EU advances with digital euro project focusing on privacy

The Eurosystem, including the European Central Bank (ECB) and national central banks of the EU area, is advancing the digital euro project aimed to modernize central bank money. Following an initial investigation phase launched in 2021, the ECB’s Governing Council approved a two-year preparation phase starting 18 October 2023 and concluding by 31 October 2025. This phase will finalise the digital euro rulebook, select potential platform and infrastructure providers, and conduct further testing, particularly its offline functionality.

A cornerstone of the digital euro project is “privacy by design” approach. Technological measures like pseudonymisation, hashing, and encryption will ensure that online transactions remain unlinked to specific individuals. Payment service providers will access only the necessary transaction data for EU law compliance, with user consent required for any additional commercial uses. The digital euro is also designed for offline use, allowing payments without an internet connection, akin to cash transactions. This offline functionality will enhance privacy and usability in areas with limited network coverage or during power outages.

Legislative and stakeholder engagement continues in parallel, with the European Parliament and Council of the European Union working on the legislative framework proposed in 2023. Stakeholder involvement ensures the digital euro meets high standards of quality, security, and usability. Fraud prevention remains a priority, with ongoing assessments indicating that current technologies can effectively detect and prevent fraud using pseudonymised information.

By the end of 2025, the ECB will decide whether to proceed further with the digital euro, contingent on the legislative process completion.

2023 BIS survey on central bank digital currencies

Survey reveals that 94% of central banks are actively exploring Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs), with each institution progressing at its own pace and considering various design features.
In 2023, there has been a significant increase in experiments and pilots related to wholesale CBDCs, particularly in advanced economies, though emerging markets and developing economies have also ramped up their efforts. The likelihood of central banks issuing a wholesale CBDC in the next six years now surpasses that of issuing retail CBDCs.

Key features under consideration include interoperability and programmability for wholesale CBDCs, and holding limits, interoperability, offline options, and zero remuneration for retail CBDCs.

Worldcoin allowed to resume operations in Kenya after year-long probe

Worldcoin, a cryptocurrency startup co-founded by OpenAI’s Sam Altman, has been permitted to resume its iris-scanning operations in Kenya after a year-long investigation into privacy and regulatory concerns was concluded. The Kenyan Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) officially closed its probe, citing no further police action as necessary. However, Worldcoin must now register its business in Kenya, secure requisite licences, and vet its vendors to maintain operations.

Worldcoin’s activities had been suspended nearly a year ago due to compliance issues with Kenyan security, financial services, and data protection laws. A parliamentary committee recommended shutting down the company altogether, citing violations of the Computer Misuse and Cybercrimes Act, and labelling its activities as potential espionage. It was also found that Worldcoin and its parent entity, Tools for Humanity, were unregistered in Kenya, and had not received approval to use the Orbs, considered telecommunications equipment.

Thomas Scott, Chief Legal Officer of Tools for Humanity, expressed gratitude for the fair investigation and said this is merely a new beginning. He highlighted the company’s commitment to working with Kenyan authorities to advance Worldcoin’s mission and create economic opportunities. While Worldcoin has resolved its immediate regulatory hurdles in Kenya, it continues to face significant scrutiny in other countries, including ongoing investigations in Germany, Spain, Portugal, and Italy.

The situation has highlighted challenges in regulating new technologies, particularly around privacy and compliance. In response, Kenya is developing a regulatory framework for virtual assets, aiming to provide clearer guidelines for crypto startups like Worldcoin. The outcome could pave the way for more structured compliance pathways amid the rapid advancements in digital finance and identity systems.

Italy set to introduce tough new regulations for cryptocurrency market

Italy is set to strengthen its surveillance of crypto assets with new measures, including hefty fines for market manipulation, according to a draft decree reviewed by Reuters. The decree, expected to be approved by the cabinet, imposes fines ranging from 5,000 to 5 million euros for offences such as insider trading and unlawful disclosure of inside information.

The legal move matches with warnings from central banks and international bodies about the risks cryptocurrencies pose to financial stability and their potential for fraud. The plan designates Italy’s central bank and market watchdog, Consob, as the authorities responsible for overseeing cryptocurrency activities to maintain financial stability and orderly market functioning.

Why does it matter?

Cryptocurrencies allow global money transfers outside the traditional financial system, with transactions recorded on a blockchain where users are identified only by wallet addresses. However, the anonymity and decentralisation have raised concerns about their misuse, prompting Italy to implement stricter controls.

Binance fined $2.25 million by India for violations

India’s Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) has fined Binance, the world’s largest crypto exchange, 188.2 million rupees ($2.25 million) for breaching local anti-money laundering regulations. The country mandates that virtual digital asset service providers, including crypto exchanges, must register with the FIU and adhere to its rules. Binance recently registered with the FIU in May to resume operations but has not yet commented on the fine.

Earlier, Binance received a show-cause notice from the FIU and eight other offshore exchanges for non-compliance. In response, the FIU requested that the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology block access to these exchanges. In contrast, KuCoin, another crypto exchange, registered with the FIU in March and faced a significantly more minor penalty of 3.45 million rupees.

Why does it matter?

The legal sanction isn’t Binance’s only run-in with regulatory bodies, as Canada fined the exchange $4.38 million in May for similar violations. Additionally, Binance’s former CEO, Changpeng Zhao, was sentenced to four months in prison in the US for violating anti-money laundering laws.

New York attorney general recovers $50 million defrauded from Gemini Earn crypto investors

In a significant win for cryptocurrency investors, New York Attorney General Letitia James announced the recovery of $50 million defrauded from participants in Gemini Earn, a high-yield cryptocurrency investment program. That is part of a broader effort to address fraud and protect investors in the crypto market. Gemini Earn, a program launched by the Winklevoss twinsGemini Trust Company, allowed users to lend their digital assets in exchange for interest. However, the program faced scrutiny when it was revealed that the funds were not being used as advertised. Instead of being securely invested, the funds were mismanaged, leading to significant financial losses for many investors.

The New York Attorney General’s office conducted an investigation, uncovering evidence of fraudulent activity and misrepresentation. Attorney General James emphasised the importance of holding companies accountable for their promises, particularly in the volatile and often opaque cryptocurrency sector. “The recovery sends a clear message that we will not tolerate deceit and fraud in any form, and we will use all available tools to protect New York investors,” said James. Gemini will provide full recoveries to more than 230,000 Earn investors, including 29,000 in New York, and agreed to a ban on operating crypto lending programs in the state.

“Gemini marketed its Earn program as a way for investors to grow their money, but actually lied and locked investors out of their accounts,” James said. “Today’s settlement will make defrauded investors whole.” The funds will be accessible within seven days, Gemini told investors on Friday. “With this final distribution, Earn users will have received 100% of the assets owed to them,” it said.  Gemini Earn promised investors attractive returns on their cryptocurrency holdings, capitalising on the growing interest in decentralized finance (DeFi). However, the program’s collapse highlighted the risks associated with high-yield crypto investments, particularly when transparency and proper regulatory oversight are lacking.

The investigation revealed that Gemini Earn’s operators misled investors about the safety and use of their funds. Rather than being securely invested, the assets were exposed to high-risk ventures without proper disclosure, resulting in substantial losses when these ventures failed.

Gemini Earn promised high interest rates to investors who lent crypto assets such as bitcoin to Genesis, a unit of Digital Currency Group, with Gemini taking fees that could exceed 4%. More than $1 billion was frozen when Genesis halted redemptions in November 2022, shortly after the collapse of Sam Bankman-Fried’s FTX cryptocurrency exchange. Genesis filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy two months later.

Why does it matter?

Gemini received a fine of $37 million in February for unsafe and unsound practices in a settlement with the New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) .The payout is in addition to James’ related $2 billion settlement with crypto lender Genesis Global Capital, which was announced on May 20. Gemini also agreed to cooperate in James’ October fraud lawsuit against Digital Currency Group and its chief executive, Barry Silbert. 

The recovery of funds was achieved through a combination of asset seizures and financial settlements. That included cooperation from various cryptocurrency exchanges and custodians who held the misappropriated assets. The Attorney General’s office worked closely with these entities to trace and reclaim the funds. The recovery has been met with mixed reactions. Investors who suffered losses expressed relief and gratitude for the Attorney General’s efforts. “It’s a step towards justice,” said one affected investor. “I hope this sets a precedent for greater accountability in the crypto industry.” On the other hand, some industry analysts argue that the case underscores the need for clearer regulations and better investor education.

Trump calls for all remaining Bitcoin to be mined in the US

Former US President Donald Trump has made a declaration, stating that he wants all remaining Bitcoin to be mined within the United States. The announcement, made on June 12, 2024, is the latest in a series of controversial statements from Trump, who has previously expressed skepticism about cryptocurrencies.

Trump’s proclamation comes at a time when Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are facing increased scrutiny from governments and regulatory bodies worldwide. The former president emphasised the need for the US to control Bitcoin mining operations to ensure the country’s dominance in the digital currency market and to safeguard national security.

Bitcoin mining is the process by which new bitcoins are created and transactions are verified on the blockchain. Miners use powerful computers to solve complex mathematical problems, which, in turn, secure the network and validate transactions. That process requires significant computational power and energy resources. Currently, the majority of Bitcoin mining operations are concentrated in countries like China, Russia, and Kazakhstan, where electricity is relatively cheap. However, the geopolitical tensions and concerns over the environmental impact of Bitcoin mining have prompted calls for a shift in mining operations to more stable and regulated regions.

The cryptocurrency community has had mixed reactions to Trump’s statement. Some industry leaders welcome the idea of increasing Bitcoin mining operations in the US, citing the potential benefits of regulatory clarity and increased investment in renewable energy sources. They argue that the US has the technological expertise and infrastructure to support large-scale mining operations sustainably. However, others express concern over the potential for increased government intervention and regulation in the cryptocurrency space. They fear that such measures could stifle innovation and contradict the decentralized spirit of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies.

Why does it matter?

Trump’s rationale for wanting Bitcoin mining to be relocated to the US centers around three main points – economic opportunity, national security, and technological leadership.

  • Economic Opportunity: Trump argues that bringing Bitcoin mining to the US would create jobs and stimulate economic growth in the tech and energy sectors. By harnessing the country’s technological infrastructure and renewable energy sources, he believes the US could become a global leader in cryptocurrency mining.
  •  National Security: By controlling Bitcoin mining operations, Trump asserts that the US can prevent foreign adversaries from leveraging cryptocurrencies for illicit activities, such as money laundering and financing terrorism. He also contends that having a significant portion of the global Bitcoin supply mined domestically would enhance the country’s financial stability.
  • Technological Leadership: Trump envisions the US leading the world in blockchain technology and digital currencies. By fostering a robust Bitcoin mining industry, he believes the country can spur innovation and set global standards for cryptocurrency regulation and adoption.

Trump positions himself as ‘crypto president’ at San Francisco fundraiser

At a San Francisco fundraiser, Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump positioned himself as a strong supporter of cryptocurrency and criticised Democrats’ regulatory efforts. The event, held at tech venture capitalist David Sacks’ home, raised $12 million. Trump declared he would be the ‘crypto president,’ according to tech executive Trevor Traina, but did not detail his policy plans.

President Joe Biden’s administration has been working on regulating digital assets to protect consumers, with an executive order in 2022 prompting agencies like the SEC to address crypto risks. White House spokesperson Robyn Patterson stated the administration supports innovation while aiming to safeguard consumers.

Jacob Helberg, an adviser to Palantir, mentioned Trump promised to halt regulatory actions against crypto if he was re-elected as US president. The fundraiser saw attendance from notable crypto figures, including executives from Coinbase and the Winklevoss twins, though representatives from their company, Gemini, did not comment. Sacks and Palihapitiya have been vocal about their crypto investments, particularly in Bitcoin. The event also highlighted the fallout from the FTX exchange scandal, where founder Sam Bankman-Fried was convicted of stealing customer funds to donate over $100 million to political campaigns.

Why does it matter?

The crypto industry is increasingly seeking political influence due to heightened regulatory scrutiny, following major firm bankruptcies in 2022. Despite San Francisco’s liberal leaning, many local venture capitalists and crypto investors back Trump, criticizing what they see as excessive regulation.

New York files lawsuit over $1 billion crypto scams targeting immigrants

New York Attorney General Letitia James has filed a lawsuit against NovaTech Ltd and AWS Mining Pty Ltd, accusing them of defrauding immigrant communities, particularly Haitians, out of over $1 billion. The suit alleges that these companies lured investors with promises of high returns, leveraging religious faith to gain trust. Instead of using the funds for legitimate trading, the majority was funneled into pyramid and Ponzi schemes by paying existing investors with funds collected from new ones. AWS Mining and its promoters, Cynthia and Eddy Petion, James Corbett, Martin Zizi, and Frantz Ciceron, promised investors 15 to 20 percent monthly returns, 200 percent returns on investments within 15 months, and bonuses for recruiting new investors.

However, the company failed to generate sufficient returns to pay these promised profits and bonuses, leading to its collapse in 2019 and causing millions of dollars in losses. Following AWS Mining’s collapse, Cynthia and Eddy Petion launched NovaTech, continuing to lure investors with promises of high returns and recruitment bonuses. They targeted minority communities, particularly Haitians, using prayer groups and WhatsApp chats, often advertising in Creole and using religious messages. James said Cynthia Petion branded herself ‘Reverend CEO’ and told investors that NovaTech was ‘God’s vision’, but privately called herself the ‘Zookeeper’ and belittled her investors as a ‘cult’ where ‘they just agree with everything you say.’

NovaTech falsely marketed itself as a registered hedge fund broker, misrepresented its licensing status in the US, and advertised high trading profits. Despite market conditions, NovaTech claimed to pay weekly trading profits, but these were fabricated, with payments coming from new investors’ funds. NovaTech collapsed in May 2023, leaving tens of thousands of investors unable to withdraw their cryptocurrency. Investigation by the Office of the Attorney General (OAG) found that from 2019 to 2023, investors deposited over a billion dollars, but less than $26 million was actually traded. The lawsuit seeks restitution, civil penalties, and a ban on their participation in the securities industry.

Why does it matter?

The following case sheds light on the susceptibility of immigrant communities to financial scams, particularly within the relatively unregulated cryptocurrency sector. James said in a statement that they’re ‘seeing the real dangers of unregulated cryptocurrency platforms with schemes like these.’  By exploiting religious faith and community trust, these fraudulent schemes inflict severe financial harm, often devastating victims’ life savings. The lawsuit seeks to recover the lost funds and hold fraudulent actors accountable, highlighting the need for robust consumer protections and the necessity of enforcing regulations to safeguard vulnerable populations. 

Rwanda to adopt digital currency by 2026

Rwanda aims to develop its own national Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) within the next two years. According to the National Bank of Rwanda (BNR), that initiative will offer Rwandans a secure, cost-free, and convenient alternative to physical cash. The CBDC is anticipated to boost financial inclusion, enabling more unbanked individuals to engage in the formal economy. Soraya Hakuziyaremye, Deputy Governor of Rwanda’s Central Bank, disclosed the 2026 target during an interview. She emphasised the importance of Rwanda’s CBDC, noting similar developments in other countries in the continent, including Nigeria, Ghana, and South Africa, which are either piloting or have already launched their own CBDCs.

Hakuziyaremye also noted that, considering Rwanda’s aspirations for ICT development and a cashless economy, it was essential to evaluate the potential benefits of following other countries’ examples, especially that  the country’s major trading partners are testing or adopting the technology. In November 2023, National Bank of Rwanda Governor John Rwangombwa announced during the presentation of the central bank’s annual report for the fiscal year 2022/2023 to a joint parliamentary session that the CBDC was in development. In May 2024, the Deputy Governor, working alongside the Ministry of Finance, ICT, and Innovation, formed a task force for a feasibility study on CBDC in Rwanda in order to explore the technological requirements, regulatory frameworks, and potential risks.

The Deputy Governor mentioned that the authority published a research paper and held a public consultation process to address various concerns and ensure the CBDC benefits the population, including data privacy, system resilience, and the potential destabilization of the financial system. After the public consultation process ends in the next four weeks, Rwanda will begin a proof of concept to test the technology, design, and speed on a small scale. Additionally, a six-month international test will be conducted to evaluate the technology for cross-border payments. Following these tests, selected individuals and companies will participate in testing the digital currency. While considering various CBDC design options, Rwanda prefers a retail CBDC distributed through banks and an offline-accessible CBDC, which would be particularly useful in areas without internet access or smartphones, or during power outages.

Why does it matter? 

The introduction of a CBDC in Rwanda holds significant importance for: 

  •  Economic Growth and Stability, as it contributes to a more stable and resilient economy by improving the efficiency of monetary policy implementation. That can lead to better control of inflation and economic stability.
  • Financial Inclusion in a country where a significant portion of the population remains unbanked or underbanked. A digital currency can provide easier access to financial services especially to individuals in remote and underserved areas.
  • Cost Efficiency by the reduction of the costs associated with producing and managing physical cash (savings on printing, transportation, and storage) 
  • Enhanced Security and Transparency due to its higher level of security compared to physical cash, reducing the risk of counterfeiting and fraud. The use of blockchain or similar technologies can ensure greater transparency and traceability of transactions, vital for combating money laundering and other illicit activities.
  • Technological Advancement through financial technology that can attract investment, stimulate innovation, and create new job opportunities in the tech sector.