Apple loses €13 billion EU tax case

The Luxembourg-based Court of Justice of the European Union upheld the Commission’s decision, confirming Apple received unlawful state aid.
Apple is nearing its first US retail employee union agreement.

Apple has lost its battle with the European Union over a €13 billion tax payment dispute, marking a major win for the EU regulators. The European Commission initially ordered the payment in 2016, accusing Apple of benefiting from favourable Irish tax rulings that significantly reduced its tax obligations. These sweetheart deals allowed Apple to pay as little as 0.005% tax in 2014.

Apple and Ireland challenged the decision, arguing that the ruling defied logic, especially since Ireland’s low tax rates were instrumental in attracting major tech firms. However, the Court of Justice of the EU upheld the Commission’s order, declaring that Ireland had provided Apple with illegal state aid, which now must be repaid.

Apple expressed disappointment, accusing the EU of retroactively changing tax laws and arguing that its income had already been taxed in the US. The final and non-appealable ruling is a significant step in the EU’s efforts to clamp down on favourable tax deals for multinational corporations.