Bridging the Digital Divide for Transition to a Greener Economy

Arguments

WTO rules for services trade, work program on electronic commerce, & Joint Statement Initiative on electronic commerce are central to WTO's efforts in the digital sphere.

---

The needs on the ground reflected in the development dimension in the discussion of the Joint Statement Initiative (JSI)

---

Bindings in trade agreements are valuable

---

Loss of customs revenue due to the moratorium on electronic transmissions is a part of the discussion

---

Report

The World Trade Organization (WTO) plays a central role in digital trade discussions, focusing on areas such as electronic commerce and inclusivity. The WTO's services agreement provides insurance against policy reversals in digital sectors, ensuring stability for businesses. The work program on electronic commerce, established in 1998, allows WTO members to avoid imposing customs duties on electronic transmissions.

This promotes the free flow of information, bridging the digital divide and supporting developing countries. The Joint Statement Initiative (JSI) on electronic commerce involves 89 participating members working to build upon existing WTO rules and ensuring inclusivity for developing countries. Participating in global trade discussions allows developing countries to have their concerns represented and contribute to the rules that impact them.

Bindings in trade agreements offer certainty and predictability, attracting investment and providing market access. Developed countries have undertaken more bindings, supporting smaller players. The moratorium on electronic transmissions exempting them from customs duties has been a topic of discussion, with studies highlighting limited impacts that vary across specific countries.

Recognizing the importance of digital inputs, the WTO acknowledges their role in the development of digital and green economies. Duties on digital inputs can hinder growth in these sectors. Overall, the WTO's efforts in the digital sphere, including services agreement, work program on electronic commerce, and JSI, shape global digital trade policies.

They prioritize inclusivity, address concerns of developing countries, and promote certainty in trade agreements. The impact of the moratorium on electronic transmissions and the role of digital inputs are also recognized. The WTO works towards a digital future that promotes growth, reduces inequalities, and fosters partnerships for sustainable development.

Arguments

The ICT sector is taking initiatives to mitigate their own emissions

---

The Internet should stay a global public good

---

The impact of WTO policies on local transitions

---

Countries should have the flexibility to control participation of foreign corporations in their sectors without permanent commitments

---

Continuation of the moratorium on electronic transmission tariffs has led to loss of revenue for developing countries

---

Developing countries need resources and financing for infrastructure and for enhancing skills related to e-commerce

---

UNCTAD's role in capacity building on e-commerce vs advocating for rules beneficial to big tech/rich countries

---

The speaker disapproves the e-commerce duty-free policy proposed by Clinton and Blair in 1998

---

Report

The discussions revolved around several key topics, including the initiatives taken by the ICT sector to reduce carbon emissions and mitigate their environmental impact. The sector has been sourcing renewable energy through long-lasting contracts with suppliers, building efficient data centres that run on renewable energies, and replacing old networks with fibre for increased energy efficiency.

These efforts have been praised and are seen as positive steps towards addressing climate change. Another area of focus was the ongoing and more efficient review of the WTO telecoms agreement. It was argued that enhancing the effectiveness of regulators can lead to well-regulated markets and lower prices, ultimately benefiting users in terms of affordability and choice.

The sentiment towards this topic was positive, highlighting the potential positive impact of such a review. The discussion also touched upon the importance of the Internet as a global public good. It was highlighted that 51% of the world population is currently connected to the Internet, demonstrating its widespread reach and impact.

There was a consensus that the Internet should remain globally accessible and not be fragmented, as this is seen as vital for fostering innovation, enabling connectivity, and promoting economic growth. However, there was opposition expressed towards the fragmentation of the Internet, with concerns raised about the potential negative consequences of such a development.

When it came to WTO policies, the impact on local transitions was deemed a neutral topic, with a desire to understand the correlation between WTO's policies and local/domestic initiatives. This reflects a need for further exploration and analysis of the effects of such policies on local economies.

Furthermore, there was a negative sentiment towards the control of foreign corporations in sectors without permanent commitments. The argument put forth was that countries should have the flexibility to control the participation of foreign corporations in their sectors without being bound by permanent commitments.

Bolivian hospital services' commitment under WTO rules was mentioned as an example, resulting in decreased autonomy due to the inability to withdraw commitment. The continuation of the moratorium on electronic transmission tariffs also received criticism, as it has led to significant revenue losses for developing countries.

It was noted that developing countries and least developed countries (LDCs) lost approximately 56 billion US dollars in tariff revenue from 2017 to 2020. Moreover, major corporations not having to pay taxes on their profits made in developing countries further compounded the issue.

This negative sentiment underscores the need to reassess the impact of the moratorium on developing economies. The discussions also revealed opposition to the plurilateral Joint Statement Initiative on E-commerce being negotiated in the WTO. It was highlighted that multilateral discussions on e-commerce were rejected at the Buenos Aires Ministerial, and there was a concern that multilateral resources of the WTO were being directed towards plurilateral discussions instead.

This negative sentiment towards the initiative reflected a desire for a more inclusive approach and a focus on reducing inequalities. Developing countries' needs for resources and financing for infrastructure and skills development related to e-commerce were considered a neutral topic.

This highlighted the recognition of the importance of supporting developing countries in their efforts to leverage e-commerce for economic growth and development. There was also a negative sentiment expressed towards the role of UNCTAD (United Nations Conference on Trade and Development) in capacity building on e-commerce.

It was argued that UNCTAD, as a neutral arbiter, should focus on advocating for rules beneficial to developing countries instead of favouring big tech and rich countries. This reflects a concern that the needs of developing countries might not be adequately represented or prioritised in the current discourse.

Overall, the discussions provided a comprehensive overview of the various perspectives and concerns surrounding the ICT sector, internet access, WTO policies, and e-commerce. The sentiments expressed highlighted a mix of positive, negative, and neutral views, underscoring the complexity and diverse range of opinions on these important topics.

Arguments

Digital technologies can contribute significantly towards achieving sustainability goals

---

Evidence shows that the silos are breaking down in how governments plan to meet green and digital challenges

---

More focus should be put on openness to deal with global challenges

---

Bridging the digital divide requires more than just internet access

---

Report

Digital technologies have the potential to significantly contribute to achieving sustainability goals. According to the Global Enabling Sustainability Initiative, 103 out of the 169 sustainable development goals can be directly influenced by digital technologies. The deployment of existing digital technologies is projected to accelerate progress in sustainability by 22% and mitigate downward trends by 23%.

Digital tools have a wide range of applications in various sectors, such as monitoring energy efficiency, facilitating the reuse of components and materials for the circular economy, and managing traffic. These tools also play a significant role in the agricultural sector by helping farmers reduce water and fertilizer consumption.

Governments are recognising the positive impact of information and communication technology (ICT) and internet connectivity on climate action and energy improvement. For instance, the Philippines is emphasising the role of ICT in its efforts to address climate change and improve energy efficiency.

Additionally, digital technologies improve efficiency and productivity across diverse sectors, including manufacturing, construction, and agriculture. Bridging the digital divide requires the development of digital skills, infrastructure, and suitable regulatory frameworks. It is crucial not to miss opportunities to utilise digital technologies in solving global problems.

In conclusion, digital technologies offer immense potential for achieving sustainability goals. They can drive progress in sustainability, promote efficient resource use, and facilitate the transition to a circular economy. It is important for governments to recognise the importance of ICT and internet connectivity in addressing climate action and energy improvement.

Bridging the digital divide and promoting cooperation are key to maximising the benefits of digital technologies and addressing global challenges.

Arguments

A digital divide exists between developed and developing countries

---

Both digital and green transformations are necessary and interconnected

---

Trade policy starts at home, and this applies to the digital economy and green economy

---

The transformation to green and digital economy requires deliberate decisions and actions at the domestic level

---

Importance of educating the newer generations about the challenges and solutions of green and digital economy

---

Report

The analysis explores the complex relationship between digital transformation and sustainability, highlighting several key points. Firstly, it reveals the existence of a digital divide between developed and developing countries. The study emphasizes that although internet access is crucial, it alone is insufficient to bridge this divide.

More developed regions within countries tend to have better connectivity than less developed areas. This digital divide contributes to income inequality and poverty as individuals in less connected areas miss out on economic opportunities provided by digital technologies. Another important aspect is the interconnectedness of digital and green transformations.

The analysis underscores the role of digital technologies in reducing greenhouse gas emissions and optimizing energy use. These technologies can aid in the transition to renewable energy sources and provide platforms for the trading of renewable energy credits. Engagement of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) is essential for sustainable practices in the green production process.

The analysis emphasizes that both digital and green transformations are vital and mutually dependent for a sustainable future. Additionally, the study notes that improvements in digital technology alone do not guarantee the achievement of sustainability goals. Deliberate decisions and actions are required to ensure that digital transformation aligns with sustainability objectives.

This deliberate approach highlights the need to consider the impact of digitalization on climate and work towards climate-beneficial digitalization. Furthermore, the analysis stresses the importance of establishing a regulatory framework and robust infrastructure to enable access to digital technologies. It suggests that reliable infrastructure is necessary for effective digital transformation.

Moreover, the low percentage of financing for information and communication technology (ICT) by multilateral development banks highlights the need for increased investment in this area. The analysis emphasizes the concept of global digital public goods, which are seen as crucial for bridging the digital divide.

Digital public infrastructure plays a critical role in achieving this goal. Additionally, it underscores the importance of empowering individuals through digital skills and knowledge, with a focus on integrating these skills into education and training programs. The analysis also highlights the significance of domestic policies and regulations in trade, particularly in the context of the digital and green economies.

It argues that trade policy should begin at home, suggesting that domestic-level decisions and actions play a significant role in shaping these economies. Finally, the analysis suggests that international efforts should prioritize the regulation of emerging technologies like artificial intelligence (AI), which may have negative externalities.

It advocates for a thorough examination of the potential risks and consequences associated with AI, and the implementation of regulatory measures to mitigate these effects. In conclusion, the analysis focuses on the existence of a digital divide and its impact on income inequality and poverty.

It underscores the interconnectedness of digital and green transformations, emphasizing the importance of deliberate decisions and actions to align digital transformation with sustainability objectives. The analysis also highlights the significance of establishing a regulatory framework and infrastructure for digital access, along with the role of global digital public goods.

Additionally, it addresses the importance of equipping future generations with the necessary knowledge and skills to navigate the challenges and opportunities of the green and digital economies. Finally, it highlights the need for international regulation of emerging technologies to effectively manage potential risks.

Arguments

Digital revolution acts as an important driver of decarbonization

---

Significant challenges lie ahead, especially the digital divide between developed and developing countries

---

Digital and green are interconnected

---

Digital technologies have the potential to balance negative environmental externalities

---

The importance of reducing vulnerabilities of those that are falling behind

---

The need for a fair, just and inclusive twin transformation

---

There is lack of discussion related to interaction between digital transformation and the environmental one in WTO

---

Report

The analysis highlights the pivotal role of digitalization in driving decarbonization efforts and promoting a green transformation. According to the World Trade Organization (WTO)'s 2022 World Trade Report titled "Climate Change and International Trade," digitalization is recognized as a significant driver of decarbonization.

This acknowledgement underscores the positive impact of digital technologies in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Moreover, the analysis reveals that existing digital technologies are contributing to shrinking the carbon footprint in key sectors, including energy, transport, manufacturing, construction, and agriculture. Investments in digital technologies facilitating green transitions have also seen substantial growth.

These findings emphasize the interconnection between digital and green transitions, showcasing how digital technologies can contribute to achieving sustainability goals. However, the analysis also highlights a pressing challenge, the digital divide between developed and developing countries. Bridging this divide is crucial as it can impede progress towards sustainable development.

The report points out that the digital divide disproportionately affects certain groups, such as women, youth, farmers, and businesses in remote locations. Therefore, reducing this divide is essential for promoting inclusivity and ensuring equitable access to digital benefits for all.

The analysis emphasizes the importance of the WTO in discussions related to digital transformation and the green economy. However, it also reveals a dearth of in-depth discussions on the interaction between digital transformation and the environment within the organization. There is a need for more comprehensive dialogue and collaboration between the fields of digital transformation and environmental sustainability within the WTO to address this gap.

Additionally, the report highlights the potential of digital technologies to counterweigh negative environmental externalities. Despite accounting for only 1.4% of global carbon emissions, the ICT sector contributes to reducing greenhouse gas intensity across the entire economy. The growth in emissions from the sector is projected to be offset by energy efficiencies and increased use of renewables.

This underscores the positive role that digital technologies can play in promoting responsible consumption and production. In conclusion, the analysis underscores the significance of digitalization in driving decarbonization efforts and promoting green transformations. It emphasizes the need to address the digital divide, particularly in developing countries, and calls for the WTO to foster more comprehensive discussions and collaboration between the fields of digital transformation and environmental sustainability.

Digital technologies have the potential to mitigate negative environmental impacts and contribute to the achievement of sustainable development goals.

Arguments

breaking the silos is important

---

national expertise should be empowered

---

promote digital and environmental literacy

---

infrastructure needs simultaneous development

---

reskilling is important to fit the future workforce

---

financial access for SMEs is crucial

---

adoption of enabling rulebook is necessary

---

inclusion of twin transition in trade relations is necessary

---

The work program on electronic commerce is on the right track with development at its core

---

The environmental impact of e-commerce needs to be investigated and addressed

---

Report

The analysis highlights various key points related to achieving twin transitions and the importance of collaboration and coordination among policymakers. One key point raised by UNCTAD is the need for a twin transition, which involves both the digital and green transitions.

To successfully accomplish this, policymakers must work together and break down silos. This collaboration is essential to ensure a smooth transition that encompasses various sectors and areas, such as technology, economy, and policymaking. Another important aspect identified is the significance of empowering national expertise.

It is argued that domestic academia, researchers, and tech experts possess a better understanding of the local context. Therefore, investment should be made in leveraging local resources and knowledge to empower national expertise. This approach would enable countries to address challenges effectively and devise strategies that align with their specific circumstances.

The analysis also emphasizes the need to promote digital and environmental literacy, particularly among the younger generation known as Generation Z and Alpha. These young individuals are more aware of environmental issues and require access to online resources and digital tools to enhance their understanding and contribute towards sustainable development efforts.

Furthermore, the development of robust digital and eco-friendly infrastructure is deemed crucial. It is suggested that by investing in such infrastructure, countries can meet the demands of the twin transition effectively. Additionally, adopting green public procurement practices can stimulate demand for green products and services, thereby contributing to the overall sustainability agenda.

Reskilling the workforce is another important consideration highlighted in the analysis. A study by Microsoft estimates the emergence of numerous technology-oriented jobs by 2025, indicating the need for prioritising upskilling initiatives. By providing individuals with the necessary skills, they can enhance their employability and successfully adapt to the changing needs of the future workforce.

The analysis also underscores the importance of inclusive and innovative funding mechanisms for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). These mechanisms can support the growth and development of SMEs, ensuring their financial access and reducing inequalities in the economic landscape. Trade policies also play a crucial role in facilitating the twin transition.

It is argued that trade policies should enable access to technologies, goods, and services required for the transition. Countries need to prioritise their specific needs and align their trade policies accordingly to effectively integrate into the twin transition process. The inclusion of the twin transition in bilateral and regional trade agreements is deemed necessary for successful implementation.

It is suggested that these agreements should incorporate provisions that address both digital and green transitions. Moreover, the innovation of technology transfer frameworks is seen as crucial in facilitating knowledge exchange and collaboration among countries. The analysis also examines the work programme on electronic commerce, recognising its focus on development.

However, it raises concern over the absence of the African continent from the Joint Statement Initiatives (JSIs). This observation signifies that not all developing countries are adequately represented, highlighting the need for more inclusive participation and collaboration. Lastly, the analysis draws attention to the environmental impact of e-commerce.

It is noted that the text lacks proposals addressing this environmental concern. The impacts of e-commerce on the environment should be investigated more thoroughly, and appropriate measures need to be implemented to mitigate negative effects. In conclusion, the analysis highlights the importance of breaking silos, leveraging national expertise, promoting digital and environmental literacy, developing robust infrastructure, reskilling the workforce, ensuring financial access for SMEs, enabling trade policies, and addressing the environmental impact of e-commerce to achieve twin transitions successfully.

By considering these factors and implementing appropriate strategies, countries can foster sustainable development and contribute to the attainment of relevant Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).