New York City targets junk fees and subscription traps
Businesses violating rules face civil penalties starting at $525 per violation plus consumer restitution.
New York City has introduced two major consumer protection measures targeting hidden charges and difficult subscription cancellations, combining mandatory all-in pricing with new ‘Click-to-Cancel’ requirements.
The Click-to-Cancel rule will take effect on 1 October 2026, making New York City the first municipality to require businesses to offer subscription cancellations that are as simple as sign-up. Companies must clearly disclose subscription terms and provide straightforward cancellation mechanisms, ending practices that rely on confusing procedures or hidden recurring charges. According to the Roosevelt Institute, the rule could save New Yorkers between $21.5 million and $162.5 million each year.
The proposed Junk Fees rule would require businesses to display the full price upfront, including all mandatory charges. Companies would be prohibited from advertising misleading prices and would have to include service and processing fees in advertised prices. Businesses that violate either rule could face consumer restitution and civil penalties starting at $525 per violation.
Consumer Reports estimates that hidden fees cost the average family of four around $3,200 annually. The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection has published guidance explaining the proposed all-in pricing rules, with public consultation remaining open until a hearing on 7 August.
Why does it matter?
The measures reflect a growing regulatory effort to tackle so-called ‘dark patterns’—design practices that make prices harder to understand or subscriptions more difficult to cancel. By requiring transparent pricing and straightforward cancellation, New York City is shifting responsibility from consumers to businesses to ensure commercial practices are fair by design.
The rules could also influence wider consumer protection policy. As many companies operate nationally or globally, local requirements on pricing transparency and subscription management may encourage businesses to adopt similar practices across multiple markets, potentially shaping future regulation in other jurisdictions.
Would you like to learn more about AI, tech and digital diplomacy? If so, ask our Diplo chatbot!