Telecom leaders collaborate on AI-RAN innovation

A group of leading telecom companies, including Nvidia, Ericsson, Nokia, and T-Mobile US, have partnered to launch the first AI-RAN Innovation Centre. Located in Bellevue, Washington, the centre aims to transform Radio Access Networks (RAN) using AI.

T-Mobile explained that the centre aligns with the AI-RAN Alliance’s mission to improve open RAN technology, enhancing network performance through AI. The operator’s CEO, Mike Sievert, noted the immense potential AI holds for reshaping future mobile networks.

The companies highlighted that AI-RAN concepts will adopt open and containerised structures similar to open RAN but with added GPU-powered accelerated computing. This approach is expected to drive advancements in network reliability, performance, and efficiency.

Additionally, the centre will incorporate Nvidia’s AI Aerial platform, offering advanced tools for designing and deploying AI in wireless networks. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang emphasised the broad impact AI will have on the wireless industry, beyond traditional applications.

Inbolt secures €15M to boost robot AI

Paris-based startup Inbolt has raised €15 million in a Series A round led by Exor Ventures, with additional support from Bpifrance and industry entrepreneurs. The company specialises in real-time robot guidance systems powered by AI. With existing investors like MIG Capital and BNP Paribas involved, Inbolt’s total funding now stands at €20 million.

Inbolt’s 3D vision technology is designed to enhance production line efficiency, enabling robotic arms to function more accurately and at speeds 100 times faster than competitors. The company’s systems are already deployed in over 20 factories across Europe and the United States, with plans to expand into Japan and the US. Inbolt’s innovations are particularly useful for industries such as automotive and electronics.

Manufacturers face increasing pressure to automate their processes due to labour shortages and the need for improved working conditions. Inbolt’s GuideNOW solution helps meet these challenges with AI-powered 3D cameras that enable real-time robot adjustments in complex environments. Stellantis, one of Inbolt’s early clients, reportedly saved over €3.1 million in a single year using their technology.

In addition to international expansion, Inbolt will use the funding to develop new products and grow its team. With a surge in demand, the company aims to continue improving the flexibility of robotic systems for various industries.

Apple’s iPhone 16 goes on sale in Russia despite ban

Russian retailers have started pre-sales of Apple’s iPhone 16, despite the company’s export ban after Moscow invaded Ukraine. Leading stores M.Video-Eldorado and mobile operator MTS are the first to offer the new devices, with M.Video planning deliveries next week. However, Russian consumers face significantly higher prices, paying hundreds of dollars more than U.S. customers.

Despite Apple halting product sales and services like Apple Pay in Russia in 2022, the iPhone 16 is still available through parallel imports from countries that have not enforced sanctions, such as Turkey, Kazakhstan, and China. The Kremlin has endorsed this grey market system to keep foreign goods accessible. However, prices are much higher in Russia, with the 128GB iPhone 16 starting at 112,999 roubles ($1,225) and the 1TB iPhone 16 Pro Max priced at 249,999 roubles ($2,710), significantly more than U.S. prices.

Despite sanctions, Western technology remains highly sought after in Russia. However, the Russian government has urged officials to stop using iPhones, claiming they are compromised by Western intelligence agencies, a claim Apple denied.

ADI and Tata explore semiconductor production opportunities in India

Analog Devices (ADI) has entered into an agreement with India’s Tata Group to explore semiconductor manufacturing opportunities in the country. Tata Electronics, the conglomerate’s electronics manufacturing division, is investing $14 billion to build India’s first semiconductor fabrication plant in Gujarat and a chip-assembly and testing facility in Assam.

The collaboration aims to produce ADI’s semiconductor products at Tata Electronics’ facilities, boosting India’s presence in the global semiconductor industry. Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government is pushing for the country to become a key player in semiconductor production, rivalling established hubs such as Taiwan.

As part of the deal, Tata will also integrate ADI’s semiconductor products into Tata Motors’ electric vehicles and Tejas Networks’ telecom infrastructure. However, neither company has disclosed specific details regarding the products that will be manufactured or utilised.

Several other global companies, including NXP Semiconductors and Micron, have also announced plans to invest in India’s growing semiconductor sector, further solidifying the nation’s ambitions in this critical technology area.

iPhone 16 prices soar in Russia amid sanctions

Russian retailers have launched pre-sales of the iPhone 16, despite Apple’s ongoing export ban to the country. Leading companies M.Video-Eldorado and MTS have begun offering the devices at prices far higher than in the United States. Deliveries are expected to begin within the next week.

Apple had paused sales in Russia in March 2022 after the invasion of Ukraine, in line with Western sanctions targeting technology exports. Although Apple no longer operates in the region, Russian retailers are obtaining the new iPhones via grey imports. These imports are routed through countries like Turkey and Kazakhstan, where sanctions are not enforced.

Prices for the iPhone 16 in Russia start at 112,999 roubles ($1,225), significantly higher than the $799 price tag in the US The Pro Max version, with 1TB storage, is priced at 249,999 roubles ($2,710), more than $1,000 over the US price. Russian consumers continue to show demand for Western technology, despite sanctions.

The Russian government supports the parallel import scheme for products like the iPhone 16. Despite efforts to encourage domestic alternatives, Western goods remain popular, even though officials have been warned to avoid using iPhones due to alleged security concerns, claims Apple has denied.

(Plenary segment & Closing) Summit of the Future – General Assembly, 6th plenary meeting, 79th session

(Plenary segment & Closing) Summit of the Future – General Assembly, 6th plenary meeting, 79th session

Session at a Glance

Summary

The transcript covers the Summit of the Future, a United Nations General Assembly meeting focused on adopting the Pact for the Future and related documents to address global challenges and reinvigorate multilateralism. World leaders and representatives from various organizations delivered statements highlighting key issues and commitments.

Many speakers emphasized the need for reforming global governance structures, including the UN Security Council, to better represent developing countries. Climate change was frequently cited as a critical challenge requiring urgent action and increased financing. Several leaders stressed the importance of bridging the digital divide and ensuring equitable access to technology.

Addressing inequalities, poverty eradication, and sustainable development were common themes. Many called for reforming the international financial system to better support developing countries. The importance of peace, security, and conflict prevention was underscored by multiple speakers.

Youth engagement and intergenerational equity emerged as significant topics, with several emphasizing the need to involve young people in decision-making. Gender equality and women’s empowerment were also highlighted as crucial for achieving the Sustainable Development Goals.

The summit concluded with the adoption of the Pact for the Future, the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration on Future Generations. These documents aim to accelerate progress on sustainable development, strengthen multilateralism, and address emerging challenges. The Chair emphasized that while this marks a significant milestone, implementation and continued action will be critical moving forward.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– Adopting the Pact for the Future, Global Digital Compact, and Declaration on Future Generations to address global challenges and reinvigorate multilateralism

– Reforming international institutions like the UN Security Council and financial architecture to be more inclusive and representative

– Accelerating progress on the Sustainable Development Goals, especially related to climate change, poverty reduction, and gender equality

– Harnessing technology and bridging the digital divide to create a more equitable future

– Empowering youth and future generations in decision-making processes

Overall purpose:

The Summit of the Future aimed to reaffirm commitment to multilateralism, outline concrete actions to address global challenges, and chart a course for a more peaceful, just and sustainable world for current and future generations.

Overall tone:

The tone was largely optimistic and forward-looking, with many speakers expressing hope that the summit would be a turning point in global cooperation. However, there were also notes of urgency and concern about the scale of challenges facing the world. Some speakers, particularly from developing countries, expressed frustration with the slow pace of reform and uneven progress. The tone became more solemn and reflective during the closing remarks, emphasizing the responsibility to turn commitments into action.

Speakers

Based on the transcript, there were:

– 1 Chair/Moderator who facilitated the discussion and introduced speakers

– 46 Speakers, including:

– Heads of State and Government

– Ministers of Foreign Affairs

– Representatives of various UN agencies and international organizations

The Chair/Moderator’s area of expertise appears to be in chairing UN General Assembly meetings and facilitating high-level discussions.

The speakers represented a wide range of expertise areas, including:

– International diplomacy and foreign affairs

– Economic development

– Climate change and environmental issues

– Peace and security

– Human rights

– Digital technology and artificial intelligence

– Education, science and culture

– Health and humanitarian affairs

– Nuclear non-proliferation

– Gender equality and women’s empowerment

– Child welfare

– Postal services

– Regional cooperation

Full session report

The Summit of the Future: A Comprehensive Overview

The United Nations General Assembly recently convened the Summit of the Future, a high-level meeting aimed at addressing global challenges and reinvigorating multilateralism. This landmark event brought together heads of state, government ministers, and representatives from various UN agencies and international organizations to discuss and commit to actions for creating a more peaceful, just, and sustainable world for current and future generations.

Context and Significance

The Summit of the Future represents a critical juncture in global cooperation, occurring at a time when the world faces unprecedented challenges such as climate change, technological disruption, and geopolitical tensions. It aimed to foster renewed commitment to multilateralism and chart a course for addressing complex global issues collaboratively.

Key Outcomes and Agreements

The summit concluded with the adoption of three significant documents:

1. The Pact for the Future

2. The Global Digital Compact

3. The Declaration on Future Generations

These documents aim to accelerate progress on sustainable development, strengthen multilateralism, and address emerging global challenges. While their adoption marks a significant milestone, the Chair emphasized that implementation and continued action will be critical moving forward.

Major Discussion Points and Areas of Agreement

1. Reforming Global Governance and Multilateralism

There was broad consensus on the need to reform and strengthen the multilateral system, particularly the United Nations and its institutions. Speakers such as Gabriel Boric Font of Chile and Gustavo Petro Urrego of Colombia called for modernizing UN institutions and reforming the Security Council to be more representative. The Interparliamentary Union advocated for enhanced cooperation between the UN and parliaments, while David Lammy of the UK stressed the importance of adapting UN peacekeeping to new realities.

2. Addressing Climate Change and Environmental Challenges

Climate change emerged as a critical challenge requiring urgent action and increased financing. Several leaders emphasized the need to transition to clean energy, reduce emissions, and mobilize climate finance for developing countries. Luis Rodolfo Abinader Corona of the Dominican Republic highlighted the importance of protecting oceans and marine biodiversity, while Mohamed Irfaan Ali of Guyana advocated for preserving forests and establishing carbon credit mechanisms.

3. Promoting Sustainable and Inclusive Development

Addressing inequalities, poverty eradication, and sustainable development were common themes throughout the summit. Mette Frederiksen of Denmark stressed the need to eradicate poverty and reduce inequalities, while Aziz Akhannouch of Morocco emphasized investing in education, health, and social protection. Many speakers called for reforming the international financial system to better support developing countries.

4. Advancing Peace, Security, and Human Rights

The importance of peace, security, and conflict prevention was underscored by multiple speakers. Antony Blinken of the USA emphasized the need to prevent conflicts and strengthen conflict resolution mechanisms. The International Committee of the Red Cross called for better protection of civilians in armed conflicts. Several speakers, including Volodymyr Zelenskyy of Ukraine, addressed ongoing conflicts and humanitarian crises, particularly in Gaza and Ukraine, stressing the urgent need for peaceful resolutions and humanitarian assistance.

5. Harnessing Science, Technology, and Innovation

Many speakers stressed the importance of bridging the digital divide and ensuring equitable access to technology. The Global Digital Compact was highlighted as a crucial framework for addressing digital challenges and opportunities. Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni of Tonga called for developing ethical governance frameworks for AI, while the Digital Cooperation Organization emphasized leveraging digital technologies for sustainable development. The Universal Postal Union representative raised concerns about the digital divide’s impact on older persons.

6. Empowering Youth and Future Generations

A recurring theme throughout the summit was the importance of youth engagement and intergenerational equity. The Declaration on Future Generations was widely supported as a means to ensure that today’s decisions consider long-term impacts. Many speakers emphasized the need to invest in education and human capital to prepare future generations for the challenges ahead.

Key Takeaways and Future Considerations

1. UN Reform: While there was broad agreement on the need for UN reform, specific details on restructuring the Security Council and other bodies remain to be negotiated.

2. International Financial Architecture: Multiple speakers called for reforming international financial institutions to better support developing countries, but concrete mechanisms are yet to be established.

3. Digital Divide: Bridging the technological gap between developed and developing countries emerged as a critical challenge requiring concerted effort.

4. Conflict Resolution: Addressing ongoing conflicts and humanitarian crises, particularly in Gaza and Ukraine, was emphasized as an urgent priority.

5. Climate Action: Balancing economic development with environmental protection remains a key challenge, with various approaches proposed by different countries.

6. Nuclear Disarmament: The Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty Organization promoted nuclear disarmament and non-proliferation as crucial for global security.

7. Cultural and Linguistic Diversity: The importance of preserving cultural heritage and linguistic diversity in the face of globalization was highlighted by several speakers, including the representative of l’Organisation Internationale de la Francophonie.

8. Regional Cooperation: Representatives from various regional organizations emphasized their role in supporting multilateralism and implementing global commitments at the regional level.

Conclusion and Next Steps

The Summit of the Future marked a significant step towards reinvigorating multilateralism and addressing global challenges. While there was broad agreement on the need for systemic reforms and collaborative action, achieving consensus on specific implementation strategies will require further negotiation and compromise.

Moving forward, the focus will shift to translating the commitments made during the summit into concrete actions. This will involve:

1. Developing detailed implementation plans for the Pact for the Future, Global Digital Compact, and Declaration on Future Generations.

2. Continuing discussions on UN reform, particularly regarding the Security Council and other key bodies.

3. Mobilizing resources and partnerships to address critical challenges such as climate change, digital inequality, and ongoing conflicts.

4. Enhancing mechanisms for youth engagement and intergenerational dialogue in global decision-making processes.

5. Strengthening cooperation between the UN, regional organizations, and national governments to ensure coherent and effective implementation of global commitments.

The summit’s outcomes provide a foundation for future discussions and actions aimed at creating a more equitable, sustainable, and peaceful world for current and future generations. The true measure of its success will be the tangible progress made in the coming years towards realizing these ambitious goals.

Session Transcript

Chair: The Sixth Plenary Meeting of the General Assembly is called to order. The General Assembly will continue the Summit of the Future under Agenda Item 123 entitled Strengthening of the United Nations System. I invite His Excellency Gabriel Boric Font, President of the Republic of Chile, to address the General Assembly.

Gabriel Boric Font: Very good afternoon to all of you who are with us today. The Secretary General has invited us to talk about the future when, without any doubt, I imagine that for the vast majority of us, it’s very difficult to even do and think about the present. Every day over the last few years, it’s become increasingly difficult to govern. There’s an undeniable democratization of information which is obliging us as those in government to be much more transparent to our citizens about how we take the decisions that we take, and there’s a feeling of unease. that’s running around the world in various forms, in which it seems that we can’t look ahead to the future optimistically. So we need to ask as members of the government what we need to do, what can we do to change this? Today I think that there’s an emerging consensus around the world that there are no longer or there shouldn’t be privileged classes and that the wealth that is created in the world should be distributed much more equally than it is today, both in the world between member states and nation states and also within nation states. And we need to be careful in how we use the finite resources that we have on our planet, in which the climate crisis, which is particularly striking many of our countries, has to be a priority. This is in part addressed in the sustainable development goals that we are seeking to achieve as member states of this organization. But President Lula recalled yesterday that if we continue at the same rhythm, only 17% of these goals will be met. So it’s very worrisome that we all come here to repeat the same words over and over again and go to a bilateral meeting without really understanding the urgency of the commitments that we’re making and that we’re not keeping to. Distinguished member countries of the United Nations, from Chile, I’d like to say. to you with frustration but also with hope that if we haven’t yet done what we need to do to build a better world, we still have time to do so. This means that we need to change our institutions. We need to ensure that there’s a conversation that’s always on the table but never concludes. We need to ensure that we have enough space to ensure that the United Nations, the United Nations was made in a world that no longer exists in 2024. 2024 is no longer 1945. We’ve seen this in various cases in which one or other country depending on a different conflict puts forward a resolution or vetoes a resolution. We have that in resolutions on Palestine and also on Ukraine. But yesterday’s world is no longer today’s. In the Security Council, for instance, in the Security Council today’s world is no longer represented. Chile has always aimed to become a member of the Security Council and we would like to demand that we change the rules of the Security Council to adapt to the world that we live in today. If we’re not able to adapt all of this institution in which we have serious reasonable people here on behalf of their countries, how can we then ask our own peoples to change? Distinguished guests, we have great challenges ahead. Without any doubt, the United Nations has been an important element in addressing challenges but it needs more vitality. We need to give it that ourselves by changing the rules of play, the rules of the game here. The generation that I belong to and the future generation nations are looking ahead to that.

Chair: I thank the President of the Republic of Chile. I invite His Excellency Mohamed Irfaan Ali, President of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana, to address the Assembly.

Mohamed Irfaan Ali: Mr. President, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, yesterday we adopted the Pact for the Future. The task for us now is to move from ambition to action, actions that create an ecosystem of harmony between the environment, people, planet, and technology, but most of all, one that promotes human dignity. Poverty has been a constant for hundreds of millions for this and past generations. This we must change now. Ensuring climate security, food security, and energy security is paramount. Let us not rehash the climate story. We know it. We must act now. Extending the climate finance commitments can no longer be postponed. Forests are an integral part of the climate solution, and it is time that a global market-based mechanism for carbon credit be put in place. Our global food security… continues to deteriorate and the projections are alarming. It is estimated that $90 billion in annual global financing will be needed between now and 2030 to provide a basic social safety net. If we are not able to meet the basic need of feeding our people, the entire Agenda 2030 is in peril. It is our collective responsibility to provide the $300 to $500 billion needed to transform our global food system. Technology transfer, insurance for farmers, access to finance, and fair trade rules are all part of the solution. On energy security, this must be built on a platform of equity and access to technology. We must not be divided on addressing the digital divide. Too many still lack the basics of connectivity. AI can be a positive game changer for humanity, but also has the potential to widen the gap between countries and people. If we do not bridge the digital divide, our global community has a responsibility to ensure that AI is a force for good that benefits everyone. Excellencies, to do all of this, our public policies and global strategies must be aligned and our global institutions responsive. Outdated and broken global systems must be fixed. We must reform international financial architecture and make it more inclusive and conducive to sustainable development for all. But sustainable development cannot flourish without peace and security. We must end and prevent wars. The Security Council must also be reformed to be more representative, responsive, and democratic. If not, it will lose both its credibility and relevance. Excellencies, as we seek to create a fair and just world, we must focus on including all our people. No region, no country, or no group must be left behind. We must do more so that our women and youth are integral in all our decisions and actions. The future we envision must target directly the more than 340 million women and girls projected to live in poverty by 2030. It must also address the 110 million young women and girls projected to remain out of school by 2030, the 24% of women and girls projected to be food insecure, and the 245 million women and girls that will experience sexual or gender-based violence by 2030. The sustainable future we build must meet the needs and aspirations of the 1.3 million additional youths the world will have by 2030, ensuring sustainable development in which access to education, health, housing, and energy must be provided. Excellencies, we must now define an implementation plan for the PACT for the future to address the challenges in building a life of dignity for every global citizen. I thank you.

Chair: I thank the President of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana. I invite His Excellency Masoud Pezeshkian. President of the Islamic Republic of Iran, to address the Assembly.

Masoud Pezeshkian: In the name of God, the compassionate, the merciful, Mr. President, addressing today’s and tomorrow’s challenges demands collaboration rooted in justice and integrity. Let us build a just and thriving future for our children. The central focus of this joint effort is to highlight the role and status of the United Nations as a symbol of multilateralism and to promote respect for the goals and principles of its charter. The Islamic Republic of Iran has in the past expressed its views on the pact for the future. Our collaborative efforts for the future should focus on reinforcing the multilateral system to effectively tackle fundamental challenges like war, discrimination, poverty, and hunger. The role of culture and family values, the necessity of intergenerational dialogue to preserve cultural values, and the attention to the role of women, girls, and youth, as well as their empowerment, are undeniable. The priorities of my administration at the national level include a focus on health, public education, public welfare, social security, creating equal opportunities, and re-establishment. reducing various forms of inequality, fair income distribution, strengthening and consolidating the family institution, reducing poverty and discrimination, expanding social justice, empowering women and youth, and fostering the enjoyment of a sustainable environment. Mr. President, achieving peace and development require respect for the right to development of nations, attention to their development priorities and cultural nuances, adherence to principles of fairness and solidarity, and the fulfillment of commitments by developed countries towards developing nations. Unilateral sanctions have hindered progress towards sustainable development goals and must be addressed in any document prepared for the future. I propose to the UN Secretary General, in collaboration with countries affected by unilateral sanctions, present a comprehensive report on this matter to the General Assembly. We call for the urgent reforms in the governance structure of international financial institutions to ensure the participation of developing countries in decision-making and norm-setting, creating a fair and accountable framework to address the financial needs of developing nations. The Pact for the Future of the Global Digital Compact should contribute to reducing the digital divide between the global North and South, particularly through the transfer of new technologies, capacity building, and removing barriers. Equal and effective participation of the Global South countries in the governance of the Internet and Artificial Intelligence, respect for national laws, and addressing monopolistic practices are essential imperatives. Dear colleagues, we call for a world free of nuclear weapons and a Middle East free of weapons of mass destruction without any preconditions. As a victim of terrorism, we have always been at the forefront of the fight against this vile phenomenon and are ready to cooperate with countries genuinely seeking to combat terrorism. Iran seeks a strong, secure and stable region where the resources of the countries can be used for mutual benefit in advancing economic and social progress and addressing common challenges. In a world where civilians in Gaza are ruthlessly killed, state-sponsored terrorism brutally targets children and women, and genocide and assassination are supported, no document will guarantee peace and development. The end of occupation, the cessation of apartheid in Palestine and an immediate ceasefire in Gaza are prerequisites for global development and peace. The Islamic Republic of Iran is prepared to work with other countries to achieve common global goals. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the President of the Islamic Republic of Iran. I invite His Excellency Santiago Pena Palacios, President of the Republic of Paraguay, to address the Assembly.

Santiago Pena Palacios: Excellencies, Heads of State and Government, ladies and gentlemen, it’s an honor to address you today at this Summit of the Future. I believe that… This is a singular space where, as a military hero and a statistician of my country said, the future is the son of the present. So what we have adopted at this summit will have a direct impact on the lives of our children and grandchildren. The consensus that we’ve reached doesn’t mean necessarily that we have agreed on all matters. However, it’s a step forward to ensure that the system carries on working. Paraguay, as a small but active country, supports positions that are principles-based, not based on pragmatism or convenience. We’re convinced, therefore, that the basic principle of international relations in the future should be as follows. We should ensure that the most fair is powerful and the powerful are fair. The principle of equity should be the fundamental pillar of our multinational system. Therefore, we shouldn’t only be listening to the most developed or powerful countries, but rather all countries, including those such as Paraguay, which, with a rich history, has much to contribute. Paraguay loves peace and renounces war. We’re convinced that the future must be one of peace, removing further away from war and conquests. We can encapsulate this with the sentence, Mike does not make right. Therefore, we defend countries such as Ukraine, Israel, or Taiwan, which have the full right to be respected and treated in a dignified manner. We also defend the rights of countries such as Paraguay. Due to geography, are landlocked. We need to ensure that we have true equality between nations. For Paraguay, the future should also be built on the basis of democracy and respect for human rights. Our history, which has been peppered with dictatorship and authoritarianism, gives us a special right to say here that this future has to be democratic. We believe in multilateralism as the most effective tool to address the challenges that cross the borders of our countries. However, we need to recognize that current multilateralism has shown that it has serious shortcomings. We need to take action, not merely speak words. And we need to favor collective work. I therefore propose that in the crisis of multilateralism, we should respond with a better multilateralism. We are aware that food insecurity that is afflicting many regions of the world should mean that we focus on this issue. The measures to address climate change shouldn’t punish the smallest, but rather strengthen them to work towards a more sustainable future. Paraguay has 100% clean, green, renewable energy. That’s 100% is showing the path ahead. Within the United Nations, we have the responsibility to ensure that the digital revolution and emerging technologies are within reach of all and are used ethically and in a balanced manner, making sure that developing countries can have access to the same opportunities. We need to consolidate an international financial system that guarantees equitable access to necessary resources to promote the well-being of all countries, particularly developing and most vulnerable countries. We are concerned that the ability of emerging economies to address global challenges is hamstrung by effects on their growth. We need a solid system which is able. to overcome the crises afflicting the most neglected. We are well aware that this pact for the future is a result of intensive negotiations in which states have had to balance their own interests and their own pretensions. We need to underscore our lack of agreement with some of the substantive aspects of the document that’s agreed. I therefore need to think that we should say that this declaration is based on a non-binding document will be aligned with our national legislation. It’s therefore fundamental for Paraguay to preserve our values and our culture and ensure that they will always be respected in our country. The productive capacity, the microphone has been cut off.

Chair: I thank the President of the Republic of Paraguay. I invite His Excellency Volodymyr Zelenskyy, President of Ukraine to address the assembly. Thank you.

Volodymyr Zelenskyy: Thank you so much, ladies and gentlemen. It’s important that the world is working to develop a shared vision for the best future for humanity. As soon as such collective efforts begin, true interests are always revealed. Ukraine supports efforts to keep all nations united, safe, and strictly adhere to the UN Charter. And you all can see who always not only stands against it, but also also actively works to undermine global unity. This time, during the work on the Pact for the Future, the same small group of seven accomplices led by Russia has once again acted destructively, always opposing any global initiatives that strengthen the effectiveness of the UN Charter. This group has always behaved this way whenever the UN tried to do something that works for everyone’s good. And you all see it. I thank Germany and Namibia for their co-facilitation of the Pact for the Future. And I also thank Zambia and Sweden for facilitating the negotiations on the Global Digital Compact. My thanks go to Jamaica and the Netherlands who co-chaired the intergovernmental process on their Declaration for Future Generations. It’s very, very important that we hear a united voice from Africa now this common stance of African nations’ global efforts. And my sincere thanks to all the countries that have offered their helpful ideas for the future. The world needs a peaceful future and sustainable development. And I say this as the President of Ukraine, a country resisting Russia’s brutal colonial aggression. And we know exactly how much global unity can achieve both here at the UN and through the peace summits for Ukraine, where we aim to overcome the destructiveness of Russia and its accomplices. We are now preparing for the second peace summit. with our partners, step by step, according to the peace formula. And we are working on food security, energy security, and holding Russia accountable for its terror. Next, we will address all other points of the peace formula, including the release of prisoners, the restoration of territorial integrity, and more. And we are preparing a document to present at the second peace summit. I invite all leaders, nations to continue supporting our joint efforts for a just and peaceful future. Putin has stolen much already, but he will never steal the world’s future, I’m sure. Thank you. Slava Ukraine.

Chair: I thank the President of Ukraine. I invite His Excellency Luis Rodolfo Abinader Corona, President of the Dominican Republic, to address the Assembly.

Luis Rodolfo Abinader Corona: Excellency, Mr. Philemon Yang, President of the 79th Session of the General Assembly of the United Nations. Your Excellency, Mr. António Guterres, Secretary-General of the United Nations. Distinguished colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, on behalf of the people and government of the Dominican Republic, I congratulate the Summit of the Future, for which we come together to create a tomorrow based on the pillars of peace. of knowledge, peace, inclusion, and sustainability. As Peter Drucker was saying, the best way of predicting the future is by creating it. The first appeal for this summit should be to leave aside what is dividing us and seek what unites us. This is the best approach to come up with joint solutions which will have a direct impact on present and future generations. It also means taking seriously the decarbonization of our economies to address the climate crisis. And even though all countries need to contribute, nations such as the Dominican Republic will have a limited impact unless the main producers of greenhouse gases contribute in a proportionate manner, proportionate to their resources and impact. Both green funds and the commitments made in climate change must be prioritized. To fully harness the potential of artificial intelligence, we need to make it accessible and inclusive for all within the context of ethical and digital sovereignty, enabling us to transform manufacturing, education, health, and environmental care, and also ensuring that it isn’t turned into a tool of exclusion or exploitation. We are seeing in real time the suffering of hundreds of thousands of people who are suffering disproportionate unjustified violence for which they are not responsible. We need to seek incentives to avoid the nations violating the basic principles of coexistence and the peaceful settlement of disputes. At the same time, we must redesign the norms underpinning international institutions so that they can fully comply with their fundamental aims, safeguarding peace and international peace and stability. We reaffirm once again the unwavering commitment of the Dominican Republic to multilateralism, renewed effective multilateralism. We appeal for respect for and abidance by international law so that all states can have effective means to be able to ensure their security. President, none of this can be done without resources. We need to speed up the building of a new international financial architecture guaranteeing available resources for investment in development, well-being, environmental protection and climate resilience. The future is here. It’s our present. It’s the very cement on which we build today through all of the daily decisions that we take. The Pact for the Future is our opportunity to redefine a fairer, more equitable and sustainable future in which everyone, anywhere around the world, can prosper in peace with dignity and in harmony with the environment. Thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the President of the Dominican Republic. I invite His Excellency Mokgweetsi Eric Kaebetswe Masisi, President of the Republic of Botswana, to address the Assembly.

Mokgweetsi Eric Kaebetswe Masisi: Your Excellency Mr. Yang, President of the General Assembly, Excellencies, Distinguished Ladies and Gentlemen, From the outset, Botswana aligns herself with the statement made by Uganda on behalf of G77 and China and by Singapore on behalf of the Forum of Small States. States, and it is an honor to deliver this statement in its national capacity. Allow me to join other delegations in congratulating and commending Namibia and Germany for the exceptional job of overseeing the intergovernmental negotiations of the Summit of the Future. It could not have been an easy feat to comprehensively balance the divergent views and negotiate the Pact of the Future, an action-oriented and concise document. We are proud to join others during this historical moment as a demonstration of our shared political will and unity. Today is therefore a clear testament to the power of collective action and unity of purpose. We are pleased that the Summit offers an opportunity to redirect focus and chart a path towards the realization of our shared goals and aspirations as contained in SGDs. As the Summit reignites hope, we owe it to succeeding generations to demonstrate that no matter how bleak any situation may present itself, with renewed focus and vigor, no challenge is insurmountable. This historical moment will be remembered as a demonstration of our shared commitment to multilateralism and equally of our shared commitment to inclusivity. Mr. President, Botswana concurs and fully endorses the timely theme of the Summit of the Future, multilateral solutions for a better world, tomorrow, which reaffirms the need for addressing global challenges collectively. Botswana further welcomes the adoption of the Pact of the Future and its annexes, Global Digital Compact and Declarations for Future Generations. Mr. President, my delegation wishes to highlight some of the issues of great importance to us as contained in the Pact of the Future and its annexes. We welcome the emphasis that the three pillars of the United Nations Charter, being sustainable development, international peace and security, and human rights, are mutually reinforcing. as well as critical under international law. Botswana further wishes to underline the sustainable development and financing main, the primacy of developing nations. I cannot state in any stronger terms that poverty eradication in all its forms and dimensions should be prioritized. We need to pay attention to the most pressing of our needs and as such we should fully commit to reform of the international financial architecture under the auspices of the United Nations, close the digital gap between the developed and developing countries, address issues of youth and future generations by ensuring that what we do will not deny any of them the benefits and opportunities and ensure generational equity. Reform the Security Council, revitalize the General Assembly, ensure unimpeded access to humanitarian aid and lastly promote cooperation. Mr. President, I recall that in my statement during the 78th session of the United Nations General Assembly, I highlighted the need for the United Nations to consider appointing a female candidate for the Secretary General position. I note that the pact acknowledges we have not done enough on this front and I concur unashamedly. It is imperative that we do our utmost to advance gender parity. My administration has placed this goal at the forefront of its key national appointments and I will continue to ensure that appointments for the empowerment of women and girls remains a central pillar of my administration. Mr. President, I am also delighted and welcome the different review mechanisms contained in the Pact for the Future, including its annexes, which aim to ensure that Congress concrete deliverables are outlined whilst ensuring a commitment to tenants of multilateralism. It is, however, key that we acknowledge that slow progress towards achieving these goals. Mr. President, allow me to conclude my remarks by assuring you and reaffirming Bhutan’s commitment to making every effort to contribute to meeting the goals that we have set ourselves for the benefit of succeeding generations. I thank you.

Chair: I thank the President of the Republic of Botswana. I invite His Excellency Mohamed Ould Cheikh El Ghazouani, President of the Islamic Republic of Mauritania, to address the Assembly.

Mohamed Ould Cheikh El Ghazouani: In the name of God, the most gracious, most merciful, may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon Prophet Mohamed. Mr. President, this summit for the future is a window of opportunity for all peoples and countries to provide a future for all nations. The crises faced by our world recently and the challenges present a challenge to our common future. If we continue to achieve the SDGs following the same track, using the same mechanisms, following the same pace, within the foreseeable future we will not be able either to eradicate poverty or to achieve peace and security or to restore the environmental balance or create the sustainable development we want. May the peace and blessings of Allah be with you all. Progress in achieving SDGs have a negative impact on our present and future. Therefore, the African continent, as a union and individual states, have made tremendous efforts to achieve the 2063rd agenda, which is consistent with the 2030 agenda of the UN. This connection, Mauritania, has endeavored, like all other African countries, to fight violence, terrorism, vulnerability, and poverty. It contributed to ensure the economic integration of Africa, yet the results achieved regionally and internationally are not up to the standard. Even worse, the development and security gains have been regressed because of the wars, conflicts, climate change, the burden, imbalances in international governance systems. To address all these challenges, it has been incumbent on the international community to find solutions, effective and efficient solutions, that will establish a common agenda to accelerate the implementation of SDGs, to restore trust and regain solidarity among nations and countries, and to present a new dynamic to ensure multilateral cooperation and to reform the international financial structures. The UN Secretary-General, that is currently chairing the AU, welcomes the fact for the future that has been just adopted. We reiterate our call to reform the United Nations, in particular the Security Council, to allow our continent to have a voice so its priorities will be given the due consideration in the international agenda. We also call to address the debt issue and address the environmental needs and enhance international cooperation and ensure international peace and security so together we can take our planet away from the collapse that is experiencing. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the President of the Islamic Republic of Mauritania. I invite His Excellency Mohamed Younis A Menfi, President of the Presidential Council of the State of Libya, to address the Assembly.

Mohamed Younis A Menfi: Your Excellency, the President of the General Assembly of the United Nations, Your Highnesses, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, may the peace be upon you. At the outset, I would like to congratulate His Excellency Mr. Yang for his election to preside over this very important summit. I express also our greatest and deepest appreciation for the efforts and the endeavors in order to achieve the very important outcomes of this summit. Ladies and gentlemen, this summit represents an exceptional opportunity in order to take a deep look at the current challenges and to find innovative and comprehensive solutions we need to work together in order to ensure a better future for the upcoming generations. And with putting new focus on the very important principles of this summit, the summit puts us before a great responsibility. We need to change our approaches while dealing with the upcoming challenges. The technological advancement, especially the digital ones, offers us new tools in order to come up with sustainable and innovative solutions. These solutions are not merely just technologies, they should be the result of a very strategic way of thinking with a forward-looking touch in upholding social responsibility. We need to be cognizant of the fact that these tools are not merely artificial intelligence, they are strategical developments in order to be able to bring about a positive change in the society. In addition, we reiterate the importance of the comprehensiveness and the fairness. The disparities economically and digitally between countries still represent obstacles towards development. We need to bridge these gaps and guarantee equal chances and opportunities for all. Ladies and gentlemen, Libya works in order to uphold its regional and international role. It supports the principles, the same ones that this summit strives to achieve. We work in order to reinforce dialogue and cooperation in order to face our common challenges such as climate change, immigration. and terrorism, we are committed to work with our international partners in order to find innovative and sustainable solutions using the strategic experiences and expertise and using also new technologies to face these challenges. The geographic location of Libya as a transit country makes us cognizant of the challenges of the unregulated migration. We try to come up with sustainable solutions in order to face this phenomenon. We reiterate in this context the importance of international cooperation to deal with the root causes of the migration and to provide development in the countries and in alignment with the principles of the Summit of the Future. Ladies and gentlemen, this summit has a main objective, is to build a future where everyone has equal opportunities. We need to work together and overcome the regional disagreements and to unite our efforts in order to achieve this very noble objective. The cooperation between countries is not an option. It is a necessity in order to achieve sustainable development and social justice. We need also to focus on the intergenerational responsibility. This is a historical opportunity and we need to guarantee that our decisions, the ones we are making today, take into account the upcoming generations and guarantee a sustainable future for them. We can no longer go on exploiting the natural resources in a very irresponsible way. In conclusion, we reiterate the importance of adhering to the principles of the Summit of the Future, the one that is calling. for adopting sustainability, justice, and innovations in all walks of life. Through our joint efforts, we can overcome the upcoming challenges and to build a world where opportunities are for all, and we can all be prosperous and live in dignity and peace. Thank you, Mr. President.

Chair: I thank the President of the Presidential Council of the State of Libya. I invite His Excellency Gustavo Petro Urrego, President of the Republic of Colombia, to address the Assembly.

Gustavo Petro Urrego: Heads of State and Delegations Stephen Hawking, the famous physician, was once asked what he thought were the causes of potential extinction of humanity in the contemporary world, and he mentioned two. Firstly, artificial intelligence to the climate crisis. I think if we’re going to talk a little bit about the future, I think that we should be understanding the interlinkages between these two concepts, which were so dangerous in the view of Stephen Hawking. AI undoubtedly can be dangerous, or it could be dangerous, when there is a confusion for human beings between reality and lack of reality, the dividing line between reality and no reality. It seems that we are currently moving towards that. that and there, there’s a danger, an immense danger for humanity that this would mean that we lose our reference with reality. Secondly, artificial intelligence, I think, is here because it does substantially increase economic productivity, manufacturing on a per hour basis. And it can also take away hundreds of millions of jobs, leading to even greater inequality than we have at the moment. Thirdly, artificial intelligence increases productivity. It’s therefore highly energy consuming. Energy around the world is used to increase productivity, to produce more, to sell more, to earn more. And the only winner is capitalism. These three elements that we could see as negative, these three elements of artificial intelligence, use enormous amounts of energy, much more than we use today, will therefore contribute to the climate crisis. If artificial intelligence uses fossil fuel as a source of its energy, we will then, as Stephen Hawking said, be facing an Armageddon, the end. A world in this way would only politically lead us to the destruction of democracy and general barbarity, which we’re already starting to see. In Gaza, for example, control of humanity through artificial intelligence confuses mankind. They can no longer see what’s real and what’s unreal. And this would be run fully counter to the democratic project that we have as a republic in Colombia. And if on top of this, we… have an explosion of demand for fossil fuels, we will have the extinction of life on Earth. Stephen Hawking, I think, was right. An alternative view, if we manage to move towards clean energy in an immediate future, to give clean energy to artificial intelligence, and if we transform our productivity, the free time of societies and of people might, therefore, mean that we see other keys to development in the future. Clean energy, high productivity, societies with free time, this would be true wealth for a nation. And then a nation would need to be built on the basis of global democracy, in which anyone around the world, wherever they are, in any nation around the world, could be equal to everyone else, a global world that we still have to build. But my vision of the future, therefore, would lead us to the opposite of what Stephen Hawking saw as the threats, a global democracy which would plan the building of clean energy around the world, which would enable their growth. And they would allow for AI that elevates productivity, not on the basis of private earnings, which leads to much more unequal societies, but rather it would allow for emancipated wealth, allow for emancipated workers with free time. And we would, therefore, live with greater wealth and happiness. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the President of the Republic of Colombia. I invite His Excellency Bassirou Dioumaye Diakhar Faye, President of the Republic of Senegal, to address the Assembly.

Bassirou Dioumaye Diakhar Faye: Mr. President, dear colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, I thank the Secretary-General for the initiative of organizing this summit, and I commend his efforts for a world of peace, a stable world where inclusive development reigns. The future we want requires us to leave no one behind, faced with the challenges to peace and security, reducing inequalities, eradicating poverty, justice and equity. We can only bring this future about if we pursue joint solutions that are rooted in a multilateral framework, a framework that inspires confidence and buy-in, and which serves everyone’s interests. Otherwise, it would continue to give rise to mistrust from some and scorn from others, and would thus lose the credibility and legitimacy that are attached to its authority. In this regard, I would like to share four observations with you. First, it is clear that our future cannot be built on the current model, which is dominated by injustices, extreme poverty that affects 10% of the world’s population, high-intensity geopolitical tensions, and unprecedented global warming, which is seriously affecting our countries. All of this is alarming and, as underscored, in reports by the UN Secretary General, if the current trends continue, 575 million people will still be living in extreme poverty in 2030. This will further hinder any hope of sustainable development. And in the face of this situation, it is essential that we attack the vicious cycle of debt, the abnormally high interest rates of which are suffocating many countries of the South. This system of inequity that is underscored in the recent UNCTAD report, constitutes a growing barrier to global prosperity, in particular in developing countries whose borrowing interest rates are between two and 12 times higher than those accorded to developed countries. To achieve better debt sustainability, we must reform conditions of access to credit above all export credit by easing the rules relating to loan interest rates and the length of grace periods and the terms of those loans. Secondly, the need to reform global political, economic and financial governance so that it reflects the realities of the present. Although progress has been made recently, including the G20’s decision to give a permanent seat to Africa and the decision by the member states of the IMF to give Africa a third seat on the executive board, a lot still needs to be done to guarantee the full inclusion of developing countries in those bodies. Thirdly, it is essential that we strengthen activities to promote education and vocational and technical training to combat ignorance and indoctrination and to provide young people with vocations and ways that they can flourish. Investing in this way would help to combat inequalities and would help achieve the Sustainable Development Goals. It is therefore more than urgent that we accelerate the implementation of the SDG relaunch plan that was initiated by the Secretary General. Fourthly, it is essential that we invest more in connectivity and digitalization by strengthening digital infrastructure, innovation and support for the creative industry of young people upon whom the future will rely. We must provide young people with the means to learn, to succeed and to flourish. They must be at the heart of our activities and be involved in management and decision making as drivers of peace and of development. Thank you for your kind attention.

Chair: I thank the President of the Republic of Senegal. I invite His Excellency Prithvirajsing Roopun, President of the Republic of Mauritius.

Prithvirajsing Roopun: Excellencies, Distinguished Delegates, We convene today at this Summit for the Future not merely as representatives of individual nations but as custodians of humanity’s collective destiny. We find ourselves in an era of unprecedented potential when human ingenuity offers lots of promises, yet countries are grappling with challenges that threaten to unravel the very fabric of our society. Climate-induced calamities, conflicts, the scourge of poverty and hunger, epidemics are not isolated occurrences, they form threads in the complex weave of our global agenda. It is this interconnectedness that brings us together under the theme multilateral solutions for a better tomorrow, which should also serve as a clarion call for action. The pact for the future is a covenant with posterity, a solemn promise to generations yet unborn that we, the stewards of today, will not falter in our duty to safeguard their inheritance. This pact must serve as the cornerstone upon which we build a more equitable, sustainable and resilient world. It must breathe life into our collective aspirations. Mauritius joins the international community in reaffirming our shared commitment to the principles enshrined in our pact. Mauritius has always prioritised inclusiveness and built a strong social protection system to create equal opportunities for each and every citizen. This commitment extends to our collective pursuit of equitable development where we acknowledge the paramount importance of ensuring equal access to economic opportunities and resources for all. Excellencies, distinguished delegates, SIDS stands as sentinels of climate change. Our challenges These are a microcosm of the global struggle against climate emergency and economic fragility. As the tides rise along our shores, so too must our collective resolve to address these existential threats. Similarly, while the international community strives towards these goals, we must commit to supporting initiatives that foster scientific and technological progress, wherein the internet vulnerabilities and specific needs of developing countries are taken into account. While we embrace the dawn of the digital age with open arms, we should do so tempered by wisdom. This is why our Pact for the Future, along with the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration for Future Generations, are all crucial parts of our forward-looking strategy. They all provide a roadmap for revitalizing our commitment to the Sustainable Development Goals and shall stand as a testament to what can be achieved when we unite in purpose and action. Mauritius reaffirms its utmost conviction to the principle of multilateralism and for the realization of this pact. Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, together we can and must craft a future that honors the dignity of every individual, harnesses the true potential of every nation, and preserves what remains from our planet’s natural ecosystem. To the generations that will inherit the world we shape today, let our legacy be one of courage, foresight, and unwavering commitment. commitment. Let it be said that when faced with unprecedented tribulation, we responded with unprecedented solidarity. I thank you for your kind attention.

Chair: I thank the President of the Republic of Mauritius. I invite His Excellency Ratu Wiliame Maivalili Katonivere, President of the Republic of Fiji, to address the Assembly.

Ratu Wiliame Maivalili Katonivere: Mr. President, Heads of State and Your Excellencies, the world is in peril. Conflicts are raging. The climate crisis is escalating. Development is faltering. Our ecosystems are failing. Wise inequalities and injustice are everywhere. It is the most vulnerable who are suffering the consequences. Tomorrow, it will be our children, their children and succeeding generations, who will pay the price for our inaction. In the face of pressing global challenges, the values of multilateralism has never been more relevant and more urgent. Fiji acknowledges the summit of the future as an opportunity to strengthen our resolve and consensus on safeguarding the future of humanity. The pact of the future, which has been adopted at this summit, represents a collective commitment to do better together and leave no one behind. Mr. President, we have a common vision for sustainable future. How can we How we achieve this vision will depend on the efforts we undertake. We have only six years until 2030 to progress a sustainable development agenda. We must urgently recalibrate international cooperation and reform the multilateral system. We must be intentionally inclusive. We must work together as member states, supported by a multilateral system that is fit for purpose and in consideration of non-state actors, private sectors and all members of society. We must choose peace over conflict and respect human rights of all as enshrined in the UN Charter. We must respect and protect our environment and its resources on land, in the sea and in the air. We must trust each other, as trust is the foundation of strong partnership. We must be true to our word. Our legacy for the generations of tomorrow depends on the action we undertake today. We must do better for them. Mr. President, I thank you.

Chair: I thank the President of the Republic of Fiji. I invite His Excellency Xavier Espot Zamora, Head of Government of the Principality of Andorra, to address the Assembly.

Xavier Espot Zamora: Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen, We are here at the summit of the future, one of the most decisive moments in the history of humanity, not just to consider the current challenges, but also to, together, forge a path that will lead us to a more just, more sustainable, and more inclusive future. And it’s high time that we do so. It is our responsibility as leaders to determinedly overcome the global challenges that are jeopardizing the well-being of future generations, our children and young people. The time has come for us to govern with greater modernity, humanity, empathy, and integrity. Andura stands ready to participate in a new stage in the history of the United Nations, where the spirit in which this organization was founded resurfaces. We commit to adhering to the Pact for the Future, a pact between peoples and for peoples. Following many attempts, it is urgent that we send a message to the citizens of the entire world and show them that multilateralism is the best tool, indeed, the only tool that we have to address universal challenges. Time has taught us that some challenges cannot be overcome unilaterally or by some groups of states alone. Climate change remains the most urgent crisis of our age. We cannot ignore this threat. We cannot leave the responsibility of resolving this problem to our children. The consequences have been felt for years, and they are devastating. They require immediate action, unconditional cooperation, and firm commitments. The transition towards a green economy is not a choice, but rather a necessity. There is no other choice. We are also living in an increasingly interconnected world in which digital. progress is transforming every area of human life. Artificial intelligence, gene manipulation, the increasing collection of biometric data, personalized medicine, and robotic manufacturing are undoubtedly advances that are generating confidence in human progress, but they could also have pernicious or harmful consequences depending on how they are used or the goals that are pursued with them. That is why, if we want technology to be a positive force, we must regulate it according to inclusive ethical criteria, making sure that nobody is left behind in this digital revolution. Data protection and the protection of private life also must become a global priority, and Andorra’s premise is this indeed, that it is adopted thanks to an ambitious digital transformation agenda. This is an agenda that includes an ethical and legal framework for the protection of citizens’ digital rights, protection of the private life, and the security of data and free access to digital information. Andorra has also set up an action plan aiming to improve the digital well-being of children and young people, and it was one of the first states to sign the Council of Europe Convention on Artificial Intelligence. Thus affirming its firm determination to strengthen human rights protection systems in the age of technological progress. Ladies and gentlemen, the triumphalist stance some experts have adopted, certainly sometimes justified, depending on the world that we live in, that has changed from 100 or 200 years ago, cannot be an excuse. We cannot allow ourselves to reject empathy and remain indifferent to the suffering that surrounds us, to the conflicts, wars, and to terrorism which is undermining global security. As the world changes, the security mechanisms that have protected us for decades need to be adapted. We must strengthen multilateralism, make its decision-making mechanisms more representative and more effective, and build the capacities of conflict prevention and mediation. Only open dialogue and diplomacy can lead to peace. Lastly, let us not forget the fight against inequalities. We must together work to redistribute opportunities and resources. The line that we need to follow continues to be the one that was laid out in the 2030 Agenda. Healthcare, education, decent work, gender equality, these must be our priorities. Allow me also to particularly focus on education, which is one of the most powerful tools that we have to transform our world. Andorra is convinced.

Chair: I thank the head of government of the Principality of Andorra. I invite His Excellency Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni, Prime Minister and Minister of Education and Training, Minister for Police, Fire Services and Emergency Services, and Minister for His Majesty’s Armed Forces of the Kingdom of Tonga, to address the Assembly.

Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni: Ladies and gentlemen, warm greetings from the Pacific, blue Pacific continent. I address you in my role as Chair of the Pacific Islands Forum at this critical summit of the future. The challenges we face are many, they are urgent, and they are interconnected. The beg for the future offers a path forward. This is a beacon of hope we all need at a time of escalating uncertainties. The PEC is introduced at a moment when there is a global demand for a more equitable, secure and sustainable world for our future generation. The PEC is a blueprint for how to get there. The PEC recognizes the importance of conducting science, technology and innovation ethically by ensuring we safeguard human rights. The PEC commits to safeguarding our shared planet’s resources and fostering an international order respecting human dignity and justice. The decision we make today will shape the future of our shared humanity. The 18 members of the Pacific Island Forum are determined to be proactive and will not leave our futures to chance. In 2022, the Pacific Island Forum launched the 2050 Strategy for the Blue Pacific Continent. The strategy is the result of our vision of peace, security, social inclusion and prosperity. Vision alone does not suffice. This is our solemn commitment to our people and future generations to build our common resilience and prosperity. The Blue Pacific Continent, our home, is under threat. Climate change, geopolitical tension and ever-growing financial and economic disparities are testing our resilience. We are determined to do everything necessary to move this vision to reality for our people. But this depends largely on a stable, open and prosperous international order based on the UN Charter. This is the foundation for security we in our Blue Pacific never have and never will take peace for granted. The reform of the Security Council must encompass the security challenges of the 21st century and beyond, including issues like climate change and its agenda. Federal representation in the Security Council must include the voices of small island developing states. As far back as the last decade of the last century, we have sounded the alarm that climate change is a threat to the people of the Pacific. The situation has worsened over time, and what was once a threat has now become a crisis. A crisis which demands immediate and decisive action. Words are no longer sufficient. The Pacific Islands as frontline states are bearing the brunt of climate change. Yes, we are victims, but importantly, we also are leaders in the fight against this global challenge. We call for urgent, transformative global action to limit warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius. The Beg for the Future rightfully insists on the link between climate change and peace and urges the fulfillment of commitments to help vulnerable countries adapt and build resilience. We call for the reform of the International Financial Institution to reflect the realities of today and to be fit for purpose. For SIDS-MVI, it is essential for precisely assessing the challenges that we face. Let me turn for a moment to the Pacific Islands Forum. We have taken steps to build resilience. This includes pioneering the Pacific Resilience Facility, our first Pacific-led climate and disaster initiative. We have established key integrations, such as the integration on the continuity of statehood and protection of persons amid sea level rise and the 2021 integration on preserving maritime zones against climate change. impacts. We have also developed and endorsed the Pacific Regional Framework on Climate Mobility and introduced a framework for resilient development in the Pacific. Incidentally, the latter is the world’s first regional framework linking climate change and disaster risk. I firmly believe that a Back for the Future is a vital catalyst for the 2030 Agenda. The Back for the Future must be our commitment to a fairer and safer future for all. The Global Digital Compact is crucial for fostering a safe, inclusive, and sustainable digital…

Chair: I thank the Prime Minister and Minister for Education and Training, Minister for Police, Fire Services and Emergency Services, and Minister for His Majesty’s Armed Forces of the Kingdom of Tonga. I invite His Excellency Amadou Ouru Bah, Prime Minister, Head of Government of the Republic of Guinea, to address the Assembly.

Amadou Ouru Bah: Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen, Heads of State and Government, Mr. Secretary General, Distinguished Guests, Our deep-rooted conviction is as follows. The future is not simply something that we achieve, it is something that we build together. On behalf of His Excellency General Mamadi Doumbouya, President of the Republic, the people of Guinea, and their government, I express to you our fraternal greetings and our congratulations to the Government of the Republic of Guinea. co-facilitators of our summit, the Republic of Namibia, and the Federal Republic of Germany. This summit represents a unique opportunity to transform our collective commitments into concrete and decisive action. The Pact for the Future is an ambitious framework for responding to the challenges that our planet faces, be it inequalities, climate threats, or the need to reinvent our approaches to sustainable development. We applaud the role of international cooperation in providing adapted responses. Investing in young people and in future generations must be at the heart of our action. We need to provide them with what they need so that they can fully realize their potential in a context where illegal migration is in the process of emptying our countries of their resources. Technological and digital innovations must be used in the service of all of humanity, because technology and innovation can only be beneficial when they benefit everyone. That is why we advocate for equitable access to technology while stressing the ethical issues in their use. Peace and security are essential elements of global stability, and they are a vital prerequisite for any sustainable development. We therefore call for strengthened cooperation among states, aiming to prevent conflicts and promote international diplomacy. Sustainable development and the financing of development are essential pillars in this global transformation. It is essential that ambitious and inclusive measures be adopted. to achieve the Sustainable Development Goals. As a country that is involved in this, my country hopes that the international financing mechanisms will be strengthened to allow all nations, particularly the most vulnerable, to make progress towards sustainable, resilient and inclusive growth. In this vein, we cannot ignore the importance of preserving our environment, in particular, sensitive ecosystems such as the Futajalon Massif. This site, which is a genuine watershed for all of West Africa, is vital for the ecological balance in our region that affects 15 states. Protecting it is not just a national issue, but it is a collective responsibility. We firmly reiterate our commitment to getting it listed on the UNESCO Global Heritage List to ensure that it is conserved for current and future generations and to strengthen global efforts for sustainable development and to anticipate and prevent water-related conflicts. Today, we have a rare and precious opportunity to redefine our collective destiny. This summit must be much more than a simple meeting. It needs to mark a turning point where together we choose to build a tangible, inclusive and prosperous future for all. The Republic of Guinea is determined to contribute actively to the implementation of the Pact for the Future. We believe in the power of multilateralism and international cooperation to build a world where everyone can belong, a more just, more inclusive, more sustainable world. Long live international cooperation and long live multilateralism. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the Prime Minister, Head of Government of the Republic of Guinea. I invite His Excellency Lesley Voltaire, Advisor to the President of the Transitional Presidential Council of the Republic of Haiti, to address the Assembly.

Lesley Voltaire: Excellencies, Mr. President of the General Assembly, Your Excellency, Mr. Secretary-General of the United Nations, Ladies and Gentlemen, Heads of State and Government, Distinguished Guests, Ladies and Gentlemen, It is with a great sense of responsibility that I address you today at this Summit of the Future. This event does not just represent a meeting of world leaders, it is also a critical moment in building a shared future based on the principles of solidarity, equity and justice. As the President of Haiti, a country facing many complex challenges, I wish to underscore the importance of the Pact for the Future, which we are adopting today at this Summit. This pact represents not only a historic commitment to renewed multilateralism, but also a unique opportunity to strengthen international structures so as to respond to the different economic, social and environmental realities that we face. The world is currently faced with unprecedented challenges that require stronger, more inclusive international cooperation. With this in mind, this Summit offers an opportunity to revitalize multilateralism and to modernize the United Nations system so that it is more inclusive and representative of the present realities. Global governance mechanisms need to be adapted to new economic and political dynamics and make sure that every nation, big or small, has a voice in settling global crises. This major event is also an opportunity to rethink global governance by addressing subjects such as financing of sustainable development, gender equality and the protection of biodiversity. In particular, reform of the international financial architecture is crucial in order to support the transition of some countries, in particular the least developed countries, the LDCs, towards sustainable development. It is essential that we make sure that the benefits of growth be equitably shared around the world. One of the cornerstones of the Pact for the Future is the inclusion of young people and the protection of future generations. Today, more than 1.9 billion young people live on our planet and their participation in decision-making processes is essential in order to ensure lasting peace and equitable development. All too often, young people are left behind or left out of economic and political discussions even though they have a vast potential to resolve global crises, be it climate change or social inequalities. In Haiti, the Transition Presidential Council and the government are working to integrate young people in all aspects of national reconstruction in collaboration with the international community. We will make sure that future generations do not bear the burden of the mistakes of the past, but rather that they benefit from progress towards lasting peace and social justice. This summit is an opportunity to reiterate this by making young people central actors in change rather than simple observers. Haiti faces a multifaceted crisis that is jeopardizing the very foundations of the state. The security crisis, fed by organ trafficking, drug trafficking, arms and munitions trafficking, on top of a humanitarian crisis, requires an urgent solution from the Haitian authorities with the assistance of the international community. Climate change, which is intensifying natural disasters such as hurricanes and droughts, is seriously affecting our country. These challenges go beyond our borders and require a collective global response. The stability of Haiti is essential not just for the region, but also for the global balance. In order to overcome these challenges, Haiti needs the support of everyone. Direct foreign investment, the fight against inequalities, and the bolstered support in security climate justice, these are all essential in order to ensure a prosperous future for our country. This summit of the future is a crucial stage in reiterating our collective commitment to multilateralism. International institutions must be reformed in order to become more inclusive and be better adapted to current challenges. The voice of developing countries such as Haiti needs to be heard in major international bodies where major decisions are taken. In order to better reflect the current geopolitical dynamics, Haiti advocates for genuinely equitable multilateralism where every continent and every state, regardless of its size or influence.

Chair: I thank the President of the Transitional Presidential Council of the Republic of Haiti. I invite His Excellency Mohammed Mustafa, Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs of the State of Palestine, to address the Assembly.

Mohammed Mustafa: Good evening, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen. In 2015, we gathered for the historic adoption of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, the most ambitious transformative plan of action for building a prosperous, equitable and sustainable world. More importantly, this agenda is centered on human dignity and shared prosperity in a just world where no one is left behind. Unfortunately, recent years have seen a surge in economic, political, climate and humanitarian crises deepening marginalization of vulnerable communities. If not addressed, these crises will undermine our multilateral systems and put us further away from realizing the goals of the 2030 Agenda. With the back to the future, we have an opportunity to reverse this dangerous trajectory by rebuilding trust in international institutions and paving the way for a future of peace, justice and sustainable future for all. Mr. President, in the State of Palestine, while striving to play a positive role in response to global challenges, we are regrettably further burdened by Israel’s illegal occupation and aggressions in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, including East Jerusalem. For over 76 years, our people have been forced to endure multiple man-made catastrophes that have directly undermined our efforts to achieve justice, peace, and prosperity. As I speak to you, before you, our people in Gaza are enduring one of the darkest chapters in modern history. For nearly a year now, Israel’s genocidal war has caused unprecedented loss and suffering and humanitarian catastrophe. At the same time, our people in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, continue to face systemic threats driven by the escalating settler’s violence, military raids, movement restrictions, and financial siege, withholding of Palestinian tax revenues. Excellencies, despite long years of oppression and occupation, our people remain steadfast. We firmly believe that human capital is our greatest asset and are thus committed to enhancing the performance of our institutions, ensuring effective governance and service delivery to our people, and to creating an enabling environment where every Palestinian has the means to survive and thrive in peace and stability. The remarkable resilience of our people, even in the face of ongoing atrocities, renews our confidence that they will heal and rise from this tragedy. Palestine has demonstrated social resilience at the national level with our commitment standing strong in unity and perseverance. It’s now our collective duty to stop the aggression and to extend this resilience beyond the social sphere in our economy, in our infrastructure, and all areas of development. We must ensure that our people have the means to survive and thrive in peace and stability. that Palestine is equipped to cope, adapt, and transform in the face of diverse challenges, preparing ourselves not only to withstand future challenges but also to build a stronger, more resilient nation. Central to this goal must be a just transition, an essential framework in the 2030 Agenda. As proven in the past, Palestine can achieve economic growth and sustainable development, but this time we must ensure their pursuit is just, fair, and inclusive, ensuring every citizen benefits equitably, guaranteeing a prosperous, sustainable future for all. Let us act together with the global solidarity and cooperation inherent in the 2030 Agenda and Pact for the Future to overcome the challenges threatening humanity. Let us remain faithful to the principles we have affirmed in this summit by restoring hope to future generations, including the Palestinian people who must

Chair: I thank the Prime Minister and Minister for Foreign Affairs of the State of Palestine. I now give the floor to His Excellency Filip Ivanovic, Deputy Prime Minister of Montenegro.

Filip Ivanovic: Thank you very much. Honorable President of the 79th session of the UN General Assembly, Excellencies, distinguished colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, we have gathered here today to embrace the adoption of a new and ambitious agenda, the Pact for the Future, with the aim to make the UN more effective, credible, and relevant for the 21st century and multiple global challenges we are faced with. To achieve this goal, one of the main steps ahead of us is to reform decades-old institutions, bearing in mind that the world has been changed significantly from the moment of the creation of the United Nations. Such includes the Security Council reform, revitalization of the work of the General Assembly, and enhancement of the cooperation with regional organizations, private sector, CSOs, and other stakeholders. In this context, Montenegro welcomes the consensus reached on the outcome documents of the Summit and firmly believes that the Pact, along with its two annexes, will make a meaningful impact, paving the way to a brighter future for both present and future generations. Another important step towards a prosperous future for all citizens is to work together on accelerating the implementation of the Agenda 2030 and Sustainable Development Goals. Along this journey, we must ensure that no one is left behind. It is of utmost importance that we continue to mobilize resources for the least developing countries, which will enable them to make substantial impact. Dear colleagues, Montenegro was among the first countries to adopt the National Strategy for Sustainable Development until 2030. In this context, I would like to emphasize that Montenegro has already presented two voluntary national reviews in 2016 and 2022 on the implementation of the Agenda 2030. Furthermore, Montenegro is one of the 32 UN member states that has adopted the National Statement of Commitment to the Implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals, which outlines specific pledges and benchmarks to focus on and enhance SDG actions in the coming years. As a new EU candidate country, Montenegro places great importance on complementarity and synergy between our EU agenda and SDGs and remains fully committed to making progress and achieving success in both processes. A revitalized role of the United Nations in the field of disarmament, an updated approach to collective security that could better prevent conflicts, the responsible use of artificial intelligence in military domain, and the adaptation of UN peacekeeping operations to new realities and threats, including enhanced protection of civilians in armed conflicts, are all crucial for ensuring a more just, secure, and peaceful future for all. In this regard, we welcome the UN Secretary General’s new agenda for peace and his recommendations. Excellencies, distinguished partners, we welcome the adoption of the Global Digital Compact, included as an annex to the Action-Oriented Pact, which aims to ensure that technology serves in the best interest of humanity, along with the efforts to bridge the global digital divide. Additionally, we support increased use of science in policymaking in order to ensure that more people could benefit from advancements in science, technology, and innovation. We also welcome the adoption of the second Annex to the Pact declaration on future generation, which reinforces our commitment to the meaningful participation of youth in the United Nations processes. Dear colleagues, we firmly believe that global challenges could only be effectively addressed through the joint cooperation of all international actors, ensuring a more inclusive, accountable, and effective global governance framework. In this context, allow me to reiterate that Montenegro remains a constructive partner in addressing these global challenges through revitalized and a more effective multilateralism strengthened by closer cooperation. cooperation, unity, and solidarity among countries, and reinforced by stronger international institutions. I look forward to working with all of you for the benefit of both present and future generations, and I am sincerely grateful for your attention. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the Deputy Prime Minister of Montenegro. I invite His Excellency Aziz Akhannouch, Head of Government of the Kingdom of Morocco, to address the Assembly.

Aziz Akhannouch: Your Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, at the outset, I’d like to convey to you the greetings of His Majesty, King Mohammed VI, to those participating in this important summit. This is a summit that is being held in an international context that is full of complex challenges. It is a summit that provides us with a unique opportunity to renew our commitment to the United Nations Charter and to renew our collective commitment to establishing new dynamism in multilateralism so that we can achieve a better and more sustainable future for generations present and future. Ladies and gentlemen, Morocco is committed firmly towards the Charter of the Pact for the future, and we believe that implementing it will rely on five main conditions. First, we must establish peace and stability and development as the the foundation of our work because we cannot establish sustainable development without peace and peace cannot be achieved without economic progress and social progress. Therefore, we stress the need to develop a global approach that is inclusive and that is based on mutual respect and trust and dialogue. Second, we must renew multilateralism based on true and genuine political will and work collectively. We are required to enhance our work that is based on legitimacy and solidarity and here, His Majesty King Mohammed VI, in his letter to those participating in the annual meetings of the IMF that were held in Marrakesh, in that, His Majesty stated that economic and social and political developments that have taken place over the past years require us to reform the institutions and the policies of multilateralism. Third, we must place Africa in the heart of the United Nations’ works and all measures that are taken here. And here, we ask, is Africa not a good indicator to evaluate our collective efforts to establish the highest aspirations of peace and stability throughout the world? We are thus required more than any time before to help Africa transform its current challenges into opportunities to achieve developments. Fourth, we must translate these commitments into tangible actions that are measurable, especially since combating climate change and combating terrorism and extremism and human trafficking and combating poverty and social inequality and food insecurity, all of these require renewed and active political will as for the climate. It is worth noting that Morocco has raised the level of its expectations in setting a new goal to lower greenhouse gases by 45.5% by 2030. And Morocco aims to enhance the level of investment in renewable energy, including green ecology, to achieve the objective of a 52% of clean energy in its energy basket by 2030. These are the same efforts that are being exerted in terms of social protection as well as enhancing nutritional and health sovereignty as has been confirmed by the latest comments by His Majesty the King in a speech from the throne in which he said, what we have achieved makes us believe in ourselves and have hope for the future. I thank you.

Chair: I thank the head of government of the Kingdom of Morocco. I now give the floor to His Excellency Ian Borg, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign and European Affairs and Trade of Malta.

Ian Borg: solutions together at this summit for a common purpose, to make the world a better place for present and future generations. Together, there is nothing we cannot achieve. Second, to create a better future, we must accelerate action right here, right now. Achieving the SDGs by 2030, or net zero by 2050, requires immediate action. Number three, this summit is not a final destination, but a stepping stone, a journey. We celebrate the positive elements in the pact for the future, and we encourage member states to be even bolder in their vision and use this occasion as a springboard towards even more ambitious action. And fourth, we must recognize the intercorrectedness and harness the synergies across the three pillars of the United Nations – sustainable development, peace and security, and human rights. The UN stands tall when these three pillars are strong. On international peace and security, a comprehensive approach encompassing these three pillars is essential in a world where conflict and crisis are becoming increasingly complex and interconnected. We support Secretary General’s call, now reflected in the pact, for a greater focus on conflict prevention. The participation of women and youth in peace processes is crucial to prevent and resolve conflict, build and sustain peace. And we must address the adverse impacts of climate change on international peace and security. On sustainable development, holistic action across its economies. economic, social, and environmental dimensions yields the best results. It’s unacceptable that extreme poverty and hunger continue to persist in today’s world. In this pact, we will commit to eradicating them. We must turn climate and environmental challenges into opportunities for a cleaner, greener world by scaling up renewable energy, transitioning away from fossil fuels, and achieving net zero. We must also work to ensure our oceans’ health, resilience, and sustainability, and take action to address sea level rise, which disproportionately impacts small island developing states. Let us harness the benefits of science, technology, innovation, and digital cooperation to improve every aspect of our lives, while keeping a watchful eye on potential threats. In an era of globalization and rapid change, governments should act as catalysts and facilitators, creating enabling environments for collaboration and dynamism, while also embracing the power of multi-stakeholder action. We’ll highlight the importance of investing in young persons, providing them with ample opportunities of quality education to reach their full potential, empowering them, and ensuring their engagement and participation. They are the innovators, entrepreneurs, dreamers, and creators who shape this world. Through this pact, we also acknowledge that children are very much our present. We are committed to their protection from armed conflict and violence, to work towards the eradication of poverty and hunger, and to put more children in schools and invest in their education. We must respect, protect and fulfill the human rights and fundamental freedoms of every person on this planet, regardless of their nationality, race, skin color, ethnicity, religion, gender or sexual orientation. We reiterate the need to reduce inequality and leave no one anywhere in the world behind. Gender equality, the empowerment of all women and girls and their full, equal and meaningful participation in the decision-making processes are essential prerequisites to sustainable development. Together, we are stronger. We join hands at this summit of the future to support efforts towards transforming global governance and a strengthened multilateral system, with the UN at its heart, embracing structural and systematic reform towards a system that is more effective.

Chair: I thank the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Foreign and European Affairs and Trade of Malta. I now give the floor to His Excellency Vivian Balakrishnan, Minister of Foreign Affairs of Singapore.

Vivian Balakrishnan: Your Excellencies, a stronger multilateral system where rules are applied universally is vital. Peace and security depend on adherence to international law and the UN Charter. We strongly support the Pact for the Future and the accompanying Global Digital Compact and the Declaration on Future Generations. These are critical building blocks for a stronger, future-ready multilateral system. We reaffirmed our commitment to international law and the UN Charter. This is vital amidst the intensifying conflicts and geopolitical tensions today. We must all recommit ourselves to peaceful resolution of disputes through diplomacy. A world in which respect for sovereignty, for territorial integrity, and international law that is being eroded will become a very dangerous world for current and future generations, and especially for small states. Second, we adopted the groundbreaking Global Digital Compact. As digital technologies continue to shape our lives in all-encompassing ways, we need to establish common rules to unlock its transformative potential whilst mitigating the risk. More than two-thirds of the UN’s targets for sustainable development can benefit directly from digital innovations. Singapore has worked with Rwanda to launch an AI playbook for small states. Together with our capacity-building efforts under the Digital Forum of Small States, this AI playbook will empower all of us to leverage AI for public good. Third, we are glad that the Declaration on Future Generations emphasises youth engagement. Young people have an even bigger stake in the future that they will inherit. The emphasis on incorporating anticipatory planning and foresight in our work is most timely. We must ensure that the policies we make today are future-ready to build a better world for successive generations. Excellencies, the adoption of the Pact represents the start of a long and essential journey to reinforce and renew our multilateral system. We need to summon collective commitment. to stay the course. We need to embrace the spirit of compromise to find common solutions. We must also have the courage to take the bold action essential for the long-term well-being of future generations. We must forge a future that is fair, just, equitable and inclusive. Thank you, Excellencies.

Arnoldo Ricardo Andre Tinoco: Mr. President, Excellencies, The Pact of the Future is not only a vision, but actually an urgent call to collective action. The call is to put dialogue over arms, negotiation over coercion and cooperation over competition. The pact that we adopted yesterday puts prevention at the heart and urges us to invest politically and financially in it. Because prevention not only saves lives, but it also protects the progress made in development. The pact reiterates our profound disappointment at the lack of progress in nuclear disarmament. However, it falls short in establishing specific deadlines for nuclear weapon states to destroy their enormous arsenals. It doesn’t even mention the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons. nuclear weapons, which is our compass here. Nuclear weapons threaten our present and our future. The pact recognizes climate change as the greatest threat for future generations and underscores that collective action is essential to address this, in particular for the greatest emitters. Costa Rica welcomes the stress put on climate action and the conservation of biodiversity. And we appeal to all states to speed up efforts to comply with obligations under the Paris Agreement and the global biodiversity coming Montreal framework and thus curb the loss of biodiversity by 2030. The pact calls on us to lift up our ambition levels for the ocean, to have a vital planet. We need a healthy ocean. From it, we get 50% of the oxygen that we breathe. It is the greatest source of protein around the world, the greatest carbon sink and climate regulator. And its biodiversity sustains 3 billion people around the world. Hence, it’s urgent that as soon as possible, the Treaty of the High Seas, the BBNJ, enters into force and that we conclude the Treaty on Plastics and do not begin mining of the deep ocean until we can prove that it will not have harmful effects on the marine environment. I invite you to participate in the third UN conference for the oceans with Costa Rica and France as co-hosts. This will be held in Nice in June 2025. We hope there to be able to seek common solutions there for the challenges. that we face. We welcome the fact that the Pact faces on science, technology and innovation as facilitators of sustainable development. Establishing governance frameworks for artificial intelligence is one of its most important agreements. Costa Rica supports the establishment of a scientific international independent panel on artificial intelligence, and the United Nations can and must develop international consensuses to address the challenges that the planet and artificial intelligence are raising and thus protect future generations. The Pact also sends out a political sign at the highest level that it is time to start having urgent conversations, particularly for those who need an international financial architecture that is fairer, more equitable and more representative, that meets the needs of the most vulnerable countries and those that are most affected by economic and environmental crises. This would be a system that guarantees access to finance for all, including concessional financing. Excellencies, we hope that by the end of this, it is thought that by the end of this century, the planet will be home to more than 10 billion people, the majority of whom will be in developing countries. Ensuring equity and the involvement of women and young people in decisions that will guide their future is fundamental to build fair and sustainable societies in which their voices are heard and their rights are respected. The Pact calls on us to overcome our differences and to take decisive steps to protect our planet.

Chair: I thank the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Costa Rica. I now give the floor to His Excellency Amery Browne, Minister for Foreign and CARICOM Affairs of Trinidad and Tobago.

Amery Browne: Mr. President, The convening of this summit is crucial to renew global solidarity, to meet our existing commitments, to take advantage of new opportunities, and to effectively identify a clear path to address contemporary challenges. In our quest to achieve sustainable development, we must ensure that all Member States are on a level playing field. Those who are particularly in unique circumstances must be afforded the necessary support through international cooperation in order to truly ensure that none are left behind. Accordingly, we must not renege on our commitments to LDCs, LLDCs, and SIDs. Therefore, Mr. President, Trinidad and Tobago underscores the importance of the reform of the international financial architecture and emphasizes that official development assistance should be guided by the Multidimensional Vulnerability Index. Mr. President, it is truly regrettable that at this time the international community is failing at the maintenance of peace and security globally. The unprecedented escalation in the number and scale of conflicts contradicts the very purpose for which the United Nations was built. We must act now. boldly and decisively to effectively bring an end to these conflicts and to achieve sustainable peace for all. The ease of access to illegal firearms in the Caribbean countries continues to harm our societies with unacceptable consequences. In this context, it is imperative that there is better cooperation within and amongst national, regional, and global stakeholders to combat, prevent, and eradicate the illicit trade in small arms and light weapons. Mr. President, Trinidad and Tobago recognizes the role of science, technology, and innovation for us to achieve sustainable development. However, as we progress into an era of high dependence on technology and rapid advancements in artificial intelligence, we must also acknowledge the magnitude of the associated risks. Therefore, as a small developing state, we are not only advocating for cooperation aimed at bridging the digital divide, but also for strengthening our capacity in cybersecurity to address those risks. Mr. President, our young people are key stakeholders in our pursuit of sustainable development. Consequently, we must ensure that they are equipped with the necessary tools and provided with opportunities to reach their full potential. Additionally, our policies and programs must include provisions to ensure the well-being of future generations. In this context, Trinidad and Tobago remains unswerving in our commitment to enhance the quality of life of our youth population and that of future generations. Mr. President, the father of our nation and first Prime Minister of Trinidad and Tobago, Dr. Eric Williams. in a statement in 1968, affirmed that the central responsibility of the UN is the maintenance of world peace, not only through conciliation and discussion, but also through the promotion of human development. His words remain relevant even today in reminding us of the importance of fulfilling our obligations as responsible members of our United Nations. Mr. President, I thank you.

Chair: I thank the Minister of Foreign and Curriculum Affairs of Trinidad and Tobago. I now give the floor to His Excellency Jeyhun Aziz oglu Bayramov, Minister of Foreign Affairs of Azerbaijan.

Jeyhun Aziz oglu Bayramov: Mr. President, Excellencies, Distinguished Delegates, Ladies and Gentlemen, The world stands at a crucial crossroads, facing unprecedented challenges, including climate change, ravaging conflicts, geopolitical tensions, and rising inequality. At this critical juncture, the summit of the future is an opportunity to address pressing challenges, bridge the gaps, and show that a multilateral system can deliver with a unified voice. Azerbaijan, as itself, lived through the most tragic consequences of violations of international law, including humanitarian law, and had been subject to injustice of non-implementation of the Charter and series of resolutions of main organs of the United Nations. nations. It is against this background that Azerbaijan fully recognizes the call of this summit for strict compliance with international law and reversal of the erosion of international norms. The Charter, as well as all the instruments and mechanisms set out therein, must be applied unreservedly without any double standards, political, geographical, or whatsoever preferences. Excellencies, we meet the halfway mark for the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, with only 17 percent of the SDG targets on track. There is an urgent need for turning our political commitments into decisive action to achieve progress. In this regard, Azerbaijan fully supports Secretary General’s efforts to galvanize progress on the SDGs and remains committed to the pledges made in the 75th anniversary declaration. At the national level, we are making progress by authorizing 17 goals, 88 targets and 119 indicators, and setting an example for others to follow. This has been achieved through a collaborative and inclusive process involving civil society, the business community, women, youth, and other key stakeholders. Liberation of our territories from occupation opened a new page also in terms of attainment of SDGs. The government has embarked on large-scale reconstruction and rehabilitation efforts worth tens of billions of U.S. dollars, covering all aspects of implementation of SDGs. Moreover, Azerbaijan has introduced a national goal, SDG 18, focusing on mine action. We call for greater international support and solidarity, as demining is crucial for addressing immediate humanitarian needs, restoring livelihoods, and revitalizing communities. We are also among the few countries worldwide and the first in our region to submit four voluntary national reports on the 23rd Agenda. for Sustainable Development Report, Azerbaijan ranks ahead of the two-thirds of the countries. Excellencies, Azerbaijan has entered into a new era, having restored its rights to sovereignty and territorial integrity safeguarded under the Charter. By putting an end to the illegality of the use of force, Azerbaijan has initiated post-conflict normalization agenda with Armenia, fully based on mutual recognition of and respect for each other’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. Building upon the progress that was made through bilateral negotiations, we call for expeditious actions to address the remaining impediments and underline the importance of exercising necessary political will and responsibility. Ladies and gentlemen, it is imperative to address climate change as the greatest transnational challenge of the century. It is not a future risk, but a present danger to billions of people worldwide. In November 2024, Azerbaijan will host the 29th Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Guided by the call in solidarity for a green world, Azerbaijan will spare no effort to strengthen collaboration for a more climate-resilient and sustainable world. We aim to bridge both developed and developing countries and foster collaborative spirit to tackle climate challenges as a common commitment and moral duty. As the COP29 incoming presidency, we have been working inclusively with all parties and non-party stakeholders. COP29 Azerbaijani presidency’s overarching and inclusive strategy is anchored in two mutually reinforcing pillars, enhance ambition and enable action, with establishing a new climate finance goal as a key priority this year. COP29 will also be an opportunity to contribute to both global peace and climate agenda. Given the intersection of conflicts and climate crisis, Azerbaijan has introduced a flagship COP29 Truth Initiative embedded in joint solemn appeal, announced a few days ago. We call for unity and respect for the truths during the months of COP.

Chair: I thank the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Azerbaijan. I now give the floor to Her Excellency Celinda Sosa Lunda, Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Plurinational State of Bolivia.

Celinda Sosa Lunda: Thank you very much, President. I’d like to begin by conveying the brotherly greetings on behalf of the Bolivian people and our President Luis Arce Catacora. President, distinguished colleagues, humanity and our planet are facing the effects of the multidimensional crisis of the capitalist system. This is reflected in a rise in poverty, in inequality, in food insecurity, the climate crisis, war, among other scourges. If we’re not able to address global problems with collective solutions, we will be facing the possibility of the collapse of the whole of mankind. For this reason, cooperation, solidarity, complementarity, peace, a balance with nature, respect for sovereignty and the self-determination of peoples must be the common values that guide the decisions that we take and the new paths through which we will build. In this context, the Pact for the Future, the Global Digital Compact and the Declaration on Future Generations are important. important instruments that allow us to look ahead to a better future for present and future generations. This pact has the great aim of correcting profound inequalities created by centuries of economic, political and social domination. Regrettably, we must also recognize that the Sustainable Development Goals will not be attained as was planned by 2030. However, we believe that the Pact for the Future must serve as impetus to speed up the implementation of the 2030 Agenda. President, colleagues, allow me to share three principles that we deem important for the implementation of the Pact for the Future. Firstly, equity in global governance. In the modern world, from the global south, which is home to the highest number of countries and people around the world, multilateral decisions must be collective. They must be taken on an equal footing with respect for sovereignty and the sovereignty enjoyed by all states. This involves undertaking real and deep-rooted reform of the UN Security Council, of international financial organizations and other multilateral fora. Secondly, climate justice and sustainable development. Our nations are the ones that have been most affected by the climate crisis, despite the fact that they are the least responsible for it. The commitments that have been made under the Pact for the Future must guarantee common but differentiated responsibilities among developed and developing countries, ensuring the funding that has been pledged for for adaptation and mitigation. It is not acceptable for those countries that are most responsible for climate change to now attempt to renegotiate the content of the Paris Agreement. Once and for all, we must build a development model based on respect for Mother Earth and the rights of all our peoples. Thirdly, capacity building. In a world in which technology is advancing quickly with artificial intelligence and already forming a part of our daily lives, it’s important for developing countries to be able to achieve the same technological development for health, education, among other areas, so that our societies can have a necessary ability to address the challenges of the future. Women and young people of the Global South are the greatest drivers in our society. For this reason, it’s fundamental that we invest in their development so that they can lead the change that we need. Furthermore, we recognize the inclusion of and the reference to the most vulnerable sectors in our societies. These include indigenous peoples and women. However, their inclusion continues to be insufficient. Bolivia believes it’s important to progress in, to undertake further deep-rooted reform. We propose promoting decolonization and dismantling the patriarchy.

Chair: I thank the Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Plurinational State of Bolivia. I now give the floor to His Excellency, David Lammy, Secretary of State for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Affairs of the United Kingdom.

David Lammy: Mr President, I stand here as a man of multiple identities, a Londoner, a patriotic Brit, a lawyer proud of my African, Guyanese, Caribbean and Indian heritage, a committed multilateralist who believes in the importance of the United Nations. I agree with my great predecessor Ernie Bevin when he said in 1945, our eyes should be fixed upon the United Nations, all nations of the world should be united to look that way. The purposes and principles of the UN remain as indispensable today as in Bevin’s time. Our task is to recapture that founding spirit so that when we reach the UN’s centenary, their legacy endures. But we cannot ignore the challenges we face. More conflicts than at any time since 1945, costing the global economy over $900 billion and creating the most refugees and displaced people on record. Geopolitical tensions are rising, progress against the Sustainable Development Goals stalling, trust in multilateralism faltering. The pact for the future and this summit offer a chance for Member States to show responsible global leadership. to engage with the rapid changes of our age and go further in meeting the needs of everyone, especially the most vulnerable. As I know all too well, countries of the Global South suffered great injustices in the past, and I’ve heard repeatedly how frustrated partners are by the unfairness of the global system. We cannot ignore these frustrations, we must act. First, as the Secretary General has said, we need greater collective efforts to prevent and end conflict. For Britain, that means upholding Ukraine’s sovereignty, urging an immediate ceasefire in Gaza and Lebanon, and supporting an end to the fighting in Sudan. It means robustly challenging member states who violate the Charter, rejecting a world in which might makes right. It means a more representative Security Council. It means supporting the international rule of law and applying it equally and fairly, which is why Britain has proposed the outstanding Professor Dapo Agande for election as a judge at the International Court of Justice. Second, we need urgent action on the climate and nature crisis. With this new government, Britain is renewing our ambitions at home, aiming to deliver clean power by 2030, and I am determined that we also reconnect abroad, building a global clean power alliance, championing creativity and reforms to unlock international climate and nature finance, particularly from the private sector, and bolstering efforts to protect at least 30 percent of the planet’s land and ocean by 2030. Third, countries like Britain must modernize our approach to development. This government believes partnership, not paternalism, is the way to deliver the Sustainable Development Goals, making best use of technology, putting indigenous people and local communities, including women and girls, at the center of decision-making on development. development programs, driving faster reform of the global financial system to strengthen the voice of the most vulnerable and tackle unsustainable debt. Friends, action on conflict, climate and poverty, delivered by a reformed multilateral system. This is the path to peace and prosperity on a livable planet all over the world, in every war zone, every refugee camp. The UN is there, a beacon of hope and humanity to which, as Bevin said, the gaze of all nations should turn. This summit must direct the world’s eyes towards that beacon once again, and Britain is proud to support it. Thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the Secretary of State for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Affairs of the United Kingdom. I now give the floor to His Excellency Antony Blinken, Secretary of State of the United States.

Antony Blinken: Good afternoon. At this summit, Secretary General Guterres and many world leaders have argued powerfully that to fulfill the crucial purpose of the United Nations, we urgently need support, reform and revitalization. The United States fully agrees. That’s why we join fellow member states in shaping and committing to a broad range of priorities in the Pact for the Future, forging the Digital Global Compact, signing on to the Declaration on Future Generations, enabling the United Nations and international institutions to better respond to shocks like pandemics and natural disasters made more severe by the climate crisis. climate crisis, addressing growing and diverse threats to international peace and security on land, the sea, the air, in outer space, and in cyberspace, ensuring that universal human rights are respected equally online and offline, empowering women and girls across the UN’s efforts, reforming the UN Security Council to better represent the developing world and, more broadly, the world as it is today. The United States believes that this should include two permanent seats for Africa, one rotating seat for small island developing states, permanent representation for Latin America and the Caribbean, in addition to the permanent seats for countries we’ve long endorsed, Germany, Japan, India. The United States supports starting negotiations on council reforms immediately. The pact for the future does not include every priority, every reform that we believe the UN needs, but it is a significant step toward strengthening and evolving this institution that every member state should get behind and work to achieve. We’re also pursuing reforms in other international institutions, as well as in our own country, that advance the bold goals and the aspirations of many member states, particularly those we’ve heard directly from developing countries. We strongly supported the African Union joining the G20 so that African voices are better represented in that group. We’re leading efforts to strengthen the ability of multilateral development banks to deliver on the Sustainable Development Goals. We’re making the biggest investments of any country ever to accelerate the transition of clean energy at home, while dedicating billions to help people in developing countries adapt to and manage the impacts of the climate crisis. And as the world’s leading humanitarian donor, we are forging new partnerships across public and private sectors. to meet what are unprecedented needs around the world. These are important steps, but more must be done because simply preserving the status quo is not an option. The United States is committed to adapting the UN system to reflect this world of today and tomorrow, not the one that existed in 1945. But we are, and we will, remain resolutely opposed to revisionism. We will not accept efforts to tear down, dilute, or fundamentally alter the core principles of the UN Charter – sovereignty, territorial integrity, independence. We will continue to affirm that no member state has the right to redraw borders by force or repress their own people. We will continue to oppose the idea that nations can assert spheres of influence or dictate who other countries ally or partner with. We will push back fiercely against attempts to undermine the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and related international human rights treaties. It’s one thing to revitalize, to reform, to adapt the organization to meet the challenges of the future. It’s quite another to try to change its core purpose and principles that are essential to avoiding repeating horrors of the past. In this pact for the future, reform has pride of place. Revisionism should have no place at all. At a time of great testing for the multilateral system, that’s an accomplishment we can and we must build on in the years to come. The United States is committed to this collective effort. We know that we’re stronger, we’re better off, we’re more effective when we’re all working together in common purpose. This is what the world needs in this moment, and it needs a strong multilateral system if it is going to meet the goals and aspirations of the people that we all represent. Thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the Secretary of State of the United States. I invite Her Excellency Mette Frederiksen, Prime Minister of Denmark, to address the Assembly.

Mette Frederiksen: Dear colleagues, To give everyone the opportunity to live good lives in freedom and in dignity, that is our most noble task, a task that can only be achieved if we truly commit ourselves to work together. Right now, we see brutal and tragic wars around the world, in Africa, in the Middle East and in Europe. And as a world community, we are faced with human disasters – poverty, hunger, climate change. If we do nothing, it will only get worse. The decisions we make today will define the future for generations to come. This is why the Pact for the Future is such an important step forward for the United Nations. Thank you, Namibia and Germany, for your lead for the Pact, and for the commitment of Secretary General Guterres. It has not always been easy, but it has been a great example of successful cooperation. The negotiations have focused on concrete and action-orientated results, with the necessary willingness to find workable compromises. It is truly significant that we have been able to adopt the Pact by consensus. We need a global system that is far more equal, that promotes solidarity and fair representation for a future with more equality. Where we ensure fair representation, especially of the African countries, we have discussed this for decades. Now it is time to make it happen. We must also face a truth that can be a bit difficult for all of us, that our current international financial system is outdated. Right now it cannot respond to the challenges we face. Old patterns and power structures stand in the way of the necessary progress. We have to reform to make it fair, to make it just and more responsive, so that we will be able together to mobilize finance at the scale we need to, when we need to, and invest in sustainable development, education for all kids, health for all human beings, and not least climate solutions. Denmark already gives a good contribution to the International Development Association, and I am proud today to announce that we intend to increase it with 40 percent. Next year, Denmark will join the UN Security Council. We know that it is a huge responsibility. We will do our very best to ensure implementation of the pact, and we look forward to work with all other members to promote, hopefully, a constructive cooperation and push for a more accountable, effective, and representative Security Council. Dear colleagues, I think we stand at the crossroads. It is what we do that really matters now. We need to set a better course for our world, to make it more more fair and to make it more just, so all people all over the world have the opportunity to live good lives in freedom and in dignity. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the Prime Minister of Denmark. I now give the floor to His Excellency Jean-Noël Barrot, Minister for Europe and Foreign Affairs of France.

Jean Noël Barrot: Mr. President of the General Assembly, Deputy Secretary-General, ladies and gentlemen, heads of state and government, ladies and gentlemen, ministers, ladies and gentlemen, ambassadors, dear colleagues, we are here today to reaffirm our commitment to an ambitious, effective and representative multilateralism to address the challenges of tomorrow. Many of you want to advance our multilateral system, a system founded on respect for the rules of law and clear principles established following the Second World War, founded also on respect for the United Nations Charter, a system based on cooperation among nations, sustainable development for all and solidarity between countries. A system which today must be reformed because global governance must be both more representative and collectively more effective. Everyone has to contribute to this and everyone has to shoulder their share of the responsibility. I thank the Secretary-General for allowing us to make headway on this essential task for future generations, which France firmly and determinedly supports. Mr. Secretary-General, this summit of the future must allow for the achievement of the 2030 Agenda and achieving the Sustainable Development Goals. on schedule. We need to accelerate our efforts to respond to climate challenges. In line with its historic engagement within the United Nations, France has worked to make sure that the Pact for the Future lives up to Member States’ expectations when it comes to reform of the Security Council. We call for an expansion in the two categories of members and a heightened presence of Africa, including among the permanent members. In the same vein, we have a joint initiative with Mexico to limit the veto in the case of mass atrocities, which is already supported by 106 states from every region of the world. France is also innovative in terms of its proposals for reform of the international financial architecture in the spirit of the Paris Pact for Peoples and the Planet, launched by the President of the Republic at the Paris Summit in June 2023. The new Peace Agenda must allow us to modernize the United Nations’ tools for international peace and security. We need to ensure that peace operations, which have changed a great deal, allow us to respond to new challenges. I commend the work of Blue Helmets. Each day, they work for peace and security around the world. I’m thinking of the men and women of UNIFIL in Lebanon and the French contingent there. I’m thinking of the Lebanese people, as Israeli strikes have just killed hundreds of civilians, including dozens of children. These strikes, conducted on both sides of the blue line and in the region more broadly, must immediately end. France once again calls upon the parties and those that support them to de-escalate and avoid a regional conflagration that would be devastating for everyone, first and foremost the civilian population. For that reason, I have asked for an emergency meeting of the Security Council on Lebanon this week. remain fully mobilized to resolve major crises that are disrupting the international agenda. France will take initiatives and will continue to condemn Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine and demand peace in respect of the law. We’ll continue to demand the release of all hostages respect for international humanitarian law and a ceasefire in Gaza. France considers that all human lives are equal in dignity. France will never turn its gaze away from any armed conflict and will continue its initiatives to support Sudan together with its partners. Mr. Secretary General, Deputy Secretary General, you’ve asked us to look to the future, and this future will be marked by great progress in the digital sphere, first and foremost in artificial intelligence. The Global Digital Compact records the commitment of all of the international community to coordinate on these new challenges. The digital revolution should not further increase the digital divide and must serve the Sustainable Development Goals. This priority will be at the heart of the Artificial Intelligence Action Summit which will take place in France on the 10th and 11th of February. The fight against climate change and for the protection of the environment is not a subject of the future, but rather a challenge of the present. The climate threat is running rampant and inaction and a lack of ambition are at fault here. We owe our populations determined, tangible, immediate and effective action. It is with this in mind that the President of the French Republic, the President of Kazakhstan and the President of the World Bank will this year co-organize the One Water Summit. Thank you.

Chair: I thank His Excellency Jean-Noël Barrot, Minister for Europe and Foreign Affairs of France. I now give the floor to His Excellency, Rexon Ramufafia, Minister for National Planning and Development, Coordination of the Solomon Islands.

Rexon Ramufafia: Mr. President, on behalf of the people and the government of Solomon Island, I am honored to address this forum. This summit is confined against the background of SDG. Progress is prevailed. The multilateralism and the international financial architecture being out of touch for our global realities. Mr. President, Solomon Island has a relatively small and open economy, which makes us highly susceptible to excess shocks. Our dispersed economic geography tightens the cost of connecting and bringing service to our people. So has the cost of domestic and international trade. We are also challenged with doing this burden of communicable and non-communicable disease. Mr. President, in July this year, Solomon Island reported through our second voluntary report that we are off track against the SDG, as well as the objectives of our national development strategy. This undercuts the importance of our decision yesterday on the path of the future. Mr. President, partnership and collaboration are indispensable to our development. However, we also recognize that we need meaningful partnership. Mr. President, climate change remains a dividing issue for Solomon Island and the Pacific region. It is an external crisis that is already impacting us. Our ecosystem and ocean economy are at risk from climate change. Weather extremes driven by climate change are already causing fatality and impacting our infrastructure, economic development, and indigenous culture. Mr. President, for those of us at the front line of climate change and sea level rise, it is frustrating to experience that climate finance is still being mobilized in modality with conditions that are not matched with the climate change emergency we are confronting. We recognize that the future of our world will be increasingly saved by technology and digital transformation. The Global Digital Pact offers the opportunity to bridge digital gaps and ensure that no one is left behind in the digital age. Mr. President, my country’s access to affordable digital technology is still limited. Despite recent efforts, including the expansion of our telecommunication network and the use of digital technology for financial inclusion, Solomon Islands launched its first-ever national cyber policy last month, a positive step for digital technology governance. We cannot ignore the urgent need for a peaceful and secure world. We are deeply committed to global peace, rule-based multilateralism, and principles of the United Nations Charter. However, the UN system must be reformed to reflect and respond effectively to the realities we face on the ground. Global cooperation and diplomacy are pathways to a peaceful resolution of conflict. Mr. President, as we talk about the future, we must remember that it belongs to our youth and future generations to come. Over 60 percent of Solomon Island’s population is under the age of 30. Our huge people are full of potential, but they face immense challenges, including impact of climate change. We are invigorating efforts to empower youth through human development and economic transformation. In conclusion, Mr. President, let us move forward with a sense of shared responsibility, ambition, and commitment to the path of the future. Let us choose future of prosperity for all, and resilience and peace. I thank you all.

Chair: I thank the Minister for National Planning and Development, Coordination of the Solomon Islands. I now give the floor to His Excellency Elmer Schialer Salcedo, Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Peru.

Elmer Schialer Salcedo: Mr. President, I bring the respectful greetings of the President of Peru, Dina Boluate Segar, who would have liked to be in this great assembly with us today. Mr. President, we stand at a time of profound global transformation, and we are living through times marked by unprecedented challenges which call on us to work together to forge a fairer and more sustainable future for all. What we need is clear to all of us, that is, new global governance which is more inclusive and equitable. In light of this, Peru has been working hard to reduce social divides and to include sectors of the population that have historically been left behind. This objective is to ensure that all of us are working together to achieve It includes higher ambitions in our national and collective action, as well as financial commitments that are sustainable on the part of the international community, that enable appropriate resources for developing countries. An important outcome from this summit is the commitment to begin an intergovernmental process for the adoption of multidimensional indicators, poverty indicators and progress indicators that go beyond measuring the progress made by countries and their consequent needs in cooperation and finance, beyond the cold figures of their GNI. Therefore I welcome the establishment of a high-level group which will be working on developing these new indicators. We trust that this work will be essential to best channel, in the most inclusive way, international cooperation, including middle-income countries, in which we continue to see pockets of poverty and exclusion. We also welcome the fact that during this summit of the future we are addressing emerging challenges for future generations, such as digitalization and artificial intelligence. Peru believes that it is crucial to build a global governance system that promotes the transfer of knowledge and technology and establishes parameters for the correct use of artificial intelligence. President, Peru understands the Pact for the Future as a tool that must respect the sovereignty of states and that further must promote cooperation based on solidarity, mutual respect. and equity. For us, this pact is not and will never be an imposition nor an agenda which erodes our traditions or our domestic legal order. Rather, we see it as a platform that allows us to work together with other nations to address the challenges that we share, such as combating poverty, protecting the environment and ensuring a fairer and more equitable global economic order for developing countries. In essence, it is an appeal to build a future in which sustainable development, peace and prosperity are accessible to all, without implying giving up our identity, values or our autonomy as a nation. Thank you very much, President.

Chair: I thank the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Peru. I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Minister of Foreign Affairs and State and Foreign Affairs of Portugal, His Excellency Paulo Rangel.

Paulo Rangel: Excellencies, it is with hope and responsibility that I assume the word in this summit of the future in representation of Portugal as well as of the first Prime Minister of Portugal that cannot be here today due to the terrible fires that have made our country in a tragedy for the last few days. We are here for the future of the world, for the future of our nations. These completely uncontrollable fires are connected to the climate changes, to the sustainable development, to the planning of cities. This city shows well the reason why the Secretary General of the United Nations, when he presented our common agenda and launched an ambitious process to reconstruct and rebuild the trust in a multilateral efficient system focused and centered on the United Nations. Aligned with this ambitious and broad initiative of a more efficient multilateralism, Portugal participated effectively and actively on the negotiations for the Pact for the Future, the Global Pact for the Future, Digital Global Pact, in a clear expression of our determination in promoting peace, sustainable development, and respect for human rights. Peace and international security start with the guarantee that each person in each corner of the world has the opportunity to have a life with dignity in a sustainable planet and a prosperous planet. The commitment of Portugal with this multilateral agenda is not something new. In peace, security, education, health, dignified employment, we also have been committed to seek collective solutions for all. We will maintain this ambition for the next year’s summit, Global Summit, to increase the partnerships that increase the resilience of the global challenges, investing in preventing and prospective capacity, to supporting the good governance of the world, the digital world, the external space promoting innovation, and the responsible… use of science and the digital transformation. Portugal is a country deeply connected to the sea, and we recognize the vital role of the oceans in the global economy and in the fight against the climate change, because we support effervescently a sustainable management that aims at the next ocean conference side by side with our partners, in particular with small island states in development, the SIDS. We are committed to reforming the global governance, including the international financial architecture. We are still committed towards this goal as an invited country by the G20 Brazilian presidency, which call to action. We subscribe, and we have the fourth international conference about development, which preparatory process is co-presided by Portugal and Burundi. Ladies and gentlemen, in the beginning of the summit, we celebrate the International Day of Peace. And it was precisely to maintain and promote peace and security that we created the United Nations. It is also one of these goals for the future to which we commit, including towards our candidacy to the Security Council for 2027-2028. We live in a world of geopolitical crisis that affect the confidence of the citizens in multilateralism, not forgetting the ones who live in Gaza, Sudan, the conflicts of Sahel, inequality, gender violence, and in the terrible impacts of climate change. What’s happening in the Pacific Islands and Caribbean islands, the forest fires also in Portugal and so. many other parts of the world. The challenges that we face today do not know borders and deserve a pact for the future. It is now up to each country, each leader, each one of us, to choose the path for the future. Portugal chooses the collective action path, and collective action, multilateralism, peace dialogue, and wavering commitment to a future for all. Thank you.

Chair: President Khawaja Muhammad Asif, Federal Minister for Defense of Pakistan

Khawaja Muhammad Asif: Bismillah ar-Rahman ar-Rahim Mr. President, let me state at the outset that no sustainable development can take place until tragedies like Gaza are perpetuated by the developed world. Mr. President, the adoption of the Pact of the Future is an expression of our collective determination to respond to the global challenges of security and development that threaten the present and future generations. For the over 100 developing countries, the Pact offers an opportunity to revitalize development and to reform our society. unequal international financial economic system. The pact will be transformative only if we translate the commitments undertaken into concrete actions. To bridge the $4 trillion SDG financing gap, we must fulfill the longstanding ODA commitments, and the Secretary General’s SDG stimulus proposal, rechannel 50% of the unused 2021 allocation of SDRs, deliver a bigger, better, and more ambitious IDA by ensuring a robust $100 billion replenishment in December this year, enlarge lending by the multilateral development banks, and lower borrowing costs of developing countries, improve the representation of developing countries in international financial institutions, review the sovereign debt architecture to make it more equitable, adopt an equitable international tax regime, and reform the WTO to serve as a vehicle for export expansion and development through preferential treatment for developing countries and avoidance of new environmental protectionism. The UN, by virtue of its universal membership and mandate, remains an indispensable platform to propel and monitor implementation of these commitments. Excellencies, bridging the digital divide is key for an equitable future. future. Pakistan welcomes the outcome of global digital compact in this regard. We must bridge the north-south divide and prevent an east-west fragmentation of the digital space. We must ensure equitable data governance, and we must capture and control the power of artificial intelligence. Thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the Federal Minister for Defence of Pakistan. I now give the floor to His Excellency Bakari Badjie, Minister of Youth and Sport of Gambia.

Bakari Badjie: Mr. President, distinguished delegates and participants, The Government of the Gambia expresses sincere gratitude to the United Nations Secretary-General for convening this significant summit, which aims to foster sustainable multilateral solutions to advance the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and beyond. We also extend deep appreciation to the co-facilitators from Namibia and Germany for their tireless efforts in facilitating the negotiation process, an invaluable contribution to the preparation and execution of this summit. The summit of the future demonstrates our collective will to strengthen multilateralism as it presents a significant opportunity to reaffirm our commitment to addressing shared global challenges as we engage in discussions on enhancing multilateralism and transforming global governance in the coming days. Let us accelerate our commitment to reinforcing our sacred multilateral principles of upholding human rights. – sustaining peace and driving sustainable development. Solidarity and respect for human dignity must underpin our collective action and commitments at all levels, be it regional or global. These are, and should remain, the bedrock of our efforts. The theme, Multilateral Solution for a Better Tomorrow, is both timely and relevant. It is particularly relevant at the critical moment when the world, especially the Global South, is grappling with persistent existential challenges, including escalating regional tension and instability such as the ongoing crisis in Ukraine, Palestine, and the Sahel region, after increased displacement of people, particularly women and children, thereby further depressing the economies of the developing countries. Mr. President, as a developing country, The Gambia is deeply concerned about the disproportionate impact of global challenges on small countries, especially the negative socio-economic dimension of the COVID-19 and the recovery efforts, increasing climate vulnerabilities, food insecurity, poverty, and emerging health threats, which continue to exacerbate existing inequalities, pushing millions further into poverty. Majority within this poverty bracket are women, who continue to face considerable barriers to education, economic resources, and deeply entrenched gender norms, hindering their participation in the workforce and decision-making process. These challenges have stalled progress on the SDGs and the 2030 Agenda, with the deadline looming and many targets unmet. We urgently need bold actions, comprehensive solutions, and significant resources to tackle these pressing global issues. Youths continue to face structural shortage of decent employment opportunities compounded by global economic uncertainty, making it challenging for government to tap into their potential. In our collective response to these complex challenges, the need for multilateral cooperation with a holistic approach built on dialogue, common understanding, solidarity, and shared responsibility are essential for safeguarding global stability and ensuring that the SDGs are achievable within this decade. In this regard, the Government of The Gambia, with the support of the United Nations, organized a two-day national youth consultation to prepare a position paper and select young delegates to attend the summit. During these consultations, young people from all over the country demanded and asked for our government to champion for the restructuring of the international financial system to better address their needs. They advocate for increased access to climate funding, the development of technical skills for climate innovation, and robust measures. The young people have also asked that they become participants in the decision-making at the political level as well as at the international level. Mr. President, The Gambia fully welcomes the adoption of the Park of the Future, recognizing it as a commitment to actionable solutions that place the further generation at the core of our concern. We reaffirm our commitment to strengthen international cooperation to ensure that the goals of this summit are realized and built upon for a better future. I thank you, Excellency, and thank you all.

Chair: I thank the Minister of Youth and Sport of The Gambia. I now give the floor to Her Excellency Adriana Mira, Vice President of Foreign Affairs of El Salvador.

Adriana Mira: Thank you very much, Mr. President, honorable heads of delegations, friends. El Salvador acknowledges enthusiastically the importance of this summit for the future, which is a milestone in the history of our international community. The instruments that we have negotiated to arrive at this summit represent a great opportunity to promote greater international cooperation and revitalize multilateralism that will lead to future discussions that will allow us to go beyond agreements towards true mechanisms and sectoral actions to support the development of all. We hope that the entire world will welcome the outcome of this summit with hope, especially at a time when developing countries require access to greater financing and resources to confront global challenges to which we face. This meeting also is an opportunity to increase trust and solidarity among countries. The current multilateral system will continue to regress if we allow the objectives and the power of the few to prevail over the rules established for the benefit of all. El Salvador is not alone. Many of the countries of the Global South are raising their voices with greater force and are offering their visions of development based on their own reality. During the negotiations of the Pact for the Future, El Salvador reiterated the urgent need to reform the Security Council so that it is transformed into a more representative, democratic, legitimate, effective, and transparent organ, an organ that allows for the participation of more countries, which today are underrepresented in this forum, in which important decisions are taken for the maintenance of international peace and security. Present generations are increasingly concerned by the problems that affect their daily lives and make it more difficult to think about the future. This discussion compels us to ask whether the actions that we are taking are necessary to build a future that our people truly need. I am proud to say that the government of El Salvador, under the vision of President Nayib Bukele, has restored hope as it has become the safest country in the Western Hemisphere. For Salvador, security was the premise that was necessary to restore our faith in our future. And while we are not neglecting to sustain that achievement, now we can prioritize actions that address economic growth, investment, and participation in international trade. The international environment forces us to invest and design policies geared towards technological technology, adaptation to climate change, and the transition towards green energy, aware of the potential of technological innovation. El Salvador has taken important steps to transform the country in the technological hub of the region by implementing policies of digital governance and enacting legal instruments to better take advantage of technologies and investment flows. My country is laying the groundwork to achieve the goal of a digital future that is inclusive, open, just, and secure. We have a commitment to eliminating the digital divide by increasing levels of connectivity and access to the internet. Our partnership with Google and the inauguration of the first commercial data center rated Tier 3 in El Salvador is a reflection of the commitment of the government to the appropriate use of technological innovation. The seeds that we are sowing today through these instruments promise a better future for all, and especially for young people and future generations. During the event called Imagining the Future, Jobs youth and opportunities promoted by the United Nations system and organized in my country, we reached the conclusion that it is fundamental to heed the voice of young people and generate opportunities for dialogue that allow us to connect with their perspectives so that within our respective agendas we can take concrete action for our young people. We trust that through the coordinated efforts of the United Nations country team and other strategic partners for development, we will continue investing in our youth. In conclusion, I would like to express the commitment of El Salvador to advance in implementing the outcomes of this summit with the hope that together we will achieve the goals that together we identified today for a better future. Thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the Vice Minister of Foreign Affairs of El Salvador. I now give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the International Criminal Police Organization.

INTERPOL: Mr. President, it is my great honor to address the General Assembly at this esteemed gathering of the United Nations Summit of the Future. This summit represents a moment of reflection and a moment of action as we reaffirm our commitment to building a resilient, equitable, and safer world. In an era marked by profound changes, from rapid technological advancements to environmental crisis, global security and sustainable development are inherently linked. Singapore recognizes the crucial role that law enforcement plays in ensuring the security and the prosperity of communities around the world. By securing the streets, police strengthen the foundations for development. By protecting communities, police empower them to reach further. This is why Interpol launched the Global Policing Goals back in 2017. These offer a blueprint for law enforcement to advance Agenda 2030 in complementarity to the UN Sustainable Development Goals. Later this year, the UN General Assembly will also seek to adopt the fourth review of its resolution on the cooperation between Interpol and the UN. Through previous reviews, the international community reinforced this complementarity and affirmed Interpol’s position as a key implementing partner. In achieving the objectives of the SDGs, we must also recognize that no country and no organization can act on its own. Criminal networks are being built around the world. Ties are being created. Actions coordinated. To counter them, we need to be more innovative and more agile. As Interpol Secretary General, it is my conviction that a safer future hinges on a single, strong global architecture of security. One that avoids silos and duplication. One that ensures inclusivity of information, of networks, and of access to technology. And one that prevents gaps and loss of critical information. Interpol stands ready to continue building this with Member States, regional, and global partners. Excellency, this summit calls on us to build opportunities for tomorrow’s generations. Founded on multilateralism and a strong, integrated security system. To fulfill this mission, we must restore and maintain trust in the institutions designed to protect peace, security, and prosperity. This means evolving our approaches to address emerging challenges responsibly, ethically, and with integrity in making the world a safer place. I thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the distinguished representative of the International Criminal Police Organization. I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance.

International Institute for Democracy & Electoral Assistance: Mr. President, Mr. Secretary General, Excellencies, I stand before you as Secretary General of International IDEA to speak on the future of our planet and the pact we need to make it viable. For me, the future has faces. I have two children, Annalena and Simon, ages 15 and 12. The pact we have forged here is about the world we will bequeath them. I want them to live in a world where women are not second-class citizens anywhere, where they don’t have to wait on current trends, 46 years to achieve equal representation in parliaments, and many more to sit as equal partners in boardrooms. If this pact does not advance this human right, which is the best opportunity for our future, we are wasting our time. I want them to live in a world that no longer accepts that 81 people own as much wealth as 50 percent of humanity combined. If this pact does not open the door to a the mental reform of capitalism to make it fairer so that our political processes and the possibility of a sustainable future are not captured by the obscenely rich, we are wasting our time. I want them to live in a world where nations are truly able to collaborate to solve the great problems of our time. If this pact does not help us to bring international governance structures closer to the realities of power in the world, starting with the UN Security Council, we are wasting our time. I want them to live in a world that cherishes democracy as one of the pinnacles of the human journey. And I use the word democracy deliberately. Not governance, not institutions, not all the euphemisms that many governments use to disguise simple truths. That democracy is the only political system that fully respects the UN Covenants on Civil and Political Rights and Social and Economic Rights, which nearly every country present here has signed up to. That democracy is the best defense against the emergence of the killing fields in Ukraine and the Middle East, in Sudan and Myanmar, and hence protects global peace. If this pact does not advance democracy, we are wasting our time. Mr. President, the British writer Aldous Huxley once asked if the world was another planet’s hell. I do not know. What I do know is that we have the obligation not to turn it into hell for Annalena and Simon’s generation. This pact may be our best chance.

Chair: to the distinguished representative of the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization.

United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization: Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, the Summit of the Future is a call to build more just, prosperous, and peaceful societies. To meet this challenge of sustainable development, UNESCO’s mandate is focused on education, science, and culture, and it is essential. This was just recalled by the compact Pact for the Future that has just been adopted. First, there can be no viable future where more than 250 million people are still deprived of the fundamental right of education. As the Pact for the Future reaffirms, we must carry out in-depth reforms in line with the work already carried out by UNESCO to achieve universal access to education, in particular for girls. Strengthening teacher training and access to digital learning technology is also essential. UNESCO is convinced that, sustainably, reducing inequalities also requires innovation and knowledge, and yet we are all aware of the gap that remains in the world in this sense. That is why it is essential that the Pact for the Future enshrines the need to promote international scientific cooperation in line with UNESCO’s recommendations on open science. Thus, we will promote the transfer of technologies and making sure that all talents can flourish and that risks are managed responsibly. And finally, culture. In all of its diverse expressions, it is our global common good that is one of the most powerful. The preservation of world heritage is a… vibrant example of this. These World Heritage Sites not only testify to the richness of human history and the beauty of nature, but preserving them is also essential for local populations that are exposed to the risks of climate change, illicit trafficking, and pressure of tourism. Our organization also stands by creators and all culture professionals who, through their talents and imaginations, bring us together and create millions of jobs, which is a powerful driver for inclusion for youth and women in particular. Article 11 of the Pact for the Future recognizes this crucial role played by culture in our societies, a role of bringing people together, of ensuring well-being, which must play its rightful role in public policies. This is a major step forward today. Together, but we can go even further by ensuring that culture is finally subject to its own goal of the post-2030 development agenda, which has yet to be built. Only culture can open up peoples to one another while nourishing the best among us all. Thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the distinguished representative of the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization and give the floor to the distinguished representative of the International Atomic Energy Agency.

International Atomic Energy Agency: Thank you very much, Mr. President. Mr. President, somebody said that to predict the future we should build it, and this is what is happening now with the adoption of the Pact of the Future and the recommitment to the goals that it entails. The IAEA, an institution born from an idea pronounced from this same rostrum of 70 years ago, is doing just that, together with you. It is doing that by underpinning the non-proliferation of nuclear weapons regime, which prevents thousands of nuclear material, which is used all over the world to be diverted for hostile uses. It is doing so by preventing that more states add nuclear weapons to those that already exist. It is doing so by preventing, by deploying in a war zone that a nuclear accident with terrible radiological consequences adds to the misery of our ongoing war. But importantly, it is also doing that through its programs like Race of Hope, which is bringing oncology and nuclear medicine to places that do not have a single radiotherapy unit. It is doing so in places where food is scarce through the Atoms for Food project. It is doing that by protecting the environment through its nuclear techniques against plastic pollution and protecting the oceans from ocean acidification and other problems like this. It is doing that in all these ways. The world and the pact that you just adopted, importantly, needs instruments, concrete instruments to materialize those goals, including in energy, which through clean nuclear energy is allowing more and more states reach economic development without harming the environment. The IAEA is just that. It’s an instrument. of all the lofty goals and ideas that have been adopted here. And the IAEA will continue doing just that. Thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the distinguished representative of the International Atomic Energy Agency and give the floor to the Joint UN Program on HIV-AIDS.

Joint UN Program on HIV-AIDS: Your Excellency, President of the General Assembly, Excellencies, distinguished delegates, we gather at a time when global crises threaten to overwhelm us. But we need not despair. I come to you with a proven path, a path through which the world can overcome all challenges. Over 25 years ago, governments came together with civil society, with the private sector, with the philanthropists, here at the United Nations, to fight a disease, HIV-AIDS. They set up institutions such as the United Nations Joint Program on HIV-AIDS. That is a program I lead. They set up a fund, the Global Fund. They set targets and they worked together, collaborated, to fight a disease. Today, almost 30… 21 million people living with HIV around the world are on treatment and living healthy lives. The AIDS response defines the path to success, a path of multilateralism. Key elements of this success are, first, shared responsibility and global solidarity. No single country or entity can ever solve global problems. Second, ensuring that the benefits of scientific innovation are shared by all countries. Third, putting human rights at the heart of all plans, ensuring that the vulnerable, marginalized people are reached first, and that there is no stigma and discrimination fighting that. Fourth, sharing financial resources. Today, we face the challenge that the most vulnerable countries to HIV AIDS with the highest burden are being choked by debt. The issue of restructuring debt is critical today. Resources should be shared. Lastly, the example of the HIV response, the coming together of countries, should inspire us to reaffirm our commitment to multilateralism. We have done it before. In 25 years, we fought this disease.

Chair: the Red Cross.

The International Comittee of the Red Cross: Thank you, Mr. President. Mr. President, yesterday, leaders of the world adopted the Pact for the Future. The ICRC is with you when you say in that pact that fellow human beings are enduring terrible suffering. We are also with you when you warn us of rising catastrophic and existential risks, many caused by the choices we make. However, you are also right when you say that there is a path to a brighter future for all of humanity. That your formula for this brighter future includes international cooperation, based on respect for international law, resonates loudly with the International Committee of the Red Cross. This year, we mark the 75th anniversary of the 1949 Geneva Conventions, which regulate how wars are to be fought. Every state in this General Assembly has committed to respect and to ensure respect for these rules both in word and in deed. We are with you in Pact Action No. 14. We will protect all civilians in armed conflict. International humanitarian law requires that fighting parties only attack military targets, take all precautions to minimize harm to civilians, and then actually do so. We encourage all states here today to use their influence to speak to warring parties directly to make sure that this happens. Last year, hundreds of thousands of civilians were killed or suffered appalling injuries, many as victims of deliberate or indiscriminate attacks. We can and must do better. We are also with you in action number 15. We will ensure people affected by humanitarian emergencies receive the support they need. The rules for humanitarian assistance are set out in IHL. Parties to armed conflict must allow and facilitate passage of humanitarian relief. However, we are faced with a compelling reality. Millions of people in war zones are left out of basic humanitarian support due to a lack of humanitarian presence. Destruction of basic infrastructure could be avoided if attacks were restrained and based on proportionality and distinction. The reality of today is that the compounding effects of destruction, disinvestment and abandonment are leading to unbearable costs for generations to come. We can and must do better. The path to a brighter future for humanity is available to us, you have said. In war, that path is lit by the Geneva Conventions. At the ICRC, we offer our hand to you along this path and we ask, let’s walk it together. Thank you, Mr. President.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the International Committee of the Red Cross and give the floor to the League of Arab States.

League of Arab States: Thank you, Mr. President. We are writing the future today. Every decision that we adopt, the path that we’re taking, will have an impact on future generations. This summit must deliver a strong message that is that future generations deserve to live in a world free of conflict, from hunger, absolute poverty, and extreme threats. These are interdependent challenges. Their intersection means that multilateralism and joint international action is essential. Indeed, urgent action is needed to counter global warming, climate change, the gaps between the rich and the developing world, especially in terms of climate financing and sharing of the benefits of climate adaptation in a fair way, the debt crisis and the challenges of new technologies, especially artificial intelligence. All these challenges can only be addressed through multilateralism and by a global organization. In spite of all these challenges, I am convinced that the essential duty of this universal organization is maintaining international peace and security. The other objectives will be difficult to achieve in a world of conflict and fear. We must acknowledge that sources of tension have expanded, efforts at solutions have stagnated. Competition among major powers does not benefit a universal organization. This competition throws us back to a period of paralysis. Everyone now is convinced that the Security Council, in its current configuration, no longer reflects. The world does not serve multilateralism in an effective way, where action can be taken on conflicts. Another example, if you look at the conflict in Gaza, the aggression of Israel. against Gaza has continued for many months. There have been massacres, killings, destruction, hunger and displacement without the Security Council being able to adopt any resolutions. At last, a resolution was adopted, but unfortunately, the Security Council could not implement it. Today, it’s the turn of Lebanon, the international community and the international organization must work to save the situation otherwise, to restore it. Otherwise, the conflict will expand and it will endanger peace and security. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the distinguished representative of the League of Arab States, and I’ll give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United Nations Human Settlements Program.

Un Habitat: Excellencies, I’m honored to address you in this plenary of the Summit of the Future on behalf of UNHCR and the new urban agenda that UNHCR is mandated to lead. The new urban agenda is a shared vision of the United Nations for a better and more sustainable future. As we commence on planning for the implementation of the Pact for the Future, UNHCR encourages the member states to recall that it is in our cities and towns where two-thirds of the people in the world are projected to leave by 2050. This shift towards urbanization is driven by various factors, including economic opportunities, better access to services, and increasingly by involuntary displacement, disasters, and conflicts. Combined with the overall growth of the world’s population, this could add another half a billion million people to cities every five years. Against this projection, UNHCR stands ready to support member states in the commitment of the Pact for the Future to ensure access for all to adequate, safe and affordable housing and support developing countries to plan and implement just, safe, healthy, accessible, resilient and sustainable cities, as well as commitments in support of access to sustainable essential services in cities and the integration of disaster risk reduction into policies and programs. Well-planned urban infrastructure, housing and services can transform the lives of people in cities towards more sustainable and resilient. Sustainable urban development, steered by inclusive, resourced local and regional authorities and with participation of the young people in cities, will also provide the foundation for long-term stability, security and peace building of societies by leaving no one and no place behind. In well-planned cities, climate and disaster risks can also be effectively managed, assisted by digital technologies. To achieve this, UNHCR and the UN members of the Local 2030 Coalition encourage the member states to also seek for means to more closely engage with local and regional governments, as recommended by the Pact for the Future, to increase the opportunity to transition to sustainable development paths by 2030. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the distinguished representative of UN-Habitat and give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean.

Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean: Mr. President, the General Assembly, your Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, the Summit for the Future gives us a unique opportunity to show to the world that it is possible to restore trust in the multilateral system and demonstrate that international and regional cooperation can respond to the huge challenges that we confront and also serve to build a more peaceful, just, productive, inclusive and sustainable future through collective action. The process that led us to the Pact for the Future and the Global Digital Compact and the Declaration for Future Generations has given us important lessons. Beyond the agreements that we reached, the most important added value of these lessons is that it is essential to think about the future, because topics that will be important for the future are already important. It’s important for policies of countries to be fully aware of what kind of future they are building. Unfortunately, as societies, we tend to live in the short term. This is a trend that was aggravated by social gaps, and this replaces analytical thinking. Thinking of the future requires forums to examine this, to analyze it. The Pact for the Future is a major step in the right direction to restore a multilateral system that was designed over 60 years ago and which, as the Secretary General mentioned, requires urgent reforms such as international financial architecture, which is not a commensurate to the challenges of development of today. Topics of peace, security, science, technology, innovation, and digital cooperation, youth and intergenerational solidarity and gender equality are fundamental topics for the world and for Latin America and the Caribbean. With this in mind, one of the priorities of our organization is to contribute to strengthening anticipatory – proactive governance in countries of the region. We are creating parliamentary commissions for the future in our region in order to discuss not only what should be the solutions but how to achieve them. We are discussing prospective policies as well as the possibilities for social dialogue to manage essential transformations. The world and Latin America need and would benefit from a world in peace, from a multilateral system that is strong, a global commercial system regulated by rules focusing on sustainable development to achieve SDGs and make progress on climate change. In the next session of our organization in Peru in October, we will have an opportunity to discuss the implementation of the commitments of the Summit for the Future in Latin America and the Caribbean. Thank you.

Chair: I now invite the representative of the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean and give the floor to the representative of the Interparliamentary Union.

Interparliamentary Union: Mr. President, the pact for the future that is the outcome of this summit does provide a clear path forward to turbo-change the SDGs and to fix a multilateral system that is nearly broken. As President of the Interparliamentary Union, I am here to tell you that you can count on our organization, with a membership of 180 national parliaments, as a trusted partner in the journey ahead. No challenge is too big for those who are determined and willing to work together. IPU welcomes the strong acknowledgement of the role of Parliaments at the United Nations provided in Action 55 of the Pact. This action line stresses the need to deepen the relationship between the United Nations and Parliaments, and welcomes the contribution of Parliaments through the IPU in supporting the implementation of United Nations Agreements. We will have an opportunity to get into the fine details of this relationship during this 79th session of the General Assembly under the item Interaction between the United Nations, National Parliaments and the IPU. We look forward to working with Member States to find more concrete ways to engage Parliaments in the work of the United Nations so that they are more aware of the discussions taking place here, and more capacitated to provide input through their governments as well as the IPU. In the quarter century since the Millennium Declaration, the relationship between the United Nations and Parliaments has grown steadily, year after year, never losing sight of its final aim, which is to make the United Nations more open, more accountable, and more able to deliver on its commitment. We are committed to strengthening that relationship. Today, most major United Nations meetings take place with at least some parliamentary components. As it was once said by the founding father of Tanzania, Mwalem Julius Kambarage Nyerere, it can be done. Play your part. We at the IPU are doing our part to make the United Nations and multilateralism stronger through Parliaments. We all need to scale up and be ready to seize the opportunity for improvement whenever it arises. People everywhere expect change. This is the time, this is the place to make that happen. I thank you.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the Inter-Parliamentary Union and give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the International Fund for Agricultural Development.

International Fund for Agricultural Development: Excellencies, Distinguished Delegates, IFAD, the International Fund for Agricultural Development, welcomes and supports the outcome of the Summit of the Future. And today I want to reconfirm our commitment to ensure leaving no one behind. In just seven decades, from the creation of the United Nations to 2020, we witnessed a remarkable progress. The prevalence of hunger dropped from two-thirds of the world’s population to less than one in ten. But for some years now, progress has stalled. Unless we take urgent and drastic action, as many as 600 million people will remain chronically undernourished by 2030. Let us recall the simple commitment at the heart of the 2030 Agenda. We will leave no one behind. This also includes the 3.4 billion people living in rural areas. Most rural people in the world depend on small farms for their livelihood. Half of our food comes from these small farms. Yet, hunger and poverty remain concentrated in the rural areas. Rural communities are the stewards of our land and of our water. In our fight against hunger, poverty and climate change, they must also be part of our first line of action. scale up the investments in these rural areas where poverty is concentrated. And we need more than just the financing. We need investments that are targeted and that are effective. We need especially to reach the people and the countries that are most in need. Today, less than one-third of development finance for food systems reaches the least developed countries. Equally concerning, less than one percent of climate finance reaches the small farm holders who are at the forefront of our fight against climate change. Looking ahead to next year’s International Conference on Financing for Development, we need targeted investments that respond to individual countries’ realities and that drive long-term sustainable impact. This will require an increase in concessional resources, especially for the poorest and most indebted countries, as well as catalyzing private sector investments. IFAD is the only United Nations specialized agency, an international financial institution, with a clear mandate to invest in rural people. And we stand ready to play our part. Thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the distinguished representative of the International Fund for Agricultural Development. And I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of l’Organisation Internationale de la Francophonie.

International Organisation of la Francophonie: Mr. President, Excellencies, I have the honor to speak on behalf of Her Excellency Madame Louise Mushikiwabo, Secretary General of la Francophonie, and to convey her warmest congratulations on the holding of the Summit of the Future and the adoption of the Pact for the Future, the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration on Future Generations. With its 88 member states and governments, l’Organisation Internationale de la Francophonie National de la Francophonie has appreciated the inclusivity of this process. We have had the opportunity to prevent our organization’s vision and contributions through our Secretary General, the group of Francophone ambassadors, and our experts. La Francophonie is constantly working for a reinvigorated multilateralism. To achieve this, it has urged the international community to reestablish the values to which our movement is so deeply attached – solidarity, equity, and full respect for diversity. That is the purpose of the advocacy that we have undertaken to ensure due consideration for cultural and linguistic diversity in the Global Digital Compact, which is the first instrument of global scope to enshrine the principles that will govern the digital space of tomorrow. That is also the thrust of our call for a reform of access to concessional financing for development that would take into account all dimensions of vulnerability – economic, social, and environmental. Driven by our duty of solidarity, we must now pursue our advocacy with international financial institutions. The next steps will be essential to make development opportunities both more equal and more sustainable. That is also the goal of the contribution that we have presented on the issues of peace and security in the context of the new Agenda for Peace. La Francophonie in the area of peacekeeping advocates for giving due consideration to multilingualism and intercultural skills, which are drivers of effectiveness in the implementation of the complex mandates of peacekeeping operations. Finally, La Francophonie welcomes the consensus that was reached on the need to honor, preserve, and promote cultural and linguistic diversity to benefit future generations. We are also pleased that the Pact for the Future provides for actions aimed at protecting and promoting culture as an integral component of sustainable development. On October 4th and 5th, La Francophonie will hold its 19th Annual Conference. Summit of Heads of State and Government in France at Villers-Cotterêts and in Paris on the topic of creation, innovation, and entrepreneurship in French. It will focus on the common efforts that we must undertake in order to achieve a renewed multilateralism. Our vast Francophone community will ensure that the outcomes of this Summit of the Future bear fruit. By drawing from our common language, French, a lever for sincere listening and dialogue which we so need, we will continue to play our full role in the development of a culture of peace. Merci.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of l’Organisation Internationale de la Francophonie. And I give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the Cooperation Council for the Arab States of the Gulf.

Cooperation Council for the Arab States of the Gulf: Mr. President, I convey my greetings and would like to begin by highlighting the importance of the Summit of the Future, which brings us here today, as well as the urgent need for such a summit at this time. We are facing an opportunity to reaffirm common principles and strengthen international cooperation to address current challenges through effective multilateral action for peace, especially given that global challenges are having an impact on sustainable development at the global level. With this in mind, I would like to share briefly the GCC’s position on the Pact for the Future. International indicators point to a slowdown in the implementation of the SDGs. More than 30 percent of them have not made progress. progress, the Gulf Cooperation Council has prioritized sustainable development through the national visions of its member states, which reflect a commitment towards the 2030 Agenda Sustainable for Development and the Paris Agreement and the Addis Ababa Action Plan. Today, GCC member states are convinced of the importance of partnerships in the context of development, and the Council plays an important role in more than 90 countries across the world. I am proud as a citizen of the Gulf of the role that Gulf states play in the implementation of SDGs in a number of countries across the world. The Council reaffirms the importance of the principles of strengthening peace as reflected in the Pact for the Future, with a focus on international law, resolving disputes through peaceful means, and seeking a solution to the issue of Palestine that is in line with the Arab Peace Initiative and international law. We must also strengthen the international order to benefit future generations. As Antonio Guterres has said, we cannot build our future based on a system built for our grandparents. We must therefore pool efforts in order to ensure that needs of future generations are met in all areas. The GCC stands ready to make its contribution to this effort. I also reaffirm the vision that we share and which is in line with the pact for the future. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the Cooperation Council for the Arab States of the Gulf, and I give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the United Nations Population Fund.

United Nations Population Fund: Mr. President of the General Assembly, Excellencies, Distinguished Delegates, I greet you in peace so desperately needed in our turbulent world. The United Nations Population Fund stands with you to forge a path to a better, more sustainable future of peace and prosperity for all. Demographic shifts, population growth, aging, migration are reshaping our world and our future. In an ever-changing world of 8 billion, our focus must be on people. This means ensuring that population dynamics are factored into development plans with an emphasis on right choices, dignity, and equality. It means investing in human capital, in health, education, and the empowerment of women and young people. We know this yields significant returns with ripple effect across generations. Our commitment to individual dignity, right, and choices is the foundation for a resilient and sustainable future. Our 1.9 billion young people have the power to transform our world. Let’s invest in their potential and support their leadership. They have a fundamental right to participate in sustainable development, humanitarian action, and sustaining peace. By leveraging science, data, statistics, combined with strategic foresight, we can ensure that we are thinking about the present and preparing for the future. Let’s embrace and shape the technology. technology that is transforming our world and our work. As we work to bridge the digital divide, our task is to ensure technology fosters empowerment and gender equality, rather than perpetuating violence. Excellencies, three decades on from the groundbreaking International Conference on Population Development in Cairo, and as the end of our ICPD 30 review process draws near, UNFPA remains laser-focused on sustainable human development. This requires rallying new allies, new partners, harnessing innovation, exploring new forms of financing, and embracing the power of technology to advance rights and choices for her and for everyone, in line with the objective of this summit. We congratulate Member States for their consensus on the Pact of the Future, the Declaration of Future Generations, and the Global Digital Compact. This important outcome offers some solution, yet we know much more remains to be done to translate commitment into action. By focusing our effort and strengthening our partnership and investment, we can overcome our common challenges and build a more inclusive, equitable, and sustainable future for all. I thank you for your kind attention.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the United Nations Population Fund and give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the Digital Cooperation Organization.

Digital Cooperation Organization: Mr. President, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, I would like to express my gratitude to Secretary General, His Excellency, António Guterres, and the co-facilitators for their efforts in bringing us to this pivotal moment. It is a privilege to address this Assembly following the historic adoption of the PAC for the Future and also the Global Digital Compact. The GDC lays out a roadmap for an inclusive, sustainable, and a secure digital future for all. However, the real challenge lies in translating these ambitious goals into actions as we strive to achieve the SDGs. The digital divide is multi-faceted, impacting the AI divide, computing divide, gender digital divide, and skills divide. The AI and computing divide create barriers as some nations rapidly innovate while others struggle to keep up. The gender digital divide limits women access to technology, and the skills divide leaves many without essential digital competencies. If we do not address these interconnected challenges, we risk leaving entire communities behind. Today, I represent the Digital Cooperation Organization, an organization dedicated to accelerating the inclusive growth of the digital economy. Our 16 member states across Asia, Europe, Africa, and the Middle East represent over 800 million people, 10% of the global population, with 75% under the age of 30. We’re committed to empowering our member states to transition from consumers to producers and innovators in the digital age. As a connector and facilitator and advisor, we ensure that everyone is equipped with the tools to succeed in the digital age. It is here, at the Summit of the Future, that we launch the Digital Economy Navigator, an innovative tool providing insights on digital… digital economy performance across 50 countries. This initiative is just one of the ways where we are turning the GDC and principles into action. But while DEN is a vital resource, it is only the beginning. We just started. We must foster collective efforts to the GDC’s ambitious goals, objectives, and commitments. I call upon every country, every individual, every organization to foster this digital navigator and to join forces in this critical endeavor. Let us create a future where everyone, everywhere can thrive.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the Digital Cooperation Organization and give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the Organization of Ibero-American States for Education, Science, and Culture.

Organization of Ibero-American States for Education, Science, and Culture: Mr. President, Secretary General, Your Excellencies, the Organization of Ibero-American States for Education, Science, and Culture would like to express its gratitude for the opportunity to participate in the Summit of the Future as an observer organization to the General Assembly. We’re very honored to offer our vision on the situation and challenges in education, science, and culture in the Ibero-American region. At a time, at a crucial moment, we have been active and developed our vision over the past 75 years. We are the oldest Ibero-American system with the greatest presence and activity in the region. Ibero-America is not what it used to be. after the crisis in 2018 and then the pandemic, which obviously requires a profound digital transformation. Progress in fulfillment of SDGs are only 22 percent of the targets, compared to 15 percent at the global level. Obviously, various short-term urgent situations have led to delays. Now it’s important for us to be more effective and efficient in education, science, and culture. That is our commitment to make public policies possible, to make sure that public policies reach a citizenship. Ibero-America has reached significant goals, for example, almost universal coverage in primary and secondary education, significant increase in higher education. But the quality of education and other public services are still insufficient. We need to obviously mobilize resources, financial ones, and as an example, we can consider that compared to countries of the OECD, they spend three times more in education, and in culture it only represents 1 percent of GDP. So we not only have to spend more, but to be more effective and efficient. This is why we need to take advantage of a unique opportunity represented by the benefits of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. There are many challenges, including in basic education, in vocational education, higher education, defending human rights and democracy, as well as science and culture. The future requires us to pull our efforts. This is why we’re We will focus particular attention on the digital transformation and artificial intelligence both in Spanish and in Portuguese. Soon we will offer to the governments of the region a strategic program

Chair: I thank the distinguished representative of the Organization of Ibero-American States for Education, Science, and Culture, and give the floor to the distinguished representative of the International Union for Conservation of Nature.

International Union for Conservation of Nature: Your Excellencies, the world is changing. There is an urgent need to respond to global crises of the loss of biodiversity and climate change that lead us to poverty and insecurity. Science has demonstrated that we are rapidly exceeding planetary limits that allow for conditions of life that are sufficient for the human species, the increase in the consumption of resources, persistent inequalities in the acceleration of climate change are subjecting the planet to an unprecedented pressure. Humans have already extinguished the life of many species, and we have led to the verge of extinction one-fourth of the remaining species. If we want to ensure the future of our planet, we must trigger a transformative change for nature and for people. This – we’re talking about the survival of the human species and of our home, planet Earth. A ray of hope comes from the recent successes in multilateral action for nature and climate. The Kunming, Montreal – framework, Global Framework for Biodiversity, and the Treaty for the High Seas are significant achievements that demonstrate the international community and the multilateral system function, and that we can achieve radical change that we need. It is essential to implement these and other key agreements. We must situate nature at the heart of global social and economic systems, change the relationship between people and nature in a way that nature offers solutions to people, and so that people enjoy the benefits offered by nature in an equitable and effective way. We have to transition towards a circular global economy that takes into account the true costs of ecosystemic services that are necessary for the production of goods and services. We must implement policies aimed at achieving a future free from fossil fuels, and one that is positive for nature. This must be based on inclusive decision-making processes that are participatory and that include in a meaningful way young people, indigenous people, and local communities taking into consideration gender aspects, and that are backed by scientific tools and data. The IUCN, the International Union for the Conservation of Nature, welcomes a pact for the future as a renewed commitment to multilateralism by the member states, although we regret the fact that the compact has not achieved the transformative change that is necessary for nature and for the climate. The IUCN is committed to supporting the implementation of the compact, and beyond this compact

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the International Union for Conservation of Nature and give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees in the Near East.

United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees in the Near East: Mr. Chair, excellencies, we have gathered here to shape our collective future. We do so amid seismic geopolitical shifts that are fiercely testing the international institutions and instruments we have relied on for three quarters of a century. We have an opportunity to reaffirm the values and principles that have served us well, and to pursue meaningful reform where needed. The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees, UNRWA, confronts daily the challenges this summit seeks to address. For 75 years, UNRWA has provided human development services for generations of Palestinian refugees in the occupied Palestinian territories, Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan. Millions of children have been educated in our schools, which equip them with the values, knowledge, and skill they need to thrive. Our education program has reached gender parity and teaches the value of human rights and tolerance. UNRWA’s education outcomes are among the best in the region and at the lowest cost per student. Our health program provides primary health care to millions, achieving universal vaccination in Palestinian refugees’ communities. Today, however, our decades-long investment in the future of Palestinian refugees is at risk. Excellencies, the blatant disregard for international humanitarian law in Gaza should alarm us all. The scale of human suffering is immense, and our ability to respond is severely constrained. 222 UNRWA staff have been killed. Two-thirds of our buildings have been damaged and destroyed, killing hundreds of people seeking United Nations protection. Legislative efforts are underway to evict UNRWA from East Jerusalem, remove its privileges and immunities, and designate it as a terrorist organization. Failing to push back against violation of international law and failing to push back against efforts to intimidate and undermine the United Nations sets a dangerous precedent. It will compromise the future of humanitarian work and erode the rule of law. Excellencies, the international response to the war in Gaza, escalating violence in the West Bank, and the spillover of conflict into Lebanon and across the region is highly concerning. International law is implemented selectively or not at all, reinforcing perception of inequality and injustice. Dehumanization is rampant in public discourse.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of UNRWA and give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the United Nations University.

United Nations University: Excellencies, Distinguished Delegates, we find ourselves at a critical moment in history, an intensifying climate crisis, growing inequality, endemic violence, and the emergence of new technologies are entrenching old divisions and creating new fault lines that threaten the cohesion of societies. The summit of the future is an opportunity to collectively address these challenges and deliver on the vision. we established here almost 10 years ago for the launch of the Sustainable Development Goals. The summit and the pact for the future is a defining moment for current and future generations. Decades from now, I hope that our children will look back and acknowledge the summit as a momentous occasion, and that they will agree that we have been good ancestors who laid the foundations of a more just, sustainable, and peaceful world. The Secretary General has argued that we can’t build a future for our grandchildren with a system that was built for our grandparents. Our future will be defined by the collective commitments we make today to transition away from fossil fuels, strengthen the governance of new technologies, build peace, and reform the international financial architecture. Science and research will be a critical facilitator of this shift, informing the development of policies and solutions, and ensuring they will have real impact. The United Nations University, through its collaborative research and education, is a source of impartial knowledge, evidence, and policy solutions. We have been committed to the development of the pact for the future, and we are committed to its successful implementation. We offer you a bridge to the scientific community. We offer you a neutral space to test ideas and build new correlations around bold policy solutions. We offer you our expertise and our networks in service of a reinvigorated multilateralism. Today, as we seek a new consensus to accelerate the attainment of the Sustainable Development Goals and secure a prosperous, resilient, and peaceful planet for current and future generations, it is imperative that we acknowledge and make strategic use of science and scientific institutions. I thank you.

Chair: I thank the distinguished representative of the United Nations University and give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty Organization. Chairperson, Excellencies, Distinguished Delegates,

Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty Organization: The future is a big place. Where will we live in it? The good areas or the bad areas? That’s up to us. But one thing for sure is that if there is a return to nuclear weapon testing, our shared future will not be bright. There were 900 nuclear weapon tests between Hiroshima in 1945 and the signing of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty in 1968. But even then, the nuclear tests kept going, an average of one a week for over 25 years. In the future, what if we return back to a renewed nuclear armed race? Or there’s a catastrophic miscalculation? Or we’re just unlucky? A pact for the future is a shared vision for a better present and a safer future. In the safer future, the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty is vital. The CTBT is smart. Our International Monitoring System network of sensors is a scientific wonder, so sensitive. The CTBT is transparent. States know that we’ll detect any test and fast. We’ll know where it has happened. And the CTBT has worked. Under the CTBT, there’s been only a handful of nuclear tests. tests this century. Remarkably, all this when the treaty is not yet entered into force. These are worrying times, even dangerous times, with reports of enhanced activities at former nuclear test sites, of threats of the use of nuclear weapons. Or we’re creating a bright future. We cannot do that if we’re heading into nuclear war. A big step towards achieving this is ending nuclear testing once and for all. The future is a big place with big issues to consider. That’s what this summit has been all about. Climate, migration, preserving the environment, the future of multilateralism. Major change usually requires major investment, but stopping nuclear tests costs so little. All it takes is our collective will and then the action of a few. There is no exaggeration. The CTBT is a great shared achievement. If this summit moves all the nations of the world towards making bold…

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty Organization, and I give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the International Trade Center.

International Trade Center: Distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, we’re here today because we’re facing some sobering realities, some tough odds. When the Sustainable Development Goals were adopted, it was a moment hailed globally as the dawn of a new era for international cooperation, one that would finally lead to a better, fairer… world. But as we’ve learned in the years since, achieving transformation on this scale is no mean feat, and it becomes even harder when crises seem to darken every horizon. Now, too often, it is easy to fall prey to pessimism, to see the world before us with so much human suffering and loss of life, with an ever-warming climate and mounting conflicts, and fear that things may never get better. But when I think of the small business leaders and the member states that we serve at the International Trade Center, it’s clear that we don’t have to look very far to see what a new world could and should look like. These small business leaders don’t have the luxury of saying that it’s too hard, and they already live and breathe the values that the SDGs were designed to uphold. These small business leaders are women who are running firms that tackle challenges ranging from food security to health care. They’re refugees who are finding new ways to support their families through digital tools while sharing their expertise with the world. They are young people who are teaching us how to safeguard our natural environment while creating new jobs along the way. They’ve inspired me to come before you today and make this request, that when we leave Turtle Bay and begin putting this Pact for the Future into motion, that we ensure that the world’s small businesses are front and center in every decision that we take. We cannot afford to do anything less. On behalf of the International Trade Center, we welcome the Pact for the Future, the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration on Future Generations. We’re already acting on many of the commitments laid out in these documents, from supporting more small businesses to take full part in the digital economy, to championing youth entrepreneurship, to supporting the vision of UN 2.0. It’s why we… brought young innovators to New York this week to celebrate their solutions for saving our planet at the Youth Entrepreneur Awards. It’s why we’re showcasing some of the work underway under ITC’s digital moonshot, our big strategic push to ensure all small businesses can take full part in the digital economy. And it’s why I can promise you this, that we at ITC will never shy away from doing the hard work of making sure this Pact for the Future delivers for those who need it most. Thank you very much.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the International Trade Center, and I give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women.

UN Women: Excellencies, good evening. As you convene here for the Summit of the Future, we join you in applauding the world’s commitment to reinvigorated and more networked multilateralism. We see a commitment to advancing gender equality and the rights of women and girls across the Pact for the Future and its annexes. And yet, the Summit comes at a time when the crisis of women’s rights preoccupies us, when we are all seized of the need to accelerate progress towards the 2030 Agenda, and when the evidence has never been more clear or compelling for SDG 5 as the accelerant to the entire 2030 Agenda. Our latest data unpacks concerning ways in which we remain off track. Without change, without acceleration, it will take 137 years to eradicate extreme poverty for women. women and girls, 68 years to eradicate child marriage, 39 years for gender parity in parliaments. Excellencies, next year we will commemorate the 30th anniversary of the Beijing Conference and its Platform for Action. It remains the most widely endorsed and visionary agenda for women’s rights in history. The best way to commemorate this and to deliver promises of the Pact for the Future is to implement real change in the lives of women and girls and critically to deliver on peace. Time to silence the guns everywhere. That is why UN Women is putting forward a plan for Beijing Plus 30 that is closely aligned to the ambition of the Pact for the Future. First we will work with member states and other stakeholders to advance high-impact, high-return-on-investment priority actions at country level that will accelerate Agenda 2030. Second, we will work to ensure more resources for the crucial role of civil society across all gender equality issues. Finally, we are echoing your call for a stronger multilateral system as a force for real change in the lives of all women and girls. We must and can make the choice to collectively leverage this moment and galvanize the will, commitment, and resources needed to get back on track. UN Women looks forward to joining you all in this endeavor. Thank you.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of UN Women and give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the United Nations Children’s Fund.

United Nations Children’s Fund: Excellencies, I have four messages to convey. First, at this summit, I know we feel a sense of tremendous accomplishment, but its success will depend on the practical implementation of what we have decided and how these decisions are applied to domestic policies, budgets, and programs to secure a better future. Second, together we have accomplished extraordinary achievements over the last few decades for our youngest citizens, our children. We know that millions of children today are surviving and thriving, having had improved access to health, nutrition, education, protection, and participation. And we also know that millions of children across the globe are facing a confluence of intractable crises, from armed conflicts through climate change to persistent poverty and inequality. Third, we must accept that children will influence and shape the future, and it is imperative that children’s rights, including their right to be heard in matters that affect them, is placed at the center of our collective development efforts. Thirty-five years ago, we also made this commitment to our future when we adopted the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the most ratified international human rights treaty in history. We further cemented this promise in MDGs and then the SDGs, but sadly we are off track to meet the SDGs, particularly those related to child rights. There is hope that comes with opportunity of accelerating to meet the SDGs and setting the present and future generations on a trajectory for success. This is a choice we have the power to make. Government and public financing are key to accelerating social investments in children. Just this morning at UNICEF House, we shared a comprehensive set of proven solutions to unlock benefits for child well-being across sectors. We can and must take these proven solutions to scale and achieve the much-needed impact for children that we have committed ourselves to across the 19 child-related SDG indicators. Our efforts have very real consequences for children around the world and our future. As you return home and your daily lives, please take with you the conviction that we can and we must work together so that every child everywhere today and tomorrow will survive, thrive.

Chair: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the United Nations Children Fund and now give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the Economic Cooperation Organization.

Economic Cooperation Organization: Mr. President, the global pact that we forged 80 years ago through the adoption of the UN Charter and its principles gave almost uninterrupted peace and prosperity to our successive generations for decades. That compact is clearly under stress today. Luckily, this summit gave us a unique opportunity to reflect on the past and chart our future. start a new course for a better future. The choices are clear. We can either have a breakthrough or a breakdown. By successfully negotiating and adopting the Pact for the Future, we have not only highlighted the significant challenges facing humanity, but also made commitments to effectively deal with these challenges. Through this summit, we are also reaffirming the UN Charter, committing to reinvigorating multilateralism, boosting implementation of our commitments, and restoring trust among member states. We are happy to see that the summit has also prioritized technology through the Digital Compact. In an era where our ability to reach common ground to tackle pressing challenges is getting constrained, cooperative regionalism is the way forward as a building block for an inclusive and more effective multilateralism. UN is and must remain at the center of all our efforts in pursuing stronger cooperation and reinvigorated multilateralism. However, the work should start at the regional level to build a strong foundation for lasting international peace and security. Therefore, strengthening regionalism would serve the purpose of enhanced multilateralism where our hopes and aspirations for a better tomorrow are rekindled. Aligned with the Agenda for Sustainable Development 2030, we at ECO crafted the Vision 2025, which aims to boost trade, enhance connectivity, secure transition towards green energy, and promote sustainable economic growth and the welfare of our people. The ECO is also in the process of finalizing its post-2025 strategy, where we would incorporate the outcomes of this. summit. The ECO is committed to enhancing regional collaboration and positioning itself as an active player on the global stage. We firmly believe that better connected and more integrated regions capable of working together to address their peace, security, and development-related challenges only make the reinvigorated multilateralism easier to achieve. It is, therefore, time to prioritize regionalism. We cannot build a solid foundation for multilateralism without strengthening.

Chair: I thank the distinguished representative of the Economic Cooperation Organization, and I give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Universal Postal Union.

Universal Postal Union: Excellencies, on behalf of the United Nations Interagency Group on Aging, I am honored as a representative of the Universal Postal Union, a member of the group, to deliver this statement. The postal sector, represented by the Universal Postal Union as a specialized agency of the United Nations, plays a vital role in the development of universal postal services that meet the needs of all citizens. With its extensive network of 700,000 post offices and a growing digital and social infrastructure, the postal system reaches even the most remote communities, providing essential services to billions of people worldwide. As we convene at this summit, often referred to as a once-in-a-generation opportunity to shape our collective future, it is imperative that we adopt a people-centered, right-based, life-course approach, one that fully includes all generations, including older persons. Demographic changes are not a distant challenge. They are already transforming our world and will define the future. Population aging is a global phenomenon that is accelerating. This demographic shift where people are living longer and increasingly healthier lives is a human success story, not a crisis. It is a testament to advances in health, living conditions, and technology. However, whether this transformation unfolds as an opportunity or a challenge depends on the policy choices we make today. The dominant narrative often frames population aging and increased longevity as inevitable burdens on national economies, health, and social care. This perspective is both limiting and inaccurate. The outcomes will depend on how we craft our policies and whether we seize the opportunity to invest in inclusive, age-responsive systems that benefit everyone. In reviewing the pact of the future, the group recognizes its bold and ambitious vision for a sustainable and equitable future. Nevertheless, we are disheartened to see only one mention of older persons compared to 30 references to youth. This stark imbalance ignores both the needs and contributions of today’s older populations and the fact that today’s youth are tomorrow’s older generations. Furthermore, we note with concern that the global digital compact, while rightly recognizing groups experiencing vulnerabilities, fails to specially mention older persons. This omission is particularly troubling given that older persons are among the groups most affected by the digital divide. They must not be left behind. Members of the United Nations Interagency Group on Aging stand ready to support member states in this endeavor, and we look forward to continuing our work in partnerships with all stakeholders. I thank you.

Chair: Thank you. I thank the distinguished representative of the Universal Postal Union. Colleagues. That was the last speaker on the list for the summit of the future. I understand you’re all very relieved to go home, which I have full sympathy for. It’s been a long day. But nevertheless, there is still one really important segment coming up, and that is the closing segment for the summit. And we will therefore suspend the meeting now until 8 o’clock. It’s just 10 minutes or so. So please bear with us. And then the PGA will return for the closing segment of the future – summit of the future. This meeting is now suspended until the closing summit is held at 8 p.m. The meeting is suspended. The Sixth Plenary Meeting is resumed. Your Excellencies, Heads of State and Government, Mr. Secretary-General of the United Nations, ladies and gentlemen, At the 75th anniversary of the United Nations in 2020, member states issued a call to action. Guided by the United Nations Charter, it was a call to better respond to current and future challenges, to reinvigorate multilateralism, and to strengthen international cooperation towards those ends. Today, the Summit of the Future and its outcome document, the Pact of the Future, has answered this call. The Pact for the Future, together with its annex crisis, the Global Digital Compact and the Declaration on Future Generations adopted yesterday set us on a stronger course of transformation. Together they outlined commitments to accelerate progress across the Sustainable Development Goals and usher in a future that is more peaceful, just, and resilient. I congratulate Member States for working with focus and solidarity over the last two years to meet this historic milestone on the road to a more effective and inclusive international cooperation. Our work does not end here. In fact, it begins anew. The summit of the future is a major step in our continuum of efforts to deliver faster and smarter on the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, the Addis Ababa Action Agenda, and the Paris Agreement on Climate Change, amongst others. And it must propel our collective ability to deliver well in the future, including at the third United Nations Conference on Land-Locked Developing Countries in December, the fourth Financing for Development Conference in July 2025, and the second World Summit for Social Development in November 2025. Throughout, stakeholder support and ownership of implementation will be critical to sustaining action at national and regional levels. It is my sincere hope. I hope that the views and ideas exchanged during the summit will inspire further initiatives in your respective countries and regions, as well as here at the United Nations. As we close the Summit of the Future, I urge all member states to continue to push for decisive action and to create meaningful progress. We must never lose sight of the lives already lost under the weight of poverty, hunger, and want. We also must never lose sight of those still suffering amid the torrents of conflict, violence, and deprivation. And finally, we must never lose sight of those future generations to whom we owe our best efforts to create a world that uplifts and empowers all of humanity, leaving no one behind. I thank you. I declare closed the Summit of the Future. The General Assembly has thus concluded this stage of its consideration of Agenda Item 123. The meeting is adjourned.

CL

Chile

Speech speed

123 words per minute

Speech length

611 words

Speech time

296 seconds

Strengthen and modernize UN institutions

Explanation

Boric argues that UN institutions need to be strengthened and modernized to better reflect current global realities. He emphasizes the need for reform to make the UN more effective and relevant in addressing contemporary challenges.

Evidence

Boric states that ‘the United Nations was made in a world that no longer exists in 2024’ and calls for changing the rules of the Security Council to adapt to today’s world.

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Governance and Multilateralism

Agreed with

Gustavo Petro Urrego

Interparliamentary Union

David Lammy

Agreed on

Reform of global governance and multilateral institutions

Disagreed with

Gustavo Petro Urrego

Masoud Pezeshkian

Disagreed on

Priorities for UN reform

GY

Guyana

Revitalize multilateralism to address global challenges

Explanation

Ali emphasizes the need to revitalize multilateralism to effectively respond to global challenges. He argues for a more inclusive and cooperative approach to international problem-solving.

Evidence

Ali calls for extending climate finance commitments and establishing a global market-based mechanism for carbon credits.

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Governance and Multilateralism

Preserve forests and establish carbon credit mechanisms

Explanation

Ali advocates for the preservation of forests and the establishment of carbon credit mechanisms. He emphasizes the importance of forests in addressing climate change and calls for a global market-based approach.

Evidence

Ali states that ‘Forests are an integral part of the climate solution, and it is time that a global market-based mechanism for carbon credit be put in place.’

Major Discussion Point

Addressing Climate Change and Environmental Challenges

Agreed with

Santiago Pena Palacios

Luis Rodolfo Abinader Corona

Arnoldo Ricardo Andre Tinoco

Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni

Agreed on

Address climate change and environmental challenges

Disagreed with

Santiago Pena Palacios

Disagreed on

Approach to climate change mitigation

IR

Iran

Speech speed

109 words per minute

Speech length

550 words

Speech time

301 seconds

Reform international financial architecture

Explanation

Pezeshkian calls for urgent reforms in the governance structure of international financial institutions. He argues for greater participation of developing countries in decision-making and norm-setting processes.

Evidence

Pezeshkian proposes creating a fair and accountable framework to address the financial needs of developing nations.

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Governance and Multilateralism

Disagreed with

Gabriel Boric Font

Gustavo Petro Urrego

Disagreed on

Priorities for UN reform

PY

Paraguay

Speech speed

132 words per minute

Speech length

657 words

Speech time

297 seconds

Transition to clean energy and reduce emissions

Explanation

Palacios advocates for a transition to clean energy and reduction of emissions to address climate change. He emphasizes Paraguay’s commitment to renewable energy as an example for other nations.

Evidence

Palacios highlights that Paraguay has 100% clean, green, renewable energy and aims to enhance investment in renewable energy to achieve 52% of clean energy in its energy basket by 2030.

Major Discussion Point

Addressing Climate Change and Environmental Challenges

Agreed with

Mohamed Irfaan Ali

Luis Rodolfo Abinader Corona

Arnoldo Ricardo Andre Tinoco

Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni

Agreed on

Address climate change and environmental challenges

Disagreed with

Mohamed Irfaan Ali

Disagreed on

Approach to climate change mitigation

UA

Ukraine

Speech speed

116 words per minute

Speech length

391 words

Speech time

202 seconds

Mobilize climate finance for developing countries

Explanation

Zelenskyy emphasizes the importance of mobilizing climate finance for developing countries. He argues that this is crucial for addressing global climate challenges and supporting sustainable development.

Major Discussion Point

Addressing Climate Change and Environmental Challenges

DO

Dominican Republic

Speech speed

119 words per minute

Speech length

461 words

Speech time

231 seconds

Protect oceans and marine biodiversity

Explanation

Abinader Corona emphasizes the importance of protecting oceans and marine biodiversity. He argues that this is crucial for maintaining the health of the planet and supporting sustainable development.

Evidence

Abinader Corona highlights that the ocean provides 50% of the oxygen we breathe, is the greatest source of protein worldwide, and sustains 3 billion people globally.

Major Discussion Point

Addressing Climate Change and Environmental Challenges

Agreed with

Mohamed Irfaan Ali

Santiago Pena Palacios

Arnoldo Ricardo Andre Tinoco

Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni

Agreed on

Address climate change and environmental challenges

G

Gustavo Petro Urrego

Speech speed

110 words per minute

Speech length

567 words

Speech time

308 seconds

Reform Security Council to be more representative

Explanation

Petro Urrego calls for reform of the UN Security Council to make it more representative of current global realities. He argues that the current structure is outdated and does not reflect the world as it is today.

Evidence

Petro Urrego states that ‘in the Security Council, today’s world is no longer represented’ and calls for changing the rules of the Security Council to adapt to the current world.

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Governance and Multilateralism

Agreed with

Gabriel Boric Font

Interparliamentary Union

David Lammy

Agreed on

Reform of global governance and multilateral institutions

Disagreed with

Gabriel Boric Font

Masoud Pezeshkian

Disagreed on

Priorities for UN reform

IPU

Interparliamentary Union

Speech speed

138 words per minute

Speech length

367 words

Speech time

158 seconds

Enhance cooperation between UN and parliaments

Explanation

The Interparliamentary Union advocates for enhanced cooperation between the UN and national parliaments. They argue that this collaboration is crucial for strengthening multilateralism and implementing UN agreements effectively.

Evidence

The IPU welcomes Action 55 of the Pact, which stresses the need to deepen the relationship between the UN and Parliaments, and welcomes the contribution of Parliaments through the IPU in supporting the implementation of UN Agreements.

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Governance and Multilateralism

Agreed with

Gabriel Boric Font

Gustavo Petro Urrego

David Lammy

Agreed on

Reform of global governance and multilateral institutions

D

David Lammy

Speech speed

128 words per minute

Speech length

565 words

Speech time

264 seconds

Adapt UN peacekeeping to new realities

Explanation

Lammy argues for adapting UN peacekeeping operations to new realities and threats. He emphasizes the need for modernizing peacekeeping efforts to better address contemporary challenges to global peace and security.

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Governance and Multilateralism

Agreed with

Gabriel Boric Font

Gustavo Petro Urrego

Interparliamentary Union

Agreed on

Reform of global governance and multilateral institutions

A

Arnoldo Ricardo Andre Tinoco

Speech speed

116 words per minute

Speech length

603 words

Speech time

311 seconds

Implement Paris Agreement and biodiversity framework

Explanation

Tinoco calls for the implementation of the Paris Agreement and the global biodiversity framework. He emphasizes the urgency of taking action to address climate change and protect biodiversity.

Evidence

Tinoco appeals to all states to speed up efforts to comply with obligations under the Paris Agreement and the global biodiversity coming Montreal framework to curb the loss of biodiversity by 2030.

Major Discussion Point

Addressing Climate Change and Environmental Challenges

Agreed with

Mohamed Irfaan Ali

Santiago Pena Palacios

Luis Rodolfo Abinader Corona

Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni

Agreed on

Address climate change and environmental challenges

S

Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni

Speech speed

132 words per minute

Speech length

661 words

Speech time

299 seconds

Invest in climate resilience for small island states

Explanation

Sovaleni emphasizes the need for investment in climate resilience for small island developing states. He argues that these nations are particularly vulnerable to climate change impacts and require support to build resilience.

Evidence

Sovaleni mentions the Pacific Resilience Facility, a Pacific-led climate and disaster initiative, as an example of efforts to build resilience in the region.

Major Discussion Point

Addressing Climate Change and Environmental Challenges

Agreed with

Mohamed Irfaan Ali

Santiago Pena Palacios

Luis Rodolfo Abinader Corona

Arnoldo Ricardo Andre Tinoco

Agreed on

Address climate change and environmental challenges

Develop ethical governance frameworks for AI

Explanation

Sovaleni calls for the development of ethical governance frameworks for artificial intelligence. He emphasizes the need to ensure that AI technologies are used responsibly and ethically, particularly in developing countries.

Evidence

Sovaleni mentions the AI playbook for small states launched by Singapore and Rwanda as an example of efforts to empower countries to leverage AI for public good.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Science, Technology and Innovation

M

Mette Frederiksen

Speech speed

119 words per minute

Speech length

471 words

Speech time

236 seconds

Eradicate poverty and reduce inequalities

Explanation

Frederiksen emphasizes the importance of eradicating poverty and reducing inequalities globally. She argues that these efforts are crucial for achieving sustainable development and ensuring a better future for all.

Major Discussion Point

Promoting Sustainable and Inclusive Development

A

Amadou Ouru Bah

Speech speed

117 words per minute

Speech length

542 words

Speech time

276 seconds

Reform global financial system to support developing countries

Explanation

Bah calls for reform of the global financial system to better support developing countries. He argues that the current system is inadequate in addressing the needs of developing nations and must be restructured to promote more equitable development.

Major Discussion Point

Promoting Sustainable and Inclusive Development

A

Aziz Akhannouch

Speech speed

107 words per minute

Speech length

502 words

Speech time

280 seconds

Invest in education, health and social protection

Explanation

Akhannouch emphasizes the importance of investing in education, health, and social protection. He argues that these investments are crucial for promoting sustainable development and improving the well-being of citizens.

Evidence

Akhannouch mentions Morocco’s efforts to enhance nutritional and health sovereignty, as confirmed by the King’s recent speech.

Major Discussion Point

Promoting Sustainable and Inclusive Development

Use space technologies to address global challenges

Explanation

Akhannouch advocates for the use of space technologies to address global challenges. He argues that these technologies can play a crucial role in sustainable development and addressing environmental issues.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Science, Technology and Innovation

M

Mohamed Younis A Menfi

Speech speed

117 words per minute

Speech length

608 words

Speech time

310 seconds

Empower women and youth economically

Explanation

Menfi emphasizes the importance of economically empowering women and youth. He argues that this is crucial for inclusive development and building a more prosperous future.

Major Discussion Point

Promoting Sustainable and Inclusive Development

J

Jean-Noël Barrot

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Bridge the digital divide and ensure equitable access to technology

Explanation

Barrot emphasizes the need to bridge the digital divide and ensure equitable access to technology. He argues that this is crucial for inclusive development and harnessing the benefits of digital innovation.

Evidence

Barrot mentions the upcoming Artificial Intelligence Action Summit in France as an initiative to address these challenges.

Major Discussion Point

Promoting Sustainable and Inclusive Development

I

International Trade Center

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Support small businesses and entrepreneurs

Explanation

The International Trade Center advocates for supporting small businesses and entrepreneurs. They argue that these actors are crucial for sustainable development and job creation, particularly in developing countries.

Evidence

The ITC mentions their efforts to support small businesses in participating in the digital economy and their Youth Entrepreneur Awards showcasing innovative solutions.

Major Discussion Point

Promoting Sustainable and Inclusive Development

A

Antony Blinken

Speech speed

144 words per minute

Speech length

682 words

Speech time

282 seconds

Prevent conflicts and strengthen conflict resolution mechanisms

Explanation

Blinken emphasizes the importance of conflict prevention and strengthening conflict resolution mechanisms. He argues that these efforts are crucial for maintaining international peace and security.

Evidence

Blinken mentions the need to address growing and diverse threats to international peace and security on land, sea, air, outer space, and cyberspace.

Major Discussion Point

Advancing Peace, Security and Human Rights

I

International Committee of the Red Cross

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Protect civilians in armed conflicts

Explanation

The ICRC emphasizes the importance of protecting civilians in armed conflicts. They argue that this is a fundamental principle of international humanitarian law that must be upheld.

Evidence

The ICRC cites the Geneva Conventions and calls on states to use their influence to ensure warring parties minimize harm to civilians.

Major Discussion Point

Advancing Peace, Security and Human Rights

C

Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty Organization

Speech speed

115 words per minute

Speech length

337 words

Speech time

174 seconds

Promote nuclear disarmament and non-proliferation

Explanation

The CTBTO advocates for nuclear disarmament and non-proliferation. They argue that ending nuclear testing is crucial for global security and a more peaceful future.

Evidence

The CTBTO highlights the effectiveness of their International Monitoring System in detecting nuclear tests and the significant reduction in tests since the treaty’s inception.

Major Discussion Point

Advancing Peace, Security and Human Rights

V

Vivian Balakrishnan

Speech speed

115 words per minute

Speech length

351 words

Speech time

182 seconds

Uphold international law and UN Charter principles

Explanation

Balakrishnan emphasizes the importance of upholding international law and UN Charter principles. He argues that this is crucial for maintaining global peace and security, especially for small states.

Evidence

Balakrishnan states that ‘A world in which respect for sovereignty, for territorial integrity, and international law that is being eroded will become a very dangerous world for current and future generations, and especially for small states.’

Major Discussion Point

Advancing Peace, Security and Human Rights

I

INTERPOL

Speech speed

122 words per minute

Speech length

365 words

Speech time

178 seconds

Combat terrorism and transnational crime

Explanation

INTERPOL emphasizes the importance of combating terrorism and transnational crime. They argue that international cooperation in law enforcement is crucial for global security and sustainable development.

Evidence

INTERPOL mentions their Global Policing Goals as a blueprint for law enforcement to advance Agenda 2030 in complementarity to the UN Sustainable Development Goals.

Major Discussion Point

Advancing Peace, Security and Human Rights

U

UN Women

Speech speed

120 words per minute

Speech length

353 words

Speech time

175 seconds

Advance gender equality and women’s rights

Explanation

UN Women emphasizes the importance of advancing gender equality and women’s rights. They argue that this is crucial for achieving the Sustainable Development Goals and building a more just and equitable future.

Evidence

UN Women cites data showing that without change, it will take 137 years to eradicate extreme poverty for women and girls, 68 years to eradicate child marriage, and 39 years for gender parity in parliaments.

Major Discussion Point

Advancing Peace, Security and Human Rights

D

Digital Cooperation Organization

Speech speed

117 words per minute

Speech length

357 words

Speech time

182 seconds

Leverage digital technologies for sustainable development

Explanation

The Digital Cooperation Organization advocates for leveraging digital technologies to promote sustainable development. They argue that digital innovation can drive inclusive growth and help achieve the SDGs.

Evidence

The organization mentions the launch of their Digital Economy Navigator, a tool providing insights on digital economy performance across 50 countries.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Science, Technology and Innovation

C

Celinda Sosa Lunda

Speech speed

117 words per minute

Speech length

579 words

Speech time

296 seconds

Ensure equitable access to digital infrastructure

Explanation

Sosa Lunda emphasizes the importance of ensuring equitable access to digital infrastructure. She argues that this is crucial for bridging the digital divide and promoting inclusive development.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Science, Technology and Innovation

U

UNESCO

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Promote international scientific cooperation

Explanation

UNESCO advocates for promoting international scientific cooperation. They argue that this is essential for addressing global challenges and achieving sustainable development.

Evidence

UNESCO mentions their recommendations on open science as a means to promote the transfer of technologies and ensure that all talents can flourish.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Science, Technology and Innovation

I

International Atomic Energy Agency

Speech speed

113 words per minute

Speech length

297 words

Speech time

156 seconds

Apply nuclear technologies for development

Explanation

The IAEA advocates for the application of nuclear technologies in development. They argue that these technologies can contribute to various areas of sustainable development, including health, food security, and environmental protection.

Evidence

The IAEA mentions programs like Race of Hope for oncology and nuclear medicine, and Atoms for Food for addressing food scarcity.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Science, Technology and Innovation

Agreements

Agreement Points

Reform of global governance and multilateral institutions

Gabriel Boric Font

Gustavo Petro Urrego

Interparliamentary Union

David Lammy

Strengthen and modernize UN institutions

Reform Security Council to be more representative

Enhance cooperation between UN and parliaments

Adapt UN peacekeeping to new realities

Multiple speakers emphasized the need to reform and modernize UN institutions, particularly the Security Council, to better reflect current global realities and improve effectiveness in addressing contemporary challenges.

Address climate change and environmental challenges

Mohamed Irfaan Ali

Santiago Pena Palacios

Luis Rodolfo Abinader Corona

Arnoldo Ricardo Andre Tinoco

Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni

Preserve forests and establish carbon credit mechanisms

Transition to clean energy and reduce emissions

Protect oceans and marine biodiversity

Implement Paris Agreement and biodiversity framework

Invest in climate resilience for small island states

Several speakers stressed the urgency of addressing climate change through various means, including forest preservation, transitioning to clean energy, protecting marine biodiversity, and implementing international agreements on climate and biodiversity.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers advocated for reforming the global financial system to better support developing countries and address their financial needs.

Masoud Pezeshkian

Amadou Ouru Bah

Reform international financial architecture

Reform global financial system to support developing countries

These speakers emphasized the importance of investing in social development and reducing inequalities as crucial steps towards sustainable development.

Mette Frederiksen

Aziz Akhannouch

Eradicate poverty and reduce inequalities

Invest in education, health and social protection

Unexpected Consensus

Ethical governance of artificial intelligence

Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni

Jean-Noël Barrot

Develop ethical governance frameworks for AI

Bridge the digital divide and ensure equitable access to technology

Despite representing different regions (Pacific Islands and France), both speakers emphasized the importance of ethical AI governance and equitable access to technology, showing a shared concern for responsible technological advancement across diverse contexts.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement included reforming global governance structures, addressing climate change and environmental challenges, promoting sustainable and inclusive development, and ensuring ethical and equitable technological advancement.

Consensus level

There was a moderate to high level of consensus on the need for systemic reforms and collaborative action to address global challenges. This consensus suggests a shared recognition of the urgency of these issues and the need for coordinated international efforts, which could potentially facilitate more effective multilateral action in the future.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Approach to climate change mitigation

Mohamed Irfaan Ali

Santiago Pena Palacios

Preserve forests and establish carbon credit mechanisms

Transition to clean energy and reduce emissions

While both speakers address climate change, Ali focuses on forest preservation and carbon credits, while Palacios emphasizes clean energy transition and emissions reduction.

Priorities for UN reform

Gabriel Boric Font

Gustavo Petro Urrego

Masoud Pezeshkian

Strengthen and modernize UN institutions

Reform Security Council to be more representative

Reform international financial architecture

Speakers disagree on which aspect of UN reform should be prioritized, with Boric focusing on overall modernization, Petro Urrego emphasizing Security Council reform, and Pezeshkian prioritizing financial architecture reform.

Unexpected Disagreements

Approach to digital technologies

Jean-Noël Barrot

Digital Cooperation Organization

Bridge the digital divide and ensure equitable access to technology

Leverage digital technologies for sustainable development

While both speakers address digital technologies, Barrot focuses on bridging the digital divide, while the Digital Cooperation Organization emphasizes leveraging technologies for development. This subtle difference in approach was unexpected given the overall agreement on the importance of digital technologies.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around climate change mitigation strategies, UN reform priorities, and approaches to leveraging digital technologies for development.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among speakers is moderate. While there are differences in approach and emphasis, most speakers agree on the overarching goals of sustainable development, UN reform, and addressing climate change. These disagreements primarily reflect different national priorities and contexts rather than fundamental ideological differences. The implications of these disagreements suggest that achieving consensus on specific implementation strategies may require further negotiation and compromise.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

Both speakers agree on the need for climate finance, but Zelenskyy focuses on developing countries in general, while Sovaleni specifically emphasizes small island states.

Volodymyr Zelenskyy

Siaosi Ofakivahafolau Sovaleni

Mobilize climate finance for developing countries

Invest in climate resilience for small island states

Both speakers agree on the need to improve UN peacekeeping and conflict resolution, but Lammy focuses on adapting peacekeeping operations, while Blinken emphasizes conflict prevention and resolution mechanisms.

David Lammy

Antony Blinken

Adapt UN peacekeeping to new realities

Prevent conflicts and strengthen conflict resolution mechanisms

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers advocated for reforming the global financial system to better support developing countries and address their financial needs.

Masoud Pezeshkian

Amadou Ouru Bah

Reform international financial architecture

Reform global financial system to support developing countries

These speakers emphasized the importance of investing in social development and reducing inequalities as crucial steps towards sustainable development.

Mette Frederiksen

Aziz Akhannouch

Eradicate poverty and reduce inequalities

Invest in education, health and social protection

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

The Summit of the Future resulted in the adoption of the Pact for the Future, Global Digital Compact, and Declaration on Future Generations

There is broad agreement on the need to reform and strengthen the multilateral system, particularly the UN and its institutions

Addressing climate change, sustainable development, and reducing inequalities were emphasized as critical priorities

Many called for reforming the global financial architecture to better support developing countries

Harnessing science, technology and innovation, especially digital technologies and AI, was seen as crucial for future progress

Strengthening international peace, security and human rights remains a key focus

Resolutions and Action Items

Implement the commitments outlined in the Pact for the Future and its annexes

Begin intergovernmental process to adopt new multidimensional indicators for measuring countries’ progress and needs

Reform the UN Security Council to be more representative

Accelerate efforts to achieve the Sustainable Development Goals

Develop governance frameworks for artificial intelligence

Strengthen UN peacekeeping operations to adapt to new realities

Mobilize increased climate finance for developing countries

Unresolved Issues

Specific details on reforming the Security Council and other UN bodies

Concrete mechanisms to reform the international financial architecture

How to effectively bridge the digital divide between developed and developing countries

Addressing ongoing conflicts and humanitarian crises, such as in Gaza

Balancing economic development with environmental protection

Ensuring equitable access to new technologies across all countries

Suggested Compromises

Balancing representation of different regions and country sizes in a reformed Security Council

Combining climate action with economic development opportunities

Leveraging both public and private sector resources for sustainable development financing

Promoting technology transfer while respecting intellectual property rights

Enhancing cooperation between the UN and regional organizations

Thought Provoking Comments

We need to ask as members of the government what we need to do, what can we do to change this? Today I think that there’s an emerging consensus around the world that there are no longer or there shouldn’t be privileged classes and that the wealth that is created in the world should be distributed much more equally than it is today, both in the world between member states and nation states and also within nation states.

Speaker

Gabriel Boric Font, President of Chile

Reason

This comment challenges existing power structures and wealth distribution, calling for a more equitable global system.

Impact

It set a tone of urgency for addressing global inequality and shifted the discussion towards concrete actions governments can take.

Extending the climate finance commitments can no longer be postponed. Forests are an integral part of the climate solution, and it is time that a global market-based mechanism for carbon credit be put in place.

Speaker

Mohamed Irfaan Ali, President of Guyana

Reason

This comment highlights the critical role of forests in climate solutions and proposes a specific mechanism for action.

Impact

It focused the discussion on practical, market-based solutions to climate change and emphasized the importance of immediate action on climate finance.

We call for the urgent reforms in the governance structure of international financial institutions to ensure the participation of developing countries in decision-making and norm-setting, creating a fair and accountable framework to address the financial needs of developing nations.

Speaker

Masoud Pezeshkian, President of Iran

Reason

This comment addresses the systemic inequalities in global financial governance and calls for specific reforms.

Impact

It shifted the conversation towards the need for restructuring international financial institutions to be more inclusive and representative.

The United States believes that this should include two permanent seats for Africa, one rotating seat for small island developing states, permanent representation for Latin America and the Caribbean, in addition to the permanent seats for countries we’ve long endorsed, Germany, Japan, India.

Speaker

Antony Blinken, Secretary of State of the United States

Reason

This comment proposes specific reforms to the UN Security Council, addressing long-standing concerns about representation.

Impact

It brought the discussion to concrete proposals for UN reform and signaled potential shifts in major power dynamics within the organization.

We must embrace and shape the technology that is transforming our world and our work. As we work to bridge the digital divide, our task is to ensure technology fosters empowerment and gender equality, rather than perpetuating violence.

Speaker

Representative of the United Nations Population Fund

Reason

This comment highlights the dual nature of technological advancement – its potential for both empowerment and harm.

Impact

It broadened the discussion on technology to include considerations of gender equality and violence prevention, emphasizing the need for ethical technological development.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by focusing on several critical themes: global wealth inequality, climate action, reform of international institutions, and the ethical implications of technological advancement. They moved the conversation from general statements about the future to specific proposals for systemic change, emphasizing the urgency of action and the need for more inclusive global governance structures. The comments also highlighted the interconnected nature of global challenges, linking issues like climate change, financial reform, and technological development to broader questions of equity and representation.

Follow-up Questions

How can we reform the UN Security Council to make it more representative and responsive to current global realities?

Speaker

Gabriel Boric Font, President of Chile

Explanation

The current structure of the Security Council does not reflect today’s world, and reform is needed to ensure fair representation and effective decision-making on global security issues.

What specific actions can be taken to bridge the digital divide between countries and ensure equitable access to technology?

Speaker

Mohamed Irfaan Ali, President of Guyana

Explanation

Addressing the digital divide is crucial for ensuring all countries can benefit from technological advancements and participate fully in the global digital economy.

How can we reform the international financial architecture to better address the needs of developing countries?

Speaker

Mohamed Irfaan Ali, President of Guyana

Explanation

The current financial system is not adequately serving the needs of developing nations, and reform is necessary to promote more equitable global development.

What measures can be implemented to ensure the responsible use of artificial intelligence and address potential risks?

Speaker

Masoud Pezeshkian, President of Iran

Explanation

As AI technology advances, it is important to establish governance frameworks to maximize its benefits while mitigating potential negative impacts.

How can we accelerate progress towards achieving the Sustainable Development Goals, given that only 17% are currently on track?

Speaker

Gabriel Boric Font, President of Chile

Explanation

With the 2030 deadline approaching, there is an urgent need to identify strategies for faster implementation of the SDGs.

What specific measures can be taken to reform global political, economic, and financial governance to reflect current realities?

Speaker

Bassirou Dioumaye Diakhar Faye, President of Senegal

Explanation

Existing global governance structures are outdated and need to be updated to ensure fair representation and effective decision-making in today’s world.

How can we strengthen the role of regional organizations in supporting global multilateralism?

Speaker

Representative of the Economic Cooperation Organization

Explanation

Regional cooperation can serve as a building block for more effective global multilateralism and help address regional challenges.

What strategies can be implemented to better include older persons in digital transformation efforts and address their specific needs?

Speaker

Representative of the Universal Postal Union

Explanation

The Global Digital Compact lacks specific mention of older persons, who are among the groups most affected by the digital divide and must not be left behind in technological advancements.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

(Interactive Dialogue 3) Summit of the Future – General Assembly, 79th session

(Interactive Dialogue 3) Summit of the Future – General Assembly, 79th session

Session at a Glance

Summary

This interactive dialogue focused on shaping a common digital future and bridging digital divides through inclusive innovation and cooperation. Participants emphasized the transformative potential of digital technologies in achieving sustainable development goals, while also acknowledging the challenges of unequal access and potential risks.

Key themes included the need to expand digital infrastructure and connectivity, especially in underserved areas and developing countries. Many speakers stressed the importance of digital skills training and education to ensure populations can fully participate in and benefit from the digital economy. The gender digital divide was highlighted as a particular concern requiring targeted efforts.

Discussions touched on the opportunities and challenges presented by artificial intelligence, with calls for ethical governance frameworks and international cooperation on AI development. Cybersecurity and online safety, particularly for vulnerable groups like women and children, were identified as critical issues requiring policy attention.

Several speakers emphasized the importance of multi-stakeholder collaboration, involving governments, private sector, civil society, and international organizations in shaping digital policies and initiatives. The need for flexible financing mechanisms to support digital development in low-resource settings was also noted.

The Global Digital Compact, adopted as part of the Pact for the Future, was welcomed as a landmark agreement providing a framework for digital cooperation. Participants stressed the importance of moving from commitments to concrete implementation actions to realize an inclusive, rights-based digital future that leaves no one behind.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– Bridging the digital divide and ensuring equitable access to digital technologies

– Leveraging digital technologies and AI to accelerate sustainable development

– Promoting digital literacy, skills development, and capacity building

– Ensuring online safety, security, and human rights protections in the digital space

– Fostering international cooperation and multi-stakeholder partnerships on digital issues

The overall purpose of this discussion was to explore ways to create an inclusive, sustainable and equitable digital future for all, in line with the newly adopted Global Digital Compact. Participants shared perspectives on leveraging digital technologies to advance sustainable development while addressing challenges like the digital divide.

The tone of the discussion was largely optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers emphasizing the transformative potential of digital technologies. However, there was also a sense of urgency in addressing digital inequalities and risks. The tone became more action-oriented towards the end, with calls to translate the Global Digital Compact into concrete implementation.

Speakers

Moderators/Facilitators:

– Mohamed Muizzu (President of Maldives) – Co-chair

– Alar Karis (President of Estonia) – Co-chair

Speakers:

– Doreen Bogdan-Martin (Secretary General of International Telecommunication Union)

– Juan M. Lavista Ferres (Corporate VP and Chief Data Scientist, AI for Good Lab at Microsoft)

– Linda Bonyo (Founder of Lawyers Hub)

– Dimitar Glavchev (Bulgaria)

– Xavier Espot Zamora (Andorra)

– Edi Rama (Albania)

– Patrice Emery Trovoada (Democratic Republic of São Tomé and Príncipe)

– Jonas Gahr Støre (Prime Minister of Norway)

– Micheál Martin (Deputy PM and Minister of Foreign Affairs and Defence of Ireland)

– Saleumxay Kommasith (Deputy PM and Minister of Foreign Affairs of Laos)

– Esther Dweck (Minister of Management and Innovation in Public Services of Brazil)

– Pavel Isa Contreras (Minister of Economy, Planning and Development, Dominican Republic)

– D.N. Dhungyel (Minister of Foreign Affairs and External Trade, Bhutan)

– Aminata Zerbo-Sabané (Minister of Digital Transition, Post and Electronic Communications, Burkina Faso)

– Ville Tavio (Minister of Foreign Trade and Development, Finland)

– Abdullah Alswaha (Minister of Communication and Information Technology, Saudi Arabia)

– Ursula Owusu-Ekuful (Minister of Communication and Digitalization, Ghana)

– Savannah Maziya (Minister of Information, Communication and Technology, Eswatini)

– Maria da Graça Carvalho (Minister of Environment and Energy, Portugal)

– Omran Sharaf (Assistant Minister for Science and Advanced Technology Affairs, UAE)

– Alexey Borisov (Representative of Russian Federation)

– Charlotta Schlyter (ECOSOC Ambassador, Sweden)

– Amanuel Giorgio (Councillor, Deputy PM Representative, Eritrea)

– Ismaila Ceesay (Minister of Information, Communication and Digital Economy, Gambia)

– Birgit Stevens (Director for UN and Francophone, Belgium Ministry for Foreign Affairs)

Representatives from various international organizations and NGOs also spoke.

Closing Remarks:

– Amandeep Singh Gill (UN Secretary-General’s Envoy on Technology)

The speakers represented a diverse range of expertise including government leadership, technology, telecommunications, law, economics, foreign affairs, and various aspects of digital development and policy.

Full session report

Expanded Summary of Interactive Dialogue on Shaping a Common Digital Future

Introduction

This interactive dialogue, co-chaired by Mohamed Muizzu, President of Maldives, and Alar Karis, President of Estonia, brought together a diverse group of participants including government leaders, technology experts, representatives from international organisations, and civil society to discuss shaping a common digital future and bridging digital divides through inclusive innovation and cooperation. The dialogue was framed by the recently adopted Global Digital Compact, which provides a framework for digital cooperation and development.

Key Themes and Discussion Points

1. Bridging the Digital Divide

A central focus of the dialogue was the urgent need to address the digital divide, with President Muizzu highlighting that over one-third of the global population remains disconnected from the internet, particularly in developing countries. Speakers emphasised various approaches to tackle this issue:

– Expanding connectivity infrastructure (Mohamed Muizzu)

– Investing in digital skills and literacy, such as Ghana’s Girls in ICT Trust (Ursula Owusu-Ekuful)

– Promoting inclusive innovation for underserved areas (Ismaila Ceesay)

– Leveraging public-private partnerships (Abdullah Alswaha)

– Addressing gender gaps in technology access and skills (Birgit Stevens)

2. Harnessing Digital Technologies for Sustainable Development

Participants highlighted the transformative potential of digital technologies in achieving sustainable development goals. Key areas of focus included:

– Using AI and digital tools to address climate change (Jonas Gahr Støre)

– Digitalisation of public services for efficiency and transparency (Edi Rama)

– Leveraging digital finance for financial inclusion (Esther Dweck)

– Adopting digital solutions for agriculture and food security (Juan M. Lavista Ferres)

– Implementing digital health solutions, such as Saudi Arabia’s virtual hospital model (Abdullah Alswaha)

3. Artificial Intelligence and Emerging Technologies

Speakers discussed the potential of AI and other emerging technologies to accelerate progress towards the SDGs, while also acknowledging associated challenges:

– Developing ethical frameworks for AI governance (UNESCO)

– Balancing innovation with responsible AI development (Charlotta Schlyter)

– Addressing potential risks and unintended consequences of AI deployment

– Ensuring AI benefits are equitably distributed across societies

4. Ensuring a Safe and Inclusive Digital Space

Speakers emphasised the importance of creating a secure and inclusive digital environment, addressing concerns such as:

– Protecting against online harms, especially for women and children (Aminata Zerbo-Sabané)

– Combating misinformation and promoting information integrity, including the UN Global Principles for Information Integrity (United Nations Department of Global Communications)

– Safeguarding privacy and data protection (Dimitar Glavchev)

– Promoting digital rights and freedoms (International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance)

5. Fostering Digital Innovation and Cooperation

Participants stressed the importance of international cooperation and multi-stakeholder partnerships in addressing digital challenges. Key points included:

– Developing digital public infrastructure and goods, such as Bhutan’s national digital identity initiative (D.N. Dhungyel)

– Promoting open source and interoperable solutions (Alar Karis)

– Enhancing international cooperation on digital issues (Charlotta Schlyter)

– Supporting digital entrepreneurship and startups (Linda Bonyo)

– Facilitating knowledge sharing and technology transfer (D.N. Dhungyel)

The Global Digital Compact

Many speakers highlighted the significance of the Global Digital Compact as a framework for addressing digital challenges and opportunities. Key aspects of the GDC discussed included:

– Its holistic approach to digital development and governance

– Focus on bending technology to serve the public interest

– Emphasis on multi-stakeholder cooperation and implementation

– Potential to accelerate progress towards the SDGs through digital means

Key Takeaways and Action Items

The dialogue resulted in several key takeaways and action items:

– Adoption of the Global Digital Compact as a framework for digital cooperation and AI governance

– Establishment of a Global Digital Dialogue on AI Governance

– Creation of a Scientific Panel on AI

– Launch of an AI Capacity Building Fund

– Commitment to develop digital skills training programs, particularly for underserved communities

– Pledge to invest in digital infrastructure to expand connectivity in developing countries

– Emphasis on creating inclusive AI development processes

Unresolved Issues and Future Considerations

Despite the progress made, several issues remain unresolved and require further attention:

– Specific mechanisms for financing digital infrastructure development in low-income countries

– Detailed frameworks for ethical AI development and deployment across different contexts

– Concrete measures to address the gender gap in technology access and skills

– Strategies to ensure AI benefits are equitably distributed and do not exacerbate existing inequalities

– Methods to effectively combat online misinformation and protect information integrity globally

– Balancing innovation with data protection and privacy concerns in diverse cultural contexts

Conclusion

In his closing remarks, Amandeep Singh Gill, UN Secretary-General’s Envoy on Technology, emphasised that the Global Digital Compact represents a breakthrough for implementation. He stressed the need to go beyond silos and institutions, working across geography, levels, sectors, and actors to implement the GDC effectively. Gill highlighted the GDC’s holistic approach and its focus on bending technology to the public interest as key strengths. This call for a new threshold of multi-stakeholder cooperation set the stage for future action and continued collaboration in realising an inclusive, sustainable, and equitable digital future for all.

Session Transcript

Mohamed Muizzu: Excellencies, distinguished delegates, distinguished participants, I call to order Interactive Dialogue 3, entitled Towards a Common Digital Future, Strengthening Inclusive Innovation and Cooperation to Bridge the Digital Divides. I’m delighted and honoured to co-chair this interactive dialogue together with my esteemed co-chair, His Excellency Alar Karis , President of Estonia, and we warmly welcome all of you participating in this dialogue this morning. This dialogue brings together member states and other relevant stakeholders to discuss the theme, Towards a Common Digital Future, Strengthening Inclusive Innovation and Cooperation to Bridge the Digital Divides, in accordance with the concept note circulated online on 14 August by the President of the General Assembly, and in keeping with the terms of Assembly Resolution 76, Oblique 307, on the modalities for the summit of the future, and Decision 77, Oblique 568, on the scope of the summit. Joining us on the podium today are Ms. Doreen Bogdan-Martin, Secretary General of the International Telecommunication Union, Mr. Juan M. Lavista Ferres, Corporate Vice President and Chief Data Scientist of the AI for Good Lab at Microsoft, and Ms. Linda Bonyo, Founder of the Lawyers Hub, who will join the co-chairs in setting the scene for this dialogue. Mr. Amandeep Singh Gill, United Nations Secretary-General’s envoy on technology, will deliver closing remarks. Excellencies, distinguished delegates, distinguished participants, I now have the pleasure to invite my fellow co-chair, His Excellency Alar Karis, President of Estonia, to make some introductory remarks.

Alar Karis: Thank you, Chair. Excellencies, distinguished delegates, distinguished participants, the theme of this dialogue resonates deeply with my country’s journey and our deep commitment to exploiting digital technologies for the betterment of society. Estonia has focused on digital innovation to accelerate the fulfillment of sustainable development goals, to bridge digital divides, and to empower all individuals. Our success story, if I can humbly say, is a great reminder of how digital technologies can transform a society, any society. Because of our difficult history, we are now fully committed to transparency, openness, and innovation. It has allowed our economy, especially our start-up ecosystem, to flourish, made our public governance more efficient, accessible, and reliable. And it has certainly put our education, health care, tax, and election systems quality to a new level. All of this can be copied or shared if you embrace open source and interoperable solutions to make digital options adaptable and scalable. So that all countries can benefit. Estonia’s approach has been to build holistic digital public infrastructure that benefits both public and private sectors. One example of this is our data exchange platform, what we call X-Road. It enables us to securely exchange data between different actors, from private banks to public offices. Today, X-Road is implemented in over 20 countries around the world. X-Road, being developed and managed by the Nordic Institute of Interoperability Solutions, is also a great example of cross-border cooperation among states. It enables data exchange between Estonia, Finland, and Iceland. We believe in the benefit of co-creating, reusing, and co-developing already existing solutions to save resources and avoid duplication. It should be our common guiding principle to bridge the divides, whilst multistakeholder cooperation and partnerships, both domestically and globally, are the foundation of an open digital society. Cooperation is important to mobilize resources and to engage in capacity building. It is the fastest way to ensure that no one is left behind, especially in developing countries. And this is especially true when it comes to artificial intelligence that holds immense potential for accelerating the sustainable development goals. But we can all only leverage the benefits if all stakeholders are around the table. In conclusion, the journey towards a common digital future is something we must take together. And luckily, we now have a global digital compact to guide us. guide us on that journey. Estonia stands ready to continue sharing its experiences and working to ensure that digital technologies are exploited for the benefit of all. Thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank my esteemed co-chair for his statement. Allow me at this point to make a few personal national remarks as it relates to the theme of this dialogue. Excellencies, distinguished delegates, at the fourth international conference on seats earlier this year, I said the future is intelligence-driven. Since then, artificial intelligence has advanced at a pace that even experts struggle to keep up with. Yet, the pressing reality is that over one-third of the global population remains disconnected from the internet, particularly in developing countries. This digital divide is not only about access to internet. It is a profound barrier to development, opportunity, and justice. For SEADs, LDCs, and LLDCs, the digital divide exacerbates existing vulnerabilities. To bridge this divide and achieve the objectives of the Global Digital Compact, I urge all participants in this interactive dialogue to identify policies and actions that ensure no country, no one, is left behind. I would like to offer three suggestions. First, we must prioritize initiatives that empower young people to participate in the digital economy. In the Maldives, we are committed to investing in digital skilling and re-skilling to fuel local innovation and drive economic diversification, supporting MSMEs and freelance workers to gain access to global workforce and marketplaces. We believe that this will enable the youth to take the lead in digital transformation. Second, we must build the necessary digital infrastructure. Digital technologies and innovation are necessary to achieve the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. We can achieve the SDGs by adopting best practices from both developing and developed countries. This includes investing in expanding high-speed Internet coverage, enhancing digital access to essential services, and integrating AI to boost productive capacity. In the Maldives, the National Center for Information Technology is undertaking several initiatives in these areas. We must also invest in capacity building, encourage technology transfer, and boost investment and financing towards these efforts. Third, as we embrace digitalization, we must safeguard consumer rights. Challenges related to unauthorized access, account hijacking, and data privacy are real. To address challenges in the Maldives, we have established the National Cyber Security Agency to address security concerns that arise in digitalization. We of course need resources for a resilient cybersecurity infrastructure to complement and support our own efforts. Ambitious actions in this area demand international cooperation, investment, and genuine partnerships. The Maldives is committed to building a digital world that is inclusive, resilient, and just. I look forward to hearing countries’ experiences, best practices, and challenges in this dialogue today. Together, we can harness the digital revolution towards our common future. Thank you. Excellencies, distinguished delegates, I now have the pleasure to invite our distinguished special invitees to make some scene-setting remarks before we proceed to the list of speakers for this dialogue. I kindly remind them of the time limit of three minutes for statements. I first invite Ms. Bogdan-Martin, Secretary General of the International Telecommunication Union.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, good morning. We live in a world of unprecedented digital opportunities, a world where AI can mitigate 10% of greenhouse gas emissions by 2030, where about 60 satellites take to the skies on average each week, where digital ID can unlock economic value equivalent to up to 13% of GDP. In this world, game-changing digital solutions can accelerate 70% of the SDG targets. But it’s also a world where 2.6 billion people are still offline, where cyber attacks surge by 80% every year, where many, in particular women, can’t afford a smartphone because entry-level handsets exceed 70% of their monthly incomes in many countries, where only 24% of digital waste is formally collected, where 85% of ITU member states don’t yet have an AI policy. Ladies and gentlemen, behind these statistics are real people, like Luis, a young ALS patient who joined the AI for Good Global Summit last year. Luis lost his ability to speak, but not his voice, thanks to AI. And Brianna, who said that all children have the same rights when the Giga Initiative helped to connect her school to the Internet. Yesterday, the UNSG challenged us. He challenged us all to put humanity’s best interests front and center in new technologies. He reminded us that we will be judged not by our agreements but by our actions. ITU, as the UN Agency for Digital Technologies, stands ready to support the implementation of the Global Digital Compact. We back our words with actions, bold and collective actions. From the Giga Initiative, ITU and UNICEF, to connect every school to the Internet by 2030, to the early warnings for all initiative protecting the most vulnerable from climate change, to our new collaboration on standards to stop the spread of AI-driven misinformation and deepfakes. Excellencies, we are in a race against time. Let’s align digital inclusion with the pace of digital transformation. Let’s balance regulation with innovation. Let’s give everyone a seat and a voice at the table. This is the test before us, our greatest test ever. Our destiny is in our hands, and the digital future is now. Thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the Secretary-General of the International Telecommunication Union. We will now hear from Mr. Juan Lavista-Ferres, Corporate Vice President and Chief Data Scientist of the AI for Good Lab at Microsoft.

Juan M. Lavista Ferres: Thank you, Co-Chairs, Mr. Presidents, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, for the opportunity to join this important dialogue, All Protocols Observed. The challenges we face today are global and complex. No single government or organization can solve them alone. International cooperation is crucial. but equally important is the participation of civil society and the private sector. At Microsoft, we have seen how digital technology can drive progress towards sustainable development goals. But technology must be more than just powerful. It must be trustworthy, safe, and inclusive. It’s only when technology empowers everyone, especially the most vulnerable, that we can fully unlock its potential. These beliefs drive our efforts. This is why we have developed an open-source map of agricultural land to improve food security, offering vital insights into where food is grown and what crops are cultivated. In some areas, AI isn’t just a solution, but it’s the only solution. For instance, diabetic leuropathy is the leading cause of blindness worldwide. With 450 million people suffering from diabetes, but only 200,000 ophthalmologists globally, it’s impossible for doctors to diagnose every case. Here, AI offers a scalable solution that can transform healthcare and lives. We’re also proud to partner with the United Nations on early warning for all initiative. In natural disasters, every minute counts. Timely information can mean the difference between life and death. By combining satellite, AI, and human expertise, we have supported real-time relief efforts with partners like University of Washington, Institute of Health Metrics, and Planet Labs. But no early warning system can help the 2.6 billion people who remained unconnected. That’s why we have partnered with Doreen and her team at the ITU to map vulnerable, unconnected communities, ensuring everyone has access to emergency notifications. At Microsoft, we believe that benefits of AI and technology should extend to every part of the world. We can’t afford to repeat the mistakes of the past, where general-purpose technology took too long to reach those who need it the most. Nearly 150 years after electricity was first introduced in New York, 750 million people still lack access to it, and a third of the world remains offline, including up to two-thirds of Africa. In the digital age, these delays are unacceptable. That’s why Microsoft is committed to making AI and technology accessible to all, especially in the global south. As part of our pledge to the ITU’s Partner to Connect initiative, we will bring high-speed Internet to 250 million people by 2025, including 100 million in Africa. This will connect more people to healthcare, education, and economic opportunities while promoting safe digital practice and fundamental rights. But connectivity alone isn’t enough. People need the skills to use AI effectively. That’s why, by 2025, we are committed to equipping 25 million people with AI skills, with a special focus on underserved communities, including 5 million women and individuals in the global south. As connectivity grows, we must also strengthen cybersecurity. Governments and tech companies must work together to create a safer digital world. Looking ahead, I hope the summit lays the foundation for a global framework for AI governance, with human rights as its core. At Microsoft, we remain committed to expanding access to digital infrastructure and skills, ensuring the benefits of AI reach everyone. Thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the Corporate Vice President and Chief Data Scientist of the AI for Good Lab at Microsoft. I now invite Ms. Linda Bonyo, founder of the Lawyers’ Hub, to make a statement.

Linda Bonyo: Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen. Africa’s innovation performance has been amazing. We power content moderation online. If you have followed the news on artificial intelligence, Africa has constantly powered the very low-value chain on artificial intelligence. But no African country was ranked in the top 40 of the Global Innovation Index. Actually, the bottom 10 least innovative countries are all African. We still struggle with electricity, and this has been mentioned by Microsoft. But I would want to highlight today two matters that I think really should concern us. One is on the startup ecosystem. There’s a constant tussle and divide between big tech companies and startup ecosystems, and how to power local startup ecosystems to grow within our countries. At the Lawyers’ Hub, we welcome the global digital compact, especially on the commitments on empowering young people, empowering micro and small businesses within the digital economy. Secondly, in pursuit of this common digital future, we face the great issue of global mobility. Despite representing the vast majority of the world’s populations, professionals from Africa, Latin America, and Asia really face barriers when attempting to engage or participate in such global forums. We must confront the issue of visa regimes and mobility. Data cannot travel faster than human beings. I want to suggest today that, by contrast, if we look at the amount of monies that we are losing, especially for startup founders from the Global South who are looking to set up businesses, looking to fundraise, are losing all these monies in visa regimes and visa applications. This is something that we need to talk about. So what must we do to close the digital divide? Number one, we must close the data gap. Data has to be representative. It has to be black, it has to be white, it has to be Global North, and it has to be Global South. We recognize that the common data standards and interoperable data exchanges can increase the sharing of data and help close these data divides. Number two, we must have a holistic approach towards coordination to avoid duplicity, which is something that has been mentioned in the Global Digital Compact and hopeful that the UN institutions will be able to guide us in these policy dialogues. But then finally, on fostering open and inclusive non-discriminatory digital environments, we must be able to engage with small and medium businesses, especially start-ups, to look at how to deploy this. We also must deploy digital public infrastructure to close the digital divide, especially in the Global South. We have a youth bonus. Let us raise these digital natives that spar the continent, especially those in the Global South, out of poverty. And we also must avoid tokenism. When we talk about digital divide, we do not see commitments. There must be commitments that ensure that we do not have tokenisms. At the Lawyers’ Hub, we are working to bridge this divide, especially the digital policy divide, by running the Africa Digital Policy Institute and building the capacity of policymakers, lawyers, and bar associations to ensure that they ably participate and make regulations that close this digital divide. And finally, recently, we launched Africa’s first AI Policy Lab, with support from the Patrick J. McGovern Foundation, and this is geared towards ensuring that there is no data gap that will help us to get into policymaking. We are committed to developing digital policy talent across the African continent, and it is time for us to show up and ensure that we close the digital divide by actual commitments in digital policy. Thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the founder of the Lawyers’ Hub. At this point, I would like to invite my fellow co-chair to take over the chair.

Alar Karis: I thank my eminent co-chair, His Excellency Dr. Mohamed Muizzu, for his efficient manner in which he has guided our proceedings during the opening segment of this dialogue. Excellencies and distinguished delegates, before I open the floor, I would like to inform that all the statements are to be made from your seat. The time limit for statements is three minutes. minutes, and due to a limited time available, this will be strictly implemented through the automatic microphone cutoff when the speaker’s allotted time elapses. The red light on the speaker’s microphone will start to blink 30 seconds before the end of the allotted speaker’s time of three minutes, and the microphone will be automatically shut down. I thank all speakers in advance for their cooperation. In the interest of time, delegations with long statements are strongly encouraged to deliver summarized versions of a statement and to submit the full text to estatements at UN.org to be posted in the UN journal as part of a record of our proceedings. I now open the floor for statements by delegations inscribed on the list of speakers for this meeting. I give the floor to His Excellency, Mr. Dimitar Glavchev, from Bulgaria. The floor is yours.

Dimitar Glavchev: Honorable Mr. Co-Chair, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, today we stand at an important moment in history as we explore how to harness digital technologies to promote sustainable development, enhance inclusion, and ensure a secure digital space for everyone. Digital technologies, when leveraged effectively, offer transformative potential for fostering sustainable development of a balanced and inclusive manner. These technologies tackle challenges like climate change and financial inclusion by boosting efficiency and innovation and resource management and poverty alleviation. They enhance resilience and economic empowerment by by expanding financial inclusion and job opportunities, especially in underserved areas. Governments should invest in regional digital infrastructure and promote engagement through a whole-of-government approach for effective policy development. In Bulgaria, in 2022, launched the Institute for Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence and Technologies at Sofia University in collaboration with Swiss universities, which highlights our commitment to technological innovation and attracts for all talents. Achieving these goals demands robust multi-stakeholder collaboration and capacity building. Governments, businesses, academia and civil society must unite to enhance technological and scientific capacity and close the digital divide. The EU Connecting Europe Facility exemplifies how joint efforts can advise critical digital infrastructure. The Bulgaria-Greece-Serbia 5G Corridor Initiative demonstrates how such partnerships can boost connectively and address digital disparities. To create an inclusive, open and secure digital space, we must prioritize protection and equity. It’s crucial to safeguard all individuals, especially women and children, from online harms. Bulgaria’s approach to balancing cyber security, digital interests and personal data protection, expanding digital infrastructure, particularly in underserved areas, is essential for equal access to the digital economy, including education, healthcare and economic opportunities. In conclusion, let me thank you for your attention and for your participation in this event.

Alar Karis: I thank His Excellency Dimitar Glavchev for his statement. And now I give the floor to His Excellency Xavier Espot Zamora from Andorra, please.

Xavier Espot Zamora: Thank you very much. Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen, at the present time, humankind is seeing a digital revolution. It’s changed how human beings interact and their way of life. All changes bring risks and opportunities and need time for adaptation. The Neolithic revolution lasted 1,000 years, the Industrial Revolution around 200 years, and the current revolution is advancing at such a rate that it will have reached its conclusion in around 100 years. We therefore need to find a common digital future. This is an urgent need because there’s a direct link between digitalization and economic, social and cultural progress. Regrettably though, digitalization is not universal. The COVID-19 pandemic has made our weaknesses clear. Lockdowns have shown how parts of the populations have not had access to digital technologies, which has led to a massive gap emerging. Because of this, it is absolutely necessary to establish shared principles for an open, safe and equal and accessible digital future, which is accessible to all. Ladies and gentlemen, mindful of this gap, Andorra this year has launched the first public-private forum for the digital transition to ensure that the digital transition is an instrument for progress and responds to the commitments we saw in the Ibero-American summit held in Andorra in 2021. This forum shows the desire of my country to show its know-how and knowledge to make progress with universal connectivity and contribute to the implementation of the global digital compact of the United Nations. Andorra has learned a great deal over these recent years. We have also much to offer, even if we’re a small country, only perhaps because of our small size. We are one of the best connected territories in the world, with 96% of our inhabitants having access to the Internet. We have also demonstrated prudence in response of all citizens. The digital transition has the potential to become a vital tool for attaining the SDGs. With that in mind, the implementation of our national strategy for the digital transition by 2030 allows us to note that digital initiatives clearly contribute to improving educational processes, to making progress towards gender equality, to boosting economic progress, decent work and achieving peace, justice and the consolidation of institutions. The environment and the digital sector are becoming the backbone of our societies and critical elements to reach sustainable development. As such, this is a challenge which can only be faced down. The speaker was cut off.

Alar Karis: I thank His Excellency Mr Zamora from Andorra and now I give the floor to His Excellency Edi Rama from Albania.

Edi Rama: Thank you very much. I will try to be as short as you wish, starting by saying that digital technology, with its promise for exponential progress, is a bless for developing countries and we in Albania have seen it in our real life and through our endeavours, becoming a place where 95% of services today are online and all the front offices and the long queues are history. On the other hand, we are seeing it in developing a model with artificial intelligence to push much faster our negotiations with the European Union for the EU membership, as we are seeing it also in building a new model for completely transparent and 95% unmanned public procurement. On the other hand, of course, digital technology is not just a bless but also a curse. cyber attacks, and Albania was victim of a very harsh cyber attack from Iran, and we witnessed in our real life how much this type of new world based on technology can be harmful to countries and citizens. But at the end, there is no doubt that if we will be able to create a system where the world and the community of nations will get the best out of the promises of the digital technology, and at the same time will tame all the downsides and the detrimental effects that can come from the malicious use of it, the world will be a much better place. Thank you very much, and I hope I got your sympathy, Mr. Chairman, by being so short.

Alar Karis: Thank you very much, Mr. Prime Minister, and now I, at this point, turn it over to my co-chair

Mohamed Muizzu: to preside over the meeting, please. I thank my esteemed co-chair. We will continue with our list of speakers. I now give the floor to His Excellency Patrice Emery Trovoada, Prime Minister of the Democratic Republic of São Tomé and Príncipe, in principle.

Patrice Emery Trovoada: Thank you, Mr. Co-Chair, ladies and gentlemen, delegates, all protocols respected, and also my three minutes, I respect them too. The African continent is often seen from the negative lens of economic and social problems, but it is also an incredible source of opportunities and innovation adapted to its unique needs, with a population which exceeds one billion inhabitants. Its human capital is a major force facilitating the digital future, as well as the economic future of the globe. Innovation we have seen in Africa has shown that Africa is not just a passive consumer of technologies, but rather a creator of models inspiring the rest of the world. Digitalization at a cross-cutting level is the driving force of global development in the future of our continent. Africa is particularly vulnerable to the impact of climate change, but it can also be a model using the digital sector to overcome environmental challenges for the management of natural resources, sustainable agriculture and the environment. the prediction of natural disasters. Innovative solutions such as precision agriculture or using drones to monitor lands which have been used can help to smartly use resources, making the future safer, and particularly food security. Africa has around 60 percent of the world’s arable land, and it also makes us able to combat climate change at a global level. Because of this, my government has just created the Conservation Trust Fund. The goal of which is to consolidate nature and the environment as economic assets. However, Africa also faces basic challenges specific to the continent, such as access to the Internet. We want to see digitalization. This affects digitalization, education, health, and has a broad impact across the globe. Nevertheless, this is a challenge to private actors. We can have public-private partnerships with a clear goal to ensure equitable digital access for all African citizens so that nobody is left behind in this transformation. The demographics speak for themselves. In a country such as mine, we are deeply attached to freedom of expression and combating disinformation, hate speech, and foreign interference on social media platforms. There is a risk of fragmentation of the Internet or splinternet because of national regulation. This threatens the unity of the global Internet and makes it more difficult to access information at a time when inspiring critical thinking via education, in our view, is critical for the progress of our respective societies, ensuring social cohesion and inclusion. My country and my country, continent Africa, cannot. The speaker was cut off.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank His Excellency Patrice Emery of the Democratic Republic of São Tomé and Príncipe for his statement. And now I give the floor to His Excellency Jonas Gahr Støre, Prime Minister of Norway.

Jonas Gahr Støre: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you for this opportunity, delegates, excellencies and colleagues. We have to deal with the world as it is, and I believe we can agree that access to digital technologies now means really how we can secure opportunities for all. We now know that digital cooperation is absolutely key to ensure that individual businesses and civil society can benefit from progress. Among such challenges that we are dealing with is climate change, global health crisis, and much more. Digital public goods are essential tools in tackling these and other risks. But they are linked. And we know, Mr. President, that digital services consume a lot of electricity. And I just come from a meeting where we are addressing the fact that 600 million people in Africa don’t have access to electricity. So I’d just like to call the attention to the initiative by the World Bank and the African Development Bank of providing 300 million people in Africa with electricity by the end of this century – by this decade, sorry, by 2030 – is part of this challenge. The UK provides and promotes financing for digital public goods in sectors such as climate and weather forecasting, agriculture, and health systems. We also help support digital public goods that help countries build essential platforms across all sectors, including digital identity and civil registration systems. And I’m happy to see that this technology can spread to all continents. They are critical for inclusion, particularly women and other groups that risk exclusion. Building safe, trusted, and inclusive digital infrastructure for all is absolutely central for leaving no one behind. And then, being here at the UN, Mr. President, multi-stakeholder collaboration and partnership has to be there for us to succeed. The Digital Public Good Alliance is a great example, with more than 40 members from countries, UN institutions, civil society, and the private sector. This alliance facilitates the discovery and deployment of open-source technology with the aim to accelerate progress towards the SDGs. And I believe it is inspiring and a really learning experience to see that digital public good developed in Sierra Leone to pay health workers during the Ebola crisis is now being used in the Philippines. And closer to home, I noted that COVID tracking tool first developed in Sri Lanka proved useful to Norwegian municipalities. in my country. So this is a learning experience. So, dear friends, we must remember that all human rights fully apply in the digital space. There is no exception. And this is being challenged. Digital technologies should be designed to minimize the risk of violating rights and doing harm, in particular to minors and children. They must be safe to use and meet the needs of all users.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank Excellency Jonas Gahr Støre, Prime Minister of Norway, for his statement. And now I give the floor to His Excellency Micheál Martin, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs and Defence of Ireland.

Micheál Martin: Many thanks, Chairperson. I’m delighted to contribute to this important discussion on strengthening inclusive innovation and cooperation to bridge digital divides. Yesterday, we adopted the Pact for the Future, the most wide-ranging international agreement in many years. And this pact and its annexes, the Global Digital Compact and the Declaration on Future Generations, amount to a step change in how the multilateral system responds to the opportunities and challenges facing our global community. And now that the pact has been agreed, our task as world leaders is to implement it, here at the United Nations and across our regions and countries, as we build a more sustainable, just and peaceful global order. Ireland strongly welcomes the Global Digital Compact. Our focus now should be on working together for its implementation. unite the international community in support of the multi-stakeholder action required to overcome digital divides. New and emerging technologies is changing the way we live and work and can pose challenges. Artificial intelligence, for example, has the potential to amplify disinformation and to erode hard-won freedoms. However, it also creates a wealth of opportunity. In order to realise the positive potential of emerging technologies, we must take a human rights-based approach and ensure compliance with international law. Ireland has experienced first-hand the transformative power of technological advancement and the emergence of our modern digital world. We now strive to ensure that a digital approach informs our work with partner countries towards their development goals. Through diverse programmes, Ireland is partnering to reduce the digital divide. In Malawi, we are supporting projects to address the gender digital divide through the Malawi Girls Can Code Too initiative. In Vietnam, artificial intelligence is being used to detect changes in mangrove cover in order to protect and expand forests affected by climate change. And the Irish Tech Challenge South Africa fosters connections between the South African and Irish tech ecosystems. A common digital future also requires us to close digital divides within countries. We must include a diverse range of voices in this debate around our common digital future. It is vital that those most affected by emerging technologies have a strong voice in shaping outcomes. As we move towards 2030, Ireland believes that the transformative power of emerging technologies has the potential to help us deliver sustainable development and to create opportunities for global peace and prosperity. I believe the Pact for the Future that we have now agreed collectively provides the basis for this important work. work. The test will be, of course, in its implementation.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank His Excellency Micheál Martin of Ireland. At this point I hand over to my eminent co-chair to preside over the meeting. I thank my esteemed co-chair. We will continue with the list of speakers. And now I give the floor to His Excellency Saleumxay Kommasith, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs of Laos People’s Democratic Republic.

Saleumxay Kommasith: Thank you, Mr. Chair, Mr. Co-Chair. The advancement of digital innovation serves as a pivotal accelerator for the achievement of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. UN member states are embracing digitalization to foster socio-economic development ranging from production, trade, finance, to service, among others. However, while many countries, particularly countries in special situations, are making significant strides in adapting digital technology, there is still a big gap among countries in this digital transformation. This digital divide can deepen existing inequality while also hampering access to resource and opportunity. Therefore, bridging this divide requires concerted effort to address barriers such as limited infrastructure, digital literacy, and affordability, ensuring that no one is left behind in this journey towards sustainable development powered by digital innovation. Despite these efforts, continual international technical and financial support and collaboration remain crucial, particularly in developing digital infrastructure and building human resource capacity in science, technology, and innovation. In this regard, the Lao PDR urges development partners to intensify efforts to enhance cooperation. mechanism in an initiative that increase capacity humans mutual support in research, development, and applications of science, technology, and innovation. Mr. President, in order to bridge the digital divide, we believe that enhancing north-south cooperation, south-south and triangular cooperation, provide ample opportunities and mutual benefit for all. By developing human resources, sharing best practice and lessons learned, including transferring technical and technological know-how, by taking into account the actual needs and circumstances of each country, as well as increasing investment in teachers and higher education, research and development, we will be able to significantly enhance our technological capability, meet the demands of skilled workforce, and advance sustainable development globally. I thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: Thank you, Mr. Kommasith. And now I give the floor to Her Excellency Esther Dweck, Minister of Management and Innovation in Public Services of Brazil. The floor is yours.

Esther Dweck: Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair, Excellencies, distinguished delegates, ladies and gentlemen. The future is digital, but it needs also to be green and inclusive. Therefore, we must drive a fair digital revolution and advance the transformation of public institutions. Innovative solutions for climate mitigation and adaptation, alongside the promotion of diversity and equity, are essential for sustainable societies. Recognizing the central role of digital transformation in an inclusive and sustainable development, Brazil, under its present Lula leadership, is committed to a triple transition – digital, social and ecological – as a strategy to tackle systemic inequalities. During our G20 Presidency, we focused on digital inclusion, understanding its vital role for global economic growth and for regional development. In order to promote digital inclusion, we must ensure meaningful and affordable connectivity and develop digital skills that are crucial for leaving no country and no one behind. As we integrate digital technology into every aspect of life, we have observed exponential growth of disinformation, misogyny and all sorts of discrimination and demystification of hate speech in social media. We must implement robust policies that protect users from online harms, particularly vulnerable groups like women and children. Concerning digital government, Brazil has strengthened the concept of digital public infrastructure, which integrates data and services into public policies, such as digital payment, digital identities and safe data sharing. Two important Brazilian DPIs, the Unified Register for Social Policy and our digital ID, linked to the gov.br platform, played a crucial role during natural disasters in Rio Grande do Sul state. The government issued more than 2.3 million financial assistance, showcasing the power of digital tools in crisis response. Environmental Registry is another vital Green DPI that combats deforestation, promotes environmental restoration, allows traceability and protects the right of indigenous population and local communities. Soon, it will also be integrated in carbon market policies. In the G20 Digital Economy discussion, Brazil proposed also the topic of information integrity. For the first time, we reached a high-level consensus on the importance of transparency and liability for digital platforms, and on the necessity of promoting resilient and diversifying information environment. Brazil is also engaged in the responsible and ethical development and use of artificial intelligence. Achieving these goals requires collaboration across government, civil society, the private sector and multilateral organizations. Our national AI plans include developing autonomous capacity in the field and launching a Portuguese-language LLM which respects intellectual property rights and cultural heritage. We reaffirm our commitment to promoting a fair and equal digital future, and we are here to collaborate with other global voices to ensure a planet for all. Together, we must act now for a sustainable and inclusive digital future. Thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank Her Excellency Ms. Dweck for her statement, and now give the floor to His Excellency Minister of Economy, Planning and Development, Pavel Isa Contreras, from the Dominican Republic.

Pavel Isa Contreras: Good morning, Excellencies. We are at a crucial juncture in history where digital technologies have transformed our societies and economies and the way in which we relate to each other. This matter could not be more relevant, moving towards a totally digital era, closing the huge gaps for technical access and ownership within our countries and beyond our own borders. is key. The digital revolution threatens to leave many behind. Overcoming these difficulties requires a collective effort. In the Dominican Republic, we’ve made notable progress with rolling out digital infrastructure with implementation of 4G and 5G networks, as well as with expanding fiber optic fiber networks and the JIGA ITU-UNICEF initiative. However, to make a lasting impact, we know that we need to continue to maintain infrastructure in a sustainable fashion. Over recent years, the Dominican government has prioritized digitalization of public services. Now, thanks to public digital infrastructure, citizens can do paperwork online and participate in decision making in a more transparent and direct fashion. In the private sphere, Dominican businesses have adopted digital solutions to boost their competitiveness. The pandemic accelerated the rise of e-commerce and remote work, which generated new opportunities. However, much remains to be done to guarantee that SMEs and MSMEs, rather, can have the necessary tools to compete in the digital economy. We cannot discuss the digital economy without talking about the importance of digital education. The Dominican Republic has chosen programs which cover use of the Internet, cybersecurity, and also AI. Only with a robust educational system will we be able to ensure that our people are prepared for the challenges of tomorrow. Closing the digital divide is a task which cannot be achieved by one country alone, or one region alone. This is a shared responsibility. Regional initiatives such as the ITU, the EU, and others are examples of how we can work together to ensure that digital innovations are available to all. future, but it is only by working together that we will be able to guarantee that nobody is left behind. We must continue to promote exchange of know-how, developing infrastructure, ensuring that there’s connectivity and that public policies are aligned with the needs of today’s digital world. From the connectivity of rural areas to cybersecurity, we need to work together to achieve real and lasting change. We are committed to do so. Thank you very much.

Alar Karis: I thank His Excellency, Pavel Isa Contreras, and at this point I hand over to my eminent co-chair to preside over the meeting. I thank my esteemed co-chair.

Mohamed Muizzu: We will continue with our list of speakers. I now give the floor to His Excellency, D.N. Dhungyel, from Bhutan, Minister of Foreign Affairs and External Trade.

Lyonpo D.N. Dhungyel: Co-chairs, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, in 1999, Bhutan took its first steps into the digital world, being one of the last countries to introduce the internet and television. Since then, technology has rapidly transformed our nation, accelerating Bhutan’s transition from isolation to global integration and unlocking new opportunities for growth. This year, Bhutan adopted its national digital strategy, a roadmap aimed at solving key challenges like urban congestion, climate change, and expanding digital payments to boost local economies. Central to this transformation is our national digital identity. In 2023, Bhutan became the first nation to establish a legal framework for self-sovereign identity. The NDI will serve as the foundation for delivering all public services digitally, ensuring effective and secure access for every citizen. Bhutan is eager to share this technology with our neighbors and world while learning from global experiences in digital innovation. However, technology’s benefits are not yet equally shared. Allow me to emphasize three key areas where action is crucial to promote inclusive digital progress. Number one, global partnerships. Bridging the digital divide requires collaboration. We believe that fostering global partnerships, we can enrich technological research, facilitate the exchange of skilled labor, and build local capacity for hands-on learning. Second, inclusivity. It’s vital that everyone, regardless of the background, can access and use digital technologies. In Bhutan, 34% of the population, including the illiterate, have received digital skills training, with our youth leading the way in sharing knowledge within their communities. Third is digital security. As digital services expand, so do vulnerabilities. Ensuring a safe and secure online environment is critical. Bhutan is enhancing digital literacy, enforcing strong policies to deter online threats and safeguarding the most vulnerable through regular threat assessment. In conclusion, we must reaffirm our commitment to building an inclusive digital future that leaves no one behind. By working together, we can harness the power of technology for the betterment of all. Thank you very much.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank His Excellency D.N. Dhungyel, Minister of Foreign Affairs and External Trade of Bhutan, and now give the floor to Her Excellency Aminata Zerbo-Sabané from Burkina Faso, Minister of Digital Transition, Post and Electronic Communications.

Aminata Zerbo-Sabané: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, Your Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, we live at a time of great uncertainty having to do with the many challenges that the world is encountering, but we can hope because we live also through the time of the digital. It’s not just a simple tool, it becomes a catalyst of change and transforms our societies and our economy. Now, despite these prospects and the many efforts made by the countries of the south, the digital gap exists and compounds all other inequalities, and this is where collective responsibility lies, our responsibility for a common digital future. Ladies and gentlemen, my country, Burkina Faso, as you know, for a decade has had to deal with recurrent terrorist attacks, and I think you’ll agree with me when I say that restoring security and territorial integrity of the country is the number one national priority. Nonetheless, the government is convinced that the true response to terrorist barbarism is through development. Under the leadership of Captain Ibrahim Traore, head of state, the place occupied by the digital as a catalyst of inclusive development is affirmed daily. The government just last week enacted a large-scale project funded together with the World Bank to the tune of 100 billion to accelerate the development of infrastructure, modernize infrastructure, and cover rural areas and localities. Ladies and gentlemen, my country is convinced that the digital challenges has to be taken comprehensively, taking into account the interest of all actors, in particular when it comes to cybersecurity and fighting cybercrime, as well as when it comes to regulating the action of the private actor, as well as balancing this against the sovereignty of the state. And I would like to hear, welcome on behalf of the government of my country, the adoption of the Global Digital Camp, whose aim is to bridge the digital divide. divide. The issue of funding is fundamental here. At this stage, I would like to launch an appeal to the digital giants and say that you have the influence and the resources to contribute towards reducing the digital divide. So invite even to a greater extent in the infrastructures developing countries, support innovation locally, and access to technologies. And this will not be charity. This will be an investment and will become profitable because you will extend the number of your consumers by 2.6 billion people who are not connected today. I would like to insist on the urgency of the issue of fiscal justice. If we had that, we will be able to benefit from the tax revenues of digital giants. We need to build together and have international cooperation, which is sincere, win-win cooperation, and equitable if we want to have a world which is more connected.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank Her Excellency, Aminata Zerbo, from Brno-Kafaso. And now I’ll give the floor to His Excellency, Ville Tavio, Minister of Foreign Trade and Development, Finland.

Ville Tavio: Mr. President, Secretary-General, Excellencies, distinguished delegates, I would like to start by thanking Secretary-General António Guterres for his leadership and efforts to make the UN system fit for the future. This summit is a culmination point in this regard. You can count on Finland’s support for your work. Last year, at the SDG summit, we agreed to accelerate the implementation of our shared global goals. We now have the opportunity to look even further ahead to agree on the future we want. Technology has emerged as one of the key questions for global development. The digital transformation presents us with a wealth of opportunities that we need to grasp. At the same time, it presents us new… risks that we need to act on. The United Nations will have a key role in making sure we have the tools to manage this process in the years ahead. With growing threats to peace and security, we need to make sure technology is a force for good and not used to amplify conflicts and create further instability. This task is in the very core of the UN Charter and mission. The global digital compact comes at critical time. It’s almost 20 years since the world last came to an agreement on a framework for harnessing technology for development. This took place at the World Summit on Information Society in Geneva and Tunis. Since then, the digital landscape has changed dramatically. The global digital compact is a landmark agreement to update our shared principles and goals for advancing global digital development, outlining what we need to focus on now and in the future. Finland’s government considers technology to be an integral part of our foreign and security policy. We have a strong focus on digital development in our development policy, including increased attention to private sector solutions and investments. We are committed to working internationally for digital development that is fair, inclusive, and sustainable with respect for human rights and equality. We are pleased that our priorities, improving digital connectivity, governing emerging technologies, addressing the gender digital divide, investing in education and digital skills, and strengthening human rights are included in the compact. Globally, we are far from reaching the target of universal connectivity as set out by the agenda 2030. The global digital compact calls for more cooperation to close the persistent digital device, especially in remote and underserved areas. In this regard, I want to highlight the need to mobilize more private investment and capital to meet these needs. Without adequate infrastructure in place, the potential of digitalization remains locked in. The global digital compact should be not a political declaration only. We need to take concrete steps to implement it. This is not a task for the UN member states alone. We need multi-stakeholder cooperation.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank His Excellency Ville Tavio, Minister of Foreign Trade and Development of Finland. And now, give the floor to His Excellency Abdullah Alswaha, Minister of Communication and Information Technology of Saudi Arabia.

Abdullah Alswaha: Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, may the peace and blessings of God be upon you. Undoubtedly, the world today is living this great opportunity of digitalization as an economic multiplier. We have an opportunity from $6 to $10 trillion that we can take advantage of together if we work in a comprehensive way in artificial intelligence. But there are a number of jobs, millions of jobs, that will be threatened if we did not work in this comprehensive way. We are at a crossroads. Either artificial intelligence will be the biggest multiplier to bridge this gap or the biggest challenge towards extending this gap. The government of His Majesty the King and His Royal Highness have made efforts in order for us to be a pioneer in multilateral international cooperation to bridge these gaps, the social gap and the economic gap, as well as gaps in the future related to artificial intelligence. In terms of social gap, we have worked with ITU to conduct a study to connect the world that is unconnected through innovative solutions on planet and in space – on planet Earth and in space. And in terms of empowering women, we are proud to have had a great success story in the 21st century in terms of empowering women to reach 35 percent, going beyond the average of G20, the European Union and Silicon Valley. As for digital health, we have harnessed the virtual hospital model as a pioneering model around the world by serving more than 30 million pilgrims who come from over 100 countries of Saudi Arabia. And lately, we had the first first surgery that was conducted to transplant a heart using robots. As for economy, we are observer member and we cooperate with all organizations in this field in a participatory way to ensure that we have a prosperous digital economy for the region and for the three continents, Middle East, Asia, Europe, and Africa. As for artificial intelligence, we are proud to have Dr. Latif Abdel Latif, who is the first woman that represents us in the advisory body for artificial intelligence, and we are working together on the pact for the future so that we can harness this era of artificial intelligence in a comprehensive way to serve humanity and planet Earth. Thank you. Mr. Chairman.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank His Excellency Abdullah Alswaha, Minister of Communication and Information Technology of Saudi Arabia, and now give the floor to Her Excellency Ursula Owusu-Ekuful, Minister of Communication and Digitalization of Ghana.

Ursula Owusu-Ekuful: Co-Chairs, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, over the past decade, we’ve observed, discussed, and shared many insights and experiences, coming to the realization that access to digital technologies and services is no longer a luxury for the privileged few, but a human right for all, regardless of social status or geographical location. By utilizing digitalization to reduce inequalities experienced in accessing basic public services, it should be our priority to implement simple, people-centric digital initiatives that benefit all. Ghana is implementing the Digital Ghana Agenda to ensure that all public services across all sectors are digitalized to enhance transparency, access, accountability, and efficiency. Our digital economy policy and strategy identifies five main pillars, universal access and connectivity, digital skills, research, and digital entrepreneurship. Unfortunately, our government, like most, does not have the resources to address the widening connectivity and service acquisition gap with our private sector funding. As a critical component to our developmental goals in the medium to long term, we require partnerships that promote a win-win approach to implement initiatives that will bring connectivity and access to underserved and unserved communities within the next four years and beyond. By utilizing shared networks in partnership with our network operators, we’re extending connectivity to our rural populations and high-speed 4G and 5G broadband services nationwide. We’ve also set up a Girls in ICT Trust to narrow the gender digital divide. The transfer of technology and knowledge to our youth through the partnerships that we secure to ensure sustainability of digital interventions and reduction of over-dependence on foreign expertise is non-negotiable. Access to affordable digital devices and narrowing the usage gap due to inadequate digital skills is a major challenge, even where connectivity is available. The affordability of internet data can be significantly reduced if developing countries have internet exchange points within their countries and continents. This will minimize internet access routes and the attendant high cost of internet access in the global south. We owe it as a duty to support developing countries to catch up as digital technologies provide a level playing field for all the haves and have-nots. We must also work to reduce the cost of devices. Digital technologies come with their own attendant challenges, such as cyberattacks, mobile fraud, online abuse, misinformation, et cetera. We can mitigate some of these challenges through comprehensive awareness campaigns and knowledge sharing promoted through in-person encounters on social media and social media handles. Being aware is being empowered. Developing countries need flexible and affordable financing instruments.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank Her Excellency Ursula Owusu-Ekuful, Minister of Communication and Digitalization. At this point, I hand over to my eminent co-chair to proceed over the meeting. Thank you. I thank my esteemed co-chair, and we will continue with our list of speakers.

Alar Karis: I now give the floor to Her Excellency Savannah Maziya, Minister of Information, Communication and Technology from Eswatini.

Savannah Maziya: The theme of this summit is so very important to us and resonates with us as the Kingdom of Eswatini. Through the leadership of His Majesty, our view is that we must all collaborate and use this critical time to chart a way that will not only develop all our economies, but also ensure that we do so in a way that is fully inclusive and equitable. The digital future is the new oil, but it must be the new oil for everyone. In Eswatini, our avenue to inclusiveness means providing strong fiber-optic bandwidth and 5G for everyone as the foundation to the integrating of more than 200 services that the government offers, with our Government in Your Hand initiative, which allows all the services to be accessed through one’s phone or the nearest community center. This will result in reliable, robust, consistent, and cost-effective data and internet. Digital services and access therein are no longer a luxury. This will enable our businesses to be more productive and make social services more effective. As a country, we are looking at working with the youth as an integral part of our sustainable inclusiveness strategy, as they represent more than 60% of our population. We are also ensuring that as we develop, we remain responsible custodians of our natural resources for future generations. As we focus on developing local investors and attracting foreign ones through our robust incentives, we need to ensure that our population is not only appropriately skilled, but also we continuously focus on data sovereignty and data safety. We invite investors to be partners in strengthening our marginalized communities such as women, youth, and the disabled. This is an opportunity to use the digital space as the great equalizer and allow us to be truly inclusive. In a time when computers are asking us if we are robots, we are continuously asking ourselves if we are doing all that we can to ensure that MSWati are part of the solution in solving the world’s problems, utilizing the digital space, but also if we can solve their problems using the very same space. It is clear to us that we stand at a time in history where in our collaboration we can be truly equal, learn from our past exclusions, and forge a prudent path forward in the most exclusive and inclusive manner. In a time when machines may play a more prominent role in our lives, it is still incumbent upon us as humans to collaborate and for the first time in human history produce a world that is truly inclusive, equitable, and allowing all to have a fair and fighting chance. This is what will make all our plans for the digital future to be without division and to be sustainable. In all our deliberations during these sessions, I trust we all keep these as our focus areas. The world requires us to do so. We thank you for the opportunity to be heard.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank your excellency Savannah Maziya, Minister of Information, Communication and Technology of Eswatini. And now I give the floor to Her Excellency Maria da Graça Carvalho, Minister of Environment and Engineering of Portugal.

Maria da Graça Carvalho: Distinguished Co-Chairs, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen. What was only a short time ago, a distant vision, is now a reality that will surely shape our near future. The digital transformation is accelerating before our very eyes, particularly with the development of emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence. Digital technologies are catalysts for development and can support and accelerate the realization of the 2030 Agenda and its sustainable development goals. However, we acknowledge that digital divides are vast and deep, both within and between countries, risking, if we don’t act, that the digital transition could become a lever for inequalities rather than a tool for inclusive development. The idea that technology should benefit everyone should be our guiding compass. Digital literacy, capacity building and the promotion of local languages and digital contents are crucial to enable communities to fully participate in the digital domain. Digital cooperation and capacity building programs must be at the heart of a coordinated effort to achieve the SDGs, with special attention being paid to the most vulnerable countries, such as small island developing states, SEADs, least developed countries, LDCs and landlocked developing countries, LLDCs. That’s why, as part of its 2030 Development Cooperation Strategy, and drawing on its own experience in the digital transition, Portugal launched a UN-Portugal Digital Fellowship aimed at these countries. Portugal welcomes the adoption of the Pact for the Future and its global digital compact. We stand for a digital future that is shared, inclusive and human-centered, anchored in international law, human rights, and the UN Charter, and leaving no one behind. I thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank Her Excellency Maria da Graça Carvalho, Minister of Environment and Energy, Portugal. Now I give the floor to His Excellency Omran Sharaf , Assistant Minister for Science and Advanced Technology Affairs from United Arab Emirates.

Omran Sharaf: Co-Chairs, Excellencies, The United Arab Emirates is pleased to participate in the Summit of the Future, which marks a major milestone in reinvigorating our multilateral system. I thank Secretary-General Guterres for his constructive insights, as well as the co-facilitators of the Pact for the Future, the global digital compact, and the Declaration on Future Generation for their tireless work. Distinguished delegates, digital technologies are advancing at breakneck speed, and while these advances do indeed bring potential risks and threaten to widen the digital divide, they also provide significant opportunities in our collective pursuit of global peace, development, humanitarian assistance, and security. The UAE has a vision for a better world, a brighter future, through the leveraging of these transformative technologies. Yet this vision cannot ignore the potential blind spots in these rapid advancement, especially when it comes to access for over a third of the global population. risk getting stuck in a dangerous cycle of marginalization, poverty, and disadvantages that only further reinforces pre-existing inequalities and thus potentially heightening the threat of irresponsible actions on a global scale. Distinguished delegates, it’s not too late for us to apply a corrective lens to remedy this. As a responsible player in the international arena, the UAE is committed to bridging the digital divide. Doing so requires a multifaceted and comprehensive approach that involves collaboration and meaningful partnership building. The UAE foreign policy position on AI highlights the importance of fostering national and international partnership rooted in cooperation and transparency. So we can advance technologies and build capacity. We demonstrate this through initiatives that provide open source AI models that build sustainable ecosystems to accelerate technological innovation, establish data centers projects in Africa that leverage geothermal energy to power AI infrastructure, enabling developing nations with tools for technological advancement, develop diverse language models to serve underrepresented communities, ensuring AI benefits reach the global south. Distinguished delegates, the UAE, the use of AI for humanitarian action provides an anticipatory approach to predict and prepare ahead of outbursts of violence, climate change, and displacement. The application of AI can enable stakeholders to intervene before the outbreak of conflict. The UAE will continue to work with every partner and stakeholder here to ensure our global community benefits from these technologies. Let us collectively commit to bridging the digital divide and building a more inclusive future for everyone and everywhere. Thank you.

Alar Karis: Thank you. His Excellency Omran Sharaf, Assistant Minister for Science and Advanced Technology Affairs from United Arab Emirates. And now give the floor to the representative of the Russian Federation, Mr. Alexey Borisov. Please.

Alexey Borisov: We are today at a critical stage on our way to a common digital future. Digital technologies open up unprecedented opportunities for sustainable development. They help make it balanced and inclusive. And introducing these technologies broadens the opportunity for international cooperation on a very vast scope of issues. The experience we already have shows that the use of digital innovation and big data analysis opens up greater effectiveness when it comes to climate change and monitoring the state of the environment. And introducing digital banking services and financial and technical solutions opens up access to financial services, helps economic growth, and improves the stability of societies. Multilateral cooperation plays a key role in overcoming digital divide. Joint efforts by the governments of private sector, academia, and civil society in science, technology, and innovation help with economic growth and sustainable development. Our common goal is to have an open, just, inclusive, and non-discriminatory environment for scientific and technical development. We do recall that the three pillars of sustainable development are interconnected, we therefore have to pay due attention to its social component, mental health, and the unique nature of everyone. Keeping cultural diversity and personal identity is a key factor for creating inclusive, open, and safe digital environment. We need to protect our consumers, women and children first and foremost, from online threats. The key role here is to be played by the governments. They are to develop and introduce reliable policies, measures of information security, and increase the digital literacy of our people. The government’s goal is to create digital platforms which increase accessibility, inclusivity, and effectiveness of services. We also have reached, attained a great deal in the area of smart cities. In Moscow, we have more than 80 projects on the basis of artificial intelligence, ranging from public transport fares and ensuring public security, all the way to making preliminary diagnosis on the basis of health data. This experience is being scaled up and expanded to all of the regions in the country. Our work in the area of supporting digital development is also conducted by the scientific research areas, academia, including the United Nations Association of Russia and the Moscow State Institute of International Relations. The UN Association conducts more than 10 events every year, showing advanced technologies. The particular attention is paid to the program on localizing SDGs to the regions, and also rating the regions according to their SDG attainments. Building a commendable digital future is an important collective task for us to make sure that no one is left behind. I thank you.

Alar Karis: I thank the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation for his statement. And now I give the floor to the distinguished representative, Her Excellency Charlotta Schlyter, ECOSOC Ambassador. The floor is yours.

Charlotta Schlyter: Thank you, Mr. Co-Chair. We’re living in an era where digital and emerging technologies are reshaping every aspect of our lives. Emerging technologies, not least artificial intelligence, hold incredible potential to accelerate progress on reaching the SDGs. Yet they also pose serious challenges, challenges we can only overcome together. From widening digital divides to concerns over data privacy and the ethical use of AI, these issues do demand collective action. Sweden together with Zambia had the honor to facilitate the negotiations on the Global Digital Compact. We are thrilled that it was adopted by consensus yesterday. The GDC reflects our shared commitment to building a digital future that is open, fair, inclusive, secure, and sustainable. Through GDC, we have agreed on a number of key initiatives, including a Global Digital Dialogue on AI Governance, a Scientific Panel on AI, and an AI Capacity Building Fund. These initiatives aim to ensure that AI serves humanity and upholds our shared values of security, trust and equity. An important aspect of our digital future is the inclusion and protection of our youth. The Global Digital Compact acknowledges this by calling on digital technology companies and social media platforms to provide online safety-related training materials and safeguards, especially for children and youth users. This aligns with our commitment under SDG 3, which emphasizes the need for online safety and mental well-being. It is crucial that we empower our younger generations with the tools and knowledge to navigate the digital world safely and responsibly. Sweden has long been a champion of an open, free and secure internet. We believe in the power of digital technologies to support sustainable growth and environmental stewardship. We look forward to working with all of you to unlock the potential of digitalization and to ensure that we build a future where digital technology truly serves all of humanity. Now the real work begins. Turning the Global Digital Compact into action requires a global effort. Thousands of people and organizations contributed to the elaboration of the Compact, and we hope for the very same stakeholders to join us in this effort. Thank you.

Alar Karis: Thank you, Ambassador Her Excellency Charlotta Schlyter from Sweden. And now I give the floor to Mr. Amanuel Giorgio , Councillor, Deputy Prime Minister and Representative from Eritrea.

Amanuel Giorgio : Thank you, Co-Chairs. In an era marked by unprecedented global challenges, the need for collective action and cooperation has never been more urgent. Escalating conflict and rising tensions, combined with the rapid progression of new technologies and their associated security implications present unparalleled challenges across all sectors. The digital divide among nations is evidently manifested in the global south, where new technologies, including artificial intelligence, advanced biotech, robotics, are not fairly introduced and utilized for societal development. In the absence of an inclusive digital ecosystem, the global development goals and other relevant priorities will be unattainable. Policymakers in the developing countries face critical challenges of identifying and making use of new technologies and innovations that could be transformative. Recent trends have also unveiled an alarming surge in hate speech, exacerbating societal divisions and promoting intolerance. This proliferation of vitriolic rhetoric continues to erode our social cohesion and threatens the very foundation of our global community. As we navigate the complexities of our interconnected world, it is crucial to ensure that the do-no-harm principle is respected in the development and use of new technologies. We must develop comprehensive ethical guidelines that prioritize community well-being in technology deployment. For a country like Eritrea, where much of the infrastructure that drives the innovation systems of developed countries is lacking, a particular challenge is how to develop local innovation systems that can address and transform potential challenges. shall gain changes into valuable vehicles for development, driven by the people to ensure sustainability. With limited resources, we are endeavoring to utilize innovations in science and technology as drivers of our development programs. For example, managing interconnectedness between the education system, health care centers, business and research institutions, and different government agencies is the premise to stimulate innovation based on cooperation between the stakeholders. In conclusion, to ensure an inclusive digital ecosystem, we must reaffirm our commitment to the principles of multilateralism, solidarity, and cooperation, and work together to fortify the multilateral system, ensuring its relevance and effectiveness in addressing the intricate challenges of the…

Alar Karis: Thank you, Mr. Amanuel Giorgio from Eritrea. And now I give the floor to the distinguished representative of the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance. All right, let’s move to the next representative. And I give the floor to the representative of Developing Aid Countries Organizations for Economic Cooperation.

Development Aid Organizations of Economic Cooperation: Thank you, Excellencies and co-chair, for giving me the floor. I’m indeed honored to represent the Developing Aid Organizations. of Economic Cooperation, a compact organization comprising eight developing countries, namely Bangladesh, Egypt, Indonesia, Iran, Malaysia, Nigeria, Pakistan, and Turkey. I’m equally honored to answer three questions posed for this session from a developing country’s standpoint. First, three strategies for leveraging digital technologies to foster sustainable development. One is optimizing data analytics to track and manage natural science effectively. Digital technology is a crucial tool for providing early warning, minimizing the impact of climate change, and building resilience. Two, mobile technology is very, very important. It’s a platform for users to access information and policymakers to disseminate their policies. Mobile technology facilitates hearing all views, leading to more inclusive decision-making. Three, promote digital capacity building. Supported by financial inclusion, it can enhance capacity and provide access to secure financial services to empower developing nations’ economies. Second, three strategies for multi-stakeholder approaches to closing the digital divide. First, enhance the Pentahelix Collaboration to Design training program to equip local population with essential digital skills tailored to their context. They can also advocate for regulations that promote equitable access to technology. Second, facilitate access to technology through mobilizing funding for infrastructure projects. such as expanding Internet access in rural areas. This will connect communities and encourage local entrepreneurship and innovation, driving economic empowerment. Third, optimize multi-stakeholder collaboration to enhance scientific and technological cooperation and joint research initiatives to lead to innovative solutions that address local challenges. Finally, Excellencies, two strategies for ensuring an inclusive, open, safe and secure digital space to protect against online harm. First, a sound regulatory framework is required to be created to protect users from online harm. Tech companies must also design safe platforms and implement preventive measures. We must also enable a framework of accountability and transparency. Two, education and awareness-raising. We must also ensure that education and awareness-raising is a key part of the educational process. Thank you.

Alar Karis: I thank the distinguished representative of the Developing Aid Countries Organization for Economic Cooperation. And now I give the floor to the representative of the International Institute for Democracy and, sorry, of the United Nations Industrial Development Organization.

United Nations Industrial Development Organization: Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, at the United Nations Industrial Development Organization, UNIDO, we welcome the adoption of the Global Digital Compact. A common digital future is possible if we urgently address the growing digital divide. A gap in digital access is a gap in opportunity, empowerment and inclusion. UNIDO supports countries in their sustainable industrial journey. And access to technologies associated with the Fourth Industrial Revolution is critical. If available and applied, such technologies enhance productivity, climate resilience, and inclusive economic growth. Ladies and gentlemen, frontier technologies like AI, Internet of Things, advanced robotics, and blockchain can be key to optimizing supply chains, reducing waste, promoting circular economy practices, enhancing competitiveness, and creating jobs. But we also need to be mindful of possible negative implications of digital and automation technologies. Mindful of how they affect existing jobs and increase potential to reshore production away from developing countries. Collaboration is therefore central to UNIDO’s strategy. Partnerships between governments, industries, the private sector, civil society, and academia are essential to scaling digital solutions. For example, UNIDO asked the Global Alliance on AI for Industry and Manufacturing, a multi-stakeholder initiative to promote the responsible development and use of AI in industry. Human oversight, robust governance, and regulatory frameworks are critical to ensure responsible and ethical use of digital technologies. At UNIDO, we are working with our member states to develop policies and set standards for the industrial sector, the sector that uses but also produces most of these technologies. Particularly for women and youth, we must foster access to a digital space that empowers everyone but does not come at the cost of human dignity, safety, and privacy. We therefore look forward to assuming a strong role in implementing the Global Digital Compact. And we look forward to working closely with member states, the UN family, and our partners in this regard. I thank you. Thank you.

Alar Karis: I thank you, distinguished representative of United Nations Industrial Development Organization. And now I give the floor to our representative of World Intellectual Property Organization.

World Intellectual Property Organization: Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, dear distinguished delegates. I had some prepared remarks, but because today is meant to be interactive, I threw them out and I decided I will speak a bit more off the cuff. First, congratulations on the GDC, hard work on behalf of the co-chairs and facilitators. The key now is how do we translate this into concrete action and impact on the ground. Let me share a couple of things that I think we need to do. First, we need to help build infrastructure in countries itself. And one of the things that WIPO is doing is to provide the IP offices in over 90 developing countries to become fully digital. That’s important because in many of these countries, if they are paper-based, they are not reaching out to the inventors and the creators and innovators in other parts of their country. And by helping them to become fully digital, by allowing them to go to the cloud, sometimes the first in the country to become fully digital, we are allowing them to provide services to every part of the country, and I think that’s very, very important, especially for young inventors and innovators who are used to using mobile digital platforms to be able to access the services that IP offices provide. Second, we must not just look at technology as a threat, but also as an opportunity, and I’m very happy to hear some ministers speak about that. One of the things they have done in partnership with a number of musicians, including Bjorn from ABBA, is to create a platform called… or Creators Learn IP, or Creators Love IP, CLIP. It’s a free online platform. We welcome all of you to have a look at it. By musicians, for musicians, to allow young aspiring musicians to learn enough about IP, data, technology, to be able to put their music and their songs online, and to use that to earn a living. And that means that someone in Indonesia can be able to use the power of digital to access and to reach out to people halfway across the world. And I think that’s really something that is very important. We have translated this into six UN languages, including additionally Portuguese. Third, let’s bring the world together to talk about these issues. WIPO has every six months an IP and AI conversation. IP has become very critical to AI, because AI learns from copyrighted materials. We need to address these issues. But more importantly, we do it in an inclusive way. We bring together civil society, academia, industry, because we believe that the solutions to the problems and the challenges and the opportunities that AI presents to us requires a multi-stakeholder approach. And so we bring everyone together to talk about these issues. We are pleased that it’s not just about talking, but doing. So I’m very happy that Doreen and myself, ITU, WIPO, and WHO has just launched a project to help AI entrepreneurs in developing countries to address health challenges in their particular countries. So of all this, I think the key now is to translate GDC into concrete action. WIPO stands ready to work with you on all of that. We welcome you to partner with us. Thank you very much.

Alar Karis: I thank the distinguished representative of World International Property Organization. And now, I give the floor to the distinguished representative of International Trade Union Confederation.

International Trade Union Confederation: Thank you very much, Chair. I speak on behalf of the International Trade Union Confederation, representing more as 200 million members globally. We live in a time of continuous evolving technological advancements, impacting profoundly our lives and our mindsets. And these changes have a great effect on the future of work in particular, bringing both opportunities and challenges for workers. We welcome the integration of a human rights perspective embedded in the newly endorsed Pact for the Future, including improving gender equality. Transitions to a digital future must be based on human and labour rights. And a clear example of how technology can generate challenges is the platform economy, where workers are treated today as a commodity by an algorithmic business model. And we will support the International Labour Organization to adopt an international binding instrument on the platform economy, which will provide a level playing field to cope with the decent work challenges that are growing in the sector. Our common digital future needs to maximize the potential of new technology to create decent and sustainable jobs. An example, an initiative such as the new Tech-Labour Partnership between the American Federation of Labour and Congress of Industrial Organizations, AFL-CIO, and Microsoft, on the other hand, are already pointing in this direction. This partnership between a trade union and a global company like Microsoft is focusing on first, sharing in-depth information on AI technology trends, secondly, incorporating workers’ perspectives in the development of AI technology, and third, helping shape public policy that supports the technology skills and needs of frontline workers. A common digital future cannot be achieved without the involvement of workers and trade unions working together with employers and governments. With the global trade union movement, the ITUC, we are ready to support a digital transition aligned with the SDGs. Thank you very much.

Alar Karis: I thank the distinguished representative of the International Trade Union Confederation. I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the International Carbon Neutrality Industry Research Organization Limited.

International Carbon Neutrality Industry Research Organization Limited: Thanks, Honorable Chair. Thanks for the speaking opportunity. I’m speaking on behalf of the international carbon neutrality industry. As we come together to shape a common digital future, we must address the urgent challenge of the global digital divide. Over a third of the world’s population remains unconnected, missing out on transformative benefits of digitalization. To close this gap, we must prioritize affordable Internet access for undeserved communities. Education is equally essential. Government and organizations must collaborate to offer training on digital literacy and personal data protection, empowering people to become informed and responsible digital citizens. Ensuring the security of our digital spaces is also important. We must enact strong legislation against cybercrime while tackling emergent threats such as the misuse of artificial intelligence, particularly in spreading misinformation, defamation, and even sexual violence. Technology as deepfakes, which generate fake contents by altering faces or voices, pose a particular threat to women and children. Investing in research to address this threat is crucial. Along with using multi-factor authentication to improve digital security, governments should also invest in monitoring systems capable of detecting cybercrime while creating clear channels for the public to report harmful online activities. Together through cooperation between stakeholders, we can foster an inclusive, safe, and secure digital space, one that empowers everyone, particularly women and children, and ensure that technology advances human rights and sustainable development. Thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu:

Alar Karis: Thank you distinguished representative of the and the National Carbon Neutrality Research Organization Limited. And now I give the floor to Her Excellency Ismaila Ceesay, Minister of Information, Communication and Digital Economy of Gambia.

Ismaila Ceesay: Co-Chairs, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, in today’s rapidly evolving world, digital technologies are reshaping every aspect of life, from agriculture, education and healthcare to business and communication. Therefore, harnessing the power of digital technologies is pivotal to creating a more prosperous, inclusive and equitable future for all. As we look forward toward a common digital future, it is essential to address the pressing challenge of the digital divide. This divide, which has increased inequality, is not only a technological gap, it is a barrier to education, employment and the opportunity to thrive in a digital economy. While urban areas are increasingly connected, rural communities face an uphill battle in gaining access to these life-changing technologies. To bridge this divide, we are focused on strengthening inclusive innovation. Innovation in the Gambia is driven by the need of our people, especially those in undeserved areas. Currently, we are developing coherent policies, harnessing strategic partnerships and investing in capacity-building initiatives that enable our people, especially in undeserved regions, to fully participate. Our aim is to develop and adopt technologies that can be used by Gambians, all Gambians for that matter, not just select few. Whether it’s enhancing mobile network coverage in rural areas, smart agriculture or creating digital literacy programs for women and young people, inclusive innovation will ensure that no one is left behind in this digital age. Moreover, strengthening cooperation is key. The digital future we envision for the Gambia cannot be… built by any one entity alone, we need collaboration between the government, private sector, civil society, and international partners. By working together, we can expand digital infrastructure, reduce costs, and develop programs that teach the skills our citizens need to participate in the digital economy. This will empower our people and provide them access to essential e-government solutions and open doors for young Gambians to gain access to education, learn new skills, and connect with opportunities far beyond our borders. But let us be clear, bridging the digital divide is not just about technology, it’s about equity, it’s about creating opportunities for all Gambians to have a voice, participate in the digital economy, and contribute to our nation’s development. As we work towards a common digital future, let us ensure that this future is inclusive, equitable, and built on cooperation. Together, we can create a digital world that leaves no one behind. Thank you.

Alar Karis: I thank His Excellency Ismaila Ceesay from Gambia. And now I give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Council of Europe.

Council of Europe: Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, Your Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen. We know and we’ve heard this morning, heard a lot that the obstacles to digital equality among citizens are numerous, we also know that they’re complex. From the viewpoint of the Council of Europe, which I represent here, these obstacles can threaten human rights of individual people, and they can create democratic deficits, and they can result in the cracks in the rule of law. And the response to those issues, it’s difficult to find them nationally. We can see that we need to be working together multilaterally, at least in part. And then, above and beyond, we can see that we are trying to get is effectiveness. And in addition to that, there has to be some kind of a legal value. And that is why, and I want to underscore that, the work done by the Council of Europe is very important here. We have a very specific, very recent example, which provides some of the response to the concerns expressed today. And that is the new Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence. It’s an international treaty which is unique of its kind. It’s an international treaty which is open for signature to members of the entire world since the beginning of the world, and provides binding rules to make sure that the artificial intelligence systems abides by human rights, democracy, and the rule of law, rather than weaken them. And it promotes artificial intelligence when it’s ethical, human-based, and pushes the boundaries of what’s possible. This text, Mr. Chair and Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, is robust and balanced. It already has had the support and work from 46 members of the Council of Europe and other non-member states who supported this work. It has already received quite a number of signatures and support from the academia, civil society, and the technological industry itself. And I would like to use this opportunity of this dialogue to launch an appeal to countries across the world to sign the convention, to ratify it, because this way, together, we can benefit from its protections. The Council of Europe obviously also has other important texts, and we have shown in the past that we can do a lot, in particular, the Budapest Convention on Cybercrime. And to conclude, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, I would like to say that our society is undergoing rapid change, very, very rapid change. change. And it’s very frequently the most disadvantaged, the marginalized, the minorities who are left behind. And that’s why we need legal standards to prevent this. And we have to make sure that they’re implemented together in common. I thank you.

Alar Karis: I thank the representative of the Council of Europe, and now I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.

Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development: Thank you, Chair, distinguished guests, excellencies, ladies and gentlemen. Let me focus my brief intervention on connectivity, because connectivity really is the backbone of the digital transformation, and also an absolute key to closing the digital divides that we’ve been talking about this morning. Ensuring that all people have access to high quality, accessible, and affordable connectivity across geographies, genders, age groups, and socioeconomic groups is essential to reap the benefits of digitalization. While progress has been made, persistent connectivity divides remain across countries. As our data shows, OECD members had an average 36 fixed broadband subscriptions per 100 inhabitants in 2023. That was a remarkable and worryingly 2.4 times the rate of the rest of the world. OECD analysis also shows that there are persistent and substantial territorial gains within countries. In OECD countries, people living in cities, for example, experienced median fixed broadband download speeds that were 50 percent higher than people living in regions far from metropolitan areas. That was in the fourth quarter of 2023. To bridge the digital divide, governments must first establish a clear understanding of connectivity gaps. The OECD supports countries through the collection of a broad range of regularly updated broadband statistics. We also assess the latest trends in broadband networks and their impacts on policy. recommendation on broadband connectivity explicitly features measures to promote access for all and represents a road map for policies to boost broadband deployment, particularly in unserved or underserved areas. But digital divides go beyond connectivity. It is also very much about gender equality, or perhaps rather the current lack of gender equality. In OECD countries, more than twice as many young men than women can program an absolutely essential skill for AI development. Girls also show lower enrollment rates in disciplines crucial for success in a digital landscape. This, of course, has downstream effects on the participation of women in scientific discovery. For instance, only 8% of AI journal articles in 23 were written exclusively by women, compared with 41% written exclusively by men. There is also a gender gap when it comes to mental health in digital environments and in problematic use of social media. These issues should be front and center of policy priorities. People of all backgrounds should be equipped with the necessary access, skills, and safeguards to use and benefit equally from digital technologies. This will be essential to guaranteeing a more inclusive digital future, inherently requiring global and multi-stakeholder cooperation. Thank you.

Alar Karis: I thank the distinguished representative of OECD, and now I give the floor to Ms. Birgit Stevens, Director for the United Nations and Francophone, Belgium Ministry for Foreign Affairs.

Birgit Stevens: Excellencies, dear co-chairs, distinguished colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, let me first express my appreciation to the Secretary General and to the co-chairs for organizing this important dialogue on shaping a common digital future. I will highlight three elements that are instrumental in leveraging digital technologies for sustainable development and for bridging divides. First, digital technologies must serve as tools of inclusivity. Innovation should be directed towards solving our most pressing global challenges. Similarly, advancements in technology should be focused on the development of new technologies. FinTech can enhance financial inclusion. To ensure digital technologies benefit everyone, we must prioritize digital skills empowerment. Bridging the digital divide requires comprehensive training programs that prioritize digital literacy, basic internet usage, and advanced skills. In Belgium, Digibanks, an initiative from one of the regional governments, serves as a concrete example of how we can use technology to bridge digital divides. These community-based digital hubs provide essential services, such as digital literacy training, access to technology, and support for digital entrepreneurship, thus not only empowering individuals, but also strengthening local economies. Second, meaningful cooperation is key to bridging digital divides. During its presidency of the European Union, Belgium organized the first EU-Africa Dialogue on Cyber and Digital Diplomacy. This initiative underscored the importance of global cooperation to create an inclusive and secure digital future for all, reinforcing the shared commitment to bridging the digital divide between continents. Third, we must recognize that the rapid pace of digital transformation brings both opportunities and risks. While technology can empower and connect, it can also expose individuals, especially women and children, to harm. Tech-facilitated gender-based violence affects a staggering 38% to 58% of women. This highlights the urgent need for action. That is why Belgium has taken the lead in drafting a resolution on combating technology-facilitated gender-based violence that has recently been adopted by the Human Rights Council. Empowering individuals through digital literacy and security training is key. Initiatives like Belgium’s Digital for Women and Girls Project provide essential knowledge and tools to navigate the digital world safely. Finally, VIX. Systems must have access to support services. Our work, for example, in Palestine and elsewhere, proves our commitment to ensuring that those harmed online receive the help they need. Bridging the digital divides is not only a matter of equity. It is a prerequisite and an opportunity to achieve the 2030 Agenda. Thank you.

Alar Karis: Thank you, Ms. Stevens, Director for United Nations and Francophone from Belgium. And now I give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization.

UNESCO: Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen. With the digital revolution and that of artificial intelligence, we are seeing a societal upheave that we haven’t seen since the Industrial Revolution. This digital revolution allows us to move towards the common good. And at UNESCO, we draw on our mandate on education, culture, science and information to ensure this is so. We advocate for open science, distance learning and the treasures listed on UNESCO World Heritage. We must also pay close attention to the unprecedented risks posed by digital technology, misinformation, hate speech, rewriting of history, the amplification of gender-based violence and online violence, especially against women. In this polarized world, we must have common points of reference to ensure that technology progresses to benefit the common good. This is the thrust behind the… AI resolution adopted unanimously by members of our organization in 2021. This has clear principles for the key challenges of artificial intelligence such as data governance, the environmental impacts, gender equality, education or research for that matter. We are supporting around 60 countries today to ensure that these principles lead to tangible public policies and we are supporting the African Union in its definition of a strategy for artificial intelligence for the entire continent. We also have drafted initial principles for digital platforms in 2023. This is a critical roadmap for governments, regulators, digital companies and citizens vis-à-vis moderation, transparency, content publishing and much more besides. This is a major challenge which public policies should seize and the Global Compact needs to have common reference points based on universal values allowing us to yield as much as we can from the digital sector. Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, thank you for your attention.

Alar Karis: I thank the distinguished representative UNESCO for her statement and now I give the floor to distinguished representative of International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance.

International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance: President Karis, President Muizzu, thank you for chairing this important dialogue. Excellencies, never before has so much information being available to so many people. This fact is reshaping politics globally. Digital technologies are creating new opportunities for people to learn about and participate in politics. Yet the full flourishing of this democratic potential is only possible when the Internet itself is democratic, open, interoperable, inclusive, and accessible by all. This must be our collective mission, both through and beyond the global digital compact. Let me share three basic ideas to advance this objective. First, we must protect the integrity of the information environment, especially around politics. Everyone agrees that people should be able to access clean water. Well, we also need to protect their access to clean sources of political information. But right now, the drinking water and the sewage are flowing from the same taps. Ending this pollution of the information environment is a task for all sectors of society. As two examples, companies must increase transparency around ranking algorithms, and governments must refrain from Internet shutdowns. Second, we must ensure that the digital public infrastructure now being built all over the world incorporates democratic rights, values, and principles by default. And here, I will underscore the importance of equality and non-discrimination of women and minorities, as well as transparency. Our goal should be universal access. Among other things, this means closing the digital gender gap. Third, we must protect the current system of governance for digital technologies, especially the multi-stakeholder model and core institutions like the Internet Governance Forum. We should also make full use of existing human rights mechanisms, while adding norms and agreements to protect human rights online and to protect the Internet itself from further fragmentation. A similarly principled and inclusive global framework is needed for artificial intelligence. Digital technologies hold great power to foster a global democratic commons. We must seize the opportunity of the Global Digital Compact and the Summit of the Future to make the Internet a common good for all people of the world, leaving no one behind. Thank you.

Alar Karis: I thank the distinguished representative of the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance. Now I give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Institute for Consumer Protection.

Institute for Consumer Protection: Distinguished Excellencies, we reached one landmark consensus with the Global Digital Compact. Now, we have a baseline, but to thrive, we must go even further. For that, I am here as a representative of consumers and human and digital rights organizations from Latin America, the Global South, and across the world. Working together, we recall on three essential implementation points to fulfill GDC’s goals for an inclusive digital future. First, we must view the GDC as a starting point, advance it, and tailor it to different contexts. We must advance it through the design of robust, adaptable, and inclusive regulation frameworks, bringing accountability and human rights in all technologies in the AI lifecycle, to prevent risks and harms to consumers, privacy, the economy, and democracy, to fight against monopoly abuses, and to promote public interest, diversity, openness, interoperability, and information integrity in the digital environment. In addition, we must adapt it to different contexts, without losing the potential of important coordinated solutions. dialogue, we must tailor the GDC to each country’s unique contexts, needs, and priorities. For example, increasing social and economic opportunities with DPIs, digital public infrastructures, and goods. In the global south, considering that 2.7 billion people are still unconnected, bridging digital divides through meaningful connectivity and digital literacy is also key. And we should always promote digital justice with special attention to gender inequalities, the needs of most vulnerable communities, and the intersection of different forms of discrimination. Second, we must foster GDC’s cross-feedback with other relevant spaces and topics. The summit of the future and its outcomes must align with existing important dialogues, held in the G20 UN DPI Safeguards Initiative and others. In different topics, we must assess the social environmental impact, the implications for workers who should also enjoy the social benefits of the value created by data, media diversity, the connection with other SDGs. This allows us to go beyond a technocratic or uncritical innovation narrative. Third, and crucially, we need a meaningful, diverse, and democratic multistakeholder engagement from the affected communities, consumers, and civil society, including the facilitation of the ECOSOC status approval here in the UN, with special attention to addressing the power asymmetry and the unbalanced access or lack of access in privileged decision spaces, as stated in the NetMundial Plus 10 principles. Summing up, the GDC is a starting point. We must contextualize it, go beyond, considering the discussions of other relevant fora and topics with a truly balanced multistakeholder participation. Your Excellencies, we cannot afford to keep this status quo. We must be bold and ambitious in building an inclusive, just, participatory, and human rights-based digital future, starting from the GDC, but going beyond and together. Thank you.

Alar Karis: I thank the distinguished representative of the Institute for Consumer Protection. At this point, I hand over to my eminent chair to oversee our meeting, please.

Avendis Consulting: I thank my esteemed co-chair. We will continue with our list of speakers. I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Avendis Consulting. Excellencies, distinguished delegates, my name is Dr. Aninu Emua. As Managing Director of Avendis Consulting, I represent our communities of women in leadership, Africa Women’s CEO’s Network, 100 Women at Davos, and Women in Philanthropy and Impact Africa, engaged in advancing inclusive leadership for the betterment of our societies and economies. My statement is on the imperative of inclusive development of emerging technologies, in particular, artificial intelligence. As we stand at the crossroads of unprecedented technological advancement, we must recognize that emerging technologies, such as artificial intelligence, are not only reshaping the future of work, but also driving the creation of new jobs and opportunities. However, we must also confront the stark reality that if we do not act decisively, these same technologies risk deepening existing inequalities, particularly the gender gap. Today, women occupy only 33% of tech jobs, and their representation in leadership roles is even lower. As technology becomes more sophisticated and central to our economies, the exclusion of women from these spaces is not only unjust, but also a significant loss to the potential of our societies. To truly bridge the digital divide, we must first close the gender gap in technology. To build an inclusive digital future, we must incorporate a gender perspective in all aspects of digital innovation and funding. This means prioritizing investments in AI and other technologies that are designed to serve the needs of all people. people, ensuring that these tools are free from bias and inclusive by design. We must also support female-led entrepreneurship, particularly in developing countries, by providing patient capital, long-term investments that prioritize impact over immediate returns. By doing so, we empower women, drive inclusive economic growth, and foster sustainable development. Furthermore, it is crucial that we address the biases embedded in the technologies we develop. AI and other digital tools can perpetuate and even exacerbate existing inequalities if not carefully managed. We must establish robust frameworks that ensure that these technologies are inclusive, equitable, and subject to human oversight. This includes legislation that protects individuals, especially women and girls, from online harms and digital exclusion. Finally, multi-stakeholder collaboration is essential to achieving these goals. Governments, the private sector, civil society, and international organizations must work together to mobilize resources, build capacity, and foster technological and scientific cooperation. By prioritizing inclusivity, we can achieve these goals.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the distinguished representative of Avendis Consulting. I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United Nations Population Fund.

United Nations Population Fund: Excellencies, distinguished delegates, the summit of the future is our chance to shape the world we want. As science and technology increasingly govern our lives, we must ensure that this digital revolution benefits everyone, drives progress and does not worsen existing inequalities. This means closing the digital divides that prevent women, girls and young people in all their diversity from accessing technology that empowers them with vital and often life-saving tools and resources. Fear for their personal safety is among the three barriers women face in accessing digital spaces. Three in four women have already faced some form of technology facilitated gender-based violence. This escalating threat is fueled by discriminatory gender norms and unsafe technology that disproportionately affects women, girls and youth. UNFPA’s body right campaign advocates for protecting personal images online just like copyrighted material. The campaign also exposes violations of bodily autonomy and privacy, especially for women, girls, minorities and LGBTQIA plus communities. By rejecting non-consensual image sharing, deep fakes and doxxing, the initiative calls for global action against digital violence. We must prevent technologies from becoming weapons to threaten, harm or kill, and create safe online environments where everyone feels secure, protected and empowered. We need human rights-based and gender transformative policies and law reform for effective regulation and protection, accountability mechanisms and survivor-centered responses. UNFPA has taken a key step by releasing its guidance on the design and use of technology for gender-based violence and harmful practices. Ensuring equal participation in the digital space also requires that we invest in education, resources and information. Women are underrepresented in technology industries, including those in health and education, leading to gender blind products and gaps in solutions for women. To change this, women and girls in all their diversity must be actively included in the design and development of those technologies. This is the goal of the UNFPA-led Equity 2030 Alliance, because an equitable future can only be achieved if it addresses the needs of all. As we work towards creating… creating meaningful and safe connectivity and technology, we need to ensure that every voice is heard, every need is met, and everyone’s potential is realized. Together we can create an equitable and peaceful and sustainable future where everyone can use and enjoy technology safely and can thrive. Thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the Distinguished Representative of the United Nations Population Fund. And now I’ll give the floor to the Distinguished Representative of the United Nations University.

United Nations University: Excellencies, Distinguished Delegates, digital technologies are impacting our lives in powerful new ways, driving immense and unprecedented societal changes. It is critical that we harness these technologies for the common good, ensuring technological progress is guided by inclusion, equity, and the rights and needs of everyone. New technologies like AI can accelerate attainment of sustainable development goals, whether for climate action, gender, equality, or peace and security, even though – equally though in the wrong hands – they could unleash irreversible harm on an unimaginable scale, jeopardizing our ability to deliver on the 2030 Agenda. For example, AI technology consumes huge amounts of water and energy, and this needs to be regulated. We need to carefully think through governance models that balance inclusion, accessibility, human rights, and innovation. We need to address the digital divide which prevents billions of people, mostly in the Global South, from participating in the digital economy. United Nations University stands ready to support the United Nations as it seeks to navigate the difficult road ahead. ahead. We offer expertise in policy development and regulation, data-driven and evidence-based actions to achieve the SDGs, and the digital technologies that enhance the work of the UN and its member states. We are shaping important conversations around the ethics of digital technologies and human-centered approaches to technological development. We are a global network of universities and research centers, enabling the United Nations to tap into diverse perspectives and expertise. We are equipping students, policymakers, UN officials, and others with critical digital literacy skills to help them exploit the opportunities that digital transformation provide. The current pace of change is unprecedented in human history, and it is difficult to anticipate how our lives will be impacted by digital innovations. Whatever the future holds, the United Nations and our university will be standing ready to respond quickly for the benefit of all. Our common digital future must be informed by inclusion and a commitment that no one should be left behind. I thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the distinguished representative of the United Nations University. And now I’ll give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United Nations Department of Global Communication.

United Nations Department of Global Communications: Thank you, Mr. Chair, excellencies, delegates, my dear colleagues. Yesterday, member states took a historic step for our common digital future by adopting the Global Digital Compact, the first global framework for digital cooperation and AI governance. And through the compact, they pledged to make the online environment safe for all and to promote information integrity, tolerance, and respect in the world. digital space. No discussion on this topic can ignore the damage that misinformation, disinformation, hate speech, and other information threats are doing to our world. This has caused a rise in polarization and a decline in trust – trust that is so needed to achieve peace, dignity, and equality on a healthy planet. To build this trust, we need integrity in our information ecosystem. Recognizing the urgency of this need, the Secretary General of the United Nations launched the UN Global Principles for Information Integrity in June. These principles are firmly rooted in human rights, and they cover a holistic framework for an inclusive, open, safe, and secure digital space where everyone is able to express themselves without fear of attack. The principles are an important resource for Member States and other stakeholders in their efforts to meet the commitments made at this summit. And some stakeholders bear an outsized responsibility, and to them our message is clear. To the big tech companies, acknowledge and mitigate the harm your products are inflicting on people and communities. Raise transparency and ensure safety and privacy by design for all users, everywhere. To all AI actors, uphold human rights and take urgent and transparent measures to ensure that all of your applications are designed and deployed safely, securely, responsibly, and ethically. To advertisers and PR companies, stop allowing the monetizing of harmful content and use your creative power to promote our common good. To the media, raise and enforce your industry’s own editorial standards, provide quality journalism based on facts and reality. And to governments, commit to a free, viable, independent, and plural media landscape, guarantee strong protections for journalists, refrain from drastic measures such as blanket internet shutdowns, and ensure responses strictly adhere to international law, including international human rights law. We hope these principles will serve as a blueprint for the information environment we need to shape our future together. I thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the distinguished representative of the United Nations Department of Global Communications. Now I’ll give the floor to the representative of ILAB.

ILAB: Thank you, Chair, Excellencies, and distinguished guests. I’m speaking on behalf of ILAB, a Mexican NGO with presence across Latin America, developing tools to bridge the digital gap dividing our future as a society. The integration of automation, robotics, and AI is poised to radically transform both economies and the future workforce. Smart farming technologies are rapidly being adopted as soon as manual labor force will be displaced in the near future. Will these innovations boost efficiency? They also endow the livelihoods of millions of workers, particularly migrants, who rely on seasonal farm jobs. The service sector is also undergoing a profound transformation with AI-driven customer service platforms, robotics, and automated systems becoming more affordable and widespread, leading to the replacement of many low-skilled employments across the regions. By 2030, nearly 50 percent of agricultural tasks will be automated, reducing the need for manual labor while increasing the demand for highly skilled labor workforce capable of operating and managing these advanced technologies. While there is an opportunity to incorporate new, better-paid professionals, it will come at the cost of displacing tens or even hundreds of workers. These are not just numbers, but real people, names, and faces who will be left without opportunities to thrive. The impact of this displacement will strain labor markets and create a vacuum in economies reliant on remittances from workers abroad. Many of the recipients of these funds are part of a population that often engages in informal economic activities. In several Latin American countries, remittances are among the top contributors to GDP. Yet millions in rural and service sectors lack access to the education and training needed to fully participate in the digital economy. Without intervention, inequality will deepen, pushing more young people into poverty, migration, and further social unrest. We need to support small and medium-sized enterprises in transitioning from traditional services models to knowledge-based value-added services. For example, in Colombia, SMEs in coffee production are adopting blockchain technology to improve transparency and efficiency in their supply chains. By modernizing SMEs, we can foster frugal innovation for the local cities. Secondly, we must equip young people and those at risk of displacement with critical skills—system thinking, long-term planning, creativity, and problem solving. Education, reskilling and outskilling must be made a priority to ensure the promises of the future are accessible to us all. Thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the distinguished representative of ILAB, and now I give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia.

United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia: Thank you, Mr. Chair, excellencies, distinguished delegates, dear colleagues. In an era where revolutionary and rapid digital transformations are shaping every facet of our lives, it is critical to ensure that everyone benefits from its positive impact, that we minimize its negative effect, and that it serves the goals of sustainable development. Yet, a third of the population in developing countries remains disconnected, deepening inequalities and threatening to leave many behind. In the Arab region, this digital divide is exacerbated by conflict, destruction, and subsequent violence. marginalization and deprivation. At Esquire, we recognize this digital divide as one of the most urgent challenges that threatens the potential desirable future of the younger generation. To that end, we are following a two-pronged strategy, internal where we are increasing and optimizing our investments in data science, comprehensive up-to-date data portals, artificial intelligence, and online policy simulation tools that we put at the disposal of member states. And external, where we have helped member states develop the Arab digital agenda and are now helping them implement it at the national level, where we are promoting inclusive digital ecosystems that leverage technology for economic growth, financial inclusion, social equality, and environmental resilience. We are supporting member states to develop their national digital transformation strategies, build local capacities, and promote innovation, precisely to ensure full meaningful engagement of youth in the design and implementation of these agendas at the core of the digital economy. Furthermore, we have embarked on a series of analytical assessments of the impact of global megatrends on the region, its people, climate, and economy, where we are trying to answer the following question. What do policymakers need to do now to optimize the benefits of these emerging trends and minimize their negative effects? We have completed a study on electric mobility and another on the metaverse and have just launched the study on the artificial intelligence, with each providing around 20 policy action recommendations. While doing so, we recognize, obviously, risks of our digital future and are focusing some of our analysis on recommendations on mitigating these risks. Allow me to conclude by underscoring ESCWA’s commitment to supporting member states in implementing

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the distinguished representative of the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia and now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia.

Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia: Thank you distinguished co-chair, esteemed delegates, the Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia, SICA in short, is an intergovernmental organization on promoting peace, security and stability in the vast continent of Asia through dialogue and unites 28 member states, 10 observer states and 11 observant partner organizations. Within the SICA catalog of confidence building measures, our member states interacting in the priority areas such as information technology and security of in the use of information and communication technologies. More than 30 seminars and workshops have been organized in the last few years including such topics as digitalization of the economy, new realities in the field of ICTs, especially amidst the post-COVID recovery, digital solutions for agriculture and SMEs. The SICA summit held in Astana in 2022 has adopted the statement on cooperation in the field of security and of and in use of ICT. This document reflects the common vision of the member states on the issues related to the prevention of the use of ICTs for illegal and criminal purposes. Within the cooperation with other organization, SICA and UNSCAP this April held the joint side event dedicated to the role of regional partnerships in achieving the SDGs including through the efficient use of digital innovations. Dear delegates, the President of Kazakhstan, Kassym-Jomar Tokayev, current chair of SICA, put forward several initiatives to further strengthen cooperation and proposed to the establishment of the SICA Council on Sustainable Connectivity to address contemporary challenges in the global economy, including supply chain disruptions and digital connectivity. SICA remains committed to leveraging digital innovation to promote sustainable development and response and address social challenges such as poverty evaluation and health care. Global Digital Compact gives us the opportunity to foster collaboration and share best practices in digital innovation among countries, ultimately contributing to safer and more resilient communities. As we work together to build a more prosperous and peaceful future, let us seize the opportunities presented by digital innovation and sustainable development to create a better world for generations to come. I thank you.

Mohamed Muizzu: I thank the distinguished representative of the Conference on Interaction and Confidence-Building Measures in Asia for his statement. Distinguished delegates, we have heard the last speaker for Interactive Dialogue 3. I would like to express my sincere appreciation to all participants for their invaluable insights and contributions to today’s meeting. At this point, I hand over to my eminent co-chair to proceed over the meeting.

Alar Karis: Thank you. Excellencies, distinguished delegates, I now give the floor to Mr. Amandeep Singh Gill, United Nations Secretary General’s Envoy on Technology, to deliver some closing remarks.

Amandeep Singh Gill: Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you to both of you, Excellencies, for leading this very important interactive dialogue. Thank you to the panelists and all those who have spoken today. their insights, and most grateful for the appreciation that they have extended to us, to each other, on the historic development today, the adoption of the pact, and its annexes, including the global digital compact. I just want to acknowledge the tremendous work that’s been put in by the co-facilitators in Sweden and Zambia, and before Zambia, Rwanda, over the past two years on consultations, on negotiations, bringing in critical inputs from stakeholders. And I’ll be remiss if I didn’t acknowledge the enormous hard work put in by the small but mighty Secretariat team, led by Dr. Renata Dwan, Special Advisor in my office. So ladies and gentlemen, what’s different with the global digital compact? First, it is the very first comprehensive agreement on digital cooperation. We are moving away from silos and sectoral approaches to a holistic approach, including building connectivity to the governance of emerging technology, in particular artificial intelligence. And we need this holistic approach, bringing not only new issues, but also new momentum to old issues by leveraging the GDC’s potential. Second, we’ve achieved a breakthrough in bending technology in the public interest, through the renewed focus on digital public goods, the new focus on digital public infrastructure, open source tools, what we can collectively call the digital commons, and then, in particular, putting this emphasis on data and AI. for humanity. This is important as we use multilateralism to fill the gaps where market forces cannot or will not do. This is not anti-market, but this is market shaping so that we build a more inclusive and impactful digital economy. So here multilateralism is acting as an equalizing force, as a shaper of the global digital landscape. Third, the Global Digital Compact is a breakthrough for implementation. And here too, we need to go beyond our silos and institutions across geography, across levels, across sectors, and across actors. This is the important how of how we implement the GDC. In a sense, this is a new threshold of multi-stakeholder cooperation. Related to implementation is the issue of financing of resources, and in the GDC we find innovation on approaches to financing, and I point you in particular to the options that the Secretary General has been invited to explore in terms of funding for capacity building around AI. And finally, excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, on the surface, the GDC may appear to be about digital technology, but in terms of its outcomes, in terms of its actions, it’s about outcomes that we need to achieve through technology so that this works for all of us, it uplifts everyone, and does not leave anyone behind. Thank you very much.

Alar Karis: I thank the United Nations Secretary-General’s Envoy on Technology, Excellencies, Distinguished Delegates, Distinguished Participants. We have come to the end of Interactive Dialogue III of the Summit of the Future. Also on behalf of my esteemed co-chair, His Excellency Dr. Mohamed Muizzu, President of the Republic of the Maldives, I sincerely thank all speakers and our special entities for their active participation and insightful contribution to our discussion on the thought-provoking theme of this dialogue. Before we adjourn, I would also like to remind participants that Interactive Dialogue IV on the theme, The Future Starts Now, Enhancing the Global System for Current and Future Generations, will be held at 3 p.m. this afternoon in this chamber. Interactive Dialogue III is now concluded. The meeting is adjourned.

Mohamed Muizzu:

M

Mohamed Muizzu

Speech speed

103 words per minute

Speech length

1542 words

Speech time

892 seconds

Expanding connectivity infrastructure

Explanation

Mohamed Muizzu emphasizes the need to expand connectivity infrastructure to bridge the digital divide. He highlights that over one-third of the global population remains disconnected from the internet, particularly in developing countries.

Evidence

In the Maldives, the National Center for Information Technology is undertaking several initiatives to expand high-speed Internet coverage and enhance digital access to essential services.

Major Discussion Point

Bridging the Digital Divide

Agreed with

Ursula Owusu-Ekuful

Ismaila Ceesay

Abdullah Alswaha

Birgit Stevens

Agreed on

Bridging the digital divide

U

Ursula Owusu-Ekuful

Speech speed

134 words per minute

Speech length

415 words

Speech time

184 seconds

Investing in digital skills and literacy

Explanation

Ursula Owusu-Ekuful stresses the importance of investing in digital skills and literacy to bridge the digital divide. She argues that education and training are essential for people to fully participate in the digital economy.

Evidence

Ghana has set up a Girls in ICT Trust to narrow the gender digital divide.

Major Discussion Point

Bridging the Digital Divide

Agreed with

Mohamed Muizzu

Ismaila Ceesay

Abdullah Alswaha

Birgit Stevens

Agreed on

Bridging the digital divide

I

Ismaila Ceesay

Speech speed

133 words per minute

Speech length

395 words

Speech time

177 seconds

Promoting inclusive innovation for underserved areas

Explanation

Ismaila Ceesay emphasizes the need for inclusive innovation to ensure that digital technologies benefit underserved areas. He argues that innovation should be driven by the needs of people, especially those in unserved regions.

Evidence

The Gambia is developing coherent policies, harnessing strategic partnerships, and investing in capacity-building initiatives to enable people in underserved regions to fully participate in the digital economy.

Major Discussion Point

Bridging the Digital Divide

Agreed with

Mohamed Muizzu

Ursula Owusu-Ekuful

Abdullah Alswaha

Birgit Stevens

Agreed on

Bridging the digital divide

A

Abdullah Alswaha

Speech speed

124 words per minute

Speech length

385 words

Speech time

184 seconds

Leveraging public-private partnerships

Explanation

Abdullah Alswaha emphasizes the importance of public-private partnerships in bridging the digital divide. He argues that collaboration between government and private sector is crucial for developing digital infrastructure and services.

Evidence

Saudi Arabia has worked with ITU to conduct a study on connecting the unconnected world through innovative solutions on planet Earth and in space.

Major Discussion Point

Bridging the Digital Divide

Agreed with

Mohamed Muizzu

Ursula Owusu-Ekuful

Ismaila Ceesay

Birgit Stevens

Agreed on

Bridging the digital divide

Implementing digital health solutions

Explanation

Abdullah Alswaha emphasizes the importance of digital health solutions in improving healthcare access and quality. He argues that these technologies can transform healthcare delivery and outcomes.

Evidence

Saudi Arabia has harnessed the virtual hospital model to serve more than 30 million pilgrims from over 100 countries.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Digital Technologies for Sustainable Development

Agreed with

Jonas Gahr Støre

Edi Rama

Esther Dweck

Juan M. Lavista Ferres

Agreed on

Harnessing digital technologies for sustainable development

B

Birgit Stevens

Speech speed

128 words per minute

Speech length

396 words

Speech time

184 seconds

Addressing gender gaps in technology access and skills

Explanation

Birgit Stevens highlights the need to address gender gaps in technology access and skills. She argues that digital inclusion must prioritize women and girls to ensure equal opportunities in the digital world.

Evidence

Belgium’s Digital for Women and Girls Project provides essential knowledge and tools to navigate the digital world safely.

Major Discussion Point

Bridging the Digital Divide

Agreed with

Mohamed Muizzu

Ursula Owusu-Ekuful

Ismaila Ceesay

Abdullah Alswaha

Agreed on

Bridging the digital divide

J

Jonas Gahr Støre

Speech speed

149 words per minute

Speech length

459 words

Speech time

183 seconds

Using AI and digital tools to address climate change

Explanation

Jonas Gahr Støre emphasizes the potential of AI and digital tools in addressing climate change. He argues that these technologies can be leveraged to improve climate forecasting and environmental management.

Evidence

Norway provides and promotes financing for digital public goods in sectors such as climate and weather forecasting.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Digital Technologies for Sustainable Development

Agreed with

Edi Rama

Esther Dweck

Juan M. Lavista Ferres

Abdullah Alswaha

Agreed on

Harnessing digital technologies for sustainable development

E

Edi Rama

Speech speed

95 words per minute

Speech length

257 words

Speech time

161 seconds

Digitalization of public services for efficiency and transparency

Explanation

Edi Rama highlights the importance of digitalizing public services to improve efficiency and transparency. He argues that this transformation can lead to better governance and service delivery.

Evidence

Albania has made 95% of its public services available online, eliminating long queues and front offices.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Digital Technologies for Sustainable Development

Agreed with

Jonas Gahr Støre

Esther Dweck

Juan M. Lavista Ferres

Abdullah Alswaha

Agreed on

Harnessing digital technologies for sustainable development

E

Esther Dweck

Speech speed

147 words per minute

Speech length

450 words

Speech time

182 seconds

Leveraging digital finance for financial inclusion

Explanation

Esther Dweck emphasizes the importance of digital finance in promoting financial inclusion. She argues that digital financial services can expand access to financial services and drive economic growth.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Digital Technologies for Sustainable Development

Agreed with

Jonas Gahr Støre

Edi Rama

Juan M. Lavista Ferres

Abdullah Alswaha

Agreed on

Harnessing digital technologies for sustainable development

J

Juan M. Lavista Ferres

Speech speed

153 words per minute

Speech length

546 words

Speech time

213 seconds

Adopting digital solutions for agriculture and food security

Explanation

Juan M. Lavista Ferres highlights the potential of digital solutions in improving agriculture and food security. He argues that these technologies can provide vital insights into food production and distribution.

Evidence

Microsoft has developed an open-source map of agricultural land to improve food security, offering insights into where food is grown and what crops are cultivated.

Major Discussion Point

Harnessing Digital Technologies for Sustainable Development

Agreed with

Jonas Gahr Støre

Edi Rama

Esther Dweck

Abdullah Alswaha

Agreed on

Harnessing digital technologies for sustainable development

A

Aminata Zerbo-Sabané

Speech speed

141 words per minute

Speech length

461 words

Speech time

195 seconds

Protecting against online harms, especially for women and children

Explanation

Aminata Zerbo-Sabané emphasizes the need to protect users, especially women and children, from online harms. She argues that ensuring a safe online environment is crucial for inclusive digital development.

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring a Safe and Inclusive Digital Space

Agreed with

United Nations Department of Global Communications

UNESCO

Dimitar Glavchev

International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance

Agreed on

Ensuring a safe and inclusive digital space

U

United Nations Department of Global Communications

Speech speed

125 words per minute

Speech length

384 words

Speech time

183 seconds

Combating misinformation and promoting information integrity

Explanation

The UN Department of Global Communications emphasizes the importance of combating misinformation and promoting information integrity in the digital space. They argue that this is crucial for building trust and achieving peace, dignity, and equality.

Evidence

The Secretary General of the United Nations launched the UN Global Principles for Information Integrity in June.

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring a Safe and Inclusive Digital Space

Agreed with

Aminata Zerbo-Sabané

UNESCO

Dimitar Glavchev

International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance

Agreed on

Ensuring a safe and inclusive digital space

U

UNESCO

Speech speed

104 words per minute

Speech length

282 words

Speech time

161 seconds

Developing ethical frameworks for AI governance

Explanation

UNESCO emphasizes the need for ethical frameworks in AI governance. They argue that such frameworks are crucial to ensure that AI development and use respect human rights and promote the common good.

Evidence

UNESCO adopted an AI resolution unanimously by its members in 2021, providing clear principles for key challenges of artificial intelligence.

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring a Safe and Inclusive Digital Space

Agreed with

Aminata Zerbo-Sabané

United Nations Department of Global Communications

Dimitar Glavchev

International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance

Agreed on

Ensuring a safe and inclusive digital space

D

Dimitar Glavchev

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Safeguarding privacy and data protection

Explanation

Dimitar Glavchev emphasizes the importance of safeguarding privacy and data protection in the digital space. He argues that this is crucial for building trust and ensuring the responsible use of digital technologies.

Evidence

Bulgaria’s approach to balancing cyber security, digital interests and personal data protection is mentioned.

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring a Safe and Inclusive Digital Space

Agreed with

Aminata Zerbo-Sabané

United Nations Department of Global Communications

UNESCO

International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance

Agreed on

Ensuring a safe and inclusive digital space

I

International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance

Speech speed

122 words per minute

Speech length

349 words

Speech time

170 seconds

Promoting digital rights and freedoms

Explanation

The International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance emphasizes the importance of promoting digital rights and freedoms. They argue that this is crucial for ensuring that the Internet remains democratic, open, and accessible to all.

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring a Safe and Inclusive Digital Space

Agreed with

Aminata Zerbo-Sabané

United Nations Department of Global Communications

UNESCO

Dimitar Glavchev

Agreed on

Ensuring a safe and inclusive digital space

A

Alar Karis

Speech speed

103 words per minute

Speech length

1366 words

Speech time

788 seconds

Developing digital public infrastructure and goods

Explanation

Alar Karis emphasizes the importance of developing digital public infrastructure and goods. He argues that this approach can benefit both public and private sectors and support inclusive digital development.

Evidence

Estonia’s data exchange platform, X-Road, is implemented in over 20 countries around the world.

Major Discussion Point

Fostering Digital Innovation and Cooperation

Promoting open source and interoperable solutions

Explanation

Alar Karis emphasizes the importance of open source and interoperable solutions in digital development. He argues that this approach allows for sharing and adapting digital solutions across countries.

Evidence

X-Road, being developed and managed by the Nordic Institute of Interoperability Solutions, enables data exchange between Estonia, Finland, and Iceland.

Major Discussion Point

Fostering Digital Innovation and Cooperation

Disagreed with

Linda Bonyo

Disagreed on

Approach to digital development

C

Charlotta Schlyter

Speech speed

131 words per minute

Speech length

352 words

Speech time

161 seconds

Enhancing international cooperation on digital issues

Explanation

Charlotta Schlyter emphasizes the importance of international cooperation on digital issues. She argues that collective action is necessary to address global digital challenges and opportunities.

Evidence

The adoption of the Global Digital Compact by consensus, which includes initiatives like a Global Digital Dialogue on AI Governance and an AI Capacity Building Fund.

Major Discussion Point

Fostering Digital Innovation and Cooperation

L

Linda Bonyo

Speech speed

157 words per minute

Speech length

599 words

Speech time

228 seconds

Supporting digital entrepreneurship and startups

Explanation

Linda Bonyo emphasizes the importance of supporting digital entrepreneurship and startups. She argues that this is crucial for fostering local innovation and economic growth in developing countries.

Evidence

The Lawyers’ Hub is working to bridge the digital policy divide by running the Africa Digital Policy Institute and building the capacity of policymakers, lawyers, and bar associations.

Major Discussion Point

Fostering Digital Innovation and Cooperation

Disagreed with

Alar Karis

Disagreed on

Approach to digital development

D

D.N. Dhungyel

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Facilitating knowledge sharing and technology transfer

Explanation

D.N. Dhungyel emphasizes the importance of knowledge sharing and technology transfer in digital development. He argues that this is crucial for helping developing countries catch up in the digital revolution.

Evidence

Bhutan is eager to share its national digital identity technology with neighbors and the world while learning from global experiences in digital innovation.

Major Discussion Point

Fostering Digital Innovation and Cooperation

Agreements

Agreement Points

Bridging the digital divide

Mohamed Muizzu

Ursula Owusu-Ekuful

Ismaila Ceesay

Abdullah Alswaha

Birgit Stevens

Expanding connectivity infrastructure

Investing in digital skills and literacy

Promoting inclusive innovation for underserved areas

Leveraging public-private partnerships

Addressing gender gaps in technology access and skills

Multiple speakers emphasized the importance of bridging the digital divide through various means, including infrastructure development, skills training, inclusive innovation, public-private partnerships, and addressing gender gaps.

Harnessing digital technologies for sustainable development

Jonas Gahr Støre

Edi Rama

Esther Dweck

Juan M. Lavista Ferres

Abdullah Alswaha

Using AI and digital tools to address climate change

Digitalization of public services for efficiency and transparency

Leveraging digital finance for financial inclusion

Adopting digital solutions for agriculture and food security

Implementing digital health solutions

Several speakers highlighted the potential of digital technologies to address various sustainable development challenges, including climate change, public service delivery, financial inclusion, agriculture, and healthcare.

Ensuring a safe and inclusive digital space

Aminata Zerbo-Sabané

United Nations Department of Global Communications

UNESCO

Dimitar Glavchev

International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance

Protecting against online harms, especially for women and children

Combating misinformation and promoting information integrity

Developing ethical frameworks for AI governance

Safeguarding privacy and data protection

Promoting digital rights and freedoms

Multiple speakers emphasized the importance of creating a safe and inclusive digital environment by addressing online harms, misinformation, ethical AI use, privacy protection, and digital rights.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the importance of international cooperation and shared digital infrastructure in fostering digital development and addressing global challenges.

Alar Karis

Charlotta Schlyter

Developing digital public infrastructure and goods

Enhancing international cooperation on digital issues

Both speakers highlighted the importance of supporting local innovation and knowledge sharing to foster digital development in developing countries.

Linda Bonyo

D.N. Dhungyel

Supporting digital entrepreneurship and startups

Facilitating knowledge sharing and technology transfer

Unexpected Consensus

Importance of open source and interoperable solutions

Alar Karis

Linda Bonyo

Promoting open source and interoperable solutions

Supporting digital entrepreneurship and startups

Despite representing different regions and contexts, both speakers emphasized the importance of open and interoperable digital solutions, suggesting a growing consensus on the value of collaborative and adaptable approaches to digital development.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement included bridging the digital divide, harnessing digital technologies for sustainable development, ensuring a safe and inclusive digital space, fostering international cooperation, and supporting local innovation and knowledge sharing.

Consensus level

There was a high level of consensus among speakers on the importance of digital technologies for sustainable development and the need for inclusive and collaborative approaches. This consensus suggests strong potential for international cooperation in addressing digital challenges and opportunities, but also highlights the complexity of balancing various priorities such as innovation, security, and inclusivity in the digital realm.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Approach to digital development

Alar Karis

Linda Bonyo

Promoting open source and interoperable solutions

Supporting digital entrepreneurship and startups

While Alar Karis emphasizes open source and interoperable solutions for digital development, Linda Bonyo focuses on supporting local digital entrepreneurship and startups. This represents a difference in approach to fostering digital innovation.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around the specific approaches to digital development and bridging the digital divide. While there is general consensus on the importance of these issues, speakers differ in their proposed solutions and areas of focus.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among the speakers is relatively low. Most speakers agree on the overarching goals of digital inclusion and development, with differences primarily in the specific strategies and focus areas. This suggests a generally unified vision for the future of digital technologies, which is positive for advancing the topic at hand.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

All speakers agree on the goal of bridging the digital divide, but they propose different methods: Muizzu focuses on infrastructure expansion, Owusu-Ekuful emphasizes digital skills and literacy, while Ceesay highlights inclusive innovation for underserved areas.

Mohamed Muizzu

Ursula Owusu-Ekuful

Ismaila Ceesay

Expanding connectivity infrastructure

Investing in digital skills and literacy

Promoting inclusive innovation for underserved areas

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the importance of international cooperation and shared digital infrastructure in fostering digital development and addressing global challenges.

Alar Karis

Charlotta Schlyter

Developing digital public infrastructure and goods

Enhancing international cooperation on digital issues

Both speakers highlighted the importance of supporting local innovation and knowledge sharing to foster digital development in developing countries.

Linda Bonyo

D.N. Dhungyel

Supporting digital entrepreneurship and startups

Facilitating knowledge sharing and technology transfer

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

The digital divide remains a major challenge, with over one-third of the global population still unconnected to the internet

Digital technologies and AI have significant potential to accelerate progress on sustainable development goals if leveraged properly

Ensuring an inclusive, safe and secure digital space is crucial, especially for protecting vulnerable groups like women and children

International cooperation and multi-stakeholder partnerships are essential for bridging digital divides and fostering responsible innovation

Digital skills development and literacy programs are needed to empower people to participate fully in the digital economy

Resolutions and Action Items

Adoption of the Global Digital Compact as a framework for digital cooperation and AI governance

Establishment of a Global Digital Dialogue on AI Governance

Creation of a Scientific Panel on AI

Launch of an AI Capacity Building Fund

Commitment by some countries to expand high-speed internet access to underserved areas

Pledge by Microsoft to equip 25 million people with AI skills by 2025, focusing on underserved communities

Unresolved Issues

Specific mechanisms for financing digital infrastructure development in low-income countries

Detailed frameworks for ethical AI development and deployment across different contexts

Concrete measures to address the gender gap in technology access and skills

Strategies to balance innovation with data protection and privacy concerns

Methods to effectively combat online misinformation and protect information integrity globally

Suggested Compromises

Balancing regulation of digital technologies with the need to foster innovation

Promoting open-source and interoperable solutions to enable technology sharing while respecting intellectual property

Leveraging public-private partnerships to expand digital infrastructure in a cost-effective manner

Developing context-specific digital strategies that address local needs while aligning with global frameworks

Thought Provoking Comments

Estonia has focused on digital innovation to accelerate the fulfillment of sustainable development goals, to bridge digital divides, and to empower all individuals. Our success story, if I can humbly say, is a great reminder of how digital technologies can transform a society, any society.

Speaker

Alar Karis, President of Estonia

Reason

This comment is insightful because it provides a concrete example of how digital innovation can be leveraged to achieve broader societal goals. It challenges the notion that digital transformation is purely a technological endeavor by emphasizing its potential for societal transformation.

Impact

This comment set a positive tone for the discussion by highlighting a success story. It encouraged other participants to consider how digital technologies could be applied in their own contexts to address societal challenges.

Yet, the pressing reality is that over one-third of the global population remains disconnected from the internet, particularly in developing countries. This digital divide is not only about access to internet. It is a profound barrier to development, opportunity, and justice.

Speaker

Mohamed Muizzu, President of Maldives

Reason

This comment is thought-provoking because it reframes the digital divide as not just a technological issue, but a fundamental barrier to development and justice. It highlights the urgency of addressing this divide.

Impact

This comment shifted the discussion towards the importance of inclusivity in digital transformation. It prompted subsequent speakers to address how their countries or organizations were working to bridge this divide.

Emerging technologies, not least artificial intelligence, hold incredible potential to accelerate progress on reaching the SDGs. Yet they also pose serious challenges, challenges we can only overcome together.

Speaker

Charlotta Schlyter, ECOSOC Ambassador

Reason

This comment is insightful because it balances the potential benefits of emerging technologies with their associated challenges. It emphasizes the need for collective action in addressing these challenges.

Impact

This comment deepened the discussion by introducing the complexity of managing emerging technologies. It led to more nuanced conversations about the governance and ethical considerations of AI and other technologies.

To bridge this divide, we must prioritize affordable Internet access for undeserved communities. Education is equally essential. Government and organizations must collaborate to offer training on digital literacy and personal data protection, empowering people to become informed and responsible digital citizens.

Speaker

Representative of International Carbon Neutrality Industry Research Organization Limited

Reason

This comment is thought-provoking because it provides concrete steps for addressing the digital divide, emphasizing both infrastructure and education. It introduces the concept of digital citizenship.

Impact

This comment shifted the discussion towards practical solutions. It prompted other speakers to share their own initiatives and strategies for digital inclusion and literacy.

The Global Digital Compact is a breakthrough for implementation. And here too, we need to go beyond our silos and institutions across geography, across levels, across sectors, and across actors. This is the important how of how we implement the GDC. In a sense, this is a new threshold of multi-stakeholder cooperation.

Speaker

Amandeep Singh Gill, UN Secretary General’s Envoy on Technology

Reason

This comment is insightful because it emphasizes the importance of implementation and cross-sector collaboration in realizing the goals of the Global Digital Compact. It highlights a shift in approach to digital governance.

Impact

As a closing remark, this comment synthesized many of the themes discussed and set the stage for future action. It emphasized the need for continued collaboration and concrete steps towards implementation.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by moving it from abstract concepts to concrete examples and practical solutions. They highlighted the transformative potential of digital technologies while also emphasizing the challenges, particularly the digital divide. The discussion evolved from identifying problems to proposing solutions, with a strong emphasis on collaboration, inclusivity, and the need for a holistic approach to digital transformation. The comments also underscored the global nature of digital challenges and the importance of international cooperation in addressing them.

Follow-up Questions

How can we ensure AI and digital technologies benefit developing countries and don’t widen existing inequalities?

Speaker

Mohamed Muizzu

Explanation

This is crucial to address the digital divide and ensure inclusive development.

What policies and actions can ensure no country or person is left behind in digital transformation?

Speaker

Mohamed Muizzu

Explanation

This is essential for achieving the objectives of the Global Digital Compact.

How can we develop digital public infrastructure that integrates democratic rights, values, and principles by default?

Speaker

International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance

Explanation

This is important to ensure digital technologies support rather than undermine democracy.

How can we address the gender gap in technology and AI development?

Speaker

Avendis Consulting

Explanation

Closing this gap is crucial for building an inclusive digital future.

What frameworks and legislation are needed to protect individuals, especially women and girls, from online harms and digital exclusion?

Speaker

Avendis Consulting

Explanation

This is necessary to ensure a safe and inclusive digital environment.

How can we mobilize more private investment and capital to meet digital infrastructure needs, especially in underserved areas?

Speaker

Ville Tavio

Explanation

This is crucial for achieving universal connectivity.

How can we ensure digital technologies and AI are designed and deployed safely, securely, responsibly, and ethically?

Speaker

United Nations Department of Global Communications

Explanation

This is essential to mitigate potential harms and ensure technologies serve the common good.

How can we support small and medium-sized enterprises in transitioning to knowledge-based, value-added services in the digital economy?

Speaker

ILAB

Explanation

This is important to help businesses adapt to technological changes and maintain economic stability.

What strategies can be implemented to equip workers at risk of displacement with critical skills needed in the digital economy?

Speaker

ILAB

Explanation

This is crucial to address potential job losses due to automation and AI.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

Saturday Closing Ceremony: Summit of the Future Action Days

Saturday Closing Ceremony: Summit of the Future Action Days

Session at a Glance

Summary

The closing ceremony of the Summit of the Future Action Days focused on shaping a peaceful, sustainable, and digital future for all. Rapporteurs summarized key discussions on achieving peace, sustainability, and digital inclusion globally. Speakers emphasized the importance of multilateralism, local government involvement, and financial reform to address global challenges.

The need for concrete action and financing to achieve the Sustainable Development Goals was a recurring theme. Speakers highlighted the importance of reforming the international financial architecture, addressing debt issues, and increasing funding for developing countries. The role of cities and local governments in implementing global initiatives was emphasized.

Youth engagement and intergenerational approaches were stressed as crucial for building a better future. Discussions covered topics such as climate change, digital technologies, and peace-building. Speakers called for solidarity, trust-building, and collective action to address global issues.

The UN Deputy Secretary-General emphasized the power of inclusive multilateralism and partnerships demonstrated during the summit. She urged continued engagement to implement commitments and hold leaders accountable. The President of Namibia highlighted the importance of civil society participation and youth leadership in shaping the future.

The Prime Minister of Barbados concluded by calling for coordinated action to address global inequities and create a more just world. She emphasized the need for widespread engagement and attitude changes to achieve meaningful progress on issues like climate change, artificial intelligence, and equitable development.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– The need for inclusive, multi-stakeholder collaboration and partnerships to address global challenges

– Reforming the international financial architecture to better support sustainable development and climate action

– The importance of youth engagement and intergenerational approaches in shaping the future

– Leveraging digital technologies and AI responsibly to advance the SDGs while managing risks

– Implementing concrete actions and commitments following the Summit of the Future

Overall purpose:

The discussion aimed to summarize the key outcomes and insights from the Summit of the Future Action Days, and look ahead to implementing the Pact for the Future and other commitments to be made at the upcoming Summit.

Tone:

The overall tone was one of urgency and call to action, while also being hopeful and inspiring. Speakers emphasized the critical challenges facing the world but expressed optimism that collaborative, inclusive efforts could drive meaningful change. The tone became more impassioned towards the end, with the final speakers making emotional appeals for unity and decisive action.

Speakers

Speakers:

– Folly Bah Thibault – Moderator/facilitator

– Nudhara Yusuf – Rapporteur for Peaceful Future for All sessions

– Betty Wainaina – Rapporteur for Sustainable Future for All sessions

– Rumman Chowdhury – Rapporteur for Digital Future for All sessions

– Anne Hidalgo – Mayor of Paris, member of UN Secretary General’s Advisory Group on Local and Regional Governments

– Axel van Trotsenburg – Senior Managing Director of the World Bank

– Amina J. Mohammed – UN Deputy Secretary General

– Nangolo Mbumba – President of Namibia

– Mia Mottley – Prime Minister of Barbados

Moderator:

– Folly Bah Thibault – Journalist and news anchor, moderating the discussion

Areas of expertise:

– Nudhara Yusuf – Peace and security

– Betty Wainaina – Sustainable development

– Rumman Chowdhury – Digital technology and AI

– Anne Hidalgo – Local government and urban issues

– Axel van Trotsenburg – International finance and development

– Amina J. Mohammed – International development and UN affairs

– Nangolo Mbumba – African politics and development

– Mia Mottley – Caribbean politics and climate change

Full session report

Revised Summary of the Summit of the Future Action Days Closing Ceremony

The closing ceremony of the Summit of the Future Action Days featured high-level speakers discussing the shaping of a peaceful, sustainable, and digital future for all. Moderated by journalist Folly Bah Thibault, the event included rapporteurs summarizing key outcomes and insights from the summit, followed by perspectives from global leaders on implementing the Pact for the Future and other commitments.

1. Rapporteurs’ Summaries

Nudhara Yusuf, rapporteur for the Peaceful Future for All sessions, highlighted:

– The importance of intergenerational dialogue and rebuilding trust

– Dismantling patriarchal power structures in peace processes

– Countering terrorism through solidarity and cooperation

– Protecting civilians from explosive weapons in populated areas

– Harnessing technology for peace while mitigating risks

Yusuf emphasized, “We stand as the last few generations who can do something about the challenges that we face, and the first few generations that have the opportunity to seize new potentials for impact.”

Betty Wainaina, rapporteur for the Sustainable Future for All sessions, focused on:

– Reforming the international financial architecture

– Strengthening international tax cooperation

– Addressing the debt crisis in developing countries

– Scaling up development and climate financing

Wainaina noted, “Debt servicing is crowding out SDG financing. Speakers stressed the need for global consensus to stem the rising debt crisis, including a systemic multilateral approach.”

Rumman Chowdhury, rapporteur for the Digital Future for All sessions, outlined:

– Reducing the digital divide and ensuring universal access

– Leveraging digital innovations to achieve SDGs

– Developing inclusive AI governance

– Fostering multi-stakeholder partnerships for digital inclusion

Chowdhury emphasized the need to address not only access to digital technology but also the skills and capacities required to use it meaningfully.

2. Global Leaders’ Perspectives

Anne Hidalgo, Mayor of Paris, stressed:

– Including local authorities in multilateral efforts

– Providing funding for cities to address climate change and development

– Fostering trust and peaceful coexistence through local initiatives

Hidalgo also highlighted the recent Paris Olympics as an opportunity to showcase sustainable practices and global unity.

Axel van Trotsenburg, Senior Managing Director of the World Bank, focused on:

– Reinvigorating multilateralism through increased funding

– Providing concessional financing for poorest countries

– Incentivizing private sector participation in developing countries

Van Trotsenburg emphasized, “Multilateralism is under threat… Yet many problems, and the mayor just mentioned climate change, you cannot solve alone. It will require international global collaboration if we want to succeed.”

Amina J. Mohammed, UN Deputy Secretary General, stressed:

– Implementing new global agreements through inclusive partnerships

– Strengthening intergenerational discourse at national and international levels

– Rebuilding trust in international institutions

Mohammed highlighted the extensive engagement of civil society and youth throughout the summit process and emphasized the power of inclusive multilateralism.

Nangolo Mbumba, President of Namibia, emphasized:

– Recognizing youth as key stakeholders in global decision-making

– Amplifying voices of marginalized groups through youth leadership

– Addressing climate change, human rights, and equitable development

Mbumba stated, “The true measure of our success will be in the effective implementation of the pact for the future, the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration of Future Generations. These initiatives will be pivotal in advancing the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.”

Mia Mottley, Prime Minister of Barbados, called for:

– Reforming financial systems to match development needs

– Ensuring equitable access to new technologies like AI

– Prioritizing education and dialogue over conflict

– Providing basic necessities to all people globally

Mottley addressed current global challenges, including ongoing wars, environmental crises, and economic inequalities. She emphasized, “If we doubted the power of the people we only need to see where that power has made significant changes even in this year that we live in, but what matters now is that there be coordinated action and that we believe and that we sell and share with each other that there is a possibility for a win-win.”

In conclusion, the Summit of the Future Action Days closing ceremony highlighted the urgent need for concrete action and financing to achieve the Sustainable Development Goals. Speakers emphasized the importance of reforming the international financial architecture, addressing debt issues, and increasing funding for developing countries. The role of cities, local governments, and youth in implementing global initiatives was stressed throughout the discussion. The overall tone was one of urgency and call to action, while also expressing hope that collaborative, inclusive efforts could drive meaningful change in addressing global challenges.

Session Transcript

Folly Bah Thibault: Excellencies, distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the closing ceremony of the Summit of the Future Action Days. I know it’s been an action-packed day for all of us, with thousands of stakeholders engaging in dozens of sessions and side events throughout the day with the primary goal of reimagining how we work together to address the most pressing opportunities and challenges of our time. As we reflect on today’s sessions, we have heard rich, impactful discussions on how we can collectively shape a more peaceful, sustainable and digital future for all. In this closing ceremony today, we will hear the main takeaways from the day’s events and will be joined by leaders who will reflect on the pact of the future and what lies ahead after this summit. The work begins today. But first, it’s my pleasure to introduce the rapporteurs for each of today’s core themes who will summarize the insights and outcomes of their respective sessions. To start us off, let’s hear from Nudhara Yusuf, the rapporteur for the Peaceful Future for All sessions. Nudhara.

Nudhara Yusuf : Thank you all so very much. When I last had the pleasure of meeting so many of you at the UN Civil Society Conference in Nairobi, we left the closing ceremony saying we would show people what civil society has to offer to a process, not just what we expect from a process. It’s been a long journey, both in these halls but also in the world outside, but it is moving to see that that energy has continued throughout. the year, so thank you for being here and for representing. The Action Day on Peaceful Futures for All drew on the core principles of trust, solidarity, and universality highlighted in A New Agenda for Peace, and it galvanized strong support for these principles. The first session of the day, the Intergenerational Dialogue for Peace, focused on the search for peace in the more complex and divided world of today. The elders, two former presidents, and two young peacebuilders reflected together on the courage and perseverance it takes to rebuild trust, engage in dialogue and diplomacy to build peace. They spoke to the difficult work of repairing communal wounds from the past and rebuilding trust while also protecting the planet. In a second session, we explored how patriarchal power structures affect the lives of people, how war amplifies and feeds on them. We discussed how to dismantle these oppressive structures and the role of women and men as leaders in this effort, and, get this, about how football can be a tool to achieve it. We were inspired by the poetry To Break the Old Patterns. I am sure many of you were moved to tears as I was. In the third session, a call to action for a future free from terrorism highlighted the need for solidarity, common understanding and cooperative approach to countering terrorism. It reinforced the commitment to universal norms in countering terrorism, acknowledging that the evolving threat requires consistent application of international law and established norms, not selective enforcement. Youth and diverse actors were recognized as vital to achieving a future free from terrorism through leadership, innovation and fostering global cooperation. Following this session, we walked for peace across the United Nations premises along a route that highlights the artwork that represents peace, solidarity and global solidarity. global unity. Inspired by the walk, we discussed protection of civilians impacted by the use of explosive weapons in urban settings. In a moving session, we heard stories of resilience, messages urging an end of multigenerational trauma, the calls for action to, one, implementation of the political declaration on the use of explosive weapons in populated areas, two, leave no one behind and address rights of persons with disabilities impacted by armed conflict, and three, commit political will and funding to eliminate these threats to civilians forever. The final session, Imagining Peace in a Digital World, explored scenarios for peace and security in 2045, defined by transformative factors like advancing technology, climate change, and the future of multilateralism. The session unpacked how technologies can be harnessed for good while mitigating risks for a peaceful digital future. A call to action was presented, too, to recommit to multilateralism through the United Nations, to resolve disputes peacefully, to develop governance frameworks that are fit for purpose in a changing world, to uphold disarmament commitments, to prevent conflict and reduce human suffering, to strengthen multi-stakeholder partnerships, to tackle future risks. We stand as the last few generations who can do something about the challenges that we face, and the first few generations that have the opportunity to seize new potentials for impact. So, we, the people of the United Nations, let’s do this. Thank you.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you, Nudhara. Thank you very much, Nudhara, for summarizing the discussions on how we can achieve a peaceful future for all. They were, indeed, very insightful discussions throughout the day here today. We’ll now hear from Betty Wainaina. the rapporteur for a sustainable future for all sessions, Betty.

Betty Wainaina: Thank you very much. Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, I am delighted to report on the session on a sustainable future for all. The message echoed by speakers throughout the day was clear, the SDGs are off track, the clock is ticking, and realising a sustainable future for all hinges on us achieving the SDGs. Financing remains a key bottleneck for the achievement of SDGs, but we have options. Swift action on reforming the international financial architecture, addressing debt and getting taxation right can set us on the right track. Let me highlight some of the concrete outcomes across the five thematic blocks of the day. In the first session on sustainable development in time of global transformation, in their dialogue, the most honourable Andrew Holness of Jamaica and Deputy Secretary General Amina Mohammed stressed that we must rebuild trust and peace and fair representation are prerequisites for developing countries’ voices to be heard. In the second session, we had a discussion on international tax cooperation. This session noted that tax is as close to a panacea as we can get. It can provide income, set incentives, and reduce inequality. Speakers stressed the need for global initiatives to strengthen international tax cooperation including the Framework Convention. on international tax cooperation. The third session delved into the question of debt. Debt servicing is crowding out SDG financing. Speakers stressed the need for global consensus to stem the rising debt crisis, including a systemic multilateral approach. Instruments, including climate resilient debt clauses and state contingent debt instruments must be rolled out at scale. Debt resolution mechanisms need to be delivered with a speed that matches the urgency of the moment. In the fourth session on scaling up development and climate financing, the speakers stressed that both scale and quality needs to be pursued ambitiously. Public development banks play a key role in this and the private sector will also need to step up to this challenge. The fifth session delved into the question of international financial architecture reform. The current architecture needs to keep pace with the realities of the 21st century and beyond. Only bold international financial architecture reform can save the sustainable development goals. Speakers called for bigger and better international financial institutions, more accessible and affordable financing for developing countries, and SDG impact as a guiding force. Speakers across all sessions were clear that action must be taken now to safeguard the SDGs and sustainable futures for all. There is no shortage of opportunities to achieve change, as many of the speakers emphasized. The fourth International Conference on Financing for Development that will be held in Spain in 2025 provides a unique moment and a platform to turn the ambitions of the world into reality. of the Pact for the Future into action to accelerate the SDGs through financing for the Sustainable Development Goals. Thank you very much.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you very much, Betty, for that comprehensive summary of your discussions and for highlighting the main points that were made today in that session, in those sessions I should say. And finally, we’ll hear from Rumman Chowdhury, the rapporteur for the Digital Future for All sessions.

Rumman Chowdhury: Excellencies, distinguished guests, colleagues, and friends, today we heard from powerful voices focused on a simple question. What is your vision of a digital future for all? We have heard how a digital future for everyone, everywhere means a universal, affordable, meaningful, inclusive, sustainable, and prosperous digital future. Many of our speakers today have highlighted the urgent need to reduce the digital divide, not just in terms of achieving universal connectivity, but also to ensure that everyone has access to affordable and safe digital technology and the skills and capacities to use it meaningfully to improve their lives. From healthcare to education, climate mitigation, poverty alleviation, and gender equality, we have seen a diverse range of groundbreaking digital innovations that are driving progress towards achieving the SDGs. To quote Bianca Johnson, a young paraplegic woman who has regained her mobility thanks to technology, what we saw is that the future is the present. We’ve also heard what an inclusive architecture for AI governance looks like, building on the AI advisory body’s report, Governing AI for Humanity, with announcements on implementing its recommendations. And last but not least, we’ve heard how stakeholders and governments can join hands to deliver on the vision of the global digital compact. None of this is possible without innovative, inclusive, and multi-stakeholder partnerships that focus on specific SDG goals and targets. The SDG digital event this morning saw the announcement of, get this, $1.05 billion in pledges to support various initiatives to advance digital inclusion via the Partner to Connect platform. The summit of the Future Action Day on digital today has shown us incredible examples of the inclusive and collaborative action being taken all over the world. Indeed, it has shown us the power of collective action. We are ready for the second half of this journey. Accelerate, innovate, collaborate, and lead. Thank you.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you very much, Rumman, for summarizing the sessions from the Digital Future for All sessions. And thanks to all the rapporteurs for the thoughtful and comprehensive summaries that they’ve provided. Now we’ll hear from a few respondents who will share their unique perspectives on the Pact for the Future. Ladies and gentlemen, it’s my honor to introduce Anne Hidalgo and Axel van Trotsenburg. Our first respondent, please join us on stage, Madame Hidalgo, Mr. van Trotsenburg. Thank you so much for joining us. So our first respondent is Madame Hidalgo, who’s a member of the Secretary General’s Advisory Group on Local and Regional Governments and the Mayor of Paris, of course. And she’ll share her reflections about the role governments play in implementing the Pact at the local level.

Anne Hidalgo: Thank you very much for being with us today. You’re going to speak to us about the role that governments will play in implementing this pact for the future at the local level. Thank you. And thank you for hosting us. First and foremost, I’d like to thank the Secretary General of the United Nations, Mr. Hidalgo, who’s opened up the door to multilateralism, including the various levels, including local authorities. What is now being proposed is that we follow up on what Martin Luther King said, that those who love peace need to know how to organize just as well as those that prefer war. And that’s what we’re talking about here. Multilateralism, what will that allow us to do? Well, it will enable us to act, because today, whether we’re talking about climate change or the social impact of climate change, the fight against poverty, whether we’re talking about democracy. We know that all of that can be evaluated in the lives of our citizens and within the level of cities because you have this phenomenon of people moving to the cities throughout the world for over 10 years now. Well, since the Paris Agreement on Climate Change, we’ve been meeting in different networks that have an exchange on good practices, particularly with regard to climate, the fight against poverty, this issue of housing and access to housing, and we’ve been meeting in these networks, French-speaking networks, the C40, for example, and for 10 years now, we’ve been working to try to get recognition for the place of local governments in global governance, not to work against states or try to usurp anyone’s authority. We want to join our forces together as part of a global coalition where actors need to be there, civil society, NGOs, national authorities, and of course, the private sector. What’s being proposed today is to be able to be present at the table of negotiations because we are essential players in the action that now needs to be carried out with regard to climate change, and in order to do that, and this is part of our agenda, we have to find funding that cities need, particularly cities in the South need. They need access to funding so that they can bring about this transformation, living better, housing, air pollution, taking the pollution out of rivers. I think now. at a crossroads in this summit for the future, where we’ve seen the facts, the work is before us. What we need now is willingness to bring all players together, particularly those that are on the front lines, particularly the mares, and I think of the Olympics and things like that and what we experienced in Paris and what we tried to share with the whole world, and namely it was this trust in humanism. I can assure you that living for more than a month, as if the world were all in Paris for a month, where we had people from all continents, all religions, all languages being brought together by sport, meeting in a peaceful environment where as mares, me as mayor, I was able to do everything I could to ensure that we had quality air, for example, so that the water of the Seine could have the pollution taken out of it, so that we could extend this universal welcome, peaceful welcome, and when you experience that, I can tell you, you want to cultivate that. We can’t extend those games or the Paraolympic Games, but what we can do is take that trust in humanity and the ability of those that prefer peace, take that so that we can build this peace together, and that is the path that is now open to us and it will be at the heart of the discussions on the Summit of the Future. Thank you very much.

Folly Bah Thibault: So, what you’re saying is that it’s important that local governments can and should play a big role in this Pact for the Future. Thank you. Thank you very much. And now we’re going to hear from Mr. Axel van Trotsenburg, the Senior Managing Director of the World Bank, who will share his reflections on how the Summit and the Pact for the Future can contribute to reform our global international financial architecture.

Axel van Trotsenburg: Well, thank you very much and good afternoon and a late Saturday afternoon. I hope that everybody stays focused. But first, a congratulation to the fantastic Olympic Games. I think that were fantastically done. I think the Summit of the Future is yet another reminder that we need to stay engaged on development. The SDGs are off track and we cannot forget that. And so, the Summit of the Future should not be limited to words. We need to encourage deeds and action. And the problem, what we are having is we need to have governments engaged, private sector engaged, and yes, multilaterals. Yet multilateralism is under threat. And many are questioning why you have multilateral organizations, be it the UN, be it multilateral development banks. Yet many problems, and the mayor just mentioned climate change, you cannot solve alone. It will require international global collaboration if we want to succeed. So that means that we actually need to put new life in multilateralism. And if you believe in that, you need to invest. You cannot limit the investment to words only. It will require significant amount. We don’t need to remind people and last year at the midterm review of the SDGs, we will need trillions of dollars. And that will have to come from all sources, from government, from private sector, from multilaterals. And that is, I think, the critical one where we need to focus. And some speakers talked about the financing. So I think one can always lecture to the other, but I think the multilaterals should start by themselves. So that is one of the areas where we actually, also at the bank, started the whole reform process. And also to see, can you actually do more with the existing resources? Because many governments, and that we have to admit, they are living on the fiscal stress. It’s not that there is unlimited resources available. And I think here we have done that, and that is a necessary condition. And more needs to be done. How can we get the private sector better involved? And particularly in developing country, and most importantly in the low-income countries. And there it is hard to attract private capital. So we need to think about de-risking mechanisms to incentivize the private sector also to participate. Why is this important? Because we need to keep behind the financing, there are people, there are jobs to create it, and they are not created. There are basically every year 1.2 million young people getting or trying to get in the market, and only a third will find a job. What is happening with the other 800 million? So I think we need to keep that in mind when we do this. Now what it requires for the poorest countries is that you need also concessional resources. Simply for two reasons. There are, they don’t have the fiscal resources to pay for high coupon debt. They will need long-term concessional financing or grants, and that will have to come also from governments. We have the largest fund available for the poorest countries called the International Development Association. It’s replenished every three years. The last round was $93 billion, and donors gave about $23.5 billion. I’m co-chairing the current round. Let me tell you, it is a struggle. It’s a big struggle. Not to agree, that’s on the policy framework. We can get good agreements. But to get more concessional resources from governments is going to be very difficult. And that is a first test. What I am saying is, we cannot only talk, we need to find these necessary resources, and that requires that we still need a mind change that multilateralism matters and ultimately will need to be reflected in policy action as well as money. And I think that is, in a way, where we need to keep this in mind, why this is important. And I just think we need to prioritize, in my mind, the poorest countries first, because their needs are the largest. But I think we are trying, for example, with the African Development Bank, to facilitate the access to energy or electricity for 300 million people in Africa. Six and a half million have no access. So we want to do that by 2030. So it’s very ambitious. But I think these are the type of things where you need to create the conditions. If you don’t have electricity, you cannot have digital. And very often, you can’t have jobs. So we will need to put the basic infrastructure in place so that people can succeed. And so what we need is a far stronger coalition of those that there is a need for internet. national solidarity, and it will need to go also through the purse. You will need to provide some money. Nobody is saying these are the exorbitant amounts in relation to the GDPs we’re having. We should be able to afford that. And that’s the plea what I would say for the summit of the future. We have to look also the summit of solidarity. We cannot forget that, and we need to act on it. Thank you.

Folly Bah Thibault: Solidarity is the key word here. Thank you very much, Mr. van Trotsenburg, Senior Managing Director of the World Bank. Thank you for sharing your reflections with us. Thank you both. Yes, you can return to your seats now. Thank you so much. And now, I’m very pleased to welcome the United Nations Deputy Secretary General to the stage, Amina Mohammed, who will offer her reflections of the conversations we’ve had the past two days here at the Summit of Future Action Days, rich conversations, insightful ones that gives a lot to think about. The DSG will also discuss what lies ahead, right? What happens next after the talking comes the action, right? All right.

Amina J. Mohammed: Thank you so much, Chair Foley, and thank you for being with us all the way through these action days. Your Excellency, the President of Namibia, Your Excellency, our sister and leader, Prime Minister Miyamoto Barbados, President of the General Assembly, Excellencies, colleagues, thank you all for your work and contributions, and very much enjoyed listening to the last session. These action days have showcased the power of inclusive and networked multilateralism, but they’ve also demonstrated the potential and the power of partnerships. They’ve reminded us of the immense potential of collaboration, of what we can achieve when we come together, united in purpose across sectors, generations, and continents. And your diverse contributions reflect the richness of what can be achieved when everyone is brought to the table in an inclusive dialogue. Yesterday, youth-led conversations forced us to face our collective responsibilities to deal with present challenges, and in doing so, take action also to secure a brighter future and for future generations. generations. They showed that meaningful youth engagement looks like in action and underscored the indispensable role that young people play in improving our world and bringing and informing concrete solutions. Today, we focus on the core issues to be resolved to allow financing to flow for sustainable development. Climate finance, taxes, debt. We also address the need to take profit of the potential of technology while managing its risks and to bring peace to a more complex and interconnected world. The discussions throughout the day have explored innovative tax corporation schemes, solutions to global debt, options for the expansion of climate financing, and for increased representation of developing countries in the global financial architecture. The relevance of intergenerational approaches, dismantling patriarchal power structures and putting young people at the forefront of discussions about the future featured strongly in the conversations under peace and security. You’ve also spoken about putting an end to terrorism, protecting civilians in armed conflict, and addressing new and emerging threats, including in the digital sphere. And you’ve insisted that a secure future depends on our ability to build trust, solidarity, and collective action. Finally, we just heard how cutting-edge technology solutions like satellite, internet, blockchain, artificial intelligence are advancing the SDGs. Yet, much work needs to be done to bridge the digital divide. Personal stories from the women and girls across Africa, the Caribbean, Latin America, all demonstrated what is possible by scaling up access and capacities around digital technologies. And all this is while bearing in mind our responsibilities. towards future generations, the 10 billion who will inhabit our planet by the end of this century. What I can promise you is that we will carry your insights and ideas forward into the summit of the future, starting from tomorrow, because your input here, and we’ve seen this throughout the two days, is central to building and shaping a better world. Excellencies and friends, four years ago we began the process for this wonderful summit of the future. The Secretary General called for a more inclusive and networked multilateral system to increase our collective effectiveness. This call was rooted in a recognition of how the world was changing, in the fact that power and the ideas to solve global problems lie in many different hands, and in the fact that our world is in desperate need of transformation. Changes that will allow us to accelerate action, to deliver the promises that have been made to the Sustainable Development Goals, to achieve the SDGs, countries will need to invest, and so we must wrestle with our financial architecture that is no longer fit for purpose. It has served its time, and it’s served it well, and so we need to take this opportunity to make that pivot and be as responsive as we can to the needs of financing the development agenda. Since this process began, the United Nations has provided a platform for the broadest possible engagement, inclusion, and collaboration, and you have responded, putting forward ideas, announcements, initiatives, coalitions, agreed to disagree. Countless civil society networks and groups, including the major groups and other stakeholders, and the impact coalitions from the UN Civil Society Conference, have all been mobilized, heard, and have shaped the outcome of the Summit of the Future. All of you and the constituencies you represent have participated every step of the process in different formats. You’ve pushed for ambition in the three new texts that we are hopeful member states will soon adopt, the Pact for the Future, the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration on Future Generations. Over these past two days alone, over 8,000 individuals have come into the UN HQ. More than 60 events have taken place inside the UN, with an additional 100 more across New York, and a further 30 around the world. world. In short, the UN made a call for an inclusive multilateralism, and you have delivered in trying to shape that. And for that, we thank you sincerely. But we do ask you to keep it up, because the day after is where it counts in implementing those commitments that will be made tomorrow. We need your continued drive, your engagement, and pressure to implement the new texts and hold us to account. You’ve proven time and time again that you’re willing to work together with governments, the UN, and all other actors that are key to building a better world. It is essential that we continue and that we keep strengthening the dialogue between political decision makers and the whole of civil society within the multilateral system. But it is also important to the intergenerational discourse that must continue to be deepened and be strengthened at the national and international level. All of this will be vital to rebuilding trust and hope and restoring legitimacy in international institutions, ensuring that global decisions that we take truly reflect the concerns, the values, and the experiences of people worldwide, 8 billion on our world today. And above all, to demonstrating that multilateralism can deliver for everyone. It can deliver for them everywhere, and it can leave no one behind when we try to shape a better future. So let’s keep working together to make all of that a reality in everyone’s life. Thank you so much.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you. Thank you very much, DSG, for your inspiring remarks, and indeed, let’s keep working together for a better future for all of us. It now gives me great pleasure to introduce the President of the Republic of Namibia, His Excellency Nangolo Mbumba, who will be looking ahead to tomorrow’s Summit of the Future, the official start of the Summit of the Future on Monday, and how we take forward the implementation of the Pact. Please welcome His Excellency Nangolo Mbumba of the Republic of Namibia.

Nangolo Mbumba: Your Excellency Philémon Yang, the 79th President of the General Assembly. Your Excellency Mia Mottley, Prime Minister of Barbados. Your Excellency Amina Mohammed, UN Deputy Secretary General. Excellencies, distinguished delegates, esteemed members of the civil society. We find ourselves in a time of profound global change, where our collective future depends not only on the decisions we make, but on the values we embrace. The United Nations has always been a beacon of common aspirations, fostering cooperation among nations to tackle challenges of our time. As we look to the future, it is clear that the strength of our global community does not only depend on the actions of governments, but on the active participation of civil society in the spirit of the Charter of the United Nations that speaks of We the People. Ladies and gentlemen, as we reflect on the significant journey leading up to this moment, summit of the future, we are reminded of the unwavering commitment and active engagement of various stakeholders, including civil society. The voice of the youth and broader civil society are energizing the world with vitality and a spirit of innovation. Their contributions have been instrumental in shaping both the debates and new commitments outlined in the Pact for the Future. This is the essence of the march of multilateralism. The belief that nations, peoples and communities, by working together towards a shared future of peace, stability and prosperity, can collectively accomplish more than when apart. This collective effort reaffirms the profound relevance of the United Nations in the global community. The action days of the past two days have underscored dynamic youth leadership as we chart a course towards the future of our global community. The outcomes of your discussions on critical issues advancing intergenerational solidarity, promoting climate and environmental foresight, ensuring governance for human rights, peace and security have been nothing short of inspirational. This conversation offers a foundation upon which we can build as we move forward with the adoption of the Pact for the Future. Ladies and gentlemen, I must underscore that our future will not and cannot rest solely on the well-crafted documents. The true measure of our success will be in the effective implementation of the pact for the future, the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration of Future Generations. These initiatives will be pivotal in advancing the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. Namibia, as is the case for most African countries, has a younger population. This pact is not just for leaders of today. It is for you, the youth, who will inherit the wealth of today and tomorrow. It is a framework that seeks to secure your future by addressing the most critical issues that humanity faces. We therefore recognize and celebrate the active participation of the youth and the critical role they play as civil society in strengthening democracy. It is through the voices of community organizations, grassroots movements, and individuals, which are often led by young people, that we are reminded of the needs and aspirations of the people we are serving. The role is critical as active partners in shaping our international institutions. Since the release of our Common Agenda by the Secretary-General, his proposal for the Summit of the Future was always clear. This summit must have an outcome that is a bold step forward, charting a path for a more just, sustainable, and inclusive world. The Pact for the Future calls for urgent action on climate change. Namibia, like many other nations, is already feeling the effect of a warming planet. Our farmers suffer from severe droughts, our ecosystems are under threat, and our coastal communities are at risk from rising sea levels. The Pact recognizes the need for global peace and security. Peace is not just the absence of war. It is the presence of justice, equality, and human rights. The Pact for the Future highlights the transformative power of technology. In a world where technological innovation is advancing at an unprecedented rate, we must ensure that these advancements do not widen the gap between the rich and the poor, between those with access and those without. It is, therefore, incumbent upon us to amplify the voices of the marginalized and to push for ambitious action in the critical areas of climate change, human rights, and equitable development. Excellencies, delegates, esteemed youth delegates of civil society, we all are part of a global community. When we adopt the Pact of the Future tomorrow, let us hold hands and pull in the same direction to ensure that together we can build a world that truly leaves no one behind. And I thank you for your attention.

Folly Bah Thibault: Thank you very much, Your Excellency, the President of Namibia, Nangolo Mbumba, for his remarks and calling for action from all of us, as he said, not just governments, of course, but civil society and the different actors. Thank you very much, Mr. President. And it’s now my great pleasure to introduce the Prime Minister of Barbados, Her Excellency Mia Mottley, who will offer her perspective on the way forward.

Mia Mottley: Thank you very much, Madam Chair, President of Namibia, the Deputy Secretary General, my dear sister, President of the General Assembly, President Yang, brothers and sisters. We are here on a Saturday afternoon from so many different corners of the earth because we know that our time here and our commitment matters more than ever. As we speak, war rages in the Middle East, in Africa, in Europe, and in the Americas while there is no declared war, there is conflict that causes the loss of lives because of access to assault weapons and all of those other things that literally have undermined citizen security in our hemisphere. We are here in the season of superlatives from the dryas. to the wettest, to the strongest storms, every possible thing that we could imagine that can disrupt our way of life from the environment, and the range of biodiversity that is so essential to the balance of our earth, has already been affecting us. And we are here, generations after countries declared independence, with the intention of being able to deliver for their people the best life possible, but constrained of course by the absence of access to development opportunities, and most importantly of all, to the fuel, to the oxygen, to the financing that matches the needs of their people. I do not tire in saying that we cannot build schools and hospitals with 10 and 15 year money. We’re here because even though noises were made every decade for the last few decades, that things ought to change, they continued in the same direction, fueled by greed, fueled by inequity, fueled by marginalization, fueled by values reflected by human beings taking decisions, or as His Holiness would say to us, from literally the desensitization that comes that allows us to take comfort in ignoring what we see and what we hear. I take comfort this evening from the fact that we are here, but we being here will only be a record or a footnote in history. if our actions just end here. Yes, the conclusion of the pact for the future is the seminal treaty and theoretical point from which we want to take our action. But the truth is that that may become just simply another document in history if all that we have come to do is to secure a pact. We have now to ensure that we enlarge the people, the army, the believers, the doers, who are prepared to say that in the same way history can record successfully that slavery was wrong and needed to be abolished, in the same way that we can have history record successfully that women should have the right of agency over their vote and their body, in the same way that history can record successfully that the people who live in separate and apart systems in South Africa, or regrettably now as we see in the Middle East, that they should be freed from the bondages that allow others to determine what their destiny should be and to be able to secure it for themselves and the least capable among them. If you lived at those points in history, you might well have said that the battle was impossible. But we know enough to know, as President Mandela told us, it is not impossible if it can. be done, or it is impossible until it is done. This world can change, but it needs our energy, our commitment, and in the same way in electoral matters we go out and find other people to help us proselytize and canvas, we must now go out and find ordinary citizens who are prepared to say that they’re not wishing to be pawns anymore of others, and that the notion of two worlds, one for those who have and the rest for those who are relegated to not have it, one for those who see people and feel people and understand their obligation to help, and others who are insensitive and do not quite frankly care or see those around them. If we doubted the power of the people we only need to see where that power has made significant changes even in this year of that we live in, but what matters now is that there be coordinated action and that we believe and that we sell and share with each other that there is a possibility for a win-win, that there is a possibility for us to have a green transition that can mitigate the damages that would otherwise come from the climate crisis, that there is the possibility for ensuring greater equitable access to artificial intelligence and that the power of regulation can ensure that it be a force for good and not an instrument of oppression or recolonization of the earth, that it is possible for us to be able to take stances that recognize that investment in education will always trump conflict and war. and guns. But that there may be difficult decisions that we may have to make too. And the problem is, is that if we have a world that is dominated only by 60 second sound bites and four column inches, rather than allowing the spaces for discussion as we are doing in here, not just at the UN but in the villages, in the towns, in the communities, in the homes, in the households, that if we don’t get that discussion going, we’re not going to get the level of participation and we’re not going to build the momentum necessary that can move the inequity and that can remove the threats that this world has. I believe that it is possible for us to have a win-win. I believe that hope can be restored. But I do recognize that we are at that inflection point. And those who have power and want to maintain the status quo, even though they do not yet have a plan for allowing us to live on Mars, they are adamant on not creating the space or the policy flexibility or the access to the funding necessary for us to bring along others. It is unconscionable for us not to recognize that unless we can provide the basics of food, water, shelter, electricity to all people on this earth, we cannot talk about being a successful generation in human civilization. And we all know, we all know that there is sufficient to be able to share. What is needed is the change in attitude and values. I’m not going to reflect only on the fact that almost every religion carries us in the direction of caring for the most vulnerable, because people may want then to get into the schisms and isms of religious differences. But there is, in African civilization, the concept of Ubuntu. I am.

Folly Bah Thibault:

N

Nudhara Yusuf

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Intergenerational dialogue and rebuilding trust

Explanation

The session focused on the search for peace in today’s complex world. It emphasized the importance of rebuilding trust and engaging in dialogue across generations to build peace.

Evidence

The session included reflections from elders, former presidents, and young peacebuilders on rebuilding trust and engaging in dialogue.

Major Discussion Point

Achieving a Peaceful Future for All

Dismantling patriarchal power structures

Explanation

The session explored how patriarchal power structures affect people’s lives and how war amplifies these structures. It discussed ways to dismantle oppressive structures and the role of women and men as leaders in this effort.

Evidence

The session mentioned using football as a tool to achieve dismantling of patriarchal structures.

Major Discussion Point

Achieving a Peaceful Future for All

Countering terrorism through solidarity and cooperation

Explanation

The session highlighted the need for solidarity, common understanding, and a cooperative approach to countering terrorism. It reinforced the commitment to universal norms and consistent application of international law in countering terrorism.

Evidence

The session recognized youth and diverse actors as vital to achieving a future free from terrorism through leadership, innovation, and fostering global cooperation.

Major Discussion Point

Achieving a Peaceful Future for All

Protecting civilians from explosive weapons

Explanation

The session discussed the protection of civilians impacted by the use of explosive weapons in urban settings. It called for action to implement political declarations on the use of explosive weapons in populated areas and address the rights of persons with disabilities impacted by armed conflict.

Evidence

The session included stories of resilience and messages urging an end to multigenerational trauma.

Major Discussion Point

Achieving a Peaceful Future for All

Harnessing technology for peace while mitigating risks

Explanation

The session explored scenarios for peace and security in 2045, considering factors like advancing technology and climate change. It discussed how technologies can be harnessed for good while mitigating risks for a peaceful digital future.

Evidence

A call to action was presented to recommit to multilateralism, resolve disputes peacefully, and develop governance frameworks fit for a changing world.

Major Discussion Point

Achieving a Peaceful Future for All

B

Betty Wainaina

Speech speed

119 words per minute

Speech length

478 words

Speech time

240 seconds

Reforming international financial architecture

Explanation

The session emphasized the need for bold reform of the international financial architecture to keep pace with 21st-century realities. Speakers called for bigger and better international financial institutions and more accessible financing for developing countries.

Evidence

The upcoming fourth International Conference on Financing for Development in Spain in 2025 was mentioned as a platform to turn ambitions into action.

Major Discussion Point

Creating a Sustainable Future for All

Agreed with

Axel van Trotsenburg

Mia Mottley

Agreed on

Need for reforming global financial systems

Strengthening international tax cooperation

Explanation

The session highlighted the importance of tax as a tool for providing income, setting incentives, and reducing inequality. Speakers stressed the need for global initiatives to strengthen international tax cooperation.

Evidence

The Framework Convention on international tax cooperation was mentioned as a potential initiative.

Major Discussion Point

Creating a Sustainable Future for All

Addressing the debt crisis in developing countries

Explanation

The session discussed how debt servicing is crowding out SDG financing. Speakers stressed the need for a global consensus to stem the rising debt crisis, including a systemic multilateral approach.

Evidence

Instruments such as climate resilient debt clauses and state contingent debt instruments were suggested to be rolled out at scale.

Major Discussion Point

Creating a Sustainable Future for All

Scaling up development and climate financing

Explanation

The session emphasized the need to pursue both scale and quality in development and climate financing. Public development banks were highlighted as playing a key role, with the private sector also needing to step up.

Major Discussion Point

Creating a Sustainable Future for All

R

Rumman Chowdhury

Speech speed

118 words per minute

Speech length

309 words

Speech time

156 seconds

Reducing the digital divide and ensuring universal access

Explanation

The session highlighted the urgent need to reduce the digital divide, not just in terms of connectivity, but also in ensuring access to affordable and safe digital technology. It emphasized the importance of providing skills and capacities for meaningful use of technology.

Major Discussion Point

Shaping a Digital Future for All

Leveraging digital innovations to achieve SDGs

Explanation

The session showcased a diverse range of groundbreaking digital innovations driving progress towards achieving the SDGs. These innovations span various sectors including healthcare, education, climate mitigation, poverty alleviation, and gender equality.

Evidence

A personal story was shared about Bianca Johnson, a young paraplegic woman who regained mobility thanks to technology.

Major Discussion Point

Shaping a Digital Future for All

Agreed with

Nangolo Mbumba

Amina J. Mohammed

Agreed on

Importance of youth engagement in shaping the future

Developing inclusive AI governance

Explanation

The session discussed what an inclusive architecture for AI governance looks like, building on the AI advisory body’s report ‘Governing AI for Humanity’. Announcements were made on implementing the report’s recommendations.

Major Discussion Point

Shaping a Digital Future for All

Fostering multi-stakeholder partnerships for digital inclusion

Explanation

The session emphasized the importance of innovative, inclusive, and multi-stakeholder partnerships focused on specific SDG goals and targets. It highlighted the power of collective action in advancing digital inclusion.

Evidence

The SDG digital event saw the announcement of $1.05 billion in pledges to support various initiatives to advance digital inclusion via the Partner to Connect platform.

Major Discussion Point

Shaping a Digital Future for All

A

Anne Hidalgo

Speech speed

131 words per minute

Speech length

645 words

Speech time

293 seconds

Including local authorities in multilateral efforts

Explanation

Hidalgo emphasized the importance of including local authorities in global governance and multilateral efforts. She argued for recognition of the place of local governments in addressing global challenges like climate change and poverty.

Evidence

Hidalgo mentioned networks like C40 where cities have been working together for 10 years to gain recognition in global governance.

Major Discussion Point

Role of Local Governments in Implementation

Agreed with

Amina J. Mohammed

Mia Mottley

Agreed on

Importance of inclusive multilateralism

Providing funding for cities to address climate change and development

Explanation

Hidalgo stressed the need for cities, particularly in the Global South, to have access to funding. This funding is crucial for transforming cities to address issues like climate change, housing, air pollution, and water pollution.

Major Discussion Point

Role of Local Governments in Implementation

Fostering trust and peaceful coexistence through local initiatives

Explanation

Hidalgo highlighted the role of cities in fostering trust and peaceful coexistence among diverse populations. She emphasized the importance of creating environments where people from all backgrounds can come together peacefully.

Evidence

Hidalgo shared her experience of hosting the Olympics in Paris, where people from all continents, religions, and languages came together in a peaceful environment.

Major Discussion Point

Role of Local Governments in Implementation

A

Axel van Trotsenburg

Speech speed

134 words per minute

Speech length

866 words

Speech time

385 seconds

Reinvigorating multilateralism through increased funding

Explanation

Van Trotsenburg emphasized the need to reinvigorate multilateralism through increased funding. He argued that addressing global challenges like climate change requires significant investment from all sources, including governments, private sector, and multilaterals.

Evidence

He mentioned that trillions of dollars will be needed to achieve the SDGs, as highlighted in the midterm review of the SDGs last year.

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Financial Architecture

Providing concessional financing for poorest countries

Explanation

Van Trotsenburg stressed the importance of providing concessional financing or grants for the poorest countries. He argued that these countries lack the fiscal resources to pay for high-coupon debt and need long-term concessional financing.

Evidence

He mentioned the International Development Association, which provides the largest fund for the poorest countries, with its last round raising $93 billion.

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Financial Architecture

Agreed with

Betty Wainaina

Mia Mottley

Agreed on

Need for reforming global financial systems

Incentivizing private sector participation in developing countries

Explanation

Van Trotsenburg highlighted the need to incentivize private sector participation in developing countries, particularly in low-income countries. He suggested developing de-risking mechanisms to encourage private capital investment in these areas.

Evidence

He mentioned that out of 1.2 million young people entering the job market annually, only a third find jobs, emphasizing the need for private sector involvement in job creation.

Major Discussion Point

Reforming Global Financial Architecture

A

Amina J. Mohammed

Speech speed

144 words per minute

Speech length

1046 words

Speech time

434 seconds

Implementing new global agreements through inclusive partnerships

Explanation

Mohammed emphasized the importance of implementing new global agreements through inclusive and networked multilateralism. She highlighted the power of partnerships and collaboration across sectors, generations, and continents.

Evidence

She mentioned that over 8,000 individuals came to the UN HQ, with more than 60 events taking place inside the UN and additional events across New York and around the world.

Major Discussion Point

Moving from Commitments to Action

Agreed with

Anne Hidalgo

Mia Mottley

Agreed on

Importance of inclusive multilateralism

Strengthening intergenerational discourse at national and international levels

Explanation

Mohammed stressed the importance of deepening and strengthening intergenerational discourse at both national and international levels. She argued that this is vital for rebuilding trust and hope in international institutions.

Major Discussion Point

Moving from Commitments to Action

Agreed with

Nangolo Mbumba

Rumman Chowdhury

Agreed on

Importance of youth engagement in shaping the future

Rebuilding trust in international institutions

Explanation

Mohammed emphasized the need to rebuild trust and restore legitimacy in international institutions. She argued that this is essential for ensuring that global decisions reflect the concerns, values, and experiences of people worldwide.

Major Discussion Point

Moving from Commitments to Action

N

Nangolo Mbumba

Speech speed

94 words per minute

Speech length

777 words

Speech time

490 seconds

Recognizing youth as key stakeholders in global decision-making

Explanation

Mbumba emphasized the importance of recognizing and celebrating the active participation of youth in global decision-making processes. He argued that the youth play a critical role in strengthening democracy and shaping international institutions.

Evidence

He mentioned that Namibia, like most African countries, has a younger population, and the Pact for the Future is for the youth who will inherit the world of today and tomorrow.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Engagement in Shaping the Future

Agreed with

Amina J. Mohammed

Rumman Chowdhury

Agreed on

Importance of youth engagement in shaping the future

Amplifying voices of marginalized groups through youth leadership

Explanation

Mbumba stressed the importance of amplifying the voices of marginalized groups through youth leadership. He called for pushing ambitious action in critical areas that affect these groups.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Engagement in Shaping the Future

Addressing climate change, human rights, and equitable development

Explanation

Mbumba highlighted the need for urgent action on climate change, ensuring global peace and security, and harnessing the transformative power of technology. He emphasized the importance of addressing these issues in an equitable manner.

Evidence

He mentioned Namibia’s experience with severe droughts, threatened ecosystems, and coastal communities at risk from rising sea levels as examples of climate change impacts.

Major Discussion Point

Youth Engagement in Shaping the Future

M

Mia Mottley

Speech speed

0 words per minute

Speech length

0 words

Speech time

1 seconds

Reforming financial systems to match development needs

Explanation

Mottley emphasized the need to reform financial systems to better match the development needs of countries. She argued that current financial structures constrain countries’ ability to deliver for their people and access development opportunities.

Evidence

She stated that countries cannot build schools and hospitals with 10 and 15 year money, highlighting the mismatch between financial structures and development needs.

Major Discussion Point

Transforming Global Systems for Equity

Agreed with

Betty Wainaina

Axel van Trotsenburg

Agreed on

Need for reforming global financial systems

Ensuring equitable access to new technologies like AI

Explanation

Mottley stressed the importance of ensuring equitable access to new technologies, particularly artificial intelligence. She argued for the need to regulate these technologies to ensure they are a force for good rather than instruments of oppression or recolonization.

Major Discussion Point

Transforming Global Systems for Equity

Agreed with

Anne Hidalgo

Amina J. Mohammed

Agreed on

Importance of inclusive multilateralism

Prioritizing education and dialogue over conflict

Explanation

Mottley emphasized the importance of prioritizing investment in education over conflict and war. She argued for creating spaces for discussion and dialogue at all levels of society to build momentum for change.

Major Discussion Point

Transforming Global Systems for Equity

Providing basic necessities to all people globally

Explanation

Mottley argued for the necessity of providing basic necessities like food, water, shelter, and electricity to all people on Earth. She stated that this is essential for considering our generation successful in human civilization.

Evidence

She pointed out that there are sufficient resources to share, but what is needed is a change in attitude and values.

Major Discussion Point

Transforming Global Systems for Equity

Agreements

Agreement Points

Importance of youth engagement in shaping the future

Nangolo Mbumba

Amina J. Mohammed

Rumman Chowdhury

Recognizing youth as key stakeholders in global decision-making

Strengthening intergenerational discourse at national and international levels

Leveraging digital innovations to achieve SDGs

These speakers emphasized the crucial role of youth in decision-making processes, intergenerational dialogue, and leveraging technology for sustainable development.

Need for reforming global financial systems

Betty Wainaina

Axel van Trotsenburg

Mia Mottley

Reforming international financial architecture

Providing concessional financing for poorest countries

Reforming financial systems to match development needs

These speakers agreed on the urgent need to reform global financial systems to better support developing countries and match their development needs.

Importance of inclusive multilateralism

Anne Hidalgo

Amina J. Mohammed

Mia Mottley

Including local authorities in multilateral efforts

Implementing new global agreements through inclusive partnerships

Ensuring equitable access to new technologies like AI

These speakers emphasized the importance of inclusive multilateralism, involving local authorities, diverse partnerships, and ensuring equitable access to new technologies.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers stressed the importance of addressing the debt crisis in developing countries and providing concessional financing to support their development needs.

Betty Wainaina

Axel van Trotsenburg

Addressing the debt crisis in developing countries

Providing concessional financing for poorest countries

Both speakers emphasized the importance of addressing systemic inequalities and prioritizing peaceful approaches to conflict resolution.

Nudhara Yusuf

Mia Mottley

Dismantling patriarchal power structures

Prioritizing education and dialogue over conflict

Unexpected Consensus

Role of local governments in global governance

Anne Hidalgo

Nangolo Mbumba

Including local authorities in multilateral efforts

Recognizing youth as key stakeholders in global decision-making

While coming from different perspectives (local government and national leadership), both speakers emphasized the importance of including diverse voices in global governance structures.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement included the importance of youth engagement, the need for financial system reform, and the value of inclusive multilateralism.

Consensus level

There was a moderate to high level of consensus among the speakers on these key issues, suggesting a shared understanding of the challenges facing global governance and development. This consensus implies a potential for collaborative action on these fronts in the implementation of the Pact for the Future.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Approach to financing development

Axel van Trotsenburg

Mia Mottley

Van Trotsenburg stressed the importance of providing concessional financing or grants for the poorest countries. He argued that these countries lack the fiscal resources to pay for high-coupon debt and need long-term concessional financing.

Mottley emphasized the need to reform financial systems to better match the development needs of countries. She argued that current financial structures constrain countries’ ability to deliver for their people and access development opportunities.

While both speakers agree on the need for better financing for developing countries, they differ in their approach. Van Trotsenburg focuses on concessional financing and grants, while Mottley argues for a more fundamental reform of the financial system.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around the specific approaches to financing development, the role of different stakeholders in global governance, and the prioritization of various issues within the broader context of sustainable development and global cooperation.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among the speakers appears to be relatively low. Most speakers seem to agree on the overall goals and the need for action, with differences mainly in the specific approaches or areas of focus. This level of disagreement is not likely to significantly impede progress on the topics at hand, but rather could lead to a more comprehensive and nuanced approach to addressing global challenges.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

Both speakers agree on the need for more inclusive decision-making processes in global governance, but they focus on different groups: Hidalgo on local authorities and Mbumba on youth.

Anne Hidalgo

Nangolo Mbumba

Hidalgo emphasized the importance of including local authorities in global governance and multilateral efforts. She argued for recognition of the place of local governments in addressing global challenges like climate change and poverty.

Mbumba emphasized the importance of recognizing and celebrating the active participation of youth in global decision-making processes. He argued that the youth play a critical role in strengthening democracy and shaping international institutions.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers stressed the importance of addressing the debt crisis in developing countries and providing concessional financing to support their development needs.

Betty Wainaina

Axel van Trotsenburg

Addressing the debt crisis in developing countries

Providing concessional financing for poorest countries

Both speakers emphasized the importance of addressing systemic inequalities and prioritizing peaceful approaches to conflict resolution.

Nudhara Yusuf

Mia Mottley

Dismantling patriarchal power structures

Prioritizing education and dialogue over conflict

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

The Summit of the Future Action Days highlighted the importance of inclusive, multi-stakeholder partnerships to address global challenges

Reforming the international financial architecture is crucial for achieving sustainable development and climate goals

Youth engagement and intergenerational approaches are essential for shaping a better future

Digital technologies and AI offer opportunities for advancing SDGs but require governance frameworks to manage risks

Local governments play a vital role in implementing global agreements and fostering peace

Rebuilding trust in multilateral institutions is necessary to address complex global issues

Resolutions and Action Items

Implement the Pact for the Future, Global Digital Compact, and Declaration on Future Generations

Scale up development and climate financing, particularly for poorest countries

Strengthen international tax cooperation, including through a Framework Convention

Develop inclusive AI governance frameworks

Increase funding and support for multilateral institutions

Enhance youth participation in global decision-making processes

Unresolved Issues

Specific mechanisms for reforming the international financial architecture

Concrete steps to address the debt crisis in developing countries

Detailed plans for bridging the digital divide globally

Precise methods for dismantling patriarchal power structures in peace processes

Exact strategies for protecting civilians from explosive weapons in urban settings

Suggested Compromises

Balancing the need for increased development financing with fiscal constraints of donor countries

Finding common ground between different stakeholders (governments, private sector, civil society) in shaping global policies

Reconciling rapid technological advancement with equitable access and ethical considerations

Harmonizing local government initiatives with national and international policy frameworks

Thought Provoking Comments

We stand as the last few generations who can do something about the challenges that we face, and the first few generations that have the opportunity to seize new potentials for impact.

Speaker

Nudhara Yusuf

Reason

This comment powerfully frames the current moment as both a critical responsibility and unique opportunity for action, emphasizing the urgency and potential of the present generation.

Impact

It set an inspiring and action-oriented tone for the discussion, emphasizing the need for concrete steps rather than just talk.

Debt servicing is crowding out SDG financing. Speakers stressed the need for global consensus to stem the rising debt crisis, including a systemic multilateral approach.

Speaker

Betty Wainaina

Reason

This highlights a critical obstacle to sustainable development and calls for a coordinated global response, demonstrating the interconnectedness of financial and development issues.

Impact

It shifted the conversation towards the practical financial challenges of implementing sustainable development goals, leading to discussion of specific policy proposals.

Multilateralism is under threat. And many are questioning why you have multilateral organizations, be it the UN, be it multilateral development banks. Yet many problems, and the mayor just mentioned climate change, you cannot solve alone. It will require international global collaboration if we want to succeed.

Speaker

Axel van Trotsenburg

Reason

This comment directly addresses a core challenge to global cooperation while asserting its necessity, particularly for issues like climate change.

Impact

It refocused the discussion on the importance of multilateral institutions and international cooperation, leading to further exploration of how to strengthen these systems.

The true measure of our success will be in the effective implementation of the pact for the future, the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration of Future Generations. These initiatives will be pivotal in advancing the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.

Speaker

Nangolo Mbumba

Reason

This comment shifts focus from agreement on principles to the critical importance of implementation, tying the discussion to concrete global development goals.

Impact

It moved the conversation from theoretical discussions to practical considerations of how to turn agreements into action, emphasizing accountability.

If we doubted the power of the people we only need to see where that power has made significant changes even in this year of that we live in, but what matters now is that there be coordinated action and that we believe and that we sell and share with each other that there is a possibility for a win-win

Speaker

Mia Mottley

Reason

This comment emphasizes the power of collective action while also stressing the need for coordination and shared vision, bridging grassroots energy with organized efforts.

Impact

It energized the discussion by highlighting recent successes and the potential for positive change, while also calling for strategic, coordinated efforts.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by consistently emphasizing the need for concrete action, global cooperation, and effective implementation of agreed-upon goals. They moved the conversation beyond theoretical agreements to practical considerations of financing, institutional reform, and coordinated efforts. The speakers highlighted both the urgency of current challenges and the unique opportunities of the present moment, creating a sense of both responsibility and possibility. This framing encouraged a forward-looking, action-oriented discussion that tied high-level agreements to tangible impacts on sustainable development and global cooperation.

Follow-up Questions

How can we effectively implement the political declaration on the use of explosive weapons in populated areas?

Speaker

Nudhara Yusuf

Explanation

This was highlighted as a key action point to protect civilians in conflict zones

What specific governance frameworks are needed to address future risks in a changing world?

Speaker

Nudhara Yusuf

Explanation

This was mentioned as part of a call to action for peace in a digital world

How can we accelerate the implementation of climate resilient debt clauses and state contingent debt instruments at scale?

Speaker

Betty Wainaina

Explanation

These were identified as important tools to address the debt crisis in developing countries

What concrete steps can be taken to reform the international financial architecture to better support developing countries?

Speaker

Betty Wainaina

Explanation

This was emphasized as crucial for achieving the SDGs

How can we effectively bridge the digital divide, particularly in terms of skills and capacities to use digital technology meaningfully?

Speaker

Rumman Chowdhury

Explanation

This was highlighted as a key challenge in achieving a digital future for all

What specific mechanisms can be developed to de-risk investments and incentivize private sector participation in low-income countries?

Speaker

Axel van Trotsenburg

Explanation

This was identified as crucial for attracting private capital to developing countries

How can we strengthen the intergenerational discourse at national and international levels?

Speaker

Amina J. Mohammed

Explanation

This was emphasized as important for rebuilding trust and legitimacy in international institutions

What concrete actions can be taken to ensure the effective implementation of the Pact for the Future, the Global Digital Compact, and the Declaration of Future Generations?

Speaker

Nangolo Mbumba

Explanation

This was stressed as the true measure of success beyond the adoption of these documents

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

A Digital Future for All (afternoon sessions)

A Digital Future for All (afternoon sessions)

Session at a Glance

Summary

This discussion focused on the Global Digital Compact (GDC) and the role of artificial intelligence (AI) in shaping a digital future that benefits humanity. The event brought together leaders from government, technology, civil society, and international organizations to explore how to harness digital technologies and AI for sustainable development while addressing potential risks.

Key themes included the importance of inclusivity, bridging the digital divide, and ensuring AI governance is rooted in human rights. Speakers emphasized the need for multi-stakeholder cooperation and global governance frameworks to guide AI development. The United Nations was highlighted as uniquely positioned to facilitate this process due to its global reach and legitimacy.

Participants discussed both the transformative potential of AI to accelerate progress on sustainable development goals and the need to mitigate risks like bias, privacy concerns, and potential misuse. The importance of building capacity, especially in developing countries, was stressed to prevent an “AI divide” from emerging.

Recommendations from the UN’s High-Level Advisory Body on AI were presented, including proposals for a global AI capacity network, an international scientific panel on AI, and mechanisms to foster inclusive AI development. Speakers noted the urgency of action, given AI’s rapid advancement.

The discussion concluded on an optimistic note, with participants expressing hope that early engagement on AI governance could help steer the technology towards benefiting humanity. However, they emphasized sustained effort and cooperation would be needed to realize this vision of an inclusive, sustainable digital future for all.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– The importance of developing AI and digital technologies in an inclusive, ethical way that benefits all of humanity

– The need for global cooperation and governance frameworks for AI, with the UN playing a key role

– Bridging the digital divide and ensuring developing countries can participate in and benefit from AI advancements

– Balancing the opportunities of AI with potential risks and challenges

– Implementing the Global Digital Compact and moving from principles to concrete actions

Overall purpose/goal:

The discussion aimed to highlight the transformative potential of AI and digital technologies while emphasizing the need for responsible development and governance to ensure these technologies benefit all of humanity. It sought to build momentum for global cooperation on AI governance through initiatives like the Global Digital Compact.

Tone:

The overall tone was optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers emphasizing the positive potential of AI while acknowledging challenges. There was a sense of urgency about the need to act quickly to shape AI’s development. The tone became more action-oriented towards the end, focusing on next steps and implementation.

Speakers

Moderators/Facilitators:

– Redi Thlabi – Journalist and TV Host Al Jazeera English

– Tumi Makgabo – In Africa World Wide Media

Speakers:

– Ian Bremmer – Political Scientist, President of Eurasia Group and GZERO Media

– Ebba Busch – Minister for Energy, Business and Industry and Deputy Prime Minister of Sweden

– Sundar Pichai – CEO, Google and Alphabet

– Felix Mutati – Minister of Technology and Science, Zambia

– Margrethe Vestager – Executive Vice President of the European Union

– Rebeca Grynspan – Secretary-General, United Nations Trade and Development (UNCTAD)

– Omar Al Olama – Minister of State for Artificial Intelligence, Digital Economy and Remote Work in the United Arab Emirates

– Josephine Teo – Minister for Digital Development and Information, Singapore

– Nnenna Nwakanma – Digital Policy, Advocacy and Cooperation Strategist

– Carme Artigas – Former Secretary of State for Digitalisation and AI of Spain and Co-Chair of the Secretary-General’s High-level Advisory Body on Artificial Intelligence

– James Manyika – Senior VP, Google-Alphabet and Co-Chair of the Secretary-General’s High-level Advisory Body on Artificial Intelligence

– Vilas Dhar – President and Trustee, Patrick J. McGovern Foundation

– Jian Wang – CTO and Founder, Alibaba Cloud

– Volker Türk, High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR)

– Alondra Nelson – Harold F. Linder Professor, Institute for Advanced Study

– Mokgweetsi Masisi – President of Botswana

– Amandeep Singh Gill – UN Secretary-General’s Envoy on Technology

– Achim Steiner – Administrator of UNDP

– Doreen Bogdan-Martin – Secretary-General of the ITU

The speakers represent a diverse range of expertise including government leadership, technology industry executives, civil society representatives, academics, and leaders of international organizations. Their areas of focus include artificial intelligence, digital development, human rights, sustainable development, and global governance.

Full session report

The Global Digital Compact and AI Governance: Shaping a Digital Future for All

This high-level discussion brought together diverse leaders from government, technology, civil society, and international organizations to explore the role of artificial intelligence (AI) in shaping an inclusive digital future. The conversation centered on the Global Digital Compact (GDC) and the need for responsible AI development and governance to benefit all of humanity.

Key Themes and Agreements

1. The Global Digital Compact as a Foundation for AI Governance

There was broad consensus on the importance of the Global Digital Compact as a starting point for global AI governance. Speakers like Carme Artigas and Omar Al Olama emphasized the unique position of the United Nations to lead this effort. James Manyika stressed the need for a multi-stakeholder approach, which was echoed by other participants. Volker Turk noted that the GDC builds on existing human rights frameworks, stating, “The Global Digital Compact is firmly anchored in human rights.”

2. AI’s Potential for Sustainable Development

Speakers agreed on AI’s transformative potential to accelerate progress on Sustainable Development Goals. Felix Mutati highlighted AI’s ability to transform lives in rural areas, saying, “AI has the potential to leapfrog development.” However, many stressed the need to bridge the digital divide to prevent an AI divide, emphasizing the importance of building AI capacity in developing countries.

3. Balancing Innovation and Risk Mitigation

There was general agreement on the need for a balanced approach to AI governance that promotes innovation while mitigating risks. Margrethe Vestager emphasized the importance of enforceable AI regulation, while Carme Artigas highlighted the need to balance innovation and risk mitigation.

4. Human Rights and Community Engagement

Speakers like Volker Turk and Alondra Nelson emphasized the importance of grounding AI governance and development in existing human rights frameworks. Vilas Dhar highlighted the importance of community engagement in AI development, challenging the typical narrative of top-down control in governance.

5. Scientific Research and Understanding of AI

Multiple speakers, including James Manyika, Dr. Wang Jian, and Alondra Nelson, stressed the importance of scientific research to better understand AI systems and their impacts. Manyika proposed “a real-time scientific panel on AI developments,” while Nelson drew parallels to rapid scientific developments during the COVID-19 pandemic.

6. Role of the Private Sector

James Manyika and others discussed the crucial role of the private sector in AI governance. Manyika emphasized the need for collaboration, stating, “We need everybody at the table – governments, civil society, academia, and the private sector.”

7. Capacity Building and Infrastructure

Many speakers emphasized the importance of capacity building and infrastructure development for AI in developing countries. Nnenna Nwakanma’s statement, “Connect the schools. Connect the young people. Connect my children,” refocused the conversation on practical, human-centered outcomes of digital development.

Key Recommendations and Action Items

1. Recommendations from the UN High-Level Advisory Body on AI, as discussed by Ian Bremmer and panelists, including:

– Establishing a global fund for AI for sustainable development

– Creating an international scientific panel on AI

– Developing a global AI capacity-building program

2. Proposal to make an online platform available for public input on the Global Digital Compact after its adoption

3. Emphasis on building AI capacity and infrastructure in developing countries to prevent an AI divide

4. Focus on sustainable and ethical AI development practices, as highlighted by Alondra Nelson

5. Plan to potentially adopt the Global Digital Compact at the upcoming Summit of the Future

Thought-Provoking Insights

1. Vilas Dhar reframed governance as a collaborative process involving multiple stakeholders, not just governments and tech companies.

2. Mokgweetsi Masisi highlighted the interconnection between digital divides, global inequality, and gender disparities.

3. Alondra Nelson acknowledged the limitations of current knowledge about AI systems, emphasizing the need for ongoing research and understanding.

Unresolved Issues and Future Directions

Despite the productive discussion, several issues remain to be addressed:

1. Specific mechanisms for enforcing AI governance globally

2. Details on implementation of the proposed global fund on AI

3. How to effectively balance AI development with sustainability and climate concerns

4. Concrete steps to ensure AI benefits reach marginalized communities

In conclusion, the discussion demonstrated a high level of consensus on fundamental principles and goals for AI governance, providing a strong foundation for global cooperation. The conversation evolved from high-level policy talk to considering concrete actions and their impacts on diverse communities, particularly in the Global South. The Global Digital Compact emerges as a crucial starting point for global AI governance, with emphasis on multi-stakeholder involvement, scientific research, capacity building, and human rights-centered approaches. As Amandeep Singh Gill noted, “The Global Digital Compact is our chance to shape our digital future.” The stage is set for continued dialogue and action on shaping an inclusive, sustainable digital future for all.

Session Transcript

Redi Thlabi: I think the applause was loudest this side. You’re very generous. Thank you. Good afternoon. Honored delegates, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Redi Thlabi. I’m a broadcast journalist, a moderator, an MC from Johannesburg, South Africa, delighted to be a visitor in the United States. I noticed that when the lunch break was announced, many of you did not leave. That tells me that you were in this room this morning when the answer to why we are here was provided. In the morning, we saw the real impact of digital tools, of artificial intelligence enabling human flourishing. Who can forget Adit, a young lady who grew up in a refugee camp, but she was able to access learning. She was able to connect with other young people from other parts of the world because she had the technology to do so. Who can forget how we witnessed the ability to get mobility after an acute injury. The mobility that you and I take for granted, but when you lose it, you need technology, you need innovation to help you be a part of the global community. You were in this room when we saw how technological tools can be enabled to respond to the planetary crisis that we are all facing today. That’s what happened this morning. So what are we doing this afternoon? We are here to ensure that those case studies that we heard about in the morning are not just the exception, but they become the norm. We are here to renew our commitments, to find solutions to the crises that we face, to ensure that we create a global digital architecture, a compact that is human-centered, that is secure, that is efficient, that is accessible to all. Because if we don’t do this, we create other frontiers of inequality. I come from Africa, I’m a part of the Global South, and we see very much how often we feel as if the world is advancing without us, even though we have the expertise, the agency, the tools, the willingness. But without the investment, without being invited into the table as we find these digital solutions, then this inequality will deepen. And so we convene today at a very hopeful moment. In a few hours, the Global Digital Compact may just become a reality. You will hear a lot about it. It has several themes that resonate. It’s about collaboration, creating policy, bringing all the stakeholders together to ensure that the case studies that we heard about in the morning become a global norm so that we all become citizens of a world where technology and AI are accessible, they are free, they are secure, and they are rooted, they are rooted in human flourishing. That’s what today is all about. But to situate us in the moment, let’s watch this very short video about the Global Digital Compact just to get a sense of the process and how it unfolded.

Official Video: GDC has been a very optimistic and constructive process during the past 18 months with broad participation from multi-stakeholders. And with GDC, we see that every country and every member state of the United Nations will have better possibilities of implementing the SDG agenda. Co-facilitators of the Global Digital Compact are so excited that we’ve come to this moment where we can actually indulge the Global Digital Compact. We as co-facilitators have engaged with yourselves. over many many hours. Over hundreds, thousands of delegates have put in their work and now it’s time to really look at this document and adopt it. And so we’re very excited that we’ve really come to this point and welcome you to this event. Thank you very much. The Global Digital Compact provides an opportunity to close the digital divide. It also provides an opportunity for Africa to engage as well as civil society organizations to engage way better at the United Nations level. The Global Digital Compact should be implemented through a multi-stakeholder process so that everyone, everywhere, can thrive in the age of AI. Governments must protect and support the people who build and govern digital public goods, like Wikipedia, which is run by volunteers who share knowledge in over 300 languages. Thank you very much for this outstanding opportunity to share with all of you how private and public collaboration can help achieve the goals of the Global Digital Compact. We at TIGO, we build broadband networks across all the communities we operate in. We call them digital highways because they provide the highways that bring our communities to the digital economy and it takes the work of everyone involved, public, private sector, everyone, so that those digital highways get built for the betterment of our communities are for the inclusion of everyone in them into the digital economy of the 21st century. Let’s make it happen together. I’m delighted to welcome the Global Digital Compact and to see that children’s rights are at the heart of this declaration. Children’s charities across the world have collaborated closely with co-facilitators and the UN Tech Envoy for two years to shape this important compact. We welcome that it now underscores a unified commitment for children’s rights and safety. I hope all will live by its words and will move from words to action. States have made bold commitments. They must now translate them into concrete actions. Equally, tech companies must not be exempt and be held accountable for the services they deliver to children. The Global Digital Compact has been a crucial platform for diverse stakeholders like me to come together and shape the future of a digital world that benefits everyone. It has fostered a sense of shared responsibility and ownership. I believe that the GDC we contributed will play a vital role in shaping a digital world.

Redi Thlabi: Thank you very much. Thank you. You will have an opportunity to make your inputs to ensure that the Global Digital Compact becomes a reality. Once it’s been adopted by world leaders, the online platform will be available tomorrow and you can share your inputs. Ladies and gentlemen, please help me welcome the Deputy Prime Minister of Sweden, Ebba Busch.

Ebba Busch: Excellencies, distinguished colleagues, ladies and gentlemen. I was suggesting earlier here when we were waiting for things to start, soon someone has to get up on stage and start singing. I’m not gonna sing here today but we’re going to talk about the digital era that we have just entered fully on now. And we’re living in an era where digital and emerging technologies, where they’re really reshaping almost every single aspect of our lives. our lives. The digital transformation presents us with unprecedented opportunities to really accelerate our work towards the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals. To fulfil those opportunities, we need to cooperate across all levels, and certainly, of course, including the UN. Sweden has, together with Zambia, had the honour of facilitating the negotiations on the Global Digital Compact that we are soon going to adopt. The Compact outlines our collective commitment to a digital future that is inclusive, that is open, that is sustainable, fair, safe and secure. And it seeks to close those digital divides and accelerate progress across the Sustainable Development Goals. Sweden is my home country, and Sweden is also home to some of the most innovative companies in the world that are enabling and driving the global digital transition forward. To truly harness this power of digital technology for a better and more sustainable future, we need an approach that involves all stakeholders. It is only by bringing together the excellent researchers, innovative companies, efficient authorities and multilateral organisations that we can create a well-functioning innovation system that works for everyone. Artificial intelligence, AI, plays a central role in this context. It has the potential to revolutionise how we work, learn and connect with one another. Yet, we must also acknowledge the challenges and risks that come with it. Of course, like so many of the new emerging technologies, AI can be used for both good and for harm. This is why it is crucial that we work together to establish common norms and governance structures that guide the use of AI in such a way that it truly, truly benefits humanity. And at the same time, limit its proliferation into areas of use that may threaten our common security, development, and future. We need a global conversation to build a shared understanding of both the opportunities and the challenges of AI. And in this regards, I really like to emphasize the Compact’s initiative to launch a global dialogue on AI governance, which engages governments and stakeholders in developing standards that prioritizes human rights, that prioritizes safety and sustainability. Increased investment will be crucial to scale up AI capacity, building for sustainable development. Taking into account the recommendations of the High-Level Advisory Body on Artificial Intelligence, the GDC encourages the establishment of a global fund on AI that is complementary to relevant UN funding mechanisms. Additionally, an international scientific panel on AI could offer valuable guidance on the global community on AI development. Sweden has long championed an open, free, and secure internet. And we believe that digital technology should be used to strengthen human rights. We have a responsibility to turn our vision of a digital future future into concrete actions that make a real difference. This means we must collaborate across borders and sectors, and we must all take responsibility to ensure that the digital transformation benefits everyone. Sweden is committed to continuing its leadership in this global process, and we look forward to working with all of you to unlock the potential of digitalization and to ensure that we build a future where digital technology truly serves all of humanity. And with that, I’d like to end with somewhat of a more personal reflection and personal note as a citizen of the world, as a mother of two. My two children back home in Sweden, they’re named Elise and Birger, they’re seven and nine years old. I was this much pregnant when I got elected party leader for my party for 10 years ago. And I’m happy and I’m proud to be able to say to them, because they are now, I mean, they are the generation that are growing up not knowing what life was like before internet, you know? Can you imagine? And I’m proud to be able to say to them that we are now truly taking their rights in the digitalized era seriously, because I’ve said so many times that a childhood in freedom requires safety online. And thank you. And it really is so. We’ve said it so many times, but you can’t say it enough times. Children’s rights are human rights. Women’s rights are human rights. And we are now bringing human rights and the sustainable developmental goals online, finally. Thank you.

Redi Thlabi: Deputy Prime Minister, thank you for your energy and inspiring case studies that you shared. Without much ado, let us hear another keynote this afternoon from the CEO of Google, Sundar Pichai.

Sundar Pichai: Mr. Secretary General, President of the General Assembly, Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, it’s a privilege to join you today. I am energized by the Summit’s focus on the future. We have a once-in-a-generation opportunity to unlock human potential for everyone, everywhere. I believe that technology is a foundational enabler of progress. Just as the Internet and mobile devices expanded opportunities for people around the world, now AI is poised to accelerate progress at unprecedented scale. I’m here today to make the case for three things. Why I believe AI is so transformative. How it can be applied to benefit humanity and make progress on the UN Sustainable Development Goals. And where we can drive deeper partnerships to ensure that the technology benefits everyone. But first, let me share why this is so important to me personally and to Google as a company. Growing up in Chennai, India with my family, the arrival of each new technology improved our lives in meaningful ways. Our first rotary phone saved us hours of travel to the hospital to get test results. Our first refrigerator gave us more time to spend as a family rather than rushing to cook ingredients before they spoil. The technology that changed my life the most was the computer. I didn’t have much access to one growing up. When I came to graduate school in the U.S., there were labs full of machines I could use anytime I wanted. It was mind-blowing. Access to computing inspired me to pursue a career where I could bring technology to more people. And that path led me to Google 20 years ago. I was excited by its mission to organize the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful. That mission has had incredible impact. Google Search democratized information access, opened up opportunities in education and entrepreneurship. Platforms like Chrome and Android helped bring 1 billion people online. Today, 15 of our products serve more than half a billion people and businesses each, and 6 of them each serve more than 2 billion. There is no cost to use them, and most of our users are in the developing world. Today we are working on the most transformative technology yet, AI. We’ve been investing in AI research, tools, and infrastructure for two decades because it’s the most profound way we can deliver on our mission and improve people’s lives. I want to talk today about four of the biggest opportunities we see, many of which align with the SDGs. One is helping people access the world’s knowledge in their own language. Using AI, in just the last year we have added 110 new languages to Google Translate, spoken by half a billion people around the world. That brings our total to 246 languages, and we are working towards 1,000 of the world’s most spoken languages. A second area is accelerating scientific discovery to benefit humanity. Our AlphaFold breakthrough is solving big challenges in predicting some of the building blocks of life, including proteins. and DNA. We have opened up AlphaFold to the scientific community free of charge and it has been accessed by more than 2 million researchers from over 190 countries. 30% are in the developing world. For example, over 25,000 researchers just in Brazil. Globally, AlphaFold is being used in research that could help make crops more resistant to disease, discover new drugs in areas like malaria vaccines and cancer treatments and much more. A third opportunity is helping people in the path of climate-related disaster, building on the UN’s initiative, Early Warnings for All. Our Flood Hub system provides early warnings up to seven days in advance, helping protect over 460 million people in over 80 countries. And for millions in the path of wildfires, our boundary tracking systems are already in 22 countries on Google Maps. We also just announced FireSat technology, which will use satellites to detect and track early-stage wildfires, with imagery updated every 20 minutes globally so firefighters can respond. AI gives a boost in accuracy, speed and scale. Fourth, we see the opportunity for AI to meaningfully contribute to economic progress. It’s already enabling entrepreneurs and small businesses, empowering governments to provide public services, and boosting productivity across sectors. Some studies show that AI could boost global labor productivity by 1.4 percentage points and increase global GDP by 7% within the next decade. For example, AI is helping improve operations and logistics in emerging markets, where connectivity, infrastructure and traffic congestion are big challenges. Freight startup Gary Logistics in Ethiopia is using AI to help move goods to market faster and bring more work opportunities to freelance drivers. These are just very early examples, and there are so many others across education, health, and sustainability. As technology improves, so will the benefits. As with any emerging technology, AI will have limitations, be it issues with accuracy, factuality, and bias, as well as the risks of misapplication and misuse, like the creation of deep fakes. It also presents new complexities. For example, the impact on the future of work. For all these reasons, we believe that AI must be developed, deployed, and used responsibly from the start. We are guided by our AI principles, which we published back in 2018. And we work with others across the industry, academia, the UN, and governments in efforts like the Frontier Model Forum, the OECD, and the G7 Hiroshima process. But I want to talk about another risk that I worry about. I think about where I grew up and how fortunate I was to have access to technology, even if it came slowly. Not everyone had that experience. And while good progress has been made by UN institutions like the ITU, gaps persist today in the form of a well-known digital divide. With AI, we have the chance to be inclusive from the start and to ensure that the digital divide doesn’t become an AI divide. This is a challenge that needs to be met by the private sector and public sector working together. We can focus on three key areas. First is digital infrastructure. Google has made big investments globally in subsea and terrestrial fiber optic cables. One connects Africa with Europe. And two others will be the first intercontinental fiber optic routes. that connect Asia-Pacific and South America, and Australia and Africa. These fiber optic routes stitch together our network of 40 cloud regions around the world that provide digital services to governments, entrepreneurs, SMBs, and companies across all sectors. In addition to compute access, we also open up our technology to others. We did this with Android, and now our Gemma AI models are open to developers and researchers, and we’ll continue to invest here. A second area is about investing in people. That starts with making sure people have the skills they need to seize new opportunities. Our Grow with Google program has already trained 100 million people around the world in digital skills. And today, I’m proud to announce our Global AI Opportunity Fund. This will invest $120 million to make AI education and training available in communities around the world. We are providing this in local languages, in partnerships with nonprofits and NGOs. We are also helping to support entrepreneurs for the AI revolution. In Brazil, we worked with thousands of women entrepreneurs to use Google AI to grow their businesses. In Asia, where fewer than 6% of startups are founded by women, we are providing many with mentorship, capital, and training. The third area is one where we especially need the help of member countries and leaders in this room, creating an enabling policy environment, one that addresses both the risks and worries around new technologies, and also encourages the kind of applications that improve lives at scale. This requires a few things. Government policymaking that supports investments in infrastructure, people. and innovation that benefits humanity. Country development strategies and frameworks like the Global Digital Compact that prioritize the adoption of AI solutions. And smart product regulation that mitigates harms and resists national protectionist impulses that could widen an AI divide and limit AI’s benefits. We are excited to be your partner and to work with you to make sure bold innovations are deployed responsibly so that AI is truly helpful for everyone. The opportunities are too great, the challenge is too urgent, and this technology too transformational to do anything less. Thank you.

Redi Thlabi: Thank you very much to the CEO of Google, Sundar Pichai, for that very holistic picture of the potential, the risks, and the opportunities. Thank you. Now let’s get to the conversation. Let’s put some meat to it, as we say in my language at home. Let’s just give some meaning to the Global Digital Compact. How do we position ourselves to move from aspiration to action and to take us through that very important conversation? Here is a sister, a moderator, and an international broadcaster, my homegirl, Tumi Makgabo.

Tumi Makgabo: Thank you. All right, we got there in the end. Good afternoon, everybody. Reedy, thank you so very much for that introduction. I feel like we flew a long way to get together in New York, but it’s always a pleasure to be in. in this incredible, exciting, stimulating city. But more importantly, I think it’s really incredible to have the opportunity to be in a room where people are thinking about what tomorrow’s going to look like. How do we create a tomorrow that works for everybody who’s involved in tomorrow? Well, you’ve heard a little bit about the GDC, and in this following conversation, we’re going to try to unpack how do we take the idea, how do we take the thought, how do we take the intent of what the GDC is trying to create and make it real, give it life, breathe it into existence. It isn’t easy, it certainly will be a challenge, but I think it’s a challenge not only that we’re up for, but it’s a challenge that is important to ensure that the society and the world looks exactly the way we hope and intend. Now, ordinarily, I could safely stand up here all by myself, but I don’t think that’s going to be the most exciting thing for you to watch. So please assist me in giving a very, very, very warm welcome to the following. Felix Mutati, who is the Minister of Technology and Science in Zambia. Margrethe Vestager, who is Executive Vice President of the European Union. Rebeca Grynspan, who is the Secretary General of UNCTAD. Omar Al Olama, the Minister of State for Artificial Intelligence, Digital Economy, and Remote Work Applications in the UAE. Josephine Teo, who is the Minister for Digital Development and Information in Singapore. And last, but most certainly not least, Nnenna Nwakanama, Civil Society Representative. To all of you, thank you so very much for joining us today. And it really is genuinely and truly an honor to have each of you joining me today. And I’m looking forward to having this conversation. I’m going to take a seat next to you. But not too close. I get a little bit nervous because I don’t know what they might do to me if I ask them a question they don’t like. The reason we really gathered here, and let’s talk for a moment about the digital compact. It’s about principles, it’s about commitments, it’s about inclusivity, not just in terms of who negotiated it, but in terms of who it’s supposed to apply to. The intention is to, and I’m going to read this so I don’t get it wrong, to support the achievement of an inclusive, open, sustainable, fair, safe, and secure digital future for all. Ambitious. In addition, there’s something that’s really important that the GDC does, and that is it recognizes the pervasive and existing digital divides, and we know, we can see what the impact of those divides are and have been in the past. And really, it responds to the need for more inclusive digital governance. So we all have an understanding of what it should do, what it shouldn’t do, and how do we deal. So the ambition is there. It’s in paper, in various iterations. How do we make that happen? Perhaps Mr. Minister, if I can begin with you. Developing countries in particular, Reedy mentioned it earlier, and I think the lived reality of most people who exist in the developing world will be able to tell you about some of the challenges that we face whenever we experience digital divides. I mean, the CEO of Google just gave us a perfect example in his remarks. How do you think the GDC will help in particular developing countries, but perhaps you can use your country as an example, to bridge that divide? It’s on. Let’s try again.

Felix Mutati: Thank you. Many thanks for having me. I’ll just tell you a short story in terms of bridging the digital divide, in terms of inclusivity, from a Zambian perspective. A young man called James in the rural part of Zambia, a farmer, farming using traditional methods because he was not included or connected, had a chance to secure a mobile phone, had a chance to get connected to internet. Using those tools, he transformed his farming methods because he had access to weather forecast, he had access to market prices, he had access to information. And our interpretation is that the Global Digital Compact is about a shared vision. Transforming life for that little boy in the rural part of Zambia. That is our simple understanding and that is why we’re here, changing lives.

Tumi Makgabo: Now there’s a particular balance that is always required because we see that sometimes when we change and transform lives, sometimes it can happen really rapidly, sometimes it takes a little bit longer. If I can come to the UAE as an example, what is the thinking about bridging and bringing together that process of rapid adoption of AI, along with making sure that it is a safe environment for all who are going to be involved in digital technology and how it changes their lives?

Omar Al Olama: Thank you very much. I’m very happy to be here and to be very honest, I think the UAE is a good example of what happens when you create a trajectory for digital development that is on steroids, as they say. we’ve experienced it. So we went from not having paved roads, not having university graduates, being a country that was maybe part of the underdeveloped world 50 years ago to being today one of the most advanced countries in the world. That advancement created a lot of opportunities, it made the UAE be able to explore frontiers like artificial intelligence, and I think it also shows that there is no excuse for us not to be able to do that for more countries. We need to move from, and I don’t mean to plagiarize President Obama here, but from yes we can to yes we will. We need to really definitely try to actually implement that vision that we have on digital development and take forward the recommendations that the panel is making towards the global south.

Tumi Makgabo: We need to also have the conversation about inclusivity. The reason we can have a conversation around developed versus developing countries is because growth has not been equitable. There are some parts of the world that have grown and done well economically, et cetera, and those that have clearly been left behind. If we can then talk for a moment, Secretary General, about how do we make sure that this compact is not just a document that is full of ambition, but it actually means that we see a manifestation of that inclusivity of growth when it comes to the digital era.

Rebeca Grynspan: Thank you. Thank you very much, and thank you for that question. First of all, let me say that we all know that we are lagging in the SDGs, yes? That only 70% of the SDGs are enrolled to be accomplished by 2030. So we have to start by thinking that we cannot have linear solutions because we need non-linear ones, pathways, to really get to the 2030 objectives. And I think that the digital revolution in AI can provide those. non-linear path towards DSDG. So it’s a great opportunity because obviously, you know, the digital technologies are transforming life in an exponential way. So that can be really a very important tool. But my second point, going to you, is that when you are in a society where things are changing so rapidly, we have to remember always that not everything changes at the same speed. So it creates tensions. It creates asymmetries. It creates imbalances that we need to deal with. So it’s not enough access. You need really a deliberate digital development strategy because you have to connect. You have to bring the stakeholders. But you have to do a lot of things. You have to create an ecosystem that is, you know, really will bring everybody to the speed, to the level that is necessary. But you start from a very uneven play field, yes? Not everybody is today in the same line to start this career. So you have to make an extra effort. And part of this extra effort is, first of all, for people, it’s not only access, but it’s affordability and quality of their access to the digital technologies. But it’s also not to relegate the developing countries to be users. We want to be producers. We want to bring the digital revolution, not only for our consumption, but we want to really use it for our diversification, for going up the ladder. in terms of the value chains in the world, to add more value, to create better employment, and to bring digital into the productive structure will really require an extra effort from the international community and also from governments to make it, as I said, a deliberate development strategy.

Tumi Makgabo: One thing that also is going to require deliberate efforts is the question of human rights. Margrethe, if I can come to you on that. How do you make sure that there is a respect and a consideration for human rights while at the same time one wants to promote fair competition and keep in mind that we’re coming from such different points of departure, there’s a lot of balancing. How is the EU thinking about that?

Margrethe Vestager: First and foremost, I think the Global Digital Compact is an amazing achievement. It is as if we have a new chance. We have it. There are so many things where we have not succeeded, and I think the Digital Compact shows that we can agree that we’re really going to engage in correcting the mistakes and show much increased effort because if we live up to what is in the Compact, well, then a lot of the things that are haunting us will be a thing of the past, and for us, we want to partner with as many countries as possible, and the fact that human rights are completely core of the Global Digital Compact makes our conversation shorter, focused because we know that we agree on the fundamentals when we digitalize. So, partnerships will be so much easier, and these are really important for us. And I think it also illustrates that there is a commitment to create trust in technology. Because that doesn’t come automatic. Technology can be terribly misused, both for crime and fraud, but also for surveillance and undermining democracy. And here we can focus on the use of technology. I think the example, the story was excellent. It’s such a good illustration of the agency that people get. Because I think that is the underlining ambition here. That all the things that we were not successful with, with trust, with focusing on the use cases and giving people agency, enabling them, then this digital compact will be, you know, a road to a future that is very different from all the bad scenarios that we actually do have ahead of us.

Tumi Makgabo: There is no question, I think, for anybody that this presents a particular opportunity. One through the GDC, but generally through technology and how we can better harness that to achieve all of these things that we wanted to do. The world of work, however, we all recognize is going to look quite different in five years’ time, let alone a decade or two down the road. In Singapore’s case, how are you ensuring that there is better preparedness for a more digitized work in the context of work? And how can we learn from what Singapore has done so that we’re not always having to go back to the beginning in order to ensure we’re better prepared for a world of work that looks so different?

Josephine Teo: Well, thank you very much for this opportunity to participate in this great conversation. My comments will build on what Margaret and the Secretary-General have said. And that is to recognize the fact that unevenness exists even for the workforce. And what it means… is that there will be some parts of the workforce that are closer to the technology frontier because their employers are already using technologies in innovative ways in their companies. And so that creates an environment for them to pick up the right skills to become even more proficient in the jobs and the requirements of the future. But there will be many other members of the workforce who, for example, may be employed by small and medium enterprises who tend to lag in terms of the technology adoption. Then there are also people who are marginalised. Sometimes it is because they have special needs. It could be because they have a disability. We have to be very creative in thinking about how all of the past barriers that put impediments in the path of these individuals to succeed. The way in which we are doing this is to enable every single one of the workers to acquire the skills to be relevant for the future. Part of it involves working with employers because they create the momentum and they create the strongest incentives. But we also need active labour market policies in the form of support for individual learning, putting resources in the hands of individual workers so that they don’t only depend on their employers to provide the training opportunities. Then in order to support this ecosystem, you need also to build up the training infrastructure so that there is a good ecosystem of training providers who not only can deliver training competently, but whose content meet the needs of the market. All of these have to come together and the more we can share with each other how these can be achieved in each of our contexts, I think the better we are going to be. So we are very grateful to the UN for putting together the GDC to create the opportunities for us to do exactly that.

Tumi Makgabo: Thank you very much, Minister Teo. Minister Al-Olama, I believe that we have to bid you farewell, so thank you very much for joining us. Do you want to, is there one more comment and thought that you want to leave us with before you go?

Omar Al Olama: I think the Global Digital Compact is a great starting point for the action to follow. The UAE, we believe that there’s a lot that needs to be done but we all need to work together on it. This technology is very pervasive, it crosses borders, and there needs to be cooperation. So we’re definitely part of this roadmap that the UN is putting forward and we’re definitely going to be a big supporter for it.

Tumi Makgabo: That’s terrific to hear. Thank you for joining us and we look forward to seeing you do that. If you can please just give him a thank you. Thank you. And no, I wasn’t waiting for him to leave, I just have to get closer to the panellists, so don’t think I’m being, I promise I’m not being weird. Nnenna, if I can come to you, from a civil society perspective. You know, the reality is that there sometimes can be a disconnect between what happens on the ground and what happens higher up between policy makers and those of us who have really good intentions. It doesn’t always manifest in the way that we hope. What does the implementation question and what does the monitoring question of the GDC look like in a civil society context from your point of view?

Nnenna Nwakanama: Sankofa, I’ll come back to that word. Fabrizio Hochschild is from Chile. Ninten Desai is from India. Lynn Sentamu is Canadian. Marcus Comer. is from Switzerland, Yanis Karklins from Lithuania, Dee Williams in St. Lucia, Adama Samaseko in Mali, and the journalist Brenda Zulu from Zambia. I’ve met these people over my 25 years of engagement in digital cooperation within the UN. These are people from all walks of life. And my first statement here today is sankofa, looking back from where we’re coming from so we know where we’re going to. The GDC is nothing revolutionary. The success is in the process, and that process is multi-stakeholder. I do believe that as we keep shaking hands between multilateralism and multi-stakeholderism, we can do much. Not just here in New York. I don’t need a visa to be able to implement GDC. I want to be at home and have the same principle of multi-stakeholderism play out in everything at national level.

Tumi Makgabo: I think we understand why you’ve been in this process for so long. We kind of get it. Thank you for that. Minister Mutati, if I can then come back to you. We can look at the broader picture, and I think the GDC is no doubt inspiring. Those who believe it or not, I did actually read it, and I think it is really inspiring, and I think it really is ambitious, and I think it genuinely is asking us to address some of the most fundamental and pressing issues that help us address the human rights challenges we face on the planet. planet. How, though, do we begin to implement that? From a Zambia perspective, what is the translation of that, from paper to reality, actually look like and involve?

Felix Mutati: Thank you very much. One of the pillars of the Global Digital Compact is strategic partnerships. And strategic partnership from a Zambia perspective, I’ll give you two examples. This year, Zambia has got challenges around climate change. Our economy, in terms of GDP, is going down. And we have difficulties and other problems. But earlier on, we had a strategic partnership to look at how we can collaborate among ourselves as Africans. And one of the countries in Africa, we went and lifted a tax innovation, collection innovation, which we started using this year. Now, the consequences of that partnership has been that, whereas the economy is going down, the tax revenue is going up. And for us, we think that is what is called strategic partnership, which is part of the Global Compact. It gives actual results. And this is actually happening. Second example, because of limited resource, to try to extend connectivity of our people, government on one side. Working with the private sector and other partners, providing the necessary incentives, they were able to plant significant infrastructure, digital infrastructure, which has enabled Internet to move from in the 50s to almost 70 percent. That is what we call strategic partnership. So Zambia, in a sense, was already implementing the global digital compact and the key pillar of partnership, and the results are there for us to see. Thank you.

Tumi Makgabo: That’s a really interesting example that you use, because it sounds to me like a lot of this has to do with ensuring that the solutions are specific to what your needs are, no doubt. But when we look more broadly, the challenge for a lot of developing countries is that they have to prioritize where they allocate those resources. So it’s easier for us to sit and say, well, you know, we have to think about ESG, or we have to think about greening, or we have to think about this safety and that health. But the resources that are required to do all of those things are quite limited. What do you think needs to happen to allow developing countries to better strike that balance, and how potentially can the GDC be supportive of that process? We know that within the document itself, it’s quite specific about a need for that to happen. But again, the reality versus what’s on paper.

Rebeca Grynspan: Yeah, it’s such a good question, because, you know, precisely today we were talking about the necessary changes in international financial architecture, really to support development. We were talking about restructuring the debt, because debt doesn’t allow many of these countries, to really have the strategies and the investments that need to be done. I gave today the number that 3.3 billion people live in countries that are paying more in service and debt than on health or education. So if you have that problem, how are you going really to have the investments that you need for making this happen? And the other part of this, I’m sorry to say, obviously, is the responsibility to think about the long-term. I always say we usually forget that the short and the long-term start at the same time. There is no long-term that is a succession of short-termism, yes? You don’t get there by short-term thinking. You need long-term thinking. But many of the systems don’t allow, don’t have the structures, don’t have the institutions like, for example, Singapore has, to really have this long-term view for a policy to stay and to persevere for the objectives. So let me just end saying, you need national responsibility, and the minister has talked about that. You need a government that really thinks about this, that does the right thing, that invests in education, that invests in the people that Nina was talking about, that brings society in an inclusive way with a voice to really harness development, but you need the international community. And that’s why the global digital compact is so important, as we have said. Because you need a framework. And the other thing, and I’m sorry to say this because we are talking about optimism, but this is a very concentrated market, yes? need to spread the opportunities because really concentration is very high. So you need international standards and international norms to really make these technologies to stay within the good and not to go to the bad, like Margrethe was saying.

Tumi Makgabo: So it’s interesting that you’re promoting the global view, which is crucial. We’ve heard from the minister the national view, but there’s that space in between, which is the regional question. Now we’ve seen what the EU has been doing. We understand the EU’s ambition generally to be a leader in many spaces, and this is not unique in that question. What can the world, or what should we be learning about broader cooperation and implementation of such policies when we look at what the EU is trying to do within its space of influence from a policy perspective? Because one size doesn’t fit all, so there needs to be some maneuverability in that regard, but there also needs to be an overview that allows everybody to understand what the rules of engagement are.

Margrethe Vestager: I think that is very well put. And the thing is that there is an asymmetry here, because the individual human being can take the most of the possibilities, but the individual cannot do away with the harm that technology can bring. That is not possible. So there is a societal, regional, global answer here to address things that are systemic in a systemic matter. And this is what we are trying to do. So we have passed legislation, the Digital Markets Act, to keep the market open so that people have choice, and so that the businesses who provide choice, that they are interested for investors. Because, if you depend on a gatekeeper to get to the market, why invest in you? We have the Digital Services Act making sure that digital services are safe to use. That they would not cause you mental health problems or undermine democracy or the integrity of our elections. And that what is legitimately decided in our democracy is also treated as such when online. We have privacy legislation and our AI Act is coming into force. All of that to create a systemic response to the things that people cannot influence themselves individually. And when you have a systemic response, and we enforce in full, because otherwise it’s worth nothing. Enforcement is everything. When we do that, then each and every one of us, alone and together, can grasp the opportunities. And that’s the important thing here, because otherwise nothing will happen. So I think one should be really careful to try to decentralize, to say, you go, you go figure out. No, no. We need that systemic response. We think that legislation is needed, because we see the harm that can be done. And I think that global digital compact is essential, especially when it comes to AI. Because AI is not just any new digital algorithm. It is so much more powerful when it comes to human agency. And that is why the use cases, the trust that we as societies will be responsible, is absolutely key for all these wonderful things that we’re talking about.

Tumi Makgabo: That brings me nicely. Okay, you want to… They keep wanting to clap for you and I keep interrupting them. So I think every now and again, I must remember to give you a chance to clap properly. That brings me nicely to the question of public-private partnerships. So, when we are looking at this process, everybody has to play their part. We need to make sure that the rules of engagement not only exist, but that they are followed and that they are implemented, and that there is consequence for transgression, right? Because it doesn’t help, and we know about, broadly speaking, the challenges of international law when it comes to the implementation and enforcement of consequence. What role, however, do you see, maybe you can give us an example in Singapore, where this public-private partnership can better foster the implementation and the oversight of what this GDC process may look like?

Josephine Teo: Well, since Margaret was talking about AI, that could be where the example arises. I think being a general-purpose technology, we all want to benefit from its transformative potential. And yet, at the level of public services, very often the expertise does not yet exist. And that’s where I think the private sector can be brought into the picture and encouraged to enable policymakers, as well as individuals, teams, organisations that make the rules to understand how this technology is implemented. And that’s exactly how we have done it in Singapore. We encouraged and we invited the private sector to contribute to the development of use cases, as well as our understanding of the guardrails that need to be put in place. But I would go one step further. I would say that the private sector can do a lot more in terms of helping to build capacity. And the capacity is so important because, particularly from the point of view of small states, on the one hand we see the opportunities, on the other hand we are told of the risks. The question is, will we… we’d be left behind as small states. Now, in this process of figuring out what to do, I think we were really appreciative that at the UN level, there was an advisory board at the high level that was constituted in a very inclusive way. And this has given us the motivation to contribute to this process by asking our own chief AI officer to be involved, and then subsequently inviting the whole high-level advisory board to meet in Singapore so that they can also engage with the forum of small states that was meeting there. Now, the result of a process like this is that we now have the ability to say, adopting the principles articulated in the GDC, how to help ourselves as nations, but equally importantly, how we can help each other. And in that regard, I’m very pleased to note that this process created an opportunity for another country that we admire greatly, which is Rwanda, to say, how about the both of us come together to create an AI playbook for small states? So that is something that we have done. And I hope that this will help all of us.

Tumi Makgabo: I just love my panel because everything they say, everybody wants to clap for them.

Margrethe Vestager: Can I add something? Because I would encourage everybody to look at the AI apprentice model that is implemented in Singapore, because that allows businesses to get to use AI while people in all walks of life can learn about how to do that. And you get experts who are embedded in the local community. So this idea of AI apprenticeships, I think the Singaporean model is really, really inspiring.

Tumi Makgabo: Thank you very much.

Josephine Teo: We’re happy to share more.

Tumi Makgabo: They’re happy to share. So everybody come, let’s share. Okay, Nnenna, if I can come to you because believe it or not, we’ve got like four minutes left. What measures do you think specifically we need to be mindful of? And I’m going to limit you in the sense that I’m going to ask you for two of the most important measures we need to make sure are in place to protect human rights as we embark on this journey.

Nnenna Nwakanama: Two measures, capacity to implement. It is okay to come to New York. It is okay to read European papers and all of that, but America and Europe do not make the world. I’m African. I’m Nigerian. I live in Cote d’Ivoire. I’m part of this world and I want that to be down here. So capacity to implement across the whole world, whether it be government, because I have spoken about multi-stakeholder, but multi-stakeholder capacity is needed, financial, human and technological. That is one. We need to balance that. The other one is connecting people. I see people talking about AI. I see, I’ve lived in the days of great technology, emerging technology, and all of the big grammar technology, but please, can we get people connected to me? And please, can we not disconnect the people who are already connected? Because some of you are here and then you go home and you disrupt internet connectivity. We have to talk about shutdown. In the GDC itself, that part has, they’ve been knowing at it. I don’t know what it’s going to be like tomorrow morning. Anyway, let me now, excellences, ladies and gentlemen, friends here and friends who are watching me online, boys and girls, cats and dogs, emojis and avatars, I myself, on behalf of my own self, I would like to endorse the GDC.

Tumi Makgabo: because I want my time back from all this clapping. Like really, I’ve lost like loads of time from the applause. Okay, we’ve literally got two and a half minutes, so I’m gonna do a rapid fire round. I’m going to ask you for two specific things that when we leave this stage and we leave this room, as individuals, we need to consider implementing. We’re not talking broad policy strokes here, we’re talking about things that you think we can do when we leave. Nnenna, you’ve given us a clue, but can you give us two different ones, and I’m gonna start with you and work my way across. We’ve got two minutes.

Nnenna Nwakanama: Connect the schools. Connect the young people. Connect my children. Thank you.

Tumi Makgabo: Okay, okay, okay, thank you. Thank you. Minister Teo.

Josephine Teo: We want to move beyond learning about digital to thriving with digital. And to do that, we can move alone, and we can go very fast that way, or we can go together, and I believe that will go even further.

Tumi Makgabo: Thank you. Even further. Secretary General, you.

Rebeca Grynspan: Embrace not only the global digital compact, talk to your governments for implementing, for supporting, but embrace the path for the future, because there are many things that we have to do for this to be possible. And in the path of the future, we have a lot that can help people to get connected.

Tumi Makgabo: Vice-President Vestager.

Margrethe Vestager: Obviously, first things first, connectivity is everything. If you’re not connected, well, what then? But as we connect, please make sure that we do not sacrifice our children. Their independence, their agency, that they do not get dependent, that they do not get sucked in, in social media that will not serve them well. We have a huge challenge in making. sure that our children, they’re not only safe, but developed, and that they can use digital for their own good and for the good of their community.

Tumi Makgabo: Minister?

Felix Mutati: Thank you. One of the biggest challenges, the skills and literacy, particularly in the rural part of our country, things we take for granted. Let us handhold our people. And let us show them how to press the numbers on the mobile phone. Thank you.

Tumi Makgabo: I don’t know if you can tell, but I thoroughly enjoyed that conversation. And it is because we had such a wonderful panel of speakers with us this afternoon. Can you please give them the appropriate round of applause? I can’t hear it. Thank you so very much. Thank you. And thank you. Thank you very much.

Redi Thlabi: OK, I see your panel doesn’t want to leave the stage to me. OK. Thank you. Thank you so very much to Dumi Mahabo for expertly leading that important conversation. We’re going to watch a very short video speaking to the themes of today about the futures that are possible for us and the kind of decisions we need to make. Let’s just watch this short video, and then I’ll introduce you to the next panel.

Official Video: One humanity, two futures. In one, we embrace AI’s potential for a world of inclusion and equity. In another, AI tools became the catalyst for division and exclusion. The choice between these paths did not lie in circuits, but in human hands. In October 2023, amid heated debates on artificial intelligence and its potential, there was excitement about the future, but also anxiety over its risks and uncertainties. The UN Secretary-General gathered 39 top AI experts to confront this challenge. The uniquely diverse group consulted intensively around the world and engaged with thousands of experts. This uniquely diverse group aligned on guiding principles to propose concrete actions for governing AI for humanity by building common scientific understanding on AI, its opportunities and its risks, by fostering common ground for effective AI policies and standards anchored in human rights, by sharing common benefits through building capacity, mobilizing resources and tackling data dilemmas, to close AI divides, and to support this global action, an AI office at the United Nations, for an equitable and inclusive future with AI. Let’s build this future together.

Redi Thlabi: Thank you very much. And I think the theme of that video links so well with the comments that came from the first panel. We all acknowledge we come from different worlds, but we are one humanity. So how do we create these digital tools, AI for humanity, make it serve humanity, make it accessible for all of humanity? I’m really looking forward. to this next panel discussion, which speaks exactly to that, AI for Humanity. And to moderate this panel discussion is Ian Bremmer, president of Eurasia Group. Ian?

Ian Bremmer: Thank you so much, and also thanks to me, who just crushed it for the last 45 minutes, absolutely, right? So now you’re stuck with me, and obviously I’m honored to be here at the Summit of the Future. We’re going to talk about artificial intelligence. I’m honored to be one of the 39 members of the high-level advisory panel on AI, and you’re going to meet a number of my peers on the panel today. It was back in 2017 that the Secretary General, António Guterres, I remember first told me that he thought that his two most important legacies in global governance would be on combating climate change and responding to the positive implications of disruptive technologies. You have seen the UN engage and lead the work on climate over the past many years, but today is a day we get to talk about and even celebrate a little some efforts in global governance on artificial intelligence. This past Thursday, I think you’ve seen it, we have released our final report, Governing AI for Humanity. It’s right here. It’s the first truly global approach to governance of artificial intelligence, and we’re going to talk today about some of the recommendations, why governance including nations from the global south is so important, and some practical reasons why this roadmap is needed. to ensure progress and greater equity, given the challenges that we face in our digital and physical future. So, with that, let me please introduce our distinguished panelists. Experts and leaders from many sectors required for a multi-stakeholder approach, five of us together on the UN High-Level Advisory Body, and two interlopers who are here anyway. As I mentioned, first of all, our co-chairs. We have Carme Artigas, who is co-chair of the body, along with James Manyka, senior vice president at Google Alphabet. We’ve got Vilas Dhar, also an HLAB member. He’s president of the Patrick J. McGovern Foundation. Dr. Wang Jian is chief technology officer at Alibaba. Volker Turk, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights. And Alondra Nelson, also an HLAB member, is a professor at the Institute of Advanced Study. I welcome all of you. Please. So, let’s get right to it. Carme, the first question I want to ask, and I’m going to start with our two co-chairs, shockingly, bracketing this whole thing, is why the United Nations, right? There have been a lot of efforts at governance of AI. There’s been a lot of money going into AI. The UN doesn’t have a lot of money, doesn’t have a lot of power, right? But here we are. So, why? I mean, obviously, part of it is because it makes us sit uncomfortably close, and that facilitates cooperation. But leaving that aside, why was it critical for the United Nations to take this on?

Carme Artigas: Yes, so this was the first question we had to answer ourselves in the body. You were independent people, and we came to the conclusion that the UN is uniquely positioned to this effort, because it’s the only global organization that has the mandate, the reach, and the legitimacy to seat all nations and all stakeholders in the table. And it has the historical, I would say, success that has done it in the past, I mean, governing international topics such as climate change or on earth control. And because AI is such a pervasive and horizontal technology, and it’s absolutely cross borders, there is no single nation or region that can solve by itself the potential harm biases, discrimination, and lack of inclusiveness. And of course there are other frameworks that are very, very valuable, but they are limited. They usually leave behind many nations, especially on the global south. So we do not pretend that UN is the right place to regulate AI at a global level. We think it’s the right place to encourage collaboration, to foster inclusive business, and ensure that AI is developed, keeping the human rights in mind.

Ian Bremmer: Now, you’re a European, and the Europeans are known for having governance, even multi-stakeholder governance as a superpower. I mean, Lord knows it’s not building AI companies, right? So given that, how do you, former minister in this field, you know, how did you engage with what can the UN do, and what should the EU really be doing?

Carme Artigas: I would say that people sometimes mix ethics, regulation, and governance. There are three different things. Ethics is how do we should, how should we all behave well, companies, governments. Governance is how do we put in mechanisms, instruments, that ensure that everybody’s behaving ethically. And regulation is one of these mechanisms, and we have done it in Europe, the first international regulation, and nobody can argue against me that regulation is not against innovation. That’s another topic, but I am open to discuss it to anyone. I think regulation builds trust, because it orders a market and gives trust. confidence to the market, the consumers, and the citizens. But there are not only a way to govern through regulation. We can govern through transparency, through oversight, through involving everybody. So governance is beyond regulation itself. It’s one mechanism. We should find also the market incentives so that companies and governments behave ethically.

Ian Bremmer: Just a quick one, because I’m responding to that. Did you say, I mean, when the group first came together, you know, 39 members from all these different countries, different walks of life, that actually coming to agreement on common principles seemed to be one of the easiest things for our group to do? That was quick. Am I right about that?

Carme Artigas: Yeah, of course.

Ian Bremmer: Anyone else want to take that on? James?

James Manyika: No, you’re fundamentally right. I mean, one of the things that was extraordinary when we began our work was how quickly we got to agree on things like, this must be based on fundamental human rights. We all agreed. This must be based on international law. We all agreed. This must benefit everybody. We all agreed. I think the hard work was, how do we all come together to think through how we actually do and achieve those things? But I think getting to the principles was relatively quite straightforward. I’m looking at Alondra here, who was a big, you know, force in getting us to many of the right places we got to, especially on issues around fundamental human rights based on the extraordinary work that she had been doing for many, many years.

Ian Bremmer: Alondra, do you want to jump in?

Alondra Nelson: Yeah, I would just say, you know, to your question of why, why is that the UN provides us with a quite incredible foundation? I mean, the UN Charter, our international accords around human rights are quite powerful kind of cornerstones for thinking about this. And so we had a place to go. And I think, you know, the challenge that we face with technology is particularly powerful and fast moving ones like AI is things are moving around and where do we anchor ourselves? And I think the why of the UN is in part that the world’s countries had agreed. have agreed upon already these fundamental kind of true North values. The challenge becomes what does that mean in a digital world? What does that mean in an AI world in which, you know, society is being kind of re-transformed and reconfigured? But I think those fundamental things are true and that’s been a really core of our work on the committee.

Ian Bremmer: And I want our audience to appreciate this. I mean, getting the Singaporeans to champion rule of law is not exactly shocking, but I mean, we’re talking about the Americans, the Russians, the Chinese, the Europeans, the global South. I mean, all participants here, this was not the hard challenge in this group. Vilas?

Vilas Dhar: I think that’s right. I mean, Ian, I want to start from a fundamental observation. We too often equate governance with control. And it’s part of a conversation that’s much bigger. I think we have followed a narrative that technology companies innovate and governments regulate and somehow in that the rest of us go along. But that’s not the point of governance, right? Governance is to set a shared vision for humanity, is to think about all of the resources we can bring to bear to make shared decisions that put agency with communities, that allow voices to participate and to come forward. When we think about the work of the body, I think this underpins the idea. What we got from the Secretary General was a mandate to think beyond, beyond the forms and functions of the moment, to think about a world where a digital future actually works for all of us. It starts from the fundamental pieces that James and Alondra spoke to. But it requires us to also envision new functions and new forms for a future that’s grounded in the idea of governance for, by, and of the people. And I think AI gives us such an amazing aperture to go back to really fundamental questions about what participatory mechanics should look like.

Ian Bremmer: I’m glad you brought that up because when, you know, so much of the conversation on AI out there is about risks, existential risks, disinformation, all of that. This group, not in any way unconcerned with those risks. but fundamentally thinking about how to use AI for humanity. I mean, climate change in a sense is a much more difficult conversation because there’s so much zero-sumness. There’s so much, you know, like reparations need to be paid because you’ve done this to us. This has been an overwhelmingly positive sum, non-zero-sum conversation. James?

James Manyika: Yeah, it has been, but it also has highlighted something else, including beyond the UN itself, is how important this is for it to be a multi-stakeholder endeavor. That was fundamentally important. Let me tell you why I think that was fundamentally important. If you think about what’s at the heart of this technology, this conversation, and what we hope for it, you point to three things, I think. One are the extraordinary opportunities, the possibility to address so much of our challenges with the SDGs, climate change, there’s so much that we could potentially do that’s transformational, number one. There are complexities and risks. There are so many of them. We have to think about all the kinds of issues that we know could happen and go wrong with this technology. And then third, the idea that this has to benefit and include everybody. If you think about each of those three things, there’s no other way to get that done other than through a multi-stakeholder effort. The opportunities, companies are pursuing those, researchers are pursuing those, NGOs are pursuing those, governments are pursuing those. The risks and complexities, same thing. Governments are thinking about those, agencies are thinking about those, researchers are, civil society is. Get to the inclusion and the opportunities. How do you go after opportunities, especially in countries and places and communities where those are not commercial opportunities? You have to include everybody. So as you think about each of the three things that are at the heart of this, it has to be a multi-stakeholder effort. And that’s why I’ll say one final thing. It’s why I was so thrilled that our body actually represented that multi-stakeholder effort. take hold of you. We had researchers, we had academics, we had activists, we had civil society, we had everybody involved. We debated a lot, argued a lot, and we worked pretty well together, I think.

Ian Bremmer: And I would say that it wasn’t obvious during the conversations who necessarily was wearing each of those hats, because the body was collective, pretty global. But I’m going to ask you, because you do wear one of those hats in real life, when we talk about governance, and Vilas just talked about the way we should think about governance, what are the responsibilities that the core private sector corporations, and even some of them state-owned enterprises are linked, should have when we think about governance of AI?

James Manyika: Well, we have several. First of all, keep in mind that much of the research, fundamental research that’s advanced in this field, is led in the private sector, a lot of the research labs are in the private sector. So that places an incredible responsibility, one which is to make sure we’re developing this technology responsibly, we’re thinking about all the beneficial uses of it, not just the commercial uses of it, we have to think about all of that, and we also have a responsibility to engage with governments and others, who are not only going to govern these technologies, but also think about, because keep in mind that this technology, three things happen to it, it’s developed, it’s deployed, and it’s used. That whole chain involves lots of other actors, so we have a responsibility as a private sector to work with each and every one of those, hear their concerns, and see and work together to think about how we deploy and use this technology responsibly. We have an enormous responsibility. Part of it, I’ll say one last thing, we have a responsibility to be transparent, and to help build trust. If this technology is going to have the impact that we think it’s going to have, the public has to trust it, the public has to feel that we and everybody else who’s developing, deploying, and using it, is held accountable. So we have a profound responsibility.

Ian Bremmer: And an interesting point there here is a technology that frankly a lot of people in the global south are more excited about and trust more than a lot of people in the advanced world also an opportunity. Right a fundamental opportunity thing about governments, but Alondra you wanted to come in and then I’m turning to Dr. Wang

Alondra Nelson: I just I think one of the things that we were grappling with is that it’s a fundamental different moment for different moment for multilateralism Right because of exactly what James said not only because you have if we think about something about multilateral action around nuclear Right, those are often owned by states or utilities. And so you have a whole different ecosystem these are technologies that are often coming out of the private sector almost exclusively or a lot of the R&D is coming out of the private sector and then as James suggested you have this sort of series of Stakeholders along the sort of lifecycle of them and that’s a whole so part of what we were grappling with was not just you know How do you govern a dynamic iterative technology? But how do you do it in a way that also is at the same time trying to reimagine what multilateralism looks like when you have when you have to have a Multistakeholder system in a way that you did not when we were trying to think about how do we do nuclear nonproliferation? it’s a completely different set of Actors with different kinds of different sets of power and different kinds of asymmetry than we’ve had to deal with before.

Ian Bremmer: I mean there are US China arms control agreements on AI that will be required But but that’s not what we’re talking about right here. Now. Dr. Wang you you are a scientist and indeed when when you started out There weren’t that many with PhDs in your field in your company. You’re also in the private sector I’m wondering how you are navigating how you think about those tensions and how those tensions are changing as AI is Moving so much faster is becoming so much more transformative as we’re talking about what governance Multistakeholder governance should look like.

Jian Wang: Yeah, I think there’s a different way to look at it. The first thing, you know think about in the UN level Actually, I feel pretty good because you know of the good structure. Like we have the United Nations, we have UNESCO, we have the ITU, these are part of the global organization. And ITU could be a very critical role in terms of technology development. And UNESCO, dealing with the science, dealing with the education and the culture, I think for any new challenge, particularly from new technology, you have to work with a different party and solve the problem from different perspective. You really cannot just solve the problem just by, you know, involve the government. You have to involve the different level of things. That’s one thing. But the scientists, I think, is very important. Get scientists, get individual involved to solve this problem. So for me, the governing is not just, you know, the responsibility of the organization, of government. It’s actually responsible to every people. Just like in the last couple of years, I’m working with the scientists in UK and the scientists in the United States, working together on the geoscience problem. And the more interesting, you know, eventually, actually not eventually, later this year, we bring this new technology to Africa. So individual could make a great deal to help solve this problem. So for me, just like the conversation today, and technology is not just creating a problem. The technology is bringing the people together, even though today is a different way to bring people together. But eventually, you know, different people love this technology. They will work together and solve the challenge. So I’m pretty confident, you know, any problem, you know, created by the human could be solved by a human being.

Ian Bremmer: So this is the most inclusive, proactive conversation I’ve seen on big governance issues, frankly, in the UN in a long time. I’m gonna now shift to implementation and to someone who’s been tasked with some of the most challenging problems in the world on that. front, Volker, none of us envy your position. As you think about AI and how AI can be used, can be implemented by governments, by non-state actors to allow impunity or to facilitate transformation and effective governance, where do you think it’s going right now and what do you think needs to be implemented as a result of these recommendations?

Volker Turk: Well, first of all, congratulations that you got the report out. I think it’s a minor miracle that you have been able to do it and really congratulations to you. When you mentioned mandate, no, you mentioned legitimacy, reach and mandate. I would add normative framework and you have mentioned it. It’s about human rights. We do not have to reinvent the wheel. We have an existing framework that is dynamic, that evolves, that deals with also the future issues and human rights is at the core of it. Because if you are not aware of the impact that anything that happens in this world on freedoms, on fundamental freedoms or on individual rights, if that is not analysed, it’s going to be a problem. And the advantage is it’s a universal framework. So it’s not about global south, global north, west versus someone else. It is universal and that is still agreed at this point in time by everyone. We had a big event on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights last year. There was no detractor from that, no spoiler. So we have that framework. It’s intergenerational. It’s not just about now, it’s also about the past because in some instances you have to deal with the grievances. of the past, but it is primarily also about the future, so it has this intergenerational dimension and it brings us back to human agency and to human dignity, which is whenever anything happens in this world, including on the digital, on the AI front, you will have to take into account. And it is multi-stakeholder. A human rights framework is by nature multi-stakeholder. We cannot do anything on the human rights front if you didn’t, if it wasn’t nourished by social movements, by civil society, by the private sector, and by member states. And actually, so we have a role model when we look at the implementation of how we can bring this to bear on the norms that states themselves have accepted, that the private sector through the business and human rights guiding principles have accepted, and how we can actually go into the granular detail that is needed in order to analyze how we are going to work.

Ian Bremmer: James wants to come in, but a quick follow-up for you first, which is people outside this room, people in this room know this. People outside this room don’t necessarily appreciate that 194 countries around the world agree on a lot of things. They agree on fundamental human rights, even if they don’t implement them. They agree, but they know what they are. They agree on sustainable development goals and where one would want humanity to go, even if right now most of them are not on track to being fulfilled. And hopefully, they agree on a global digital compact and how one deploys artificial intelligence to help ensure that we can actually get some of this better. So when you think about that, if you had a crystal ball, right now, do you believe over the next two, three years that AI is potentially on track to help actually implement, execute more of the things that we agree on but aren’t doing?

Volker Turk: Look, we are obviously at a very difficult geopolitical moment, no doubt about that. But we hopefully will have the global digital compact and the pact for the future. It’s a good beginning. beginning, it’s not enough, it will require a lot of dedicated attention to it, it will require continued multi-stakeholder conversations, it will require a governance framework that becomes more and more effective. Of course we are divided, polarised, we are not at the best place when it comes at the societal level to bring coherence to things, but this is precisely where whatever we can hang on to that works, including the report that you brought out, it actually shows that it is possible and we need to grab on to that and run with it.

Ian Bremmer: James?

James Manyika: Well you know, as you know well Ian, a couple of things that were on our minds when we were doing the work, one is the need to move and act very quickly, for at least two reasons that were centred in our work, the SDGs, the world’s behind, we’re all behind if you recall, we centred the need to contribute to accelerate the SDGs, the ITU has just done some phenomenal work that highlights that of something like the 169 goals in the SDGs, something like 134 of them could benefit and be accelerated using AI, we have to move. The second thing that was on our minds was the issues around capacity, and this is where especially the Global South comes to mind, because I grew up in the Global South, unless we’re able to give people access to this technology, both to participate and benefit from it, the risk of the digital divide becoming the AI divide is too huge, so we have to act, we have to act, that’s why one of our recommendations is around either the capacity fund or capacity network, we have to bring together a multi-stakeholder group that moves quickly to bring capacity and access to especially the Global South.

Ian Bremmer: I mean climate change, we didn’t really have decades, but the reality was you kind of could kick the can for a while and just let other people pay for it, the kids. You don’t have that time on this issue, which is why I don’t think I’m not surprised that everything happened in a year because, I mean, you need light speed to make that work. Carme, you want to come in and then Vilas.

Carme Artigas: Yes, exactly. I think these recommendations are only as good as our capacity to implement them as soon as possible. So as you have mentioned, and no of these recommendations are built on vacuum. We’re building on existing frameworks that already work, like human rights, but also the excellent work that UN agencies are already doing in their own domains. And that they will keep on doing that, and probably they will have much more burden of work around all these topics on AI. But we need additional instruments because there is still a global governance deficit. And because this is so horizontal, it requires so much coordination. So this is why we did not recommend, as the first thing, an international agency. Because that takes a long time, it’s a big institution, and we will see if that comes.

Ian Bremmer: And the governments, they were not ready to approve that. If you’d announced it, it wouldn’t have happened.

Carme Artigas: I don’t know, but we are proposing things that are actionable, and that we believe that in less than 18 months’ time can be ready for work. Because that’s what we need. And I think that governance is far from an innovator, it’s a catalyzer, and it’s an enabler. And I think that’s what we should be focused on.

Ian Bremmer: An agenda setter?

Carme Artigas: Of course. But I think having this conversation, and these conversations, was not the public opinion one year ago. And I think we are starting a conversation now that I hope is followed beyond the Global Digital Compact, and the companies and the governments and all the institutions will support our recommendation.

Ian Bremmer: I mean, this is the sneaky thing about the UN, right? Which is that, you know, you actually put it together, you imagine it, you start actually having conversations that other people aren’t having, and they will, default, become what people are talking about.

Vilas Dhar: Here’s the power in it, Ian. I think you’re exactly right. There is a way to talk about this that is the law of big numbers. That AI is the story of billions of dollars of investment, millions of lines of code. The foundation models that have the most parameters. And you can almost turn it into a math problem. There were a number of experts on the body with me that were computer scientists. I think we probably would all say, I hated doing math homework as a kid. I certainly don’t want to do it now. It’s not the solution. Instead, what I think about is all of these things we are talking about aren’t really about put all the ingredients together, put them in a stew pot and get an answer. It’s think about the fact that almost all of this comes down to the experience of people on the ground. My brothers and sisters, my cousins, my uncles, my aunts in countries across the planet. And what we put forward in the report is a mechanism to think about real intervention that intersects with people where they are. We don’t think about capacity building as finding a few critical enablers and saying let’s invest in compute. Or let’s just make sure there are data sources. Instead, we think about a holistic network that says let’s actually look with communities at what their needs are and think about a mechanism by which we say there is massive resources across the system. There is those contextual pieces of a normative framework. There is that mandate and that integrity. But it doesn’t happen because any entity, the UN or otherwise, says we are now going to come in and build AI for the public good. Happens because we work with communities to say what do you need to build and want to build? The second recommendation in the report that’s relevant is this idea of a global fund. The idea that we actually need capital resources that sit apart from and outside of our political mechanisms that hold instead a moral responsibility to say we need to take the resources necessary for communities to define their digital agency and make sure that they have the economic resources that let them use that money in the way they need to to build what they do. Now, we haven’t defined the specific form of that fund for a very specific reason. This is something that needs to happen through a participatory mechanism. That through the global digital compact and the implementation that comes, we need to take rights, we need to take frameworks, we need to take capital and turn it into something that actually advances progress.

Ian Bremmer: Alondra, as someone who does public policy for a living, what do you take out of this? If you were in charge of global implementation, what would you, how would you think, not about priority. advertising, but how would you think about your agenda? What would you want to make sure that people are taking away from the next steps?

Alondra Nelson: Well, first I would go to process, because that’s what wonks do. But would it be, just to double click on what Vilash said, I mean, part of this process was a lot of consultation with lots of people from civil society, with the impacted communities. So if we really want to steer and shape these good outcomes, we need to figure out how to do that in part by engaging communities. So any implementation, exactly to Vilash’s point, has to include communities that are impacted, that are going to be impacted, need to have a seat at this table in this conversation, whether or not they have PhDs in computer science or can do math. That’s critically important. I think the other piece is that we don’t know enough. So I would also associate myself with Dr. Jian, and that we don’t know the science. I mean, if we think back about the high watermark of the COVID-19 pandemic, and there were lots of preprints and lots of papers, and I think in that context, perhaps it was okay to say, you know, we’re going to figure out the science as we’re, you know, we’re going to build a plane while we’re flying it. We actually don’t know enough about these systems and tools and models. A lot of what we do know, a few people know, a lot of people don’t know. So I think one of the sort of outcomes of the report is really a commitment to implementing a kind of common understanding. And we’re seeing across the, you know, sort of international ecosystem, different ways for doing that. We proposed in the report, creating an international panel for understanding AI, for the science of AI, that would complement work on AI safety, that would complement some of the other sort of multilateral and regional things that are happening. But even these have to be done in a way that is communicating that information to not only nation states, but sees the public as an audience for how these tools work, what they can do, what their limitations are, and how we can use that information to steer them to the good outcomes that I think many of us hope and want, but are not inevitable and are not unique inherently characteristics of the technology.

Ian Bremmer: And I’d like to believe that this panel right now is actually leading by example specifically on that. That’s what we’re trying to do on this stage right now, right? Volker, you wanted to go and then James.

Volker Turk: Just to, because I think it’s a very important discussion, because if you look at the future and what startups want to do these days, they will want to do something for the for the good, common good, public good, whatever you call it. But you need to fill it then with content. That’s where the human rights side comes in, because you want to do something that is of benefit to humanity. And we often hear that actually from those who are involved in this. That’s important. But there is also the risk side and we cannot avoid talking about the risks. And because risks, we can also look at it from like traffic regulations. I mean you’re going to hit another car if you don’t respect the traffic regulations. And it’s a little bit the same when it comes to innovation, to all kinds of creative work.

Ian Bremmer: I want to give James and Dr. Wang a chance to come in and then we’re going to turn to risks. And I’m going to go to you first, by the way, but go ahead James.

James Manyika: I want to just underscore something that Dr. Nelson just described, which is there’s so much more research still to do in this field. I mean I, in my day job, I oversee the research teams that are researching and building these systems. And the field is moving so quickly, the advance is coming so fast. There’s still a lot more that we still need to learn. Some of that is surprising as being incredibly beneficial. We have all these breakthroughs and landmark breakthroughs in science and other places. But some of them are risks that we’re still researching. So I think the research frontier, that’s why one of the key pieces in our recommendation was this idea of a scientific panel that tries to keep it. But it’s got to be one that works very, very differently than what say the IPCC does. It has to be real-time. IPCC does what, a report every seven years? We can’t do that here. So that’s why the ongoing research both to understand the benefits benefits, the potential, as well as the risks, is so fundamentally important. That’s why many of us are involved in a lot of these AI safety institutes and research to really work on the frontier of the risks.

Ian Bremmer: Dr. Wang, you want to come in?

Jian Wang: Yeah, I think that back to this research challenge, I think it’s something to bring up, you know, at this time. Just thinking about every year, we have more than 5 million paper published, probably some number even bigger than 5 million, that’s a lot of paper. And just like climate change, it’s a very, very complex system, and it takes time for people to really understand. And come to the AI, it’s even more complex than the climate change, okay. So I would say that really needs something new and a framework to bring the whole science community together. Again, I want to emphasize that, and with a UN framework, and otherwise, there’s no single science committee can solve this problem.

Ian Bremmer: And is it fair to say in this field that right now, especially when we look at the two countries that are leading the way in AI, U.S. and China, that the scientific community is actually getting further apart?

Jian Wang: And most of the time, I won’t look at this field based on the countries, okay. So if you look at the people who really pioneered this area, they are from Europe, okay, from Canada. So it is not just country by country, and you have to look at how the science community actually works, okay. So for me, actually, the reason that people are thinking about U.S. and China is just because they have good AI infrastructure, helped people do the research, okay. So I think for the UN, we have to make sure they have the global shared AI infrastructure so everybody could contribute, and everybody could contribute. to solve the problem, okay. This is actually how big tech companies should do as well. You know, it’s not just for your company, but it’s really on a shared infrastructure, particular technology infrastructure, I would say.

Ian Bremmer: For the rest of the people, yeah. Oh, okay. Who was first? No, to focus first. So, only because I want to shift towards, again, we can have a very upbeat conversation about where we want to get, but as you said very eloquently, the geopolitical environment right now, the trajectory is not towards more integration, more global cooperation. It’s actually towards more conflict, and the political and economic models that we thought we could kind of take for granted are themselves under siege. So, when you look at the AI initiatives that are now being put together against that geopolitical conflict, that context, where do you see the biggest challenges?

Volker Turk: Well, it is obviously, once the genie is out of the bottle, how do you control the genie? And I think- Once all sorts of actors have that technology. For instance, and this is a phenomenon that is not just in one part of the world. I mean, we get a lot of it. We actually get a lot of requests for advisory services from member states and startup companies all around the world who want to do the right thing. So, they’re asking us, what type of risk models do we use? How do we regulate? How do we get a multi-stakeholder system in place? And it’s incredibly important that we are very fast in making sure that these advisory services can be provided. We have done it with the big tech companies. I mean, I brought you one of the documents that came out of this, which looks at taxonomy of risks from a human rights perspective, which wants to really complement the existing risk frameworks and really say you need to look at obligations. when it impinges on individual freedoms and rights. And that work is incredibly important. It’s not about ethics anymore, it is about obligations that we have towards people.

Ian Bremmer: All right, please.

Carme Artigas: I just wanted to comment on all the discussions about risk. I don’t know if we all remember that we’re talking about machine learning and deep learning, the conversations were about fairness. All of a sudden, when generative AI came to scene, we forgot about the conversation of fairness, we focused the focus on risks, in most of them existential risk or risk for frontier AI models, and sometimes that is preventing us to look at the existing risks that we already have in the present, more on the sides of fundamental rights. And it’s very interesting, and I recommend everybody having access to the document, and an agenda we have included, which is a risk analysis, a risk survey, involving many countries in the world, different stakeholders, and how interesting it is to see the difference on perception of risks of global north, global south, men and women. And we’re talking about risk because we are not informed that we need this scientific panel on the real facts, sometimes we tend to be dramatic or probably overreacting, and we forget to talk about opportunities. And if we see how risk is perceived in the global south is less perceived, people are more concerned about the opportunities they can miss.

Ian Bremmer: But they’re being left out.

Carme Artigas: Absolutely. So let’s talk also about opportunities, let’s have scientific panel inform us, not only on the risk, more transparency from the private companies, of course, but also on the great opportunities. And I can mention the huge acceleration we can expect on achieving the sustainable development goals, and also how can we allow for education and public health and universality. And I think that is the discussion that we still need to have.

Ian Bremmer: So the principle global risk here is that the lack of resources, the lack of urgency, means the digital divide becomes an AI divide, and we end up splitting apart much farther, right? And humanity doesn’t look like humanity very much in that environment. right?

James Manyika: No, it doesn’t. I mean, I was going to interject very, very quickly. If you remember in our work, one of the fascinating observations for me is when we’re talking about the risks, we often talked about misapplication and misuse. Several members in our body said, please add missed uses. If you remember that word, it’s actually in there. Missed opportunities. And that was mostly some of the members in the Global South thinking about the missed opportunities when this technology could actually transform their lives, circumstances. But all of that hinged on this ability, having the capacity to be able to participate. And we spent a lot of time thinking about the enabling infrastructure, the enablers to enable participation that range everything from very basic things that are in the digital compact like broadband connectivity, even electricity, right? In addition to access to models and compute. So I think this question of access and capacity is so fundamental to the inclusivity part of this conversation.

Ian Bremmer: So addressing the missed opportunity isn’t like, oh, we’re paying you because we’re doing something wrong. It’s because you’re actually creating market opportunities. I mean, it should be additive.

Alondra Nelson: Can I jump in here and just have a slight push back a little bit? I mean, I do think, so we did hear quite a lot from people in the global majority that they didn’t want to be left out. But there were also concerns about climate and sustainability, about the mining of critical minerals, about the extraction of labor that has to be done to train data. So I want to be very clear about what we’re hearing on the sort of landscape of inequality when you think about the entire AI stack and not just the sort of deployed tool or system.

Ian Bremmer: It feels like a race, right? I mean, on the one hand, you need these tools to address the challenges, but making the tools is also going to strain the challenges. Yeah? Please.

Vilas Dhar: I mean, we assume that inertia is the problem, right? We assume that inertia is inevitability, that the ways that we develop are the only ways can do it. Today, in this building, we are showing an AI model in a collaboration with Rafik Anadol, who I know is friends with many of us, a model that’s trained on 100 million pieces of data, sourced ethically with community consent from across the planet, trained on a model that uses only renewable power, that goes slow rather than fast, that generates incredible pieces of aesthetic beauty, and can also be used to build a predictive climate model that lets us test interventions. AI doesn’t have to be an attack against our climate sustainability. What we have to change instead is the why behind our reasons for moving so fast, for what the commercial purposes are that are often putting us in conflict against things like political rights, economic rights, climate issues, and more. There are other ways. Risks are not deterministic. We talk about risks so we can come up with better paths to better futures.

Ian Bremmer: Do you buy that? I mean, I’m asking… Thank you.

Alondra Nelson: I do. I do. I mean, I think that we are, you know, we talk quite a lot about a few organizations, but we have other organizations that are creating different models or trying to think about the sustainability issue. And I think we should be, if we’re really serious about advancing on the SDGs, we should need to be really serious about the sustainability issues and about, I think, a growing conversation that says we just need more energy, full stop, and, you know, whatever happens, you know, so be it. And so we, I think particularly in a place, in a conversation at the UN, we’ve got to figure out a way to hold all those things together and put them in balance, even understanding that it’s going to be very hard to do. And I think this is, that’s innovation, right? I mean, I think that we have had other moments where we said, you know, you’ve got to, you’ve mentioned seatbelts, seatbelts in the cars, we put guardrails on the road that allow you to sort of go where you want to go, steer a little bit faster. I mean, there are other kinds of historical moments in which we have had to make choices about how we want to advance things. And I would, you know, I think one of the challenges that we want to offer to the world, particularly to the scientific community, is how do you build these models more sustainably? How do you build data centers that are cooler, that use less water? I mean, it is a, like, it’s a, it is, these are the scientific challenges. engineering challenges of our time. And I think for many scientists, they’re incredibly exciting to think about as puzzles and how do we incentivize that?

Ian Bremmer: So we have only three minutes left. And I wanna use that for our two co-chairs, if you don’t mind. And I wanna ask both of you, take a step back. Is this a historic moment? In 10 years time, do we go back? Is there a COP process for artificial intelligence? Are we thinking differently about global AI? Are we applying our models in ways that are more inclusive, more integrative because of what is being done right now? Do you believe that? I wanna ask both of you, what it means for you. James.

James Manyika: I think this is a very important moment. One of the things that gives me enormous confidence is the fact that we’re still so early in the development of this technology. The fact that we’re having these debates, these discussions, this early in the development of a technology that still is in its early stages gives me a lot of hope. The fact that we’re able to at least agree on fundamental principles that should guide the development of this technology, that gives me enormous hope. The fact that we can actually have a multi-stakeholder conversation about this and come together to think about, so how do we do this? It goes back to what you said, Ian. The fact that we very quickly got to agree on basic principles and that much of the debate and hard work all had to do with how do we do it, that gives me hope. So I’m actually quite optimistic about all of this. I think, but it’s only incumbent on everybody here and all of us in the room to make sure we progress this with humanity’s best interests at the center of what we do with this technology.

Ian Bremmer: Carme, you get a minute.

Carme Artigas: I’m absolutely confident that here, in changing times, we have managed to develop AI for the good of humanity with more inclusiveness, with more opportunity to all, not only relying to the goodwill of organizations and governments, but we have. created really the governance instruments to make it happen and that we would look back to today of today and say, we were proposing the right thing, but most important, the nations were brave enough to adopt them.

Ian Bremmer: So before we close, I want to thank you to the panel, but I know everybody here would be a little remiss if we didn’t ask our friend Amandeep to stand up, our special envoy who made this process work. Tireless, tireless efforts, incredibly balanced decency, moral guidance and integrity and reflects everything that we are hoping for on this panel would not be happening if he wasn’t there. And I just want to thank you for everybody here. Thanks so much for joining us. We’re out of time and we’ll see you soon.

Redi Thlabi: Thank you so much, Ian, for this marvelous moderating of that panel and to your panelists as well. So much love, respect and affection, I see, but we’ve got to move along to the next segment of the program. Thank you all so very much. Thank you. I’ll introduce our next guest once we’ve all settled down to prepare for the next speaker as we wind down to the final segment of our convening this afternoon. I’d like us to settle down so we can give the president his moment and an opportunity to address us as we take the final steps to our event today. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, again, please help me in starting this joint closing. Help me welcome, a warm welcome, he’s travelled a long way to be here. Western Africa is a long way from here. His Excellency, I’m not going to call him up until we’ve all settled. I think it is appropriate. I think it is appropriate to demonstrate our own commitment, our own respect, and a word that Ian used earlier, decency, in describing Amandeep Singh Gill, UN Secretary General’s envoy on technology. So I’d like us to afford the same warmth and decency to our next speaker. It is a pleasure to welcome on stage his Excellency, the President of Botswana, Mokgweetsi Masisi, for his closing comments.

Mokgweetsi Masisi: Mr. Secretary General, Excellencies, I wish to express my profound gratitude to the Secretary General of the United Nations, His Excellency Antonio Guterres, for the invitation to participate in the Action Days session ahead of the summit of the future that is scheduled for 22nd to the 23rd September 2024, particularly on the segment of the digital track. Recommendations go to all the speakers and presenters on the digital future for all for highlighting the significance of digital justice. Digital technology is pivotal in global transformation. The effects of its impact can either be positive or negative, depending on how we harness the opportunities and mitigate challenges. However, the scope of positive impact remains high if we can collectively work towards this end. It is critical to make a link between digital inclusion and digital cooperation to bridge the divide between nation-states and within nation-states. We need to recognize that the digital divide emanates from disparities between the developed and developing countries. Technology has the potential to advance the promotion and acceleration of closing the gap in opportunities between genders and, consequently, can lead to the attainment of gender parity goals. More importantly, digital space has the potential to advance the promotion of human rights, if unimpeded. Furthermore, issues of international peace and security leverage on the use of digital technologies to inform the world of the threats and challenges that need to be addressed. Botswana, therefore, commits to be part of the brigade that flags the criticality of the potential of digitalization and cautions of its threats. Thus, my Administration has prioritized digitalization as one of its priorities within its flagship strategy of the Reset and Reclaim Agenda. I assure you of the Republic of Botswana Government’s commitment to continue to be open and amplify our voice on issues of digitalization. It is also my fervent hope that the global aspirations outlined in the Global Digital Compact would close gaps, create inclusivity, and promote access. by once again extending my sincere appreciation to the Secretary-General and all other key stakeholders for a productive session as we all look towards the summit of the future tomorrow. Thank you.

Redi Thlabi: Thank you very much. And now, for the final segment of our closing, a pleasure to welcome Amdip Singh Jo, UN Secretary-General’s envoy in technology. If you could also join him on stage, please. We heard from you earlier this morning Achim Steiner, Administrator of UNDP. If you can also come with him at the same time, thank you. Thank you. Doreen Bogdan-Martin, Secretary-General of the ITU. If you could also kindly come on stage, please. I’ll pick on you first, Amandeep, to speak, okay? Thank you.

Amandeep Singh Gill: And thank you to all of you for being here with us at this moment, this very important moment. And I want to thank my partners in this endeavour, Doreen and Achim, and their teams for the incredible work that we’ve been able to do together. I have only three points to share with you as reflection from the day. First, the importance of connection. And as we heard in the video, it’s not about connecting the circuits, it’s about connecting the people. So it’s the connections across people, people from different geographies, different backgrounds, different sectors, different lived experiences. We can only get the digital future right. if we connect people. The other second point that I take away from the day is the importance of not retreating into silos. Everything is connected. We can’t deal with AI without dealing with data. We can’t deal with either without dealing with digital public infrastructure and connectivity and so on. So we need to take a holistic view. And the last point I want to share is the importance of humility. I think we need to listen more than we speak. All of us who are in the policy space need to be very, very humble about what their understanding of technology is, what its implications are. We need to work together. We need to constantly update ourselves and hang out with the right people so that we can bring their insights, their valuable insights, into our policy work and improve the quality of our policy responses. So thank you very much. It’s a very exciting moment. It’s a very sobering moment at the same time. There’s a lot of work ahead. But with you, we can get there. Thank you.

Redi Thlabi: Thank you so much. I think you can speak at the podium or on your microphone. It’s up to you.

Achim Steiner: I’ll just use the microphone. And thank you, I will not use the teleprompter because it’s really just two things that I want to say. One is a really big thank you. You and we and all of us in the UN today had a treat. We listened to presidents, to CEOs, to young entrepreneurs, to artists, to people who, together with science, engineering, technology, are able to walk again, at least, with the help of technology. We’ve had an extraordinary day. And I hope that what you can take away from this SDG Digital Day and also this prospect of AI that to all of us is still somewhat unknown, even though we know it is going to be central to our lives as we think into the future, is this age of possibility. There is so much in the world right now that makes… everyone feel like they live under a cloud and sometimes you lose perspective. I think today I hope you all got a sense of what an extraordinary age we live in and if we make the right choices what an extraordinary age it can be for the next generation and for everyone. In that spirit I want to thank Amandeep, I want to thank Doreen, our staff who’ve actually been working for weeks on all of this and everybody else who supported this day today by turning it into something that I hope the United Nations will always be known for. Even in the darkest days there is hope and it will be done and it will be led by people. Thank you so much.

Doreen Bogdan-Martin: Thank you, thank you Achim and thank you Amandeep and indeed it has been an extraordinary, extraordinary day. Sustainable, inclusive, responsible. Three concepts at the heart of our digital track during the summit of the future action days and I would like to add to that hope because nothing gives me more hope for our shared digital future than all of you. Our brilliant innovators, our partner to connect pledgers, our digital game changers, you showed us technology can be co-created with the people it’s built for involving them directly as decision makers in design. You showed us how to make digital work with the lived realities of people in developing countries and underserved and vulnerable populations. You showed us how emerging tech from augmented reality to AI can help boost our planet’s resilience while supporting climate action. You showed us how digital skill building can lead to decent work and economic prosperity. in the unlikeliest of places against all odds. You showed us what peace tech can do to rescue the SDGs. You even showed us how much it will take, literally, an investment to connect everyone everywhere by 2030 through the Connecting Humanity Action Blueprint mentioned by Saudi Arabia. And you showed us your commitment to do what it takes through new Partner to Connect pledges. And I thank you for those new pledges. Ladies and gentlemen, we are the SDG generation. A digital future full of hope, possibility, and ambition is in our hands. And I want to thank each and every one of you for giving us a glimpse today. You gave us a glimpse of what is possible. We may have come to the end of our first Digital Action Day, our second SDG Digital, but the action certainly does not stop here. It can’t. Because too much is at stake. Fired up by hope, let’s take everything that we’ve learned today, let’s go out there and let us build a more sustainable, inclusive, and responsible digital future for all. And let’s build it together. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, as we wrap up, and as Akeem already mentioned, I think it’s important to understand this really was a team effort here. And I also want to acknowledge all of the staff, and if I may, can I ask the staff to just stand up? Because this wouldn’t have happened without our amazing teams. I know it’s dark in the room. Thank you.

Redi Thlabi: Thank you very much. Now that’s leadership, because often we say we leave no one behind, but we forget the people who are doing the groundwork, who perhaps don’t have the opportunity to shine on the global stage. So I find that very inspirational indeed. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, let me thank you, all of you, for being here today. It’s been a long day. I’ve got nothing to add to all the challenging, inspiring messages that we’ve heard today as we journey together towards a digital future for all. For all. Now, the last thing I’m going to tell you is that that online forum or platform where you can make your inputs is going to be up tomorrow after world leaders have adopted the Global Digital Compact. Please speak honestly, share what you know, what you think, what you’ve experienced, and take the learnings from today as you make your input. We look forward to them. Thank you so very much for today. Goodbye.

C

Carme Artigas

Speech speed

172 words per minute

Speech length

963 words

Speech time

335 seconds

Unique UN position to lead global AI governance

Explanation

The UN is uniquely positioned to lead global AI governance due to its mandate, reach, and legitimacy. It can bring all nations and stakeholders to the table, building on its historical success in governing international issues.

Evidence

Examples of UN’s past success in governing climate change and arms control

Major Discussion Point

The importance and role of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

Agreed with

Omar Al Olama

James Manyika

Tumi Makgabo

Volker Turk

Agreed on

Importance of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

Balancing innovation and risk mitigation in AI governance

Explanation

AI governance should focus on both opportunities and risks, not just existential risks. There is a need to balance innovation with risk mitigation, considering the different perceptions of risks across global north and south.

Evidence

Risk analysis survey showing differences in risk perception between global north and south

Major Discussion Point

Governance and regulation of AI

Disagreed with

James Manyika

Disagreed on

Focus on risks vs opportunities in AI governance

O

Omar Al Olama

Speech speed

191 words per minute

Speech length

254 words

Speech time

79 seconds

GDC as starting point for future action on AI

Explanation

The Global Digital Compact is seen as a great starting point for future action on AI. It provides a framework for cooperation and action on AI governance.

Evidence

UAE’s commitment to be part of the roadmap put forward by the UN

Major Discussion Point

The importance and role of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

Agreed with

Carme Artigas

James Manyika

Tumi Makgabo

Volker Turk

Agreed on

Importance of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

J

James Manyika

Speech speed

181 words per minute

Speech length

1479 words

Speech time

489 seconds

Need for multi-stakeholder approach in AI governance

Explanation

AI governance requires a multi-stakeholder approach due to the diverse nature of opportunities, risks, and inclusivity challenges. This approach involves companies, researchers, NGOs, governments, and civil society.

Evidence

Composition of the UN advisory body representing diverse stakeholders

Major Discussion Point

The importance and role of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

Agreed with

Carme Artigas

Omar Al Olama

Tumi Makgabo

Volker Turk

Agreed on

Importance of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

Need to bridge digital divide to prevent AI divide

Explanation

There is an urgent need to bridge the digital divide to prevent it from becoming an AI divide. This requires providing access to AI technology and building capacity, especially in the Global South.

Evidence

Recommendation for a capacity fund or network to bring AI access to the Global South

Major Discussion Point

Opportunities and challenges of AI for development

Agreed with

Tumi Makgabo

Sundar Pichai

Agreed on

Addressing the digital divide to prevent an AI divide

Role of private sector in responsible AI development

Explanation

The private sector has a significant responsibility in AI development, including conducting fundamental research, developing technology responsibly, and engaging with governments and other stakeholders. They also have a duty to be transparent and build public trust.

Evidence

Examples of private sector research labs leading AI development

Major Discussion Point

Governance and regulation of AI

Need for real-time scientific panel on AI developments

Explanation

There is a need for a scientific panel that can provide real-time insights on AI developments, both in terms of benefits and risks. This panel should work differently from existing models like the IPCC, given the rapid pace of AI advancements.

Evidence

Comparison with IPCC’s seven-year reporting cycle, which is too slow for AI

Major Discussion Point

Governance and regulation of AI

Addressing both risks and missed opportunities of AI

Explanation

AI governance should address not only the risks but also the missed opportunities, especially for the Global South. There is a need to focus on enabling infrastructure and capacity building to ensure inclusive participation in AI development and benefits.

Evidence

Inclusion of ‘missed uses’ in the advisory body’s risk discussions

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring AI benefits humanity

Agreed with

Sundar Pichai

Felix Mutati

Agreed on

AI’s potential to accelerate progress on Sustainable Development Goals

Disagreed with

Carme Artigas

Disagreed on

Focus on risks vs opportunities in AI governance

T

Tumi Makgabo

Speech speed

166 words per minute

Speech length

2102 words

Speech time

757 seconds

GDC addresses digital divides and inclusive governance

Explanation

The Global Digital Compact aims to address existing digital divides and promote more inclusive digital governance. It recognizes the need for a more equitable digital future.

Major Discussion Point

The importance and role of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

Agreed with

James Manyika

Sundar Pichai

Agreed on

Addressing the digital divide to prevent an AI divide

V

Volker Turk

Speech speed

162 words per minute

Speech length

854 words

Speech time

315 seconds

GDC builds on existing human rights frameworks

Explanation

The Global Digital Compact builds on existing human rights frameworks, which provide a universal and dynamic foundation for addressing AI governance. This approach ensures that human rights considerations are central to AI development and deployment.

Evidence

Reference to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and its continued relevance

Major Discussion Point

The importance and role of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

Agreed with

Carme Artigas

Omar Al Olama

James Manyika

Tumi Makgabo

Agreed on

Importance of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

Focusing on AI use cases that benefit humanity

Explanation

There is a need to focus on AI use cases that benefit humanity and contribute to the common good. This involves filling the concept of ‘public good’ with content that aligns with human rights principles.

Evidence

Mention of startups focusing on projects for the common good

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring AI benefits humanity

S

Sundar Pichai

Speech speed

136 words per minute

Speech length

1405 words

Speech time

618 seconds

AI can accelerate progress on Sustainable Development Goals

Explanation

AI has the potential to accelerate progress on the UN Sustainable Development Goals. It can be applied to benefit humanity in various areas such as health, education, and climate action.

Evidence

Examples of AI applications in language translation, scientific discovery, and disaster prediction

Major Discussion Point

Opportunities and challenges of AI for development

Agreed with

James Manyika

Felix Mutati

Agreed on

AI’s potential to accelerate progress on Sustainable Development Goals

AI enables economic progress and entrepreneurship

Explanation

AI is enabling economic progress and entrepreneurship, especially in emerging markets. It can boost productivity across sectors and create new opportunities for businesses.

Evidence

Example of Gary Logistics in Ethiopia using AI to improve operations and create job opportunities

Major Discussion Point

Opportunities and challenges of AI for development

Agreed with

James Manyika

Tumi Makgabo

Agreed on

Addressing the digital divide to prevent an AI divide

J

Josephine Teo

Speech speed

141 words per minute

Speech length

795 words

Speech time

338 seconds

Importance of building AI capacity in developing countries

Explanation

There is a need to build AI capacity in developing countries to ensure they can participate in and benefit from AI advancements. This involves working with employers, providing individual learning support, and building training infrastructure.

Evidence

Singapore’s approach to enabling workers to acquire relevant skills for the future

Major Discussion Point

Opportunities and challenges of AI for development

F

Felix Mutati

Speech speed

98 words per minute

Speech length

411 words

Speech time

251 seconds

Potential of AI to transform lives in rural areas

Explanation

AI and digital technologies have the potential to transform lives in rural areas by providing access to information and services. This can lead to improved farming methods and economic opportunities.

Evidence

Example of a young farmer in rural Zambia using a mobile phone and internet to access weather forecasts and market prices

Major Discussion Point

Opportunities and challenges of AI for development

Agreed with

Sundar Pichai

James Manyika

Agreed on

AI’s potential to accelerate progress on Sustainable Development Goals

M

Margrethe Vestager

Speech speed

137 words per minute

Speech length

792 words

Speech time

345 seconds

Need for global cooperation on AI governance

Explanation

There is a need for global cooperation on AI governance to address challenges that individual countries cannot solve alone. The Global Digital Compact provides a framework for such cooperation.

Major Discussion Point

Governance and regulation of AI

Importance of enforceable AI regulation

Explanation

Enforceable AI regulation is crucial to create a systemic response to the challenges posed by AI. This includes legislation to keep markets open, ensure digital services are safe, and protect privacy.

Evidence

Examples of EU legislation like the Digital Markets Act and Digital Services Act

Major Discussion Point

Governance and regulation of AI

A

Alondra Nelson

Speech speed

207 words per minute

Speech length

1177 words

Speech time

340 seconds

Centering human rights in AI development

Explanation

Human rights should be at the center of AI development and governance. This involves anchoring AI governance in fundamental human rights principles and international law.

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring AI benefits humanity

Need for sustainable and ethical AI development practices

Explanation

There is a need for more sustainable and ethical AI development practices. This includes addressing issues of climate sustainability, labor practices in data training, and the extraction of critical minerals.

Evidence

Mention of concerns about climate impact, labor exploitation, and resource extraction in AI development

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring AI benefits humanity

V

Vilas Dhar

Speech speed

217 words per minute

Speech length

859 words

Speech time

236 seconds

Importance of community engagement in AI development

Explanation

Community engagement is crucial in AI development to ensure that AI solutions meet the needs of the people they are intended to serve. This involves working with communities to understand their needs and involving them in decision-making processes.

Evidence

Proposal for a global fund to support community-defined digital agency

Major Discussion Point

Ensuring AI benefits humanity

Agreements

Agreement Points

Importance of the Global Digital Compact (GDC)

Carme Artigas

Omar Al Olama

James Manyika

Tumi Makgabo

Volker Turk

Unique UN position to lead global AI governance

GDC as starting point for future action on AI

Need for multi-stakeholder approach in AI governance

GDC addresses digital divides and inclusive governance

GDC builds on existing human rights frameworks

Speakers agreed on the critical role of the Global Digital Compact in addressing AI governance, digital divides, and promoting inclusive development while building on existing frameworks.

Addressing the digital divide to prevent an AI divide

James Manyika

Tumi Makgabo

Sundar Pichai

Need to bridge digital divide to prevent AI divide

GDC addresses digital divides and inclusive governance

AI enables economic progress and entrepreneurship

Speakers emphasized the importance of bridging the digital divide to ensure equitable access to AI technologies and prevent further inequalities.

AI’s potential to accelerate progress on Sustainable Development Goals

Sundar Pichai

James Manyika

Felix Mutati

AI can accelerate progress on Sustainable Development Goals

Addressing both risks and missed opportunities of AI

Potential of AI to transform lives in rural areas

Speakers highlighted AI’s potential to contribute to sustainable development and improve lives, particularly in developing regions.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the need for a balanced approach to AI governance that promotes innovation while mitigating risks through enforceable regulations.

Carme Artigas

Margrethe Vestager

Balancing innovation and risk mitigation in AI governance

Importance of enforceable AI regulation

Both speakers stressed the importance of grounding AI governance and development in existing human rights frameworks.

Volker Turk

Alondra Nelson

GDC builds on existing human rights frameworks

Centering human rights in AI development

Unexpected Consensus

Multi-stakeholder approach to AI governance

Carme Artigas

James Manyika

Vilas Dhar

Unique UN position to lead global AI governance

Need for multi-stakeholder approach in AI governance

Importance of community engagement in AI development

Despite representing different sectors (government, private sector, and civil society), these speakers unexpectedly agreed on the necessity of a multi-stakeholder approach to AI governance, emphasizing the importance of inclusive participation from various sectors and communities.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement included the importance of the Global Digital Compact, the need to address digital divides, AI’s potential for sustainable development, the necessity of human rights-based approaches, and the importance of multi-stakeholder governance.

Consensus level

There was a high level of consensus among speakers on fundamental principles and goals for AI governance. This consensus suggests a strong foundation for global cooperation on AI development and regulation, which could facilitate more rapid progress in implementing the Global Digital Compact and related initiatives. However, the specific mechanisms for implementation and balancing various interests may still require further negotiation and refinement.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Focus on risks vs opportunities in AI governance

Carme Artigas

James Manyika

Balancing innovation and risk mitigation in AI governance

Addressing both risks and missed opportunities of AI

While both speakers acknowledge the need to address risks, Carme Artigas emphasizes the importance of not overlooking opportunities, especially for the global south, while James Manyika stresses the need to address both risks and missed opportunities equally.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around the balance between focusing on risks versus opportunities in AI governance, and the specific approaches to ensuring sustainable and ethical AI development.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among the speakers is relatively low. Most speakers agree on the fundamental principles and goals of AI governance, with differences mainly in emphasis and specific implementation strategies. This suggests a generally unified vision for the Global Digital Compact, which bodes well for its potential implementation and effectiveness.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

Both speakers agree on the need for ongoing research and monitoring of AI developments, but James Manyika focuses on the speed and real-time nature of the panel, while Alondra Nelson emphasizes the importance of sustainability and ethical considerations in AI development.

James Manyika

Alondra Nelson

Need for real-time scientific panel on AI developments

Need for sustainable and ethical AI development practices

Both speakers recognize the potential of AI for development, but while Sundar Pichai focuses on the positive impacts, Alondra Nelson emphasizes the need to address sustainability and ethical concerns in AI development.

Sundar Pichai

Alondra Nelson

AI can accelerate progress on Sustainable Development Goals

Need for sustainable and ethical AI development practices

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the need for a balanced approach to AI governance that promotes innovation while mitigating risks through enforceable regulations.

Carme Artigas

Margrethe Vestager

Balancing innovation and risk mitigation in AI governance

Importance of enforceable AI regulation

Both speakers stressed the importance of grounding AI governance and development in existing human rights frameworks.

Volker Turk

Alondra Nelson

GDC builds on existing human rights frameworks

Centering human rights in AI development

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

The Global Digital Compact (GDC) is seen as a crucial starting point for global AI governance and cooperation

AI has significant potential to accelerate progress on Sustainable Development Goals and enable economic development

There is a need for inclusive, multi-stakeholder governance of AI that involves developing countries

Balancing innovation with risk mitigation is key in AI governance and regulation

Centering human rights and community engagement in AI development is essential

Building AI capacity and infrastructure in developing countries is critical to prevent an AI divide

Resolutions and Action Items

Launch of a Global AI Opportunity Fund by Google to invest $120 million in AI education and training globally

Proposal to establish a global fund on AI for sustainable development

Recommendation to create an international scientific panel on AI

Plan to make an online platform available for public input on the Global Digital Compact after its adoption

Unresolved Issues

Specific mechanisms for enforcing AI governance globally

Details on implementation of the proposed global fund on AI

How to effectively balance AI development with sustainability and climate concerns

Concrete steps to ensure AI benefits reach marginalized communities

Suggested Compromises

Using existing UN frameworks and agencies to implement AI governance rather than creating new institutions immediately

Focusing on both risks and opportunities of AI to address concerns of developed and developing nations

Balancing regulation with market incentives to encourage ethical AI development by companies

Thought Provoking Comments

We too often equate governance with control. And it’s part of a conversation that’s much bigger. I think we have followed a narrative that technology companies innovate and governments regulate and somehow in that the rest of us go along. But that’s not the point of governance, right? Governance is to set a shared vision for humanity, is to think about all of the resources we can bring to bear to make shared decisions that put agency with communities, that allow voices to participate and to come forward.

Speaker

Vilas Dhar

Reason

This comment reframes the concept of governance in a more inclusive and participatory way, challenging the typical narrative of top-down control.

Impact

It shifted the conversation towards considering governance as a collaborative process involving multiple stakeholders, not just governments and tech companies. This perspective was echoed by other panelists throughout the discussion.

We don’t think about capacity building as finding a few critical enablers and saying let’s invest in compute. Or let’s just make sure there are data sources. Instead, we think about a holistic network that says let’s actually look with communities at what their needs are and think about a mechanism by which we say there is massive resources across the system.

Speaker

Vilas Dhar

Reason

This comment provides a nuanced view of capacity building, emphasizing the importance of community needs and holistic approaches.

Impact

It deepened the discussion on implementation strategies, moving beyond technical solutions to consider social and community contexts.

We need to recognize that the digital divide emanates from disparities between the developed and developing countries. Technology has the potential to advance the promotion and acceleration of closing the gap in opportunities between genders and, consequently, can lead to the attainment of gender parity goals.

Speaker

Mokgweetsi Masisi

Reason

This comment highlights the interconnection between digital divides, global inequality, and gender disparities.

Impact

It broadened the scope of the discussion to include considerations of global equity and gender equality in digital development.

We don’t know enough. So I would also associate myself with Dr. Jian, and that we don’t know the science. I mean, if we think back about the high watermark of the COVID-19 pandemic, and there were lots of preprints and lots of papers, and I think in that context, perhaps it was okay to say, you know, we’re going to figure out the science as we’re, you know, we’re going to build a plane while we’re flying it. We actually don’t know enough about these systems and tools and models.

Speaker

Alondra Nelson

Reason

This comment acknowledges the limitations of current knowledge about AI systems and draws a parallel to the rapid scientific developments during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Impact

It introduced a note of caution and humility into the discussion, emphasizing the need for ongoing research and scientific understanding alongside policy development.

Connect the schools. Connect the young people. Connect my children.

Speaker

Nnenna Nwakanma

Reason

This simple yet powerful statement cuts through complex policy discussions to highlight a fundamental priority.

Impact

It refocused the conversation on the practical, human-centered outcomes of digital development, particularly for young people and education.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by broadening its scope beyond technical and policy considerations to include community needs, global equity, scientific understanding, and practical human outcomes. They challenged conventional narratives about governance and implementation, emphasizing the importance of inclusive, participatory approaches and acknowledging the complexities and unknowns in the field of AI. The discussion evolved from high-level policy talk to considering concrete actions and their impacts on diverse communities, particularly in the Global South.

Follow-up Questions

How can we ensure AI benefits are distributed equitably and the digital divide does not become an AI divide?

Speaker

James Manyika

Explanation

This is critical to ensure AI does not exacerbate existing inequalities between developed and developing countries.

How can we build AI models and data centers more sustainably to address climate and environmental concerns?

Speaker

Alondra Nelson

Explanation

This is important to ensure AI development does not conflict with climate goals and sustainability efforts.

How can we create a real-time scientific panel to study and report on AI developments and impacts?

Speaker

James Manyika

Explanation

A rapid, ongoing research effort is needed to keep up with the fast pace of AI advancement and inform governance efforts.

How can we implement capacity building and create a global fund to support AI development in the Global South?

Speaker

James Manyika and Vilas Dhar

Explanation

This is crucial to enable developing countries to participate in and benefit from AI advancements.

How can we better involve impacted communities in shaping AI governance and development?

Speaker

Alondra Nelson

Explanation

Ensuring diverse voices are included is essential for creating AI systems that work for all of humanity.

How can we create a shared global AI infrastructure to enable more inclusive research and development?

Speaker

Jian Wang

Explanation

This could help democratize AI development and reduce concentration of power in a few countries or companies.

How can we balance discussions of AI risks with equal focus on opportunities, especially for the Global South?

Speaker

Carme Artigas

Explanation

A balanced approach is needed to fully realize AI’s potential while mitigating risks.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.

The Power of the Commons: Digital Public Goods for a More Secure, Inclusive and Resilient World

The Power of the Commons: Digital Public Goods for a More Secure, Inclusive and Resilient World

Session at a Glance

Summary

This event focused on the power of digital commons and digital public goods (DPGs) in creating a more secure, inclusive, and resilient world. Speakers from governments, international organizations, academia, and civil society discussed the transformative potential of DPGs and digital public infrastructure (DPI) in fostering sustainable development and advancing human rights globally.

Key themes included the importance of multi-stakeholder collaboration, the need to close digital divides, and the critical role of community-led initiatives in developing DPGs. Speakers highlighted successful examples like Wikipedia and emphasized how DPGs can democratize access to knowledge and technology. The discussion underscored the importance of embedding human rights and democratic values in the design of digital systems.

Participants stressed the need for robust governance frameworks and universal safeguards to ensure DPGs and DPIs respect privacy, promote inclusion, and protect against misuse. The role of governments in providing legal frameworks and supporting connectivity was discussed, alongside the importance of civil society participation in shaping digital governance.

Academia was highlighted as a key contributor to digital commons through knowledge creation, incubation of projects, and research on societal impacts. Speakers called for increased investment in digital skills and emphasized trust and safety as crucial for the continued development and use of DPGs.

The event concluded with calls to action for building a global ecosystem around DPGs, integrating them into various policy fields, and fostering international cooperation to leverage their potential in addressing global challenges and achieving sustainable development goals.

Keypoints

Major discussion points:

– The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for inclusive development and achieving the Sustainable Development Goals

– The need for multi-stakeholder collaboration and community-led approaches in developing and governing DPGs

– The role of governments in supporting DPGs through policy frameworks, funding, and infrastructure

– The critical importance of embedding human rights and democratic values in the design of digital systems and DPGs

– The potential of DPGs to democratize access to knowledge and empower marginalized communities

Overall purpose:

The discussion aimed to highlight the transformative potential of digital public goods and digital public infrastructure in fostering sustainable, inclusive development worldwide. It sought to encourage multi-stakeholder partnerships to promote and protect DPGs that are truly universal and reflect diverse voices.

Tone:

The overall tone was optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers expressing enthusiasm about the potential of DPGs while also acknowledging challenges. There was a sense of urgency about the need to act now to shape the digital future in line with democratic values and human rights. The tone remained consistent throughout, emphasizing collaboration and shared responsibility among different stakeholders.

Speakers

Moderators/Facilitators:

– Costanza Sciubba Caniglia (Anti-Disinformation Strategy Lead at Wikimedia Foundation)

– Nicole Manger (Lead Global AI Governance and Digital Cooperation at Federal Foreign Office of Germany)

Speakers:

– Amandeep Gill (UN Secretary-General’s Envoy on Technology)

– Krzysztof Szczerski (Ambassador of Poland)

– Alicia Buenrostro Massieu (Deputy Permanent Representative of Mexico to the UN)

– Rebecca MacKinnon (Vice President Global Advocacy at Wikimedia Foundation)

– Ivan Sigal (Executive Director of Global Voices)

– Fabro Steibel (ITS Rio)

– Eileen Donahoe (Coordinator for Digital Freedom, US Department of State)

– Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi (Director General of NITDA Nigeria)

– Marianne Díaz Hernández (YID Campaigner at Access Now)

– Jimmy Wales (Co-founder of Wikipedia)

– Urs Gasser (Professor at Technical University of Munich)

– Emran Mian (Director General for Digital and Telecoms, UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology)

– Anna Christmann (Member of German Parliament, member of UN Secretary-General’s High-Level Advisory Body on AI)

Areas of expertise among speakers include digital governance, technology policy, digital rights, civil society engagement, digital public goods, artificial intelligence, and international relations.

Full session report

Digital Public Goods: Building a More Secure, Inclusive, and Resilient World

This high-level discussion brought together experts from governments, international organizations, academia, and civil society to explore the transformative potential of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) in fostering sustainable development and advancing human rights globally.

Event Structure and Overview

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia opened the event, outlining its structure: opening remarks, success stories, and a panel discussion. The event aimed to highlight the importance of DPGs and DPI in promoting inclusive digital transformation and sustainable development.

Key Themes and Discussions

1. The Importance of Digital Public Goods and Infrastructure

Speakers unanimously agreed on the critical role of DPGs and DPI in promoting inclusive, sustainable digital transformation. Amandeep Gill, UN Secretary-General’s Envoy on Technology, set the tone by emphasising that “well-governed commons are the foundations of human civilization. Digital is no exception, and today more than ever digital commons are vital to our interconnected world.”

Fabro Steibel provided a thought-provoking perspective, noting that “DPIs emerge earlier and faster in the Global South than in the Global North. This is what research shows and most likely this is because out of necessity. In the Global South, we need better technologies to spread and equalise wealth and power.” This insight challenged common assumptions about technological innovation and highlighted the unique contributions of the Global South in developing digital public infrastructure.

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu, Deputy Permanent Representative of Mexico to the UN, stressed the importance of DPGs and DPI in closing the digital divide, while Eileen Donahoe, Coordinator for Digital Freedom at the US Department of State, emphasised the need for universal safeguards to protect human rights in the development and implementation of these technologies.

2. Multi-stakeholder Collaboration and Community-led Approaches

The discussion highlighted the crucial role of multi-stakeholder collaboration in developing and governing DPGs. Speakers agreed that involving diverse stakeholders, including civil society, academia, and community members, is essential for creating truly inclusive and effective digital public goods.

Marianne Díaz Hernández of Access Now emphasised the role of civil society in ensuring DPGs remain transparent, inclusive, and responsive to societal needs. Urs Gasser, Professor at Technical University of Munich, highlighted academia’s multifaceted contribution: “Academia can not only contribute in these different forms substantively to the formation of digital commons and digital public goods. It can also study and assess what we can learn about digital commons as we go forward, about the societal impact about the relevance, we can assess whether we pass the Wikipedia test when new policies are rolled out.”

Jimmy Wales, co-founder of Wikipedia, stressed the importance of community-driven governance, using Wikipedia as a prime example of a successful DPG. He suggested that when considering digital policies, one should ask, “If you’re about to pass some rule, think about, is this going to wreck Wikipedia? And if it is, it might not be a great rule.”

3. The Role of Governments and Policy Frameworks

While there was broad agreement on the importance of government support for DPGs, there were nuanced differences in how speakers viewed the government’s role. Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi, Director General of NITDA Nigeria, emphasised the need for governments to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs.

Emran Mian, Director General for Digital and Telecoms at the UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology, focused on the importance of digital skills and trust and safety in the context of enjoying and creating DPGs. Anna Christmann, member of the UN Secretary-General’s High-Level Advisory Body on AI, called for bringing DPG discussions to other policy areas like climate change and COP negotiations.

4. Human Rights and Democratic Values in Digital Systems

A recurring theme throughout the discussion was the critical importance of embedding human rights and democratic values in the design of digital systems and DPGs. Marianne Díaz Hernández provided a thought-provoking comment on this issue: “When we focus on development above human rights, instead of understanding development as a tool to achieve human rights, we risk creating systems that have not been designed with human rights as a principle, but as an afterthought.”

Eileen Donahoe echoed this sentiment, advocating for universal safeguards to protect human rights in DPGs and DPI. This emphasis on human rights highlighted a key challenge: balancing rapid development of DPGs with ensuring robust protections for individual rights and freedoms.

5. Success Stories and Practical Applications

Ivan Sigal from Global Voices shared insights on the importance of multilingualism in DPGs, highlighting their work in creating tools for underrepresented languages. Fabro Steibel discussed successful DPI implementations in Brazil, emphasizing the role of open-source solutions in government services.

6. Global Digital Compact and Future Initiatives

Amandeep Gill highlighted the Global Digital Compact as a new foundation for international action on DPGs and DPI. He emphasized its role in addressing key digital issues and promoting cooperation. Gill also mentioned the upcoming OSPOS for Good Conference, focusing on open-source technologies for public good.

Anna Christmann called for new hands-on initiatives to co-design frontier open data and AI solutions as DPGs. The discussion also touched on the relevance of the upcoming Summit of the Future in shaping the global digital landscape.

7. Challenges and Future Directions

The discussion identified several challenges and areas for future focus in the development of DPGs:

– Balancing development goals with protecting human rights

– Establishing sustainable funding mechanisms for DPGs and open-source projects

– Improving data and AI literacy to enable wider participation in DPG development

– Addressing potential risks and misuse of DPGs and open data

– Ensuring multilingualism and local context in global DPGs

– Developing governance models that balance community-driven approaches with government support

– Integrating DPGs into broader policy discussions on climate change, education, and healthcare

Conclusion

The discussion underscored the transformative potential of digital public goods and digital public infrastructure in fostering sustainable, inclusive development worldwide. It emphasised the need for multi-stakeholder partnerships to promote and protect DPGs that are truly universal and reflect diverse voices. The overall tone was optimistic and forward-looking, with speakers expressing enthusiasm about the potential of DPGs while also acknowledging the challenges ahead.

As the world continues to grapple with digital transformation, the insights from this discussion provide a valuable framework for leveraging DPGs to create a more secure, inclusive, and resilient global digital ecosystem. The emphasis on human rights, community-driven approaches, and multi-stakeholder collaboration offers a path forward in harnessing the power of digital commons for the benefit of all.

Session Transcript

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Hello, good morning, welcome, Excellencies, colleagues, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you so much for joining us today for our event, The Power of the Commons, Digital Public Goods for a More Secure, Inclusive, and Resilient World. My name is Costanza Sciubba Caniglia, I am the Anti-Disinformation Strategy Lead at the Wikimedia Foundation, and I am honored today to co-moderate this event with my colleague, Nicole Mangier, Lead Global AI Governance and Digital Cooperation at the Federal Foreign Office of Germany. Before we start, I wanted to thank our co-organizers, the Office of the Tech Envoy, the Permanent Mission of Poland and Mexico, the Federal Foreign Office of Germany, TUM, the Network of Centers, and multiple Wikimedia affiliates, Wikimedia EU, Wikimedia Poland, Wikimedia Czech, and Wikimedia Deutschland. I’m going to leave the floor to Nicole in a moment, but just wanted to articulate the event is going to be divided in four parts. We’re going to have opening remarks, and then we’re going to have a section on success stories that will serve to ground the panel that will come afterwards, with a couple of examples of grassroots digital public good examples. And then we’re going to have a panel of experts, and then we’ll close with a couple of closing remarks. And with this, Nicole, to you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much, Amandeep. Thank you so much, Amandeep. So thanks a lot, Costanza. And I also very warmly welcome you to our side event, The Power of the Commons, the role of digital public goods for a more secure, inclusive, and resilient world. So this event, as Costanza said, is co-hosted by the Wikimedia Foundation and its affiliates by the governments of Mexico and Poland, and then by the UN Secretary General’s Envoy on Technology. So I want to step a little back. ask the question, like, why are we meeting here on this topic today? So, I guess we are all expecting to be, to see the pact for the future and especially the global digital compact to be adopted successfully tomorrow and adopted. Yeah, and so it’s going to be the first Compass truly global approach to an open, free, secure, and human-centered digital future for all and everywhere. And so for us today, we wanted to highlight especially the transformative potential of digital public goods for the values of the GDC, such as enabling access, inclusive access to digital technologies, and also enabling civil society to have a voice in how technology is designed and governed. Also to pool scarce resources like data and infrastructure to really increase resilience and sustainability and have a digital transformation that is also sustainable. So without further ado, I would like to introduce our esteemed speakers, opening speakers, and I first pass it on to His Excellency Under-Secretary-General Amandeep Gill, Secretary General’s Envoy on Technology.

Amandeep Gill: Thank you very much, Nicole, and I’d like to begin by welcoming all of you to the pre-summit of the Future Action Day. Thank you for being here at UN Headquarters with us. It means a lot. It means a lot to the Secretary General, to all of us. I want to also thank Mexico, Poland, and Wikimedia for organizing this event, this very important event, and I want to thank Germany for their consistent support to this constellation of important ideas. Ladies and gentlemen, well-governed commons are the foundations of human civilization. Digital is no exception, and today more than ever digital commons are vital to our interconnected world. When we speak about digital commons, we mean resources that are collectively owned and managed by a community and freely accessible to all members of our society, and on the technology front, open digital resources are key to the equitable advancement of digital digital technologies, particularly emerging technologies like AI. Nicole mentioned the Global Digital Compact. So after nearly two years of consultation and negotiations, the negotiations have concluded and there’s a text on the table as part of the pact for the future for a decision tomorrow. This document, the Global Digital Compact, embeds an international commitment to global digital commons through digital public goods and digital public infrastructure. So it is a new foundation for more meaningful, more impactful action in this area. This is very significant. The GDC can play a crucial role in democratizing access to knowledge and technological resources, ensuring that everyone everywhere, regardless of their socioeconomic status, has the opportunity to participate in benefit from the digital economy. This inclusivity is crucial for reducing inequalities and promoting social equity, aligning with the goal of leaving no one behind. Further, the collaborative nature of digital commons, including digital public goods and digital public infrastructure, fosters innovation and creativity. By enabling the free exchange of ideas and resources, by bringing data sets together, by bringing talent, coding talent in particular, together, digital commons help accelerate technological advancements and the development of new solutions to global challenges. At the same time, because you have many more eyes on the code, many more eyes on the data, you prevent misuse. You build a set of safeguards, a set of checks and balances that ensure that our digital commons work for everyone. This open and responsible innovation ecosystem can support economic growth, the creation of jobs, enhancement of productivity, contributing to overall economic prosperity and social well-being. At the UN, we know that the open nature of open source software, platforms, data, AI models are a key enabler of the Sustainable Development Goals. By leveraging the potential of Digital Commons, we believe we can accelerate progress towards the 2030 Agenda. As part of the Secretary General’s commitment to Digital Commons, my office, together with many partners, some of which are in the room today, organizes the yearly OSPOS for Good Conference. In July, we hosted this together with Germany and Kenya, the second edition of this conference. Through two days at the UN, over 600 participants from around the world gathered in New York with active engagement, high-quality discussions, and a collaborative spirit characteristic of the open-source community. I’d like to finish these remarks by inviting you all to join us in collaborating on the future of this conference in follow-up to the Global Digital Compact. In this spirit, I wish you an invigorating exchange today. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much, Under-Secretary General Gill. I pass on the word to His Excellency, Ambassador of Poland Krzysztof Szczerski. I am so sorry, possibly, for mispronouncing the name, but I hope I got it over to you.

Krzysztof Szczerski: Thank you very much, Excellencies, Mr. Special Envoy, ladies and gentlemen, I’m so excited to be here, being one of the, not only the daily reader of the Wikipedia, but also having my own profile on it. It’s good to be in the system, somehow. Okay, it’s my honor to be with you today, as we heard, in the dawn of the summit of the future, which we are all very excited about. First and foremost, let me congratulate the Wikimedia Foundation for gathering us and for working tirelessly to ensure the success of today’s discussions. Poland is, of course, happy to be the co-sponsor of this event. As a gentleman, digital cooperation is going to be heavily featured during the Summit of the Future and the entire High-Level Week. We expect, as we already heard, that already tomorrow the heads of states and governments will adopt the foundation for the global digital cooperation, the document which is named, as we heard, Global Digital Compact. This will mark the new era of recognition that we need to act swiftly, decisively and collectively to utilize and govern the ever-expanding digital sphere. I am more than happy to see involvement of many stakeholders from outside the governments like the lead organizer of this event, Wikimedia, in our discussions. It’s only with their active participation on equal footing that we can fully tap the potential of digital public goods and digital public infrastructure for realization of the Sustainable Development Goals. Colleagues, one of the aims of this meeting is to highlight the potential of digital commons, the role of which is inavailable in providing individuals and communities with free and easy access to information. And I just want to underline the word information because I think we get too much of the free and easy access to disinformation. And it’s crucially important since this device becomes now the best friend of many of ours. So therefore it’s very important to really guarantee that it’s free, easy, but also reliable. Therefore I would like to share with you just a couple of cases of how public open data is used by citizens in my country, Poland, to build interest in digital tools, to participate in public life, and to monitor the activity of public authorities. Take for example the portal dane.gov.pl. This is a universal access point to open data in Poland and has been enthusiastically embraced by various stakeholders. It’s a governmental portal, but open for everybody. Presidents interested in monitoring state activities use it as a tool for holding the government accountable. Companies leverage data to build innovative products and services. Another set of examples includes the fact-checking platforms run by civil society. There are various of them. Their adaptability to most recent events, such as fact-checking related to the upcoming elections, is one of their strengths. Our goal, however, in all these efforts, is not to simply implement open data policy, but to do more to construct a comprehensive, robust, citizen-friendly system that is fueled by the valuable data. And we have been recognized for our efforts by the major European and global open data rankings. Ladies and gentlemen, in conclusion, I am looking forward to learning about the concrete examples of how digital public goods and digital public infrastructure can contribute to a safe, resilient, and open digital world, which we strive to build in order to leave no one behind. And I wish you all the very enriching and exciting discussions, and I thank you. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: And next, I would pass on the word to Her Excellency Alicia Buenrostro Massieu, Deputy Permanent Representative of the Mexican United States to the United Nations in New York. The floor is yours.

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu: Thank you very much, and it’s also a pleasure to be here with all of you. In particular, it’s very good to share the floor with such a panel. And having the creator of Wikipedia, as my colleague from Poland has just mentioned, it’s just a real honor, and with them, a big deal as well. And for Mexico, a country that really has put a lot into the global digital compact. So it’s an honor, really, to be here today representing my country, Mexico. The Pact for the Future, and more specifically… the Global Digital Compact represents certainly an opportunity to consolidate a global digital governance framework that fosters inclusion, equity, and sustainability, as well as to emphasize the political relevance of this framework in the multilateral sphere. It’s the first time that we are working on this type of issue from a real compact, and that is a step forward and as the Ambassador of Poland has just mentioned, we really look forward to being able to witness that this has been passed tomorrow morning. So for my country, for Mexico, the promise of digital transformation lies in its ability to drive inclusive growth, reduce inequalities, and accelerate progress towards the Sustainable Development Goals. Technology must be a development catalyst and not a luxury for a few, and that is the position of my country. So this should be for everybody. Mexico’s priorities are very clear. First, we must close the digital divide and ensure that no one is left behind in the digital age. Second, to empower small and medium-sized enterprises. Technology can be a great equalizer by fostering innovation and supporting local economic activity. Third, Mexico is committed to ensuring that human rights are respected in all digital policies, and that is very important as well. As a country that enshrines the right to access information and communication technologies in our Constitution, we are dedicated to promoting meaningful digital inclusion, particularly for groups in vulnerable situations that have faced historical exclusions, such as women, indigenous peoples, and Afro-descendant communities. At the heart of our efforts is the concept of digital public goods as essential for building a digital commons that is transparent, equitable, and open to all. By investing in digital public infrastructure, we create pathways for marginalized communities to be able to fully participate in the global economy. It’s not just about providing access, but about empowering our people to innovate, to grow, and contribute to the development of their communities. Digital public goods align with Mexico’s goals of inclusive economic development and socio-economic equity. In this context, the Global Digital Compact gains relevance as a roadmap for building secure, inclusive, and rights- based digital ecosystems. Early last year, Mexico co-hosted the GDC consultation for the Americas in Mexico City, and Amandeep was there. That was along with Germany and the Office of the Secretary’s General Envoy, as I mentioned. This consultation brought together key actors from across the region to discuss the most pressing issues around digital governance and the role of digital public goods. Throughout the GDC negotiations, my country has pushed for the creation of open government initiatives, which focus on integrating digital tools into public administration to promote transparency and accountability. We are advocating for the development of inclusive and accessible digital tools, particularly tailored to small and medium enterprises and entrepreneurs. These tools must be affordable and adaptable to the needs of small businesses and local innovators, helping them leverage the power of technology for economic growth. Mexico is committed to investing in inclusive digital infrastructure, focusing on marginalized and underserved communities. By expanding access to the infrastructure in rural and in economically disadvantaged regions, we can help bridge the digital divide and ensure equitable opportunities for all. And to conclude, I would like to encourage all governments and stakeholders to ensure that digital transformation benefits all people everywhere, and that is a commitment that we almost assume. By investing in digital public goods and digital public infrastructure, and by collaborating and building on the principles, objectives, commitments, and actions outlined in the Global Digital Compact, we can consolidate the construction of a global digital environment that is inclusive, equitable, and sustainable. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you, and I would like to pass it on now to our civil society voice on this stage, Rebecca MacKinnon. She is Vice President Global Advocacy at Wikimedia Foundation and also founder of Global Voices. Rebecca, the floor is yours.

Rebecca MacKinnon: Thank you so much, Nicole. I’m here today representing the Wikimedia Foundation along with my colleague Costanza here and several other colleagues in the room. Someone was asking me just before we got seated what’s the difference between the Wikimedia Foundation and Wikipedia. We are the nonprofit organization that serves as the technical, legal, and fundraising host for Wikipedia and other volunteer-run projects that operate in over 300 languages. Wikipedia, of course, being created before the foundation existed by Jimmy Wales, who you’ll hear from later. We also have staff who support the global community of volunteers who build and maintain these projects around the world. And, of course, I’d like to thank all of our co-organizers shown on the screen today, in particular the governments of Poland, Mexico, and Germany and the Office of the UN Tech Envoy, without whose support we wouldn’t be here. And also grateful to the partnership of many others in the United Nations system, national governments, and civil society and academia who’ve helped organize this event and, more generally, in their commitment to support and protect digital public goods like Wikipedia. And we’ll take the next slide, please. So this is a group of just some of the people who maintain and create Wikipedia who traveled to Katowice in Poland just last month for an annual conference called Wikimania. It was organized, one of the key organizers actually sitting right there, the young man named Maciek. And thanks to our co-hosts and the gracious Polish people for welcoming us. We are very lucky to have him here today. Wikipedia is a digital native, but a lot of the people who build and govern this global resource of free knowledge actually find it very important to gather in person, as you see here, to brainstorm, learn from each other, and build human bonds that enable us to collaborate with empathy and understanding of each other’s lived experience. Next slide, please. New language communities are joining the Wikimedia family all the time. And this is an example, Wikimedia founder Jimmy Wales, sitting there, who you’ll hear from in a few minutes, gave the 2024 Newcomer of the Year Award at Wikimania to the people who’ve created a new version of Wikipedia in the Waiyu language. Next slide, please. And here is that new Waiyu language, Wikipedia. Waiyu is spoken by about 400,000 indigenous people in northwestern Venezuela and northeastern Colombia. It’s an example of a project that benefits an indigenous community that commercial internet companies have no financial incentive to care about. Top-down government services in a lot of countries also often fail to prioritize the needs of indigenous people whose ancient communities often span across several borders, which is why it’s so vital that governments must protect and support the people and the work behind such community-led bottom-up projects. Projects like Wikipedia, but many others, and we’ll hear some more examples later, serve the public interest by creating knowledge, infrastructure, and access to information built on a robust digital commons that we’ve heard about already, which includes open-source software, a range of open content and open data projects, and open licensing for content that enables projects to build upon one another in an interdependent ecosystem. Next slide, please. So here we have a photo of the Igbo language user group in Nigeria, jumping across. the Atlantic Ocean, and a community outreach activity that they carried out not too long ago. Wikipedia exists in several Nigerian languages, run by volunteers who all care passionately about preserving and strengthening their community’s linguistic and cultural heritage, while contributing also to a global body of knowledge about the people, places, issues, and ideas in their countries and communities. So then that knowledge also gets translated into other languages and ends up in English, et cetera. And in so doing, they’re also helping to advance technical capacity, economic opportunity, and cultural flourishing in their own communities. To put it another way, they’re directly contributing to the advancement of quite a number of SDGs. And there’s simply no way that a top-down approach to digital public infrastructure and digital public goods is going to be able to reach all of the underserved, vulnerable, and marginalized communities around the world, full of talented people who will take initiative in innovative ways if given half a chance, as we’ve been discovering throughout the Wikimedia communities. So we believe that the future of the internet should be one that promotes and protects these types of projects and these people, like those who we work with around the world. Wikipedia is one of the most famous examples, but there’s many others that have emerged over the past two decades, and we’re going to be hearing about a few of them in just a few minutes. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you, Rebecca, and thanks to all our distinguished speakers here on this stage. We are now transitioning to the second segment of hearing success stories of civil society grassroots organizations. because DPGs are really at its core about grassroots involvement and so that’s why we would like to highlight these success stories and also the perspectives of two organizations, one Global Voices and the second ITS Rio on how they are using the potential of DPGs and also possibly certain challenges what you know when it comes to governance structures, robust funding mechanisms and also creating robust data AI literacy to leverage DPGs successfully. So with that said I would like to call Fabro Steibel and Ivan Sigal on the stage with me. So we will start with one example of successful DPGs which is Global Voices. So this is really a multilingual community of writers, translators, academics and digital rights activists worldwide and I would like to give the floor to Ivan Seagal, Executive Director of Global Voices.

Ivan Sigal: Good morning. I’m Ivan Sigal as is just told. I’m now the actually outgoing Executive Director of Global Voices. This is my last public appearance in this role. We’re an organization that’s been for the past 20 years has been a forum for the perspectives and priorities of global majority writers and activists and explores how information technologies affect movements, politics, culture and information integrity. Some 8,000 writers, translators and researchers have participated from 160 countries and contributed to our to our work over the years. We’re dedicated to building understanding across cultures and languages and specifically we understand that the internet does not by itself bring around positive social change. Rather we need to invest in and build an internet based on a vision that reflects those values and we’re one of many communities and initiatives and organizations that exists as a digital public good that works in a much smaller level than a group like Wikipedia but is an example of what people can accomplish when the internet flourish functions as a flourishing and healthy information ecosystem rather than as a censored or surveilled information space or based on a small number of platforms that function as walled gardens or exists as a field of data to be extracted and monetized primarily for artificial intelligence. So my key message today is good internet regulation should support proactively support flourishing information ecosystems marked by a diversity of sources and languages and retaining the means of all people to be part of a network public’s participating in the creation sharing and consumption of information and knowledge. A key element of healthy information ecosystems is information integrity. By this I mean not just controlling or removing the most harmful elements of disinformation in online spaces, but proactively supporting the trustworthiness of information sources, ensuring that users have meaningful agency over information environments and control over their data, and working for more inclusive and diverse participation in online spaces. We work on these issues in numerous ways, such as our Civic Media Observatory, which is a research project to investigate and decode how people understand information and create knowledge in complex information ecosystems. We work with local researchers who have deep knowledge of local context and subtext of information and narrative to explain how information functions in their societies, rather than looking just at factuality or just at data flows. And the example we have there is the Unfreedom Monitor, which is a two-year, 20-country study in networked authoritarianism, which explores how states use both technology and regulation to restrict expression and augment those restrictions through information operations and propaganda. Another example of what this looks like, Global Voices for the last 15 years has run a project called Rising Voices, which is dedicated to supporting marginalized communities to participate and create online with networks of mutual support and learning. We focus on the ability of minority and indigenous language communities to create their own information spaces as they see fit. We work, for example, with Mayan language communities across the Americas to use the internet for language preservation and revitalization. These images come from our annual, this is from our 2024 Mayan Language Summit, which is now an annual event held in Mayan. Very unusual that an event is actually run in Mayan as opposed to being a secondary language to build networks of support for the use of Mayan in online contexts. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much, Ivan. And now, moving from a global organization, we are now zooming in on one regional use case. So, I am very glad to welcome Fabros Deibel here on stage for ITS Rio. So, ITS Rio, it’s the Institute of Technology Rio, that is really working to represent and strengthen Brazil’s and Latin America’s voice in global discussions and conversations on technology governance and digital rights. And it is also a member of the DPI Safeguards Initiative with Fabro himself also being in the Digital Public Goods Alliance. So, Fabro, the floor is yours.

Fabro Steibel: Nicole, thank you very much and thank you Wikimedia for the invitation. I start with a fact. DPIs emerge earlier and faster in the Global South than in the Global North. This is what research shows and most likely this is because out of necessity. In the Global South, we need better technologies to spread and equalize wealth and power. So, when you look at DPIs from the Global South, you ask them why they cannot be DPGs, why you cannot open the digital public infrastructures for good. And this is what we bring as a civil society member of Brazil, also as an academic, as a member of the network of centers, and as a member of the DPGA alliance. So, openness in Brazil is no coincidence. In the 90s, people from civil society and academia, they penetrate the government, they enter the government, and they start to foster open culture from inside the government. Outside the government, the culture keeps open and now we have a strong ecosystem. And we come from this ecosystem. So, what we are doing with DPGA and what do you think we can contribute to this debate today? Number one, we need very good green DPIs. We need open green DPIs. Brazil has CAR, C-A-R, which is a brilliant digital public infrastructure that can be even more brilliant if we bring the openness idea to it. It’s open data, but it’s not really a DPG yet. So, bringing this idea can have, as Wikimedia has a community around it that makes use of this data, make new… So, we have a lot of data, and we have a lot of data, and we can use it to do new surveillance of this data, and then we can fight deforestation or land rights. Number two, information integrity. We had Pegabot, Bot Catcher, that is an open algorithm that used to identify in Twitter the use of bots for this information. We collaborated with journalists and others having that. And we have a lot of data, and we have a lot of data, and we can use it to identify bots, and also, someone got our algorithm and made Atrapabot, a version of it using Mozilla language back to identify bots in Colombia. And lastly, the last case we have is on civic participation. So, we love to use technology to make new ways for people to enjoy deliberating together. So, we have a lot of data, and we have a lot of data, and we can use it to identify bots, and we can use it to make voting for people to deliberate in a more meaningful way other than a majority always wins. And the case studies we have shows that we have young football teams that are using Cucurdamos to select the coach. And we did this in partnership with Taiwan, who has a brilliant captain as well. And we tried it for the human aspect of the environment and it has to be, you know, you can now interact with it, and makes the environment better. You can now interact with it, and then becomes part of the more harmonious ecosystem. And we see now the perspective that can not only open technology, but open technology thinking about the human aspect as well.

Nicole Manger: I talked to leveraging DPGs, you know, across different themes and topics. And I will now pass it over to our expert panel with Costanza moderating, and they will pick up on these success stories, but also look more deeply into potential challenges like funding mechanisms, governing structures, and also data AI literacy. And also really be informed by other existing successful initiatives Amandeep mentioned before, the DPI safeguards initiative, the Digital Public Goods Alliance, and also the OSPO for Good conference that was just hosted here in New York in July. So with that, I hand it over to Costanza and our esteemed panelists. Thank you.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Let’s give a moment to our speakers to get seated. There’s, yes, a very, a very exciting panel. So we’re now going to move to the panel section of our event. I am honored to introduce some of the world-leading experts on the topic of digital public goods and digital governance. This past month and the months in front of us, as we all know, are critical times for the future of digital, global digital governance. And the global digital compact process, the pact of the future, WISE’s review, the high-level advisory board on artificial intelligence are all elements that are going to shape the future of our digital and physical world. One thing before we start that I want to say is this event is in many ways a follow-up event to a conversation that we started with Access Now during the CSW this year and before. So I just wanted to mention this and it’s great to be with Marianne today and with Access Now. But going to the panel, we wanted to have a moment here in the action day to reflect in particular on the transformative potential of digital public goods such as Wikipedia and others and digital public infrastructure and fostering sustainable development worldwide. Digital public goods, especially when grounded in robust digital commons, are essential for inclusive open, sustainable, and digital world and so we want to really encourage this multi-stakeholder partnership. As you can see, this panel has a really wide multi-stakeholder perspective and so we want to encourage this to promote and protect TPGs that truly are universal and reflect on how to best enable civil society and communities globally to have a voice in how technology is developed. So without further ado, I’ll pass it on to our panelists. Dr. Donahoe, I would like to start with you. Dr. Donahoe is the coordinator for digital freedom in the US Department of State’s Bureau of Cyberspace and Digital Policy. So Dr. Donahoe, digital public goods and DPIs have been such a central topic of discussion in the negotiations around the Global Digital Compact and more in general in the discussion about how to rethink global internet governance. I know you’ve been working about a model of right-respecting DPI which is achieved through universal safeguards. Can you tell us more about this and how multilateral and multi-stakeholder effort to protect TPGs and DPI should be shaped?

Eileen Donahoe: Great. First, let me congratulate the organizers here. This is a really remarkable event and it’s a very good reflection of where the DPG-DPI conversation is in the world and it’s very notable that this subject is at the top of the agenda at the high-level week at UNGA. I’m gonna make a comment that’s just based on observing what we’ve already heard. I think what we observed is that the multi-stakeholder community is way ahead and actually building digital public goods and global commons and that’s been going on for decades and you can use the case of Wikimedia, Wikipedia as an example. I think we’re here at UNGA which is a state-centric event. It’s a multilateral led body and I think it is really fair to say that states are generally behind and just catching on to these concepts and also that states are generally much more focused on DPIs and just trying to get ahead around that subject. So, But I will note that, so I’m gonna talk a little about what I see in the multilateral space that’s good and also what the U.S. is focused on and universal safeguards. Basically, here at the U.N. and in the Global Digital Compact, everybody’s really still focusing on definitions and concepts. And I think we’ve gravitated around several core features which include open interoperable standards and specifications that include delivery of public and private services at scale that are ideally and we will be fighting for rights respecting by design and protection of fundamental freedoms embedded in the design. But all of this is intended to drive toward inclusion, development, acceleration of the SDGs. And I just have to say it is really a giant change in the global conversation. This has been central to the G20 under the leadership of Brazil and India. It’s been part of the G7. It’s been in multiple agencies at the U.N. and that is brand new. That has never happened before. So this is really a new topic for states. What I will emphasize for the United States in particular, there are two key parts and it’s a combination of concern and excitement. The concern is that yes, DPGs and DPI hold tremendous promise to accelerate development. And obviously that is the core rationale that states are latching onto it. People are yearning to be part of the digital transformation. There is not equity around the world in that regard. And that is the driving motivation, animating energy here. But what we all have to be careful of is the risks that come with this digitization of infrastructure. And I’m sure we’re gonna be hearing. that from access, but we in the United States are also really focused on risk, and we have embraced the work of the Office of the Tech Envoy and UNDP on universal safeguards because we think that in every instance when DPIs, DPGs, digital commons are built, you have to be thinking about the impact on citizens’ rights. And the core of those concerns relates to privacy, and I will also say obviously equal protection, non-discrimination, and also the risk of exclusion from basic services if you do not build in safeguards and just embrace the technology itself. This is ultimately about bringing democratic values into the digital future around the world, and if we fail to bring safeguards with the actual access to the technology, we will be failing our citizens. The second part I want to mention that we’re really excited about, though, and this is what I do believe civil society has been onto for years, is that technology itself is now a vehicle for governance innovation. It is the way that the governing world can catch up to the pace of technological change, and I think it’s very exciting, this idea that the design, development, and deployment of the technology becomes the vehicle for spreading values and for governing in a way that protects citizens. And so, for me, that is why I’m really actually very excited about the opportunity of DPI, that it’s not just about inclusion in the digital transformation. It is about bringing values. by design in the technology. And last point I want to make is I really want to applaud the Universal Safeguards Initiative that last year at UNGA, OSET, Amandeep himself, Robert Opp from UNDP, they were on the stage launching the Universal Safeguards Initiative. That has been a year-long process. We have been part of it. Foundational principle number one is do no harm and it is about protecting human rights by design and we really applaud that. But the key idea here is no developing country and citizens in developing countries should never be asked to exchange their human rights. They do not trade off their human rights for inclusion in the digital ecosystem or for to be part of the digital transformation. That’s not okay. Development and human rights are not intention.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: They must go together so. Thank you, thank you Dr. Donahoe, such an important message. I love your conclusive message especially. Now I would like to move to Mr. Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi, Director General of NITDA Nigeria. So Mr. Abdullahi, digital public goods seem to be very important of course for social and economic development, also what we were just talking about, respectful of human rights. In your current position and as an expert on digital development, how do you see the role of government support for people to operate digital public goods and also to develop digital public goods? And before passing the floor to you, I just also want to mention Wikipedia has a very active community also of Wikimedians in Nigeria who work especially on multilingualism. So that’s also something that how do you think about those communities, not Wikipedia in particular, but in general communities that develop digital public goods in Nigeria?

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi: Okay, thank you very much. First and foremost, I want to thank the organizers for inviting me and also for giving Africa opportunity to be part of this conversation. Because for me, digital technology is dramatically transforming our world, offering immense potential benefits for the well-being and advancement of humanity, our societies and our planets. And it also holds the promise of accelerating the achievement of sustainable development goals. This can only be achieved through international cooperation that close all digital gaps. Because we recognize those digital gaps are really posing challenge to countries, in particular developing countries who have so many challenges to solve but with limited resources. So I think we should focus on closing that gap because imagine a person sitting next to you never clicked a link, never sent an email and never experienced social media. So almost half of the world population are excluded from this digital transformation, especially in Africa. So we cannot be talking about digital public good without ensuring every person is included. Because if that person is excluded, the technology will not consider that person when making its decisions. So that’s why we are quite fascinated about this conversation on digital public good. And also, like it mentioned before, this DPI-DPG conversation started from the global south, where people are excluded. And we can see the passion about bringing everyone to be part of it. And in Nigeria also, the government is focused on achieving that. We are starting with the digital public infrastructure. We are laying the foundation. We are putting the legal framework in place and also ensuring that we have a robust digital identity, a robust payment system and data exchange platform. So we have two and we are lacking the data exchange platform. platform. Now the government is working on coming up with standard and ensuring that we have that data exchange platform. That will enable us to build the digital public goods when we have the strong DPI stack in place. But now we are having some in silos, like you mentioned about Wikipedia. Wikipedia is a very good example in Nigeria of DPI, where people, the communities around are creating the platform. And that ensure democratization of access to services as well as quality information, fact-checking. Because we should learn from social media, how it started, where it is controlled by few, and also it is for profit. That’s why you can see a lot of things are happening without the control of the countries. Like we came from a way whereby most of these big techs, they don’t even listen to developing countries. They do things based on developed countries’ laws and mission, vision, and so on. And also that is really affecting us in the developing countries. Because for them it is about profit, it’s about what they will make. Few people decide what you see, what you buy, and what you can even think, or who you can friend, what you can believe. But with DPG, it will be open for societies, communities, and societies to look at information, to ensure you have the right information in place, and ensure things are fact-checked before being in public. So in Nigeria we have other smaller ones apart from the Wikipedia, which they are open, but in a siloes form. We cannot call them like a big DPGs. Like for example, we have a platform called Budget, where people can go and check information about government budget, and also do a fact-check to provide information for people in communities to look at budget line item, where the project is supposed to be executed, and check to ensure if it is executed or not. So this also can help for good governance, and it will make things to be open and transparent. So I think it’s good to support this kind of initiatives as well. We also have the National Health Information System project, which is driven by government to make health record available for decision makers, for health service providers, and so on, so that they can have access to health record and citizens can easily get services. So for governments, when you talk about DPGs, government has critical role to play, because it is about democratizing access, and also it is it is about breaking all the experience we have with social media, where few people are controlling everything. So we need to break that unaccountable control over public digital infrastructure. So the DPG will provide that. So government needs to provide the legal framework, because everything you do, you need to have laws that will guide it. You need to have framework and governance in place. So government has the convening power to bring the civil society, the private organizations, and everyone on board to discuss on the governance framework, to discuss on inclusive connectivity and also to intervene to connect the unconnected. So we have so many initiatives we are doing on that. Like in Nigeria, almost about more than 40% of the citizens are excluded. So government is promoting connectivity. We launched the 9,000 kilometers fiber optics project where government want to connect the remote societies and underserved communities. In addition to that also, we have other initiatives around digital literacy. Because it is not just about connecting, but people need to be digitally literate to navigate around the digital platform as well. So we do a lot in training people in developing our digital fluency in the country. We are working with other partners like Ministry of Education. We are developing digital literacy and skills curriculum to infuse it into our formal education so that people will learn from schools. We are also having other projects that will build talent. Because also you need to build your proficiency in building these digital offerings. Because no country will rely on another for its digital offerings. We need people within the country that can build the communities and services. So these are things government is doing in addition to the legal framework like we are working on enacting a law on digital economy and e-governance in Nigeria which can help in promoting digital public infrastructure as well as digital public good. But also for me the most important is this kind of conversation so that developing countries and African countries should have voice on what we are doing globally. Thank you.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Thank you so much. Thank you so much. Marianne, I would like to move on to you now to talk about especially how civil society is a critical stakeholder in global digital governance and for the development of digital public goods. Marianne Diaz-Hernandez is the YID campaigner at Access Now. She’s also a Venezuelan lawyer and digital rights activist and fiction writer. So as I mentioned earlier, this panel really is born as a second step of a conversation that we started together with Access Now a few months back. And so it’s great to continue this conversation and have so many more partners joining it as well. So I’m particularly interested to hear, how you think things have changed in them and what the role of civil society really should be as we move towards a new digital governance. You work extensively to make sure that all stakeholders have a perspective on digital public goods, including community development, digital public goods, and civil society agency. So what can you tell us about that?

Marianne Díaz Hernández: Thank you, Costanza. And thank you, everyone, for the privilege and the honor of your time and attention. Digital public goods, as well as the public infrastructure, which has also been mentioned a lot today on the upcoming days, I’m sure, have a profound need for community-led and community developed spaces where free speech and free assembly and civic life and dissent can thrive. And that requires the existence of spaces of total or partial anonymity and pseudonymity. And it is only possible to understand, design, and regulate these type of spaces through a multi-stakeholder lens, which is the only way that can ensure that the development and the governance of these digital commons remains transparent, inclusive, and responsive to a wide array of societal needs. DPGs are not only extremely important to society on their own standing, as the stories that were previously shared very clearly highlight, but also as the foundation for DPI, as Fabro was detailing, among others. Both of these assets need to be protected and nurtured to enable equitable access and to prevent monopolization or control by a select few. And this inclusivity ensures that the governance of digital spaces aligns with public interest and is the only way to protect them as open participatory environments that will encourage democratic engagement and free expression. And to go back to what Dr. Donahue was touching upon, when we focus on development above human rights, instead of understanding development as a tool to achieve human rights, we risk creating systems that have not been designed with human rights as a principle, but as an afterthought. We are then in need of a paradigm shift that allows us to understand that privacy, anonymity, free speech are not principles that are intentioned with the notion of development, but that have to be at the core of the design of the systems that are necessary to build the trust that the systems require in order to operate. There will be no development without these principles built into the systems that we create. So if we are to build and implement systems that are either created by the private sector, or by governments, or by any sort of hybrid model, the only way that we can make these systems accomplish what we want them to do, which is to support us in achieving the sustainable development goals, and ultimately achieving universal human rights, it is to build systems that are based in solid trust. And the construction of that trust cannot be taken by granted. It requires full and meaningful participation of society in a way that ensures and protects their agency in how to build, implement, and engage with technology. I believe then that civil society needs to work together and with other multi-stakeholders in articulating and putting forward the notion that what we require at this moment in time is a paradigm shift. We are not only speaking about enabling or defending human rights, or when these technologies are created, but about creating these technologies for a world that is built. with public in mind. Where public means built to benefit everyone by shared resources and managed by the community. And this does require a paradigm shift from a world view where resources are meant to be administered by specific actors in society. That model is not sustainable. It’s not participatory and it doesn’t help us in building strong democracies. Thank you.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Thank you so much, Marianne. And now that we are talking about civil society participation, I would like to move on to you, Jimmy. Jimmy is, Jimmy Wales is the co-founder of Wikipedia, so it’s really an honor to introduce you. So you have the unique experience of having created one of the largest, most used digital public goods in the world, which is really a unique kind of experience. What have you learned about how people are able to come together and create and govern projects that serve the public interest? And what advice can you give to all stakeholders and why is it important to do it today?

Jimmy Wales: Great, thank you. And thank you to the organizers and everyone for making this happen. It’s a great event. Yeah, so I think one of the key elements in terms of advice and thinking about this has already been mentioned a couple of times today and that is values. The original vision for Wikipedia was for all of us to imagine a world in which every single person on the planet is given free access to the sum of all human knowledge. And that’s what we’re doing at Wikipedia. And so every element of that is really, really important to us. When we say every single person on the planet, that means that we’re inherently global. We’re in many, many, many languages. And when I say the sum of all human knowledge, it means we care a lot about the quality of what we put out. It isn’t just sort of a giant random message. board we actually try to impart knowledge. This was 23 years ago when I started Wikipedia and it was just a handful of us typing away on the internet with very very limited software and very limited resources. But today Wikipedia is one of the top 10 most visited websites in the world. We have hundreds of millions of visitors every month from all around the world. We’re in over 300 languages, although of course some of those languages are quite small and just getting going. And for me that aspect of our work is one that I’m probably the most passionate about. I’m always very excited to think about the impact that we can have in bringing the ability for people to share knowledge in their own world, in their own community, in their own mother tongue. Some of the values that really carry us forward, we really care a lot about reliable sources. We have policies, for example, our well we have a lot of internal jargon. BLP policy, biography of living persons, which basically says if you see something negative in a biography it better have a source and if it doesn’t you should just remove it immediately and not just discuss what to do about it. Take it out and let’s discuss it then to say of course there’s going to be negative information. It needs to be really reliable and this can be contrasted with of course social media where people just write whatever they want and who knows maybe it’s fact-checked eventually or not. We try to be really really careful about that. One of our core community rules is no personal attacks. So obviously a lot of open spaces on the internet are just rife with personal attacks and that can be fine if it’s a political debate and discussion that often can be quite personal but it’s not right for us. We’re trying to write an encyclopedia. We’re a global movement in many many many different languages but everything in Wikipedia is locally written. Even as we move into an era of AI and I’m actually very excited about the really rapid increases that we’re seeing in the quality of machine translation and yet we have no concept or idea that we should just start wholesale translating Wikipedia into small languages because we know that it’s about that local cultural context. It’s about the local people. They will of course use these tools and it will… you know, finally accelerate that work so that we’re going to see really rapid growth in a lot of the languages that previously have been much more slower to grow. Really, Wikipedia, when we think about a digital public good, I think one of the paradigm cases that everyone should have in mind is Wikipedia. It’s a global resource used by almost everyone on the planet. We’re a non-profit organization. We’re community-built, community-driven. And when I see things in the Global Digital Compact that talk about protecting and supporting digital public goods, I’m very, very happy about this. Because too often, when policymakers are thinking about how to make decisions on public policy and the Internet, they’re really thinking about top-down social media platforms that I always say they run like feudal estates. All the people using it are like the serfs, but the master makes the rules from top down. Whereas we’re a community. We’re a bunch of people. All the rules of Wikipedia are made by the community. All of the decisions are made out in the community. The Wikimedia Foundation doesn’t engage in sort of constant moderation. Boy, the number of times people have complained to me, Wikipedia says this, Jimmy Wales is a communist. I’m like, well, first, I’m not a communist, and second, I didn’t write it. And there’s the sources, and there’s actually a debate, and you can get involved, and let’s have a discourse about human knowledge. So my call to action, really, for everyone is to, and to governments in particular, is let’s think about, as we’re doing public policy, let’s really begin to adopt what I would call the Wikipedia test. If you’re about to pass some rule, think about, is this going to wreck Wikipedia? And if it is, it might not be a great rule. And that might not be, you might want to step back and say, hold on a second, we do need to, oh, yes, clap, please, yes. We need to protect these open communities. So, thank you.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Thank you so much. First one was for the Wikipedia test. Yes, thank you so much. And now I’d like to move to Professor Gasser, who is Professor of Public Policy Governance and Innovative Technology at the Technical University of Munich, TUM, who has been a great partner also in organizing this event, and also the Dean of the TUM School of Social Sciences. So, Professor Gasser, I’d like to move to you as an expert scholar representing academia and go back to the idea of digital commons as a necessary condition for the development of digital public goods. So, academia is also a big contributor to the digital commons. How do you see its role in this context and in improving shared access to knowledge and digital public goods in general?

Urs Gasser: Wonderful. Thank you so much for inviting also perspectives from academia. And, of course, it’s a great honor to be on this panel. And I would like to start right where Jimmy started as well with values. I think if you look at the values of academia, and Fabro set the stage beautifully, you see how this idea of public interest mission of academic organizations and the public interest-driven mindset of academics and academic community make academia a natural ally to the cause of digital public goods and the commons. So, I see a lot of resemblance and echoes to what you just described. I think Fabro already pointed out and alluded to the different functions that academic institutions and, more importantly, also the human beings in academia can play as we aim for more robust commons ecosystems. I just would like to maybe highlight three such roles. The first one is academia, academic networks and individuals as trusted creators of knowledge. If you look back over the past couple of decades, academics have been key contributors to building the digital commons by sharing data and knowledge about the world and doing so through open access publishing, among other things. The second role I would like to highlight is academia as an incubator and convener. Academic communities and values have been a key driver in incubating and launching digital public infrastructures. Just think back about the origins of the internet and the world wide web that were shaped by academic values and communities. But also as we’ve heard examples today, I hope I don’t reveal secrets, but global voices or creative commons and many more projects were closely linked to academic institutions and communities when they started. So you see the role of academia here again as we think about the creation of digital public infrastructures. And let me emphasize one point, what the beauty of it is, is that it’s happening in a distributed way, in a collaborative spirit, and that’s very powerful. The third role I would like to briefly highlight is that academia can not only contribute in these different forms substantively to the formation of digital commons and digital public goods. It can also study and assess what we can learn about digital commons as we go forward, about the society. societal impact about the relevance, we can assess whether we pass the Wikipedia test when new policies are rolled out. So academia can be a learning partner in our endeavors, can help to inform policymaking and good governance. So you see all together, and I just highlighted three rules, you see how academia should actually join the calls around this table and stakeholders for strong principles, policies, and practices that embrace the wealth of distributed academic networks so that together with the other stakeholders we can double down on our commitment to build strong and robust commons ecosystems for the future. Thank you very much.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Thank you so much, and thank you to all of the panelists. I now I’m gonna move to the closing section of this event because we are already running a little over time, but thank you so much for for your participation. And now I would like to call back my co-moderator, Nicole. And for the closing remarks, Mr. Emran Mian, the Director General for Digital and Telecoms in the UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology. Yes, please, Dr. Emran Mian, you have the floor.

Emran Mian: Thank you very much. Conscious of time, I’ll be very brief. Thank you very much for organizing this event. It’s been a real pleasure to listen to stakeholders across this community talk about DPGs and their contributions to them. There’s just two things I wanted to bring out as reflections. One is focusing on digital skills and the skills that people need both to create DPGs but also to enjoy DPGs. And this is a shared responsibility, I think, across the stakeholder community, businesses, civil society, and government. And the UK government, for our part, we’re very pleased of the way in which we’re able to work with partners in countries such as Indonesia, Kenya, and Nigeria to help people to acquire these digital skills. And there’s a lot more to do on that front. And then the second thing I just wanted to draw out was trust and safety. To continue to enjoy DPGs and for DPGs to continue to be created, people need to trust the digital technologies that they are using, and they need to be safe when they’re doing so. And again, for our part as a UK government, we’ve been really pleased to be part of a conversation on AI safety and to have initiated that at Bletchley Park with a UK-hosted safety summit last year. And it’s great to see the continuance of that in all kinds of ways, including a summit in Seoul earlier this year. And earlier this morning we were hearing from the French about their plans for an AI action summit early next year. And I know this is a real source of concern. sort of attention and action for the UN as well. I’ll stop there. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much. And I will now introduce Dr. Anna Christmann. She has multiple heads in innovation technology in the German ecosystem, as member of parliament, amongst others. I guess most people here in New York know her from her role in the Secretary General’s high-level advisory body on AI. Anna, the floor is yours.

Anna Christmann: Yeah, thank you so much. I’m very happy to be part of this panel. And just mentioning first that I’m very inspired by the panels that we just had. And I think it’s an important signal that this panel takes place today in the context of the Global Digital Compact. I think that is just a very important signal of the relevance of digital common goods for the society on a global scale and all the things that we heard about leaving no one behind, strengthening the multi-stakeholder approach, access for everyone and everywhere. I think these are just very important principles and it’s good that they are here in New York in the context of the summit of the future. And then maybe two very concrete points to the questions. What is the call to action that we heard for the future now, building on what we heard today. It was all the great examples also, of course, what we have already as common global digital comments. And I would say one is to really be active now in building this international ecosystem of the multi-stakeholder approach of all the people who are involved already in the open source community and everything around, but also bringing all the other stakeholders into this field. And we heard states might not be the leaders so far, but bringing them as very active actors into this ecosystem. So I would invite us all to really start new hands on initiatives and. projects to co-design frontier open data and also AI solutions and I think there are also links to the work that we did at the high-level advisory body and artificial intelligence at the UN and we have the report which is a lot about capacity building and openness and I think that really links a lot to what we heard today. And of course they are crucial is bringing the people together have the ecosystem have also the investments and the multi-stakeholder governance I think that would be important principles for that. And then maybe mentioning also one very concrete thing that we can do from here on is bringing as a question of DPGs across policy fields and there of course in the UN context as a question of climate policy is one obvious one so bringing this idea and discussions that we had today also to the context of the COP I think would be very valuable as well and I think if everyone is active like we are also in Germany just to mention this very short with with also different initiatives around digital sovereignty data institutes as we are just building if we get this ecosystem on the global scale I think there’s lots to win for all of us. Thank you.

Nicole Manger: Thank you so much and so I guess in light of the timing Constanze and I will just wrap up. So it was our intention here today to convene high-level speakers from UN member states the United Nations and especially academia and civil society really to discuss best practices and a common understanding and I guess just linking to what Dr. Anna Christmann has said we really invite all of you to join our conversations to kick-start projects to really enable this global solutions architects, ecosystem on developing DPGs together.

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia: Yes, yes, thank you. Thank you everyone, it was a fantastic conversation that I am sure will lead to many more conversations. So to be continued, thank you everyone for participating.

A

Amandeep Gill

Speech speed

116 words per minute

Speech length

579 words

Speech time

297 seconds

DPGs and DPI are essential for inclusive, sustainable digital transformation

Explanation

Amandeep Gill emphasizes that digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) are vital for an equitable and sustainable digital future. He argues that these resources are key to democratizing access to knowledge and technological resources.

Evidence

The Global Digital Compact embeds an international commitment to global digital commons through digital public goods and digital public infrastructure.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for global development

Agreed with

Fabro Steibel

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Agreed on

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

The Global Digital Compact provides a new foundation for DPG/DPI action

Explanation

Gill highlights that the Global Digital Compact, as part of the Pact for the Future, establishes a new basis for more meaningful action in the area of digital public goods and infrastructure. This document represents a significant step forward in international commitment to these resources.

Evidence

The Global Digital Compact embeds an international commitment to global digital commons through digital public goods and digital public infrastructure.

Major Discussion Point

The future of DPGs and digital governance

F

Fabro Steibel

Speech speed

194 words per minute

Speech length

552 words

Speech time

170 seconds

DPGs emerge faster in the Global South out of necessity

Explanation

Fabro Steibel points out that digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) tend to develop more quickly in the Global South due to pressing needs. He suggests that this is because these technologies are essential for spreading and equalizing wealth and power in these regions.

Evidence

Examples of DPGs from Brazil, such as CAR (rural environmental registry) and Pegabot (bot detection tool).

Major Discussion Point

The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for global development

Agreed with

Amandeep Gill

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Agreed on

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

A

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Speech speed

127 words per minute

Speech length

704 words

Speech time

330 seconds

DPGs and DPI are critical for closing the digital divide

Explanation

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu emphasizes the importance of digital public goods and infrastructure in reducing inequalities and promoting digital inclusion. She argues that these resources are essential for ensuring that technology benefits all people, particularly marginalized communities.

Evidence

Mexico’s efforts to develop inclusive digital infrastructure and tools for small and medium enterprises.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for global development

Agreed with

Amandeep Gill

Fabro Steibel

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Agreed on

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

E

Eileen Donahoe

Speech speed

130 words per minute

Speech length

829 words

Speech time

382 seconds

DPGs and DPI need universal safeguards to protect human rights

Explanation

Eileen Donahoe argues for the importance of incorporating universal safeguards into digital public goods and infrastructure to protect human rights. She emphasizes that development and human rights should not be seen as conflicting goals, but rather as complementary.

Evidence

The Universal Safeguards Initiative launched by the Office of the Tech Envoy and UNDP.

Major Discussion Point

The importance of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) for global development

Need to balance development goals with protecting human rights

Explanation

Donahoe stresses the importance of integrating human rights protections into the design and development of digital public goods and infrastructure. She argues that development should not come at the expense of human rights, but rather should be a tool to achieve them.

Evidence

The Universal Safeguards Initiative with its foundational principle of ‘do no harm’.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and considerations in developing DPGs

K

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Speech speed

112 words per minute

Speech length

1070 words

Speech time

572 seconds

Governments need to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs

Explanation

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi emphasizes the critical role of governments in creating an enabling environment for digital public goods. He argues that governments must establish legal frameworks and ensure connectivity to support the development and use of DPGs.

Evidence

Nigeria’s initiatives to promote connectivity, including a 9,000 km fiber optics project and digital literacy programs.

Major Discussion Point

The role of different stakeholders in developing and governing DPGs

Agreed with

Amandeep Gill

Fabro Steibel

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Agreed on

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

Disagreed with

Jimmy Wales

Disagreed on

Role of government in DPG development

M

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Speech speed

143 words per minute

Speech length

573 words

Speech time

239 seconds

Civil society ensures DPGs remain transparent, inclusive and responsive to societal needs

Explanation

Marianne Díaz Hernández argues that civil society plays a crucial role in ensuring that digital public goods serve the public interest. She emphasizes the importance of community-led spaces and multi-stakeholder governance in creating transparent and inclusive digital commons.

Major Discussion Point

The role of different stakeholders in developing and governing DPGs

Agreed with

Urs Gasser

Jimmy Wales

Agreed on

Multi-stakeholder approach in DPG development and governance

Need for a paradigm shift to build technologies with the public in mind

Explanation

Díaz Hernández calls for a fundamental change in how we approach technology development. She argues for creating technologies that are built with the public interest as a core principle, rather than as an afterthought.

Major Discussion Point

The future of DPGs and digital governance

U

Urs Gasser

Speech speed

126 words per minute

Speech length

490 words

Speech time

232 seconds

Academia serves as creators, incubators and assessors of DPGs

Explanation

Urs Gasser highlights the multifaceted role of academia in the development of digital public goods. He argues that academic institutions and individuals contribute as trusted creators of knowledge, incubators of new projects, and assessors of the societal impact of DPGs.

Evidence

Examples of academic contributions to the digital commons, such as open access publishing and the incubation of projects like Global Voices and Creative Commons.

Major Discussion Point

The role of different stakeholders in developing and governing DPGs

Agreed with

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Jimmy Wales

Agreed on

Multi-stakeholder approach in DPG development and governance

J

Jimmy Wales

Speech speed

166 words per minute

Speech length

911 words

Speech time

327 seconds

Community-driven governance is key for successful DPGs like Wikipedia

Explanation

Jimmy Wales emphasizes the importance of community-driven governance in the success of digital public goods like Wikipedia. He argues that allowing the community to make rules and decisions leads to a more robust and responsive platform.

Evidence

Wikipedia’s community-driven policies and decision-making processes.

Major Discussion Point

The role of different stakeholders in developing and governing DPGs

Agreed with

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Urs Gasser

Agreed on

Multi-stakeholder approach in DPG development and governance

Disagreed with

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Disagreed on

Role of government in DPG development

E

Emran Mian

Speech speed

171 words per minute

Speech length

289 words

Speech time

101 seconds

Importance of digital skills and trust/safety for DPG adoption

Explanation

Emran Mian highlights the critical role of digital skills and trust in the adoption of digital public goods. He argues that people need both the skills to use DPGs and the confidence that these technologies are safe and trustworthy.

Evidence

UK government’s work with partners in countries like Indonesia, Kenya, and Nigeria to help people acquire digital skills.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and considerations in developing DPGs

N

Nicole Manger

Speech speed

120 words per minute

Speech length

889 words

Speech time

442 seconds

DPGs require robust funding mechanisms and data/AI literacy

Explanation

Nicole Manger points out the need for strong funding mechanisms to support the development of digital public goods. She also emphasizes the importance of data and AI literacy in leveraging DPGs effectively.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and considerations in developing DPGs

R

Rebecca MacKinnon

Speech speed

130 words per minute

Speech length

802 words

Speech time

368 seconds

Multilingualism and local context are crucial for global DPGs

Explanation

Rebecca MacKinnon emphasizes the importance of multilingualism and local context in the development of global digital public goods. She argues that DPGs should reflect the linguistic and cultural diversity of their users to be truly inclusive and effective.

Evidence

Examples of Wikipedia versions in various languages, including indigenous languages like Waiyu.

Major Discussion Point

Challenges and considerations in developing DPGs

A

Anna Christmann

Speech speed

148 words per minute

Speech length

465 words

Speech time

187 seconds

Importance of bringing DPG discussions to other policy areas like climate

Explanation

Anna Christmann suggests expanding the discussion of digital public goods to other policy areas, particularly climate policy. She argues that integrating DPG concepts into broader policy discussions can enhance their impact and relevance.

Major Discussion Point

The future of DPGs and digital governance

Call for new hands-on initiatives to co-design frontier open data and AI solutions

Explanation

Christmann calls for practical initiatives to collaboratively design cutting-edge open data and AI solutions. She emphasizes the importance of multi-stakeholder involvement in these efforts to ensure their effectiveness and inclusivity.

Major Discussion Point

The future of DPGs and digital governance

Agreements

Agreement Points

Importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development

Speakers

Amandeep Gill

Fabro Steibel

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Arguments

DPGs and DPI are essential for inclusive, sustainable digital transformation

DPGs emerge faster in the Global South out of necessity

DPGs and DPI are critical for closing the digital divide

Governments need to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs

Summary

Multiple speakers emphasized the crucial role of digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) in promoting inclusive development, particularly in the Global South.

Multi-stakeholder approach in DPG development and governance

Speakers

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Urs Gasser

Jimmy Wales

Arguments

Civil society ensures DPGs remain transparent, inclusive and responsive to societal needs

Academia serves as creators, incubators and assessors of DPGs

Community-driven governance is key for successful DPGs like Wikipedia

Summary

Speakers agreed on the importance of involving multiple stakeholders, including civil society, academia, and community members, in the development and governance of DPGs.

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the need to prioritize human rights and public interest in the development of digital technologies and infrastructure.

Speakers

Eileen Donahoe

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Arguments

DPGs and DPI need universal safeguards to protect human rights

Need for a paradigm shift to build technologies with the public in mind

Unexpected Consensus

Global South leadership in DPG development

Speakers

Fabro Steibel

Alicia Buenrostro Massieu

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Arguments

DPGs emerge faster in the Global South out of necessity

DPGs and DPI are critical for closing the digital divide

Governments need to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs

Explanation

There was an unexpected consensus on the Global South’s leadership and innovation in DPG development, challenging the common perception of technological advancement being primarily driven by the Global North.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of agreement included the importance of DPGs and DPI for inclusive development, the need for multi-stakeholder involvement in DPG development and governance, and the recognition of human rights and public interest in digital technologies.

Consensus level

There was a high level of consensus among speakers on the fundamental importance and potential of DPGs and DPI. This strong agreement suggests a solid foundation for future collaborative efforts in developing and implementing DPGs globally, particularly in addressing development challenges in the Global South.

Disagreements

Disagreement Points

Role of government in DPG development

Speakers

Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi

Jimmy Wales

Arguments

Governments need to provide legal frameworks and connectivity for DPGs

Community-driven governance is key for successful DPGs like Wikipedia

Summary

While Abdullahi emphasizes the critical role of governments in creating an enabling environment for DPGs, Wales stresses the importance of community-driven governance. This represents a difference in perspective on the primary drivers of successful DPG development.

Overall Assessment

Summary

The main areas of disagreement revolve around the role of different stakeholders in DPG development and governance, as well as the approach to integrating human rights and public interest into DPG design.

Disagreement level

The level of disagreement among the speakers is relatively low. Most speakers agree on the importance of DPGs for global development and the need for inclusive, rights-respecting approaches. The differences mainly lie in the emphasis placed on various stakeholders’ roles and the specific strategies for implementation. These nuanced disagreements can actually be beneficial for developing a comprehensive approach to DPG development and governance, as they highlight different perspectives that need to be considered.

Partial Agreements

Partial Agreements

Both speakers agree on the importance of protecting human rights in the development of DPGs, but they differ in their approach. Donahoe advocates for universal safeguards, while Díaz Hernández calls for a more fundamental paradigm shift in how technologies are developed.

Speakers

Eileen Donahoe

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Arguments

DPGs and DPI need universal safeguards to protect human rights

Need for a paradigm shift to build technologies with the public in mind

Similar Viewpoints

Both speakers emphasized the need to prioritize human rights and public interest in the development of digital technologies and infrastructure.

Speakers

Eileen Donahoe

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Arguments

DPGs and DPI need universal safeguards to protect human rights

Need for a paradigm shift to build technologies with the public in mind

Takeaways

Key Takeaways

Digital public goods (DPGs) and digital public infrastructure (DPI) are essential for inclusive, sustainable global digital transformation

DPGs and DPI require multi-stakeholder collaboration between governments, civil society, academia, and communities

Universal safeguards and human rights protections must be built into DPGs and DPI by design

Community-driven governance and local context are crucial for successful global DPGs like Wikipedia

The Global Digital Compact provides a new foundation for international action on DPGs and DPI

Resolutions and Action Items

Incorporate the ‘Wikipedia test’ when developing digital policies to ensure they don’t harm open community projects

Bring DPG discussions to other policy areas like climate change and COP negotiations

Start new hands-on initiatives to co-design frontier open data and AI solutions as DPGs

Build a global ecosystem and multi-stakeholder governance structures for DPGs

Unresolved Issues

How to balance rapid development of DPGs with ensuring robust human rights protections

Sustainable funding mechanisms for DPGs and open-source projects

How to improve data and AI literacy to enable wider participation in DPG development

Addressing potential risks and misuse of DPGs and open data

Suggested Compromises

Develop universal safeguards for DPIs that protect rights while enabling development

Use AI and machine translation to accelerate growth of smaller language Wikipedias while maintaining local community involvement

Thought Provoking Comments

Well-governed commons are the foundations of human civilization. Digital is no exception, and today more than ever digital commons are vital to our interconnected world.

Speaker

Amandeep Gill

Reason

This comment frames digital commons as a fundamental part of modern civilization, elevating their importance.

Impact

It set the tone for the discussion by emphasizing the critical nature of digital commons in our interconnected world, encouraging participants to consider their broad societal impact.

DPIs emerge earlier and faster in the Global South than in the Global North. This is what research shows and most likely this is because out of necessity. In the Global South, we need better technologies to spread and equalize wealth and power.

Speaker

Fabro Steibel

Reason

This insight challenges the common assumption that technological innovation primarily comes from the Global North.

Impact

It shifted the conversation to consider the unique needs and contributions of the Global South in developing digital public infrastructure, broadening the global perspective of the discussion.

When we focus on development above human rights, instead of understanding development as a tool to achieve human rights, we risk creating systems that have not been designed with human rights as a principle, but as an afterthought.

Speaker

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Reason

This comment highlights a crucial tension between development and human rights in the context of digital technologies.

Impact

It deepened the conversation by emphasizing the need to prioritize human rights in the design and implementation of digital systems, encouraging a more nuanced approach to development.

If you’re about to pass some rule, think about, is this going to wreck Wikipedia? And if it is, it might not be a great rule.

Speaker

Jimmy Wales

Reason

This ‘Wikipedia test’ provides a simple yet powerful heuristic for evaluating digital policies.

Impact

It introduced a practical framework for policymakers to consider the impact of regulations on open, community-driven digital public goods, potentially influencing future policy discussions.

Academia can not only contribute in these different forms substantively to the formation of digital commons and digital public goods. It can also study and assess what we can learn about digital commons as we go forward, about the societal impact about the relevance, we can assess whether we pass the Wikipedia test when new policies are rolled out.

Speaker

Urs Gasser

Reason

This comment highlights the multifaceted role of academia in both creating and studying digital commons.

Impact

It expanded the discussion to include the importance of ongoing research and assessment in the development and governance of digital public goods, emphasizing a learning-oriented approach.

Overall Assessment

These key comments shaped the discussion by broadening its scope from a primarily Western and government-centric view to a more global, multi-stakeholder perspective. They emphasized the critical importance of digital commons in modern society, highlighted the unique contributions of the Global South, stressed the need to prioritize human rights in technological development, introduced practical frameworks for policy evaluation, and underscored the role of academia in both creating and studying digital public goods. This resulted in a rich, nuanced conversation that considered the complex interplay between technology, policy, human rights, and global development in the context of digital public goods.

Follow-up Questions

How can we ensure digital public goods and infrastructure are designed with human rights as a core principle rather than an afterthought?

Speaker

Marianne Díaz Hernández

Explanation

This is important to ensure development of digital systems aligns with human rights and builds necessary trust.

How can we better enable civil society and communities globally to have a voice in how technology is developed?

Speaker

Costanza Sciubba Caniglia

Explanation

This is crucial for ensuring digital public goods reflect diverse needs and perspectives.

How can we apply the ‘Wikipedia test’ when developing new internet regulations and policies?

Speaker

Jimmy Wales

Explanation

This approach could help protect open communities and digital public goods when crafting new rules.

How can we strengthen the multi-stakeholder ecosystem for developing digital public goods?

Speaker

Anna Christmann

Explanation

Building a robust ecosystem with diverse stakeholders is key for advancing digital public goods.

How can we integrate digital public goods into climate policy discussions, such as at COP?

Speaker

Anna Christmann

Explanation

Bringing digital public goods into other policy areas could expand their impact and application.

How can we improve digital skills both for creating and using digital public goods?

Speaker

Emran Mian

Explanation

Enhancing digital skills is crucial for the development and adoption of digital public goods.

How can we ensure trust and safety in the creation and use of digital public goods?

Speaker

Emran Mian

Explanation

Trust and safety are fundamental for the continued creation and enjoyment of digital public goods.

Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed.