Former GCHQ chief calls for transparency amid UK’s attempt to access encrypted iCloud accounts

A controversy has emerged over the British government’s reported attempt to compel Apple to grant authorities access to encrypted iCloud accounts, leading to calls for increased transparency from intelligence agencies. Sir Jeremy Fleming, the former head of the UK’s GCHQ from 2017 to 2023, addressed this issue at the Munich Cyber Security Conference, highlighting the need for public understanding and trust in intelligence operations. He emphasised that an agency’s ‘license to operate’ should be grounded in transparency.

The UK government has contested the description of a ‘back door’ in relation to the notice, clarifying that it seeks to ensure Apple maintains the capability to provide iCloud data in response to lawful warrants, a function that existed prior to the introduction of end-to-end encryption for iCloud in December 2022.

Since 2020, Apple has provided iCloud data to UK authorities in response to four of more than 6,000 legal requests for customer information under non-IPA laws. However, this data excludes requests made under the Investigatory Powers Act (IPA), the UK’s primary law for accessing tech company data.

Fleming emphasised the importance of intelligence agencies providing clear explanations of their operations, particularly in relation to new technologies. He pointed out the need for a better understanding of how intelligence agencies operate in practice, particularly as technological advancements change their methods.

For more information on these topics, visit diplomacy.edu.