented by female and gender minorities. So let me also start with a small story, a very personal story. When I arrived in D.C., I just saw that we have a very little, like a very low number of female working in the diplomatic community in D.C. And I was lucky enough to meet some colleagues who felt the same. My French and Italian colleague in D.C., we joined forces and we said we need to do something against that. So we founded WSDA and developed a joint vision, a mission and a vision for WSDA to be clear in what we want to achieve and what we want to deliver. Can I have my next slide, please? So our aim is to, our mission actually is to strengthen diversity and promote female representation in science and science diplomacy, to address the gender gap and bias throughout all levels of S&T policy and policymaking areas. WSDA aims to be the global platform to spark, to connect, to mentor, support and sponsor more women science diplomats and policy makers. Our vision is really to connect women in science diplomacy globally to advance the gender gap. and ensure science and science diplomacy is for all. Next slide, please. So how do we want to achieve that? We are currently like a network of more than 60 members based in DC, and our action items are currently to promote related gender equality and diversity in science diplomacy, to speak up and get involved where it’s possible, to promote the representation of female and diverse researchers and science diplomats. And how do we do that? We organize regular meetings. We organize every year in the framework of the UN Girls and Women in Science a whole week of events to represent and to showcase the contribution of female and gender diverse minorities to science and science policy. We intend to strengthen the networking among female and diverse science diplomats. We intend to build a supportive community to share best practices, resources, and knowledge. So what we do here concretely is to really provide training for the onboarding of new science diplomats, and we really want to extend our network also to science diplomats from other countries, especially from the global south, for those also countries that do not have a science diplomat but need that expertise and advice and networking. That’s what we are here for in Washington, DC. And we also train the next generation of science diplomats. Science diplomacy is still an area that is growing that is not well known as a career opportunity. So what we do, we go to universities. We talk to students there and introduce them to that career opportunity, actually. Next slide. So how do we get there? And that’s where you all come into play. We build on partnership, on volunteerism, and community building. And that’s where I call all of you and ask you to join our network, to join forces here, and to contribute and take actions together. Thank you very much.

María Estelí Jarquín: Thank you. Thank you so much and we will now travel to the heart of the Americas. Four countries working together using scientific evidence to build one of the most important marine corridors of the planet. Let’s hear the story of the Eastern Tropical Marine Corridor in the voice of Mr. Jose Julio Casas, who kindly recorded this video to us from the Galapagos Island.

Jose Julio Casas: The Eastern Tropical Marine Corridor is a special region in the Pacific, known as SEMAR. The Eastern Tropical Marine Corridor is a special region in the Pacific, known as SEMAR. The Eastern Tropical Marine Corridor is a special region in the Pacific, known as SEMAR. The Eastern Tropical Marine Corridor is a special region in the Pacific, known as SEMAR. The Eastern Tropical Marine Corridor is a special region in the Pacific, known as SEMAR. In addition, it acts as an essential corridor for the migration of many species, allowing them to travel long distances in search of food, reproduction and refuge. However, this invaluable ecosystem faces serious threats. Illegal fishing, pollution, climate change and uncontrolled exploitation. Protecting the Sea does not only mean preserving its biodiversity, but also ensuring the livelihood of millions of people who depend on fishing and tourism in the region. This is why the Sea collaborates closely with scientists and academic institutions, non-governmental organizations and public and private donors. This strengthens cooperative governance, facilitates the design and implementation of marine protection strategies and ensures long-term sustainable financing. All this work together, between civil society, between government entities and between different partners, has ensured that the Corridor, in these 20 years, has grown, has increased and is taking big steps towards the future, generating protection at the regional level. The Sea is a natural gem that we must protect for future generations. By working together, we can ensure that these ecosystems maintain a rich marine biodiversity for the benefit of all, from the local communities that depend on them for their livelihood to the whole world that benefits from their environmental and scientific value. Working with the Academy allows the generation of new knowledge that provides information with a scientific basis for decision-making at the governmental level. Our responsibility is to act today to ensure a sustainable future where marine life flourishes and the beauty of these oceans lasts for future generations.

María Estelí Jarquín: We have just heard inspiring action-oriented stories shaped by years of resilience, hard work and vision at the intersection of science and diplomacy. Now let’s turn our focus to discussing current challenges and opportunities that lie ahead of the future. We have brought together an outstanding group of panelists to lead this discussion. I will first introduce each of them and explore their work and perspectives on science diplomacy. I will start with Ms. Sandrine Dixson-Declève who is co-president of the Club of Rome and the executive chair of Earth for All. Sandrine brings extensive experience chairing European Commission’s expert groups on research and innovation and climate change amongst others. I’ll ask our esteemed panelists if they could merge and turn into a statement their prepared questions. So Sandrine, what does science diplomacy mean to you? We are navigating a multipolar world often marked by conflicting positions and I was struck by what I read in your bio. You dedicate part of your time to facilitating difficult conversations, an invaluable skill in today’s landscape. So my question to you is, how can science diplomacy be leveraged as a tool to facilitate challenging dialogues, build bridges between nations or groups with conflicting interests and use science as a driving force for diplomacy?

Sandrine Dixson-Declève: Thank you so much, Maria. It’s such a pleasure to be here amongst all of you. Maybe let me bring in 35 years of trying to build bridges and facilitate these difficult conversations, starting off with actually working with the Global Legislators Organization for a Balanced Environment, which was one of the first organizations anchored in science diplomacy. Already 35 years ago, trying to bring members of the U.S. Congress across both sides of the political spectrum and across Europe, Japan, at that time the Soviet Union, and also other. countries to do pre-discussions around scientific evidence in the area of the environment in order to foster diplomatic negotiations. This was a time when science was actually respected, as was so prominently said by Sir Peter Gluckman. And I think it’s very important that we take into consideration that we are absolutely in a very different world. Those 35 years of experience were actually science and evidence decision making was part of the way in which we put in place our environmental policy making, as well as our social policy making. But today, I want to come with a plea, a really deep plea and a humility and reality check. The science element is weak already in our declaration and in our pact for the future. And yet here we are talking about its importance. We are in a planetary emergency, which has already been declared by the Secretary General himself. We do not have one anchored planetary emergency plan based on the scientific evidence that shows we’re in an emergency in any country across the globe. Updated science is rarely brought into negotiations. None of our COP negotiations are anchored in updated science. They are updated in past scientific evidence. Policy negotiators are rarely taken, taking scientists with them when in bilateral or multilateral negotiations. Those very important days that were referred to again by Sir Peter Gluckman no longer exist. Scientists also often, to be fair, do not have the time to join necessary meetings or delegations as they are time bound and funding bound to deliver their own scientific results. This is the reality check. So what can we do about it? First of all, we need to bring evidence and. back into the fold of all policymaking and we all as a community need to call for it. We need to hold our governments accountable for not actually respecting the scientific evidence that we have before us. I’ve been called in so many ways an activist and yet I have worked for the oil and gas companies, I have worked for policymakers, I’ve worked for presidents and kings and yet now I’m an activist. I’m an activist because I’m a realist, because I understand that for the last 35 years we were able to use science and evidence in making very important decision-making and yet today we are no longer doing so. Now the problem is exactly as the undersecretary indicated, the fact that we have social media, that we have different narratives and story building which are taking a precedence over scientific decision-making. So together we need to actually be much more forceful in our call and our drive for science but we have to also build the capacity for scientific decision-making to happen in multilateral negotiations and also bilateral negotiations and lastly we need to ensure that our educational system, our universities are actually fostering better science diplomacy and undertaking that looks at the complexity of the world that we have before us. So I will end with that in the hope that actually we will all mutually work together to ensure that science is anchored back in to the way in which we solve our planetary emergency, in the way in which we have done in our work at the Club of Rome and through Earth for All by looking at system dynamic modeling, social and environmental tipping points and solutions for both. Thank you.

María Estelí Jarquín: Thank you for your statement, and I will now turn to Dr. Dalee Sambo Dorough, who has been instrumental in advancing the UN declarations on the right of indigenous peoples, reflecting her commitment to justice and indigenous empowerment. She currently holds the Arctic region seat on the UN expert mechanism on the right of indigenous peoples and is currently a senior scholar and a special advisor on Arctic indigenous peoples at the University of Alaska Anchorage. Dali, we saw key lessons from the Science Policy Society interfacing the case studies, and I would like to ask your thoughts on how science diplomacy can close the action knowledge gaps. In your experience, how can science diplomacy be used to bridge the gap between indigenous and non-indigenous knowledge systems, and how important is mutual recognition in this context? Thank you very much.

Dalee Sambo Dorough: First of all, allow me to say that my people span a long, linear region of the world, from the Russian Far East throughout Alaska, Canada, and Greenland. In relation to the questions that were set to me in terms of what has shaped my contributions, I want to harken back to June of 1977, the late Eben Hopson, who’s recognized as the founder of the Inuit Circumpolar Council, an indigenous peoples organization. He stated, our language contains the memory of 4,000 years of human survival through the conservation and good managing of our Arctic wealth. Our language contains the intricate knowledge of the ice that we have seen no others demonstrate. Without our central involvement, there can be no safe and responsible Arctic resource development. For decades, Inuit have dealt with multifaceted, interconnected problems that transcend national boundaries. Our contributions feature our own diplomacy. Inuit were the first to prepare a comprehensive Arctic policy. The preamble affirms that we are committed to contributing our knowledge for the betterment of humanity, the common security of all peoples and states, and world peace. The document addresses environmental issues, renewable resource management, scientific research within our communities, and decision making, among many other issues. We have highlighted that Inuit are an integral part of Arctic ecosystems. For centuries, our hunting, fishing, and harvesting activities have been and continue to be in harmony with and an important part of the dynamic processes of Arctic ecosystems. Therefore, the profound relationship between Inuit and other living species of the natural world must be fully recognized in any strategies pertaining to our Arctic homelands. We have also affirmed that indigenous knowledge and scientific research are both valid systems of knowledge that should be recognized within the context of cooperative research. In this way, scientists and, importantly, decision makers will have the best available information on which to base their actions. We believe that through the recognition of and respect for indigenous knowledge, we can make further extraordinary contributions to science diplomacy. In relation to bridging the gap between indigenous and non-indigenous knowledge systems, mutual respect and mutual recognition are paramount. Presently, the major gap is lack of implementation of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. The UN Declaration Preamble, adopted by the General Assembly and a whole not far from here, affirms that recognizing that respect for Indigenous knowledge, cultures, and traditional practices contributes to sustainable and equitable development and proper management of the environment. The Declaration explicitly recognizes the right of Indigenous peoples to self-determination, the prerequisite for the exercise and enjoyment of all other human rights. The UN Declaration also affirms our right to maintain, control, protect, and develop Indigenous knowledge. Though there is a corresponding obligation of UN member states to implement this right, there appears to be little political will to do so. To generate understanding, Inuit, myself, we’ve developed our own definition of Indigenous knowledge. We have also used Inuit diplomacy within the Arctic Council, the UNFCCC, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and many other venues of diplomacy and politics. We seek to advance ethical and equitable co-production of knowledge, which requires creative and culturally appropriate methodologies that use both Indigenous knowledge and science applied across all processes of knowledge creation. In our view, the substantive and procedural elements of this right must be recognized and respected. Equity, trust, being deliberate and intentional, building relationships, reciprocity, communication, and many other elements are necessary to ensure that one knowledge system is not privileged over another. Both must be valued and recognized as equally important. I believe that if our objectives are heeded, and the objectives of Indigenous peoples across the globe, if they are heeded, scientists, diplomats, and policymakers will actually gain the best available knowledge on which to inform their decisions. A byproduct, they will also contribute to the implementation of our fundamental human rights as distinct peoples, as Indigenous peoples. And to the moderator and also to the co-organizers of this important event, I hope the message lands somewhere.

María Estelí Jarquín: Thank you, Dalee. And finally, I would like to introduce you to Dr. Mohammad Hosseini, who is an assistant professor of ethics in the Department of Preventive Medicine at Northwestern University, where he collaborates with various institutes around research projects related to technology ethics and AI. He currently leads the Trust in Science workgroup at the Global Young Academy. And Mohamed, as a young researcher based in the U.S. and a member of the Uganian scientific diaspora, I’d like to hear your insights on the lessons you have learned throughout your scientific career, especially through your involvement in global networks such as the Young Academy. So my question to you is, what challenges do young scientists face when engaging in science diplomacy? And how can this challenge be addressed by multilateral institutions and governments?

Mohammad Hosseini: Well, thank you so much. As a young researcher who was born in Iran and is now in the U.S., I can tell you that science diplomacy means one thing to me and people like me, and that is hope. Hope that we can be better than our politicians, and we can do better, and we can inspire them. And it is my hope that I can work together with researchers around the globe, and it is also my hope and ambition that I can help improve our DEI policies to also include researchers who are based in countries that are currently excluded from the global scene. Think of people who are based in places like Cuba, DRC, Palestine, North Korea, Russia. There’s many examples. Do you think these countries don’t have researchers? Boy, I’ve got news for you. They do. They have researchers, but we are unable to connect with them. And you might be thinking, well, look at this young person, so full of hopes and dreams. I can tell you, in research, we dream all the time. When we start thinking about a project, when you conceptualize, we first dream about it. We conceptualize. We dream. And I’m here to also encourage you all to dream. You might be thinking, well, doing science with North Korea, how about dual use? How about national interests? Well, I get that, and I agree with you. But I think we can start with areas that do not threaten our national security. We can start with water and crop management. We can start with humanity, social science. We can think about those areas to collaborate with them, to get them out of the silos where they are put into because of their politicians and because of our politicians. One challenge we face is mobility. As a member of the Global Young Academy, I can tell you, this year, we had our AGM a little bit further in DC. Believe it or not, 15% of people who registered could not join the meeting because of visa issues, including our co-chair. We have other challenges that might be hailed by politicians as a victory, international and unilateral sanctions. In my case, it kind of makes me sad to say this, but the sanctions have made it impossible to work with anyone in Iran. And I’m not talking about working on a nuclear physics project, no. I’m talking about a project about, and I’m not joking, ethics in library sciences. You know why? Because the sanctions have not excluded scientific collaborations and communications. And consider any kind of collaboration above undergraduate level as an instance of import or export of services, and therefore subject to sanctions. I think this is ludicrous. And I think as a community of researchers who dream all the time, we can dream of a better world. And on that, I hope that I can encourage all of you to be dreamers, to be like researchers who can dream big, and connect the world through building bridges. Thank you.

María Estelí Jarquín: Thank you, Mohammad. And before we move on to the closing remarks, I want to acknowledge our great panelists for collaborating with such precise statements, and also to the incredible team that worked tirelessly for months to bring us all together today. Now it is my privilege to hand over to Professor Tshilidzi Marwala, Rector of the United Nations University, and Dr. Emran Mian, Director General, Digital Technologies and Telecoms of the UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology, for their closing remarks. Rector, you have the floor.

Tshilidzi Marwala: Thank you, thank you very much, distinguished colleagues. And thanks to the International Science Council for hosting this event on one of the most important questions facing us today. How science can help us meet global priorities like sustainable development, climate change, and the AI revolution. We have had examples of countries coming together around science, like Costa Rica and Ecuador, around marine areas, and groups of countries agreeing on Earth observation satellites. And I think the message is clear. Science can help to build trust amongst countries, helping to form the basis for greater collaboration. And this obviously has a direct bearing on the reduction of confrontation. We also had a strong message from the Moroccan PR. We need a deeper investment in science. And this has to be inclusive. Because many of the problems that we actually face are actually common. We are not going to deal with issues of climate change unless we allow data to flow. We are not going to deal with issues. of climate change if we do not allow scientists to move from one place to another. If we restrict scientists from actually sharing data, of sharing models, and actually of coming together. We also heard from Peter, that the science community needs to be an integral partner to diplomatic processes. The scientists are too excluded from the political power metrics. I think we need to bring them to the core. The biggest force for whether it is social, political, and economic transformation is actually science. Why do we not hear the voices of scientists in our politics? And of course, this obviously makes our movement forward actually restricted. We had case studies from places like the Middle East and the Democratic Republic of Congo in my own continent on how science and policy makers can partner to address complex problems like resource sharing, like environmental protection, like the advancement of SDGs. These examples show that science can form the foundation for stronger and more effective policy making. Policy needs to be adaptive. One of the most important dinners that I had in Tokyo was with Sir Peter, where he was talking about the concept of adaptive policy making. When we talk about adaptive policy making, we are talking about policy making in a very simple way. When we talk about adaptive policy making, we are talking about policy making in a very we think of the old work of Darwin. The idea of adapting whatever we do, especially if we are operating in an environment that is changing much, much more rapidly than we can actually be able to respond is absolutely essential. So we need new tools of analysis. We need to talk more with leaders of higher education institutions because these are the people who are responsible for creating an atmosphere for the next generation of thinkers. Today, earlier on, we were talking about even going to the school levels so that we can be able to respond, we can build systems that are robust and so on and so forth. I think for us to make progress, we really need to bring more trust in science. And I think on the question of how to build trust in science because around the world we see science being under attack. Why is science under attack? I think it’s because science now is entangled with vested interests. The funding, the private funding of science has been good but the problem is that the private players actually have another motive. Some of it is profit maximization. And because of that, this has undermined science. And the real contributions, real discussions around how to deal with issues of climate change are actually being undermined because the founders of science, especially the private sectors, are some of the biggest culprits. And of course, this we need to change. Of course, the issue of policy makers policy makers using scientific science to make decisions is very important. For me, the value chain of using science to make policy is the issue of data. How do we use data? How do we use logic with all its imperfection? Because it is not perfect in order to deal with issues of science. Earlier on, we heard about the role of uncertainty because science is fundamentally uncertain. There is no theory that is around that is certain. It’s as certain as the best information we have and it can change in time. And of course, because that whole concept of uncertainty is embedded in science, whether it is a vaccine that is 80% effective, which is good, but it can be 20% wrong because that is what 80% certainty actually means. It actually means we need to go back to the people so that they understand science, they understand uncertainty, and they understand that because of this concept of high certainty, it means, yes, there will be cases where things are not going to work, but the greatest amount of people are going to be helped. Our scientific advisory board offered several ideas and proposals after our retreat last week. We can build more local forums where community leaders, businesses, scientists, and public could come together and work together. We can build more public repositories of. scientific research and data where the latest developments and data can actually be deposited for everybody to have access to it. We have to simplify science. We have to simplify science because science literacy is now a human rights issue. And if it is a human rights issue, we need to migrate from using bombastic language that confuse people so that we can actually broaden access to science. We can invest in programs to combat misinformation and disinformation. And we can establish international forums such as this. But this international forum should not actually just be restricted to this room. As a UN official, I think the issue of taking the values of the United Nations to the people is very important. It means that person who is sitting in a village where I come from, who does not have the luxury of reading the latest articles from Science Magazine and Nature, must also be brought into the discussion, which means we need to go out there and simplify the concepts and go out there and educate. This year, the UN launched an international decade of sciences and sustainable development. This is an important initiative that highlights how science can deliver for people around the world. But it can only do that if we build trust in science and scientific organizations. And I think I need to say this because we have many scientific organizations, but they are fragmented. Sometimes we hear people saying, we don’t trust this because it comes from country X and country Y. And this, obviously, is dangerous for all of us. I’m, however, delighted that the International Science Council is playing its rightful role. which is central. In this, and I am committing the United Nations University to support all efforts to build trust in science and to take science to the people. Thank you very much.

Emran Mian: I thank you. I’m following remarks made by a set of very distinguished scientists and I should begin by admitting that I’m merely a bureaucrat and so these are bureaucrats reflections on some of the things that we’ve just been hearing about. The first thing I wanted to emphasize is just the importance of countries such as the UK contributing, playing their part in funding collaboration between countries on science. And this is something that we invest in across the world, over 300 million pounds that we’re currently investing in international science partnerships. We’ve recently come back into the horizon framework that enables collaboration between a large number of principally European but not exclusively European countries. And I think the role that the UK plays by that match by lots of other countries I think in fostering those international networks is a really important one. And I think a one that sort of is really important for governments to continue to do. The second thing that I think is really important thing for governments to do is to put science at the heart of decision-making. And I think Sandra Eden’s challenge on this is a really important one. The way we manage this in the UK system is in every government department, every single government department, we have a chief scientific advisor who sits as part of the leadership team of that department. And then we have a government chief scientific advisor who’s part of the top table in government. Obviously that’s not the only model by which you can achieve this, but the principle of bringing scientists and really scientists themselves and not people speaking on behalf of scientists into the heart of decision-making I think is something that has real importance. And then the third thing I just mentioned, and again this is me being self-conscious about being a bureaucrat, is sometimes the bureaucrats need to get out of the way and enable science collaboration, science diplomacy to happen. I was really thinking about this a few weeks ago. I was in a room with a set of physicists and talking about something that one of my teams is working on to foster international partnerships on compute. As people here will know, lots of countries are investing lots… and lots of money in building these massive clusters of compute to enable AI development. And in the same way as countries have collaborated on other elements of science infrastructure such as particle accelerators and telescopes, this is an element of scientific infrastructure that countries can be collaborating on. And this is beginning to happen. And we’re doing a lot of work to try and sort of play our part in making this happen. And I was talking about this with a research group of physicists and then one of them sort of held out his telephone and said, this is how we do international computer partnerships. And he showed me a group that they have, which is a global group of particle physicists, who simply message each other and ask, where do you have some compute capacity? I’ve got some code that I need to run. And then somebody will say, I’ve got some compute capacity next week, send me your code. And I think there’s the important point here is that I think scientific collaboration simply wants to happen. Scientific knowledge simply wants to happen across national boundaries. It’s not bounded nationally. Governments can help to make this happen, but also sometimes governments just need to get out of the way and let scientists do it.

María Estelí Jarquín: Thank you so much for your closing remarks. And this finishes our side event. Thank you so much for joining us today. Please connect to our experts and feel out the evaluation form of this event, which can be accessed on the QR code on the screen. Thank you.

A

Ambassador Maritza Chan

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Science diplomacy can bridge gaps between nations and facilitate collaboration

Explanation

Ambassador Chan emphasizes that science diplomacy is a tool for fostering peace, collaboration, and diplomacy between nations. She argues that scientific evidence should inform diplomatic decisions.

Evidence

Examples of marine conservation collaboration between Costa Rica and Ecuador, and the use of space technology for monitoring international peace and security treaties.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of science diplomacy for global challenges

Agreed with

Melissa Fleming

Ambassador Omar Hilale

Sir Peter Gluckman

Agreed on

Importance of science diplomacy for global challenges

M

Melissa Fleming

Speech speed

121 words per minute

Speech length

1123 words

Speech time

554 seconds

Science diplomacy is needed to navigate complex global crises and make the world more sustainable and equitable

Explanation

Fleming highlights the critical need for science diplomacy in addressing interlocking global crises. She argues that policymakers need to be informed by science to create a more sustainable and equitable world.

Evidence

Mentions the Department of Global Communications’ collaboration with the scientific community on campaigns related to public health, vaccine confidence, and climate change.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of science diplomacy for global challenges

Agreed with

Ambassador Maritza Chan

Ambassador Omar Hilale

Sir Peter Gluckman

Agreed on

Importance of science diplomacy for global challenges

A

Ambassador Omar Hilale

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Science diplomacy allows for leveraging scientific expertise to develop comprehensive strategies for long-term sustainable solutions

Explanation

Ambassador Hilale emphasizes that science diplomacy offers a framework for using scientific expertise and innovation to address global challenges. He argues that it can help develop strategies for both immediate problems and long-term sustainable solutions.

Evidence

Mentions Morocco’s partnerships in renewable energy, water management, and sustainable agriculture initiatives.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of science diplomacy for global challenges

Agreed with

Ambassador Maritza Chan

Melissa Fleming

Sir Peter Gluckman

Agreed on

Importance of science diplomacy for global challenges

Science diplomacy can help address critical issues while amplifying Africa’s voice in international discussions

Explanation

Ambassador Hilale highlights the potential of science diplomacy to address Africa’s challenges while increasing its influence in global discussions. He argues that Africa’s involvement in science diplomacy is necessary for a sustainable and equitable future.

Evidence

Mentions the Coalition on Science, Technology, and Innovation for Africa’s development.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of science diplomacy for global challenges

Agreed with

Ambassador Maritza Chan

Melissa Fleming

Sir Peter Gluckman

Agreed on

Importance of science diplomacy for global challenges

S

Sir Peter Gluckman

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

The era of globalization and commitment to global interdependence in science is in retreat

Explanation

Sir Peter Gluckman observes that the conditions that previously supported science diplomacy are changing. He argues that the commitment to global interdependence and cooperation on global science issues is diminishing.

Evidence

Mentions the shift from open science to a more restricted approach in many countries.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and opportunities in science diplomacy

New technologies that don’t respect national boundaries are challenging existing frameworks

Explanation

Gluckman points out that emerging technologies are creating challenges for existing diplomatic and regulatory frameworks. He argues that these technologies operate beyond national boundaries, complicating traditional approaches to governance.

Evidence

Mentions AI, synthetic biology, quantum technology, and use of ocean beds as examples of challenging new technologies.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and opportunities in science diplomacy

There is a need to embed science diplomacy within countries’ diplomatic toolkits

Explanation

Gluckman emphasizes the importance of integrating science diplomacy into national diplomatic strategies. He argues that few countries have fully incorporated science diplomacy into their foreign policy approaches.

Evidence

Suggests the need for science advisors in foreign ministries connected to domestic science communities.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and opportunities in science diplomacy

Agreed with

Professor Tshilidzi Marwala

Dr. Emran Mian

Agreed on

Need for greater integration of science in policymaking

D

Dr. Gihan Kamel

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Science alone cannot solve political and economic problems, but science diplomacy can play an important role

Explanation

Dr. Kamel acknowledges that science by itself cannot resolve all political and economic issues. However, she argues that science diplomacy can significantly contribute to addressing regional challenges and instabilities.

Evidence

Mentions the role of science diplomacy in addressing health, environment, energy, and food challenges that contribute to regional instability.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and opportunities in science diplomacy

E

Evelina Santa-Kahle

Speech speed

143 words per minute

Speech length

603 words

Speech time

251 seconds

There is a need to promote female representation in science and science diplomacy

Explanation

Santa-Kahle emphasizes the importance of increasing female representation in science and science diplomacy. She argues that this area is heavily underrepresented by women and gender minorities, necessitating action to address the gender gap.

Evidence

Mentions the founding of the Women in Science Diplomacy Association (WSDA) to address this issue.

Major Discussion Point

The role of diversity and inclusion in science diplomacy

D

Dr. Dalee Sambo Dorough

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Indigenous knowledge systems should be recognized and respected alongside scientific research

Explanation

Dr. Dorough argues for the recognition and respect of indigenous knowledge systems in scientific research and diplomacy. She emphasizes the importance of mutual recognition and equity between indigenous and non-indigenous knowledge systems.

Evidence

Mentions the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and Inuit contributions to Arctic policy and research.

Major Discussion Point

The role of diversity and inclusion in science diplomacy

D

Dr. Mohammad Hosseini

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Young scientists face challenges in mobility and international collaboration due to visa issues and sanctions

Explanation

Dr. Hosseini highlights the difficulties young scientists encounter in participating in international collaborations. He argues that visa issues and international sanctions create barriers to scientific exchange and cooperation.

Evidence

Mentions that 15% of registered participants couldn’t attend a recent Global Young Academy meeting due to visa issues, and discusses how sanctions prevent collaboration even on non-sensitive topics.

Major Discussion Point

The role of diversity and inclusion in science diplomacy

P

Professor Tshilidzi Marwala

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

There is a need to bring more trust in science and combat misinformation

Explanation

Professor Marwala emphasizes the importance of building trust in science and scientific organizations. He argues that combating misinformation is crucial for effective science diplomacy and policy-making.

Evidence

Suggests creating public repositories of scientific research and data, and investing in programs to combat misinformation.

Major Discussion Point

Building trust and implementing science in policymaking

Scientists should be brought into the core of political decision-making processes

Explanation

Marwala argues for greater inclusion of scientists in political decision-making. He emphasizes that science is a major force for social, political, and economic transformation and should be central to policy discussions.

Major Discussion Point

Building trust and implementing science in policymaking

Agreed with

Sir Peter Gluckman

Dr. Emran Mian

Agreed on

Need for greater integration of science in policymaking

Disagreed with

Dr. Emran Mian

Disagreed on

Role of governments in facilitating scientific collaboration

D

Dr. Emran Mian

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Governments need to put science at the heart of decision-making and fund international scientific collaboration

Explanation

Dr. Mian emphasizes the importance of governments prioritizing science in decision-making processes. He argues for increased funding for international scientific partnerships to foster collaboration between countries.

Evidence

Mentions the UK’s investment of over 300 million pounds in international science partnerships and the presence of chief scientific advisors in every UK government department.

Major Discussion Point

Building trust and implementing science in policymaking

Agreed with

Sir Peter Gluckman

Professor Tshilidzi Marwala

Agreed on

Need for greater integration of science in policymaking

Sometimes bureaucrats need to get out of the way and let scientists collaborate naturally

Explanation

Dr. Mian suggests that while governments can facilitate scientific collaboration, they should also allow scientists to cooperate freely. He argues that scientific knowledge naturally transcends national boundaries and sometimes bureaucracy can hinder this process.

Evidence

Provides an example of particle physicists using informal messaging groups to share compute capacity internationally.

Major Discussion Point

Building trust and implementing science in policymaking

Disagreed with

Professor Tshilidzi Marwala

Disagreed on

Role of governments in facilitating scientific collaboration

Agreements

Agreement Points

Importance of science diplomacy for global challenges

Speakers

Ambassador Maritza Chan

Melissa Fleming

Ambassador Omar Hilale

Sir Peter Gluckman

Arguments

Science diplomacy can bridge gaps between nations and facilitate collaboration

Science diplomacy is needed to navigate complex global crises and make the world more sustainable and equitable

Science diplomacy allows for leveraging scientific expertise to develop comprehensive strategies for long-term sustainable solutions

Science diplomacy can help address critical issues while amplifying Africa’s voice in international discussions

Summary

Multiple speakers emphasized the crucial role of science diplomacy in addressing global challenges, fostering collaboration between nations, and developing sustainable solutions.

Need for greater integration of science in policymaking

Speakers

Sir Peter Gluckman

Professor Tshilidzi Marwala

Dr. Emran Mian

Arguments

There is a need to embed science diplomacy within countries’ diplomatic toolkits

Scientists should be brought into the core of political decision-making processes

Governments need to put science at the heart of decision-making and fund international scientific collaboration

Summary

Several speakers argued for the increased integration of scientific expertise in policymaking processes and diplomatic strategies.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers highlighted the importance of inclusivity and diversity in science diplomacy, emphasizing the need to recognize and include underrepresented groups and knowledge systems.

Speakers

Dr. Dalee Sambo Dorough

Dr. Mohammad Hosseini

Arguments

Indigenous knowledge systems should be recognized and respected alongside scientific research

Young scientists face challenges in mobility and international collaboration due to visa issues and sanctions

Unexpected Consensus

Balancing government involvement and scientific freedom

Speakers

Dr. Emran Mian

Dr. Gihan Kamel

Arguments

Sometimes bureaucrats need to get out of the way and let scientists collaborate naturally

Science alone cannot solve political and economic problems, but science diplomacy can play an important role

Explanation

Both speakers, despite their different backgrounds, acknowledged the limitations of both science and bureaucracy alone, suggesting a balanced approach where governments facilitate but don’t overly restrict scientific collaboration.

Overall Assessment

Summary

There was broad agreement on the importance of science diplomacy for addressing global challenges, the need for greater integration of science in policymaking, and the importance of inclusivity and diversity in scientific collaboration.

Consensus level

High level of consensus on core principles, with some variation in specific implementation strategies. This suggests a strong foundation for advancing science diplomacy initiatives, but potential challenges in agreeing on precise mechanisms for implementation.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Role of governments in facilitating scientific collaboration

Speakers

Professor Tshilidzi Marwala

Dr. Emran Mian

Arguments

Scientists should be brought into the core of political decision-making processes

Sometimes bureaucrats need to get out of the way and let scientists collaborate naturally

Summary

While Professor Marwala argues for greater inclusion of scientists in political decision-making, Dr. Mian suggests that sometimes governments should allow scientists to cooperate freely without bureaucratic interference.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around the role of governments in facilitating scientific collaboration and the specific challenges facing international scientific cooperation.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among the speakers is relatively low. Most speakers agree on the importance of science diplomacy and the need for greater international collaboration. The disagreements are mainly about the specific approaches to achieve these goals, which suggests a generally unified vision for the future of science diplomacy with some differences in implementation strategies.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

Both speakers agree on the challenges facing international scientific collaboration, but they focus on different aspects. Sir Peter Gluckman emphasizes the broader retreat from globalization, while Dr. Hosseini highlights specific barriers like visa issues and sanctions.

Speakers

Sir Peter Gluckman

Dr. Mohammad Hosseini

Arguments

The era of globalization and commitment to global interdependence in science is in retreat

Young scientists face challenges in mobility and international collaboration due to visa issues and sanctions

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers highlighted the importance of inclusivity and diversity in science diplomacy, emphasizing the need to recognize and include underrepresented groups and knowledge systems.

Speakers

Dr. Dalee Sambo Dorough

Dr. Mohammad Hosseini

Arguments

Indigenous knowledge systems should be recognized and respected alongside scientific research

Young scientists face challenges in mobility and international collaboration due to visa issues and sanctions

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

Science diplomacy is crucial for addressing global challenges and fostering international collaboration

There are significant challenges to science diplomacy, including geopolitical tensions and lack of trust in science

Diversity and inclusion in science diplomacy need to be improved, including representation of women, indigenous knowledge, and young scientists

Governments need to prioritize science in policymaking and fund international scientific collaboration

Building trust in science and combating misinformation are essential for effective science diplomacy

Resolutions and Action Items

Calls for deeper investment in science, especially in inclusive ways

Suggestion to build more local forums where community leaders, businesses, scientists and public can work together

Proposal to create more public repositories of scientific research and data

Commitment from the United Nations University to support efforts to build trust in science and take science to the people

Unresolved Issues

How to effectively integrate science into diplomatic processes and policymaking

How to address restrictions on scientific collaboration due to geopolitical tensions and sanctions

How to improve science communication and literacy among the general public

How to balance national interests with the need for global scientific collaboration

Suggested Compromises

Starting scientific collaboration in non-sensitive areas like water and crop management with countries currently excluded from global scientific community

Simplifying scientific language to make it more accessible to the general public

Allowing scientists more direct involvement in political decision-making processes

Balancing government support for international scientific collaboration with allowing scientists to collaborate naturally without bureaucratic interference

Thought Provoking Comments

Science is the field of evidence and concrete actions. Diplomacy is the art to make the impossible possible. And as Eliza just said, we need scientists as they need diplomacy. And when they gather all together, they are able to reach the best results, to help the world, to heal the wounds of our planet, and also to contribute to the implementation of SDGs.

Speaker

Omar Hilale

Reason

This comment succinctly captures the complementary nature of science and diplomacy, framing their combination as a powerful force for positive change.

Impact

It set the tone for the discussion by emphasizing the importance of integrating science and diplomacy to address global challenges.

Unless we use science wisely and urgently, we are all at risk.

Speaker

Peter Gluckman

Reason

This stark warning underscores the critical importance of leveraging scientific knowledge to address global threats.

Impact

It added a sense of urgency to the discussion and highlighted the high stakes involved in effectively utilizing science for diplomacy and policymaking.

Can science save us? Can science save Sesame? Can Sesame save the Middle East? No. The only fact that we know is that science alone cannot solve the many political security and economic problems that we are facing. But we know very well that science diplomacy can.

Speaker

Gihan Kamel

Reason

This comment realistically assesses the limitations of science while emphasizing the potential of science diplomacy to address complex regional issues.

Impact

It shifted the discussion towards a more nuanced understanding of how science and diplomacy must work together to solve multifaceted problems.

We need to bring evidence and back into the fold of all policymaking and we all as a community need to call for it. We need to hold our governments accountable for not actually respecting the scientific evidence that we have before us.

Speaker

Sandrine Dixson-Declève

Reason

This comment forcefully argues for the integration of scientific evidence into policymaking and calls for accountability from governments.

Impact

It challenged participants to consider how to more effectively advocate for science-based policymaking and hold decision-makers accountable.

As a young researcher who was born in Iran and is now in the U.S., I can tell you that science diplomacy means one thing to me and people like me, and that is hope. Hope that we can be better than our politicians, and we can do better, and we can inspire them.

Speaker

Mohammad Hosseini

Reason

This personal perspective highlights the transformative potential of science diplomacy, especially for researchers from politically isolated countries.

Impact

It brought attention to the human dimension of science diplomacy and its potential to bridge political divides, shifting the conversation to consider more inclusive approaches.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by emphasizing the urgent need for integrating science and diplomacy to address global challenges, highlighting both the potential and limitations of science diplomacy, and calling for more inclusive and accountable approaches. The speakers brought diverse perspectives from different regions and career stages, enriching the conversation with real-world examples and personal insights. The discussion evolved from defining the relationship between science and diplomacy to exploring concrete ways to leverage this relationship for sustainable development and peace-building, while also addressing challenges such as political barriers and the need for greater inclusivity in scientific collaboration.

Follow-up Questions

How can we strengthen the role of science in diplomatic processes and policy-making?

Speaker

Sir Peter Gluckman

Explanation

Sir Peter emphasized that the science community must play a more integral role in diplomatic processes, as science is often excluded from political decision-making. Strengthening this connection is crucial for addressing global challenges effectively.

How can we rebuild trust in science and combat misinformation in the digital age?

Speaker

Melissa Fleming

Explanation

Melissa Fleming highlighted the challenge of communicating scientific facts in the age of social media, where misinformation spreads rapidly. Exploring ways to rebuild trust in science and effectively communicate facts is crucial for informed decision-making.

How can we ensure that developing economies and underrepresented regions are included in science diplomacy initiatives?

Speaker

Maritza Chan

Explanation

Ambassador Chan emphasized the importance of including developing economies and underrepresented regions in science diplomacy efforts to ensure no one is left behind in addressing global challenges.

How can we improve the integration of indigenous knowledge systems with scientific research?

Speaker

Dalee Sambo Dorough

Explanation

Dr. Dorough highlighted the need for better recognition and integration of indigenous knowledge systems in scientific research and policy-making, emphasizing the importance of mutual respect and recognition.

How can we address the challenges young scientists face in engaging in science diplomacy, particularly those from countries excluded from the global scientific community?

Speaker

Mohammad Hosseini

Explanation

Dr. Hosseini raised concerns about the barriers young scientists face, especially those from countries excluded from global scientific collaboration due to political reasons. Addressing these challenges is crucial for fostering truly global scientific cooperation.

How can we simplify scientific communication to make it more accessible to the general public?

Speaker

Tshilidzi Marwala

Explanation

Rector Marwala emphasized the need to simplify scientific language and concepts to make them more accessible to the general public, viewing science literacy as a human rights issue.

How can we develop more effective models for integrating scientific advice into government decision-making processes?

Speaker

Emran Mian

Explanation

Mr. Mian discussed the UK model of having chief scientific advisors in every government department and suggested exploring various models to effectively integrate scientific advice into government decision-making.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

Ericsson join MSSA to enhance global mobile coverage

Ericsson has recently joined the Mobile Satellite Services Association (MSSA), marking a significant step in advancing Non-Terrestrial Networks (NTNs) and expanding global connectivity. The following collaboration underscores Ericsson’s commitment to developing Direct-to-Device (D2D) and Internet of Things (IoT) services through space-based networks, integrating satellite networks with terrestrial cellular systems to address coverage gaps.

Recognising the transformative potential of 5G NTN, Ericsson aims to extend mobile coverage to underserved areas, leveraging L- and S-band spectrum well-suited for mobile satellite services. By employing 3GPP standards, this integration will enable conventional 5G devices to maintain connectivity even in regions lacking terrestrial network coverage, thus contributing to a scalable, sustainable, and affordable global connectivity ecosystem.

Ericsson’s involvement with the Mobile Satellite Services Association (MSSA) highlights its commitment to improving mobile network coverage and reliability. Freddie Södergren of Ericsson’s Business Area Networks emphasises the potential of integrating Non-Terrestrial Networks with land-based networks to enhance global connectivity. Mark Dankberg, MSSA Board Chairman, views Ericsson’s membership as a key boost to developing standards and best practices for Direct-to-Device (D2D) services, aiming for a seamless and affordable user experience through integrated networks.

YouthLead: Inclusive digital future for all

YouthLead: Inclusive digital future for all

Session at a Glance

Summary

This discussion focused on creating an inclusive digital future, addressing the digital divide, and empowering youth through technology. Speakers emphasized the importance of bridging digital gaps, particularly for marginalized communities and developing countries. They highlighted the need for universal internet access, digital literacy, and affordable devices to ensure equal opportunities in the digital age.

The conversation touched on the potential of AI and emerging technologies to drive innovation and sustainable development, while also acknowledging associated risks such as bias and privacy concerns. Speakers stressed the importance of responsible AI development that reflects diverse cultures and languages.

Government representatives shared initiatives to engage youth in digital policymaking and foster innovation. The importance of intergenerational cooperation and mentorship was emphasized to nurture young leaders in the tech sector. Speakers also discussed the role of space technology in expanding connectivity and the need for policies that support innovative solutions.

The discussion highlighted the critical role of education in closing the digital divide, with examples of peer learning platforms and initiatives to improve digital skills. Intellectual property rights were addressed as a means to empower youth innovation and entrepreneurship.

Throughout the session, there was a strong emphasis on youth leadership and inclusion in shaping digital policies and technologies. Speakers called for greater representation of young voices in decision-making processes and the development of digital solutions that address local needs. The discussion concluded with a reminder of the challenges faced by youth in conflict zones and a call for inclusive thinking in technological development.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– The need to bridge the digital divide and ensure inclusive access to technology, especially for youth in underserved areas

– The importance of engaging and empowering youth in digital policymaking and governance

– Leveraging AI and emerging technologies responsibly to advance sustainable development goals

– Promoting digital skills, literacy and innovation among young people

– Addressing ethical challenges like AI bias and online safety

Overall purpose:

The discussion aimed to explore how to create an inclusive, equitable and youth-led digital future that harnesses technology to achieve sustainable development while addressing challenges like the digital divide.

Tone:

The tone was largely optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers emphasizing the potential for youth to drive positive change through technology. There was also a sense of urgency about the need to act quickly to shape an inclusive digital future. The tone became more somber at the very end when conflicts and hardships faced by youth in some regions were highlighted.

Speakers

Moderators/Facilitators:

– Moderator: Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla, Major Group of Children and Youth, Science Policy, Tech Focal Point

Speakers:

Sara Sabry – First Female African Astronaut; Executive Director of Deep Space Initiative

Melissa Michelle Munoz Suro – ITU Secretary General’s Youth Advisory Board, GDirector of Innovation at the Government Office of Information and Communication Technologies of the Dominican Republic

Zubair Junjunia – Social Entrepreneur and founder of ZNotes and UNDP & Samsung Generation17 Young Leader 

Mohamed Orman Bangura – Minister of Youth Affairs, Sierra Leone

Eylul Ercin – Global Teen Advisor, Girl Up, United Nations Foundation

Hamza Hameed – ITU SG Youth Advisory board member; Senior Practice Manager for Space & Connectivity, Access Partnership Singapore

Emra Mian – Director General for Digital Technologies and Telecom, UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology

Yurii Romashko – CEO of the think tank Institute of Analytics and Advocacy

Daniella Darlington – ITU Secretary General’s Youth Advisory Board member

Anatola Araba – Artist, futurist, and award-winning filmmaker

Doreen Bogdan-Martin – ITU Secretary General

Nchimunuya Munyama – CEO at Netagrow Technologies

Marcos Athias Neto – Assistant Administrator and Director, for Bureau for Policy and Programme Support (BPPS) UNDP

Clara Brown – Observer Constituency Representative, UNFCCC

Edward Kwakwa – Assistant Director General, Global Challenges and Partnerships Sector, WIPO

Priscilla Efe Johnson – Founder of XariAfrica Academy and UNDP & Samsung Generation17 Young Leader 

Tayma Abdalhadi – Innovator of User-centric, Digital Solutions

Areas of expertise cover digital inclusion, AI, space technology, youth empowerment, sustainable development, innovation, and intellectual property rights.

Full session report

Expanded Summary of Discussion on Creating an Inclusive Digital Future

Introduction

This discussion brought together a diverse group of speakers, including youth leaders, government officials, and representatives from international organisations, to explore the creation of an inclusive digital future. The conversation centred on addressing the digital divide, empowering youth through technology, and leveraging emerging technologies for sustainable development. Throughout the session, there was a strong emphasis on youth leadership and inclusion in shaping digital policies and technologies, with the audience repeatedly affirming their desire for a “youth-led” digital future.

Key Themes and Discussion Points

1. Bridging the Digital Divide

A primary focus of the discussion was the persistent digital divide and its disproportionate impact on youth and marginalised communities. Speakers highlighted various aspects of this divide:

– Infrastructure gaps: Emra Mian emphasised the limited connectivity and access to devices in underserved areas.

– Digital skills gap: The need to improve digital literacy and skills, especially for youth, was stressed.

– Gender gap: Doreen Bogdan-Martin pointed out the disproportionate impact on women and girls.

– Rural-urban divide: Clara Brown highlighted the lack of access in rural and remote areas.

– Economic barriers: Yurii Romashko discussed the high costs of devices and internet access.

While there was consensus on the existence and importance of the digital divide, speakers differed in their emphasis on specific aspects. This suggests a need for multifaceted approaches to address the issue comprehensively.

2. Youth Empowerment in Digital Policymaking

The discussion strongly advocated for increased youth representation and empowerment in digital policymaking:

– Youth representation: Mohamed Bangura stressed the need for youth voices in digital policymaking.

– Mentorship: Doreen Bogdan-Martin highlighted the importance of intergenerational cooperation and guidance through initiatives like ITU’s Generation Connect movement.

– Youth innovation: Marcos Athias Neto emphasised supporting youth-led digital solutions and entrepreneurship, mentioning UNDP’s Youth CoLab program.

– Youth engagement: Creating opportunities for youth participation in governance was discussed, including the importance of voting as mentioned by ASG Marcos Neto.

– Youth advisory boards: The involvement of youth in shaping digital strategies was proposed.

3. Space Technology and Innovation

A significant portion of the discussion focused on the role of space technology in creating an inclusive digital future:

– Satellite connectivity: Hamza Hameed discussed using lower earth orbit satellites to bridge digital divides in remote areas.

– Global perspective: Sara Sabry, the first Egyptian astronaut, shared her unique viewpoint on global interconnectedness from space, noting that “From space there are no lines separating countries, no divisions between people.”

– Innovation potential: Speakers explored how space technology could drive innovation and contribute to sustainable development goals.

4. Digital Innovation for Sustainable Development

The potential of digital innovation to drive sustainable development was a key theme:

– AI for social good: Clara Brown explored leveraging AI to address global challenges.

– Digital entrepreneurship: Supporting youth-led digital businesses was emphasised.

– Localised solutions: Priscilla Efe Johnson stressed customising digital innovations for specific community needs.

– Intellectual property: Edward Kwakwa discussed WIPO’s initiatives to make IP rights more accessible to young innovators.

5. Mentorship and Tools for Innovation

Rather than focusing solely on formal education, the discussion emphasized the importance of mentorship and providing tools for innovation:

– Peer learning: Examples of peer learning platforms were shared.

– Innovation tools: Nchimunuya Munyama emphasized the need to provide tools for innovation to young people in underserved areas.

– Customised approaches: The need for tailored digital skills programmes was discussed.

6. Artistic Representation of the Digital Future

Anatola Araba’s performance provided an artistic perspective on the digital future, emphasizing themes of connectivity, innovation, and youth empowerment. This creative element added depth to the discussion and highlighted the importance of diverse forms of expression in envisioning the future.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The discussion concluded with Priscilla Efe Johnson and Tayma Abdalhadi emphasizing the need for inclusive thinking and remembering youth in conflict zones. Key takeaways included:

1. The need for multifaceted approaches to address the digital divide.

2. The importance of youth empowerment and inclusion in digital policymaking.

3. The potential of space technology and digital innovation to contribute to sustainable development goals.

4. The necessity of localised and customised digital solutions.

5. The value of mentorship and providing tools for innovation.

Suggested action items included implementing the ITU’s IP Youth Empowerment Strategy, scaling up promising youth-led digital solutions, and developing modern tech policies to accelerate innovative technologies like lower earth orbit satellites for connectivity.

The discussion also touched on the Global Digital Compact, highlighting its importance in shaping the future of digital governance. The overall tone was optimistic and forward-looking, with a sense of urgency about the need to act quickly to shape an inclusive digital future. The diverse perspectives shared by the speakers, informed by a consultation process described by Yurii Romashko, highlighted the complexity of the challenges ahead, but also the wealth of innovative ideas and commitment to creating a more equitable digital world.

Session Transcript

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): So, thank you so much for being here. That was an excellent, excellent session. Thank you so much to the gender session for setting the context. We request and invite everyone in the room to please take a seat. We will get started with our digital session. We will focus on a lot of interesting things and we have an amazing panel of experts and speakers lined up for the session. Again, maybe start to move and center yourself and find a spot to sit down and we’ll get the show started. Thank you.

Official Summit Video: In our accelerating digital age, incredible opportunities exist. But many young people continue to face major barriers. Poor connectivity, a lack of digital skills and limited access to devices are just some of the challenges that deepen the digital divide and prevent young people from sharing their voices. From participating in the digital economy and from accessing vital resources. As technologies evolve, new digital risks emerge, including online safety, security and privacy, misinformation, deep fakes, tech-facilitated gender-based violence and the mental health toll of social media. So, what kind of digital future do we want? How can we minimize these risks while harnessing the power of digital technology to build an inclusive, safe and equitable digital world for all? Young people are navigating these questions and shaping the digital future today.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator):  Awesome, nothing like an AI-generated video to kick off the digital session. Thank you so much again for being here today. We appreciate your presence. And again, it was a real. important question. How many of you paid attention to the video? Raise your hand because there were a lot of people moving around. What kind of digital future do we want? And the goal is youth led. I know we’re halfway through the session for today. I’m gonna scream what kind of digital future do we want and I want to hear back youth led. What kind of digital future do we want? That was pretty good. I thought I would have to do a second time. Thank you so much again. Again, as the video has shared, the digital revolution is an unprecedented opportunity for global development and connectivity. But it also highlights a lot of inequalities. The previous session did touch upon them and we will explore them much more deeply in the context of digital divide. Furthermore, exclusion from digital technology policymaking sidelines youth voices and documents and policies and frameworks that define the future of digital cooperation on various levels often miss that youth engagement component. The Global Digital Compact, which we will hopefully agree on in the next 48 hours, is an agreement that aims to establish a framework for a secure, free, and open digital future. There are six main objectives for the Global Digital Compact and I know many of you are really aware and well-versed in the document, but for those who are joining us for the first time, the objectives are closing all digital divides and accelerating progress across the sustainable development goals. Expand inclusion in and benefits for the digital economy for all. Foster an inclusive, open, safe, and secure digital space that respects, protects, and promotes human rights. Advance responsible, equitable, and interoperable data governance approaches. Enhance international governance of artificial intelligence for the benefit of all. And then there’s a lot of follow-up and mechanisms and reviews that we will also explore more. But when we talk about digital and AI, something that a lot of people do not think about is how digital is enabling space. And how many of you wanted to be an astronaut when you were growing up? Raise your hand. No? I had dreams of being an astronaut till I found out I had glasses in my seventh grade. But here we have today someone who is inspiring and who has done it. She thought about it and done it, did it. We have the first female African astronaut. Her ability to discuss the themes of future space and sustainability will set the agenda for today and how we can explore more on the topics of digital and AI divide and what the future can potentially look like. I would like to invite onto the stage the CEO of Deep Space Initiative and the first Egyptian astronaut, Sara Sabry.

Sara Sabry: Distinguished guests, esteemed leaders, and fellow citizens of the world. My name is Sara Sabry. I am proud to stand before you today as the first Egyptian astronaut and the first Arab woman and the first woman from the African continent to go to space. I’ve had the rare privilege of seeing our planet from a perspective that few experience. A vantage point that transcends borders, cultures, and divisions. From space there are no lines separating countries, no divisions between people. They’re just one earth, our shared home. And it is more interconnected, more united, and more hopeful than we often realize. But here on the ground I’ve seen something very different. As a woman from Africa and the Middle East, I have witnessed firsthand the devastating impact of oppression and injustice. From gender inequality, to suppression of free speech, to the denial of basic human rights. These are challenges that people in my region and around the world confront every single day. Too often it is the most vulnerable, especially women and children, who bear the brunt of these struggles. But there is hope. Because we, the people of this world, have the power to change these realities. But hope is not a passive emotion, it is an act of choice. It is the belief that the future is in our hands and that the problems we face, no matter how overwhelming, are solvable. As an engineer, I always approach problems by breaking them down into manageable parts. It’s how I design solutions, step-by-step, piece-by-piece. And this is how we must approach our biggest challenges facing humanity today. Whether it’s protecting human rights or confronting climate change, we can and we must solve these issues one step at a time. Let me tell you about the view from space. From up there, you see Earth as it truly is. A single living organism covered by a thin blue line, the atmosphere, that protects us all. It’s so fragile, yet incredibly powerful. Just like our own role on this planet. Fragile, but capable of immense impact. Climate change is a direct threat to that thin blue line, to the very system that sustains life on Earth. And though the problem seems enormous, the solution is within our grasp. But it starts with us, with the choices we make every day, and the actions we demand from our leaders. I stand here as part of a generation that refuses to accept a broken world. Young people today are not just calling for change, we are leading it. We are pushing for justice, for equality, for the rights of every person to be respected. We are fighting for this Earth, knowing that it is not just a fight for nature, but a fight for humanity’s future. We understand that these issues, human rights, environmental protection, equality, are not separate struggles. They are all part of the same mission, to build a future where every person can thrive. Each of us has a role to play. No matter where you come from, no matter what position you hold, or the resources you have, we have a responsibility to act. And if we work together, we can address these problems step by step. It starts with breaking them down and focusing on solutions. We have the ability to dismantle oppression, protect human rights, and reverse the tide of climate change, but only if we choose to act now. As the first Egyptian, the first Arab woman, and the first African woman to travel to space, I am living proof that barriers can be broken. Change is possible. Our world is more interconnected than we think, and our actions ripple across borders. The challenges we face may be great, but so is our capacity for innovation, resilience, and hope. We can choose hope. We can choose action. We can create the future we deserve, one where human rights are upheld, one where the Earth is protected, and where no one is left behind. Let us take responsibility for this planet. Let us protect the thin blue line that shields us. And let us unite in our shared mission to safeguard the rights and future of all people. Thank you.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank you so much, Sara. I think it’s truly important for us to recognize that the digital divide is not a phenomenon that is an isolated event. It exists because of the broken systems and structures that exist within our society. And it’s also really important to understand the role of government’s policy and education in bridging this digital divide. Our next two speakers are going to be talking about government perspectives on digital and AI divide, and how education and skills can be a key to bridging the digital divide. I want to invite onto the stage Ms. Melissa Michelle Munoz-Suro, who is on the ITU Secretary General’s Youth Advisory Board, and is also on the Government Office for ICT in the Dominican Republic. And also Zubair Junjunia, who is the founder of Z-Notes, and also a Generation 17 youth leader. Melissa and Zubair, the stage is yours.

Melissa Michelle Munoz Suro: When I was 25, I found myself standing in a room full of policymakers, developers, designers tasked with a monumental responsibility, leading the development of the Dominican Republic national AI strategy. The first one in Latin America, Central America, and the Caribbean. And I knew this was much bigger than me. It wasn’t just about policy or technology, it was about the future of millions of Dominicans who were left behind in the digital age. You see, 2.6 billion people around the world are still not connected. While we’re here talking about the latest AI breakthroughs, the vast part of the world is just struggling to lock on. I was 19 when I first entered the public sector, and I saw right in front of me all the challenges our community faced. Rural areas without internet, studying without access to digital education, or even electricity. And it was clear to me that this digital and AI divide was not just a technical issue, but a social one. I believe that digital transformation wasn’t just for Silicon Valley or Beijing, it has to be for everyone, from my home country to the most remote communities on the planet. And how do we bridge this divide? One powerful answer is you. In my work, I have seen how my team of 33 young people bring creativity, passion, and perspective into policymaking. That’s why, for example, we launched initiatives like Semillero Digital, where we’re turning 100 young people who were neither studying or working into skilled developers ready to shape the future of AI in the Dominican Republic. We have the opportunities to use AI to enhance education, drive economic growth, and solve the environmental challenges, but AI will only be as good as the data we fit into it. If the training data, the languages, and the perspective behind AI are biased or incomplete, we risk developing an AI system that… and amplify these biases. The DRAI strategy is a bold commitment to regional integration in Latin America with a clear message. AI will be regional or it will not be. Everything we develop will be in and on Spanish with our scientists, ensuring that AI reflects all culture. To build responsible AI, we must focus on inclusion, not just in theory, but in real concrete ways. The UN has unique capacity to champion what I call AI inclusion. And this means including our data, our problems, our language in the development of AI. The AI for Good Summit show AI’s potential to face the global challenges. But for success, we need standards and interoperability. At the UN’s AI Governance Day, the work set the foundation for responsible AI. AI need of creating guidelines, UN values, and support for developing skills in developing countries. In AI governance, we are still focused on regulation, but the world is starting to ask what now? It’s not enough to regulate, we need to implement AI that truly benefits everyone. My message is clear. Young leaders, make me sure this future isn’t just driven by technology, it’s driven by people. Thank you.

Zubair Junjunia: 10 years ago, I chose not to accept the status quo, the uneven playing of education. Everyone has a right to access quality education. And at the age of 16, in my own small way, I wanted to make a difference. And I started a website, ZNotes, to share my own study notes. Today, ZNotes is the world’s largest peer learning community that has reached over five and a half million students in 190 countries. And it is thanks to thousands of young people who have joined this as a global movement. Our community powered learning platform has proven to improve students’ self-efficacy, their sense of global citizenship, and their willingness to contribute towards social development. And it leverages three of our greatest assets in our fight against educational inequality. Number one, the power of youth. Young people are not just passive beneficiaries, and we need to flip the script. Empower them to be agents of change, to be creators of education, to be proponents of education, and you can see the difference that happens. The power of community. Many of you will remember learning from each other after break, after school, in coffee shops. Peer learning is proven to be an incredible way of improving academic learning outcomes. And the third one, the power of technology. We have the opportunity to learn from the best teachers, from accessing cutting-edge research, and connect with others across the globe. Emerging technologies like AI are now having the opportunity to personalize learning, empower educators, and enable inclusive learning assessments. And so, it is more important than ever before in our fight against educational inequality that we think about the barrier of the digital divide. To our heads of states convening next week, an inclusive digital world is integral to an inclusive global society. Thank you.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator):  Thank you, Melissa and Zubair. And I think I want to touch upon something that they both mentioned, is that we live in a world that has significantly changed over the last two decades. There are many things that are the same. We’re still fighting against those same things, but the context has changed. And with the change in the context, we need new leaders. AI policy, digital policy, cannot have young people as participants. We need youth leaders in digital and AI governance and policy plans. With that, it is my pleasure to invite… on our first panelists who are expert speakers and representatives from government. I would like to invite Minister Mohamed Orman Bangura from the Minister of Youth from Sierra Leone. Eylul Ercin, who is a youth leader, AI developer, and global teen advisor at GirlUp. Hamza Hameed, lawyer, Access Partnership, and a member of the ITU Secretary General’s Youth Advisory Board. And Dr. Emra Mian, who is the Director General for Digital Technologies and Telecom, Department for Science, Innovation, and Technology UK. Please, a round of applause for our panelists. Thank you so much again for joining us today, and we appreciate the different perspectives you bring. My first question is for His Excellency Mohamed Bangura. Can you share any examples of how Sierra Leone is empowering young people through digital inclusion policies and initiatives? What role do you believe governments, particularly in low-income countries, should play in closing that digital divide?

Mohamed Bangura: Yeah, thank you very much. As a government, I was blessed to serve under the presidency of retired Brigadier General Smotherbill six, seven years ago. And one thing we believe governments everywhere, especially in low-income countries, should do is that the presidency has to believe in young people. I happened to serve in a government that he was head of state at 28, and he left, he came back after 20 years, happens to be a president. And the first time of his service, which I served before, I was appointed as minister at 32. He, our flagship program happens to be human capital that says you feed the brain, you feed the tummy, try to be very healthy. And the presidency has to be deliberate in digital investment and believe in young people. That’s because of the youth bulge, government leadership has to be deliberative in bringing young people at the table. one of the youngest cabinets, you have a Minister of Foreign Affairs, 33, you have a Minister of Communication and Innovation, 27, Chief Minister, Dr. David Sengeh, happens to be around 36, 37, and it’s deliberate that government has to believe in young people, and by so doing, for you to enable young people to reach their potential, you bring them on the table. Innovation technology, the Presidency also believes that our current challenges, our current problems can only be solved by innovation and technology. As a result of that, he appointed a Chief Minister, a Chief Innovation Officer from MIT, Dr. Sengeh, who happens to be a Minister of Basic Education, and now he’s the Chief Minister. The Chief Minister is like the Prime Minister of a country. And deliberately, he also created a space, Directorate of Science and Technology, under his Presidency, that he supervised directly. And that notwithstanding, he created a Ministry of Communication and Innovation, appointed a young lady at the age of 27, to ensure that she leads that area. So, from the area of government, what we believe is that young people, I mean, they’re not asking for favor, they’re in the majority. I remember creating the space for every young individual from achievement level, district level, national level, they should be at the center of every stage. And when you’re serving in cabinets, you should ensure that you don’t see young people as coming for your job. It’s like you’re just creating the space to ensure that they have access to the Presidency. It’s as a result of that, every year we have what we call the Tech Summit. You bring innovators, you bring young people, you bring the Presidency, you bring entrepreneurs, you bring potential investors in the youth space, in the digital space, to meet and discuss the challenges, solutions, and how do they want it to be. So what we believe as a government is that women, especially female youth, should not just be at the back end, they should also reach at the cabinet area. So the only way we believe that things will change, having more young people in cabinet, especially more women, we’ll have the GIBI Act that says every position, parliament, appointment, should be 30 percent. The last cabinet before this, we have the Safe Abortion Bill, which was presented by the Minister of Health, Deputy Minister of Health, Dr. Angelika, to possibly just 28 years. So we still believe that young people should be at the center, young people should be role model, and they should be given the space by the presidency, and every facet, they should be the key decision-making table.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): I appreciate that message a lot. And everybody here has heard it. You need to run for parliament. And taking the insights from you, you shared, young women also need to be a leader, leadership positions, and kind of share their message. And we have a young female leader on our panel. Elul, can you share a little bit about how AI both promises solutions and presents risks for the marginalized communities? And what do you think are some of the most pressing ethical, technical challenges facing young people in digital age? And don’t on the hat of if you were the parliamentarian, and you could wave a magic wand.

Eylul Ercin: Thank you for this question. That’s really great and really current. I think we’ve been seeing more and more on the news about legislation regarding AI, and it’s gaining momentum, especially discussions around privacy concerns or ownership of intellectual property. Something that I want to emphasize, an issue that I think goes relatively unnoticed is biased data sets that lead to biased algorithms. I’m going to try to demonstrate with an example. So there is a case where Amazon actually stopped using a discontinued hiring algorithm because they discovered after a while that the algorithm was favoring certain words on resumes that were used more commonly, overwhelmingly more commonly by men, like executed. Certain algorithms that feed on data sets can lead to the amplification of existing inequalities. But that is not to say that we want to kind of, you know, stop with what we’re doing with AI because actually there is so much more potential to it. So it’s a blank canvas, basically. It’s not evil inherently. It’s just what we teach it. So if we use AI the way we want it to be, if we feed data sets to it that are inclusive and diverse, then AI holds so much potential for the future.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank you so much. And I think it’s really important to understand who is the creators, who are the creators and who is influencing the creators. And I think I was talking to Dr. Emra a little bit about AI and everything, and something that he brought up was it’s important to focus on emerging technologies, but many in the world also lack access. We need to simultaneously talk about how do we get more research in emerging technologies, but also focus on bridging the digital divide simultaneously because this is a once in a lifetime movement and point for us to change the course. Dr. Emra, and given this context, what are some of the most persistent digital divides for you that you’ve observed from the government perspective? Can you share some impactful initiatives that the UK government has supported to engage young people in digital policymaking?

Emra Mian: Sure, thanks very much. I mean, first of all, just to say that I think a lot of what’s been said in the last few minutes about AI and data, I think there’s a lot there to reflect on and a lot there for us to act on in concert. Just three other things that I wanted to pull out very quickly. I think first is the point that you’ve just introduced about digital infrastructure. An inclusive digital future for all will be hampered if people don’t have equal access to high quality digital infrastructure. And in the UK, this manifests itself with young people who grow up in rural or remote areas not having that access. But even sometimes in urban areas where you might only be a few streets away from very high quality digital infrastructure, but where you live, perhaps because people may have lower incomes, you don’t have that same access. This is something that we’re acting on within the UK, but I think this is clearly something we need to act on in lots of other places and in concert as well. The second thing I just wanted to very quickly pull out was the way in which we also need to improve digital skills, and that’s such an important part of inclusivity. And again, this is something that government, business, and civil society can act together on. In fact, some of the very effective ways in which people learn digital skills online is when they’re trying to do things that a commercial provider is doing. So a lot of people’s knowledge about and confidence of doing things online comes from, for example, making or receiving payments. And so financial institutions have got a responsibility here alongside governments and civil society. And then the third thing I just wanted very quickly to mention is online safety. I think we face a real risk that people who are not safe online will retreat from these digital spaces, and for that reason, we will fail to have an inclusive digital future. Government clearly has a role here in terms of regulation. Civil society has a role here in terms of showing where people are not safe and helping to bring transparency to that. And clearly businesses, including technology companies, have a responsibility here to ensure that their spaces are as safe as possible.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank you so much. And again, it’s so interesting you share that message because for many in the room who are young people, they’ve had pictures taken of them from the moment they started walking. And there’s albums and albums of pictures, and all of that is data. And what happens when the digital space that you are born into doesn’t feel like you belong there, where do you go? And a lot of you mentioned a lot of those themes. Hamza, as a lawyer, I’m gonna ask on you to kind of tie the knots on the different themes we’ve heard here. From your perspective, how can innovative technologies bridge the digital divide with support from policy, but also ensure that perspectives from underserved communities are represented?

Hamza Hameed: Thanks a lot for that question, and a big thank you to all the facilitators of the Action Days for organizing this fantastic occasion and dialogue. Look, imagine a young mind brimming with ideas and thoughts and not being able to express them or share them with anyone simply because of a lack of internet. Now, this is reality for approximately 2.6 billion people all around the world, more than 50% of whom are young people. So 1.3 billion young people around the world don’t have access to good internet or internet at all to be able to really share their voices online. I think bridging the digital divide isn’t just about access to technology, it’s really about empowering young people to come online, share their voices, and shape their futures, whether that be through access to education, whether that be access to healthcare, or whether that be the ability to set up a business. I think a lot of my work revolves around promoting space technology and connectivity through space, and I think innovative technologies like that present a fantastic opportunity to bridge the digital divide and contribute to connecting more and more people to the internet. Organizations like the ITU play a critical role here by setting standards and facilitating multilateral dialogue to really get these people on the internet and to enable policymakers to put in place policies and regulations that are conducive to innovation and facilitate growth and connectivity for all. I think new technologies, for example, the rise of lower earth orbit satellites that provide internet where terrestrial networks have to. traditionally not been able to provide it, have already illustrated and connected people in the most remote parts of the world. And it’s really important for policymakers to develop modern tech policies that can accelerate the development and implementation of these innovative technologies. Space technologies like this not only help with connectivity but also promote remote sensing and disaster management, whether that be precision farming or other innovative activities that allow young people to grow their livelihoods and be more expressive online. I think bridging that digital divide will be a concerted effort. And for that, I encourage all policymakers, especially those that are here in this room today, to really think about the progressive and innovative policies that they need to put in place to bring these technologies to the people who need them the most so that we can promote and shape a more inclusive, equitable, and sustainable digital future for all. Thanks.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank you so much, Hamza. And a round of applause for our expert panelists. Thank you so much for your messages. We appreciate it. And you’ve seen it here first. Member states and youth are on the same page. And hopefully we’ll see more of that as the pad continues. Thank you so much for joining us. And as a part of the consultation for today’s session, I know many of you are watching live on the UN Web TV. As a part of the consultation planning and design of this session, we organized a consultation with various UN entities supported by the UN Youth Office, the ITU, UNDP, UNFPA, WIPO, and the Major Group for Children and Youth. And I would like to invite Yurii Romashko, who is a Generation 17 leader and the CEO of the Institute of Analytics and Advocacy to present a summary of the consultations and to represent you all watching live.

Yurii Romashko: Today, there are thousands of young leaders from all of the world here. Not everybody was able to join the summit in person. To ensure that voices of young people are heard, a global informal consultations on youth lead and inclusive digital future was open from the 3rd to 9th of September. A total of 100 global contributors joined the consultations from around the world and shared their experience. So I have the special and honorable mission to be the voice of youth and present the key takeaways from the consultations which you can see on the screen. Youth accurately identify the main barriers in accessing digital technologies among which limited infrastructure, limited digital literacy, high cost of devices and internet access. Therefore global effort and collective action are needed for universal use digital connectivity. This connectivity must provide inclusive technologies that ensure fair access for all young people to use them in a fair way. This is important because IA and technologies are essential to make a real chance to advance global goals. In this global context policy actors must engage in accessible dialogue with young people and amplify youth voices in decision-making. This requires implementation of decision-making structures at all levels for greater involvement of young people. To accelerate progress it’s necessary to focus policies on closing the digital divide and integrate digital literacy into education systems. All of this can provide extraordinary opportunities for youth driven digital innovations and sustainable development in communities. And last but not least to build just safe and inclusive artificial intelligence systems requires youth inclusion, access, transparency and governance leadership. Thank you.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank You Yuri. And, again, as we’ve all heard, space does not necessarily mean the only way you get engaged with space is to be an astronaut, and we wanted to hear what you all think about what space is and technologies are and AI is. I would like to invite Daniella Darlington, who is a responsible AI leader and also a member of the ITU Secretary General, to share some perspectives about young people that she’s heard about space and AI.

Daniella Esi Darlington: Distinguished guests, fellow advocates for youth empowerment, and digital innovators. So ahead of International Youth Day, ITU, UNDISA, IGF, and UN Habitats conducted a series of quizzes with input from the Youth Advisory Board and other youth groups on space, technology, AI, and sustainable development. Now, let me invite you into the minds of the 270 young people surveyed. While questions on AI, digital divide, among others, garnered significant interest, space technology received lower interest. So according to our survey, while 95% of youth actually felt that they are more connected than ever before, only 66% could identify where the biggest digital gaps exist. Imagine a young person in a hyper-connected urban center, unaware that their fellow peers lack access to basic internet. In fact, 77% of our responders correctly understood this gap. Now consider in Africa, only 53% of youth aged between 15 and 24 are connected online, compared to a staggering 98% in Europe. This stark contrast is even more pronounced when looking at the overall population. We found a high level of awareness. among youth regarding AI and its ethical implications. An impressive 100% of the responders recognized key ethical principles in AI development among others. However, it appears that young people are unaware of how space technologies can contribute to combating hunger, with only 62% making the connection in the survey. It appears that the full potential of space data and in combating hunger among others is not known. This lack of awareness is a missed opportunity for innovation, so what do we do with this information? Our call to action is simple. Let’s bridge not just the digital divide, but the awareness divide. Let’s empower our youth, not just with the technology, but with the digital skills to solve global problems. The next breakthrough in climate action, the next breakthrough in sustainable development or agriculture, the next innovation in disaster resilience is not in a satellite or service. It’s in the minds of our youth, ready to be unlocked. Distinguished leaders, we’ve connected our youth to the world, now it’s time to connect them to its future. Thank you.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank you so much, Daniela. I feel like time is just disappearing as we hear to all these amazing expert speakers. It’s like tiny pills of knowledge that are being sent your way. It’s really important when we’re talking about digital AI, technology, infrastructure, to also recognize that all of these technologies are the end of the day human experience. And what else, if nothing, art that talks about the human experience most. And I’m privileged to invite an amazing filmmaker, futurist, Anatola Araba, who has collaborated with me. collaborated with another amazing cinematographer and advocate Malik Malik Afegbua on a performance that you’re about to experience now, and I will say it this will be a treat for your eyes and ears Anatola

Anatola Araba: Hello Thank you for joining me for a brief creative interlude this poem is about the UN’s sustainable development goals and whether we will reach them by 2030 and The importance of each voice in shaping the future. It was written by me Anatola Araba with visuals by Malik Afegbua, so please enjoy Please Keep your arms and legs inside the vehicle because we are about to embark on a journey where no one has gone before Where you may ask to the future, of course My name is Anatola and I’ll be your conductor on this enchanting voyage Thank you for choosing the quantum Express the only train that travels through space and time to visit our possible shared futures Sound like science fiction Allow me to explain You see the one thing about the future is that it’s not a physical place rather the future exists as a spectrum of possibilities And every action that we take sends a ripple effect into that spectrum, shaping the timelines of tomorrow. Anyways, seatbelts on. The train is leaving the station. Chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga. Gaze out of the window. Time starts to speed up. We flash past 2025, then 2027, 2030, then 2034, until we grind to a halt in the spring of 2035. We arrive in New York City, five years after the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals were first slated to be achieved. This used to be the city that never slept, but now it barely treads water. The Empire State Building has been destroyed by recent hurricanes. There have been more and more of these devastating storms due to the effects of climate change. Oh, and Lower Manhattan is about 11 inches underwater. What happened here, you ask, horrified? We were supposed to have sustainable cities by 2030. Well, in this future, it appears that that was just another dream deferred. But have no fear. The future is full of possibilities, and this here was just one. Let’s head to the next stop on our voyage, one where technology and innovation were embraced to enable humans to thrive. I sure hope it’s better than this, you say. All aboard! The train is leaving this station. Chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga. We flash across time like lightning through a cloud. We fly past 2035, then 2050, 2065. Until we crash. Welcome to the Nile, Egypt. Only in this future, the water that once nourished entire civilizations is almost entirely dried up. It appears that everyone was surprised when artificial superintelligence declared that the best way to protect humanity was by destroying all of nature. But by then, it was too late to stop it. This is outrageous, you cry. New technology was supposed to help bridge the digital divide, not turn our greatest nations into a wasteland. Hang your head, defeated. What are we all fighting for then, if the future is doomed to be this way? May I ask, if you would not like the world to be this way then, what is the world you imagine? The one you’d like to see if there was no limitation. Perhaps this vision could help lead us to a more hopeful destination. It doesn’t matter, you say. It’s already too late. Remember, the future is not a physical place. It exists as a spectrum of possibilities. Every action you take sends a ripple effect into that spectrum, shaping the timelines of tomorrow. But I’m not a world leader or a tech billionaire, you argue. My actions are like a tiny drop in the ocean that is tomorrow. But that’s where you’re wrong. You only need a tiny drop of food coloring. to turn the worlds of green into green. So, I will ask you once more. What needs the world to imagine if there is no limitation? Let me begin with what if. What if. What if we actually did develop sustainable cities by 2030 and communities could gather in safe, green, public spaces and gardens grew food in abundance on lawns and rooftops? What if our algorithms were guided by a north star of diversity and innovation? What if technology worked entirely with nature and AI was designed for everyone, not just the select few? What if historically marginalized voices were heard and valued and the imagination of black, indigenous, and people of color were allowed to blossom to their fullest potential? What if this were the beginning of a new era? A blinding flash washes over the parts of its friends. The light of a new possibility can be seen far in the distance. What more shines brighter than the others? A new future. One that will outboard make noise with seas to boast. What are we waiting for? Now, let’s go! All aboard! The train is approaching a new timeline. Chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga-chugga. Hey, keep your arms and legs inside the vehicle because we are about to embark on a journey we’re known for. Where, you may ask? To the future! Reimagined.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): I feel like I simultaneously saw the Marvel Avengers endgame scenario and the Stephen King movie at the same time. How many of you felt goosebumps? Raise your hand. Yes, that’s the power of art and for the future that you saw and the future that we want to avoid, it’s not going to be enough to take a group of people of this size room. It’s going to take everybody out there on the planet. It’s going to take multiple generations and I am so honored to invite a panel of experts who are going to show how multiple generations are going to work together and solve this problem and steer us on the right direction. I would like to invite on to the stage our ITU Secretary General, Ms. Doreen Bogdan-Martin. Youth Activist, Nchimunuya Munyama. The ASG for UNDP, Mr. Marcos Neto. Science Policy Interface Focal Point, Ms. Clara Brown. And the Assistant Secretary General for WIPO, Mr. Edward Kwakwa. I would want to call this the star panel of the session. I want to jump in super quick since I know we value your time and your presence here. Ms. Doreen, we’ve heard from multiple members of your advisory panel. Thank you so much for that initiative. A round of applause. You’ve done a lot for empowering youth at ITU. Could you please elaborate more about your vision for bridging the digital divide, making technology and AI more accessible to young people, but also centering the feminist movement and the experiences of girls and young people from rural and remote areas. And I’ve heard you are the songbird of hope in the digital world, so I hope you can inject some of that is into us today.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: Thank you so much Yash and it’s slightly intimidating I think to be in this crowd because when you’re surrounded by smart young people you know much more than than we do and congratulations to Anatole that was just amazing. Thank you. I think it’s important for young people to remember that you are the most connected demographic in history but I think it’s also important to remember that you shouldn’t or we shouldn’t take that for granted and so I thought I’d kind of pick up a little bit from what Anatola just just showed amazingly with with that screen and ask you I know it’s late but close your eyes for a second everybody open your eyes and don’t fall asleep okay it’s 2013 not 2030 2013 the UN has just done and this is actually true the world that we want consultation it was amazing because at the time a million people answer answered that survey from around the world and we thought that’s incredible but what we at the ITU found kind of shocking that in the million people that were surveyed and asked about their priorities for the future internet access to the internet to connectivity was at the bottom of the list why because every single person that answered it had access to the internet now I know time is bracing but close your eyes again open okay it’s 2030 so what does 2030 look like I think Anatola said it well in the second part 2030 and this depends on you you said we need young people to lead if you lead if you help us lead in 2030 we can have an inclusive just safe fair, sustainable future for all. That’s where we need to focus. That’s where I’m focused at the ITU with my amazing youth advisory board, with my young professionals program, with our Generation Connect movement, with all the work that we’re specifically targeting for girls, for women and girls to close that digital gender gap. We have lots of skilling programs. I’ve heard that mentioned as well before. We’re also very focused on participation. We need you. We need you at AI for Good. We need you at the WSIS Forum. We need you at our Space Sustainability Forum where we did have a number of our space youth there. So we need you at the table. Because with you, we can shape a digital future that meets your needs and that is inclusive and makes the world a better place and helps us to achieve those SDGs that are way off track. Thank you.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank you so much. And I know you didn’t say the word, but a key part of the formula is mentorship. And that’s what you’re doing, I think, even though we’re not using the word. And even in the previous panel, we’re not just gonna have young parliamentarians show up in a week. They require a lot of mentorship and it requires every generation to work together. And Nchimunuya, you’ve had an impressive journey as an innovator in sustainable technology. And you’ve heard the different ways in which young people can stay engaged and engage in policy. What do you think is the role of digital inclusion in fostering innovation in those who do not have access to fill out that survey, the people who are underserved?

Nchimunuya Munyama: Okay, thank you so much. Once again, it’s a privilege to be here, to be among the powerful panel. Thank you so much. I will start by speaking about my experience, having been coming from the underserved area of those that do not have access to technology itself. I grew up in a farm where I had to learn how to create my own tools and how to actually grow. my own tomatoes. So I can, I think all I had was just creativity but I never had the tools itself, I mean like the tool itself to actually build what I wanted to do. So bringing it to this session, I think my main focus, as she has mentioned mentorship, but my main focus is also what if we could create a system that every young person out there can be given the tools to innovate. If it be, let’s say if it’s the tech itself, it can be the tool itself to help them create what they want to create. Just like my parents taught me morals, etiquette, safety, discipline, what if we could do that to the young generations, those who are upcoming in this sector itself. So I think for me mentorship has played a key role in my upbringing in this tech industry and also like how I was involved in the space of actually getting to know about these tools and my journey actually has been inspired by that experience and I am here because I have a team of young people in my country that believe in me and also I have supported people that actually want to follow my path. So to me I see myself as a beacon of hope for others and I believe that if we create the necessary tools for the young people to create what they want to create, definitely we will have an inclusive community. And lastly I would say that we also need to be creators, we need to be creators of our own technology and not passive consumers. I believe that every young person has the knowledge and the how to create their own tools to actually thrive in that area itself. Thank you.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank you so much and you make growing tomatoes super easy, it was not. I tried in COVID, I got like three tomatoes of like a big plant that was the size of like six foot. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. And I remember the first time I was in the UN at a science event was at the SDG Digital last year. It was a full day of sessions. People were committing and ITU and UNDP are pivotal for that initiative. ASG Neto, in your experience with UNDP, how critical is digital inclusion in achieving sustainable development goals, particularly for young people in least developed countries? And how are you supporting young people get more engaged in the processes? And we see such a good work you’re doing. How are you empowering them more?

Marcos Athias Neto: Thank you. And it’s a pleasure to be here. It’s great. You know, I want the Quantum Express, but just the last stop. I do not want to see the first two stops of the Quantum Express. But it can happen. There is no reason why it should happen. If we do what Doreen said, if we do it while we’re talking here, we will have the last stop. Now, two thirds of youth under 25 years old do not have internet at home. They can’t connect it to the Z nodes that we saw the colleague talk about earlier and get an increased education or open a business. One of the things we are doing, for example, in the Asia-Pacific region, we have a program partnership with Citibank Foundation called Youth CoLab. And we’ve actually supported 19,000 young people over 28 countries to actually improve or create 2,600 business, entrepreneurship. That is the innovation that needs to come in. The technology is essential to make those innovations go forward faster than we need to do right now. We have in our Africa Bureau at UNDP, we have a program of bringing young African women. We get about 20, 40, I don’t remember how many, every year and bring to New York, put work in my office for one year, all trying to build the best capabilities in those SKUs. The important point about closing the digital divide, and we fundamentally believe, is that young people must have a voice in closing the digital divide. Right, so being on our, we are dealing with a super election year, right? We as UNDP together with other members of the UN system are huge in doing election. Almost every day we are involved in an election around the world. One of the things that are very clear for us is to make sure that young people have a voice, and engage in those elections. And that I say, are actually competing, are actually running for office, and are being elected. So for us, those are a few of the things that matters. Across from entrepreneurship, to mentorship, to governance, and good citizenship in elections. Across the gamut, the future belongs to the young, belongs to you. Please, join in. Don’t sit on the side, don’t hope that my generation is going to fix it. It’s your time. Thank you.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank you so much. And the key message to everybody viewing this live, is go vote, wherever you are. That’s how you show your priorities and share feedback to policymakers. Thank you so much, ASG Marcos. Clara, as a young leader in this space, being a representative for adolescent girls, what challenges do you see for youth in accessing and utilizing digital tools to make an impact?

Clara Brown: Thank you so much. So, I’d first like to start by saying that my motivation to become a voice for youth in technology started with one line of code. And then it expanded from there to become eight coding languages and quantum computing. Some of the challenges that I foresee is a lack of intergenerational cooperation moving forward. And I think that’s something that this really showcases well that we are addressing this these challenges. I had the honor of helping to select some incredible youth innovators as nominees for the innovation showcase of the STI forum and these inspiring youth led initiatives are harnessing the power of technology for sustainable and inclusive development for vulnerable communities. In other areas I have helped fund youth led local solutions to bridge the digital divide that disproportionately affects youth and again the digital divide a crucial piece of the puzzle that we are still trying to solve. So the digital divide it disproportionately affects youth particularly young women in rural communities and it is crucial that we continue to sustainably fund and support work towards gender and socio-economic digital equity for youth and a safe equitable future for all people and our planet. As an observer constituency representative to the technology executive committee of the UNFCCC I have witnessed the power of innovation such as AI for climate action and AI for good to stimulate youth led innovation for climate action and social change. It’s time to scale up promising youth solutions. We need more international cooperation connecting young leaders in the tech and innovation space to each other as well. Raising awareness of opportunities and improving digital access democratizing the development and deployment of technology and AI to advance the SDGs globally.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator): Thank you I apologize for cutting you Clara but I also know we’re running out of time and actually that’s a great segue into I saved the last question for you because a big part of scaling up is going to be policy and is intellectual property rights, whether it be AI, data, even the compact, it’s a core component that many member states are discussing and debating. ASG, Kwakwa, can you just share a little bit about what steps is WIPO taking to make intellectual property rights more accessible to young people who are driving to change through digital innovation, entrepreneurship, and are trying to take these solutions and scale them up?

Edward Kwakwa: Thank you very much, Yash. So great question. I mean, I could take up 10 minutes of your time, but I know you are in a hurry, so I’ll be very quick. At WIPO, what we’ve tried to do, first thing, this year we launched what we call an IPS strategy. It’s IP Youth Empowerment Strategy. And that strategy aims to explain to the young people how best they can incorporate themselves in the intellectual property ecosystem. So we try and instill passion in them, we try and instill action in them, and we provide support to the young people so they use their intellectual property assets. Let me give you an example. We do things like, we call it IP in a box, in countries such as Zambia or Uganda. And what we do there is we try and use the intellectual property system and show the youth how it can be a fun thing to do, in addition to owning the intellectual property. So I know not everyone here is a football enthusiast, but let me give an example. Kylian Mbappe, what he’s done is he has trademarked his celebratory iconic stance. So this is with the European Patent Office to ensure no one uses it without his authorization. This is an important intellectual property asset. And when you have a celebrity such as. as Kylian Mbappe, exposing the benefits of the intellectual property system, you get the majority of the youth in the world also interested in the IP system. So WIPO, we are doing everything we can to make sure the youth, the most important constituents we have. And Clara, I could explain to you how this year, last year, our World IP Day theme was on IP and women. And the year before, it was on IP and the youth. So clearly all these two years, we spent the time explaining to the international community why intellectual property is important and how effective and important the role of women as well as youth is in the intellectual property ecosystem.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator):  Thank you so much. That’s important. Again, I think we started with a gender session and we see that key message running throughout every session. And a big round of applause to our star panelists. We appreciate your time. Thank you so much. Thank you so much again. And I’m going to make our ITUSG proud by saying that our closing is going to be about how the digital future is going to be woman-led. And I have two amazing speakers to share the closing remarks. I have Priscilla Efe Johnson, who is a Generation 17 leader, and Tayma Abdalhadi, who is a technologist and a digital rights advocate from Palestine. The stage is yours.

Priscilla Efe Johnson: Thank you so much everyone for your time and for being here with us. Thank you to all our panellists and to all our speakers for sharing their insights. Just to give a brief summary, we’ve heard from our panellists, we’ve heard from our youth activists and I think I would like to emphasise that technology can be leveraged as a tool to accelerate holistic development but we must emphasise the need for inclusion in bridging the digital divide. When talking about leveraging technology, especially for marginalised communities, we must understand that creating impactful digital solutions is not just about introducing fancy new tech, AI models or platforms. If we truly want to ensure that leaving no one behind is not just a catchphrase, then we must push for basic computer literacy for primary school girls in rural Nigeria as much as we push for new AI models. I pose this as an urge to leaders, innovators and activists that as we embrace innovation, we must ensure the customisation and localisation of innovation to the specific needs of underserved communities by ensuring inclusion of language, gender identities and the unique context of each individual to bridge the digital and development divide, leaving no girl, no woman and no one behind. Thank you.

Tayma Abdalhadi: Thank you so much, Efe. With this, we close today but as representatives of our youth, it would not be right not to put on the forefront and remember our heroes, our people under conflicts, under rockets, our youth who are fighting every day in Gaza, Palestine, Sudan, Syria, Lebanon, every day to make this future happen while we discuss it here safely in this room. We would also want to invite you all to put this mindset, this inclusive mindset that you are one accident, one gene, one born in a geographical area away from being in the position of those youth under rockets, under hunger, under censorship. So, this is an invitation from me and all the youth that spoke today to think before we speak, to think before we develop the technology, to think before we make any resolution, whether it was the president of the country or the youngest student in the education. Every person can make a difference and every person can convey this message of inclusivity, justice and support. Thank you, everyone. This is Tayma from Palestine and see you tomorrow.

Sri Yeswanth (Yash) Tadimalla (Moderator):  Thank you so much, everyone. going to end it the way we started. I’m going to ask, what kind of digital future do you want? What kind of digital future do you want? Thank you.

E

Emra Mian

Speech speed

183 words per minute

Speech length

396 words

Speech time

129 seconds

Infrastructure gaps – Limited connectivity and access to devices in underserved areas

Explanation

Emra Mian highlights that an inclusive digital future is hindered by unequal access to high-quality digital infrastructure. This manifests in both rural areas and some urban areas where people may have lower incomes.

Evidence

In the UK, young people in rural or remote areas often lack access to digital infrastructure. Even in urban areas, some neighborhoods may have limited access despite being close to high-quality infrastructure.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Divide and Inclusion

Agreed with

Doreen Bogdan-Martin

Clara Brown

Yurii Romashko

Agreed on

Digital divide disproportionately affects youth and marginalized communities

Disagreed with

Clara Brown

Yurii Romashko

Disagreed on

Approach to bridging the digital divide

Digital skills gap – Need to improve digital literacy and skills, especially for youth

Explanation

Mian emphasizes the importance of improving digital skills as a crucial part of digital inclusivity. He suggests that this requires collaborative efforts from government, business, and civil society.

Evidence

Many people gain digital skills and confidence through everyday online activities, such as making or receiving payments through financial institutions.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Divide and Inclusion

D

Doreen Bogdan-Martin

Speech speed

148 words per minute

Speech length

437 words

Speech time

176 seconds

Gender gap in digital access – Disproportionate impact on women and girls

Explanation

Bogdan-Martin highlights the need to focus on closing the digital gender gap. She emphasizes the importance of targeting programs specifically for girls and women to ensure their inclusion in the digital world.

Evidence

ITU has implemented various programs targeting women and girls, including skilling programs and initiatives to close the digital gender gap.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Divide and Inclusion

Agreed with

Emra Mian

Clara Brown

Yurii Romashko

Agreed on

Digital divide disproportionately affects youth and marginalized communities

C

Clara Brown

Speech speed

122 words per minute

Speech length

291 words

Speech time

142 seconds

Rural-urban divide – Lack of access in rural and remote areas

Explanation

Clara Brown points out that the digital divide disproportionately affects youth in rural communities. She emphasizes the need for sustainable funding and support to work towards digital equity for youth in these areas.

Evidence

As an observer constituency representative to the Technology Executive Committee of the UNFCCC, Brown has witnessed the power of innovation such as AI for climate action and social change.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Divide and Inclusion

Agreed with

Emra Mian

Doreen Bogdan-Martin

Yurii Romashko

Agreed on

Digital divide disproportionately affects youth and marginalized communities

Disagreed with

Emra Mian

Yurii Romashko

Disagreed on

Approach to bridging the digital divide

Y

Yurii Romashko

Speech speed

134 words per minute

Speech length

270 words

Speech time

120 seconds

Economic barriers – High costs of devices and internet access

Explanation

Romashko identifies high costs of devices and internet access as major barriers to digital inclusion. This economic factor prevents many young people from accessing digital technologies and participating fully in the digital world.

Evidence

This insight was derived from global informal consultations on youth-led and inclusive digital future, which gathered input from 100 global contributors.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Divide and Inclusion

Agreed with

Emra Mian

Doreen Bogdan-Martin

Clara Brown

Agreed on

Digital divide disproportionately affects youth and marginalized communities

Disagreed with

Emra Mian

Clara Brown

Disagreed on

Approach to bridging the digital divide

M

Mohamed Bangura

Speech speed

153 words per minute

Speech length

601 words

Speech time

234 seconds

Youth representation – Need for youth voices in digital policymaking

Explanation

Bangura emphasizes the importance of including young people in key decision-making positions, particularly in government. He argues that governments should be deliberate in bringing young people to the table, especially in areas of innovation and technology.

Evidence

In Sierra Leone, the government has appointed young people to key positions, including a 27-year-old Minister of Communication and Innovation, and a 33-year-old Minister of Foreign Affairs.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Empowerment in Digital Policymaking

Agreed with

Marcos Athias Neto

Agreed on

Need for youth representation and empowerment in digital policymaking

M

Marcos Athias Neto

Speech speed

147 words per minute

Speech length

397 words

Speech time

161 seconds

Youth innovation – Supporting youth-led digital solutions and entrepreneurship

Explanation

Neto highlights UNDP’s efforts to support young people in creating and improving businesses through digital entrepreneurship. He emphasizes the importance of technology in accelerating these innovations.

Evidence

UNDP’s Youth CoLab program in the Asia-Pacific region has supported 19,000 young people over 28 countries to create or improve 2,600 businesses.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Empowerment in Digital Policymaking

Agreed with

Mohamed Bangura

Agreed on

Need for youth representation and empowerment in digital policymaking

Youth engagement – Creating opportunities for youth participation in governance

Explanation

Neto stresses the importance of ensuring young people have a voice in governance, particularly in elections. He emphasizes the need for young people to not only engage in elections but also to run for office and be elected.

Evidence

UNDP is involved in elections around the world and focuses on ensuring young people have a voice and engage in these elections.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Empowerment in Digital Policymaking

Agreed with

Mohamed Bangura

Agreed on

Need for youth representation and empowerment in digital policymaking

E

Eylül Erçin

Speech speed

99 words per minute

Speech length

208 words

Speech time

125 seconds

Algorithmic bias – Risk of AI amplifying existing inequalities

Explanation

Eylül highlights the risk of biased datasets leading to biased algorithms, which can amplify existing inequalities. She emphasizes that AI is not inherently problematic, but rather reflects the data it’s trained on.

Evidence

Eylül cites an example of Amazon discontinuing a hiring algorithm that favored words commonly used by men, such as ‘executed’, leading to gender bias in hiring.

Major Discussion Point

Ethical Considerations in AI and Technology

Data inclusivity – Need for diverse and representative datasets

Explanation

Eylül stresses the importance of using inclusive and diverse datasets when training AI. She argues that by feeding AI diverse and inclusive data, we can harness its potential for a better future.

Major Discussion Point

Ethical Considerations in AI and Technology

S

Sara Sabry

Speech speed

163 words per minute

Speech length

704 words

Speech time

259 seconds

Humanity’s interconnectedness and responsibility – Joint action to address climate change, rights violations, and inequality

Explanation

Sabry highlights humanity’s shared responsibility in tackling climate change, inequality, and human rights violations, using her space perspective to emphasize global unity. She argues that problems, though complex, can be solved with hope and collective action. Hope is an active choice that requires responsibility from everyone.

Major Discussion Point

Joint action for a better future for all

M

Melissa Michelle Muñoz Suro

Speech speed

165 words per minute

Speech length

516 words

Speech time

187 seconds

AI governance – Developing frameworks for ethical AI use

Explanation

Munoz Suro discusses the importance of developing governance frameworks for responsible AI use. She emphasizes the need for regional integration in AI development to ensure it reflects diverse cultures and languages.

Evidence

Munoz Suro contributed to development of the Dominican Republic’s national AI strategy, the first in Latin America, Central America, and the Caribbean. The strategy emphasizes regional integration and development of AI in Spanish.

Major Discussion Point

Ethical Considerations in AI and Technology

H

Hamza Hameed

Speech speed

166 words per minute

Speech length

421 words

Speech time

151 seconds

Space technology – Using satellite connectivity to bridge digital divides

Explanation

Hameed highlights the potential of space technology, particularly lower earth orbit satellites, to provide internet connectivity in remote areas where terrestrial networks are not feasible. He emphasizes the need for policymakers to develop modern tech policies to accelerate the implementation of these innovative technologies.

Evidence

Hameed mentions that lower earth orbit satellites have already connected people in the most remote parts of the world.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Innovation for Sustainable Development

P

Priscilla Efe Johnson

Speech speed

149 words per minute

Speech length

212 words

Speech time

85 seconds

Localized solutions – Customizing digital innovations for specific community needs

Explanation

Johnson emphasizes the need to customize and localize digital solutions to the specific needs of underserved communities. She argues that truly inclusive innovation must consider language, gender identities, and the unique context of each individual.

Evidence

Johnson gives an example of pushing for basic computer literacy for primary school girls in rural Nigeria as much as pushing for new AI models.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Innovation for Sustainable Development

E

Edward Kwakwa

Speech speed

152 words per minute

Speech length

344 words

Speech time

135 seconds

Intellectual property – Making IP rights accessible to young innovators

Explanation

Kwakwa discusses WIPO’s efforts to make intellectual property rights more accessible to young people. He emphasizes the importance of educating youth about how to incorporate themselves into the intellectual property ecosystem.

Evidence

WIPO launched an IP Youth Empowerment Strategy to explain to young people how to best incorporate themselves in the intellectual property ecosystem. They also run programs like ‘IP in a box’ in countries such as Zambia and Uganda.

Major Discussion Point

Digital Innovation for Sustainable Development

Agreements

Agreement Points

Digital divide disproportionately affects youth and marginalized communities

Emra Mian

Doreen Bogdan-Martin

Clara Brown

Yurii Romashko

Infrastructure gaps – Limited connectivity and access to devices in underserved areas

Gender gap in digital access – Disproportionate impact on women and girls

Rural-urban divide – Lack of access in rural and remote areas

Economic barriers – High costs of devices and internet access

Multiple speakers highlighted various aspects of the digital divide, emphasizing its disproportionate impact on youth, women, rural communities, and those facing economic barriers.

Need for youth representation and empowerment in digital policymaking

Mohamed Bangura

Marcos Athias Neto

Youth representation – Need for youth voices in digital policymaking

Youth innovation – Supporting youth-led digital solutions and entrepreneurship

Youth engagement – Creating opportunities for youth participation in governance

Both speakers emphasized the importance of including young people in decision-making processes, particularly in government and digital policymaking, as well as supporting youth-led innovations and entrepreneurship.

Similar Viewpoints

These speakers all emphasized the importance of ethical considerations in AI development, including the need for diverse datasets, responsible development practices, and governance frameworks to ensure AI aligns with human rights and ethics.

Eylul Ercin

Melissa Michelle Munoz Suro

Algorithmic bias – Risk of AI amplifying existing inequalities

Data inclusivity – Need for diverse and representative datasets

Responsible AI development – Aligning AI with human rights and ethics

AI governance – Developing frameworks for ethical AI use

Unexpected Consensus

Space technology for digital inclusion

Hamza Hameed

Sara Sabry

Space technology – Using satellite connectivity to bridge digital divides

While coming from different perspectives (technology and astronautics), both speakers highlighted the potential of space technology to address global challenges, including digital inclusion. This unexpected connection between space exploration and digital rights showcases a novel approach to bridging the digital divide.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement centered around addressing the digital divide, empowering youth in digital policymaking, ensuring ethical AI development, and leveraging innovative technologies (including space technology) for digital inclusion.

Consensus level

There was a high level of consensus among speakers on the importance of addressing the digital divide and involving youth in digital policymaking. This strong agreement suggests a unified direction for future efforts in digital inclusion and youth empowerment. However, the specific approaches and focus areas varied among speakers, indicating a need for diverse strategies to address these complex issues.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Approach to bridging the digital divide

Emra Mian

Clara Brown

Yurii Romashko

Infrastructure gaps – Limited connectivity and access to devices in underserved areas

Rural-urban divide – Lack of access in rural and remote areas

Economic barriers – High costs of devices and internet access

While all speakers agree on the existence of a digital divide, they emphasize different aspects as the primary barrier: Mian focuses on infrastructure gaps, Brown highlights the rural-urban divide, and Romashko emphasizes economic barriers.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around prioritizing different aspects of the digital divide and approaches to ethical AI development.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among the speakers is relatively low. Most speakers agree on the overall goals but differ in their emphasis on specific aspects or approaches. This suggests a general consensus on the importance of addressing the digital divide and ensuring ethical AI development, which is positive for advancing these issues. However, the different emphases may lead to challenges in prioritizing specific actions or allocating resources.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

All speakers agree on the need for ethical AI development, but they propose different approaches: Ercin focuses on addressing algorithmic bias through diverse datasets, and Munoz Suro advocates for developing governance frameworks.

Eylul Ercin

Melissa Michelle Munoz Suro

Algorithmic bias – Risk of AI amplifying existing inequalities

Responsible AI development – Aligning AI with human rights and ethics

AI governance – Developing frameworks for ethical AI use

Similar Viewpoints

These speakers all emphasized the importance of ethical considerations in AI development, including the need for diverse datasets, responsible development practices, and governance frameworks to ensure AI aligns with human rights and ethics.

Eylul Ercin

Melissa Michelle Munoz Suro

Algorithmic bias – Risk of AI amplifying existing inequalities

Data inclusivity – Need for diverse and representative datasets

Responsible AI development – Aligning AI with human rights and ethics

AI governance – Developing frameworks for ethical AI use

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

The digital divide remains a significant challenge, with infrastructure gaps, skills gaps, and economic barriers limiting access for many, especially in underserved areas.

Youth empowerment and inclusion in digital policymaking is crucial for shaping an inclusive digital future.

Ethical considerations in AI and technology development, including addressing algorithmic bias and ensuring online safety, are critical.

Digital innovation, including space technology and AI, has significant potential to contribute to sustainable development goals.

Localized and customized digital solutions are needed to address the specific needs of different communities.

Intergenerational cooperation and mentorship are important for bridging the digital divide and fostering youth innovation.

Resolutions and Action Items

Implement the ITU’s IP Youth Empowerment Strategy to engage young people in the intellectual property ecosystem

Scale up promising youth-led digital solutions and innovations

Integrate digital literacy into education systems

Increase youth participation in digital policymaking and governance

Develop modern tech policies to accelerate innovative technologies like lower earth orbit satellites for connectivity

Unresolved Issues

Specific strategies for addressing the digital gender gap in different regions

Detailed plans for ensuring AI governance frameworks are implemented globally

Methods for balancing rapid technological advancement with ethical considerations and human rights protection

Concrete steps for making intellectual property rights more accessible to young innovators in developing countries

Suggested Compromises

Balancing the focus on advanced technologies like AI with efforts to provide basic digital access and literacy in underserved areas

Combining top-down policy approaches with bottom-up youth-led initiatives to address the digital divide

Integrating both global standards and localized solutions in digital development efforts

Thought Provoking Comments

From space there are no lines separating countries, no divisions between people. They’re just one earth, our shared home. And it is more interconnected, more united, and more hopeful than we often realize.

Speaker

Sara Sabry

Reason

This comment provides a unique perspective from someone who has seen Earth from space, challenging typical views of national borders and divisions.

Impact

It set a tone of unity and interconnectedness for the discussion, encouraging participants to think globally rather than locally about digital issues.

Young people are not just passive beneficiaries, and we need to flip the script. Empower them to be agents of change, to be creators of education, to be proponents of education, and you can see the difference that happens.

Speaker

Zubair Junjunia

Reason

This comment challenges the traditional view of youth as recipients of education and policy, instead positioning them as active creators and change agents.

Impact

It shifted the conversation towards discussing ways to actively involve youth in shaping digital policies and educational initiatives.

Something that I want to emphasize, an issue that I think goes relatively unnoticed is biased data sets that lead to biased algorithms.

Speaker

Eylul Ercin

Reason

This comment highlights a critical but often overlooked issue in AI development, bringing attention to the ethical implications of data bias.

Impact

It deepened the discussion on AI ethics and prompted consideration of the need for diverse and inclusive data sets in AI development.

I think bridging the digital divide isn’t just about access to technology, it’s really about empowering young people to come online, share their voices, and shape their futures, whether that be through access to education, whether that be access to healthcare, or whether that be the ability to set up a business.

Speaker

Hamza Hameed

Reason

This comment reframes the digital divide issue from mere access to technology to a broader concept of empowerment and opportunity.

Impact

It expanded the conversation beyond technical solutions to consider the broader societal impacts of digital inclusion.

If we truly want to ensure that leaving no one behind is not just a catchphrase, then we must push for basic computer literacy for primary school girls in rural Nigeria as much as we push for new AI models.

Speaker

Priscilla Efe Johnson

Reason

This comment provides a concrete example of how to balance cutting-edge technology with basic digital literacy, emphasizing true inclusivity.

Impact

It grounded the discussion in practical realities and highlighted the importance of addressing foundational digital skills alongside advanced technologies.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by consistently emphasizing themes of inclusivity, youth empowerment, and the need for a holistic approach to digital development. They challenged participants to think beyond technological solutions and consider the broader societal implications of digital policies. The comments also highlighted the importance of diverse perspectives in shaping the digital future, from the view from space to the needs of rural schoolgirls. This led to a rich, multifaceted discussion that balanced aspirational goals with practical considerations for achieving true digital inclusion.

Follow-up Questions

How can we ensure AI and technology development includes diverse data sets and perspectives to avoid bias?

Speaker

Eylul Ercin

Explanation

Important to prevent AI from amplifying existing inequalities and ensure inclusive development

What policies and initiatives can improve digital infrastructure access in both rural and urban low-income areas?

Speaker

Emra Mian

Explanation

Critical for addressing persistent digital divides and ensuring equal access

How can governments, businesses, and civil society work together to improve digital skills, especially for underserved populations?

Speaker

Emra Mian

Explanation

Necessary for true digital inclusion and empowerment

What steps can be taken to enhance online safety and prevent marginalized groups from retreating from digital spaces?

Speaker

Emra Mian

Explanation

Essential for creating an inclusive digital future where all feel safe to participate

How can innovative space technologies be leveraged to bridge the digital divide in remote areas?

Speaker

Hamza Hameed

Explanation

Offers potential solutions for connecting underserved populations globally

What policies are needed to accelerate the development and implementation of innovative connectivity technologies?

Speaker

Hamza Hameed

Explanation

Crucial for enabling widespread access to digital tools and opportunities

How can we create systems to provide young people, especially in underserved areas, with the tools and resources to innovate?

Speaker

Nchimunuya Munyama

Explanation

Important for fostering innovation and empowering youth in all communities

What strategies can increase youth participation in governance and policymaking, particularly around digital issues?

Speaker

Marcos Athias Neto

Explanation

Critical for ensuring young people’s voices shape the digital future

How can we improve international cooperation to connect young leaders in tech and innovation globally?

Speaker

Clara Brown

Explanation

Necessary for scaling up promising youth-led solutions to global challenges

What steps can be taken to make intellectual property rights more accessible and understandable to young innovators?

Speaker

Edward Kwakwa

Explanation

Important for empowering youth to protect and benefit from their innovations

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

Microsoft and G42 establish AI hubs in Abu Dhabi

The UAE’s AI ambitions take a leap forward with two new centres in Abu Dhabi, led by Microsoft and G42. The facilities will focus on developing responsible AI technologies and promoting best practices across the academic and private sectors.

One of the centres will address underrepresented languages in AI by creating large language models, while the other brings experts together to explore responsible AI usage. Both centres build on Microsoft’s recent $1.5 billion investment in G42.

Competition in AI is growing in the region, with Qatar and Saudi Arabia also seeking to emerge as key hubs. However, G42’s decision to divest from China ensures that the partnership aligns with US and UAE government security concerns.

By opening these new centres, the UAE hopes to bolster its position as a global AI leader, demonstrating its shift away from reliance on oil toward innovative technology development.