Musk’s X faces Alexandre de Moraes and potential shutdown in Brazil

Elon Musk’s social media platform X faces a critical showdown with Brazil’s Supreme Court, which could soon order the platform shutdown in the country. The legal battle escalated after X missed a deadline to appoint a legal representative in Brazil, a requirement under local law. The conflict has deepened tensions between Musk and Supreme Court Judge Alexandre de Moraes, whom Musk accused of engaging in censorship.

Earlier this month, the Brazilian Supreme Court froze the bank accounts of Musk’s Starlink satellite internet company as part of a broader dispute over X’s non-compliance with court orders. The fines, reportedly amounting to over $3.6 million, stem from X’s failure to provide certain documents requested by the court. In response, Musk took to X to denounce the court’s actions, labelling Moraes as an ‘evil dictator’ and announcing that SpaceX would offer free internet service to Brazilian users until the matter is resolved.

The heart of the dispute lies in Judge Moraes’ orders to block accounts on X that are accused of spreading misinformation, particularly those linked to former President Jair Bolsonaro supporters. Musk has publicly criticised these orders as censorship, arguing that they violate free speech. Despite initial resistance, X eventually agreed to comply with the court’s demands but cited operational issues for its incomplete compliance.

This legal struggle has jeopardised X’s future in Brazil, one of its largest markets. The platform had already announced plans to close its operations in the country, blaming Moraes’ censorship orders for the decision. Meanwhile, Brazil’s President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva has backed Moraes’ stance, emphasising the importance of respecting local laws and protecting private information.

As the battle unfolds, Brazilian users of X have reacted with a mix of humour and concern, creating memes and debating the implications of the court’s actions on free speech. The situation remains tense, with the potential shutdown of X in Brazil looming, highlighting the broader conflict between digital platforms and governmental control.