WTO Ministerial: Members diverge on digital trade outcomes

At the 14th WTO Ministerial Conference in Yaoundé, Cameroon, two parallel tracks concerning digital trade took centre stage, each with distinct outcomes. The first was the long-standing moratorium on customs duties on electronic transmissions, a temporary ban renewed every two years since 1998, which expired after members were unable to agree on a new extension.

The second was the plurilateral Agreement on Electronic Commerce concluded in 2024 by the Joint Statement Initiative on e-commerce (JSI), aiming to establish digital trade rules, including a prohibition on e-commerce duties. While the moratorium lapsed without a multilateral consensus, a coalition of countries decided to move forward with implementing the plurilateral e-commerce agreement.

Moratorium on customs duties on electronic transmissions

The Ministerial Conference concluded without a final declaration and without an agreement on the moratorium, leading to its lapse. Negotiators were unable to reach a consensus on the length of a new extension, with differing views among members preventing a deal.

The outcome also meant that a broader set of discussions on WTO reform, which had been politically linked to the approval of the moratorium, remained unresolved. Discussions on both fronts, as well as about the future of the Work Programme on e-commerce (WPEC), are expected to continue at the next General Council meeting in May.

At the heart of the impasse were differing perspectives on how long the moratorium should be extended. While some members, particularly the US, sought a longer-term solution, others have traditionally advocated a shorter renewal, reflecting a desire for caution given the rapid pace of technological change and the need to preserve policy flexibility for the future.

During MC14, Brazil was the leading voice, emphasising the importance of caution in light of developments such as AI and 3D printing, suggesting that a shorter extension with room for review would allow members to reassess as the digital landscape evolves. Efforts to find a middle ground ultimately fell short as time ran out.

This is not the first time that the moratorium has lapsed; it happened at the 1999 Seattle ministerial, before the moratorium was reinstated at Doha two years later. The current expiry of the moratorium does not mean tariffs will automatically be imposed.

Still, it creates policy space for some countries to consider introducing tariffs if they are not bound by trade agreements that prohibit customs duties on electronic transmissions.

Plurilateral Agreement on E-commerce will be implemented on an interim basis

A coalition of 66 WTO members announced they would move forward with implementing the JSI e-commerce agreement through interim arrangements. Australia, Japan, and Singapore, serving as co-convenors, confirmed that the pact, which aims to facilitate digital trade and prohibit duties on e-commerce transactions, will enter into force once 45 members have formally notified their acceptance.

In the meantime, JSI members will continue to seek inclusion of the Agreement under the WTO legal architecture. Upon the entry into force, the signatories of the Agreement, which excludes major economies, such as the United States, Brazil, and India, will be bound by a moratorium on customs duties on electronic transmissions, offsetting some of the impact of the expiry of the WTO-wide moratorium.

The initiative received support from WTO Director-General Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, who noted that participating economies are helping establish a shared regulatory framework that can lower costs and unlock new opportunities. However, the path for other plurilateral efforts remains uncertain, as India registered dissent against the incorporation of the agreement achieved within another plurilateral negotiation, on Investment Facilitation for Development, into the WTO rulebook.

The country argued that incorporating such frameworks into the WTO rulebook risks eroding the organisation’s foundational principles. It asked for a discussion of guardrails and legal safeguards before integrating any specific plurilateral outcome into the WTO.

Would you like to learn more about AI, tech and digital diplomacy? If so, ask our Diplo chatbot!