Meta urged to rethink content removal amid Israel-Palestine controversy

The phrase in question, often heard at pro-Palestinian demonstrations, has sparked debate, with critics claiming it promotes antisemitism and supporters viewing it as a call for solidarity.
Millions of Vietnamese users rely on Meta’s platforms as the company plans significant investments in AI and manufacturing.

Meta’s Oversight Board has advised the Facebook parent company not to automatically remove the phrase ‘From the river to the sea’, which is interpreted by some as a show of solidarity with Palestinians and by others as antisemitic. The board determined that the phrase holds multiple meanings and cannot be universally deemed harmful or violent.

The phrase refers to the region between the River Jordan and the Mediterranean Sea, encompassing Israel and the Palestinian territories. Often used at pro-Palestinian rallies, critics argue it calls for Israel’s destruction, while others dispute this interpretation. The board emphasised the importance of context in assessing such political speech, urging Meta to allow space for debate, particularly during times of conflict.

Meta expressed support for the board’s review, acknowledging the complexities involved in global content moderation. However, the Anti-Defamation League criticised the decision, saying the phrase makes Jewish and pro-Israel communities feel unsafe. The Oversight Board also called on Meta to restore data access for researchers and journalists following its recent decision to end the CrowdTangle tool.

The board’s ruling highlights the ongoing challenges in regulating sensitive content on social media platforms, with a need for balancing free speech and community safety.