Charting an inclusive path for digitalisation and a green transition for all
Event report
Speakers:
- Richard Niwenshuti
- Reina Otsuka
- Emma Sävenborg
- Robin Michelle Zuercher
Moderators:
- Sabina Cifou
Table of contents
Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the IGF session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed. The official record of the session can be found on the IGF's official website.
Knowledge Graph of Debate
Session report
Audience
The discussion covered several key topics related to technology transition and its impact on climate change, government regulation, digital solutions, and environmental sustainability.
One audience member expressed concern about the slow adoption of technological standards and its potential impact on global warming. They highlighted that it took 15 years to agree on the USB-C standard, underscoring the need for a faster adoption process to effectively address climate change. This negative sentiment emphasizes the urgency of speeding up technological standardization to mitigate global warming.
Another speaker highlighted the effectiveness of government regulation in driving the adoption of tech standards. They gave the example of the European Union's requirement for Apple to adopt the USB-C standard, illustrating how government intervention can play a crucial role in shaping industry practices. This positive argument suggests that government regulations can facilitate the implementation of technological standards and promote a more consistent and efficient transition to newer technologies.
The discussion also addressed the environmental costs associated with digital solutions. While digital technologies offer numerous benefits, it is important to acknowledge and mitigate their environmental impacts. The speakers emphasized the importance of a "twin transition" approach, which involves a balanced focus on both digitalization and environmental impact. This approach aims to mitigate the negative consequences of digital solutions and ensure sustainable practices. The sentiment here is neutral, recognizing the need for environmental consciousness while leveraging digital technologies.
Lastly, the speakers stressed the significance of minimizing environmental impact in developing countries undergoing digitalization. They acknowledged that developing nations are increasingly embracing digitalization, but environmental considerations should not be overlooked in this process. The audience agreed that measures should be taken to minimize the environmental impact of digitalization in these regions. This neutral standpoint highlights the importance of achieving a balance between technological advancement and sustainable practices.
Overall, the discussion provided valuable insights into the need for swift adoption of technological standards to address climate change, the role of government regulation in driving tech standardization, the environmental costs associated with digital solutions, and the importance of minimizing environmental impact during digitalization in developing countries. The arguments and evidence presented shed light on the complex relationship between technology transition and environmental sustainability.
Richard Niwenshuti
The analysis highlights the crucial role of digital tools in policy making and trade. It emphasizes that relying on the strength and capacities of digital tools is essential for making the right policy decisions. Digital tools provide policymakers with access to vast amounts of data, enabling them to analyze trends, assess impacts, and develop evidence-based strategies. This supports the argument for the usage of digital tools and data for policy decisions, which aligns with SDG 9: Industry, Innovation, and Infrastructure.
In the context of trade, the analysis underscores the importance of speed. It states that in trade, time is cost. The faster the trade process, the more efficient and cost-effective it becomes. Digital tools enable businesses to streamline their operations, automate processes, and reduce time-consuming paperwork. This highlights the significance of speed in trade, which is crucial for achieving SDG 8: Decent Work and Economic Growth.
Furthermore, the analysis also emphasizes the alignment of digital trade with sustainable solutions. It highlights that digital trade minimizes the footprints of production. By digitizing trade processes, companies can reduce their reliance on physical resources, leading to lower carbon emissions and environmental impact. This supports the argument that digital trade can contribute to achieving SDG 13: Climate Action.
The analysis recognizes that different countries are at different levels of digital transition, including within Africa. It cites the example of Rwanda, which has made significant investments in digital infrastructure and serves as a pathway for other African countries. The argument is made that investments in digital transitions should be prioritized in Africa to avail the benefits of wider market opportunities and digital trade. There is a need for digital payments integration and digital skills development for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in Africa. Additionally, there is a desire to integrate digital tools in production chains to boost productivity, supporting SDG 9: Industry, Innovation, and Infrastructure.
In terms of trade, the analysis emphasizes the need to invest in technologies that optimize production before focusing on trade. It states that low production levels globally have attributed to the growth in food prices. Digitization can help optimize agricultural processes, leading to better pricing and increased food production, contributing to achieving SDG 2: Zero Hunger.
The analysis highlights that digital tools play a key role in trading high-value products in mature markets. It cites Rwanda's efforts to target high-value markets that require digital precision. Digital tools help maintain the standards and criteria necessary for entering these mature markets, supporting SDG 8: Decent Work and Economic Growth and SDG 9: Industry, Innovation, and Infrastructure.
In terms of policy development, the analysis acknowledges the varying levels of transition and capabilities between countries. It suggests that negotiations on digital trade policy should take into account these differences to ensure that policies are suitable for countries at different stages of digital transition. This underlines the need for more policy instruments and support to facilitate the transition for countries that are lagging behind in digital trade, contributing to SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals.
The analysis also recognizes the importance of combating e-waste and promoting responsible consumption and production. It highlights the implementation of state-of-the-art e-waste facilities in Rwanda, where electronic materials are renewed, and hazardous materials are safely handled. This showcases the commitment to responsible consumption and production practices, supporting SDG 12: Responsible Consumption and Production.
Regarding climate control, the analysis states that multi-sector interventions are necessary. It mentions Rwanda's goal of reducing carbon emissions by 38 percent by 2035 and its transition to electronic mobility. This highlights the need for collaboration, partnerships, and complementarity in achieving digital transition and climate resilience solutions, aligning with SDG 13: Climate Action and SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals.
In terms of trade standards, the analysis acknowledges that trade now relies on meeting certain voluntary metrics. This highlights the growing importance of standards in trade and the need for businesses to meet these metrics to ensure fair and sustainable trade practices, contributing to SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals and SDG 10: Reduced Inequalities.
Overall, the analysis highlights the significance of digital tools in policy making and trade, the need for investments in digital transitions, particularly in Africa, and the alignment of digital trade with sustainable solutions. It emphasizes the importance of considering different levels of transition and capabilities in digital trade policy negotiations. It also stresses the need for responsible consumption and production practices, multi-sector interventions for climate control, and adherence to trade standards in achieving the Sustainable Development Goals.
Emma Sävenborg
The analysis highlights several key arguments related to trade policy and its impact on sustainability. One of the main arguments is the necessity for trade policy to be based on evidence and correct data. Emma, a senior advisor for digital trade and services at the National Board of Trade, emphasizes the importance of accurate and reliable data in making informed decisions about emissions and trade. Without the right data, it is impossible to fully understand the emissions being released and the potential environmental consequences of trade activities. Therefore, trade policy should rely on accurate data to address sustainability goals effectively.
Another key argument is the role of trade policy in achieving sustainable standards. Trade can encourage innovation and the spread of technical know-how, which are essential for driving sustainable development. By promoting trade, solutions to environmental challenges can be widely disseminated and implemented, leading to more impactful results. Lowering tariffs on environmental goods is also highlighted as a means to make these goods more accessible and encourage their use, promoting sustainability.
Balancing intellectual property (IP) rights and technology transfer is also crucial for achieving green transition. the right balance can facilitate the dissemination of green technologies, allowing for the successful adoption and implementation of sustainable practices. Trade agreements can leverage best practices and discourage environmentally harmful practices by including provisions that encourage sustainability and discourage harmful practices.
The analysis also emphasizes the need to expand digital trade negotiations and include more countries, particularly developing ones. Currently, many African countries have yet to negotiate their digital trade agreements due to limited bureaucratic capacity. Additionally, countries with smaller delegations face challenges in engaging in Joint Statement Initiatives due to demanding processes. By broadening the conversation and creating incentives for more countries to participate, especially developing ones, a more inclusive and comprehensive digital trade framework can be established.
Another important point raised in the analysis is the need to acknowledge and address different levels of readiness, priorities, and perspectives in digital trade. The perception of what digital trade entails depends on a country's level of digital maturity. It is crucial to recognize that different countries may prioritize different issues in digital trade based on their specific circumstances and needs. By acknowledging and accommodating these differences, a more balanced and effective approach to digital trade can be achieved.
The analysis also underlines the importance of providing support and assistance to countries in participating in digital trade. Currently, only a small percentage of aid for trade funds are allocated to digital, which is deemed insufficient. To ensure that developing countries are not left behind in the digital trade sphere, specific capacity-supporting mechanisms need to be incorporated into all types of negotiations.
Furthermore, the analysis highlights the establishment of a green digital action track, with industry leaders discussing and working on an action plan to map out green standards. This signifies a commitment to implementing agreed-upon green standards within the digital trade sector. However, the analysis does not provide information on how policymakers can accelerate the implementation of these standards, leaving this question unanswered.
Finally, Emma Sävenborg's perspective is notable in the analysis. She advocates for more inclusion of environmental issues in digital trade discussions and expresses a commitment to introducing more green elements into the sphere of digital trade in the longer term. Her insights highlight the need to consider environmental considerations in all aspects of trade, including digital trade, and work towards a more sustainable future.
In conclusion, the analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the various arguments and perspectives related to trade policy and sustainability. It emphasizes the importance of basing trade policy on evidence and correct data, promoting sustainable standards through trade, and finding a balance between IP rights and technology transfer. The need for inclusive digital trade negotiations and support for developing countries in digital trade are also underscored. The establishment of a green digital action track and Emma Sävenborg's commitment to environmental considerations in digital trade further contribute to the discussion. Overall, the analysis highlights the potential of trade policy to promote sustainability and the importance of incorporating environmental concerns into trade discussions and decision-making processes.
Robin Michelle Zuercher
The analysis of the given statements highlights several significant points related to the relationship between green and digital transformation, the importance of connectivity, the impact of the ICT industry, the role of standards, and the need for collaboration.
Firstly, there is a consensus among the speakers that green and digital transformation should work hand in hand. Digitalisation is seen as having key opportunities in climate, trade, and the circular economy. This implies that incorporating sustainable digital practices can contribute to achieving environmental goals and promoting economic growth simultaneously.
Connectivity is emphasised as a crucial factor for ensuring inclusivity in the digital age. It is stated that 2.6 billion people do not have access to the internet, and the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) is mandated to work towards achieving universal connectivity. This indicates that providing internet access to all communities, especially the most difficult to connect, is seen as essential for bridging the digital divide and reducing inequalities.
However, it is acknowledged that the growing ICT industry has negative implications. The sector's greenhouse gas emissions are on the rise, and significant amounts of e-waste are being generated. Estimates suggest that e-waste could reach 110 million metric tons by 2050. The growing amount of e-waste and greenhouse gas emissions indicate that sustainable practices need to be implemented in the ICT industry to mitigate its environmental impact.
To address these challenges, speakers highlight the importance of moving towards a circular economy and adopting sustainable practices. The ITU is actively involved in developing guidelines and capacity building tools for green data centers, assisting developing countries with e-waste regulation, and working on international standards for circular design and digital product passports. These initiatives aim to promote a circular economy and reduce the environmental impact of ICT-related activities.
Collaboration and inclusivity are consistently emphasized as crucial for sustainable digital development. The ITU's diverse membership is highlighted as an asset in ensuring inclusivity in the standard-setting process. The ITU is also leading a collaborative initiative for green digital action at COP28, demonstrating the commitment to fostering collaboration among stakeholders.
Standards play a crucial role in building transparent and equitable markets, as they provide a level playing field for all participants. Speakers point out that standards are behind common tasks such as making phone calls or listening to music, highlighting their pervasive influence. Regulators and policymakers are encouraged to incorporate standards when forming policies to enable sustainable and circular procurement of ICTs and influence supply chain formation.
The trade perspective is recognized as significant in the green and digital agenda. Speakers emphasize the need for collaboration between the trade community and the standardization process. This suggests that involving various communities, such as trade and environment, can enhance the process of standards development and ensure a holistic approach.
In conclusion, the analysis reveals the importance of integrating green and digital transformation, ensuring connectivity for inclusivity, addressing the negative impact of the ICT industry, promoting sustainable practices and a circular economy, fostering collaboration and inclusivity in the standardization process, and considering the trade perspective. These insights provide valuable considerations for policymakers, regulators, and stakeholders involved in the sustainable development of digital technologies.
Reina Otsuka
In this analysis, the speakers delve into the potential benefits and challenges of digital technology in addressing environmental issues and promoting sustainable development. They highlight the idea that digital technology can allow countries to bypass outdated environmental management and traceability methods and take a giant leap forward. By embracing digital solutions, nations can revolutionize the way they manage their environment and ensure greater resilience in the face of challenges.
The speakers also emphasize that digital transformation has the power to revolutionise the socioeconomic system. With digitalisation, operations can become ten times faster, more efficient, and scalable. This can have a profound impact on economic growth and create opportunities for innovation and development. The potential for digital technology to drive socioeconomic progress is vast and can lead to significant advancements in various sectors.
Another key point highlighted in the analysis is the role of digital technology in climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies. For instance, smart agriculture and energy efficiency are examples of digital applications that can contribute to mitigating climate change. Real-time data obtained through digital technology is essential for early warning systems and risk-informed planning in adaptation strategies. By leveraging digital solutions, countries can enhance their efforts to combat climate change and build resilience in the face of its impacts.
However, the speakers caution that the green transition should not leave behind those who are most affected by climate change. While digital technologies bring numerous benefits, it is important to ensure inclusivity and consider the needs of marginalised communities. Many people, especially those in developing countries, still lack access to the internet, which hampers their ability to benefit from digital advancements. Therefore, the green transition should be integrated with the digital transition to ensure that all sectors of society can reap the benefits and address environmental challenges effectively.
Access to finance for green initiatives is another area where digital technology can play a significant role. Digital solutions can facilitate data-based trust in carbon markets and support payment for ecosystem service (PES) schemes. These schemes compensate custodians of ecosystems for their efforts in preserving the environment. By leveraging digital technology, countries can improve financial mechanisms and support the transition towards a greener economy.
The analysis also emphasises the importance of open data and data sharing policies to eliminate duplication of efforts. It highlights the need for a digital infrastructure that promotes innovative solutions and collaboration. By sharing data openly, companies and organisations can avoid unnecessary duplication of data collection efforts, improving efficiency and fostering innovation.
Additionally, the speakers stress the need to build digital technology as an ecosystem that involves various stakeholders such as governments, the private sector, academic partners, local communities, and even citizen science. For digital technology to be adopted successfully and sustainably, it needs to be a collaborative effort. They provide examples of successful engagements, such as the partnership between the Rwanda ICT Chamber of Commerce and a village community to develop business models for supporting a cold chain. This case study illustrates the concept of a digital ecosystem in practice and highlights the benefits of involving multiple stakeholders in the adoption of digital technology.
The analysis also touches upon several environmental issues associated with the digital transition. For instance, e-waste management and the environmental impact of server centres are significant concerns. The speakers suggest that these issues should be addressed to ensure a sustainable digital transition. Furthermore, the extraction of minerals for digital technology is deemed a hidden but significant issue that must be reckoned with in the pursuit of sustainable development.
When discussing national digital strategies, the speakers stress the importance of considering both environmental and social aspects. Safeguards related to these issues should be implemented from the inception of a digital strategy to ensure that it aligns with sustainable development principles. They cite the ongoing digital readiness assessment in Tanzania as an example of the need to consider environmental and social factors in digital strategies.
Lastly, the speakers acknowledge that addressing environmental and digital issues requires partnerships and a holistic approach. They advocate for various ministries, such as trade, environment, and digital, to work together and collaborate on solutions. The Coalition for Digital Environmental Sustainability is highlighted as a platform that aims to foster such partnerships and encourage diverse discussions on these critical topics.
In conclusion, the speakers in this analysis shed light on the potential benefits and challenges of digital technology in addressing environmental issues and promoting sustainable development. They highlight the need to integrate digital and green transitions, ensure inclusivity, manage e-waste and server centre emissions, address mineral extraction concerns, and consider social and environmental safeguards in national digital strategies. Partnerships and a holistic approach are seen as crucial for managing the complex intersection between digital and environmental sustainability. By embracing these ideas, countries can leverage digital technology to create a more sustainable and resilient future.
Moderator
The discussion centred around the significance of sustainable digital transformation and universal connectivity in achieving the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The International Telecommunication Union (ITU) played a central role, emphasising its mandate to connect the world. Member states have prioritised sustainable digital transformation alongside universal connectivity, recognising the need to address the environmental impact of digitalisation.
Collaboration emerged as a key theme, with participants stressing the importance of integrating digital and green transitions. The trade angle, circular economy, and dematerialisation were highlighted as key opportunities. The role of digital tools and data in policy making was emphasised, particularly the need for evidence-based decision making and the use of data by policy makers.
Trade was identified as essential for promoting innovation, disseminating technical knowledge, and advancing sustainability. However, challenges such as the digital divide and slow adoption of digital solutions by small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) were acknowledged. Efforts to regulate e-waste, promote circular economy practices, and establish green standards were discussed.
The participants underscored the need for partnerships and a holistic approach to address challenges and maximise the benefits of the digital and green agenda. They called for unified global dialogue and inclusive digital trade policies. The importance of interconnectedness in policy making, both domestically and internationally, was emphasised. Furthermore, concern was raised about the potential widening of the gap between countries due to the rapid pace of digital transformation.
Noteworthy initiatives, such as Rwanda's investment in digital infrastructure and e-waste management, as well as China's digitisation of its e-waste system, were highlighted as examples of integration of digital technology and potential for sustainable practices.
The significance of standards, particularly in promoting green practices and ensuring a level playing field in trade, was emphasised. Attention was drawn to the slow adoption of voluntary standards by the industry, suggesting the need for regulatory intervention to drive their implementation. The involvement of the trade community in the standardisation process was deemed beneficial.
Overall, the expanded summary emphasises the importance of sustainable digital transformation, universal connectivity, and the use of digital tools and data in achieving the SDGs. Collaboration, partnerships, and a comprehensive approach are seen as crucial to address challenges and maximise the positive impacts of the digital and green agenda.
Speakers
A
Audience
Speech speed
154 words per minute
Speech length
338 words
Speech time
132 secs
Arguments
Speeding up the process of tech transition is necessary for containing global warming
Supporting facts:
- The audience member cited the 15-year timeframe required to agree on the USB-C standard and urged for quicker adoption of technological standards.
Topics: Tech Transition, Global Warming, Standardization
Utilizing digital technologies comes with environmental impacts
Supporting facts:
- Digital solutions, though beneficial, have environmental costs that are often overlooked.
- To mitigate such, there is need for a twin transition- a balanced focus on both digitalization and environmental impact.
Topics: Digital solutions, Environmental cost, Twin Transition
Report
The discussion covered several key topics related to technology transition and its impact on climate change, government regulation, digital solutions, and environmental sustainability. One audience member expressed concern about the slow adoption of technological standards and its potential impact on global warming.
They highlighted that it took 15 years to agree on the USB-C standard, underscoring the need for a faster adoption process to effectively address climate change. This negative sentiment emphasizes the urgency of speeding up technological standardization to mitigate global warming.
Another speaker highlighted the effectiveness of government regulation in driving the adoption of tech standards. They gave the example of the European Union's requirement for Apple to adopt the USB-C standard, illustrating how government intervention can play a crucial role in shaping industry practices.
This positive argument suggests that government regulations can facilitate the implementation of technological standards and promote a more consistent and efficient transition to newer technologies. The discussion also addressed the environmental costs associated with digital solutions. While digital technologies offer numerous benefits, it is important to acknowledge and mitigate their environmental impacts.
The speakers emphasized the importance of a "twin transition" approach, which involves a balanced focus on both digitalization and environmental impact. This approach aims to mitigate the negative consequences of digital solutions and ensure sustainable practices. The sentiment here is neutral, recognizing the need for environmental consciousness while leveraging digital technologies.
Lastly, the speakers stressed the significance of minimizing environmental impact in developing countries undergoing digitalization. They acknowledged that developing nations are increasingly embracing digitalization, but environmental considerations should not be overlooked in this process. The audience agreed that measures should be taken to minimize the environmental impact of digitalization in these regions.
This neutral standpoint highlights the importance of achieving a balance between technological advancement and sustainable practices. Overall, the discussion provided valuable insights into the need for swift adoption of technological standards to address climate change, the role of government regulation in driving tech standardization, the environmental costs associated with digital solutions, and the importance of minimizing environmental impact during digitalization in developing countries.
The arguments and evidence presented shed light on the complex relationship between technology transition and environmental sustainability.
ES
Emma Sävenborg
Speech speed
166 words per minute
Speech length
1973 words
Speech time
714 secs
Arguments
Trade policy should be based on evidence and correct data
Supporting facts:
- Emma works at the National Board of Trade as a senior advisor for digital trade and services.
- She emphasizes on the need for right data to know what emissions are released and to make informed decisions.
Topics: Trade Policy, Digital Trade, Data Management
Trade policy can help in achieving sustainable standards
Supporting facts:
- Trade encourages innovation and the spread of technical know-how
- Solutions become impactful through global commercialization via trade
Topics: Trade, Sustainability, Innovation, Commercialization
Lowering tariffs on environmental goods services can promote sustainability
Supporting facts:
- Lowering tariffs can make environmental goods more accessible and thereby encourage their use
Topics: Trade Policy, Tariffs, Environmental Goods
Balance of IP rights and technology transfer can enhance green transition
Supporting facts:
- The right balance between IP protection and tech transfer can encourage the dissemination of green technologies
Topics: IP rights, Technology Transfer, Green Transition
The conversations around digital trade negotiations need to be broadened and incentives created for more countries, especially developing ones, to join.
Supporting facts:
- Not many African countries have negotiated their digital trade agreements
- The bureaucratic capacity concerning digital trade negotiations tends to be low
- Countries with smaller delegations face a challenge engaging in Joint Statement Initiatives due to their demanding processes
Topics: Digital Trade Negotiations, Joint Statement Initiative, Development Support
Different levels of readiness, priorities, and perspectives in digital trade need to be acknowledged.
Supporting facts:
- The perception of what digital trade is, depends on the country's level of digital maturity
- Some countries prioritize issues like fluctuating currencies and competition that others might not consider top priority in digital trade
Topics: Digital Trade Readiness, Negotiations, Joint Statement Initiative
Development support needs to be adapted to assist countries in taking part in digital trade.
Supporting facts:
- Currently, only 0.4% of aid for trade funds are allocated to digital, which is insufficient
- Specific capacity-supporting mechanisms should be included in all types of negotiations
Topics: Development Support, Digital Trade, Aid for Digital Trade
Green digital action track on building implementation around green standards is being established
Supporting facts:
- Industry leaders are currently discussing within each other
- They are working on an action plan to map what kind of green standards are in place
- The action plan will be launched at COP
Topics: Industry, Policy making, Green standards
Agreed set of green standards need to be implement
Supporting facts:
- Industry leaders are currently discussing within each other
- They are working on an action plan to map what kind of green standards are in place
Topics: Green Standards, Implementation
Emma Sävenborg points out that there is a lack of environmental considerations in digital trade negotiations and in her own work.
Supporting facts:
- Digital Green Trade is a potential title she jokingly ponders, signs that she is seriously considering in introducing more green elements in the sphere of digital trade.
- Sävenborg plans to work on this issue in the coming years, suggesting a commitment to this stance in the longer term.
Topics: Digital Trade, Sustainability, Negotiations
Report
The analysis highlights several key arguments related to trade policy and its impact on sustainability. One of the main arguments is the necessity for trade policy to be based on evidence and correct data. Emma, a senior advisor for digital trade and services at the National Board of Trade, emphasizes the importance of accurate and reliable data in making informed decisions about emissions and trade.
Without the right data, it is impossible to fully understand the emissions being released and the potential environmental consequences of trade activities. Therefore, trade policy should rely on accurate data to address sustainability goals effectively. Another key argument is the role of trade policy in achieving sustainable standards.
Trade can encourage innovation and the spread of technical know-how, which are essential for driving sustainable development. By promoting trade, solutions to environmental challenges can be widely disseminated and implemented, leading to more impactful results. Lowering tariffs on environmental goods is also highlighted as a means to make these goods more accessible and encourage their use, promoting sustainability.
Balancing intellectual property (IP) rights and technology transfer is also crucial for achieving green transition. the right balance can facilitate the dissemination of green technologies, allowing for the successful adoption and implementation of sustainable practices. Trade agreements can leverage best practices and discourage environmentally harmful practices by including provisions that encourage sustainability and discourage harmful practices.
The analysis also emphasizes the need to expand digital trade negotiations and include more countries, particularly developing ones. Currently, many African countries have yet to negotiate their digital trade agreements due to limited bureaucratic capacity. Additionally, countries with smaller delegations face challenges in engaging in Joint Statement Initiatives due to demanding processes.
By broadening the conversation and creating incentives for more countries to participate, especially developing ones, a more inclusive and comprehensive digital trade framework can be established. Another important point raised in the analysis is the need to acknowledge and address different levels of readiness, priorities, and perspectives in digital trade.
The perception of what digital trade entails depends on a country's level of digital maturity. It is crucial to recognize that different countries may prioritize different issues in digital trade based on their specific circumstances and needs. By acknowledging and accommodating these differences, a more balanced and effective approach to digital trade can be achieved.
The analysis also underlines the importance of providing support and assistance to countries in participating in digital trade. Currently, only a small percentage of aid for trade funds are allocated to digital, which is deemed insufficient. To ensure that developing countries are not left behind in the digital trade sphere, specific capacity-supporting mechanisms need to be incorporated into all types of negotiations.
Furthermore, the analysis highlights the establishment of a green digital action track, with industry leaders discussing and working on an action plan to map out green standards. This signifies a commitment to implementing agreed-upon green standards within the digital trade sector.
However, the analysis does not provide information on how policymakers can accelerate the implementation of these standards, leaving this question unanswered. Finally, Emma Sävenborg's perspective is notable in the analysis. She advocates for more inclusion of environmental issues in digital trade discussions and expresses a commitment to introducing more green elements into the sphere of digital trade in the longer term.
Her insights highlight the need to consider environmental considerations in all aspects of trade, including digital trade, and work towards a more sustainable future. In conclusion, the analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the various arguments and perspectives related to trade policy and sustainability.
It emphasizes the importance of basing trade policy on evidence and correct data, promoting sustainable standards through trade, and finding a balance between IP rights and technology transfer. The need for inclusive digital trade negotiations and support for developing countries in digital trade are also underscored.
The establishment of a green digital action track and Emma Sävenborg's commitment to environmental considerations in digital trade further contribute to the discussion. Overall, the analysis highlights the potential of trade policy to promote sustainability and the importance of incorporating environmental concerns into trade discussions and decision-making processes.
M
Moderator
Speech speed
196 words per minute
Speech length
2419 words
Speech time
740 secs
Arguments
The International Telecommunication Union's mandate is to connect the world.
Supporting facts:
- Robin Zirker is from the International Telecommunication Union
- Member states have put sustainable digital transformation on an equal footing with universal connectivity
Topics: International Telecommunication Union, Digital Transformation
Need for green and digital transformation to work hand in hand and the transition to a circular economy and renewable energy.
Supporting facts:
- Sustainable digital transformation has been given equal importance as universal connectivity
- Robin emphasises on the importance of sustainable production and consumption
Topics: Green Transformation, Digital Transformation, Renewable Energy, Circular Economy
Use of digital tools and data for policy making
Supporting facts:
- Relying on the strength and capacities of digital tools for decision making
- Data is needed for policy makers to make right decisions
Topics: Policy Making, Data Usage, Digital Tools
Speed of digital trade
Supporting facts:
- In trade perspective, time is cost
- Digital trade aligns to speed of doing things
Topics: Digital Trade, Speed, Efficiency
Digital trade aligns with greening
Supporting facts:
- Digital trade minimizes production footprints
- Aligns us to sustainable solutions
Topics: Digital Trade, Greening, Sustainability, Climate Change
The importance of data in policy making
Supporting facts:
- Emma Sevenberg highlighted the need for evidence-based trade policy
- Richard also mentioned the necessity of data prior to Emma
Topics: Data, Policy making, Digitalization, Trade
Speed at which digital transformation is happening can further widen the gap between countries.
Supporting facts:
- Some countries are into the quantum commercialization space while some are still unacquainted with quantum.
Topics: digital transformation, inequality
A third of the global population is still not connected to the internet
Supporting facts:
- ITU released the latest internet usage estimates showing 2.6 billion people are not connected
- ITU's key mandate is universal connectivity
Topics: Internet connectivity, ICT infrastructure
ICT sector's greenhouse gas emissions and e-waste are growing
Supporting facts:
- ICT sector greenhouse gas emissions are increasing due to the digital revolution
- 53.6 million metric tons of e-waste were generated in 2019, expected to grow to 110 million metric tons by 2050
Topics: Greenhouse gas emissions, E-waste
Efforts are being made to regulate e-waste and enhance circular economy
Supporting facts:
- ITU is developing international standards on circularity design, digital product passports
- ITU is working on guidelines to enable green data centers and minimize ICT-induced greenhouse gas emissions
Topics: E-waste management, Circular economy
Trade has a huge role in encouraging innovation, spreading technical know-how and commercializing solutions.
Supporting facts:
- Trade encourage innovation and the spread of technical know-how.
- Commercializing and trading these solutions globally increases their impact.
Topics: Trade, Innovation, Trade policy
Trade negotiations are effective in leveraging best practices and establish standards.
Supporting facts:
- Trade negotiations promote discussions on best practices and industry initiatives.
- They also work on promoting common standards.
Topics: Trade negotiations, Standards
Investment in digital infrastructure is a panacea to optimal African green economy and trade benefits
Supporting facts:
- The state of digital transformation is different for each African country.
- Rwanda has heavily invested in digital infrastructure.
- Using digital tools optimizes the production chain and market determination.
- E-commerce calls for integrated digital payments and upskilling SMEs.
Topics: Digital Transformation, Green Economy, African Economy, Trade
Digital tools and technologies should be integrated into primary sectors like agriculture for effective production and trade
Supporting facts:
- Optimized production is a response to global increase in food prices.
- The precision offered by digital tools in agriculture could help in identifying and managing production chains, thereby aligning products to fit high value markets.
- Digital tools are necessary for determining inputs in agriculture and precise pricing.
Topics: Digital Transformation, Agriculture, Trade
The different states of transition among different countries in negotiations is a major challenge
Supporting facts:
- Not all countries have e-commerce policies streamlined
- Digital capacities and capabilities vary across countries
Topics: Trade negotiations, Digital trade, E-commerce
Recognizing and acknowledging state of play in different countries is essential
Supporting facts:
- Putting up public instruments facilitate transition
- Chances should be given to those who are less capable in transition
Topics: Trade negotiations, E-commerce, Digital trade
Emma suggests three ways to enable more incentives for developing countries to join negotiations
Supporting facts:
- There is a need to recognize different levels, priorities, and perspectives in digital trade negotiation
- There is a specific lack of bureaucratic capacity specifically in digital trade negotiation
- We need to adapt our development support to these countries to meet the evolving trend of digitalization
- 0.4% of the trade-related development aid goes to digital, which needs to get increased
Topics: Digital Trade, Digitalization, Trade Negotiations, E-commerce Negotiations
Standardization process is aimed at inclusivity and integrating different regions and perspectives.
Supporting facts:
- Bridging the digital standardization gap program was set up to focus on developing countries where there is lack of awareness or engagement.
Topics: Standardization, Inclusivity, Perspective gathering
ITU is trying to extend the process of the standards beyond the ICT community. Environment community and trade community are key for green standards.
Supporting facts:
- IEC, ISO and ITU are currently discussing a joint statement on green by design principles for all future standards.
Topics: ITU, ICT community, Green standards
Standards are voluntary and raising their awareness is vital.
Supporting facts:
- An ITU standard on universal chargers and adapters in 2010 influenced the EU decision to enforce type C USB charger for all tablets, mobile phones, and cameras by end of 2024 and for laptops by 2026.
Topics: Standards, Awareness
The process of standardization and its uptake in the industry is slow and often requires regulatory intervention to prompt its use
Supporting facts:
- EU regulation forced Apple to comply with the new USB-C standard
Topics: Standardization, Industry Compliance, Regulation
Working on an action plan to implement green standards
Supporting facts:
- A group of industry leaders are consulting and mapping the green standards present in the industry and identifying best practices.
- The action plan would be launched at COP.
Topics: green standards, sustainability, climate change
Need to accelerate policymaking process for green standards.
Topics: policymaking, green standards, climate change
Rwanda has an e-waste facility that uses state-of-the-art technology to collect and renew electronic materials, converting around 10,000 tons per year.
Supporting facts:
- Rwanda's e-waste facility renews and recycles multiple electronic materials, including mobiles and computers
Topics: E-waste, Recycling, Innovation
Transition to a green economy requires a multi-sector approach and strong collaboration between private operators, education institutions, and government policies.
Supporting facts:
- Rwanda has converted some of its common modes of transport like motorcycles to electronic versions with the collaboration of private sector
Topics: Green Economy, Public-Private Partnership, Environmental Policy
Companies should not only push trading in markets but also consider models that support the removal of harmful materials and are sensitive to mother nature.
Topics: Corporate Social Responsibility, Sustainable Business Practices
E-waste needs to be managed effectively
Supporting facts:
- China has released an app for waste pickers to collect e-waste appropriately
- E-waste system in China has been digitized
Topics: Digital Strategy, Waste Management
Server center emissions needs to be reduced
Supporting facts:
- Need to consider combining renewable energy with server centers
Topics: Digital Technology, Renewable Energy
Extraction of minerals is an underlying issue of digital transition
Supporting facts:
- This is an indirect issue of the digital strategy, not directly visible
Topics: Mineral Extraction, National Digital Strategy
Partnership is essential and there should be a holistic approach where all ministries and departments talk to each other
Supporting facts:
- Trade should be in discussion with the Environment and Digital ministries
Topics: partership, holistic approach
Promotion of Coalition for Digital Environmental Sustainability
Supporting facts:
- Reina Otsuka encouraged people to join the coalition for more learning and diversity in discussion
Topics: digital environmental sustainability
Importance of collaboration in the green and digital agenda
Supporting facts:
- Robin Michelle Zuercher highlighted the importance of collaboration in the context of green and digital agendas
- The trade perspective is crucial in the discussion on green and digital agenda
Topics: Collaboration, Green and digital agenda, Trade perspective
Importance of collaboration, partnerships, strong complementarities in different levels of digital transition
Topics: Digital Transition, Partnerships
Switch to climate resilience solutions
Topics: Climate Resilience
Understanding the role of standards in trade
Topics: Trade, Standards
Emma Sävenborg is exploring the incorporation of green parts or environmental issues into her work in the digital context.
Supporting facts:
- Emma Sävenborg expressed her interest in evolving her role to 'Digital Green Trade Senior Advisor'
- She raises question about the lack of green parts in the negotiation process and the insufficient emphasis on environmental issues in the digital arena
Topics: Digital Trade, Environment, Negotiation
Report
The discussion centred around the significance of sustainable digital transformation and universal connectivity in achieving the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The International Telecommunication Union (ITU) played a central role, emphasising its mandate to connect the world. Member states have prioritised sustainable digital transformation alongside universal connectivity, recognising the need to address the environmental impact of digitalisation.
Collaboration emerged as a key theme, with participants stressing the importance of integrating digital and green transitions. The trade angle, circular economy, and dematerialisation were highlighted as key opportunities. The role of digital tools and data in policy making was emphasised, particularly the need for evidence-based decision making and the use of data by policy makers.
Trade was identified as essential for promoting innovation, disseminating technical knowledge, and advancing sustainability. However, challenges such as the digital divide and slow adoption of digital solutions by small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) were acknowledged. Efforts to regulate e-waste, promote circular economy practices, and establish green standards were discussed.
The participants underscored the need for partnerships and a holistic approach to address challenges and maximise the benefits of the digital and green agenda. They called for unified global dialogue and inclusive digital trade policies. The importance of interconnectedness in policy making, both domestically and internationally, was emphasised.
Furthermore, concern was raised about the potential widening of the gap between countries due to the rapid pace of digital transformation. Noteworthy initiatives, such as Rwanda's investment in digital infrastructure and e-waste management, as well as China's digitisation of its e-waste system, were highlighted as examples of integration of digital technology and potential for sustainable practices.
The significance of standards, particularly in promoting green practices and ensuring a level playing field in trade, was emphasised. Attention was drawn to the slow adoption of voluntary standards by the industry, suggesting the need for regulatory intervention to drive their implementation.
The involvement of the trade community in the standardisation process was deemed beneficial. Overall, the expanded summary emphasises the importance of sustainable digital transformation, universal connectivity, and the use of digital tools and data in achieving the SDGs. Collaboration, partnerships, and a comprehensive approach are seen as crucial to address challenges and maximise the positive impacts of the digital and green agenda.
RO
Reina Otsuka
Speech speed
184 words per minute
Speech length
2265 words
Speech time
738 secs
Arguments
Digital can enable countries to leapfrog obsolete environmental management and traceability methods
Supporting facts:
- United Nations Development Program works with 170 countries to support eradicating poverty and building resilience
Topics: Digital Transition, Environmental Management, Traceability
The green and digital transitions should be intertwined to address climate change and nature degradation in a more effective manner.
Supporting facts:
- Climate change and nature degradation are exponentially growing problems
- Digital transformation is also an exponentially growing trend
Topics: Climate Change, Digital Transformation, Green Transition
Digitalization has the potential to make operations 10x faster, efficient, and scalable, hence revolutionizing the socioeconomic system.
Supporting facts:
- Digital transformation is pushing for a 10x improvement in efficiency, speed, and scalability
Topics: Digital Transformation, Socioeconomic System
There is a need for open data and data sharing policies to eliminate duplication of data efforts and to build a digital infrastructure for innovation.
Supporting facts:
- The EU deforestation regulation requires commodity companies to regularly survey agriculture fields such as cocoa, resulting in duplication of efforts as different companies conduct their own surveys and do not share their data with one another.
- Farmers are surveyed multiple times a year without ever seeing their own map or data.
Topics: Digital Technology, Open Data, Data Sharing
e-waste is a critical area to consider when transitioning to digital technology
Supporting facts:
- China has created an app that connects citizens to waste pickers to ensure proper e-waste collection
- The entire e-waste system in China was digitized
- Rwanda may have a similar app
Topics: e-waste, digital transition
The emission from server centers needs to be addressed
Supporting facts:
- Consideration needed to combine renewable energy with server centers
Topics: Server Emission, Digital Technology
The extraction of minerals for digital technology is a hidden but significant issue
Topics: Mineral Extraction, Digital Technology
Safeguards related to these issues should be considered from the inception of a national digital strategy
Supporting facts:
- Countries should consider both environmental and social aspects when creating digital strategies
- Ongoing digital readiness assessment in Tanzania
Topics: Digital Strategy, Safeguards
Partnerships and holistic approach are essential for managing environmental and digital issues
Supporting facts:
- Reina pointed out the importance of various Ministries like trade, environment, digital etc talking together
- Mentioned a platform called the Coalition for Digital Environmental Sustainability
Topics: Partnerships, Holistic Approach, Environmental Sustainability, Digital Technology
Report
In this analysis, the speakers delve into the potential benefits and challenges of digital technology in addressing environmental issues and promoting sustainable development. They highlight the idea that digital technology can allow countries to bypass outdated environmental management and traceability methods and take a giant leap forward.
By embracing digital solutions, nations can revolutionize the way they manage their environment and ensure greater resilience in the face of challenges. The speakers also emphasize that digital transformation has the power to revolutionise the socioeconomic system. With digitalisation, operations can become ten times faster, more efficient, and scalable.
This can have a profound impact on economic growth and create opportunities for innovation and development. The potential for digital technology to drive socioeconomic progress is vast and can lead to significant advancements in various sectors. Another key point highlighted in the analysis is the role of digital technology in climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies.
For instance, smart agriculture and energy efficiency are examples of digital applications that can contribute to mitigating climate change. Real-time data obtained through digital technology is essential for early warning systems and risk-informed planning in adaptation strategies. By leveraging digital solutions, countries can enhance their efforts to combat climate change and build resilience in the face of its impacts.
However, the speakers caution that the green transition should not leave behind those who are most affected by climate change. While digital technologies bring numerous benefits, it is important to ensure inclusivity and consider the needs of marginalised communities. Many people, especially those in developing countries, still lack access to the internet, which hampers their ability to benefit from digital advancements.
Therefore, the green transition should be integrated with the digital transition to ensure that all sectors of society can reap the benefits and address environmental challenges effectively. Access to finance for green initiatives is another area where digital technology can play a significant role.
Digital solutions can facilitate data-based trust in carbon markets and support payment for ecosystem service (PES) schemes. These schemes compensate custodians of ecosystems for their efforts in preserving the environment. By leveraging digital technology, countries can improve financial mechanisms and support the transition towards a greener economy.
The analysis also emphasises the importance of open data and data sharing policies to eliminate duplication of efforts. It highlights the need for a digital infrastructure that promotes innovative solutions and collaboration. By sharing data openly, companies and organisations can avoid unnecessary duplication of data collection efforts, improving efficiency and fostering innovation.
Additionally, the speakers stress the need to build digital technology as an ecosystem that involves various stakeholders such as governments, the private sector, academic partners, local communities, and even citizen science. For digital technology to be adopted successfully and sustainably, it needs to be a collaborative effort.
They provide examples of successful engagements, such as the partnership between the Rwanda ICT Chamber of Commerce and a village community to develop business models for supporting a cold chain. This case study illustrates the concept of a digital ecosystem in practice and highlights the benefits of involving multiple stakeholders in the adoption of digital technology.
The analysis also touches upon several environmental issues associated with the digital transition. For instance, e-waste management and the environmental impact of server centres are significant concerns. The speakers suggest that these issues should be addressed to ensure a sustainable digital transition.
Furthermore, the extraction of minerals for digital technology is deemed a hidden but significant issue that must be reckoned with in the pursuit of sustainable development. When discussing national digital strategies, the speakers stress the importance of considering both environmental and social aspects.
Safeguards related to these issues should be implemented from the inception of a digital strategy to ensure that it aligns with sustainable development principles. They cite the ongoing digital readiness assessment in Tanzania as an example of the need to consider environmental and social factors in digital strategies.
Lastly, the speakers acknowledge that addressing environmental and digital issues requires partnerships and a holistic approach. They advocate for various ministries, such as trade, environment, and digital, to work together and collaborate on solutions. The Coalition for Digital Environmental Sustainability is highlighted as a platform that aims to foster such partnerships and encourage diverse discussions on these critical topics.
In conclusion, the speakers in this analysis shed light on the potential benefits and challenges of digital technology in addressing environmental issues and promoting sustainable development. They highlight the need to integrate digital and green transitions, ensure inclusivity, manage e-waste and server centre emissions, address mineral extraction concerns, and consider social and environmental safeguards in national digital strategies.
Partnerships and a holistic approach are seen as crucial for managing the complex intersection between digital and environmental sustainability. By embracing these ideas, countries can leverage digital technology to create a more sustainable and resilient future.
RN
Richard Niwenshuti
Speech speed
162 words per minute
Speech length
2136 words
Speech time
790 secs
Arguments
Usage of digital tools and data for policy decisions
Supporting facts:
- Relying on the strength and the capacities of digital tools for making the right policy decisions
Topics: Policy Making, Digital Tools
Significance of speed in trade
Supporting facts:
- In trade perspective, time is cost
Topics: Digital Trade, Speed
Digital trade aligns with sustainable solutions
Supporting facts:
- Digital trade minimizes the footprints of production.
Topics: Digital Trade, Sustainable Solutions
Different countries are at different levels of digital transition, including within Africa
Supporting facts:
- Rwanda has made a pathway by heavily investing in digital infrastructure
Topics: Digital transition, Africa, Digital Infrastructure
Understanding the need to invest in technologies that optimize production before talking about trade
Supporting facts:
- Globally, growth in food prices has been attributed to low production
- Digitization can help optimize agricultural processes leading to better pricing
Topics: Technology, Production, Trade
Negotiations on digital trade policy should take into account the differing levels of transition and capabilities between countries
Supporting facts:
- Not all countries have e-commerce policies yet
- The state of play of different countries on the continent varies significantly in terms of capacities and capabilities for digital trade
Topics: WTO negotiations, Digital trade policy, E-commerce
Implementation of state-of-the-art e-waste facilities in Rwanda
Supporting facts:
- The e-waste facility in Rwanda renews electronic materials and puts away hazardous materials
- The e-waste facility in Rwanda processes around 10,000 tons in a year
Topics: e-waste, Rwanda, renewable materials
New products should be sensitive to the environment
Supporting facts:
- Companies should look at models that support taking out materials out of space
- Companies should produce items that respond to climate issues
Topics: environment, product creation, private companies
Importance of collaboration, partnerships and complementarity in digital transition and climate resilience solution
Supporting facts:
- Mention of interesting platforms that have been noted for possible pursuit
Topics: Collaboration, Partnerships, Digital Transition, Climate Resilience Solution
Understanding the role of standards in trade
Supporting facts:
- Trade now relies on meeting certain voluntary metrics
Topics: Standards, Trade
Report
The analysis highlights the crucial role of digital tools in policy making and trade. It emphasizes that relying on the strength and capacities of digital tools is essential for making the right policy decisions. Digital tools provide policymakers with access to vast amounts of data, enabling them to analyze trends, assess impacts, and develop evidence-based strategies.
This supports the argument for the usage of digital tools and data for policy decisions, which aligns with SDG 9: Industry, Innovation, and Infrastructure. In the context of trade, the analysis underscores the importance of speed. It states that in trade, time is cost.
The faster the trade process, the more efficient and cost-effective it becomes. Digital tools enable businesses to streamline their operations, automate processes, and reduce time-consuming paperwork. This highlights the significance of speed in trade, which is crucial for achieving SDG 8: Decent Work and Economic Growth.
Furthermore, the analysis also emphasizes the alignment of digital trade with sustainable solutions. It highlights that digital trade minimizes the footprints of production. By digitizing trade processes, companies can reduce their reliance on physical resources, leading to lower carbon emissions and environmental impact.
This supports the argument that digital trade can contribute to achieving SDG 13: Climate Action. The analysis recognizes that different countries are at different levels of digital transition, including within Africa. It cites the example of Rwanda, which has made significant investments in digital infrastructure and serves as a pathway for other African countries.
The argument is made that investments in digital transitions should be prioritized in Africa to avail the benefits of wider market opportunities and digital trade. There is a need for digital payments integration and digital skills development for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in Africa.
Additionally, there is a desire to integrate digital tools in production chains to boost productivity, supporting SDG 9: Industry, Innovation, and Infrastructure. In terms of trade, the analysis emphasizes the need to invest in technologies that optimize production before focusing on trade.
It states that low production levels globally have attributed to the growth in food prices. Digitization can help optimize agricultural processes, leading to better pricing and increased food production, contributing to achieving SDG 2: Zero Hunger. The analysis highlights that digital tools play a key role in trading high-value products in mature markets.
It cites Rwanda's efforts to target high-value markets that require digital precision. Digital tools help maintain the standards and criteria necessary for entering these mature markets, supporting SDG 8: Decent Work and Economic Growth and SDG 9: Industry, Innovation, and Infrastructure. In terms of policy development, the analysis acknowledges the varying levels of transition and capabilities between countries.
It suggests that negotiations on digital trade policy should take into account these differences to ensure that policies are suitable for countries at different stages of digital transition. This underlines the need for more policy instruments and support to facilitate the transition for countries that are lagging behind in digital trade, contributing to SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals.
The analysis also recognizes the importance of combating e-waste and promoting responsible consumption and production. It highlights the implementation of state-of-the-art e-waste facilities in Rwanda, where electronic materials are renewed, and hazardous materials are safely handled. This showcases the commitment to responsible consumption and production practices, supporting SDG 12: Responsible Consumption and Production.
Regarding climate control, the analysis states that multi-sector interventions are necessary. It mentions Rwanda's goal of reducing carbon emissions by 38 percent by 2035 and its transition to electronic mobility. This highlights the need for collaboration, partnerships, and complementarity in achieving digital transition and climate resilience solutions, aligning with SDG 13: Climate Action and SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals.
In terms of trade standards, the analysis acknowledges that trade now relies on meeting certain voluntary metrics. This highlights the growing importance of standards in trade and the need for businesses to meet these metrics to ensure fair and sustainable trade practices, contributing to SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals and SDG 10: Reduced Inequalities.
Overall, the analysis highlights the significance of digital tools in policy making and trade, the need for investments in digital transitions, particularly in Africa, and the alignment of digital trade with sustainable solutions. It emphasizes the importance of considering different levels of transition and capabilities in digital trade policy negotiations.
It also stresses the need for responsible consumption and production practices, multi-sector interventions for climate control, and adherence to trade standards in achieving the Sustainable Development Goals.
RM
Robin Michelle Zuercher
Speech speed
191 words per minute
Speech length
2055 words
Speech time
645 secs
Arguments
Green and digital transformation should work hand in hand
Supporting facts:
- Sustainable digital transformation is put on an equal footing with universal connectivity at ITU
- Dematerialization angle is crucial for sustainable production and consumption
Topics: digitalization, sustainability, green transformation
Connectivity is key to ensuring inclusivity in the digital age
Supporting facts:
- 2.6 billion people are still not connected to internet
- ITU has the mandate for universal connectivity
- ITU works on international standards for technology and networks
- ITU has established a platform to connect the most difficult to connect
Topics: Digital divide, Internet connectivity, ITU initiatives
The growing ICT industry contributes to greenhouse gas emissions and e-waste
Supporting facts:
- ICT sector greenhouse gas emissions are growing
- 53.6 million metric tons of e-waste were generated in 2019
- Estimates suggest that e-waste could grow to 110 million metric tons by 2050
Topics: ICT industry, Greenhouse gas emissions, E-waste
Moving towards a circular economy and sustainable practices is crucial
Supporting facts:
- ITU works on guidelines and capacity building tools on green data centers
- ITU helps developing countries with e-waste regulation
- ITU is developing international standards on circularity design in products and digital product passports
Topics: Circular economy, E-waste regulation, Green data centers
The standardization process needs to be inclusive by integrating different regions and perspectives.
Supporting facts:
- ITU launched 'Bridging the Digital Standardization Gap' program to train developing countries on how they can contribute and participate in the standards process.
Topics: Standardization, Inclusivity
Strong involvement of different communities, such as trade and environment, can enhance the process of standards development.
Supporting facts:
- World Standards Cooperation is considering a joint statement on green by design principles for all future standards involving IEC, ISO, and ITU.
Topics: Trade, Environment, Standards development
Voluntary standards take time to develop and implement but have significant benefits.
Supporting facts:
- The type C USB charger standard, based on an ITU standard from 2010, will be applicable to all tablets, mobile phones, and cameras by the end of 2024 in the EU, extended to laptops by 2026.
Topics: Voluntary standards, Standard implementation
Standards are crucial tools for building transparent and equitable markets and ensuring a level playing field for all.
Supporting facts:
- Standards are behind many common tasks, like making a phone call or listening to music
Topics: Standards, Equitable markets
The significance of the trade perspective in the green and digital agenda
Topics: Trade, Green and digital agenda
Report
The analysis of the given statements highlights several significant points related to the relationship between green and digital transformation, the importance of connectivity, the impact of the ICT industry, the role of standards, and the need for collaboration. Firstly, there is a consensus among the speakers that green and digital transformation should work hand in hand.
Digitalisation is seen as having key opportunities in climate, trade, and the circular economy. This implies that incorporating sustainable digital practices can contribute to achieving environmental goals and promoting economic growth simultaneously. Connectivity is emphasised as a crucial factor for ensuring inclusivity in the digital age.
It is stated that 2.6 billion people do not have access to the internet, and the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) is mandated to work towards achieving universal connectivity. This indicates that providing internet access to all communities, especially the most difficult to connect, is seen as essential for bridging the digital divide and reducing inequalities.
However, it is acknowledged that the growing ICT industry has negative implications. The sector's greenhouse gas emissions are on the rise, and significant amounts of e-waste are being generated. Estimates suggest that e-waste could reach 110 million metric tons by 2050. The growing amount of e-waste and greenhouse gas emissions indicate that sustainable practices need to be implemented in the ICT industry to mitigate its environmental impact.
To address these challenges, speakers highlight the importance of moving towards a circular economy and adopting sustainable practices. The ITU is actively involved in developing guidelines and capacity building tools for green data centers, assisting developing countries with e-waste regulation, and working on international standards for circular design and digital product passports.
These initiatives aim to promote a circular economy and reduce the environmental impact of ICT-related activities. Collaboration and inclusivity are consistently emphasized as crucial for sustainable digital development. The ITU's diverse membership is highlighted as an asset in ensuring inclusivity in the standard-setting process.
The ITU is also leading a collaborative initiative for green digital action at COP28, demonstrating the commitment to fostering collaboration among stakeholders. Standards play a crucial role in building transparent and equitable markets, as they provide a level playing field for all participants.
Speakers point out that standards are behind common tasks such as making phone calls or listening to music, highlighting their pervasive influence. Regulators and policymakers are encouraged to incorporate standards when forming policies to enable sustainable and circular procurement of ICTs and influence supply chain formation.
The trade perspective is recognized as significant in the green and digital agenda. Speakers emphasize the need for collaboration between the trade community and the standardization process. This suggests that involving various communities, such as trade and environment, can enhance the process of standards development and ensure a holistic approach.
In conclusion, the analysis reveals the importance of integrating green and digital transformation, ensuring connectivity for inclusivity, addressing the negative impact of the ICT industry, promoting sustainable practices and a circular economy, fostering collaboration and inclusivity in the standardization process, and considering the trade perspective.
These insights provide valuable considerations for policymakers, regulators, and stakeholders involved in the sustainable development of digital technologies.