Main Session on Cybersecurity, Trust & Safety Online | IGF 2023
Event report
Speakers
- Alissa Starzak, Cloudflare’s Vice President, Global Head of Public Policy
- Christopher Painter, Director, Global Forum on Cyber Expertise
- Elizaveta Belyakova, Chairperson, Alliance for the Protection of Children in the Digital Environment
- Ernesto RodrÃguez Hernández, Vice Minister of Communications, Cuba
- Folake Olagunju, Program Officer for Cybersecurity, Internet and eApplications, ECOWAS
- Katitza Rodriguez, EFF Policy Director for Global Privacy
Table of contents
Disclaimer: This is not an official record of the IGF session. The DiploAI system automatically generates these resources from the audiovisual recording. Resources are presented in their original format, as provided by the AI (e.g. including any spelling mistakes). The accuracy of these resources cannot be guaranteed. The official record of the session can be found on the IGF's official website.
Knowledge Graph of Debate
Session report
Moderator 1
The analysis provides insights into various aspects of cybersecurity and cybercrime, including the relationship between global initiatives and national regulations and activities. It examines the need to enhance the link between global and national policies in this area. The analysis also highlights the role of the Internet Governance Forum (IGF) in facilitating multi-stakeholder discussions on cybersecurity initiatives. It emphasizes the importance of IGF in providing a platform for ministers, industry experts, and civil society representatives to engage in discussions and exchange ideas on cybersecurity.
Another proposed solution discussed in the analysis is the creation of a database of cybersecurity experts for knowledge sharing. Efforts have been made to develop such databases within the Organization of American States and through the United Nations' open-ended working group on cybersecurity. The aim is to facilitate information exchange and collaboration among different countries and regions.
The analysis also mentions the agreement on the need for a pool of knowledge to aid in dealing with cybercrime. Olga Cavalli, a contributor in the analysis, supports the idea of having a knowledge pool to enhance capabilities in tackling cybercrime.
Furthermore, the importance of dialogue and cooperation in leveraging technology is emphasized. Active participation, interaction, learning, and sharing information are highlighted as key elements in harnessing the potential of technology. The analysis advocates for trusting in human skills and potential in the context of technology.
Overall, the analysis reveals the interconnectedness of global initiatives, national regulations, and activities in the field of cybersecurity and cybercrime. It underscores the significance of multistakeholder dialogues, knowledge sharing, and cooperation in addressing these issues effectively. The positive sentiment expressed throughout the analysis signifies a collective belief in the potential of these approaches in building more secure and resilient digital environments.
Katitza Rodriguez, EFF Policy Director for Global Privacy
The discussions on cybercrime and cybersecurity highlight the importance of finding a balance between security and the protection of privacy and human rights. However, the current UN Cybercrime Treaty is viewed as counterproductive and potentially undermines privacy rights. It focuses primarily on enhancing law enforcement powers, with minimal attention given to strengthening systems and networks at a technical level. Additionally, certain provisions within the treaty could criminalise the work of independent security researchers and allow governments to force engineers to compromise security measures, potentially violating privacy.
To address the challenges of cybersecurity, it is suggested that systems and networks need to be strengthened at the technical level. This would require better incentives to encourage the development of more secure software, devices, and networks. Legal protections for security researchers are also necessary to ensure their work in identifying vulnerabilities and improving security is not hindered. Furthermore, there is a need for enhanced education and information sharing about threats, vulnerabilities, and solutions among users and developers.
One of the major concerns with the current UN Cybercrime Treaty is the lack of adequate safeguards and disparities in privacy protections across different countries. The treaty places mandatory powers for criminal investigations, while the safeguards remain optional. This opens the door for potential abuses and compromises privacy rights. The variation in privacy protection across countries also raises concerns about meeting international human rights standards, as international cooperation in dealing with cybercrime may depend on the privacy protection provided by the assisting country's national law.
Another argument presented is that there should be a minimum baseline for privacy protections in the UN Cybercrime Treaty. It is suggested that treaty-specific safeguards should be put in place to protect and establish a baseline for international cooperation. Currently, there is a significant disparity in the level of privacy protections and human rights from one country to another.
Companies also play a crucial role in upholding human rights. It is argued that companies should have grounds to refuse cooperation if a request is disproportional or violates human rights law. The broad scope of the treaty may lead to potential abuses, and companies need the ability to deny cooperation on grounds of human rights violations.
Overall, the discussions on cybercrime and cybersecurity underscore the need to ensure that human rights and privacy are not compromised in the pursuit of security. The current UN Cybercrime Treaty lacks adequate safeguards and may potentially violate privacy rights. Strengthening systems and networks at a technical level, providing legal protections for security researchers, and enhancing education and information sharing are seen as positive steps. A minimum baseline for privacy protections is necessary, and companies should have the ability to refuse cooperation if it violates human rights. Upholding human rights and promoting international cooperation are essential in effectively addressing cybercrime.
Ernesto RodrÃguez Hernández, Vice Minister of Communications, Cuba
There is increasing concern regarding the development of cyber offensive capabilities and the legitimacy of using force in response to cyber attacks, particularly for certain states. These states have included offensive cyber weapons as part of their national security strategies and doctrines, considering the use of force as a legitimate response to cyber attacks. This trend raises questions about the potential implications and consequences of such actions in international relations and security.
The misuse of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) and media platforms has emerged as a significant threat to nations. Individuals, organizations, and states are covertly and unlawfully exploiting computer systems to carry out attacks. These activities can potentially trigger international conflicts. Moreover, social networks and electronic broadcasts are being used as tools for interventionism, promoting hate speech, incitement to violence, destabilization, and the dissemination of false information and fake news. This misuse of ICTs and media platforms not only endangers peaceful relations but also undermines principles of justice and strong institutions.
To address these challenges, it is suggested that countries commit to using ICTs for peaceful purposes, fostering cooperation and development. A global commitment should be established, encouraging nations to utilize information and communication technologies for the betterment of society. Additionally, implementing technical assistance mechanisms to exchange good practices can enhance international cooperation in this domain.
In addition to commitments and cooperation, the development of a legally binding international instrument is necessary to bridge the gaps in cybersecurity. This instrument should complement existing international law and effectively address the growing challenges and threats in cyberspace. International cooperation is crucial in tackling these issues and ensuring stability and security in the digital realm.
It is also acknowledged that existing international laws need adjustments to encompass cyberspace adequately. Given the highly dynamic nature of cyberspace, traditional laws may not cover emerging issues. Thus, a binding regulatory framework is needed to establish clear standards and criteria for cyber activities. Additionally, violations of treaties and conventions should be effectively addressed to maintain the integrity and security of the digital world.
The complexities involved in maintaining good cyber practices and the violations of treaties and conventions highlight the need for comprehensive solutions. It is important to address the challenges faced by both developing and developed countries in the digital arena. Developing countries, in particular, face difficulties due to the digital divide, leading to disparities in accessing information and financing for development. Bridging this divide and promoting equal opportunities for all nations is crucial for achieving sustainable development and reducing inequalities.
The importance of discussions and consensus-building regarding cyberspace-related topics is crucial. Continued dialogue among nations and stakeholders is necessary to navigate the complex landscape of cyberspace and develop shared norms and principles. Such discussions can help establish conventions that promote the development of all peoples and safeguard global interests.
Lastly, it is important to recognize the time constraints involved in addressing all the issues in the world of cyberspace. The rapidly evolving nature of technology and the increasing threats in cyberspace pose significant challenges. While it is essential to strive for comprehensive solutions, it is also prudent to acknowledge the limitations and prioritize actions that can have the greatest impact in mitigating risks and promoting a secure and peaceful cyberspace.
In conclusion, the analysis highlights the pressing need for regulations and international cooperation to address the growing challenges in cyberspace. This includes concerns about the development of cyber offensive capabilities, the misuse of ICTs and media platforms, and the gaps in current cybersecurity measures. Adopting a binding regulatory framework, adjusting existing international laws, bridging the digital divide, and fostering dialogue and consensus-building are vital steps towards creating a safer and more inclusive digital environment.
Elizaveta Belyakova, Chairperson, Alliance for the Protection of Children in the Digital Environment
The protection of children from cyber security threats and cyber crime is highlighted as a crucial matter in the collection of statements. The creation of the Russian Alliance for the Protection of Children in the Digital Environment demonstrates the commitment to address this issue. Furthermore, the issue gained recognition at the 2023 BRICS Summit, where participating countries pledged to take action to secure a safe digital environment for children. Major IT companies are urged to commit to initiatives aimed at mobilizing the public to protect children on the Internet. The Russian IT society has already taken voluntary steps in this direction. Additionally, the Digital Ethics of Childhood Charter was established to establish ethical principles regarding children's online safety. A major concern expressed in the statements is the threat of sexual exploitation and abuse of children on the Internet. Disturbingly, a UN statistic reveals that 80% of children in 25 countries reportedly feel at risk of sexual abuse or exploitation online. The We Protect Global Alliance goes as far as to describe the easy access to child sexual abuse material online as a "tsunami."
The need for data exchange pertaining to the localization of harmful and dangerous material, as well as information on new criminal methods and attacker details, is stressed. In 2022, the removal of 9,126 units of content relied on a hash database with the involvement of major players in the Russian IT market. Furthermore, joint efforts and open discussions are considered essential in protecting children from cyber threats. Elisaveta, a prominent figure, emphasizes the significance of collective actions in safeguarding children against such threats.
In conclusion, the protection of children from cyber security threats and cyber crime is a pressing issue. The establishment of organizations such as the Russian Alliance for the Protection of Children in the Digital Environment and voluntary commitments by major IT companies demonstrate progress towards securing a safe digital environment for children. However, the prevalence of sexual exploitation and abuse online remains a distressing concern, necessitating further action and cooperation.
Folake Olagunju, Program Officer for Cybersecurity, Internet and eApplications, ECOWAS
The analysis conducted on cybersecurity in the West African region reveals several key findings. One major issue is the lack of national and regional coordination to effectively combat cyber threats. This coordination is crucial for developing and implementing comprehensive strategies that address the complex challenges posed by cybercrime. Due to resource limitations on technical, financial, and human fronts, the West African region is ill-equipped to tackle cybersecurity effectively.
Another important aspect highlighted in the analysis is the insufficient allocation of resources to the cybersecurity sector. Many member states do not have dedicated budget line items for cybersecurity, which hampers their ability to invest in the necessary tools and technologies needed to protect against cyber threats. Additionally, there is a shortage of qualified personnel in the region, further exacerbating the problem. Furthermore, the weak critical infrastructure in West Africa makes it particularly susceptible to cyber attacks, with frequent power outages and telecommunication disruptions already being commonplace.
The COVID-19 pandemic has brought necessary attention to the importance of cybersecurity and digitalization. As member states were forced to adopt digital solutions to meet the daily needs of their citizens, the conversation around digitalization security increased. This shift has highlighted the need for robust cybersecurity measures to safeguard critical systems and protect personal data.
The analysis also emphasizes the need for increased cooperation, information sharing, and involvement of the private sector in cybersecurity efforts. Peer-to-peer cooperation between member states is crucial for effectively combating cyber threats. Furthermore, the analysis suggests that incentives for workers and partnerships with the private sector can significantly improve the cybersecurity landscape in the region.
The approach taken by the Global Forum on Cyber Expertise (GFCE) in collaborating with regional economic communities, such as the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), is commendable. The GFCE aims to enhance capacity building in the region through such partnerships, which aligns with the goals and needs of the West African countries.
While global best practices in cybersecurity are valuable, the analysis highlights the need for local adaptations. Cybersecurity practices from other regions, such as the US, may not be directly applicable in West Africa without considering the local context and challenges. Therefore, promoting a practical approach to cybersecurity and encouraging local adaptation of global strategies are essential.
To address the issues surrounding cybersecurity in the region, a joint platform for advancing cybersecurity in West Africa was launched under the G7 German presidency. This program aims to establish an Information Sharing and Analysis Center (ISAC). The establishment of such a center is considered an excellent approach to enhancing information sharing and cooperation among stakeholders.
In conclusion, the comprehensive analysis of cybersecurity in West Africa underscores the urgent need for action. Promoting a cybersecurity culture, improving communication, coordination, and cooperation at both national and regional levels, and prioritizing resource allocation are vital steps to effectively combat cyber threats in the region. Additionally, the analysis highlights the significance of local adaptations, capacity building, and the involvement of the private sector in addressing cybersecurity challenges and protecting critical infrastructure.
Christopher Painter, Director, Global Forum on Cyber Expertise
The analysis explores various arguments surrounding cybercrime negotiations, stakeholder involvement, capacity building, cybersecurity, emerging technologies, and the digital economy.
One of the key points highlighted is the need for expertise in cybercrime negotiations. The analysis suggests that negotiations often lack input from experts who understand the real challenges on the ground. It further notes that the current model of negotiations, which is primarily built for countries, tends to involve a lot of geopolitical issues. This argument highlights the importance of including expert knowledge to develop effective policies to combat cybercrime.
Another argument put forth is the crucial involvement of stakeholders outside of government in cybercrime discussions. The analysis emphasizes that there is a wealth of outside expertise and insights available, and bringing in this expertise is essential for creating effective policies. This argument recognizes the need to involve various stakeholders such as industry experts, civil society organizations, and academia to ensure a more comprehensive approach to tackling cybercrime.
The analysis also addresses the growing international issue of cybercrime. It notes that cybercrime, particularly ransomware attacks, has significantly affected people's daily lives, making it a pocketbook and backyard issue for many individuals. Additionally, cybercrime has become a political priority for countries around the world. These observations underscore the urgency of addressing cybercrime as a pressing global challenge.
In terms of cybersecurity, the analysis highlights the need for sustained attention to this issue. It acknowledges that cybersecurity has matured as a policy concern but identifies the challenge of bridging the gap between the political level and the practitioner level. The analysis suggests that ransomware attacks have helped raise the profile of cybersecurity and the importance of protecting against new and existing threats.
Furthermore, the analysis touches on the issue of policymakers feeling intimidated by technical issues. It points out that policymakers often struggle to understand complex technical concepts, which can hinder effective policymaking. However, the analysis argues that technical concepts can be understood by non-technicians if they are adequately explained. This highlights the importance of effective communication and education to bridge the gap between technical experts and policymakers.
Capacity building is also identified as a key aspect in the analysis. It highlights that countries, especially developing ones, require assistance in dealing with cybersecurity threats, building national strategies, establishing emergency response teams, and applying international norms and laws. The analysis praises the Global Forum on Cyber Expertise for coordinating capacity-building efforts worldwide.
Notably, the analysis observes the importance of not losing sight of the larger cybersecurity issue amidst the focus on emerging technologies. While emerging technologies are part of the problem, it is crucial to maintain a holistic approach to cybersecurity.
In conclusion, the analysis provides insights into various aspects of cybercrime, cybersecurity, stakeholder involvement, and capacity building. It underscores the need for expertise in cybercrime negotiations and involving stakeholders outside of government. The analysis highlights the urgency of addressing cybercrime as a global issue and the necessity of sustained attention to cybersecurity. It also emphasizes the importance of adequately explaining technical concepts, capacity building efforts, and maintaining a balance between addressing emerging technologies and the larger cybersecurity challenges.
Audience
The analysis encompasses a range of important discussions relating to cybersecurity, digitalisation, international law, knowledge-sharing, and solar technology. One notable point emphasised is the need to effectively utilise emerging technologies to enhance cybersecurity measures. This argument underscores the importance of staying ahead of cyber threats by employing advanced technologies. Policymakers are urged to prioritise cybersecurity and treat it seriously.
The significance of cybersecurity is further underscored by research findings which indicate a potential increase in a country's GDP per capita with the maturity and implementation of robust cybersecurity measures. This evidence demonstrates the economic benefits that can be gained through investing in cybersecurity.
The debate surrounding the need for a legally binding instrument to govern responsible state behaviour in cyberspace is another key aspect addressed. While international law is already deemed applicable in cyberspace, there is a call for a specific instrument to address the complexities and unique challenges of cybersecurity. The involvement of stakeholders such as the technical community, civil society, and international law firms is viewed as crucial in shaping this instrument.
The analysis also highlights the importance of knowledge-sharing in the context of cybersecurity. It suggests the creation of a worldwide knowledge pool accessible to individuals across different regions, including Africa and South West Africa. The inclusion of non-technical aspects, such as social, psychological, and gender considerations, is emphasised as essential in developing comprehensive cybersecurity strategies.
In terms of infrastructure development, the potential of using solar technology to address the electricity gap in West Africa's telecommunications sector is explored. This could potentially provide a sustainable solution to power critical telecommunications infrastructure.
Another important topic in the analysis is the need for specific measures to ensure the safety and security of children online. It is argued that a holistic approach to cybersecurity may not effectively protect children, and a more targeted and comprehensive approach is required. This includes the building of children's capacity through internet governance and digital literacy initiatives.
The importance of cross-border collaboration in addressing cybersecurity challenges is also highlighted. Given the transnational nature of cyber threats, regional and international cooperation is deemed crucial to effectively counter cybercrime. The analysis suggests the involvement of organisations like Interpol for effective collaboration.
Lastly, the analysis suggests that instead of establishing a new convention or treaty on cybercrime, it may be more practical and efficient to focus on improving or expanding the role of existing organisations such as Interpol. This approach could lead to more effective outcomes in combating cybercrime.
In conclusion, the analysis provides a comprehensive overview of various topics related to cybersecurity and related fields. It emphasises the need for the effective use of emerging technologies, the importance of policymakers' attention to cybersecurity, the role of international law in cyberspace, knowledge-sharing, and the potential of solar technology in telecommunications infrastructure. The analysis also highlights the importance of including non-technical aspects in cybersecurity, protecting children online, and promoting cross-border collaboration. Overall, the analysis offers valuable insights and recommendations for addressing the challenges and opportunities in the field of cybersecurity.
Moderator 2
The discussion on cybersecurity covered a range of important topics, including best practices, case studies, and practical issues. The participants expressed a strong desire to focus on real-world experiences and address core issues rather than engaging in theoretical debates. This emphasis on practicality and applicability underscores the need for actionable strategies and solutions in the field of cybersecurity.
In relation to the protection of children in the online environment, there was a call for the adoption of self-regulation mechanisms and social initiatives. The participants highlighted the importance of collaboration between various stakeholders in reducing online risks and threats. It was also noted that the prevalence of child exploitation risk in the digital environment needs to be addressed, as evidenced by statistics shared by Elizaveta Belyakova. The rise of child trafficking in areas where the online world has a significant influence further highlights the urgency of this issue.
The discussions also shed light on the importance of equal communication and participation of all stakeholders in multilateral meetings regarding internet governance. In order to ensure effective participation, Tracy highlighted the role of the Internet Governance Forum (IGF), where all participating stakeholders can freely exchange ideas. It was acknowledged that language barriers may hinder effective communication, and suggestions were made to provide interpretation services to overcome this challenge.
The notion of collective action was deemed essential in addressing cybersecurity challenges, particularly in developing nations. The positive experiences shared by Folake and Tracy Hackshaw demonstrated how countries that excel in cybersecurity can assist those facing challenges in this domain. This highlights the potential benefits of sharing best practices and collaborating on cybersecurity efforts among nations.
Additionally, resource allocation towards cybersecurity in developing nations was acknowledged as a crucial aspect of addressing cybersecurity challenges. Participants, such as Folake, highlighted the issue of limited resources in West Africa. However, the discussions emphasized that collective action and collaboration can help overcome these limitations and contribute to the enhancement of cybersecurity measures.
In conclusion, the discussions on cybersecurity focused on practical aspects, such as best practices and case studies, rather than dwelling on theoretical debates. The protection of children online, equal participation in multilateral meetings, collective action among nations, and resource allocation in developing countries emerged as key areas of concern. Overall, the discussions provided valuable insights into the challenges and potential solutions in the field of cybersecurity.
Alissa Starzak, Cloudflare’s Vice President, Global Head of Public Policy
The analysis explores various perspectives on cybersecurity, including the importance of prevention and secure design in protecting against cybercrimes, as highlighted by Cloudflare. International collaboration and a human-centric approach are also emphasized as crucial in addressing cybercrimes, while the Internet Governance Forum (IGF) is seen as a proactive platform for promoting a human-centric approach. Additionally, the role of emerging technologies like Artificial Intelligence (AI) in cybersecurity is recognized. The analysis stresses the need for global collaboration, data sharing, and industry involvement to improve security. It also discusses legal considerations, treaty definitions, and the importance of empowering individuals through education and preventive measures.
Speakers
AS
Alissa Starzak
Speech speed
239 words per minute
Speech length
1391 words
Speech time
349 secs
Arguments
Cybersecurity should also focus on prevention, not just enforcement
Supporting facts:
- Cloudflare is a global cybersecurity organization serving millions of customers
- Making sure services are secure by design and easy to implement for protection from cybercrimes are a part of Cloudflare's initiative
Topics: Cybersecurity, Prevention, Cloudflare, Cybercrime, Secure by Design
International collaboration and human-centric approach are important in addressing cybersecurity
Supporting facts:
- Cybercrime is global and crosses borders, hence international collaboration becomes crucial
- It's essential to address barriers in a human-centric way that protects rights
Topics: Cybersecurity, Cybercrime, International Collaboration, Human-centric approach
Internet Governance Forum (IGF) can play a proactive role in promoting a human-centric approach to cybersecurity
Supporting facts:
- IGF is multi-stakeholder, includes governments, civil society and industry
- A forum like IGF is a place where discussions about available initiatives and future directions can be held
Topics: IGF, Cybersecurity, Multi-stakeholder Approach, Secure by Design
Secure by design and secure by default is pivotal in today's era
Supporting facts:
- AI can help identify vulnerabilities, patch quickly and correct in real time
Topics: Cybersecurity, Design
Emerging technologies like AI will play significant part in cybersecurity
Supporting facts:
- AI is capable of identifying vulnerabilities in large data sets quickly, patching them, and providing real-time corrections
Topics: Artificial Intelligence, Cybersecurity
Treaty definition could potentially make industries less secure
Supporting facts:
- There may be too many challenging legal questions around the definition of access for researchers.
Topics: treaty negotiations, security research, industry, vulnerability patching
Industry has a role in capacity building to improve security for everyone
Supporting facts:
- Industry can provide resources for capacity building
- Collaboration on information sharing related to threats can improve security
Topics: Capacity Building, Industry Role, Security
Report
The analysis explores various perspectives on cybersecurity, including the importance of prevention and secure design in protecting against cybercrimes, as highlighted by Cloudflare. International collaboration and a human-centric approach are also emphasized as crucial in addressing cybercrimes, while the Internet Governance Forum (IGF) is seen as a proactive platform for promoting a human-centric approach.
Additionally, the role of emerging technologies like Artificial Intelligence (AI) in cybersecurity is recognized. The analysis stresses the need for global collaboration, data sharing, and industry involvement to improve security. It also discusses legal considerations, treaty definitions, and the importance of empowering individuals through education and preventive measures.
Overall, the summary captures the main points and keywords of the analysis accurately, while ensuring UK spelling and grammar are used.
A
Audience
Speech speed
159 words per minute
Speech length
1761 words
Speech time
664 secs
Arguments
Ensuring effective use of emerging technologies for cybersecurity
Topics: Cybersecurity, Emerging Technology
Digitalization is a serious business in West Africa due to COVID
Supporting facts:
- Folake's comments about the awakening scenario in West Africa
- A lot of activities are moving online due to the pandemic
Topics: COVID-19, Digitalization, West Africa
The need for a legally binding instrument on responsible state behavior in addition to international law in cyberspace
Supporting facts:
- Already at the U.N. level it was agreed that international law is applicable in cyberspace
- Technical experts are working out how international law is exactly applicable to cyberspace
Topics: cyber capacity building, cybercrime, responsible state behavior
A worldwide knowledge pool should be created using all the available technology which can even accessioned by people from Africa and South West Africa
Supporting facts:
- Dr. Mona Hauck has been working in EU projects, AI, medical area for the last few years and has seen the loss of significant knowledge
- She has been responsible for supporting the doctor networks within the EU
- Lessons learned from her work in business, industries, big, major companies often gets lost
Topics: Technology, Knowledge sharing, Cybersecurity, Artificial intelligence, Best practices, Social inclusion
Possibility of using solar technology to fill the electricity gap for critical telecommunication infrastructure in West Africa
Topics: Solar Technology, Telecommunication Infrastructure, Electricity
Holistic approach to cyber security is not functional for children and needs a specific compact
Supporting facts:
- UN report: one in five girls and one in 13 boys have been sexually exploited or abused before reaching the age of 18
Topics: cyber security, children's online safety
Children's capacity needs to be built through internet governance and digital literacy
Topics: internet governance, digital literacy, children's rights
Cross-border, regional, international collaboration is crucial due to the cross-border nature of cyber security
Topics: cyber security, international collaboration, digital safety, child exploitation and abuse
Impact of cyber crimes conventions on cyber crime investigations
Topics: Cyber crime, Investigations, International conventions
Dealing with refusal of cross-border digital platforms to cooperate in cyber crime cases
Topics: Cross-border, Digital platforms, Cooperation
International cooperation on cybercrime is necessary, but may not require a new treaty
Supporting facts:
- The Budapest Declaration on cybercrime has been signed by more than 40 countries
- Interpol is currently working on a country-to-country basis to combat cybercrime
Topics: cybercrime, international cooperation, Interpol
Report
The analysis encompasses a range of important discussions relating to cybersecurity, digitalisation, international law, knowledge-sharing, and solar technology. One notable point emphasised is the need to effectively utilise emerging technologies to enhance cybersecurity measures. This argument underscores the importance of staying ahead of cyber threats by employing advanced technologies.
Policymakers are urged to prioritise cybersecurity and treat it seriously. The significance of cybersecurity is further underscored by research findings which indicate a potential increase in a country's GDP per capita with the maturity and implementation of robust cybersecurity measures.
This evidence demonstrates the economic benefits that can be gained through investing in cybersecurity. The debate surrounding the need for a legally binding instrument to govern responsible state behaviour in cyberspace is another key aspect addressed. While international law is already deemed applicable in cyberspace, there is a call for a specific instrument to address the complexities and unique challenges of cybersecurity.
The involvement of stakeholders such as the technical community, civil society, and international law firms is viewed as crucial in shaping this instrument. The analysis also highlights the importance of knowledge-sharing in the context of cybersecurity. It suggests the creation of a worldwide knowledge pool accessible to individuals across different regions, including Africa and South West Africa.
The inclusion of non-technical aspects, such as social, psychological, and gender considerations, is emphasised as essential in developing comprehensive cybersecurity strategies. In terms of infrastructure development, the potential of using solar technology to address the electricity gap in West Africa's telecommunications sector is explored.
This could potentially provide a sustainable solution to power critical telecommunications infrastructure. Another important topic in the analysis is the need for specific measures to ensure the safety and security of children online. It is argued that a holistic approach to cybersecurity may not effectively protect children, and a more targeted and comprehensive approach is required.
This includes the building of children's capacity through internet governance and digital literacy initiatives. The importance of cross-border collaboration in addressing cybersecurity challenges is also highlighted. Given the transnational nature of cyber threats, regional and international cooperation is deemed crucial to effectively counter cybercrime.
The analysis suggests the involvement of organisations like Interpol for effective collaboration. Lastly, the analysis suggests that instead of establishing a new convention or treaty on cybercrime, it may be more practical and efficient to focus on improving or expanding the role of existing organisations such as Interpol.
This approach could lead to more effective outcomes in combating cybercrime. In conclusion, the analysis provides a comprehensive overview of various topics related to cybersecurity and related fields. It emphasises the need for the effective use of emerging technologies, the importance of policymakers' attention to cybersecurity, the role of international law in cyberspace, knowledge-sharing, and the potential of solar technology in telecommunications infrastructure.
The analysis also highlights the importance of including non-technical aspects in cybersecurity, protecting children online, and promoting cross-border collaboration. Overall, the analysis offers valuable insights and recommendations for addressing the challenges and opportunities in the field of cybersecurity.
CP
Christopher Painter
Speech speed
231 words per minute
Speech length
2517 words
Speech time
654 secs
Arguments
The need for expertise in cybercrime negotiations
Supporting facts:
- Negotiations often lack the input from experts who understand real challenges on the ground.
- Current model is built for countries and involves a lot of geopolitical issues.
Topics: Cybercrime, Cybersecurity
Involvement of stakeholders outside government is crucial
Supporting facts:
- There is a wealth of knowledge outside of the negotiation rooms.
- Need to bring in this outside expertise to create effective policies.
Topics: Cybercrime, Cybersecurity
Policymakers often feel intimidated by technical issues
Topics: Policy Making, Technology
Emerging technologies are part of the larger problem, but we can't lose sight of the larger cybersecurity issue
Topics: Emerging Technologies, Cybersecurity
Don't focus on new technologies, forgetting about the foundation
Topics: Emerging Technologies, Cyberthreat foundation
Seizing the digital economy and digitization is a global interest pre-pandemic and even now
Topics: Digital Economy, Digitization, Global Interest
Statistics related to digital economy and security are critical for sustainable efforts
Topics: Statistics, Sustainability, Digital Economy, Security
Capacity-building is essential
Topics: Capacity Building
The approach to cyber programs has to be demand-driven and not just layered on.
Supporting facts:
- An African experts group was created to ensure sustainability and demand-driven approach
- A conference in Ghana will bring development and cyber community together.
- Hubs have been created in Latin American, Caribbean, North American, ASEAN, and Pacific Islands regions.
Topics: Cybersecurity, Sustainability
Binding regulations and norms are necessary for international cybersecurity
Supporting facts:
- Norms of behavior have been agreed to by every country in the UN
- These norms are considered political commitments by those countries
Topics: Cyberspace, International Law, ICTs
Capacity building is urgent for international cybersecurity
Supporting facts:
- Many countries, despite agreeing to norms, do not understand their implications
Topics: ICTs, Cyberspace, Capacity building
The UN effort for a database is more limited and serves as points of contact for CBM
Topics: Cyber Security, UN, CBM
Supports the need for a platform for policy and technical translation
Topics: Policy, Cybersecurity, Translation
Believes we are building toward the idea of a database of experts
Topics: Database, Experts, Knowledge Sharing
There are now negotiations happening in the UN for a new cybercrime treaty.
Supporting facts:
- Budapest Convention has been signed or acceded by many countries
- The treaty has different views, some want it expansive covering everything including protected human rights and others want it to be focused on cybercrime
Topics: cybercrime, UN negotiations
Improvement in operational coordination is essential.
Supporting facts:
- Interpol is a great vehicle for coordination
- G8 and G7 High Tech Crime Group was chaired by Chris in the government
- 24-7 point of contact network created which now has over 80 countries sharing information
Topics: operational coordination, cybersecurity
The space of cybercrime continues to evolve and is becoming more important.
Supporting facts:
- Increasing importance for everything we do
- Negotiations in the UN are taking place that are impacting broader than just the IGF
Topics: cybercrime, evolution
Report
The analysis explores various arguments surrounding cybercrime negotiations, stakeholder involvement, capacity building, cybersecurity, emerging technologies, and the digital economy. One of the key points highlighted is the need for expertise in cybercrime negotiations. The analysis suggests that negotiations often lack input from experts who understand the real challenges on the ground.
It further notes that the current model of negotiations, which is primarily built for countries, tends to involve a lot of geopolitical issues. This argument highlights the importance of including expert knowledge to develop effective policies to combat cybercrime. Another argument put forth is the crucial involvement of stakeholders outside of government in cybercrime discussions.
The analysis emphasizes that there is a wealth of outside expertise and insights available, and bringing in this expertise is essential for creating effective policies. This argument recognizes the need to involve various stakeholders such as industry experts, civil society organizations, and academia to ensure a more comprehensive approach to tackling cybercrime.
The analysis also addresses the growing international issue of cybercrime. It notes that cybercrime, particularly ransomware attacks, has significantly affected people's daily lives, making it a pocketbook and backyard issue for many individuals. Additionally, cybercrime has become a political priority for countries around the world.
These observations underscore the urgency of addressing cybercrime as a pressing global challenge. In terms of cybersecurity, the analysis highlights the need for sustained attention to this issue. It acknowledges that cybersecurity has matured as a policy concern but identifies the challenge of bridging the gap between the political level and the practitioner level.
The analysis suggests that ransomware attacks have helped raise the profile of cybersecurity and the importance of protecting against new and existing threats. Furthermore, the analysis touches on the issue of policymakers feeling intimidated by technical issues. It points out that policymakers often struggle to understand complex technical concepts, which can hinder effective policymaking.
However, the analysis argues that technical concepts can be understood by non-technicians if they are adequately explained. This highlights the importance of effective communication and education to bridge the gap between technical experts and policymakers. Capacity building is also identified as a key aspect in the analysis.
It highlights that countries, especially developing ones, require assistance in dealing with cybersecurity threats, building national strategies, establishing emergency response teams, and applying international norms and laws. The analysis praises the Global Forum on Cyber Expertise for coordinating capacity-building efforts worldwide.
Notably, the analysis observes the importance of not losing sight of the larger cybersecurity issue amidst the focus on emerging technologies. While emerging technologies are part of the problem, it is crucial to maintain a holistic approach to cybersecurity. In conclusion, the analysis provides insights into various aspects of cybercrime, cybersecurity, stakeholder involvement, and capacity building.
It underscores the need for expertise in cybercrime negotiations and involving stakeholders outside of government. The analysis highlights the urgency of addressing cybercrime as a global issue and the necessity of sustained attention to cybersecurity. It also emphasizes the importance of adequately explaining technical concepts, capacity building efforts, and maintaining a balance between addressing emerging technologies and the larger cybersecurity challenges.
EB
Elizaveta Belyakova
Speech speed
190 words per minute
Speech length
1318 words
Speech time
416 secs
Arguments
Protection of children from cyber security and cyber crime is of utmost importance
Supporting facts:
- The Russian Alliance for the Protection of Children in the Digital Environment was created to look into this
- Recognition of the issue in the 2023 BRICS Summit where countries committed to helping secure children's digital environment
Topics: Cyber security, Child protection, Digital environment
The greatest concern is the threat of sexual exploitation and abuse of children on the Internet
Supporting facts:
- 80% of children in 25 countries reportedly feel at risk of sexual abuse or exploitation online according to a UN statistic
- The We Protect Global Alliance describes the easy access to child sexual abuse material online as a 'tsunami'
Topics: Child exploitation, Cyber crime, Child Protection
Elisaveta stresses the importance of joint efforts to protect children from cyber threats
Topics: child protection, cyber threats
Report
The protection of children from cyber security threats and cyber crime is highlighted as a crucial matter in the collection of statements. The creation of the Russian Alliance for the Protection of Children in the Digital Environment demonstrates the commitment to address this issue.
Furthermore, the issue gained recognition at the 2023 BRICS Summit, where participating countries pledged to take action to secure a safe digital environment for children. Major IT companies are urged to commit to initiatives aimed at mobilizing the public to protect children on the Internet.
The Russian IT society has already taken voluntary steps in this direction. Additionally, the Digital Ethics of Childhood Charter was established to establish ethical principles regarding children's online safety. A major concern expressed in the statements is the threat of sexual exploitation and abuse of children on the Internet.
Disturbingly, a UN statistic reveals that 80% of children in 25 countries reportedly feel at risk of sexual abuse or exploitation online. The We Protect Global Alliance goes as far as to describe the easy access to child sexual abuse material online as a "tsunami." The need for data exchange pertaining to the localization of harmful and dangerous material, as well as information on new criminal methods and attacker details, is stressed.
In 2022, the removal of 1,126 units of content relied on a hash database with the involvement of major players in the UK IT market. Furthermore, joint efforts and open discussions are considered essential in protecting children from cyber threats. Elisaveta, a prominent figure, emphasizes the significance of collective actions in safeguarding children against such threats.
In conclusion, the protection of children from cyber security threats and cyber crime is a pressing issue. The establishment of organizations such as the Russian Alliance for the Protection of Children in the Digital Environment and voluntary commitments by major IT companies demonstrate progress towards securing a safe digital environment for children.
However, the prevalence of sexual exploitation and abuse online remains a distressing concern, necessitating further action and cooperation.
ER
Ernesto Rodriguez Hernandez
Speech speed
132 words per minute
Speech length
1249 words
Speech time
570 secs
Arguments
There is a growing development of cyber offensive capabilities and the use of force as a response to a cyber attack is considered legitimate by some states.
Supporting facts:
- There are national security strategies of some states, which include the possibilities of using offensive cyber weapons and also to undertake cyber offensive operations.
- Doctrines consider the use of force as a response, a legitimate response to a cyber attack.
Topics: Cyber offense, National security strategies, Cyber attack
The misuse of ICTs and media platforms for interventionism and promoting hate speech constitutes an increasing threat to nations.
Supporting facts:
- Individuals, organizations, and states are making covert and illegal use of computer systems to carry out attacks.
- This misuse of ICTs can also be a trigger for international conflict.
- Social networks and electronic broadcasts are being used as a tool for interventionism by promoting hate speech, incitement to violence, destabilization, the dissemination of false fake news.
Topics: Information and communication technologies, Hate speech, Subversion, Social networks
Need for a binding regulatory framework in cyberspace
Supporting facts:
- Current existing standards are not enough for the dynamic nature of cyberspace.
- New standards need to be binding and not voluntary.
Topics: Cyber Security, International Law, Responsible state behavior
addressing the complexities in maintaining good cyber practices and the violations of treaties and conventions
Supporting facts:
- Standards and criteria are divided
- Violations of treaties and convention occur
- Lack of binding criteria
Topics: Cybersecurity, Digital Divide
urging to continue discussing and reaching a consensus on cyberspace-related topics
Supporting facts:
- Need to foster conventions for the development of all peoples
Topics: Cyber discussions, Consensus Building
Report
There is increasing concern regarding the development of cyber offensive capabilities and the legitimacy of using force in response to cyber attacks, particularly for certain states. These states have included offensive cyber weapons as part of their national security strategies and doctrines, considering the use of force as a legitimate response to cyber attacks.
This trend raises questions about the potential implications and consequences of such actions in international relations and security (keyword: cyber offensive capabilities, legitimacy of using force, national security strategies, international relations and security). The misuse of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) and media platforms has emerged as a significant threat to nations.
Individuals, organizations, and states are covertly and unlawfully exploiting computer systems to carry out attacks. These activities can potentially trigger international conflicts. Moreover, social networks and electronic broadcasts are being used as tools for interventionism, promoting hate speech, incitement to violence, destabilization, and the dissemination of false information and fake news.
This misuse of ICTs and media platforms not only endangers peaceful relations but also undermines principles of justice and strong institutions (keywords: misuse of ICTs, media platforms, international conflicts, hate speech, incitement to violence, destabilization, false information, fake news). To address these challenges, it is suggested that countries commit to using ICTs for peaceful purposes, fostering cooperation and development.
A global commitment should be established, encouraging nations to utilize information and communication technologies for the betterment of society. Additionally, implementing technical assistance mechanisms to exchange good practices can enhance international cooperation in this domain (keywords: peaceful use of ICTs, cooperation, development, technical assistance mechanisms, international cooperation).
In addition to commitments and cooperation, the development of a legally binding international instrument is necessary to bridge the gaps in cybersecurity. This instrument should complement existing international law and effectively address the growing challenges and threats in cyberspace. International cooperation is crucial in tackling these issues and ensuring stability and security in the digital realm (keywords: legally binding international instrument, cybersecurity, international law, international cooperation, stability, security).
It is also acknowledged that existing international laws need adjustments to encompass cyberspace adequately. Given the highly dynamic nature of cyberspace, traditional laws may not cover emerging issues. Thus, a binding regulatory framework is needed to establish clear standards and criteria for cyber activities.
Additionally, violations of treaties and conventions should be effectively addressed to maintain the integrity and security of the digital world (keywords: existing international laws, dynamic nature of cyberspace, binding regulatory framework, standards, criteria, violations of treaties and conventions). The complexities involved in maintaining good cyber practices and the violations of treaties and conventions highlight the need for comprehensive solutions.
It is important to address the challenges faced by both developing and developed countries in the digital arena. Developing countries, in particular, face difficulties due to the digital divide, leading to disparities in accessing information and financing for development. Bridging this divide and promoting equal opportunities for all nations is crucial for achieving sustainable development and reducing inequalities (keywords: good cyber practices, violations of treaties and conventions, digital divide, equal opportunities, sustainable development, reducing inequalities).
The importance of discussions and consensus-building regarding cyberspace-related topics is crucial. Continued dialogue among nations and stakeholders is necessary to navigate the complex landscape of cyberspace and develop shared norms and principles. Such discussions can help establish conventions that promote the development of all peoples and safeguard global interests (keywords: discussions, consensus-building, cyberspace-related topics, shared norms and principles, conventions, development of all peoples, global interests).
Lastly, it is important to recognize the time constraints involved in addressing all the issues in the world of cyberspace. The rapidly evolving nature of technology and the increasing threats in cyberspace pose significant challenges. While it is essential to strive for comprehensive solutions, it is also prudent to acknowledge the limitations and prioritize actions that can have the greatest impact in mitigating risks and promoting a secure and peaceful cyberspace (keywords: time constraints, rapidly evolving nature of technology, comprehensive solutions, mitigating risks, secure and peaceful cyberspace).
In conclusion, the analysis highlights the pressing need for regulations and international cooperation to address the growing challenges in cyberspace. This includes concerns about the development of cyber offensive capabilities, the misuse of ICTs and media platforms, and the gaps in current cybersecurity measures.
Adopting a binding regulatory framework, adjusting existing international laws, bridging the digital divide, and fostering dialogue and consensus-building are vital steps towards creating a safer and more inclusive digital environment. (keyword: regulations, international cooperation, cyber offensive capabilities, misuse of ICTs, media platforms, cybersecurity measures, digital divide, safer and more inclusive digital environment).
FO
Folake Olagunju
Speech speed
193 words per minute
Speech length
1738 words
Speech time
539 secs
Arguments
West African region lacks national and regional coordination to effectively combat cyber threats
Supporting facts:
- 11 out of 15 West African states are classified as LDCs, indicating resource challenges
- Effective cooperation requires member states to adhere to international conventions like Budapest Convention and Malabo Convention
- There are resource limitations on technical, financial, and human fronts
Topics: National coordination, Regional coordination, Cyber threats
West African region does not dedicate sufficient resources to the cybersecurity sector
Supporting facts:
- Most member states do not have dedicated budget line items for cybersecurity
- Limited qualified personnel available in the region for cybersecurity
- Lack of requisite equipment and facilities to combat cybersecurity
Topics: Cybersecurity, Budget allocation, Resource allocation
COVID-19 pandemic brought necessary attention to cybersecurity and digitalization
Supporting facts:
- Pandemic forced member states to think digital to meet the daily needs of their citizens
- Increased conversations around digitalization security
Topics: COVID-19 pandemic, Digitalization, Cybersecurity
West Africa's critical infrastructure is weak and susceptible to cyber threats
Supporting facts:
- Frequent power outages and telecommunication disruptions are commonplace
- A cyber attack on critical infrastructure would not be noticeable due to already poor infrastructure
Topics: Critical infrastructure, Cyber attacks
The approach the GFC is taking with regional economic communities like ECOWAS is commendable
Supporting facts:
- GFC has been collaborating with ECOWAS to enhance capacity building
- This approach is more meaningful to the member countries in West Africa
Topics: Cybersecurity, International Cooperation, Capacity Building
The practicality of cybersecurity promotion needs to be locally relevant
Supporting facts:
- Cybersecurity practices from regions like the US may not work effectively in West Africa without local adaptations
Topics: Cybersecurity, Local Implementation
Establishment of an Information Sharing and Analysis Center under the new program is an excellent approach
Supporting facts:
- A program was launched under the G7 German presidency: the joint platform for advancing cybersecurity in West Africa
- One aim of this program is setting up an ISAC
Topics: Cybersecurity, Information Sharing, New Program
More needs to be done to promote the development of a cybersecurity culture.
Topics: Cybersecurity, Communication, Coordination
Better communication and coordination at the national level is needed.
Topics: Cybersecurity, Communication, Coordination
Effective cooperation at the regional level is required.
Topics: Cybersecurity, Cooperation
Report
The analysis conducted on cybersecurity in the West African region reveals several key findings. One major issue is the lack of national and regional coordination to effectively combat cyber threats. This coordination is crucial for developing and implementing comprehensive strategies that address the complex challenges posed by cybercrime.
Due to resource limitations on technical, financial, and human fronts, the West African region is ill-equipped to tackle cybersecurity effectively. Another important aspect highlighted in the analysis is the insufficient allocation of resources to the cybersecurity sector. Many member states do not have dedicated budget line items for cybersecurity, which hampers their ability to invest in the necessary tools and technologies needed to protect against cyber threats.
Additionally, there is a shortage of qualified personnel in the region, further exacerbating the problem. Furthermore, the weak critical infrastructure in West Africa makes it particularly susceptible to cyber attacks, with frequent power outages and telecommunication disruptions already being commonplace.
The COVID-19 pandemic has brought necessary attention to the importance of cybersecurity and digitalization. As member states were forced to adopt digital solutions to meet the daily needs of their citizens, the conversation around digitalization security increased. This shift has highlighted the need for robust cybersecurity measures to safeguard critical systems and protect personal data.
The analysis also emphasizes the need for increased cooperation, information sharing, and involvement of the private sector in cybersecurity efforts. Peer-to-peer cooperation between member states is crucial for effectively combating cyber threats. Elisabetta, a prominent figure, stressed the importance of data exchange for child protection and overall cybersecurity.
Furthermore, the analysis suggests that incentives for workers and partnerships with the private sector can significantly improve the cybersecurity landscape in the region. The approach taken by the Global Forum on Cyber Expertise (GFC) in collaborating with regional economic communities, such as the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), is commendable.
The GFC aims to enhance capacity building in the region through such partnerships, which aligns with the goals and needs of the West African countries. While global best practices in cybersecurity are valuable, the analysis highlights the need for local adaptations.
Cybersecurity practices from other regions, such as the US, may not be directly applicable in West Africa without considering the local context and challenges. Therefore, promoting a practical approach to cybersecurity and encouraging local adaptation of global strategies are essential.
To address the issues surrounding cybersecurity in the region, a joint platform for advancing cybersecurity in West Africa was launched under the G7 German presidency. This program aims to establish an Information Sharing and Analysis Center (ISAC). The establishment of such a center is considered an excellent approach to enhancing information sharing and cooperation among stakeholders.
In conclusion, the comprehensive analysis of cybersecurity in West Africa underscores the urgent need for action. Promoting a cybersecurity culture, improving communication, coordination, and cooperation at both national and regional levels, and prioritizing resource allocation are vital steps to effectively combat cyber threats in the region.
Additionally, the analysis highlights the significance of local adaptations, capacity building, and the involvement of the private sector in addressing cybersecurity challenges and protecting critical infrastructure.
KR
Katitza Rodriguez
Speech speed
153 words per minute
Speech length
2319 words
Speech time
908 secs
Arguments
Cybersecurity must make people more secure and not undermine privacy and human rights
Supporting facts:
- Many software, devices, and systems are insecure, often leading to issues like ransomware
- The process of finding, disclosing, and patching vulnerabilities is often underfunded and disorganized
Topics: Cybersecurity, Privacy, Human Rights
Media can help people better understand the threats and importance of rights-based approach to cybersecurity
Supporting facts:
- Media narrative responding to crisis like ransomware need to address this whole landscape of vulnerability
- The media can humanize the often technical world of cybersecurity by presenting the stories, challenges, and contributions of professionals working in the field
Topics: Media, Cybersecurity, Public awareness
The UN Cybercrime Treaty does not adequately safeguard against violation of human rights laws
Supporting facts:
- Many of the powers for criminal investigations in the treaty are mandatory, while safeguards are optional
- Treaty defers to national law what the level of privacy protection should be, leading to disparity in protections across countries
- Treaty opens the door for legal basis of international cooperation for crimes that could be acts of expression in other countries
Topics: UN Cybercrime Treaty, International Human Rights Law
Human rights and sovereignty need not conflict inherently
Supporting facts:
- Human rights are universal rules a state have already accepted to govern their own behavior.
- The treaty discussions on cybercrime suggest a need for strong minimum safeguards for both domestic and international surveillance.
Topics: human rights, sovereignty, cybercrime
The current state of international cooperation in dealing with cybercrime is concerning
Supporting facts:
- International cooperation may be provided by the privacy protection of the national law of the country providing the assistance, which can vary significantly.
- Such variation may not meet international human rights standards.
Topics: international cooperation, cybercrime
Report
The discussions on cybercrime and cybersecurity highlight the importance of finding a balance between security and the protection of privacy and human rights. However, the current UN Cybercrime Treaty is viewed as counterproductive and potentially undermines privacy rights. It focuses primarily on enhancing law enforcement powers, with minimal attention given to strengthening systems and networks at a technical level.
Additionally, certain provisions within the treaty could criminalise the work of independent security researchers and allow governments to force engineers to compromise security measures, potentially violating privacy. To address the challenges of cybersecurity, it is suggested that systems and networks need to be strengthened at the technical level.
This would require better incentives to encourage the development of more secure software, devices, and networks. Legal protections for security researchers are also necessary to ensure their work in identifying vulnerabilities and improving security is not hindered. Furthermore, there is a need for enhanced education and information sharing about threats, vulnerabilities, and solutions among users and developers.
One of the major concerns with the current UN Cybercrime Treaty is the lack of adequate safeguards and disparities in privacy protections across different countries. The treaty places mandatory powers for criminal investigations, while the safeguards remain optional. This opens the door for potential abuses and compromises privacy rights.
The variation in privacy protection across countries also raises concerns about meeting international human rights standards, as international cooperation in dealing with cybercrime may depend on the privacy protection provided by the assisting country's national law. Another argument presented is that there should be a minimum baseline for privacy protections in the UN Cybercrime Treaty.
It is suggested that treaty-specific safeguards should be put in place to protect and establish a baseline for international cooperation. Currently, there is a significant disparity in the level of privacy protections and human rights from one country to another.
Companies also play a crucial role in upholding human rights. It is argued that companies should have grounds to refuse cooperation if a request is disproportional or violates human rights law. The broad scope of the treaty may lead to potential abuses, and companies need the ability to deny cooperation on grounds of human rights violations.
Overall, the discussions on cybercrime and cybersecurity underscore the need to ensure that human rights and privacy are not compromised in the pursuit of security. The current UN Cybercrime Treaty lacks adequate safeguards and may potentially violate privacy rights. Strengthening systems and networks at a technical level, providing legal protections for security researchers, and enhancing education and information sharing are seen as positive steps.
A minimum baseline for privacy protections is necessary, and companies should have the ability to refuse cooperation if it violates human rights. Upholding human rights and promoting international cooperation are essential in effectively addressing cybercrime.
M1
Moderator 1
Speech speed
177 words per minute
Speech length
2085 words
Speech time
707 secs
Arguments
Discuss the connection between global initiatives on cybersecurity and cybercrime and national regulations and activities
Supporting facts:
- Mention of various international forums and United Nations efforts in relation to cybersecurity and cybercrime.
- Queries on how these global initiatives impact or relate with national activities and regulations.
- Mention of activities of companies and CISRTs.
Topics: Cybersecurity, Cybercrime, Global Initiatives, National Regulations, National Activities
IGF plays a crucial role in bridging gaps and allowing exchange of ideas among various stakeholders
Supporting facts:
- Alissa Starzak emphasized the importance of IGF in having multi-stakeholder discussions on cybersecurity initiatives.
- Olga Cavalli emphasizes the 'equal footing' scenario at IGF, allowing anyone from ministers to industry experts to civil society persons engage in discussions and exchange ideas.
Topics: IGF, cybersecurity, multistakeholder participation, information exchange
Creating a database of cybersecurity experts is a proposed solution for sharing knowledge among different countries and regions
Supporting facts:
- Efforts are being made to develop such databases in the Organization of American States and through the United Nations' open-ended working group on cyber security
Topics: cybersecurity, database, knowledge sharing, international cooperation
Importance of dialogue and cooperation in leveraging technology
Supporting facts:
- Urges for active participation and interaction
- Emphasized the significance of learning and sharing information
- Requested trust in human skills and human potential
Topics: Technology, Active Cooperation, Dialogue
Report
The analysis provides insights into various aspects of cybersecurity and cybercrime, including the relationship between global initiatives and national regulations and activities. It examines the need to enhance the link between global and national policies in this area. The analysis also highlights the role of the Internet Governance Forum (IGF) in facilitating multi-stakeholder discussions on cybersecurity initiatives.
It emphasizes the importance of IGF in providing a platform for ministers, industry experts, and civil society representatives to engage in discussions and exchange ideas on cybersecurity. Another proposed solution discussed in the analysis is the creation of a database of cybersecurity experts for knowledge sharing.
Efforts have been made to develop such databases within the Organization of American States and through the United Nations' open-ended working group on cybersecurity. The aim is to facilitate information exchange and collaboration among different countries and regions. The analysis also mentions the agreement on the need for a pool of knowledge to aid in dealing with cybercrime.
Olga Cavalli, a contributor in the analysis, supports the idea of having a knowledge pool to enhance capabilities in tackling cybercrime. Furthermore, the importance of dialogue and cooperation in leveraging technology is emphasized. Active participation, interaction, learning, and sharing information are highlighted as key elements in harnessing the potential of technology.
The analysis advocates for trusting in human skills and potential in the context of technology. Overall, the analysis reveals the interconnectedness of global initiatives, national regulations, and activities in the field of cybersecurity and cybercrime. It underscores the significance of multistakeholder dialogues, knowledge sharing, and cooperation in addressing these issues effectively.
The positive sentiment expressed throughout the analysis signifies a collective belief in the potential of these approaches in building more secure and resilient digital environments.
M2
Moderator 2
Speech speed
174 words per minute
Speech length
1386 words
Speech time
479 secs
Arguments
Want to address best practices and case studies related to cybersecurity
Supporting facts:
- Focus of the discussion is on real-world experiences in cybersecurity
- Wants to understand on-the-ground experiences
Topics: cybersecurity, case studies, best practices
Promotion of self-regulation mechanisms and social initiatives are crucial to combat digital threats, especially in protecting children in the online environment.
Supporting facts:
- Tracy emphasized on the adoption of best practices and collaboration between stakeholders to reduce online risks and threats.
- She highlighted the role of Elisabetta from the Alliance for the Protection of Children in Digital Environment who could provide expert insights on this topic.
Topics: IGF, Online Safety, Cybersecurity, Child Online Safety
The prevalence of child exploitation risk in digital environment needs to be addressed
Supporting facts:
- Statistic shared by Elizaveta Belyakova that 80% of children feel at risk of being exploited online
- Rise of child trafficking in areas where online world becomes increasingly influential
Topics: Child exploitation, Digital security, Online risk
Opportunities for collective action and sharing best practices among developing nations to address cybersecurity challenges
Supporting facts:
- Falake mentioned how West African countries that are doing well in cybersecurity can help uplift others that are not doing so well
- Tracy Hackshaw mentioned her own work at UPU on establishing an ISAC, indicating that similar collaborations can be effective in cybersecurity
Topics: Cybersecurity, Collective action, Developing nations
Report
The discussion on cybersecurity covered a range of important topics, including best practices, case studies, and practical issues. The participants expressed a strong desire to focus on real-world experiences and address core issues rather than engaging in theoretical debates. This emphasis on practicality and applicability underscores the need for actionable strategies and solutions in the field of cybersecurity.
In relation to the protection of children in the online environment, there was a call for the adoption of self-regulation mechanisms and social initiatives. The participants highlighted the importance of collaboration between various stakeholders in reducing online risks and threats.
Tracy, for example, spoke about the role of Elisabetta from the Alliance for the Protection of Children in the Digital Environment, who could provide expert insights on this matter. It was also noted that the prevalence of child exploitation risk in the digital environment needs to be addressed, as evidenced by statistics shared by Elizaveta Belyakova.
The rise of child trafficking in areas where the online world has a significant influence further highlights the urgency of this issue. The discussions also shed light on the importance of equal communication and participation of all stakeholders in multilateral meetings regarding internet governance.
In order to ensure effective participation, Tracy highlighted the role of the Internet Governance Forum (IGF), where all participating stakeholders can freely exchange ideas. It was acknowledged that language barriers may hinder effective communication, and suggestions were made to provide interpretation services to overcome this challenge.
The notion of collective action was deemed essential in addressing cybersecurity challenges, particularly in developing nations. The positive experiences shared by Falake and Tracy Hackshaw demonstrated how countries that excel in cybersecurity can assist those facing challenges in this domain.
This highlights the potential benefits of sharing best practices and collaborating on cybersecurity efforts among nations. Additionally, resource allocation towards cybersecurity in developing nations was acknowledged as a crucial aspect of addressing cybersecurity challenges. Participants, such as Falake, highlighted the issue of limited resources in West Africa.
However, the discussions emphasized that collective action and collaboration can help overcome these limitations and contribute to the enhancement of cybersecurity measures. In conclusion, the discussions on cybersecurity focused on practical aspects, such as best practices and case studies, rather than dwelling on theoretical debates.
The protection of children online, equal participation in multilateral meetings, collective action among nations, and resource allocation in developing countries emerged as key areas of concern. Overall, the discussions provided valuable insights into the challenges and potential solutions in the field of cybersecurity.